Stratigraphy and Geochronology of Upper Quaternary Eolian Sand on the Southern High Plains of Texas and New Mexico, United States
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Stratigraphy and geochronology of upper Quaternary eolian sand on the Southern High Plains of Texas and New Mexico, United States Vance T. Holliday* Department of Geography, 550 North Park Street, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA ABSTRACT posits most likely were remobilized in late INTRODUCTION Holocene time. Most of the deposits and Eolian sand in dune ®elds and sand landforms of the dune ®elds and sand The Southern High Plains of northwestern sheets cover .10 000 km2 (;10%) of the sheets are late Holocene, dating before 4000 Texas and eastern New Mexico is a semiarid Southern High Plains of northwestern Tex- 14C yr B.P. and mostly before 1500 14Cyr region known to be affected by drought and as and eastern New Mexico. These deposits B.P. The Muleshoe and Lea-Yoakum dunes wind erosion. Wind erosion is a particularly are concentrated in three west-east±trend- and the Seminole sand sheet underwent persistent problem in this dry region, docu- ing belts of dunes (the Muleshoe, Lea- substantial eastward expansion in late Ho- mented to some degree in all years of the his- Yoakum, and Andrews dune ®elds, from locene time. Buried soils and radiocarbon toric record (e.g., Fryrear and Randel, 1972; north to south) that appear to be eastern ages show that the eolian sand accumulated Kimberlin et al., 1977). New data show that extensions of the Mescalero-Monahans in several stages, probably in response to wind erosion and eolian sedimentation oc- dune system in the Pecos River valley, and cyclic drought. The Muleshoe dunes accu- curred periodically in the region during late in the Seminole sand sheet, a discontinuous mulated after ca. 1300 cal yr B.P. (ca. 1400 Quaternary time and that these processes were accumulation of sheet sands between the 14C yr B.P.), after ca. 750±670 cal yr B.P. likely the result of episodic drought and in Lea-Yoakum and Monahans-Andrews (ca. 850±750 14C yr B.P.), just after ca. 500 some cases prolonged aridity (Holliday, dunes. The most common landforms are cal yr B.P. (ca. 450 14C yr B.P.), and during 1989a, 1995a, 1995b, 1997a, 1997b, 2000a). parabolic dunes associated with blowouts, the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The Given this geologic record and the paleocli- coppice dunes, and sand sheets, all typical Lea-Yoakum dunes were active after ca. matic implications for the Southern High of sandy, vegetated, semiarid landscapes, 3400 cal yr B.P. (ca. 3200 14C yr B.P.) and Plains, and predictions based on the results of barchan dunes, in keeping with a relatively historically. The Seminole sand sheet was most climate models used in studies of green- limited sand supply and an underlying sur- active ca. 430±330 cal yr B.P. (ca. 360 14C house warming (e.g., Schneider, 1989; Smith face that is relatively hard (Blackwater yr B.P.) and in the twentieth century. The and Tirpak, 1990; Woodhouse and Overpeck, Draw Formation, Pleistocene), and fence- Andrews dunes were subjected to at least 1998), a reasonable assumption can be made row dunes, historic dunes formed along two phases of eolian sedimentation after ca. that these phenomena will continue to be a ®eld boundaries. These eolian deposits ac- 2320 cal yr B.P. (ca. 2320 14C yr B.P.). severe problem in the region. cumulated episodically in the late Pleisto- Comparisons with eolian chronologies from A more complete assessment of the effects cene and Holocene and provide clues to the other regions on the Great Plains suggest of future drought on the High Plains landscape history of regional drought and aridity. The that dune mobilization was a regional phe- requires a better understanding of the history earliest phase of sedimentation occurred and impact of past climatic extremes. Pre- nomenon after ca. 2300 cal yr B.P. (ca. 2300 when sheet sands were deposited between ferred long-term, high-resolution records such 14C yr B.P.); after ca. 1500±1400 cal yr B.P. 11 000 and 8000 14C yr B.P., probably in as tree rings and speleothems are not available (ca. 1650±1550 14C yr B.P.); after ca. 700 several phases, based on archaeological for most parts of the Great Plains. Moreover, cal yr B.P. (ca. 800 14C yr B.P.); between data, as a result of episodic drought begin- environmental conditions on the Southern 500 and 300 cal yr B.P. (ca. 450±300 14Cyr ning between 11 000 and 10 000 yr B.P. Eo- High Plains inhibit preservation of extensive B.P.); and in the nineteenth century. The lian deposits dating between 8000 and 3000 or long-term paleontological or paleobotanical climatic ¯uctuations responsible for mobi- yr B.P. are rare, although eolian sediment records. The eolian record, although far from lizing the dunes probably were relatively 8000±4500 14C yr B.P. is ubiquitous in the ideal, appears to be the most complete late minor, yet the landscape impacts were sub- draws that cross the region, and paleoen- Quaternary, regionally traceable indicator of stantial, resulting in widespread wind ero- vironmental indicators show that the region the geomorphic response to climatic extremes, was subjected to aridity throughout middle sion and dune construction. especially periods of prolonged drought. Eo- Holocene time. The middle Holocene de- lian sediments and associated soils are the Keywords: dunes, lamellae, New Mexico, most obvious and most extensive products of *E-mail: [email protected]. Southern High Plains, Texas. the past 30 k.y. and more of eolian activity in GSA Bulletin; January 2001; v. 113; no. 1; p. 88±108; 10 ®gures; 5 tables; Data Repository item 2001012. For permission to copy, contact Copyright Clearance Center at www.copyright.com 88 q 2001 Geological Society of America STRATIGRAPHY AND GEOCHRONOLOGY OF UPPER QUATERNARY EOLIAN SAND the region. Moreover, the dunes in particular east sides of some playas. The dune ®elds and 1961; Hawley et al., 1976) that the dune ®elds are believed to be very sensitive to the effects lunettes have different origins and stratigraph- were constructed by westerly winds funneled of drought and deserti®cation (Forman et al., ic records. The focus of this paper is the are- through reentrants of the western escarpment. 1992, 1995; Muhs and Maat, 1993; Muhs et ally more extensive dune ®elds. The lunettes In the Muleshoe dunes, several phases of al., 1997a). were described elsewhere (Holliday, 1997a). late Quaternary dune construction were iden- In order to better understand the history of The lunettes and dune ®elds mantle the Black- ti®ed by Green (1951) and Gile (1979, 1981, wind erosion and eolian sedimentation in the water Draw Formation and, where the Black- 1985), but they had very limited age control. Southern High Plains, I conducted a system- water Draw Formation was de¯ated or never Gile (1979) also showed that soil morphology atic investigation of the dune ®elds and sand deposited, the Ogallala Formation (Holliday, could be a useful tool for stratigraphic corre- sheets of the region (largely 1992±1996) that 1995b, 1997a). Sedimentation in the draws, lation throughout the dune ®eld. Haynes cover ;10% of the surface. The work focused playas, and lunettes began in late Pleistocene (1975, 1995) and I (Holliday, 1995a) pro- on (1) the eolian record as an indicator of the time, and the valleys and lake basins ®lled duced the only numerical age control for the late Quaternary paleoenvironments, comple- with a variety of deposits (Haynes, 1975; Muleshoe dunes, indicating that the sediment menting systematic studies of the draws (Hol- Reeves, 1991; Holliday, 1995a; Holliday et accumulated episodically from the early to liday, 1995a) and lunettes (Holliday, 1997a), al., 1996). late Holocene. and (2) the geomorphic evolution of the Most of the eolian sand of the Southern In the Monahans dunes, a complex record dunes, in particular clues concerning the sen- High Plains is found in three west-east±trend- of Pleistocene and Holocene eolian sedimen- sitivity of the sands for remobilization. This ing dune ®elds associated with reentrant val- tation was recognized by Huf®ngton and Al- paper presents the results of that research. For leys in the western escarpment (Fig. 1). From britton (1941) and Green (1961). They corre- a concurrent study of the source areas of the north to south, these sands are in the Mule- lated the deposits using vertebrate faunas, but dunes based on mineralogy and geochemistry, shoe dunes (or sandhills); the informally otherwise had no means for re®ning the geo- see Muhs and Holliday (2001). termed Lea-Yoakum dunes (or Bledsoe chronology. East of the Monahans dunes, ar- dunes); and the informally termed Andrews chaeological stratigraphy, paleontology, and SETTING AND BACKGROUND dunes. An extensive belt of dunes is located soils were used to reconstruct the eolian re- in the Pecos Valley adjacent to the western cord at the Midland archaeological site in the The Southern High Plains, or Llano Esta- escarpment of the High Plains (Fig. 1), called Scharbauer dunes (Wendorf et al., 1955; Wen- cado (``stockaded plains''), is a broad plateau the Mescalero dunes in New Mexico and the dorf and Krieger, 1959). Recent geoarchaeo- covering ;130 000 km2 (Fig. 1). It is an al- Monahans dunes in Texas. logical research in the area re®ned the chro- most featureless plain, historically a prairie of Smaller, isolated dune ®elds and sand sheets nology at the Midland site and also showed perennial short grass (Blair, 1950). Altitudes are also scattered across the southern and that there were at least two local phases of range from 1700 m in the northwest to 750 m southwestern Southern High Plains. A few of eolian sedimentation in the Holocene (Hof- in the southeast.