DOCSLIB.ORG

Consistent Thermostatistics Forbids Negative Absolute Temperatures

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Consistent Thermostatistics Forbids Negative Absolute Temperatures ARTICLES PUBLISHED ONLINE: 8 DECEMBER 2013 | DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS2815 Consistent thermostatistics forbids negative absolute temperatures Jörn Dunkel1* and Stefan Hilbert2 Over the past 60 years, a considerable number of theories and experiments have claimed the existence of negative absolute temperature in spin systems and ultracold quantum gases. This has led to speculation that ultracold gases may be dark-energy analogues and also suggests the feasibility of heat engines with efficiencies larger than one. Here, we prove that all previous negative temperature claims and their implications are invalid as they arise from the use of an entropy definition that is inconsistent both mathematically and thermodynamically. We show that the underlying conceptual deficiencies can be overcome if one adopts a microcanonical entropy functional originally derived by Gibbs. The resulting thermodynamic framework is self-consistent and implies that absolute temperature remains positive even for systems with a bounded spectrum. In addition, we propose a minimal quantum thermometer that can be implemented with available experimental techniques. ositivity of absolute temperature T, a key postulate of Gibbs formalism yields strictly non-negative absolute temperatures thermodynamics1, has repeatedly been challenged both even for quantum systems with a bounded spectrum, thereby Ptheoretically2–4 and experimentally5–7. If indeed realizable, invalidating all previous negative temperature claims. negative temperature systems promise profound practical and conceptual consequences. They might not only facilitate the Negative absolute temperatures? creation of hyper-efficient heat engines2–4 but could also help7 to The seemingly plausible standard argument in favour of negative resolve the cosmological dark-energy puzzle8,9. Measurements of absolute temperatures goes as follows10: assume a suitably designed negative absolute temperature were first reported in 1951 by Purcell many-particle quantum system with a bounded spectrum5,7 can and Pound5 in seminal work on the population inversion in nuclear be driven to a stable state of population inversion, so that most spin systems. Five years later, Ramsay’s comprehensive theoretical particles occupy high-energy one-particle levels. In this case, the study2 clarified hypothetical ramifications of negative temperature one-particle energy distribution will be an increasing function of the states, most notably the possibility to achieve Carnot efficiencies one-particle energy ✏. To fit7,10 such a distribution with a Boltzmann ⌘>1 (refs 3,4). Recently, the first experimental realization of an factor exp( ✏), β must be negative, implying a negative Boltz- 7 / − 1 ultracold bosonic quantum gas with a bounded spectrum has mann ‘temperature’ TB (kBβ)− < 0. Although this reasoning attracted considerable attention10 as another apparent example may indeed seem straightforward,= the arguments below clarify that system with T < 0, encouraging speculation that cold-atom gases TB is, in general, not the absolute thermodynamic temperature T, could serve as laboratory dark-energy analogues. unless one is willing to abandon the mathematical consistency of 1 Here, we show that claims of negative absolute temperature thermostatistics. We shall prove that the parameter TB (kBβ)− , in spin systems and quantum gases are generally invalid, as they as determined by Purcell and Pound5 and more recently= also in arise from the use of a popular yet inconsistent microcanonical ref. 7 is, in fact, a function of both temperature T and heat capacity 11 entropy definition attributed to Boltzmann . By means of rigorous C. This function TB(T,C) can indeed become negative, whereas the derivations12 and exactly solvable examples, we will demonstrate actual thermodynamic temperature T always remains positive. that the Boltzmann entropy, despite being advocated in most modern textbooks13, is incompatible with the differential structure Entropies of closed systems of thermostatistics, fails to give sensible predictions for analytically When interpreting thermodynamic data of new many-body states7, tractable quantum and classical systems, and violates equipartition one of the first questions to be addressed is the choice of the in the classical limit. The general mathematical incompatibility appropriate thermostatistical ensemble15,16. Equivalence of the implies that it is logically inconsistent to insert negative Boltz- microcanonical and other statistical ensembles cannot—in fact, mann ‘temperatures’ into standard thermodynamic relations, thus must not—be taken for granted for systems that are characterized explaining paradoxical (wrong) results for Carnot efficiencies and by a non-monotonic2,4,7 density of states (DOS) or that can undergo other observables. The deficiencies of the Boltzmann entropy can phase-transitions due to attractive interactions17—gravity being a be overcome by adopting a self-consistent entropy concept that prominent example18. Population-inverted systems are generally was derived by Gibbs more than 100 years ago14, but has been thermodynamically unstable when coupled to a (non-population- mostly forgotten ever since. Unlike the Boltzmann entropy, Gibbs’ inverted) heat bath and, hence, must be prepared in isolation5–7. entropy fulfils the fundamental thermostatistical relations and In ultracold quantum gases7 that have been isolated from the produces sensible predictions for heat capacities and other ther- environment to suppress decoherence, both particle number modynamic observables in all exactly computable test cases. The and energy are in good approximation conserved. Therefore, 1Department of Mathematics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue E17-412, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139-4307, USA, 2Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics, Karl-Schwarzschild-Straße 1, Garching 85748, Germany. *e-mail: [email protected] NATURE PHYSICS VOL 10 JANUARY 2014 www.nature.com/naturephysics 67 | | | ǟɥƐƎƏƓɥ !,(++-ɥ4 +(2'#12ɥ (,(3#"ƥɥ++ɥ1(%'32ɥ1#2#15#"ƥɥ ARTICLES NATURE PHYSICS DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS2815 barring other physical or topological constraints, any ab initio Note that TB becomes negative if !0 < 0, that is, if the DOS is thermostatistical treatment should start from the microcanonical non-monotic, whereas TG is always non-negative, because ⌦ is ensemble. We will first prove that only the Gibbs entropy provides a monotonic function of E. The question as to whether TB or a consistent thermostatistical model for the microcanonical density TG defines the thermodynamic absolute temperature T can be operator. Instructive examples will be discussed subsequently. decided unambiguously by considering the differential structure of We consider a (quantum or classical) system with microscopic thermodynamics, which is encoded in the fundamental relation variables ⇠ governed by the Hamiltonian H H(⇠ V , A), = ; where V denotes volume and A (A1,...) summarizes other @S @S @S = dS dE dV dAi external parameters. If the dynamics conserves the energy E, all = @E + @V + @A ✓ ◆ ✓ ◆ i ✓ i ◆ thermostatistical information about the system is contained in the 1 p ai X microcanonical density operator dE dV dAi (4) ⌘ T + T + i T δ(E H) X ⇢(⇠ E,V ,A) − (1) All consistent thermostatistical models, corresponding to pairs ; = ! (⇢,S) where ⇢ is a density operator and S an entropy potential, must which is normalized by the DOS satisfy equation (4). If one abandons this requirement, any relation to thermodynamics is lost. !(E,V ,A) Tr δ(E H) Equation (4) imposes stringent constraints on possible entropy = [ − ] candidates. For example, for an adiabatic (that is, isentropic) When considering quantum systems, we assume, as usual, volume change with dS 0 and other parameters fixed (dAi 0), that equation (1) has a well-defined operator interpretation, for one finds the consistency= condition = example, as a limit of an operator series. For classical systems, the trace simply becomes a phase-space integral over ⇠. The average of @S @E @H p T (5) some quantity F with respect to ⇢ is denoted by F Tr F⇢ , and = @V =− @V =− @V we define the integrated DOS h i⌘ [ ] ✓ ◆ ✓ ◆ ⌧ More generally, for any adiabatic variation of some parameter ⌦(E,V ,A) Tr ⇥(E H) Aµ V ,Ai of the Hamiltonian H, one must have (Supple- = [ − ] mentary2{ Information)} which is related to the DOS ! by differentiation, @S @E @H @⌦ T (6) ! ⌦ 0 @Aµ E =− @Aµ S =− @Aµ = @E ⌘ ✓ ◆ ✓ ◆ ⌧ 1 Intuitively, for a quantum system with spectrum E , the quantity where T (@S/@E)− and subscripts S and E indicate quantities { n} ⌘ ⌦(En,V ,A) counts the number of eigenstates with energy less kept constant, respectively. The first equality in equation (6) follows than or equal to En. directly from equation (4). The second equality demands correct Given the microcanonical density operator from equation (1), identification of thermodynamic quantities with statistical expec- one can find two competing definitions for the microcanonical tation values, guaranteeing for example that mechanically mea- entropy in the literature12–14,17,19,20: sured gas pressure agrees with abstract thermodynamic pressure. The conditions in equation (6) not only ensure that the thermo- S (E,V ,A) k ln(✏!), B = B dynamic potential S fulfils the fundamental differential relation (equation (4)). For a given density operator ⇢, they can be used to SG(E,V ,A) kB ln(⌦) = separate consistent entropy definitions from inconsistent ones. where ✏ is a constant with dimensions of energy, required to Using only the properties of
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Temperature Dependence of Breakdown and Avalanche Multiplication in In0.53Ga0.47As Diodes and Heterojunction Bipolar Transistors
    This is a repository copy of Temperature dependence of breakdown and avalanche multiplication in In0.53Ga0.47As diodes and heterojunction bipolar transistors . White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/896/ Article: Yee, M., Ng, W.K., David, J.P.R. et al. (3 more authors) (2003) Temperature dependence of breakdown and avalanche multiplication in In0.53Ga0.47As diodes and heterojunction bipolar transistors. IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, 50 (10). pp. 2021-2026. ISSN 0018-9383 https://doi.org/10.1109/TED.2003.816553 Reuse Unless indicated otherwise, fulltext items are protected by copyright with all rights reserved. The copyright exception in section 29 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 allows the making of a single copy solely for the purpose of non-commercial research or private study within the limits of fair dealing. The publisher or other rights-holder may allow further reproduction and re-use of this version - refer to the White Rose Research Online record for this item. Where records identify the publisher as the copyright holder, users can verify any specific terms of use on the publisher’s website. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELECTRON DEVICES, VOL. 50, NO. 10, OCTOBER 2003 2021 Temperature Dependence of Breakdown and Avalanche Multiplication in InHXSQGaHXRUAs Diodes and Heterojunction Bipolar Transistors M.
    [Show full text]
  • PHYS 596 Team 1
    Braun, S., Ronzheimer, J., Schreiber, M., Hodgman, S., Rom, T., Bloch, I. and Schneider, U. (2013). Negative Absolute Temperature for Motional Degrees of Freedom. Science, 339(6115), pp.52-55. PHYS 596 Team 1 Shreya, Nina, Nathan, Faisal What is negative absolute temperature? • An ensemble of particles is said to have negative absolute temperature if higher energy states are more likely to be occupied than lower energy states. −퐸푖/푘푇 푃푖 ∝ 푒 • If high energy states are more populated than low energy states, entropy decreases with energy. 1 휕푆 ≡ 푇 휕퐸 Negative absolute temperature Previous work on negative temperature • The first experiment to measure negative temperature was performed at Harvard by Purcell and Pound in 1951. • By quickly reversing the magnetic field acting on a nuclear spin crystal, they produced a sample where the higher energy states were more occupied. • Since then negative temperature ensembles in spin systems have been produced in other ways. Oja and Lounasmaa (1997) gives a comprehensive review. Negative temperature for motional degrees of freedom • For the probability distribution of a negative temperature ensemble to be normalizable, we need an upper bound in energy. • Since localized spin systems have a finite number of energy states there is a natural upper bound in energy. • This is hard to achieve in systems with motional degrees of freedom since kinetic energy is usually not bounded from above. • Braun et al (2013) achieves exactly this with bosonic cold atoms in an optical lattice. What is the point? • At thermal equilibrium, negative temperature implies negative pressure. • This is relevant to models of dark energy and cosmology based on Bose-Einstein condensation.
    [Show full text]
  • Two Level System & Negative Temperature
    PHYS4006: Thermal and Statistical Physics Lecture Notes Part - 4 (Unit - IV) Two Level System & Negative Temperature Dr. Neelabh Srivastava (Assistant Professor) Department of Physics Programme: M.Sc. Physics Mahatma Gandhi Central University Semester: 2nd Motihari-845401, Bihar E-mail: [email protected] Two level energy system • Consider a system having two non-degenerate microstates with energies ε1 and ε2. The energy difference between the levels is ε= ε - ε 2 1 ε2 Let us assume that the system is in ε= ε - ε thermal equilibrium at temperature T. 2 1 So, the partition function of the system is – ε1 Z exp 1 exp 2 ........(1) kT kT The probability of occupancy of these states is given by - exp 1 exp 1 kT kT 1 P 1 Z exp 1 exp 2 1 exp 2 1 kT kT kT 2 exp 2 exp 2 exp 2 1 kT kT kT P 2 Z exp 1 exp 2 1 exp 2 1 kT kT kT or, 1 and exp P1 ......(2) T P ........(3) 1 exp 2 T 1 exp T where 2 1 k From (2) and (3), we can see that P1 and P2 depends on T. Thus, if T=0, P1=1 and P2=0 (System is in ground state) When T<<θ, i.e. kT<<ε then P2 is negligible and it begins to increase when temperature is increased. 3 • Consider a paramagnetic substance having N magnetic atoms per unit volume placed in an external magnetic field B. Assume that each atoms has spin ½ and an intrinsic magnetic moment μB.
    [Show full text]
  • Atomic Gases at Negative Kinetic Temperature
    PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending PRL 95, 040403 (2005) 22 JULY 2005 Atomic Gases at Negative Kinetic Temperature A. P. Mosk Department of Science & Technology, and MESA+ Research Institute, University of Twente, P.O. Box 217, 7500 AE Enschede, The Netherlands and Laboratoire Kastler-Brossel, Ecole Normale Supe´rieure, 24 rue Lhomond, 75231 Paris CEDEX 05, France (Received 26 January 2005; published 21 July 2005) We show that thermalization of the motion of atoms at negative temperature is possible in an optical lattice, for conditions that are feasible in current experiments. We present a method for reversibly inverting the temperature of a trapped gas. Moreover, a negative-temperature ensemble can be cooled (reducing jTj) by evaporation of the lowest-energy particles. This enables the attainment of the Bose- Einstein condensation phase transition at negative temperature. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.95.040403 PACS numbers: 03.75.Hh, 03.75.Lm, 05.70.2a Amplification of a macroscopic degree of freedom, such ized in the vicinity of a band gap in a three-dimensional as a laser or maser field, or the motion of an object, is a (3D) optical lattice. The band gap is an energy range inside phenomenon of enormous technological and scientific im- which no single-particle eigenstates exist. If the atoms are portance. In classical thermodynamics, amplification is not constrained to energies just below the band gap the effec- possible in thermal equilibrium at positive temperature. In tive mass will be negative in all directions and the entropy contrast, due to the fluctuation-dissipation theorems [1,2], of the ensemble will decrease with energy.
    [Show full text]
  • Query on Negative Temperature, Internal Interactions and Decrease
    Query on Negative Temperature, Internal Interactions and Decrease of Entropy Yi-Fang Chang Department of Physics, Yunnan University, Kunming, 650091, China (e-mail: [email protected]) Abstract: After negative temperature is restated, we find that it will derive necessarily decrease of entropy. Negative temperature is based on the Kelvin scale and the condition dU>0 and dS<0. Conversely, there is also negative temperature for dU<0 and dS>0. But, negative temperature is contradiction with usual meaning of temperature and with some basic concepts of physics and mathematics. It is a question in nonequilibrium thermodynamics. We proposed a possibility of decrease of entropy due to fluctuation magnified and internal interactions in some isolated systems. From this we discuss some possible examples and theories. Keywords: entropy; negative temperature; nonequilibrium. PACS: 05.70.-a, 05.20.-y 1.Restatement of Negative Temperature In thermodynamics negative temperature is a well-known idea proposed and expounded by Ramsey [1] and Landau [2], et al. Ramsey discussed the thermodynamics and statistical mechanics of negative absolute temperatures in a detailed and fundamental manner [1]. He proved that if the entropy of a thermodynamic system is not a monotonically increasing function of its internal energy, it possesses a negative temperature whenever ( S / U ) X is negative. Negative temperatures are hotter than positive temperature. He pointed out: from a thermodynamic point of view the only requirement for the existence of a negative temperature is that the entropy S should not be restricted to a monotonically increasing function of the internal energy U. In the thermodynamic equation relating TdS and dU, a temperature is 1 T ( S / U) X .
    [Show full text]
  • NIKOLAI G. BASOV the High Sensitivity of Quantum Amplifiers, and There Was Investigated the Possibility of the Creation of Various Types of Lasers
    N IKOLAI G . B A S O V Semiconductor lasers Nobel Lecture, December 11, 1964 In modern physics, and perhaps this was true earlier, there are two different trends. One group of physicists has the aim of investigating new regularities and solving existing contradictions. They believe the result of their work to be a theory; in particular, the creation of the mathematical apparatus of modern physics. As a by-product there appear new principles for constructing devices, physical devices. The other group, on the contrary, seeks to create physical devices using new physical principles. They try to avoid the inevitable difficulties and con- tradictions on the way to achieving that purpose. This group considers various hypotheses and theories to be the by-product of their activity. Both groups have made outstanding achievements. Each group creates a nutrient medium for the other and therefore they are unable to exist without one another; although, their attitude towards each other is often rather critical. The first group calls the second « inventors », while the second group accuses the first of abstractness or sometimes of aimlessness. One may think at first sight that we are speaking about experimentors and theoreticians. However, this is not so, because both groups include these two kinds of physicists. At present this division into two groups has become so pronounced that one may easily attribute whole branches of science to the first or to the second group, although there are some fields of physics where both groups work together. Included in the first group are most research workers in such fields as quan- tum electrodynamics, the theory of elementary particles, many branches of nuclear physics, gravitation, cosmology, and solid-state physics.
    [Show full text]
  • Light and Thermodynamics: the Three-Level Laser As an Endoreversible Heat Engine
    Light and thermodynamics: The three-level laser as an endoreversible heat engine Peter Muys Laser Power Optics, Ter Rivierenlaan 1 P.O. box 4, 2100 Antwerpen Belgium [email protected] +32 477 451916 Abstract: In the past, a number of heat engine models have been devised to apply the principles of thermodynamics to a laser. The best one known is the model using a negative temperature to describe population inversion. In this paper, we present a new temperature scale not based on reservoir temperatures. This is realized by revealing a formal mathematical similarity between the expressions for the optimum power generated by an endoreversible heat engine and the optimum output-coupled power from a three-level laser resonator. As a consequence, the theory of endoreversibility can be applied to enable a new efficiency analysis of the cooling of high- power lasers. We extend the endoreversibility concept also to the four-level laser model. 1. Introduction It was found very early in the history of the laser that a three-level optical amplifier could be considered as a heat engine [1] . The justification was based on a quantum model of the lasing element, and hence was named a “quantum heat engine”. The engine is working between two reservoirs, the hot and the cold one, at respective (absolute) temperatures TH and TC. In the ideal case of reversible operation, this engine follows the Carnot law: its efficiency with which heat (pump power) is converted to work (laser power) is limited by TC =1 − (1) TH A number of conceptual difficulties were pointed out later [2] , such as the debatable assignment of negative temperatures to the different atomic transitions, since these are out of equilibrium, and hence not suited to the concept of temperature which presupposes thermal equilibrium.
    [Show full text]
  • Mesoscopy and Thermodynamics
    EPJ manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Mesoscopy and thermodynamics L. G. Moretto, J. B. Elliott, and L. Phair Nuclear Science Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720 Received: date / Revised version: date Abstract. The interplay of thermodynamics and statistical mechanics is discussed with special attention to mesoscopic systems and phase transitions. PACS. 25.70.Pq – 05.70.Jk – 24.60.Ky – 64.60.Ak 1 Introduction course of theoretical speculation is wisely trimmed by the correctness of thermodynamical empiricism. Thermodynamics is an empirical science devoted to the The “recent” extension of experimental [1–3] and the- description of macroscopic systems. It follows formally oretical research to systems that are neither wholly mi- from its three principles and stands firmly independent croscopic nor macroscopic, thus aptly named mesoscopic, of any microscopic description. Statistical mechanics, on should be enlightened by the same wisdom. While names the other hand, is founded on the general principles of and functions (temperature, entropy, free energy...) were mechanics, and attempts to bridge the gap from the mi- borrowed from thermodynamics, the urge to label the field croscopic description of a system to its macroscopic ther- as “novel” led to rash statements such as the primacy of modynamical properties. This attempt has met with un- one ensemble (microcanonical) over the others, or even deniable success through the introduction of ensembles to the affirmation of a “new” thermodynamics or to the such as microcanonical, canonical, grand canonical, etc., “failure” of the “old” thermodynamics and its principles. whereby microstates, constrained to satisfy some specific These rash statements have often been accompanied macroscopic conditions are used to obtain average values by a cavalier disregard for the physical definitions and of macroscopic variables.
    [Show full text]
  • Statistical Physics
    Part II | Statistical Physics Based on lectures by H. S. Reall Notes taken by Dexter Chua Lent 2017 These notes are not endorsed by the lecturers, and I have modified them (often significantly) after lectures. They are nowhere near accurate representations of what was actually lectured, and in particular, all errors are almost surely mine. Part IB Quantum Mechanics and \Multiparticle Systems" from Part II Principles of Quantum Mechanics are essential Fundamentals of statistical mechanics Microcanonical ensemble. Entropy, temperature and pressure. Laws of thermody- namics. Example of paramagnetism. Boltzmann distribution and canonical ensemble. Partition function. Free energy. Specific heats. Chemical Potential. Grand Canonical Ensemble. [5] Classical gases Density of states and the classical limit. Ideal gas. Maxwell distribution. Equipartition of energy. Diatomic gas. Interacting gases. Virial expansion. Van der Waal's equation of state. Basic kinetic theory. [3] Quantum gases Density of states. Planck distribution and black body radiation. Debye model of phonons in solids. Bose{Einstein distribution. Ideal Bose gas and Bose{Einstein condensation. Fermi-Dirac distribution. Ideal Fermi gas. Pauli paramagnetism. [8] Thermodynamics Thermodynamic temperature scale. Heat and work. Carnot cycle. Applications of laws of thermodynamics. Thermodynamic potentials. Maxwell relations. [4] Phase transitions Liquid-gas transitions. Critical point and critical exponents. Ising model. Mean field theory. First and second order phase transitions. Symmetries and order parameters. [4] 1 Contents II Statistical Physics Contents 0 Introduction 3 1 Fundamentals of statistical mechanics 4 1.1 Microcanonical ensemble . .4 1.2 Pressure, volume and the first law of thermodynamics . 12 1.3 The canonical ensemble . 15 1.4 Helmholtz free energy .
    [Show full text]
  • 3.6 MC-CE Negative Temperature II
    Negative temperature II Masatsugu Sei Suzuki Department of Physics, SUNY at Binghamton (Date: November 29, 2018) Fig. (a) Subsystem 1 has an upper limit to energy it can have, whereas subsystem 2 is a normal thermodynamic system, which has no upper limit to the energy it can have and is always T at a positive absolute temperature ( 2 0 ). In the initial state, with the adiabatic partition T in place, subsystem 1 starts at a negative absolute temperature ( 1 0 ). (b) The adiabatic partition is replaced by a diathermic partition. In the approach to thermal equilibrium, heat is transferred, on average, from subsystem 1, which is initially at a negative absolute temperature, to subsystem 2 which is always at a positive absolute temperature. 1 S 1 S 1 , 2 T U T U 1 1 V N 2 2 V N 1, 1 2, 2 As the closed composite system as shown in the above figure, approaches thermal equilibrium on average, S S dS dS1 dU 2 dU 0 12U 1 U 2 1VN 2 VN 11, 22 , U U Since 1 2 constant, we get dU dU 2 1 Hence we have S S dSdS[1 2 ] dU 1 2 U U 2 1VN 2 VN 11, 22 , 1 1 ( ) dU T T 2 2 1 T T 1 2 dU 0 TT 2 1 2 where 1 S 1 S 1 , 2 T U T U 1 1 V N 2 2 V N 1, 1 2, 2 T T T T dU Suppose that 1 and 2 are positive temperature.
    [Show full text]
  • The Physics of Negative Absolute Temperatures
    The Physics of Negative Absolute Temperatures Eitan Abraham∗ Institute of Biological Chemistry, Biophysics, and Bioengineering, School of Engineering and Physical Sciences, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh EH14 4AS, UK Oliver Penrosey Department of Mathematics and the Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Colin Maclaurin Building, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh EH14 4AS, UK (Dated: November 25, 2016) Negative absolute temperatures were introduced into experimental physics by Purcell and Pound, who successfully applied this concept to nuclear spins; nevertheless the concept has proved con- troversial : a recent article aroused considerable interest by its claim, based on a classical entropy formula (the `volume entropy') due to Gibbs, that negative temperatures violated basic princi- ples of statistical thermodynamics. Here we give a thermodynamic analysis which confirms the negative-temperature interpretation of the Purcell-Pound experiments. We also examine the princi- pal arguments that have been advanced against the negative temperature concept; we find that these arguments are not logically compelling and moreover that the underlying `volume' entropy formula leads to predictions inconsistent with existing experimental results on nuclear spins. We conclude that, despite the counter-arguments, negative absolute temperatures make good theoretical sense and did occur in the experiments designed to produce them. PACS numbers: 05.70.-a, 05.30.d Keywords: Negative absolute temperatures, nuclear spin systems, entropy definitions I. INTRODUCTION amine, in section IV, the statistical mechanics argument which has been held to rule out negative temperatures; The concept of negative absolute temperature, first we find that this argument is not logically compelling mooted by Onsager[1, 2] in the context of two- and moreover (subsection IV D) that it leads to predic- dimensional turbulence, fits consistently into the descrip- tions inconsistent with known experimental results.
    [Show full text]
  • Population Inversion, Negative Temperature, and Quantum
    Population Inversion, Negative Temperature, and Quantum Degeneracies Zotin K.-H. Chu WIPM, 30, West Xiao-Hong Shan, Wuhan 430071, PR China Abstract We revisit the basic principle for lasing : Population inversion which is nevertheless closely linked to the negative temperature state in non-equilibrium thermodynamics. With the introduction of quantum degeneracies, we also illustrate their relationship with the lasing via the tuning of population inversion. Introduction Atomic and molecular physics arc certainly the oldest subfields of quantum physics and ev- erybody knows the major role that they played in the early 1920s when the first principles of quantum mechanics were elaborated. After this golden era, many physicists considered research in these subfields essentially complete and in fact, for several decades, activity in atomic and molecular physics decreased steadily in comparison with the large effort directed towards nu- clear and high-energy physics. The advent of lasers (LASER means : Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation), and more precisely of tunable lasers, changed this situation and since the early 1970s, atomic and molecular physics, gradually intermingling with laser physics, has become an area where more and more activity is contributing substantially to the understanding of many phenomena. There has been a gradual change in the use of lasers in the teaching as well as research labora- tory. Increasingly, the laser is not being used for spectroscopy, but as a tool [1]. However, the art of making a laser operate is to work out how to get population inversion for the relevant arXiv:0902.0421v2 [physics.gen-ph] 9 Apr 2009 transition.
    [Show full text]