A Report on the Bay Area Complex Litigation Superior Courts
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Report on the Bay Area Complex Litigation Superior Courts By Frank Burke, Chandra S. Russell, Stephanie D. Biehl, Adam R. Brausa, Adrian Canzoneri, Shana Inspektor, Kapri L. Saunders, and Ashley L. Shively Winter 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I: INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW .......................................................................................1 PART II: INTERVIEW SUMMARIES .................................................................................................11 San Francisco County Superior Court .................................................................................12 Interview of Hon. Mary E. Wiss ...................................................................................13 Interview of Hon. Curtis E.A. Karnow ..........................................................................19 San Mateo County Superior Court .....................................................................................25 Interview of Hon. Marie S. Weiner ..............................................................................26 Santa Clara County Superior Court ....................................................................................35 Interview of Hon. Brian C. Walsh ...............................................................................36 Interview of Hon. Thomas E. Kuhnle ...........................................................................42 Alameda County Superior Court ........................................................................................46 Interview of Hon. Winifred Smith .................................................................................47 Interview of Hon. George C. Hernandez ......................................................................54 Interview of Hon. Brad Seligman ................................................................................59 Contra Costa County Superior Court ..................................................................................65 Interview of Hon. Barry P. Goode ..............................................................................66 The Interview Team ............................................................................................................73 PART III: APPENDIX OF GUIDELINES & SAMPLE ORDERS .......................................................... A-1 San Francisco County Superior Court .............................................................................. A-2 Hon. Curtis E.A. Karnow ......................................................................................... A-3 Complex Litigation Users’ Manual .......................................................... A-4 Class Action Materials ............................................................................. A-9 Jury Trial Preparation ............................................................................ A-14 i Pre-Trial Filing Events – Bench Trial ...................................................... A-18 Hon. Mary E. Wiss ............................................................................................... A-20 Standard Discovery Order Issued at Initial CMC ................................... A-21 San Mateo County Superior Court ................................................................................ A-22 Hon. Marie S. Weiner ........................................................................................... A-23 Complex Civil Litigation Guidelines ....................................................... A-24 Case Management Order #1 and Order for Permissive E-Filing ........... A-27 Case Management Order #11 and Order Setting Jury Trial ................. A-33 Stipulation and Protective Order – Single Level of Confidentiality ...... A-39 Stipulation and Protective Order – Double Level of Confidentiality ... A-48 Santa Clara County Superior Court ............................................................................... A-57 Complex Civil Guidelines ...................................................................................... A-58 Hon. Brian C. Walsh ............................................................................................. A-82 Rules of Safe Passage ............................................................................ A-83 Jury Selection ........................................................................................ A-84 Alameda County Superior Court ................................................................................... A-85 Hon. Winifred Smith ............................................................................................. A-86 General Guidelines ................................................................................ A-87 Discovery Disputes ................................................................................ A-90 Procedural Guidelines for Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlements ........................................................................................... A-91 Procedural Guidelines for Final Approval of Class Action Settlements ........................................................................................... A-94 Recommended Court Contact Information Language to Include in Class Notices ......................................................................................... A-97 Guidelines for Sealed Documents ......................................................... A-99 ii Copies of Non-California Authorities .................................................. A-101 Hon. George C. Hernandez ................................................................................. A-102 General Guidelines for Litigating in Dept. 17...................................... A-103 Model Protective Order for Complex Cases ....................................... A-106 Hon. Brad Seligman ........................................................................................... A-112 Complex Litigation .............................................................................. A-113 Order Designating Case Complex Litigation ....................................... A-116 Order re Appointment of Provisional Designated Defense Counsel .. A-117 Preliminary Fact Sheet New Filing – Asbestos Litigation .................... A-127 Initial Case Management Order – Asbestos ....................................... A-130 Contra Costa County Superior Court ........................................................................... A-137 Hon. Barry P. Goode .......................................................................................... A-138 A Handy Guide to Department 17 ...................................................... A-139 Notice of Assignment for Case Management Determination ............ A-143 Order re Trial and Issue Conference ................................................... A-145 Issue Conference Checklist ................................................................. A-153 Electronic Case Filing Standing Order ................................................. A-158 iii PART I: INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW 1 This Part I provides an overview of our Introduction and interview findings. Part II contains the complete interview summaries for each Judge prepared by The Interview Team. Part Overview III contains supplemental materials, including guidelines and sample orders, In the summer and fall of 2017, we offered by the Judges. conducted one-on-one interviews of the nine Bay Area Complex Litigation Judges on Case Mix behalf of the Association of Business Trial Lawyers (ABTL). Our goal was to provide a The case mix information was either comparative perspective for practicing anecdotal or based on the individual lawyers about the respective Judges’ case Judges’ case management data, since none mix, standard pretrial and trial practices, of the Counties track this information in their likes and dislikes concerning lawyer their official statistics. conduct, and other as-yet-unpublished feedback for counsel. The interviewers All of the Judges reported that employment asked the Judges a common set of prepared and wage hour class action and PAGA questions on these topics. actions constitute either their largest category of actions or are among the top The Judges interviewed were Hon. Mary E. two types of actions in their court. They Wiss and Hon. Curtis E. A. Karnow of San constitute 48-50% of the actions in Santa Francisco County; Hon. Marie S. Weiner of Clara, 35% of the actions in San Mateo, 10- San Mateo County; Hon. Brian C. Walsh and 43% of the actions in the various Alameda Hon. Thomas E. Kuhnle of Santa Clara Departments, and one of the top two County; Hon. Winifred Smith, Hon. George categories in San Francisco and Contra C. Hernandez, and Hon. Brad Seligman of Costa. Alameda County; and Hon. Barry P. Goode of Contra Costa County. The next largest categories vary by County. Contra Costa has significant construction The authors of this report comprised The defect and mass tort cases, and Judge interview Team (further details are included Goode also handles CEQA cases. San at the end of Section II). Francisco has significant mass tort claims as well as many coordinated and consolidated After preparing our interview notes and this claims of various types. Another overview, we provided them to the Judges Department handles asbestos and CEQA for editing and comments. The Judges were claims. In San Mateo County, securities extremely generous with their time, both in actions are approximately 15% of the total the interviews and