DOCSLIB.ORG

Josephus' Use of Heimarmene in the Jewish Antiquities Xiii, 171-3

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Josephus' Use of Heimarmene in the Jewish Antiquities Xiii, 171-3 JOSEPHUS' USE OF HEIMARMENE IN THE JEWISH ANTIQUITIES XIII, 171-3 LUTHER H. MARTIN Josephus uses the word heimarmene (fate, or, destiny) in but four passages in his Jewish Antiquities: XIII, 171-3: XVI, 397; XVIII, 12-22; and XIX, 347.1 In two of these passages, XIII, 171-3 and XVIII, 12-22, as well as in a parallel passage in The Jewish War II, 162-6, he uses the issue of determinism to distinguish between the three Jewish "philosophies": the Pharisees, the Sadducees, and the Essenes.2 2 The Pharisees, according to Josephus in Ant. XVIII: postulate that everything is brought about by fate still they do not deprive the human will of the pursuit of what is in man's power, since it was God's good pleasure that there should be a fusion and that the will of man with his virtue and vice should be admitted to the council-chamber of fate. (Ant. XVIII, 13) Later, in this same passage, he characterizes the position of the Sadducees and the Essenes by contrasting them with this Pharisaic position on heimarmene. The Sadducees, he writes, "own no obser- vance of any sort apart from the laws," while the Essenes "leave everything in the hands of God" (Ant. XVIII, 16). Josephus also refers here (Ant. XVIII, 11) to a parallel account in the second book of his earlier The Jewish War, in which he described both the Pharisees and the Sadducees, in part, in terms of their contrasting attitudes towards heimarmene: the Pharisees... attribute everything to Fate (alyapyivq) and to God; they hold that to act rightly or otherwise rests, indeed, for the most part with men, but that in each action Fate (alyapyivq) cooperates.... The Sadducees...do away with Fate (alyapyavq) altogether. (Bell. II, 162-4) This passage from The Jewish War seems to clarify the description of the Sadducees which Josephus gives in the Antiquities XVIII, 16: In owning "no observance of any sort apart from the laws," "the Sadducees...do away with Fate." 128 In the brief passage on the three philosophies in Ant. XIII, 171-3, Josephus presents the attitude towards heimarmene as the single issue which distinguishes the three philosophies: Now at this time there were three schools of thought among the Jews, which held different opinions concerning human affairs; the first being that of the Pharisees, the second that of the Sadducees, and the third that of the Essenes. As for the Pharisees, they say that certain events are the work of Fate but not all; as to other events, it depends upon ourselves whether they shall take place or not. The sect of Essenes, however, declares that Fate (F-'L4otp4ivTi)is mistress of all things, and that nothing befalls men unless it be in accordance with her decree. But the Sadducees do away with Fate holding that there is no such thing and that human actions are not achieved in accordance with her decree, but that all things lie within our own power, so that we ourselves are responsible for our well-being, while we suffer misfor- tune through our own thoughtlessness. This is the only passage in which Josephus presents the opinion of all three philosophies explicitly towards heimarmene. Given the singularity and centrality of his use of this term in Ant. XIII, 171-3, an examination of Josephus' use of this term in the Antiquities best might be focused upon his use of heimarmene in this passage. The problems which can be focused upon this passage are essen- tially twofold. First, what does Josephus mean by heimarmene? and, why does he use so centrally a concept for which, as George Foot Moore has observed, "there was no equivalent word in Hebrew-and no corresponding conception?"3 Second, as heimarmene means "fate" or "destiny" in some sense, its meaning must be discussed in relation to the determinism/free will issue rais- ed by Josephus in this passage and implied in any discussion of fate. What then is the relationship of any kind of determinism to a God in whose hands, according to Josephus, is the universe, and who is "perfect and blessed, self-sufficing and sufficing for all" and who "is the beginning, the middle, and the end of all things" (Apion II, 190)? Josephus' use of heimarmene in the historical and theological con- text of his description of the three Jewish "philosophies" is a prob- lematic question not only in studies of Josephus and Hellenistic Judaism, but in the study of Hellenistic religion as a whole. The satirical writings of Lucian of Samosata, for instance, in the follow- ing century point to these issues: .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Implicit Theories of Friendships: Examining the Roles of Growth and Destiny Beliefs in Children's Friendships a DISSERTATION
    Implicit Theories of Friendships: Examining the Roles of Growth and Destiny Beliefs in Children’s Friendships A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Sara Gayle Kempner IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY W. Andrew Collins, Ph.D., Nicki R. Crick, Ph.D. August 2008 © Sara Gayle Kempner 2008 Acknowledgements I would like to thank my advisors, Andy Collins and Nicki Crick. Andy, thank you for being a mentor and advisor to me and supporting the development of my interests. Your continuing dedication to my education means so much to me. Nicki, you welcomed me into your lab and allowed me to broaden my research experiences. I am grateful for your nurturance and support. I would like to thank my committee members Richard Weinberg and Jeffry Simpson. Rich, you have been a great supporter of all my interests in graduate school. Jeff, it was in your close relationships seminar where the ideas for this project first emerged. Thank you for being a part of this project. I owe a great deal of gratitude to the schools, teachers, and children who participated in this study and shared their thoughts with me. Especially one child who asked me how I was going to use their answers to get a Ph.D. After explaining that I would put their answers into a computer, analyze it, and write a paper the child remarked, “Well that sounds pretty easy!” I would like to thank all the undergraduates who helped collect and enter data.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Philosophy.Pdf
    I N T R O D U C T I O N What Is Philosophy? CHAPTER 1 The Task of Philosophy CHAPTER OBJECTIVES Reflection—thinking things over—. [is] the beginning of philosophy.1 In this chapter we will address the following questions: N What Does “Philosophy” Mean? N Why Do We Need Philosophy? N What Are the Traditional Branches of Philosophy? N Is There a Basic Method of Philo- sophical Thinking? N How May Philosophy Be Used? N Is Philosophy of Education Useful? N What Is Happening in Philosophy Today? The Meanings Each of us has a philos- “having” and “doing”—cannot be treated en- ophy, even though we tirely independent of each other, for if we did of Philosophy may not be aware of not have a philosophy in the formal, personal it. We all have some sense, then we could not do a philosophy in the ideas concerning physical objects, our fellow critical, reflective sense. persons, the meaning of life, death, God, right Having a philosophy, however, is not suffi- and wrong, beauty and ugliness, and the like. Of cient for doing philosophy. A genuine philo- course, these ideas are acquired in a variety sophical attitude is searching and critical; it is of ways, and they may be vague and confused. open-minded and tolerant—willing to look at all We are continuously engaged, especially during sides of an issue without prejudice. To philoso- the early years of our lives, in acquiring views phize is not merely to read and know philoso- and attitudes from our family, from friends, and phy; there are skills of argumentation to be mas- from various other individuals and groups.
    [Show full text]
  • Fate and Death Through a Daimonic Lens
    FATE AND DEATH THROUGH A DAIMONIC LENS FATE AND DEATH THROUGH A DAIMONIC LENS By JASON SOLOMON BINDER, B.A.Sc., B.A. Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts McMaster University © Copyright by Jason Solomon Binder, September 2014 MA Thesis – J. Binder; McMaster University – Classics. McMaster University MASTER OF ARTS (2014) Hamilton, Ontario (Classics) TITLE: Fate and Death through a Daimonic Lens AUTHOR: Jason Solomon Binder, B.A.Sc., B.A. (McMaster University) SUPERVISOR: Dr. Sean Corner NUMBER OF PAGES: vi, 101 ii MA Thesis – J. Binder; McMaster University – Classics. Abstract This thesis is concerned with the ancient Greek conceptualization of fate and death, as explored through the figure of the daimon in literature from Homer and Hesiod to Plato and Euripides. Filling a gap in scholarship, I elucidate the spectrum of meaning inherent in the word daimon, and how it shifts over time. From the Archaic to the Classical period the word daimon is found as a synonym for theos, “god”, as a vocative address, or in reference to “fate” and the generalized “will of heaven.” At the same time, a particular group of divine personifications, including Thanatos, Moira, Ker, and Erinys are counted as daimones. We also find the term used to designate unnamed but individuated lesser divinities, guardian spirits, and demonic possessors, and even as the divine aspect of the self. In the early Archaic poets these latter categories are only nascent. The individuated daimon becomes the focus of the lyric poets and pre-Socratic philosophers; in the later pre-Socratics the daimon begins to be internalized, moving from possessive spirit to psychic force.
    [Show full text]
  • Benjamin's Moment
    BENJAMIN’S MOMENT Kia Lindroos Man könnte sagen, daß unsern tiefsten Augenblicken gleich jenen Päkchenzigaretten – ein kleines Bildchen, ein Photo unsrer selbst – ist mitgegeben worden. Und jenes “ganze Leben” das, wie wir oft hören, an Sterbenden oder an Menchen, die in der Gefahr zu sterben schwe- ben, vorüberzieht, setzt sich genau aus diesen kleinen Bildchen zusammen. (Walter Benjamin, Aus einer kleinen Rede über Proust, GS II. 3: 1064). In this essay, I focus on the Benjaminian moment. The moment is un- derstood firstly as a temporal instance that has become a meaningful issue in several of Benjamin’s essays on literature, history, film and photography. Secondly, I thematise the more extensive Benjaminian moment, which occupies a central position in 20th Century thought. For instance, Michael Löwy notes that Benjamin’s Geschichtsphiloso- phische Thesen is the most significant and revolutionary document since Marx’s Thesen über Feuerbach” (Löwy 2001: 4-5). One core argu- ment in Benjamin’s Thesen is the importance of emphasising revo- lutionary action as a rupture, a form of action with the potential to intervene in any unquestioned continuum of thinking, action, or po- litical, historical or aesthetic understanding. His aim is to highlight the relevance of various forms of present experiences, for example in understanding revolutionary action as marking the desire to pull ‘the emergency break’ as opposed to remaining a complacent passenger in the train ‘of history’ (cf. Benjamin GS 1.3: 1232). It is this revolu- 115 BENJAMIN’S MOMENT tionary character of the Benjaminian moment that remains relevant to this day and highlights the significance of Benjamin among theo- rists on time and history.
    [Show full text]
  • Illinois Classical Studies
    1 Recognizing Helen i TIMOTHY W. BOYD In Book 4 of the Odyssey, Helen and Menelaus, now home again in Sparta, are entertaining Telemachus, the son of Odysseus. Along with their hospitality, they each offer an anecdote about Odysseus as they saw him in a moment of great stress at Troy. These anecdotes have been the subject of much scholarly speculation, not only about their content, but also about the behavior of the tellers. Froma Zeitlin, for example, sees each of the stories as having two levels. In the upper, they are "tales from the past that seems to have been forgiven, transmuted into a play of symmetrical reversals that charm instead of dismay." In the lower level, they are about Helen as the embodiment of fiction itself. In a less theoretical vein, Douglas Olson concentrates upon the possible function of the stories within the greater narrative, suggesting that the anecdotes "prepare us for what is to come many books later, in another household, between another couple." Another interpretation, that of Charles Rowan Beye, is that these are stories both about a missing hero and about Helen's loyalty—or lack of it.^ That there are so many differing interpretations of these two stories is not surprising. On the surface, they are what they purport to be: tales of Odysseus, told to his son, Telemachus. Just below that surface, however, they do appear to be about something else. Helen's story, for example. My thanks to the following people for their assistance in creating this essay: Carolyn Higbie, Gregory Nagy, Victor Ortiz, David Sansone, and the readers at ICS.
    [Show full text]
  • Eternal Destiny Pt5 the Path to Destiny
    Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny Re 20:11-21:8/ Ro 8:28-29 Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny What is Destiny? • Destiny is the path established by God for every individual before the foundation of the world that leads to the discovery of the essential purpose for their existence. Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny Define Purpose • Simply, the reason for which anything is created or exists Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny • PURPOSE is established in us before the earth was formed (before time) (Eph1:4-6) 1. Chronos: • Each of us is given a “Measure of Time” to discover, develop and establish PURPOSE – This is known as Chronos . Within the confines of Chronos is Kairos. 1. Kairos: a. The opportune and decisive moment. b. In the New Testament, kairos means "the appointed time in the purpose of God"; the time when God acts Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny A.7 Directives for the Believer of Purpose 1.Bring Glory to God 2.Praise & Worship 3.Bear Fruit 4.Love One Another 5.Preach the Gospel 6.Make Disciples 7.Serve One Another Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny Keys to Discovering Your Specific Purpose by Shana Schutte 1.Listen to your dissatisfactions 2.Listen to others 3.Listen to your gifts 4.Listen to your passions Eternal Destiny pt5 The Path to Destiny What is Destiny? • Destiny is the path (of life) established by God for every individual before the foundation of the world that leads to the discovery of the essential purpose for their existence.
    [Show full text]
  • Nietzsche's Doctrine of Eternal Return
    University of Rhode Island DigitalCommons@URI Senior Honors Projects Honors Program at the University of Rhode Island 2007 Nietzsche’s Doctrine of Eternal Return David R. Gadon University of Rhode Island, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.uri.edu/srhonorsprog Part of the Philosophy Commons Recommended Citation Gadon, David R., "Nietzsche’s Doctrine of Eternal Return" (2007). Senior Honors Projects. Paper 47. http://digitalcommons.uri.edu/srhonorsprog/47http://digitalcommons.uri.edu/srhonorsprog/47 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors Program at the University of Rhode Island at DigitalCommons@URI. It has been accepted for inclusion in Senior Honors Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@URI. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Nietzsche’s Doctrine of Eternal Return David Ray Gadon Honors Senior Thesis Spring 2007 Sponsor: Dr. Galen A. Johnson Gadon 2 Nietzsche’s Doctrine of Eternal Return “Six thousand feet beyond man and time.” 1 In the Western world, we have a pronounced affinity for understanding time as something ultimately simple. Despite our recognition of the differences in subjective perception of the passing of intervals, we tacitly affirm that time itself must objectively follow a comprehensible structure of unidirectional flow which, like the commonly cited river metaphor, begins at one point and is definitively moving towards another. Thanks especially to the Judeo-Christian model of history plowing inevitably towards a conclusion at the end of days, even in the absence of direct religious influence, our intuitive understanding of time remains linear. We see this model addressed and contested by metaphysicians throughout the ages, but only rarely do we glimpse a philosophy that is able to cogently upturn this intuitively correct ideal.
    [Show full text]
  • Fate, Destiny and Eternal Recurrence
    FATE, DESTINY AND ETERNAL RECURRENCE ‘Love is our true destiny’ Thomas Merton Fate and Destiny The concepts of fate and destiny are often confused. The term “fate” is derived from the Latin word fatum, meaning “that which has been spoken.” Fate is based on the idea that there is a natural order in the universe or a preordained course of events, which cannot be changed. “Destiny,” on the other hand, is derived from the Latin word destino, meaning “that which has been firmly established.” Unlike fate, there is an element of choice and freedom in destiny – it is something we can potentially shape and alter through free will. Fate is unavoidable and inevitable; destiny can be modified and altered. Throughout history, philosophers, mystics, poets, statesmen, and even humorists have contemplated the meaning and significance of fate and destiny: · Marcus Aurelius: “Accept the things to which fate binds you, and love the people with whom fate brings you together, but do so with all your heart.” · The Bhagavad Gita: “It is better to live your own destiny imperfectly than to live an imitation of somebody else’s life with perfection.” · Shakespeare: “It is not in the stars to hold our destiny but in ourselves.” · Hafiz: “The place you are right now God circled on a map for you.” · Goethe: “Destiny grants us our wishes, but in its own way, in order to give us something beyond our wishes.” · John Galsworthy: “Life calls the tune, we dance.” · William Jennings Bryan: “Destiny is not a matter of chance. It is a matter of choice.
    [Show full text]
  • When God Alters Our Fate: Relational Freedom in Romans 5:1–11 and 8:18–39
    start page: 223 Stellenbosch eological Journal 2018, Vol 4, No 2, 223–241 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17570/stj.2018.v4n2.a11 Online ISSN 2413-9467 | Print ISSN 2413-9459 2018 © Pieter de Waal Neethling Trust When God alters our fate: Relational freedom in Romans 5:1–11 and 8:18–39 Stephan Joubert University of the Free State, Bloemfontein, South Africa [email protected] Abstract Fate played an enormous role in the Ancient Mediterranean world. Fate was personified in numerous ancient deities such as the Keres, the Moirae, and Fortuna. At the same time Stoic views on fate, as a chain of causes, impacted hugely on the ancients’ general view on fate as an inexorable force which cannot be opposed, or whose direction and eventual outcomes cannot be changed. Against the backdrop, Paul’s understanding of the nature of God’s presence, actions and influence in the lives of believers in Romans 5:1–10 and 8:18–39 is discussed. Fate, in the sense of that which has been predetermined and written into the lives of individuals before birth, and which comes into existence in many different, fixed forms, or fate as a chain of causes, is never on Paul’s mind. God’s foreordained plan is not a predetermined, unalterable fate for each and every person over which they have no control or say whatsoever. Rather, God’s πρόθεσις (prothesis) relates to the salvation of all believers. God refuses to surrender his people to their fate, namely death and eternal destruction. He changes fate into destiny for all who believe in Christ.
    [Show full text]
  • Jung and Aion: Time, Vision, and a Wayfaring Man
    Jung and Aion: Time, Vision, and a Wayfaring Man Lance S. Owens C. G. Jung stated in 1957 that the visionary experiences recorded in The Red Book: Liber Novus were the foundation of his life work: “My entire life consisted in elaborating what had burst forth from the unconscious and flooded me like an enigmatic stream . the numinous beginning, which contained everything, was then.” Liber Novus is now historically placed in a hermeneutic relationship with Jung’s subsequent writings. Jung composed the first page of Liber Novus in 1915. On this in- troductory folio leaf he graphically intertwined a prophecy of the future and the coming of a new aeon: an epochal turning-point in human con- sciousness. Though this revelation was foundational to his subsequent work, Jung did not initially feel free to publicly disclose its keynote. After several extraordinary near-death visions in 1944, Jung real- ized it was his duty to finally and openly communicate the central revela- tion recorded in Liber Novus.ThefirstmanuscriptpageofLiber Novus penned by Jung in 1915—deeply considered, dense with verbal and pictorial imagery formed in response to the Spirit of the Depths—and the complexly crafted commentary in Aion, composed three decades later, are fundamentally wed. They both declare the dawning of a new aeon. While each work might be studied as an independent text, one can only comprehend Jung and his struggle with Liber Novus in their conjunction. ho hath believed our report? and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed? For he shall grow up before him as a tender plant, and as a root out of a dry ground.
    [Show full text]
  • A Family Gathering at Rhamnous? Who's Who on the Nemesis Base
    A FAMILY GATHERING AT RHAMNOUS? WHO'S WHO ON THE NEMESIS BASE (PLATES 27 AND 28) For Marina T HE DATE of the introductionof the cultof Nemesisat Rhamnoushas notbeen deter- mined with any degree of certainty,but the associationof the goddess with the Athe- nian victoryat Marathon, made by ancient literarysources, has led some scholarsto suggest that the cult was founded, or at least expanded, in the aftermath of the Persian Wars.1 I An earlier version of this article was submitted as a school paper to the American School of Classical Studies at Athens in 1989. Later versions were presentedorally in 1990 at the AmericanAcademy in Rome, the CanadianAcademic Centre in Rome, and the annual meeting of the ArchaeologicalInstitute of Americain San Francisco. I am grateful to the Fulbright Foundation and the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley, whose support allowed me to undertakepreliminary research for this paper in Athens; to the Luther Replogle Foundation whose generosity allowed me to continue my work as Oscar T. Broneer Fellow in Classical Archaeologyat the AmericanAcademy in Rome;to John Camp who introducedme to the problemsof the Rhamnous base; and to Christina Traitoraki for her kind assistancein the early stages of the preparationof this paper. I have profited greatly from the insights, suggestions, and criticisms of M. Bell, J. Boardman,D. Clay, A. S. Delivorrias, C. M. Edwards, E. S. Gruen, E. Harrison, D. C. Kurtz, M. Mar- vin, M. M. Miles, J. Neils, M. C. J. Putnam, B. S. Ridgway, A. F. Stewart, B. A. Stewart, and J. M.
    [Show full text]
  • Searching Destiny Library Manager with Basic Power Visual Searches
    Destiny® Library Manager™ Searching Destiny Library Manager with Basic, Power, and Visual Searches Your patrons have diverse searching needs and techniques. Destiny Library Manager offers flexible searching options with its Basic, Power, and Visual search features. Using Basic Search A Basic search lets you use simple search terms or phrases to find materials and set limiters to narrow your search results. To conduct a Basic search: 1. Go to Catalog > Library Search > Basic. 2. Enter a search term in the Find field. 3. Select any of the limiters to narrow your search (optional). For more information, see the Narrowing Your Search with Limiters section. 4. Select one of the following search buttons. Keyword: Searches all title, author, subject, series, and note tags (fields of information) in the district’s title records. Title: Searches for the term anywhere in a title. Author: Searches for authors and illustrators. Subject: Searches for titles about a particular subject, topic, person, or place. Series: Searches for titles in a particular series of books. ©2016 Follett School Solutions, Inc. 1 Using Power Search A Power search is a more complex search interface that lets you use Boolean operators and additional limiters. To conduct a Power search: 1. Go to Catalog > Library Search > Power. 2. From the first drop-down, select the type of search you want to perform: Keyword, Title, Author, Subject, Series, or Note. 3. Enter a search term(s) in field next to the type of search you selected. 4. From the second drop-down, select how you want Destiny to search with the search term(s): All these words: Finds materials that contain all of the words in the search term.
    [Show full text]