25 years of civic education

SAPERE AUDE

Freedom, Legal Consciousness, Ethics

Segovia, June 13–17, 2018

Association of Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe

In memory of Arseny Roginsky

El Rancho de la Aldegüela, Torrecaballeros (Segovia)

in collaboration with Valsaín Foundation (Fundación Valsaín para la promoción y defensa de los valores democráticos) Wednesday 13 June DEMOCRACY, R U LE OF LAW, AND ETHICS

09.45–10.30 Opening session 15.30–17.00 Session: Lena Nemirovskaya Democracy, Rule of Law and Values in the Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Digital Society Álvaro Gil-Robles Tomás de la Quadra-Salcedo Commissioner for Human Rights of Council of Europe (1999–2006), President of the Valsaín Foundation 17.00–17.30 Coffee break Vladimir Lukin Human Rights Commissioner of (2004–2014), 17.30–19.00 Session: president of the Russian Paralympic Committee Authoritarian Regime and Russian Society Javier López-Escobar Tatiana Vorozheikina Regional Delegate, Regional Community of Castilla y León 19.00–19.30 Coffee break 10.30–12.00 Session: Can We Get Democracy Without Values? Álvaro Gil-Robles 19.30–21.30 Round table: The Rule of Law. What Rule? What Law? 12.00–12.30 Coffee break Alexander Shmelev

12.30–14.00 Session: 21.30 Dinner Securing Identity – Estonia’s Return to Europe Riina Kaljurand

14.00–15.30 Lunch

4 / 5 Thursday 14 June Friday 15 June POLITICS, ECONOMY, S OCIETY, AND ETHICS THE RULE OF LAW, AND ETHICS

10.00–11.30 Session: 9.30–11.30 Session: The Language of Propaganda Aristotle and Plato: the Idea of a State

Anastasia Bonch-Osmolovskaya Andrey Zakharov Vasily Zharkov 11.30–12.00 Coffee break 11.30–12.00 Coffee break 12.00–13.30 Session: 30 Years on the Road Across the Empire: a Selfie 12.00–13.30 Session: Pilar Bonet Legal Tools as Mechanism for Repairing Broken Societies - The Rule of Law and 13.30–15.00 Lunch International Obligations Arild Humlen 15.00–16.30 Session: Global Institutions: Challenges, Crises and 13.30–15.00 Lunch Ways Out Alexandre Guessel 15.00–16.30 Session: Former Socialist Countries Lagging Behind 16.30–17.00 Coffee break in Democracy Elena Lukianova 17.00–18.30 Session: 30 Years on the Road to Economic Success 16.30–17.00 Coffee break and Back Kirill Rogov 17.00–19.00 Round table: Civilisation and Culture 18.30–19.00 Coffee break Alexander Shmelev

19.00–20.30 Discussion 19.00 Dinner

20.30 Dinner

6 / 7 Saturday 16 June 18.00–20.00 Screening: The Right to Remember FREEDOM, MEMORY, AND ETHICS Elena Zhemkova Vladimir Lukin Natalia Mirza You can only understand freedom from the experience of Alexander Daniel “unfreedom ARSENY ROGINSKY ” 20.00 Dinner

9.00–10.30 Session: “Volya”: a Different Kind of Liberty Sunday 17 June Maxim Trudolyubov 25 YEARS OF CIVIC EDUCATION: WE ARE ALL DIFFERENT, 10.30–11.00 Coffee break BUT WE ARE ALL CITIZENS

11.00–12.30 Session: The Future of the Past 9.00–10.30 Session: Dmitry Gorin Russia and the West. Reflections on recent events 12.30–14.00 Lunch Lord Robert Skidelsky

14.00–15.30 Session: 10.30–11.00 Coffee break The Politics of Memory Alvydas Nikžentaitis 11.00–12.30 Session: Split Between Eastern and Western Christianity 15.30–16.00 Coffee break – and Its Impact on Russian Thought Edward Skidelsky 16.00–17.30 Session: and Anti-Stalinism as Actual 12.30–13.00 Closing remarks Concepts of Present Issues: Yury Senokosov Rethorics and Narratives Alexander Daniel 13.00–14.30 Lunch

17.30–18.00 Coffee break 15.00–18.00 Visit to San Lorenzo de El Escorial

8 / 9 Experts

Anastasia Associate Professor, Faculty of Elena Lukianova Professor, Department of Constitutional Bonch-Osmolovskaya Humanities School of Linguistics (Russia) and Municipal Law, Faculty of Law, (Russia) Programme; Academic Supervisor, National Research University of the National Research University Higher Higher School of Economics; Lawyer School of Economics Vladimir Lukin Human Rights Commissioner of Russia Pilar Bonet Chief Correspondent in Moscow, El País (Russia) (2004–2014); President, Russian (Spain) Paralympic Committee Alexander Daniel Historian, Board Member, Memorial Natalia Mirza Head of Secretariat, Russian Paralympic (Russia) human rights and humanitarian society (Russia) Committee Tomás De La Professor, University Carlos III, Madrid Lena Nemirovskaya, OBE Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Quadra-Salcedo (Russia) (Spain) Alvydas Nikžentaitis Historian Álvaro Gil-Robles President Valsaín Foundation; (Lithuania) y Gil-Delgado Commissioner for Human Rights, Kirill Rogov Political Scientist; Academic Secretary, (Spain) Council of Europe (1999–2006) (Russia) Member of the Editorial Committee, Alexandre Guessel Director of Political Advice, Te New Model of Economic Growth (Council of Europe) Council of Europe Group; Columnist at Vedomisti daily business newspaper, Novaya Gazeta, Dmitry Gorin Professor, Plekhanov Russian University RBC, Suddeutsche Zeitung and Te (Russia) of Economics Financial Times Arild Humlen Lawyer (with admission to the Supreme Yury Senokosov (Norway) Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Court); Humlen Advokater AS (Humlen (Russia) Lawyers Ltd Co) Alexander Shmelev Riina Kaljurand Political Analyst Director, Lennart Meri Conference (Russia) (Estonia) Edward Skidelsky Senior Lecturer, University of Exeter; Javier López-Escobar Regional Delegate, Regional (United Kingdom) Author (Spain) Community of Castilla y León

10 / 11 Lord Robert Skidelsky Member of the House of Lords, UK (United Kingdom) Parliament, Author Participants Maxim Trudolyubov Columnist, Vedomosti daily, Te New (Russia) York Times, Republic; Author and ARMENIA Contributor, Te Russia File, Kennan Institute, Inliberty Armen Ghazaryan Research Fellow, Caucasus Institute Tatiana Vorozheikina Political Analyst (Russia) POLAND Andrey Zakharov Editor, Neprikosnovennyi Zapas: Debates (Russia) on Politics and Culture magazine Lola Buryeva Correspondent, News Department, TV Belsat Vasily Zharkov Programme Director, Head of the Maria Harmast Chairman, For Free Russia association (Russia) International Politics Master’s Agnieszka Kaniewska Programme, Te Moscow School of Social PR Specialist, Coordinator, Siberian and Economic Studies Bialystok- Resurrection project Elena Zhemkova Executive Director, Memorial human (Russia) rights and humanitarian society RUSSIA

Yegor Alasheev Staff Member, Headquarters of Alexei (Samara Oblast) Navalniy, Samara Maria Anikina Correspondent, Belsat TV; Coordinator, (Novosibirsk Oblast) Strange People community Alexey Barayev Public Council Member, Department of (Yaroslavl Oblast) Tourism, Yaroslavl Region Sergey Belinin Head of Debt Collection, Legal Entities (St Petersburg) Department, Finance Capital Andrei Berezin Chairman, Youth Committee, (St Petersburg) Novosibirsk Chemical Chemical Concentrates plant Roman Bugakov Coordinator, Headquarters of Alexei (Ryazan Oblast) Navalniy, Ryazan

12 / 13 Lyudmila Bulygina Volunteer, Lisa Alert public search squad Ruslan Kahrimanov Project Manager, Civil Society (Nizhny Novgorod Oblast) (Republic of Dagestan) Development Assembly regional public organisation, Dagestan Sergey Chekandin Teacher of History and Social Studies, (Krasnodar Krai) All-Russian Children’s Centre, Orlyonok Yuri Kanygin Coordinator, Regional Office of the (Pskov Oblast) Open Russia movement, Pskov Maxim Dementiev Civic Activist, Regional Office of Te (Samara Oblast) Progress Party political party, Samara Tatyana Karchenkova Freelance Journalist (Omsk Oblast) Anna Dulevskaya Coordinator, Memorial movement: (Oryol Oblast) Te Last Address, Oryol Rasul Kataganov Leader, Public Nogai national organisation (Karachay-Cherkess Republic) Rinat Galeev Deputy Chairman, Regional Office of (Rostov Oblast) the Civil Initiative political party Roman Kazakov Chairman, Coordination Council, people’s (Krasnoyarsk Krai) control in housing and communal Alisa Galyenko Deputy, Council of Deputies, services interregional public movement (Moscow) Khoroshevsky District Polina Kostyleva Dmitry Garmatyuk Civic Activist, Election Observer Director, UniCon-Kuban company (St Petersburg) (Krasnodar Oblast) Andrey Lapehin Nikita Gerasimov Lawyer, AGORA international human Private Practice Lawyer (Chelyabinsk Oblast) () rights group Olga Lapehina Lawyer, AGORA international human Alexander Gorbachev Head, Land, Labor and Environmental (Chelyabinsk Oblast) rights group (Bryansk Oblast) Law Department, Bryansk State University Elena Lashmanova Natalia Gorbacheva Civic Activist, Animal Rights Advocate Individual Entrepreneur (Republic of Mordovia) (Moscow Oblast) Ekaterina Leonova Head of Academic Programmes, Dmitry Gorokhov Coordinator, Observers of St Petersburg (Rostov Oblast) International School of Business, (St Petersburg) public organisation, Krasnogvardeysky Southern Federal University district Olga Lisinova Maxim Gradoboev Photo Correspondent, Rabochiy Put’ Homeowners’ Representative (Smolensk Oblast) (Kirov Oblast) regional socio-political newspaper, Smolensk Grigory Gribenko Chairman, Regional Office, Yabloko Martha Lubas Chairman, Public Environmental (Irkutsk Oblast) political party, Irkutsk (Tyumen Oblast) Council, Tobolsk Eugene Ivanov Research Fellow, Teacher, Higher School Ruslan Magomedov Coordinator and Co-Founder, Observers (Kursk Oblast) of Economics Research University (Republic of Dagestan) of Dagestan project Olga Juravel Head of Journalism Training Department, (Novosibirsk Oblast) Novosibirsk State University 14 / 15 Kamran Manafly Author, Laboratory of Citizenship project Roman Rusanov Deputy Assistant, City Duma, (Krasnodar Krai) (Amur Oblast) Blagoveshchensk Mohammed Matiev Chairman, Council of Charitable Daria Rustamova Correspondent, Producer, Author of (Republic of North Foundations of Ingushetia; Co-Founder, (St Petersburg) Programmes, St Petersburg TV channel Ossetia-Alania) Metro Station social co-working Andrey Ryzhov Coordinator, Mentori National Resource Gertrude Mazaeva Civic Activist, Open Russia movement (Rostov Oblast) Center for Mentorship (Rostov Oblast) Anastasia Shamarina Editor, Krasnoyarsk Media Information Victoria Mikisha Freelance Correspondent, Takie Dela (Krasnoyarsk Krai) Agency (Khabarovsk Krai) (Tese kinds of Tings) on-line magazine Nikita Shishkin Director, Cinema TV channel Yunona Nevzorova Secretary of the Supreme Council, (St Petersburg) (Irkutsk Oblast) League of Young Voters, Irkutsk region Ivan Slobodenyuk Editor-in-Chief, Kommersant Southern Valeriya Odarenko Editor-in-Chief, Naukograd-Vesti (Chelyabinsk Oblast) Ural newspaper (Novosibirsk Oblast) newspaper and Naukograd-Press web Elena Sokovnina Editor-in-Chief, Te Source of Beauty portal (Kirov Oblast) and Health magazine Dmitry Pikalov Associate Professor, Advertising and Ekaterina Syschikova Deputy, State Assembly of the Republic of (Stavropol Krai) Public Relations Department, North- (Republic of Mordovia) Mordovia; Leader, Young Families Caucasian Federal University Club project Valeriya Pokidova Freelance Journalist; Volunteer, Alexey Tabalov Leader, Shkola Prizyvnika (School for (Amur Oblast) Volunteerism of Amur youth movement (Chelyabinsk Oblast) New Recruits) autonomous non-profit Ruslan Polonkoev Project Manager, Ezdel Cultural and human rights organisation (Republic of Ingushetia) Educational Centre Yevgeny Trubchenko SMM Specialist, Fifth Season company; Maria Ponomareva Head, Historical Urban Studies Master’s (Samara Oblast) Civic Activist (Rostov Oblast) Programme, Southern Federal University Julia Tsiruleva Editor-in-Chief, Besedka, Vestnik Yugo- Svetlana Prosvirina Director, Alliance company (Ivanovo Oblast) Zapada newspaper; Voluntary (Vologda Oblast) Lawyer, Dissernet project Lada Rodchanina Editor, Yuga.ru information portal Tatiana Udalova Senior Lecturer, , (Krasnodar Krai) (Amur Oblast) Communication and Journalism Department, Amur State University; Dmitry Rudenkin Associate Professor, Institute of Public Presenter, Echo of Moscow in (Sverdlovsk Oblast) Administration and Entrepreneurship, Blagoveshchensk radio station Ural Federal University

16 / 17 Ratmir Umaev Deputy Director, Rostov Branch of the (Rostov Oblast) All-Russian State Institute of Notes Cinematography Vera Vlasova Head of Special Projects, Journalist, Editor, (Kirov Oblast) Echo of Moscow in Kirov radio station Yuri Vorobiev Deputy Head of Entrepreneurship and (Novosibirsk Oblast) Investment Policy Department, Novosibirsk City Hall Ilyas Yusupov Leader, Civic Participation project (Republic of Dagestan)

Maria Zaryaeva Teacher of Mathematics, Orlyonok All- (Krasnodar Oblast) Russian Children’s Centre Anastasia Zhdanova Educator-Facilitator, Orlyonok-FM (Krasnodar Krai) radio station Mariana Zhinova Chief Editor of Art Broadcasting, (Karachay-Cherkess Republic) Arkhyz 24 TV channel Natalia Zhukova Sociologist; Coordinator of Health (Rostov Oblast) Projects

UKRAINE

Ilya Afanasyev Associate Professor, Deputy Head of the Department of Advertising and Public Relations, Institute of Journalism of Kyiv University Alexandra Karpenko Head of Events, Same but Different marketing communications agency Polina Lavrova Director, LAURUS publishing house Maria Litvin Press Secretary, Firtash Foundation private fund

18 / 19