Am73 524.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
American Mineralogist, Volume 73, pages524-533, 1988 High-pressure-high-temperaturemelting experimentson a SiOr-poor aphanitic kimberlite from the Wesseltonmine, Kimberley, South Africa Ar,.q.ND. Encan Department of Geology, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada M,q.roro Anrvrl Geological Institute, Yokohama National University, Yokohama 240, Iapan DrlNe K. Bl.r.owrN Department of Geology, Acadia University, Wolfville, Nova Scotia BOP 1X0, Canada Dlvro R. Bnr,r, Department of Geological and Planetary Sciences,California Institute of Technology,Pasadena, California 9 I 125, U.S.A SrvroN R. Snre, E. Mrcrrnrr, W. SxrNNnn Anglo American ResearchLaboratories, Johannesburg, South Africa Eow.qno C. Welxpn Department of Geology, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada Ansrn-lcr Phaserelations in a SiOr-poor aphanitic Group I kimberlite from the Wesseltonmine, 'C. South Africa, were determined at 10-40 kbar and 1000-1525 Experiments were done first with no additional HrO or COr, equivalent to the initial amounts in the rock of 6.20 wto/oHrO and 4.77 wto/oCOr, and secondwith sufficient CO, added to bring the total to 10.34 wto/oCOr. These amounts are equivalent to a mole fraction of CO, (X""r) of 0.24 and 0.52, respectively.Oxygen fugacities are difficult to predict but were likely less than the MW and greaterthan the IW buffer assemblages.All experimentsare suprasolidusand apparently vapor absent.In addition to liquid, runs at X.or:0.24 produced the following assemblageswith decreasingpressure from 40 to 10 kbar and temperaturesfrom 1400 to 1000 "C: olivine, olivine * spinel, olivine * spinel * clinopyroxene + calcite + perov- skite,and olivine * spinel + monticellite + calcite + perovskite.At Xcor:0.52, runs at 20-35 kbar produced olivine * spinel, olivine A clinopyroxene * spinel, and olivine + clinopyroxene + spinel + calcite. Above 35 kbar, the latter assemblageis replaced by olivine * clinopyroxene + dolomite. Comparison of the compositions of the minerals in the rock with those produced in the experiments indicates good agreement except for spinelsthat are highly oxidized in the experimental products relative to those in the rock. The run assemblagesare comparable with the minerals in the aphanitic kimberlite except for clinopyroxene,which is absentin the rock, and ilmenite, apalite,and phlogopite, which are presentin the rock but not in the experimental runs. Basedon the X.or:0.24 exper- iments, the inferred P-T path of ascent of the aphanitic kimberlite magma above about 40-km depth may have exceededthe temperature(1250-1300'C) at which clinopyroxene is stable for this composition. The antipathy of clinopyroxene and monticellite in the X.or:0.24 experiments may be used to explain the incompatibility of these minerals in kimberlite and suggeststhat monticellite need not be a product associatedwith crustal processes. The aphanitic Wesseltonkimberlite has lower SiO, and MgO and higher CaO than other Group I kimberlites and, when plotted on the CMS system,lies on the CaO-rich side of the olivine-clinopyroxene join whereasmore SiOr-rich Group I kimberlites fall close to this join. These compositional differencesmay account for the absenceof orthopyroxene in any of the experimental assemblagesand possibly for the fact that calcite is the only carbonatemineral below 35 kbar and occurs only at high Xco, conditions. Most Group I kimberlite compositions are representedby the model carbonatedlherzolite system (oliv- ine-clinopyroxene-orthopyroxene-dolomite)for which a pseudo-eutecticmelting relation- ship involving enstatite may occur. The absenceof orthopyroxene in the present experi- ments doesnot precludethe more SiOr-undersaturatedWesselton kimberlite magma from 0003-004x/88/0506-0524$02.00 524 EDGAR ET AL.: MELTING OF APHANITIC K]MBERLITE 525 being the product of crystal fractionation at mantle depths of a more SiOr-rich kimberlite magma derived by partial melting of a carbonatedlherzolite source.However, the absence of orthopyroxene in the experiments does indicate that the aphanitic kimberlite magma could have evolved from a source devoid of orthopyroxene and with calcite as the car- bonate phase.The present experiments suggestthat the aphanitic Wesseltonkimberlite is not an evolved speciesbut may representa primitive kimberlite magma. IxrnooucrroN berlite, olivine microphenocrystsoccur in a matrix con- il- Experimental studies under pressureand temperature sisting of variable amounts of calcite, monticellite, perovskite, rare conditions compatible with crystallization and differen- menite, spinel, apatite, serpentine,and phlogopite tiation of kimberlite magmasare valuable in understand- phlogopite. Olivine and xenocrystsand xeno- The ing the evolution of kimberlites (Mitchell, 1986).The only liths of country rock occur only in trace amounts. (Table available studiesusing actual kimberlites are those of Eg- aphanitic kimberlite used in this study 1; analyses gler and Wendlandt (1979) on a modified Lesotho kim- l, 2) has lower SiOr, MgO, and KrO and higher TiOr, berlite composition with 0-l I wto/oHrO and that of Ito AlrOr, and CaO than the mean value for macrocrystic I et al. (1968) on an anhydrous kimberlite from the Du- kimberlites from the same locality and from Group toitspan mine. Most experimentalwork pertinent to kim- kimberlites generally (Table l; analyses3, 4). This com- berlites has involved determination of the role of peri- position also differs considerablyfrom that usedby Eggler dotite, particularly lherzolite and harzburgite with and Wendlandt (1979) in their experiments. orthopyroxene as an essentialmineral, and/or the signif- ExpnnrmnNTAL coNDITToNS AND TECHNIQUES icance of CO, in their genesis,using simplified model periodotite systems (cf. Eggler and Wendlandt, 1979; Experimentswere done under two setsof COr/HrOratios. In Wyllie, 1979, 1980; Olafssonand Eggler,1983; Brey et the first setof experiments,between 10 and 40 kbar,no HrO or al., 1984;'Huang and Wyllie, 1984). Experiments on the CO, other than that in the rock itself was used.These experi- crystallization and evolution of kimberlite magmas are hampered wide by the variation in kimberlite composi- TneLe1. Compositionsof aphanitic,macrocrystic, and average tions and hencethe difficulty in identifying compositions Grouplkimberlites that may be reasonablyrepresentative of primitive kim- berlite magma. 1 2 (n:7) 3 (n: 17) 4 (n: 44\ This paper describessuprasolidus, apparently vapor- sio, 25.60 24.46(22.80-26.00)31.5s(28.90J4.50) 30.26 absent experimentsbetween l0 and 40 kbar on a Group Tio, 3.35 3.11(2.53J.48) 2.OO(1.73-2.32) 1.91 Alro3 3.31 3.58(3.00J.90) 2.57('t.704.45) 2.87 I aphanitic kimberlite from the Wesselton mine, Kim- FerOnn 10.30 9.74(9.06-10.20) 9.01(8.5&-9.46) 8.63 berley, South Africa. The scarcity of xenoliths and xeno- MnO 0.21 0.19(0.15-0.22) 0.15(0.12-0.19) 0.16 crysts, the fine-grained nature of this kimberlite, and its Mgo 27.20 25.94(2326-29.10)31.30(27.10-33.40) 29.62 CaO 15.30 15.07(12.70-16.7018.14(6.40-9.59) 10.13 low SiO, content relative to other kimberlites suggestthat Naro 0.28 0.26(0.10-0.80) 0.35(0.05-0.60) 0.39 the aphanitic kimberlite at Wesselton may represent a KrO 0.70 0.68(0.13-1.23) 1.29(O.4U2.321 1.31 primitive, DA 1.83 1.74(1.45-2.56) 1.00(0.4il1 .58) 1.48 closeto although not necessarilyprimary, kim- 4.77 6.92(3.45-10.86)4.26(1.45-5.97) 5.24 berlite magma composition. If this assumption is correct, Hro* 6.20 7.56(4.92-9.39) 7.71(3.96-10.09) 7.64 then the experiments can be used to determine possible Total 99.05 99.25 99.33 99.64 crystallization paths during ascentof the aphanitic Wes- Trace elements(ppm) F 2500 2225 1784 1917 selton kimberlite from depths correspondingto 40 kbar cr 800 to those correspondingto l0 kbar by comparing the poly- s-671 271 367 baric-polythermal mineral assemblagesobtained in the v-170 105 123 Cr 2410 2007 1291 1517 experimentswith those inferred from the petrography of Co 87 110 94 the rock. Such experimentsalso indicate potential genetic Ni 810 729 1233 1061 relationships between extremely SiOr-undersaturated Cu 105 60 oo Zn 111 88 86 aphanitic varieties of kimberlite, such as the one used in Rb 20 60 78 77 this study, and the more common, relatively SiOr-en- Sr 1180 1256 905 1186 Y1026 12 16 riched macrocrystickimberlites, such as the macrocrystic Zr 580 502 258 318 Wesseltonkimberlite. Nb 250 284 146 171 Ba 1000 1578 1198 1399 Nofe.'Columns are (1) aphanitickimberlite used in this study (after Shee, PBrnocnLpHy AND cHEMrsrRy oF GRoup I 1986, and by X-ray fluorescencetechniques by X-ray Assay Laboratories, KIMBERLITES,I.TWNSSTITON Don Mills, Ontario); (2) mean and ranges of 7 aphanitic kimberlitesfrom Wesselton (after Shee, 1986); (3) mean and ranges of 17 macrocrystic Shee(1984, 1986)described the geology,petrography, kimberlites from Wesselton (after Shee, 1986); (a) mean of 44 Group I classification, and chemistry of the hypabyssal facies kimberlitesfrom Wesselton,DeBeers, Benfontein, Dutoitspan (after Shee, Group I kimberlites at Wesselton.In the aphanitic kim- 1986). 526 EDGAR ET AL.: MELTING OFAPHANITIC KIMBERLITE ments representthe minimum HrO + CO2 prior to crystalliza- chargesat previous run conditions and reducing or increasing tion, and the results assumethat loss of these volatiles during the temperatureby 25'C. In all cases,these runs produced the ascentwas minimal and that neither HrO nor CO, was added sameassemblages as the runs done on the low- or high-temper- by secondaryprocesses. Probably someloss ofvolatiles occurred ature side ofthe liquidus (Table 2). during ascent,and the presenceof serpentinein the groundmass Products of the experimentsconsisted of combinations of ol- suggeststhat some of the volatiles may not be of magmatic or- ivine, spinel, monticellite, clinopyroxene, perovskite, calcite, and igin.