DOCSLIB.ORG

Selective Attention and Perceptual Load in Autism Spectrum Disorder

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Selective Attention and Perceptual Load in Autism Spectrum Disorder Selective Attention and Perceptual Load in Autism Spectrum Disorder Anna Remington University College London A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy September 2009 1 Declaration I, Anna Remington confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. A Remington 2 Abstract This thesis examines selective attention in young adults with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Existing literature regarding this issue is mixed; some research suggesting an overly-focused attentional style (Rincover & Ducharme, 1987) while others highlight an abnormally broad attentional lens (Burack, 1994). The research presented here has, for the first time, examined selective attention in individuals with ASD using a theoretically-led approach based on Lavie’s Load Theory of attention and cognitive control (Lavie et al., 2004). Load theory states that the perceptual load (amount of potentially task relevant information) of a task affects selective attention. This theory may explain the equivocal findings in the current data on selective attention and ASD. Using behavioural measures, the pattern of selective attention under various levels of load was explored in individuals with ASD and matched controls. The results provide evidence of increased perceptual capacity in ASD. This means that, at any one time, individuals with ASD may be able to process more information from the visual environment. This increase in capacity was evident on tasks of both unconscious and conscious perception. In light of the social deficits observed in the condition, the work in this thesis also explored selective attention in the presence of social distractor stimuli. Results indicated that faces are less salient for individuals with ASD and, unlike for typical adults, are not processed in an automatic and mandatory fashion. These results bring together findings on selective attention with work on social processing in an attempt to find basic abnormalities which might be fundamental in explaining the disorder. 3 For Guy 4 Contents Abstract ...................................................................................................................3 List of Tables ...........................................................................................................8 List of Figures .........................................................................................................9 List of Abbreviations ............................................................................................ 10 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................. 10 Chapter 1: Autism Spectrum Disorder ................................................................ 12 Social Impairment ........................................................................................... 12 Communication Deficit ................................................................................... 13 Repetitive and Rigid Behaviour ....................................................................... 13 Asperger Syndrome and Autism Spectrum Disorder ...................................... 14 Prevalence ......................................................................................................... 14 Biological Theories of ASD ............................................................................... 15 Neuroanatomical Abnormalities ...................................................................... 16 Biochemical Abnormalities ............................................................................. 19 Genetics of Autism .......................................................................................... 21 Psychological Approach .................................................................................... 22 Theory of Mind ............................................................................................... 23 Executive Dysfunction .................................................................................... 29 Weak Central Coherence ................................................................................. 33 Systemizing, Empathizing and the Extreme Male Brain .................................. 36 Summary ........................................................................................................... 37 Chapter 2: Selective Attention and Perceptual Load .......................................... 40 Selective Attention ............................................................................................ 41 Autism and Attention ........................................................................................ 49 Arousal ........................................................................................................... 50 Sustained Attention ......................................................................................... 51 Orienting, Disengaging and Attention Shifting ................................................ 52 Selectivity and Filtering .................................................................................. 54 Visual search ................................................................................................... 58 Chapter 3: Selective Attention and Perceptual Load in ASD ............................. 62 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 62 Participants and Diagnosis ............................................................................... 63 Ethical Considerations ..................................................................................... 65 Methodology ...................................................................................................... 65 Apparatus and Stimuli ..................................................................................... 65 Procedure ........................................................................................................ 67 Results ............................................................................................................... 68 Search Slopes .................................................................................................. 71 Accuracy data ................................................................................................. 72 Discussion .......................................................................................................... 73 Chapter 4: Perceptual Load and Conscious Perception in ASD ......................... 76 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 76 5 Participants ....................................................................................................... 79 Methodology ...................................................................................................... 80 Apparatus and Stimuli ..................................................................................... 80 Procedure ........................................................................................................ 82 Results ............................................................................................................... 84 Letter Search ................................................................................................... 84 Letter search error analysis .............................................................................. 85 CS Detection ................................................................................................... 86 Percentage Detection ....................................................................................... 87 False alarm rate ............................................................................................... 88 Detection sensitivity ........................................................................................ 89 Response Bias ................................................................................................. 91 Error Analysis ................................................................................................. 91 Control Block .................................................................................................. 92 Discussion .......................................................................................................... 92 Mixed trial paradigm. ....................................................................................... 94 Participants ....................................................................................................... 94 Methods ............................................................................................................. 95 Results ............................................................................................................... 95 Letter Search ................................................................................................... 95 CS Detection ................................................................................................... 97 Percentage Detection ....................................................................................... 97 False alarm rate ............................................................................................... 99 Detection sensitivity (d’) ................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Role of Perceptual Load in Visual Awareness
    BRAIN RESEARCH 1080 (2006) 91– 100 available at www.sciencedirect.com www.elsevier.com/locate/brainres Research Report The role of perceptual load in visual awareness Nilli Lavie⁎ Department of Psychology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT Article history: Does awareness depend on attention? This is a fundamental issue for understanding the Accepted 6 October 2005 relationship of attention and awareness, yet previous research provided mixed results. Available online 18 January 2006 Here, I describe new research that shows that the effects of attention on awareness depend on the level of perceptual load in the attended task. Awareness reports in both Keywords: the inattentional blindness and change blindness paradigms were found to depend on the Attention extent to which an attended primary task loads attention. Neuroimaging results revealed Awareness the involvement of frontoparietal attention network in awareness and transcranial Load magnetic stimulation experiments confirmed a causal role for frontoparietal activity in Change blindness awareness. These results clarify the role of attention and associated frontoparietal Inattentional blindness activity in visual awareness within the framework of load theory of attention. Distracter © 2005 Published by Elsevier B.V. Neuroimaging TMS 1. Introduction from the task-relevant processing spills over involuntarily, resulting in the perception of irrelevant stimuli (late selection). Would focusing attention on a current task prevent intrusions
    [Show full text]
  • Memory Specificity, but Not Perceptual Load, Affects Susceptibility to Misleading Information
    Memory specificity, but not perceptual load, affects susceptibility to misleading information Francesca R. Farina1,2,* & Ciara M. Greene1 1School of Psychology, University College Dublin, Ireland. 2Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland. Note: This paper has not yet been peer-reviewed. Please contact the authors before citing. Correspondence may be sent to Francesca Farina, Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland. Email: [email protected] 1 Abstract The purpose of this study was to examine the role of perceptual load in eyewitness memory accuracy and susceptibility to misinformation at immediate and delayed recall. Despite its relevance to real-world situations, previous research in this area is limited. A secondary aim was to establish whether trait-based memory specificity can protect against susceptibility to misinformation. Participants (n=264) viewed a 1-minute video depicting a crime and completed a memory questionnaire immediately afterwards and one week later. Memory specificity was measured via an online version of the Autobiographical Memory Test (AMT). We found a strong misinformation effect, but no effect of perceptual load on memory accuracy or suggestibility at either timepoint. Memory specificity was a significant predictor of accuracy for both neutrally phrased and leading questions, though the effect was weaker after a one-week delay. Results suggest that specific autobiographical memory, but not perceptual load, enhances eyewitness memory and protects against misinformation. Keywords Perceptual load; memory specificity; eyewitness; misinformation. 2 General Audience Summary The misinformation effect is a memory impairment for a past event that occurs when a person is presented with leading information. Leading information can distort the original details of a memory and produce false memories.
    [Show full text]
  • Neural Encoding of Attended Continuous Speech Under Different Types of Interference
    Neural Encoding of Attended Continuous Speech under Different Types of Interference Andrea Olguin, Tristan A. Bekinschtein, and Mirjana Bozic Abstract ■ We examined how attention modulates the neural encoding Critically, however, the type of the interfering stream significantly of continuous speech under different types of interference. In modulated this process, with the fully intelligible distractor an EEG experiment, participants attended to a narrative in English (English) causing the strongest encoding of both attended and while ignoring a competing stream in the other ear. Four different unattended streams and latest dissociation between them and types of interference were presented to the unattended ear: a nonintelligible distractors causing weaker encoding and early dis- different English narrative, a narrative in a language unknown to sociation between attended and unattended streams. The results the listener (Spanish), a well-matched nonlinguistic acoustic inter- were consistent over the time course of the spoken narrative. ference (Musical Rain), and no interference. Neural encoding of These findings suggest that attended and unattended information attended and unattended signals was assessed by calculating can be differentiated at different depths of processing analysis, cross-correlations between their respective envelopes and the with the locus of selective attention determined by the nature EEG recordings. Findings revealed more robust neural encoding of the competing stream. They provide strong support to flexible for the attended envelopes compared with the ignored ones. accounts of auditory selective attention. ■ INTRODUCTION “late selection” approaches. The early selection theory Directingattentiontoasinglespeakerinamultitalker (Broadbent, 1958) argued that, because of our limited environment is an everyday occurrence that we manage processing capacity, attended and unattended informa- with relative ease.
    [Show full text]
  • Applied History of Psychology/History of Research on Attention 1 Applied History of Psychology/History of Research on Attention
    Applied History of Psychology/History of Research on Attention 1 Applied History of Psychology/History of Research on Attention There has been a large increase in research activity in the area of attention since the 1950s. This research has focused not only on attention, but also how attention is related to memory and executive functioning. Human learning and behaviour are dependent on our ability to pay attention to our environment, retain and retrieve information, and use cognitive strategies. An understanding of the development of attention is also critical when we consider that deficits in attention often lead to difficulties in school and in the work force. Thus, attention is an important topic in the study of psychology, specifically in the areas of development (see Part II of this book), learning (Part III), and psychological disorders (see the section on ADHD in Part IV). There is no doubt that an understanding of attention and related concepts is critical to our understanding of human cognition and learning. Introduction to The History of Research on Attention The study of attention is a major part of contemporary cognitive psychology and cognitive neuroscience. Attention plays a critical role in essentially all aspects of perception, cognition, and action, influencing the choices we make. The study of attention has been of interest to the field of psychology since its earliest days. However, many ideas about attention can be traced to philosophers in the 18th and 19th centuries, preceding the foundation of the field of psychology. The topic of attention was originally discussed by philosophers. Among the issues considered were the role of attention on conscious awareness and thought, and whether attention was directed voluntarily or involuntarily toward objects or events.
    [Show full text]
  • HEARING LOSS and DEMENTIA: CONNECTING the DOTS the Participant Will Be Able To:  Identify Age-Related Sensorineural Hearing Loss Presented By: and Dementia
    2/15/2019 LEARNING OBJECTIVES HEARING LOSS AND DEMENTIA: CONNECTING THE DOTS The participant will be able to: Identify age-related sensorineural hearing loss Presented by: and dementia. Distinguish hallmark signs and causes of Dr. Diana Blakeney-Billings, CCC-A Assistant Professor – Alabama A&M University dementia. CSD Department Differentiate dementia from other neurologic diseases and syndromes. and Co-presenter: Mrs. Kaci W. McAfee, BS, SLP-A CHRONIC CO-MORBIDITIES OF HEARING LOSS Psychosocial Physiological Conditions Age-related hearing loss has contributed to faster Consequences declines in other disorders. Hypertension Cognitive Disorders Dementia/cognitive disorders Cardiovascular Disease (Dementia/Alzheimer’s Untreated hearing loss is an independent variable Arthritis Disease) Balance disorders Hypertension, diabetes, and ototoxic drugs Chronic kidney disease Communication Hearing loss can threaten health outcomes Stroke Disorders particularly older aged adults. Falls Depression Older adults with hearing loss develop brain Diabetes Infectious diseases shrinkage faster. Cancer Quality of Life AGE RELATED HEARING LOSS (ARHL) CAUSES OF ARHL Chronic health condition Most Common – inner ear changes from aging Presbycusis Central changes impact perceiving auditory verbal Gradual process and nonverbal stimuli Certain medications Bilateral high frequency sensorineural loss, Morphological alterations (stria vascularis) symmetrical Central Auditory Pathway Degeneration Peripheral and central pathology Genetics
    [Show full text]
  • Cortical and Sensory Causes of Individual Differences in Selective Attention Ability Among Listeners with Normal Hearing Thresholds
    JSLHR Review Article Cortical and Sensory Causes of Individual Differences in Selective Attention Ability Among Listeners With Normal Hearing Thresholds Barbara Shinn-Cunninghama Purpose: This review provides clinicians with an overview even in listeners with NHTs. Studies of variability in control of of recent findings relevant to understanding why listeners attention and in sensory coding fidelity may help to isolate with normal hearing thresholds (NHTs) sometimes suffer and identify some of the causes of communication disorders from communication difficulties in noisy settings. in individuals presenting at the clinic with “normal hearing.” Method: The results from neuroscience and psychoacoustics Conclusions: How well an individual with NHTs can are reviewed. understand speech amidst competing sounds depends Results: In noisy settings, listeners focus their attention by not only on the sound being audible but also on the engaging cortical brain networks to suppress unimportant integrity of cortical control networks and the fidelity of the sounds; they then can analyze and understand an important representation of suprathreshold sound. Understanding sound, such as speech, amidst competing sounds. Differences the root cause of difficulties experienced by listeners with in the efficacy of top-down control of attention can affect NHTs ultimately can lead to new, targeted interventions that communication abilities. In addition, subclinical deficits address specific deficits affecting communication in noise. in sensory fidelity can disrupt the ability to perceptually Presentation Video: http://cred.pubs.asha.org/article. segregate sound sources, interfering with selective attention, aspx?articleid=2601617 This research forum contains papers from the 2016 Research The challenge of understanding speech in settings Symposium at the ASHA Convention held in Philadelphia, PA.
    [Show full text]
  • Effects of an Auditory Lateralization Training in Children Suspected to Central Auditory Processing Disorder
    ORIGINAL ARTICLE J Audiol Otol 2016;20(2):102-108 pISSN 2384-1621 / eISSN 2384-1710 http://dx.doi.org/10.7874/jao.2016.20.2.102 Effects of an Auditory Lateralization Training in Children Suspected to Central Auditory Processing Disorder Yones Lotfi1, Abdollah Moosavi2, Farzaneh Zamiri Abdollahi3, Enayatollah Bakhshi4, and Hamed Sadjedi5 1Audiology Department, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, 2Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, 3Audiology Department, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, 4Biostatistics Department, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, 5Engineering Faculty, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran Background and Objectives: Central auditory processing disorder [(C)APD] refers to a deficit in auditory stimuli processing in nervous system that is not due to higher-order lan- guage or cognitive factors. One of the problems in children with (C)APD is spatial difficulties which have been overlooked despite their significance. Localization is an auditory ability to detect sound sources in space and can help to differentiate between the desired speech from other simultaneous sound sources. Aim of this research was investigating effects of an auditory lateralization training on speech perception in presence of noise/competing signals in children suspected to (C)APD. Subjects and Methods: In this analytical interven- tional study, 60 children suspected to (C)APD were selected based on multiple auditory Received May 30, 2016 processing assessment subtests. They were randomly divided into two groups: control Revised July 14, 2016 (mean age 9.07) and training groups (mean age 9.00). Training program consisted of de- Accepted August 3, 2016 tection and pointing to sound sources delivered with interaural time differences under Address for correspondence headphones for 12 formal sessions (6 weeks).
    [Show full text]
  • Twenty Years of Load Theory – Where Are We Now and Where Should We Go Next?
    Twenty Years of Load Theory – Where Are We Now and Where Should We Go Next? Gillian Murphy 1, John A. Groeger 2 & Ciara M. Greene 3 1University College Cork, Ireland, 2University of Hull, United Kingdom, 3University College Dublin, Ireland. Abstract Selective attention allows us to ignore what is task-irrelevant and focus on what is task- relevant. The cognitive and neural mechanisms which underlie this process is a key topic of investigation in cognitive psychology. One of the more prominent theories of attention is Perceptual Load Theory which suggests that the efficiency of selective attention is dependent on both perceptual and cognitive load. It is now more than 20 years since the proposal of Load Theory and it is timely to evaluate the evidence in support of this influential model. The present article supplements and extends upon previous reviews (Lavie, 2005; 2010) by examining more recent research in what appears to be a rapidly expanding area of research. The article comprises five parts, examining (1) the evidence for the effects of perceptual load on attention, (2) cognitive load, (3) individual differences under load, (4) alternative theories & criticisms and (5) the future of Load Theory. We argue that the key next step for Load Theory is the application of the model to real world tasks. The potential benefits of applied attention research are numerous and there is tentative evidence that applied research would provide strong support for the theory itself as well as real world benefits in activities where attention is crucial, such as driving and education. Keywords Selective Attention : Perception : Perceptual Load : Load Theory : Distraction : Visual Attention Corresponding Author: Gillian Murphy School of Applied Psychology, University College Cork, North Mall, Cork.
    [Show full text]
  • The Auditory System at the Cocktail Party Chapter 5 Modeling the Cocktail Party Problem
    Springer Handbook of Auditory Research John C. Middlebrooks Jonathan Z. Simon Arthur N. Popper Richard R. Fay Editors The Auditory System at the Cocktail Party Chapter 5 Modeling the Cocktail Party Problem Mounya Elhilali Abstract Modeling the cocktail party problem entails developing a computational framework able to describe what the auditory system does when faced with a complex auditory scene. While completely intuitive and omnipresent in humans and animals alike, translating this remarkable ability into a quantitative model remains a challenge. This chapter touches on difficulties facing the field in terms of defining the theoretical principles that govern auditory scene analysis, as well as reconciling current knowledge about perceptual and physiological data with their formulation into computational models. The chapter reviews some of the compu- tational theories, algorithmic strategies, and neural infrastructure proposed in the literature for developing information systems capable of processing multisource sound inputs. Because of divergent interests from various disciplines in the cocktail party problem, the body of literature modeling this effect is equally diverse and multifaceted. The chapter touches on the various approaches used in modeling auditory scene analysis from biomimetic models to strictly engineering systems. Keywords Computational auditory scene analysis Á Feature extraction Á Inference model Á Multichannel audio signal Á Population separation Á Receptive field Á Source separation Á Stereo mixture Á Temporal coherence 5.1 Introduction In everyday life, humans are constantly challenged to attend to specific sound sources or follow particular conversations in the midst of competing background chatter—a phenomenon referred to as the “cocktail party problem” (Cherry 1953). Whether at a real cocktail party, walking down a busy street, or having a conver- M.
    [Show full text]
  • The Relationship Between Attention and Working Memory
    In: New Research on Short-Term Memory ISBN 978-1-60456-548-5 Editor: Noah B. Johansen, pp. © 2008 Nova Science Publishers, Inc. Chapter 1 The Relationship between Attention and Working Memory Daryl Fougnie Vanderbilt University Abstract The ability to selectively process information (attention) and to retain information in an accessible state (working memory) are critical aspects of our cognitive capacities. While there has been much work devoted to understanding attention and working memory, the nature of the relationship between these constructs is not well understood. Indeed, while neither attention nor working memory represent a uniform set of processes, theories of their relationship tend to focus on only some aspects. This review of the literature examines the role of perceptual and central attention in the encoding, maintenance, and manipulation of information in working memory. While attention and working memory were found to interact closely during encoding and manipulation, the evidence suggests a limited role of attention in the maintenance of information. Additionally, only central attention was found to be necessary for manipulating information in working memory. This suggests that theories should consider the multifaceted nature of attention and working memory. The review concludes with a model describing how attention and working memory interact. I. Introduction The capacity to perform some complex tasks depends critically on the ability to retain task-relevant information in an accessible state over time (working memory) and to selectively process information in the environment (attention). As one example, consider driving a car in an unfamiliar city. In order to get to your destination, directions have to be retained and kept in working memory.
    [Show full text]
  • Auditory Selective Attention: an Introduction and Evidence for Distinct Facilitation and Inhibition Mechanisms
    Aus dem Epilepsiezentrum Erlangen Leiter: Prof. Dr. med. Hermann Stefan der Neurologischen Klinik mit Poliklinik der Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg Direktor: Prof. Dr. med. Stefan Schwab Durchgeführt im Helen Wills Neuroscience Institute der University of California, Berkeley, USA Direktor: Robert T. Knight, M.D. Betreuer: Aurélie Bidet-Caulet, Ph.D. Auditory Selective Attention: an introduction and evidence for distinct facilitation and inhibition mechanisms Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Medizinischen Fakultät der Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg vorgelegt von Constanze Elisabeth Anna Mikyska aus München Gedruckt mit Erlaubnis der Medizinischen Fakultät der Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg Dekan: Prof. Dr. med. Dr. h.c. J. Schüttler Referent: Prof. Dr. med. H. Stefan Korreferent: Prof. Dr. med. Dipl.-Psych. Ch. Lang Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 29. Februar 2012 To my family Table of contents 1 Summary 1 1.1 Summary 1 1.2 Zusammenfassung 3 2 Introduction 5 2.1 Auditory system: anatomy and function 5 2.1.1 Ear 5 2.1.2 Sub-cortical auditory relays 10 2.1.3 Auditory cortex 13 2.2 Investigation of auditory perception and processing 14 2.2.1 Psychophysics – psychoacoustics 15 2.2.2 Brain activity – electroencephalography (EEG) 17 2.2.2.1 Introduction and history 17 2.2.2.2 Physiological fundamentals 17 2.2.2.3 Recording 22 2.2.2.4 Classification of frequency 25 2.2.2.5 Artifacts 27 2.2.2.6 Data analysis: preprocessing and event-related potentials (ERP) 30 2.2.2.7
    [Show full text]
  • Cortical Classification with Rhythm Entropy for Error Processing In
    www.nature.com/scientificreports OPEN Cortical Classifcation with Rhythm Entropy for Error Processing in Cocktail Party Environment Based Received: 13 February 2018 Accepted: 5 April 2018 on Scalp EEG Recording Published: xx xx xxxx Yin Tian, Wei Xu & Li Yang Using single-trial cortical signals calculated by weighted minimum norm solution estimation (WMNE), the present study explored a feature extraction method based on rhythm entropy to classify the scalp electroencephalography (EEG) signals of error response from that of correct response during performing auditory-track tasks in cocktail party environment. The classifcation rate achieved 89.7% with single- trial (≈700 ms) when using support vector machine(SVM) with the leave-one-out-cross-validation (LOOCV). And high discriminative regions mainly distributed at the medial frontal cortex (MFC), the left supplementary motor area (lSMA) and the right supplementary motor area (rSMA). The mean entropy value for error trials was signifcantly lower than that for correct trials in the discriminative cortices. By time-varying network analysis, diferent information fows changed among these discriminative regions with time, i.e. error processing showed a left-bias information fow, and correct processing presented a right-bias information fow. These fndings revealed that the rhythm information based on single cortical signals could be well used to describe characteristics of error-related EEG signals and further provided a novel application about auditory attention for brain computer interfaces (BCIs). In everyday life, the food of sensory information were regulated by attention system into a manageable stream, and attention orienting played a primary role in complex visual environment by fnding relevant information and fltering out irrelevant information to bias the target selection and processing1.
    [Show full text]