Augmenting the Instrumental Music Program: a Case Study of Mark Wood’S Electrify Your Strings Program

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Augmenting the Instrumental Music Program: a Case Study of Mark Wood’S Electrify Your Strings Program AUGMENTING THE INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC PROGRAM: A CASE STUDY OF MARK WOOD’S ELECTRIFY YOUR STRINGS PROGRAM A Thesis by Jeremy Charles Samuel Bachelor of Music, Fort Hays State University, 2004 Submitted to the Department of Music and the faculty of the Graduate School of Wichita State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Music Education May 2018 © Copyright 2018 by Jeremy Charles Samuel All Rights Reserved AUGMENTING THE INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC PROGRAM: A CASE STUDY OF MARK WOOD’S ELECTRIFY YOUR STRINGS PROGRAM The following faculty members have examined the final copy of this thesis for form and content, and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Music Education, with a major in Instrumental Music. _______________________________ Steve Oare, Committee Chair _______________________________ Elaine Bernstorf, Committee Member _______________________________ Robert Bubp, Committee Member iii DEDICATION This thesis is dedicated to my wife, Alison, and my daughter, Layla, whose love, understanding and support are unwavering in all my undertakings. iv An experience-based philosophy of music education is inclusive of all musics and of all ways of being engaged with it because every particular kind and type of music, and every particular way music is made and received, represents a particular opportunity for musical experience. All such opportunities are precious. -Bennet Reimer v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my adviser, Steve Oare, for guiding me through the thesis process to completion and for his masterful editorial skills. I would also like to thank Elaine Bernstorf for introducing me to research and convincing me that I had the skills to complete a thesis. My wife, Alison and my daughter, Layla have my deepest gratitude. Thank you for your support and love despite the long hours this thesis kept me away. I am so fortunate to have you ladies in my life. Thank you also to Bill and Judy Pettijohn for pushing me to continue my education; I wouldn’t have done it otherwise. I am so fortunate to have you as parents. To all the participants in this study, and especially Mark Wood and Laura Kaye. Thank you for allowing me the time in your busy schedules for interviews and follow-up questions. Your insight into the Electrify Your Strings program made this thesis a reality. Finally, I would like to thank all of the music mentors I have had throughout the years who have shaped the way I think about music: Brad Shores, my high school band teacher; Neal Allsup, who gave me my first shot at playing jazz bass; Brad Dawson, who made sure I always found paid gigs; and especially Paul Ranieri, who has become not only my bass mentor, but also a good friend. vi ABSTRACT The purpose of this research was to examine Mark Wood’s Electrify Your Strings (EYS) program. Three research questions guided this study: 1) What is the history of the EYS program and what was the driving philosophy behind its start? 2) What are the pedagogical benefits, if any, that EYS provides for a typical music ensemble? 3) What is the perception of EYS by current music educators, students, parents and school administrators? This case study attempted to triangulate current research against participant interviews and their member checking, (Creswell and Poth, 2018). Participants were selected from current music educators, former high school students, parents of high school students, and school administrators who all had participated in an EYS event. Interviews were semi-structured in nature, transcribed, and double coded using a set of a priori codes that evolved between the first and second coding. Perception of the program was positive, citing increased student confidence, increased camaraderie in the ensemble, increased program growth and retention, and increased support of the program as benefits of participation in EYS. Perceived hindrances were few, cost of the program and logistics of hosting a program, but insignificant against the perceived benefits. EYS is not a new paradigm in music pedagogy. It doesn’t replace the long standing tradition of Western European classical music. It augments the successful pedagogy already being used in the classroom, incorporating classic rock and contemporary music, to encourage students to use creativity, innovation, movement, and self-expression to connect with music more deeply. Keywords: Popular music, informal learning, Mark Wood, Electrify Your Strings vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page 1. INTRODUCTION 01 Mark Wood’s Electrify Your Strings 01 The Problem 01 2. LITERATURE REVIEW 02 Perception 03 Teacher Perception 03 Student Perception 06 Perception in the United States 08 Perception outside the United States 09 Incorporating Popular Music-Informal Learning 10 Incorporating Popular Music-Creativity 13 Incorporating Popular Music-Notation 14 Incorporating Popular Music-Issues 15 Incorporating Popular Music-Benefits 16 Conclusion 18 3. METHODOLOGY 19 Introduction to Methodology 19 Researcher Bias 19 Research Questions 19 Methodology and Design 20 Population Sample 20 Instrumentation 21 Data Analysis 22 Ethical Considerations 22 Consent 22 Procedure 23 First Coding 24 Second Coding 25 4. RESULTS 26 Introduction to Results 26 Tallied Results 26 History of Electrify Your Strings 28 The EYS Process 29 Perception of EYS-Hindrances 32 viii TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Chapter Page Cost 32 Logistics 33 Perception of EYS-Benefits 34 Increased Support for the Orchestra Program 34 Increased Growth and Retention of the Orchestra Program 37 Increased Confidence Among Orchestra Students 38 Increased Camaraderie Among Orchestra Students 38 Personal Relationship with Wood and Kaye 39 Philosophy of Electrify Your Strings 39 5. DISCUSSION 41 Discussion 41 Research Question 1 42 Research Question 2 45 Research Question 3 47 Increased Confidence 47 Increased Growth and Retention of Orchestra Program 49 Increased Camaraderie 50 Increased Support 51 Personal Relationship 53 Summary 54 Recommendations for Future Research 55 Conclusion 56 BIBLIOGRAPHY 58 APPENDICES 62 A. Semi-Structured Interview Questions 63 B. A Priori Codes 77 C. Interview Transcripts 79 D. Consent Form 187 ix LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS EYS Electrify Your Strings TLP The Lakewood Project S.T.E.M. Science, Technology, Engineering and Math x CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION Mark Wood’s Electrify Your Strings I first heard about Mark Wood and his Electrify Your Strings (EYS) program when I attended a strings workshop led by Julie Lyonn Lieberman. She described a wild electric violin shaped like a ‘flying-v’ guitar that Wood invented and the rock music he was playing with high school students all over the United States. The Problem My first observation of an EYS event was in 2008. The performance was the culmination of a community youth orchestra’s EYS event which incorporated Mark Wood as well as The Mark Wood Experience. The Mark Wood Experience consisted of electric guitar and bass, drums, keyboard, vocals and Mark Wood playing his Viper seven string electric violin. The music performed ranged from The Beatles to Led Zeppelin and was presented in ‘rock concert’ fashion. In Humphreys’ (2004) paper on the history of popular music in schools he stated that the current public school music model has remained virtually unchanged since the late nineteenth century. Chapter 2: Literature Review discusses current incorporation of popular music in public school ensembles in the United States of America and other countries, examining hindrances to and potential benefits of full incorporation. This study set out to examine EYS as a means of incorporating popular music in the public school ensemble. 1 CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW According to Mantie (2013), popular music research has experienced a growth recently, though little information exists related to Mark Wood’s Electrify Your Strings (EYS) program, and no material specifically addresses the EYS program directly. For a program that has been in existence since 2001 in public school music programs across the United States (Robbins, 2011), this is surprising and it suggests that research of the EYS program is needed. Discussion of popular music has potential pitfalls, one of which is the language we use when discussing music other than that in the Western European classical tradition. Bowman (2004) defines popular music as music created for the enjoyment and enrichment of everyday people in their everyday lives. Rodriguez (2004) goes further, stating that, “Popular music had become the vernacular music of the young, suggesting they are more fluent in it in terms of basic skills like describing, performing, creating and responding: than in other types of music,” (pg. 21). Vernacular music is ordinary everyday music such as pop and folk music and often defined in part in terms of accessibility and in stark contrast to Art music. Vernacular as a term does not carry the dichotomy that popular does; if one music is described as popular, then there is a music that is not popular, which can often be easily misconstrued as ‘un-popular.’ Western European classical music, as well a jazz, was once the popular music of its time, yet it is no longer referenced as vernacular music. For the purpose of this paper, the term popular music will refer to music that is commonly found on the “Top 40” charts of the last 60 years. The term school music will refer to music common in the public school system. These include jazz, Western European classical music, and music specifically for the wind band. 2 In examining popular music, some common themes started to become clear. These themes involve the perception of popular music in school, the incorporation of popular music within the school music setting, and the over-arching rationale for the incorporation of popular music into school music settings. Perception There are four aspects of the perception of popular music in the classroom discussed in current research: How current music educators perceive popular music in the classroom.
Recommended publications
  • Negrocity: an Interview with Greg Tate
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works Publications and Research New York City College of Technology 2012 Negrocity: An Interview with Greg Tate Camille Goodison CUNY New York City College of Technology How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/ny_pubs/731 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] NEGROCITY An Interview with Greg Tate* by Camille Goodison As a cultural critic and founder of Burnt Sugar The Arkestra Chamber, Greg Tate has published his writings on art and culture in the New York Times, Village Voice, Rolling Stone, and Jazz Times. All Ya Needs That Negrocity is Burnt Sugar's twelfth album since their debut in 1999. Tate shared his thoughts on jazz, afro-futurism, and James Brown. GOODISON: Tell me about your life before you came to New York. TATE: I was born in Dayton, Ohio, and we moved to DC when I was about twelve, so that would have been about 1971, 1972, and that was about the same time I really got interested in music, collecting music, really interested in collecting jazz and rock, and reading music criticism too. It kinda all happened at the same time. I had a subscription to Rolling Stone. I was really into Miles Davis. He was like my god in the 1970s. Miles, George Clinton, Sun Ra, and locally we had a serious kind of band scene going on.
    [Show full text]
  • Sundayiournal
    STANDING STRONG FOR 1,459 DAYS — THE FIGHT'S NOT OVER YET JULY 11-17, 1999 THE DETROIT VOL. 4 NO. 34 75 CENTS S u n d a yIo u r n a l PUBLISHED BY LOCKED-OUT DETROIT NEWSPAPER WORKERS ©TDSJ JIM WEST/Special to the Journal Nicholle Murphy’s support for her grandmother, Teamster Meka Murphy, has been unflagging. Marching fourward Come Tuesday, it will be four yearsstrong and determined. In this editionOwens’ editorial points out the facthave shown up. We hope that we will since the day in July of 1995 that ofour the Sunday Journal, co-editor Susanthat the workers are in this strugglehave contracts before we have to put Detroit newspaper unions were forcedWatson muses on the times of happi­until the end and we are not goingtogether any­ another anniversary edition. to go on strike. Although the compa­ness and joy, in her Strike Diarywhere. on On Pages 19-22 we show offBut four years or 40, with your help, nies tried mightily, they never Pagedid 3. Starting on Page 4, we putmembers the in our annual Family Albumsolidarity and support, we will be here, break us. Four years after pickingevents up of the struggle on the record.and also give you a glimpse of somestanding of strong. our first picket signs, we remainOn Page 10, locked-out worker Keiththe far-flung places where lawn signs— Sunday Journal staff PAGE 10 JULY 11 1999 Co-editors:Susan Watson, Jim McFarlin --------------------- Managing Editor: Emily Everett General Manager: Tom Schram Published by Detroit Sunday Journal Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Rock Y Más Rock
    Image not found or type unknown www.juventudrebelde.cu Rock y más rock Publicado: Jueves 25 octubre 2007 | 12:00:11 am. Publicado por: Juventud Rebelde ElImage increíble not found or vocalista type unknown Chris Cornell El increíble vocalista Chris Cornell. A tono con la celebración por estos días de una nueva emisión del festival Ciudad Metal, evento que tiene por sede la capital villaclareña, dedico hoy mi sección a informar acerca de algunos discos salidos en meses recientes de este popular género musical. Quiero comenzar hablando de un CD que me ha encantado en particular. Tras la ruptura con sus compañeros de Audioslave, que optaron por rehacer a Rage Against The Machine, el notable vocalista Chris Cornell ha iniciado una carrera como solista con la presentación de Carry On, un álbum diría yo bastante intimista y personal. La pieza principal del CD es You know my name, un corte incluido en la banda sonora de la última película de James Bond, Casino Royale. Sin duda, este es uno de los buenos temas del fonograma, donde también aparecen otros muy sobresalientes como Arms around your love, Ghosts, Billie Jean o Finally forever. No creo ser reiterativo si aseguro que Chris se muestra en todas sus potencialidades como vocalista y corrobora que él es uno de los mejores cantantes de rock surgidos de los 90 hacia acá. Siempre he pensado que lo mejor de todo lo grabado por Smashing Pumpkins ha sido el doble disco Mellon collie and the infinite sadness, de 1995. Otras propuestas del ensamble, en verdad me han interesado muy poco.
    [Show full text]
  • The Complete Ask Scott
    ASK SCOTT Downloaded from the Loud Family / Music: What Happened? website and re-ordered into July-Dec 1997 (Year 1: the start of Ask Scott) July 21, 1997 Scott, what's your favorite pizza? Jeffrey Norman Scott: My favorite pizza place ever was Symposium Greek pizza in Davis, CA, though I'm relatively happy at any Round Table. As for my favorite topping, just yesterday I was rereading "Ash Wednesday" by T.S. Eliot (who can guess the topping?): Lady, three white leopards sat under a juniper-tree In the cool of the day, having fed to satiety On my legs my heart my liver and that which had been contained In the hollow round of my skull. And God said Shall these bones live? shall these Bones live? And that which had been contained In the bones (which were already dry) said chirping: Because of the goodness of this Lady And because of her loveliness, and because She honours the Virgin in meditation, We shine with brightness. And I who am here dissembled Proffer my deeds to oblivion, and my love To the posterity of the desert and the fruit of the gourd. It is this which recovers My guts the strings of my eyes and the indigestible portions Which the leopards reject. A: pepperoni. honest pizza, --Scott August 14, 1997 Scott, what's your astrological sign? Erin Amar Scott: Erin, wow! How are you? Aries. Do you think you are much like the publicized characteristics of that sun sign? Some people, it's important to know their signs; not me.
    [Show full text]
  • Featuring: Phi Kappa Phi Member Focus
    Featuring: Phi Kappa Phi Member Focus • Wish You Well Foundation • Seeger, Springsteen, and American Folk Music • Chapter News • David Thurmaier • Member News • Jazz Yesterday and Today: So Much Music for One Small Word • Bookshelf • David E. Aaberg The Quest for Country Music Jocelyn R. Neal The Songs Remain the Same…Sort of Philip Chang The Tale of Two Witches: Reflections on an Unlikely Friendship in Wicked Kevin Clifton American Music Education: A Struggle for Time and Curriculum David Conrad The Honor Society of Phi Kappa Phi was founded in 1897 and became a national organization through the Board of Directors efforts of the presidents of three state universities. Its Paul J. Ferlazzo, PhD primary objective has been from the first the recogni- National President tion and encouragement of superior scholarship in Northern Arizona University Dept. of English, Box 6032 all fields of study. Good character is an essential sup- Flagstaff, AZ 86011 porting attribute for those elected to membership. The motto of the Society is philosophia krateit¯o ph¯o t¯o n, Robert B. Rogow, CPA, PhD which is freely translated as “Let the love of learning National President-Elect rule humanity.” Eastern Kentucky University Phi Kappa Phi Forum Staff College of Business and Technology 317 Combs Building Guest Editor: Richmond, KY 40475 DAVID THURMAIER Donna Clark Schubert National Vice President Editor: Troy University 101-C Wallace Hall AMES AETZ J P. K Troy, AL 36082 Associate Editors: Wendell H. McKenzie, PhD STEPHANIE BOND SMITH Past President Phi Kappa Phi encourages and recognizes academic Dept. of Genetics LAURA J.
    [Show full text]
  • Black Rain.Pdf
    Produced by Ozzy Osbourne and Kevin Churko MUSICIANS: Ozzy Osbourne - Vocals Zakk Wylde – Guitars and Keyboards Mike Bordin – Drums and Percussion Blasko – Bass 1 Not Going Away We won't be breathing for long / When it's / All gone / Gone / We can never go back / Burn into the air and atmosphere / Watching Ozzy Osbourne, Zakk Wylde and Kevin Churko the rain come down / Turn your head away ignore the fear / Watching the ice crash down / Chorus: Our father's justice gets closer / Don't tell me I'm wrong / Don't tell me that you knew all along / I won't roll over dead / Only I know what goes on in my head / I've How could you fuck us all over / Rape, steal and murder / God bless the almighty dollar / Death, doom and disaster / The point of got nothing to hide / I'm not guilty inside / I won't give up / After all I'm still crazy / Chorus: I'm not going away / I'm not going / no return / No earthly life ever after / Is it too late to learn? / Burn into the air and atmosphere / Watching the rain come / Our Try so hard to break me / But all your diamonds turn to sand / I'm not going away / I'm not going / Say goodbye forever / I'll wait father's justice gets closer / How could you fuck us all over / Rape, steal and murder / God bless the almighty dollar / the almighty dollar for you in no man's land / Get out of my way / There's nothing you can do to change what I say / I won't ever let go / I got the answer but you'll never know / I got my eyes open wide /Ain't gonna slip up or slide / Can't take me down / After all I'm still crazy / 6 11 Silver
    [Show full text]
  • Tmz Marilyn Manson Points Fake Rifle
    http://www.tmz.com/2017/11/06/marilyn-manson-points-gun-concert-san-bernardino-shooting/ TMZ MARILYN MANSON POINTS FAKE RIFLE At San Bernardino Concert Crowd 11/6/2017 6:52 AM PST Marilyn Manson Points Fake Rifle at San Bernardino Concert Crowd Marilyn Manson showed a shocking lack of empathy Sunday night as he pretended to spray the crowd with bullets from a fake semi-automatic weapon ... in a county that is still reeling from a mass shooting. Marilyn --- in a wheelchair after a September injury that crushed his leg -- was performing at the Glen Helen Amphitheater in San Bernardino ... the city where a terrorist killed 14 people in December 2015. Perhaps with that in mind -- and a penchant for controversial headlines -- Marilyn pulled out the fake rifle while performing "We Know Where You F****** Live." A mic is attached to the scope of the rifle. Disturbing as hell. 11/6/2017 Marilyn Manson goes for a shock while Rob Zombie, Stone Sour rock at Knotfest 2017 – Press Enterprise THINGS TO DOMUSIC + CONCERTS Marilyn Manson goes for a shock while Rob Zombie, Stone Sour rock at Knotfest 2017 Marilyn Manson performs during day two of Ozzfest Meets Knotfest at Glen Helen Amphitheater Sunday in Devore, CA. November 5, 2017. (TERRY PIERSON,THE PRESS-ENTERPRISE/SCNG) By KELLI SKYE FADROSKI | [email protected] | Orange County Register PUBLISHED: November 6, 2017 at 12:21 am | UPDATED: November 6, 2017 at 6:14 am http://www.pe.com/2017/11/06/marilyn-manson-goes-for-a-shock-while-rob-zombie-stone-sour-rock-at-knotfest-2017/?utm_source=dlvr.it&ut… 1/7 11/6/2017 Marilyn Manson goes for a shock while Rob Zombie, Stone Sour rock at Knotfest 2017 – Press Enterprise Though the weather was cold, the ground was muddy and the sun was lost all day in the clouds, it didn’t stop thousands of die-hard heavy metal and hard rock fans from descending upon Glen Helen Amphitheater in Devore on Sunday, Nov.
    [Show full text]
  • Amazon Publishing London 2018 Non-Fiction
    LONDON 2018 RIGHTS GUIDE ADULT FICTION TITLES For Global Rights inquiries, please contact: Galen Maynard—Director, Global Rights Alexandra Levenberg—Sr. Manager, Global Rights Jodi Marchowsky—Manager, Global Rights Amazon Publishing 1350 Avenue of the Americas, 5th Floor New York, New York 10019 [email protected] Adult Fiction Rights Guide Table of Contents Book Club Fiction ................................................................................... 2 Graphic Novels ......................................................................................36 Inspirational Fiction .............................................................................43 Literary Fiction and Poetry .................................................................48 Mysteries and Thrillers ........................................................................56 Romance ................................................................................................95 Science Fiction and Fantasy ..............................................................128 For media inquiries, please contact: [email protected] ©2018. Amazon Publishing, Amazon Encore, 47North, AmazonCrossing, Edition M, Jet City Comics, Lake Union Publishing, Little A, Montlake Romance, Thomas & Mercer, Tinte & Feder, and Waterfall Press are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates. All Rights Reserved. Book Club Fiction The Passion Against the The Dragon Queen According to Inquisition William Andrews Carmela Marcos Aguinis Historical Fiction Lake
    [Show full text]