Commonwealth Journal.Max COMMONWEALTH: a Journal of Political Science
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COMMONWEALTH A Journal ofPolitical Science 1991 Volume 5 ISSN 0890-2410 Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max COMMONWEALTH: A Journal of Political Science EDITOR: Donald G. Tannenbaum (Gettysburg College) MANAGING EDITOR: James E. Skok (Penn State Harrisburg) EDITORIAL REVIEW BOARD Aryeh Botwinick Michael J. Malbin (Temple University) (State Univ. of New York at Albany) David Butler Harvey C. Mansfield, Jr. (Nuffield College/Oxford University (Harvard University) M. Margaret Conway Kenneth F. Mott (University of Florida) (Gettysburg College) Lester G. Crocker Craig N. Murphy ·... (University of Virginia, Emerit11~) (We11~ley (:011"8") R()ger H. Davidson Mark P. Petracca (University of Maryland) (University of California, Irvine) J~ail. B. Blshtain Elmer Plisehkc (University of Maryland, Emeritus) H. Mark Roelof (New York University) Bruce M. Russett (Yale University) Victoria Schuck (Stanford University) J. David Singer (University of Michigan) Alonzo T. Stephens, Sr. (Tennessee State Univ., Emeritus) Elliott White (Temple University) Aaron Wildavsky (University of Caliornia, Berkeley) Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max COMMONWEALTH: A JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE Contents Volume 5 1991 ISSN 0890-2410 Modernity, Nobility, Morality: Leo Strauss's View of Nietzsche Gordon J. Tolle. .. 1 Agenda Setting and the Asbestos Issue: The Media Role in Issue Definition Kathleen K. McQuaid ... .. 16 The Will of the Community: Theories of Representation at the Founding and in Recent Political Practice Gerald De Maio and Douglas Muzzio ................................... 32 Evolution of Participation in International Organizations Elmer Pliscbke ........................................ 57 PENNSYLVANIA RESEARCH Newspaper Coverage of the 1990 Pennsylvania Gubernatorial Campaign Erika G. King, Robert A. Wells and Elizabeth W. Wells ................................. 75 INDEX TO VOLUMES I TO 5 .................................. 89 GUIDELINES TO COMMONWEALTH STYLE ..................... 94 Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max ABOUT THE AUTHORS Gerald De Maio is an Associate Professor ofPolitical Science at Baruch College/ City University of New York. His major focus of interest is American political thought. He has published articles in the Canadian Review ofAmerican Studies, Polity, Social Science Quarterly, and the Western Political Quarterly, among others. Erika G. King is the Hillman Professor and Chair of the Department of Political Science at Chatham College. She has written articles on newspaper and newsmagazine coverage of politics and on crowd psychology in Journalism Quarterly, Journal ofAmerican Culture, and Journal ofthe History ofBehavioral Sciences. Douglas Muzzio is Professor at Baruch College/ City University ofNew York. His central interests are in urban politics and public policy. He has published in the American Political Science Review, Polity, Social Science Quarterly, Urban Affairs Quarterly, and the Journal of Urban Affairs, among others. Kathleen K. McQuaid is Assistant Professor of Politics and Economics at Mansfield University. Her areas of interest include political communication, political behavior, and policy analysis. Elmer Plischke is Professor ofPolitical Science Emeritus ofthe Univer sity of Maryland. In addition to over 100 articles and editorials, he is the author of 28 books and monographs, including Contemporary u.s. Foreign Policy, Diplomat in Chief' The President at the Summit, Conduct ofAmerican Diplomacy (three editions). Gordon Tolle has taught at South Dakota State University for decades, except for brief stints at the University of Colorado and Arizona State University. He has published Human Nature Under Fire: The political Philosophy ofHannah Arendt (1982) and has been the director ofhis school's European Studies Program. Elizabeth W. Wells received her B.A. with lIonors in Political Scicncc from Chatham College in 1990. Robert A. Wells is Instructor in Political Science at Chatham College. HE has written a book chapter on foreign policy attitudes and has published an article on Soviet Resource allocation in Journal of Conflict Resolution. Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max ACKNOWLEDGEMENT COMMONWEALTH is published annually under the authorization ofthe Pennsylvania Political Science Association and ~tjnt to all members, individual, departmental and institutional. Subscription rates for all categories of membership: see separate annonncements elsewhere in this issue. Changes of address sent to PPSA Secretary, Dr. Thomas Brogan, Albright College, Reading, PA 19603. Postmas ter: send notification about undelivered journals to this address. Second class postage paid at Harrisburg, PA and at additional mailing offices. Copywright 1990 by the Pennsylvania Political Science Association. (lSSN 0890-2410). COMMONWEALTH will print free of charge camera-ready official annonncements of up to one page of the American Political Science Association, as well as the Northea.<:tem Political Science Association and its constituent members, and other organizations whose Journals provide corresponding privi leges to PPSA. Contact the Managing Editor. Advertising and reprint information and rates are also available from the Managing Editor. Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max THE PENNSYLVANIA POLITICAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATION OFFICERS EXECUTIVE COUNCIL President 1988-1991 Michael Roskin Nicholas Berry (Lycoming College) (Ursinus College) First Vice President Joan Hulse Thompson Thomas Baldino (Beaver College) (Wilkes University) 1989-1992 Second Vice President Albert Dalmolen Zachary Irwin (Mansfield University) (penn State, Behrend College) Joseph Melusky (St. Francis College) Treasurer 1990-1993 Donald Buzinkai James M. Hoefler (King's College) (Dickinson College) Secretary Richard Martin Thomas Brogan (Slippery Rock University) (Albright College) Past President Donald G. Tannenbaum (Gettysburg College) Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max In the COMMONWEALTH Dunald G. TaummbaulIl, Editur In addition to the finest research offered to us in the last year, this issue of COMMONWEALTH has a special feature: the Index to Volumes I through 5 will be found following the articles. Covering the first five years of CoMMoN WEALTH, it indicates the range of quality manuscripts recommended by our reviewers. Examining the 26 we published, a breakdown by subfield reflects a pattern similar to one I noted in this space ~o years ago, in Volume 3. To date, the largest number of articles, 12, have been in American politics, including six on Pennsylvania government and politics, a special interest of a number of our readers. In second place were seven articles on political theory, followed by four in comparative politics, two which examined international relations, and one in biopolitics. We would have liked to have had more publishable manuscripts sent to us on these last three subjects, but for a variety of reasons, including the number of specialized journals in these areas, we were not. We continue to welcome all of the fine rn:lnlJscripts we can get, in all suhfields and areas. The Index is divided into three parts. An Author Index lists the authors and co-authors of all 26 articles in the five volumes alphabetically by last name, followed by the Iocation of each article. The Title Index lists all articles in order of appearance, beginning with those in Volume 1. Finally, a. Subfield1Area Index lists articles al))habetically by the five major cate!!;ories and one s))ecial interest category (pennsylvania Politics) noted above. I want to express my appreciation to my editorial assistant,Christopher T. Leonardo of Gettysburg College, for the special effort he made in compiling the Index. The five articles in this issue reflect, once again, a variety ofintellectually stimulating subjects. In Gordon Tolle's paper, Leo Strauss's rejection ofNietzsche is persuasively argued, and his position is effectively contrasted with SCholarship emphasizing the affinity of Strauss and Nietzsche. Tolle then indicates how an awareness of Strauss's rejection helps to clarify the concept of natural right and the differences between ancient and modern thought. The piece by Gerald De Maio and Douglas Muzzio demonstrates the contemporary relevance of the debates over representation which emerged at constitutional ratifying conventions early in American history. Such continuing relevance is shown by the authors as they link those early debates with political practices in American municipal government during three periods of recent history: at the turn of the century, in the 1960s-1980s, and in 1991. Two atticles in this issue speak to the role and influence ofvariau:) media outlets in both contributing to and limiting public awareness of important issues. Kathleen McQuaid's article, a case study ofthe growing perception of the dangers of asbestos in the United States, points to the role of the media in defining public Volume 5 - Commonwealth Journal.max policy issues for the public agenda and how media attention can wax and wane independent of how serious the problem actually is. A second paper on media influence, by Erika King and co-authors, is amodel for investigating press activity in the latest political campaign for governor of Pennsylvania. A content analysis of major Pennsylvania newspapers indicates the kinds ofissues the press deemed important and those the press chose to ignore or play down. The author~' finilings are related to the role of the press in gubernatorial campaigns, and the hypotheses they formulated may prove useful for studying campaigns