Download Document
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AN UNTIMELY HISTORY OF ARCHITECTURE AND REAL ESTATE HOUSE IN NINETEEN EPISODES UNA STORIA INATTUALE DELL’ARCHITETTURA E DEI BENI IMMOBILIARI HOUSING IN DICIANNOVE EPISODI 2012 1975 1939 VIOLENCE ENTERS A CO-OPERATORS FHA DENIES INSURED GATED COMMUNITY WITHHOLD MORTGAGE FOR EAST CARRYING CHARGES LANSING USONIA 2010 FOR NINE MONTHS THE NEW AMERICAN 1937 HOME® FAILS 1970 ARCHITECT FINDS OIL MAGNATE’S SIMILARITIES 2009 HOUSTON NEW TOWN BETWEEN RUSSIANS BRAZILIAN TO SHAPE GROWTH AND AMERICANS GOVERNMENT THROUGH SCIENCE LAUNCHES MINHA 1933 CASA, MINHA VIDA 1962 PRESIDENT CHICAGO HOUSING PROMOTES SAVING 2000 AUTHORITY OPENS AS CIVIC DWELL MAGAZINE 1,096-UNIT WILLIAM RESPONSIBILITY CLAIMS A NEW GREEN HOMES FRONTIER 1932 1952 ARCHITECT PRESENTS 1994 HOUSE & HOME BROADACRE FEDERAL HOUSING SPLITS FROM CITY AS SOLUTION POLICY MEETS ARCHITECTURAL TO THE NATION’S LOCAL RESISTANCE FORUM HOUSING PROBLEM 1986 1949 1918 FEDERAL LOW- LIFE MAGAZINE UNITED STATES HOUS- INCOME HOUSING TAX HOLDS ROUNDTABLE ING CORPORATION CREDIT APPROVED ON HOW TO PRODUCE BUILDS HOUSING FOR CHEAPER HOUSING WARTIME WORKERS 1978 ARCHITECT 1944 1910 DISASSEMBLES THE CALIFORNIA ARTS FRANK LLOYD SUBURBAN HOME AND ARCHITECTURE WRIGHT SELLS HIS ENVISIONS THE VISION FOR SUBUR- POST-WAR HOUSE BANIZING AMERICA The Temple Hoyne Buell Center for the Study of American Architecture House Housing HOUSE HOUSING: AN UNTIMELY HISTORY OF ARCHITECTURE AND REAL ESTATE IN NINETEEN EPISODES Reinhold Martin House Housing is an exhibition installed by the Temple Hoyne Buell Center for the Study of American Architecture in the third-floor apart- ment of Columbia University’s Casa Muraro in June 2014, to coincide with the opening of the 14th International Architecture Exhibition in Venice. Assembled by a team of researchers at Columbia and staged as an open house, it represents the beginning of a long-term project that centers on the critical analysis of architecture’s engagement with real estate development, particularly in the design of housing. The exhibi- tion responds unsolicited to Biennale curator Rem Koolhaas’s theme of “Fundamentals,” which includes what Koolhaas calls the “fundamen- tals of our buildings, used by any architect, anywhere, anytime.”1 House Housing replies with a multimedia sample of economic fun- damentals that show modernity’s basic facts under construction — by governments, industries, institutions, and cultures — beginning in the early twentieth century. Its nineteen brief, historical episodes, running from 1910 to 2014, locate housing at the center of the current economic regime, with the United States as an influential node in a transnation- al network. In architecture, economic fundamentals begin from the ground up. The laws of real estate, relating to the acquisition of land, the financing of construction, the cost of building maintenance and ser- vices, profit from rent or resale, the value of equity, or the price of credit, inexorably constrain any building component (like a window) or any building type (like a house). They are visible even in the residential work of such singular figures as Frank Lloyd Wright, not least because the Greek oikos, or household, forms the root of the word “economy” itself. But look closely and you will see that what seems fundamental, basic, or natural is, like any other law, a historical artifact subject to change. House Housing narrates its episodes in a mixture of domestic media that range across the century, from phonograph to television, answering machine to iPad, thereby converting the apartment into a whispering, humming history machine. Though they mainly focus on the continen- tal United States, the discrete episodes are excerpts from transnational processes. As such, they address matters of universal concern, even in non-market situations. Their objects range from houses designed by fig- ures as well-known as Wright, to a seemingly ordinary gated community in Florida. Their untimeliness is twofold. First, these episodes return us to financial matters widely discussed in the immediate aftermath of the 2008 foreclosure crisis but now largely abandoned, by mainstream discourse, in favor of greener pastures. Second, the historical episodes, which are assembled non-chronologically, disclose surprising repeti- tions — of themes, tendencies, and actions. This reminds us that the eco- nomic infrastructures on which architecture rests are the outcome of such repetitions, rather than an a priori, natural ground. House Housing is about those infrastructures, where “infrastruc- ture” is defined as that which repeats. Every time we turn on the faucet, the water system repeats. Every time a house is bought or sold, the real estate system repeats. But every transaction also reconfirms and rebuilds che ciò che ci viene proposto come fondamentale, basilare, o naturale, è, that system, which in turn builds houses, which, in turn, cannot be come qualsiasi altra legge, un artefatto storico soggetto a cambiamento. built without architectural techniques that shape them, and stories that House Housing narra i suoi episodi per mezzo di un misto di media establish their value. In this way, the laws of real estate and the laws of domestici che si estendono lungo tutto il secolo, dalla radio alla tele- architecture are constituted and reconstituted together, as effortlessly as visione al computer, in modo da convertire l’appartamento in un flowing water. sussurro, una mormorante macchina della storia. Sebbene si concentri- House Housing sets out to show how such laws are written, as sto- no soprattutto sul territorio continentale degli Stati Uniti, questi episodi ries that form dominant cultural imaginaries. The “American Dream,” incrociano processi transnazionali. Come tali affrontano questioni d’in- closely connected to American economic power and to global housing teresse universale, perfino in situazioni estranee al mercato. Gli oggetti markets, is one such story. Others running silently in the background of di studio vanno da case progettate da figure conosciute come Wright a the exhibition include the European doctrine that transnational debt be comunità residenziali chiuse, apparentemente ordinarie, in Florida. La met with national austerity, and the ambiguous slogan “capitalism with loro inattualità è duplice. In primo luogo, tali episodi ci rimandano ai Chinese characteristics.” All of these stories and many like them repeat problemi finanziari largamente discussi nell’immediato indomani della through the channels of the house and of its equally troubled companion, crisi di pignoramenti del 2008, oggi in parte abbandonati dal discorso housing. They do so discreetly, in focus groups, home décor, congres- dominante che crede in pascoli più verdi. In secondo luogo, gli episodi sional hearings, press commentary, garages, fireside chats, residence storici, che vengono qui assemblati in modo non cronologico, rivelano permits, zoning laws, and investment portfolios. Each repetition recon- sorprendenti ripetizioni—di temi, tendenze e azioni—che ci ricordano stitutes the law of the household — the nomos of “economy” — while also di come le infrastrutture economiche sulle quali si basa l’architettu- suggesting the possibility that next time, things could be different. ra sono l’esito di tali ripetizioni e non un loro terreno naturale, dato a 1. Rem Koolhaas, “Fundamentals,” La Biennale di Venezia, accessed April 15, 2014, http://www.labiennale.org/en/ priori. architecture/exhibition/koolhaas House Housing è una mostra su queste infrastrutture, ove “infra- struttura” è definita come ciò che ripete. Ogni volta che apriamo il House Housing è il titolo della mostra allestita dal Temple Hoyne Buell rubinetto, il sistema idraulico si ripete. Ogni volta che una casa viene2 Center for the Study of American Architecture al secondo piano di Casa acquistata o venduta, il sistema immobiliare si ripete. Ogni transazi- Muraro, nei locali di proprietà della Columbia University, durante il one riconferma e ricostruisce questo sistema. Sistema che porta a mese di giugno 2014, e che coinciderà con l’apertura della Quattordi- costruire più case, che, a loro volta, non possono essere costruite senza cesima Mostra Internazionale di Architettura di Venezia. Realizza- tecniche architettoniche che ne determinano la forma, e narrative che ta da un gruppo di ricercatori della Columbia, la mostra è allestita in ne stabiliscono il valore. In tal modo, le leggi del mercato immobiliare e forma di open house e presenta gli inizi di un progetto di lunga durata dell’architettura si costituiscono e ricostituiscono assieme, con la fluidi- incentrato sull’analisi critica del coinvolgimento dell’architettura con tà dell’acqua che scorre. il mercato immobiliare, in special modo nel campo della progettazione House Housing intende mostrare come tali leggi siano scritte residenziale. La mostra è una risposta—seppur non sollecitata—al tema come storie che formano immaginari culturali dominanti. L’“American “Fundamentals,” proposto dal curatore della Biennale, Rem Koolhaas, Dream”, intimamente connesso con la potenza economica americana e che definisce “gli elementi fondamentali dell’architettura impiegati da i mercati immobiliari globali, è una di queste storie. Altre che scorrono ogni architetto, ovunque e in qualsiasi momento.”1 silenziosamente sullo sfondo della mostra includono la dottrina europea House Housing risponde a tale tema con una campionatura mul- secondo la quale il debito transnazionale debba essere affrontato con le timediale di “fondamentali” economici che mostrano