Paul Murray, M.S., P.E. Principal Consultant

PROFILE Paul Murray is a Principal Consultant with over 10 years of forensic-related OFFICE 4044 Clipper Court experience in projects and cases involving evaluation of earthquake damage to Fremont, CA 94538 structures (residential, commercial, industrial, etc.) and infrastructure. Responsibilities for these scopes of work include visual investigation, CONTACT damage assessment, determination of cause and origin of damage, drone Office: +1 888 782 3473 Direct: +1 628 242 0149 operation, development of remediation and retrofit options, and report writing, in Cell: +1 415 265 9649 addition to peer review of engineering reports. Mr. Murray has also served as Fax: +1 866 914 7561 part of catastrophe response teams for tornado, hurricane, and earthquake [email protected] events. Key strengths include the following: CORPORATE OFFICE 5565 Glenridge Connector Suite 900 ► Seismic Assessment and ► Catastrophe Atlanta, GA 30342 Rehabilitation Response ► Retaining Walls ► Appraisals

► Foundations ► Wind and Hail Damage Assessment WEBSITE ► Wood Structures ► Fire Damage Assessment www.envistaforensics.com

► Concrete Structures ► Hurricane and Storm Surge Damage ► Masonry Structures Assessment

► Steel Structures ► Tornado Damage Assessment ► Commercial and ► Swimming Pools Residential Roofing ► Site Grading and Drainage ► Building Envelopes and ► Water Intrusion Windows ► Cost Estimates

► Construction Defects

► Industries: Forensics, commercial, industrial and residential structures, and infrastructure

► CAD/Design Packages: RISA 3D, E-Tabs, Enercalc, and AutoCAD

EDUCATION Master of Science, Civil Engineering, 2007 (Emphasis in Structural Engineering) University of California – Davis, California

Bachelor of Science, Architectural Engineering, 2005 California Polytechnic State University – San Luis Obispo, California

Rev 2020-08-25 PT&C Forensic Consulting Services, P.A. Page | 1 Paul Murray, M.S., P.E. Principal Consultant

LICENSES Professional Engineer (PE):

► ► ► California ► ► Colorado ► Oklahoma ► Florida ► Oregon ► Idaho ► ► ► Utah ► Montana ► Washington

CERTIFICATIONS Remote Pilot In Command (RPIC), UAS/Drone Inspections and Photography – Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)

PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS ► American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)

► Structural Engineers Association of California (SEAOC)

PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND May 2020 – Present: Envista Forensics – San Francisco, California Principal Consultant

May 2010 – May 2020: Envista Forensics – San Francisco, California Technical Field Supervisor / Senior Project Engineer

July 2007 – May 2010: DCI Engineers – San Diego, California Structural Project Engineer

October 2006 – June 2007: Opus West Construction Corporation – Sacramento, California Project Intern

December 2005 – September 2006: Curry Price Court – San Diego, California Project Engineer

Summer 2004 & 2005: Curry Price Court – San Diego, California Intern

Rev 2020-08-25 PT&C Forensic Consulting Services, P.A. Page | 2 Paul Murray, M.S., P.E. Principal Consultant

REPRESENTATIVE PROJECT EXPERIENCE

Salesforce / Transbay Terminal Structural Evaluation San Francisco, California ► Evaluation of failed built-up, structural steel girders in a brand-new transportation terminal in downtown San Francisco. Gestamp Windfarm Structural Evaluation

Gestamp Windfarm Structural Evaluation Punta Lima, Puerto Rico ► Evaluation of structural damage sustained to 12 wind turbines (including the foundations and built-up steel towers) during Hurricane Maria. Red Mountain Group, Roof Collapse Evaluation

Red Mountain Group, Roof Collapse Evaluation Dublin, California ► Evaluation of structural damage sustained to the roof framing system of a Joanne's craft store, including determination of cause, extent of damage and repair recommendations.

Highrise Condominium Evaluations - Hurricane Michael Panama City Beach, Florida ► Evaluation of damage to various high-rise condominium buildings from Hurricane Michael including structural damage, interior moisture intrusion, and exterior roofing and cladding damage (utilization of drone for exterior inspection).

Napa / American Canyon Earthquake Napa, California and surrounding areas

► Evaluation of commercial, residential, healthcare and medical office structures for damage sustained from a magnitude 6.0 earthquake in American Canyon, California (Napa area).

La Habra California Earthquake Fullerton, California

► Evaluation of residential structures for damage sustained from a magnitude 5.1 earthquake in La Habra, California (Los Angeles area).

Oklahoma City Earthquake – Earthquake Damage Evaluation Oklahoma City and surrounding areas, Oklahoma

► Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for earthquake-related damage to numerous residential structures.

2020-08-25 PT&C Forensic Consulting Services, P.A. Page | 3

Apple, Inc. (Apple Campus 2) Cupertino, California

► Evaluation of remedial work and water mitigation efforts by the general contractor and associated subcontractors ($4 million claim) following storm-related damage sustained to the construction site of the new Apple campus.

Centreville Homes versus Watt Communities – Construction Defect Evaluation Rohnert Park, California

► Responsible for evaluation of a multi-family residential complex for construction defects.

Silverstone Enterprises – Construction Defect Evaluation Great Falls, Montana

► Evaluation of a large, single-family residential structure for alleged construction defects.

Century Hill Association – Concrete Podium Collapse Century Hill, California (Los Angeles area)

► Evaluation of a collapse reinforced concrete podium slab, as part of a multiple story residential complex over a single story subterranean parking structure.

Loughborough HOA – Foundation Damage Evaluation Merced, California

► Responsible for the evaluation of foundation damage to a physical therapy / chiropractic center building.

The Siegel Group Nevada, Inc. – Partial Roof Collapse Evaluation Las Vegas, Nevada

► Responsible for the evaluation of a partial roof collapse of a single story casino building.

Kimberling Inn, Inc. – Tornado Damage Evaluation Kimberling, Missouri

► Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for tornado damage to multiple buildings (between one and three stories) in a hotel complex.

Hurricane Irene (2011-2012) and Hurricane Sandy (2012-2013) – Hurricane Damage Evaluation Numerous states on the East Coast

► Catastrophe Duty – Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for hurricane damage to numerous structures, both residential and commercial, across multiple states (New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Virginia, Washington D.C., etc.).

Moore, Oklahoma Tornado Outbreak – Tornado Damage Evaluation Moore, Oklahoma and surrounding areas

► Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for tornado damage to residential and commercial structures.

Rev 2020-08-25 PT&C Forensic Consulting Services, P.A. Page | 4

Spring 2011 Tornado Outbreak – Tornado Damage Evaluation and

► Catastrophe Duty – Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for tornado damage to numerous structures, both residential and commercial, across multiple states (Alabama and Mississippi).

Mainstreet Diner – Fire Damage Evaluation Alturas, California

► Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for fire damage to a diner building.

Dines Properties – Hail Damage Evaluation Dallas, Texas

► Responsible for the evaluation and repair recommendations for hail damage to the roof systems and exterior finish systems of numerous commercial buildings.

Rev 2020-08-25 PT&C Forensic Consulting Services, P.A. Page | 5