ARTICLE
Received 18 May 2016 | Accepted 28 Sep 2016 | Published 17 Nov 2016 DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 OPEN A natural light-driven inward proton pump
Keiichi Inoue1,2,3, Shota Ito1, Yoshitaka Kato1, Yurika Nomura1, Mikihiro Shibata4,5, Takayuki Uchihashi4,5, Satoshi P. Tsunoda1 & Hideki Kandori1,2
Light-driven outward H þ pumps are widely distributed in nature, converting sunlight energy into proton motive force. Here we report the characterization of an oppositely directed H þ pump with a similar architecture to outward pumps. A deep-ocean marine bacterium, Par- vularcula oceani, contains three rhodopsins, one of which functions as a light-driven inward H þ pump when expressed in Escherichia coli and mouse neural cells. Detailed mechanistic analyses of the purified proteins reveal that small differences in the interactions established at the active centre determine the direction of primary H þ transfer. Outward H þ pumps establish strong electrostatic interactions between the primary H þ donor and the extra- cellular acceptor. In the inward H þ pump these electrostatic interactions are weaker, inducing a more relaxed chromophore structure that leads to the long-distance transfer of H þ to the cytoplasmic side. These results demonstrate an elaborate molecular design to control the direction of H þ transfers in proteins.
1 Department of Life Science and Applied Chemistry, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Showa-ku, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan. 2 OptoBioTechnology Research Center, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Showa-ku, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan. 3 PRESTO, Japan Science and Technology Agency, 4-1-8 Honcho, Kawaguchi, Saitama 332-0012, Japan. 4 Department of Physics, Kanazawa University, Kanazawa 920-1192, Japan. 5 Bio-AFM Frontier Research Center, Kanazawa University, Kanazawa 920-1192, Japan. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to H.K. (email: [email protected]).
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13415 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 1 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415
icroorganisms utilize ion-transporting rhodopsins such Results as light-driven pumps and light-gated channels for PoXeR is a light-driven inward H þ pump. P. oceani is an Melectrochemical membrane potential generation and a-proteobacterium found at a depth of 800 m in the south-eastern signal transduction, respectively1. These rhodopsins are also Pacific ocean. Analysis of the genome of P. oceani showed important tools for optogenetics, which control neural activity by the existence of three microbial rhodopsins13. Two rhodopsins light2. While light-driven outward H þ and inward Cl pumps contain the NDQ and NTQ motifs, suggesting light-driven were discovered in the last century3–5, more recent metagenomic outward Na þ (PoNaR) and inward Cl (PoClR) transport, analyses led to the discovery of an outward Na þ pump6, and respectively (Fig. 2). The remaining rhodopsin possesses the DTL cation7,8 and anion channels9. Figure 1 summarizes the motif (Fig. 2a) and has amino-acid sequence 51% identical to that functions of ion-transporting rhodopsins in which transport is of ASR14, a photochromic light sensor (Supplementary Fig. 1). uni-directional for pumps and bi-directional for channels1. Nevertheless, unlike ASR, this rhodopsin does not contain a long The direction of transport for known retinal-binding ion Arg-rich C-terminus (Supplementary Fig. 1), and can be classified pumps is exclusively outward for cations and inward for as a xenorhodopsin (XeR), whose function is unknown15 anions, increasing membrane potential. The presence of inward (Supplementary Fig. 1). Thus, unlike many microbes that cation and outward anion pumps is highly unlikely in nature, as it normally contain an H þ pump, P. oceani does not seem to is energetically unfavourable. have one. Instead, it has an Na þ pump (PoNaR), a Cl pump Previously, we engineered inward H þ transport by mutating (PoClR) and rhodopsin of an unidentified function (PoXeR). Anabaena sensory rhodopsin (ASR)10, a photochromic light We tested the ion-transporting functions of these rhodopsins sensor. Wild-type ASR does not transport ions, but an ASR using heterologous expression of C-terminally his-tagged proteins mutant (D217E) exhibited light-induced inward H þ transport in E. coli. The membranes of PoNaR-expressing bacteria were when expressed in Escherichia coli cells. D217 is located in yellow (Fig. 3a), suggesting low expression or improper folding of the cytoplasmic region of ASR, and light-induced difference the protein. In contrast, PoClR and PoXeR formed red/purple Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy clearly pigment (Fig. 3a). Next, we examined their ion-pumping showed an increased proton affinity for E217, which activities. For PoClR-expressing cells, we observed a light-induced presumably controls the unusual directionality opposite to increase in pH, which was accelerated by carbonylcyanide-m- that in normal proton pumps. However, in that paper, chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) (Fig. 3a). This pH increase was þ we could not determine if the mutant functioned as an H similar in NaCl and CsCl, but was abolished when Na2SO4 was pump or channel as the inside of the cell was negatively charged. used. Strong anion dependence is fully consistent with the inward On a related note, conversions of light-driven outward H þ Cl pump function of PoClR. For PoXeR-expressing cells, we pumps into an H þ channel by mutation were reported also observed a light-induced pH increase in all salts, but the recently11,12. signals disappeared in the presence of CCCP (Fig. 3a). This Here we report that a microbial rhodopsin from a deep-ocean suggests inward H þ transport driven by light for PoXeR. Even marine bacterium, Parvularcula oceani, functions as inward H þ though ASR does not transport ions14, we engineered inward H þ pump when expressed in E. coli and mouse neural cells. transport of an ASR mutant (D217E) by light10. However, it was Mechanistic analyses of purified proteins reveal that the retinal not clear D217E ASR is an inward H þ pump or channel, because chromophore structure and primary photoisomerization the inside of the cell is negatively charged. To verify the active (C13 ¼ C14 trans to cis) are identical between outward and inward nature of inward proton transport, voltage and current across the H þ pumps. Nevertheless, the direction of primary H þ transfer membrane should be controlled. For this purpose, we expressed differs because of different electrostatic interactions of the PoXeR in mouse ND7/23 cells and performed protonated Schiff base with its counterion. We discuss these electrophysiological measurements. The data in Fig. 3b display findings in terms of the molecular mechanisms of light-driven an inward current for all measured membrane voltages (from inward and outward H þ pumps. 55 mV to 45 mV). More importantly, the obtained I–V curve was identical for different extracellular pH values (7.2 and 9.0), typical for light-driven H þ pumps. Thus, despite the lack of measurements in native cells, the results in E. coli and ND7/23 cells strongly suggest that PoXeR is a natural light-driven Cytoplasmic side inward H þ pump. + + – X+, Y– H , Na Cl – þ – – – – Molecular properties of PoXeR. The unusual inward H pumping activity of PoXeR poses questions about its physiolo- gical role and molecular mechanism. The former is difficult to address as the culture of native cells is not available. As for the þ + + + latter, we studied the molecular mechanism of the inward H N N N H H H pumping by various spectroscopic methods using PoXeR expressed in E. coli. Figure 4a shows the absorption spectrum of PoXeR (lmax ¼ 567 + + + ++ + nm) in the dark and after illumination, and a high-speed atomic force microscopy (AFM) image (Fig. 4b) shows that PoXeR forms Light-driven Light-driven Light-gated + + a trimer in the nanodisk membrane. ASR contains predominantly H or Na pump Cl– pump channel all-trans chromophore in the dark but the 13-cis, 15-syn Extracellular side chromophore is formed after light-adaptation16,17. This is also the case for PoXeR, which is 92% all-trans in the dark while Figure 1 | Ion-transporting microbial rhodopsins. Light-driven outward all-trans and 13-cis forms are equally distributed after the cation pumps (left) and inward anion pumps (middle) function as active illumination (Fig. 4c). Calculated absorption spectra of all-trans transporters, while light-gated channels conduct cations or anions in a and 13-cis forms exhibit lmax at 568 and 549 nm, respectively, passive manner (right). similar to those observed for ASR18.
2 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13415 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 ARTICLE a protein, and replaced it after each single excitation measurement. Figure 5a shows the time-resolved difference spectra (left), Residue number of BR 8285 89 96 115 194 204 212 216 223 absorption changes at each wavelength (centre) and decay- Residue number of PoR3 7174 78 85 108 187 197 205 209 216 associated spectra (right). Upon photoexcitation of the all-trans BR R D T DDEED K L form (PoXeRAT), the red-shifted K intermediate appears first, KR2 R N D Q GFR D K L and decays to the blue-shifted L intermediate in 2 ms. Then, the PoR1 (PoNaR) R N D Q GIR D K L M intermediate containing a deprotonated Schiff base appears with two distinct time-constants (210 ms and 6.0 ms). This FR R NTQ ALR D K L analysis shows the presence of two states for L and M, one of PoR2 (PoClR) R NTQ A F R D K L which is in equilibrium. The M-intermediate decays in 200 ms, PoR3 (PoXeR) R D T L D S S P K D but the transient absorption does not return to zero (Fig. 5a, ASR R D TS QSD P K D centre) at 41 s, indicating the presence of another long-lived intermediate state. The difference spectrum obtained by transient
b absorption spectroscopy (spectrum at 2 s in Fig. 5a, left) coincides VsPR BPR PR with that obtained by steady-state absorption measurements in GPR Fig. 4a (Fig. 5a, inset). Therefore, the last intermediate represents XR PR ESR metastable 13-cis state (PoXeR13C) that reverts into PoXeRAT in Nd PR Gl Sensor SRI 91 s (Fig. 5b). The photocycle of PoXeRAT is summarized XR TR KR1 ClR Hs in Fig. 5c: the inward H þ transport is made possible by (i) H þ Cs SRI GR Hv CIR SRI release from the Schiff base to the cytoplasmic region upon Sr M formation and (ii) H þ uptake from the extracellular region CbCIR SRII Hs upon M decay. FR NpSRII CIR XeR Sp ASR þ CIR Hc H pathway during the inward transport in PoXeR.As Po XeR þ þ CIR PoXeR light-driven outward H pumps contain internal H acceptors Nm 1 0.2 and donors , we examined candidates for such groups for the NaR NpHR þ Po NaR2 MR inward H pump. Membrane-embedded carboxylates are strong Tr Hw Sr KR2 AR2 Hs HR þ NaR1 GI AR3AR1 BR BR candidates for internal H acceptors and donors, as is the case Tr NaR HR NaR HR þ NaR Ia for D85 (acceptor) and D96 (donor) in an outward H pump BR NaR BR Nd (refs 19,20). Figure 6a shows putative location of eight intramembrane carboxylates possibly involved in the transport, Figure 2 | Amino-acid sequence alignment of important residues and which we replaced with neutral residues (D-to-N or E-to-Q). phylogenetic tree of microbial rhodopsins. (a) Important residues for the Among the mutants, only D74N showed the absence of colour. function of microbial rhodopsins. BR, KR2, FR and ASR are outward H þ þ As D74 acts as the counterion of the protonated Schiff base, pump, outward Na pump, inward Cl pump, and photochromic sensor, we attempted a more conservative replacement, D74E. The respectively. Dashed rectangles indicate the positions of NDQ and NTQ inward H þ pumping activity was measured for various mutants motifs and residues unique for XeR. (b) Phylogenetic tree of selected (Fig. 6b), and the initial slopes are plotted in Fig. 6c. microbial rhodopsins. The rhodopsins included in the phylogenetic tree: The results clearly show a significant reduction in the pumping bacteriorhodopsin from Halobacterium salinarum (BR), archaerhodopsin-1, -2 activity in E35D/Q, D74E, D108E/N and D216N. In contrast, and -3 from Halorubrum sodomense (AR1, AR2 and AR3), bacteriorhodopsin D216E showed about threefold higher inward H þ pumping and middle rhodopsin from Haloquadratum walsbyi (HwBR, MR), activity than wildtype (WT). It should be noted that the halorhodopsin from H. salinarum, Salinibacter ruber and Natronomonas corresponding mutant of ASR (D217E) shows inward H þ pharaonis(HsHR, SrHR, NpHR), PoXeR, xenorhodopsin from Haloplasma transport10. Previously, light-induced difference FTIR contractile (HcXeR), ASR, sensory rhodopsin II from N. pharaonis and H. spectroscopy of D217E ASR revealed protonation of E217 upon salinarum (NpSRII and HsSRII), sensory rhodopsin I from S. ruber, Haloarcula deprotonation of the Schiff base (M intermediate)10. Here we vallismortis and H. salinarum (SrSRI, HvSRI and HsSRI), proteorhodopsin from applied similar FTIR analysis to PoXeRAT (Supplementary Fig. 2). Krokinobacter eikastus, Gillisia limnaea, Nonlabens dokdonensis and Vibrio sp. The top panel of Fig. 6d shows a positive peak at 1,736 cm 1, AND4 (KR1, GlPR, NdPR, VsPR), blue-absorbing proteorhodopsin from which down-shifts to 1,726 cm 1 in D O in the M-minus- uncultured bacterium (BPR), green-absorbing proteorhodopsin from 2 PoXeRAT difference spectra. This is a characteristic signal of uncultured marine gamma proteobacterium (GPR), rhodopsin from protonated carboxylic acids, indicating that carboxylate is the H þ Exiguobacterium sibiricum (ESR), thermophilic rhodopsin from Thermus acceptor of the Schiff base. Similar positive peaks were observed thermophilus (TR), xanthorhodopsin from S. ruber (XR), rhodopsin from for D74E and D108N, but an entirely different spectral feature Gloeobacter violaceus PCC 7421 (GR), putative Cl pumping rhodopsin from was obtained for D216E. Sharp positive peaks of WT at 1,736 Citromicrobium sp. JLT1363, Citromicrobium bathyomarinum and Sphingopyxis 1 - and 1,726 cm in H2O and D2O were shifted to 1,719 and baekryungensis (CsClR, CbClR, SpClR), Cl pump from Fulvimarina pelagi and 1,708 cm 1 in D216E, respectively, and the remaining pair of Nonlabens marinus S1-08 (FR and NmClR), PoClR, PoNaR, two putative NaRs 1 peaks at 1740 ( )/1734 ( þ )cm in H2O (1,730 ( )/1,725 from Truepera radiovictrix (TrNaR1 and TrNaR2), putative NaR from Indibacter 1 ( þ )cm in D2O) originates from a different carboxylic acid. alkaliphilus (IaNaR), NaR from N. dokdonensis, G. limnaea and K. eikastus This strongly suggests that D216 is the H þ acceptor during (NdNaR, GlNaR and KR2). the inward H þ transport in PoXeR. In agreement with that idea, the positive peak at 1,736 cm 1 was absent in D216N. In Photoreaction dynamics of a dark-adapted PoXeR. We next contrast, a positive peak was observed at 1,188 cm 1 in the C–C studied the photocycle of the dark-adapted PoXeR protein, which stretching region of retinal chromophore, indicating that the M presumably represents the inward H þ pumping process. intermediate did not form in D216N. There was no positive peak To avoid photoexcitation of the 13-cis form, we measured in the frequency region of protonated carboxylic acids and the single-wavelength kinetics of a 0.6 ml sample of dark-adapted 1,188 cm 1 band was present (no M formation) in E35Q/D as
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13415 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 3 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415
a PoNaR PoClR PoXeR
– CCCP Po ClR PoXeR + CCCP NaCl NaCl
CsCl CsCl pH (0.3 / div.) pH pH (0.3 / div.) pH Δ – CCCP Δ
Na2SO4 + CCCP Na2SO4
0 100 200 0 100 200 Time (s) Time (s)
pH 9.0 b o Theoretical shift of Vrev in ion channel 150 mV 570 nm light 0.0 mV pH 7.2 20 o 0 –0.5 164 mV –20 –40 pHo –60 –1.0 7.2
Current –1.5 9.0
5 pA Normalized current N=3 –2.0 0.1 s –50 0 50 100 150 Membrane voltage (mV)
Figure 3 | Light-driven H þ transport activity of PoXeR. (a) E. coli C43(DE3) strain cells in which the expression of PoNaR, PoClR and PoXeR was induced (upper), and ion-pumping activity was assayed by observing pH changes (lower). Light is on between 0 and 150 s. (b) Electrophysiological measurements of PoXeR-driven photocurrent in ND7/23 cells (left) and I–V plot of the current at pHo 7.2 and 9.0.
25 well. From homology modelling, E35 is likely to be located near adaptation in BR , suggesting that PoXeR13C contains the 13-cis, D216, and the E35 mutation may raise the pKa of D216, leading 15-syn configuration. to the lack of M formation. According to the structure of ASR, the distance between the Schiff base and D217 (D216 in PoXeR) is 14.7 Å (ref. 21), and such long-range H þ transfer should be Discussion mediated by other residues and/or water molecules in the inward In this paper, we report the discovery and characterization of a H þ pump. natural retinal-binding inward H þ pump (PoXeR). Mechanistic As for the identity of H þ donor to the Schiff base, the decay of analyses of the purified protein revealed that the retinal the M intermediate accompanies protonation of the Schiff base, chromophore structure and primary photoisomerization þ and if H is taken up from the aqueous phase, the decay of M (C13 ¼ C14 trans to cis) are identical between outward and inward should slow down at high pH (ref. 22). We thus measured the M H þ pumps. Nevertheless, direction of the primary H þ transfer in decay kinetics at different pH values. Figure 7a shows strong pH PoXeR is opposite to that in outward H þ pumps. The pathway of dependence of the M rise but limited pH dependence of the M the inward H þ transport in PoXeR is summarized in Fig. 8. The decay. In fact, the speed of M decay increased at pH 9.0. This fact primary H þ transfer occurs from the Schiff base to D216 on the indicates the presence of an internal H þ donor. If it is a cytoplasmic side. E35 modulates its pKa by forming hydrogen- carboxylic acid, we expect a negative band in the 1,760– bonding network with D216, similar to the one reported for ASR 1 26 þ 1,700 cm region in the PoXeR13C-minus-PoXeRAT difference (E36 and D217) .SecondaryH transfer occurs from an FTIR spectra. However, Fig. 7b shows a broad positive peak unidentified group to the Schiff base on the extracellular at 1,723 cm 1 in addition to a peak pair at 1,741 ( þ )/ side. This sequence of events in H þ transport is entirely 1,736 ( )cm 1. Absence of deprotonation signal in this region opposite to the one well-known for outward H þ pumps such questions the role of a carboxylic acid as the H þ donor. Other as BR1,27–33. residues such as arginine and protein-bound water molecules are We suggest the following mechanism for the distinct vectoriality possible candidates for the internal H þ donor23,24. The spectral between PoXeR and BR transport (Fig. 9). Photoexcitation first features at 1,336 ( þ )cm 1 and 1,198 ( )/1,183 ( þ )cm 1 converts the all-trans chromophore into a twisted 13-cis,15-anti (Fig. 7b and Supplementary Fig. 3) resemble those of the dark state in both, but its relaxation differs between BR and PoXeR.
4 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13415 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13415 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications atr frtnletatdfrom extracted retinal of pattern ieeouina pcfi aeegh cnr) ea-soitdsetaotie ygoa tigo h hne ntasetasrto (right absorption ( ( transient state. in nm. dark-adapted 585 changes and the at light-adapted of between fitting spectrum global difference by the obtained spectra shows Decay-associated (centre). wavelengths specific at time-evolution all- 100% of spectra calculated the represent lines AUECMUIAIN O:10.1038/ncomms13415 DOI: | COMMUNICATIONS NATURE AUECOMMUNICATIONS NATURE of dynamics Photoreaction | 5 Figure of properties Molecular | 4 Figure
Δ O.D. a –0.15 –0.10 –0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 c h htcceof photocycle The ) Δ O.D. 400 400 Wavelength (nm) 495 500 Δ b
O.D. 450
585nm 582 600 0 Wavelength (nm) 700 500 :31 O:1.08nom145|www.nature.com/naturecommunications | 10.1038/ncomms13415 DOI: | 7:13415 | a 2
550 Absobance Po t t t t t =2ms =660 =95 =9 =3 450 Po XeR. Po Time (min) e.Vle ftetm-osat fec rcs r h mean the are process each of time-constants the of Values XeR. μ μ 4 600 μ s s μ s XeR. s Po c XeR. 650 Absorbance t 6 t 500 t =16.6ms t =240ms ( =5.5ms =95ms t a =2s 6 bopinsetao ak n light-adapted and dark- of spectra Absorption ) = 91s 11- ( 700 a rnin ifrneasrto pcr fdark-adapted of spectra absorption difference Transient ) cis trans 8 Wevelength (nm) 560 549 -15- Δ O.D. 550 all- 567 n 0%13- 100% and 8 –0.10 –0.05 –0.15 10 syn 0.00 0.05 0.10 trans 568 9- -15- 600 cis 13- 10 10 -15- syn cis 100% all- –5 100% 13- L -15- cis Light-adapted syn 13- 1, 490 Dark-adapted c Retention time(min) 10 650 om.( forms. syn cis = 5.96 –4 12 Po -15- M trans = 203 XeR cis 400 10 Time (s) ± anti form b b –3 form 0.07 ms 11- h rcs fdr-dpainetmtdb h eoeyo absorption of recovery the by estimated dark-adaptation of process The ) 570 ihsedAMiaeof image AFM High-speed ) ± 700 L 1 ms cis 14 2, 540 10 M -15- 400 –2 L 2, 520 anti 10 9- Po Po cis Po –1 b 16 Po XeR XeR light -15- XeR dark 5 nm e prl n rnesldlns epciey.Dashed respectively). lines, solid orange and (purple XeR 10 anti 13C all- M 0 400 ± trans 18