Charter Authorizer Accountability Report 2018-19
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TEXAS CHARTER AUTHORIZER ACCOUNTABILITY REPORT 2018–2019 Submitted to the Texas Education Agency Charter Authorizer Accountability Report 2018–19 School Year Contributing Authors: Toni Templeton Catherine L. Horn Dina Alghazzawi Jeanette Narvaez Binh Bui 3 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 Acknowledgments The authors of this report are grateful to charter school program staff and research and analysis staff at the Texas Education Agency who were involved in detailed programmatic and method- ological discussions and providing data for analysis and feedback on results. The authors would also like to thank Sherri Lowrey and Diana D’Abruzzo for their assistance throughout the project. Copyright © Notice: The materials are copyrighted © and trademarked ™ as the property of the Texas Education Agency (TEA) and may not be reproduced without the express written per- mission of TEA, except under the following conditions: 1. Texas public school districts, charter schools, and education service centers (ESCs) may reproduce and use copies of the materials and related materials for districts’ and schools’ educational use without obtaining permission from TEA. 2. Residents of the state of Texas may reproduce and use copies of the materials and related materials for individual personal use only without obtaining written permission of TEA. 3. Any portion reproduced must be reproduced in its entirety and remain unedited, unaltered, and unchanged in any way. 4. No monetary fee can be charged for the reproduced materials or any document contain- ing them; however, a reasonable fee to cover only the cost of reproduction and distribu- tion may be charged. Private entities or persons located in Texas that are not public school districts, charter schools, or ESCs or any entity, whether public or private, educational or noneducational, located outside the state of Texas MUST obtain written approval from TEA and will be required to enter into a license agreement that may involve the payment of a licensing fee or a royalty. For information, contact: Copyrights Office, Texas Education Agency, 1701 N. Congress Ave., Austin, TX 78701-1494; phone 512-463-9041; email [email protected]. 4 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 Table of Contents List of Tables 6 List of Figures 7 List of Acronyms Used in This Report 11 Executive Summary 12 Background 12 Overview of Texas Charter School Campuses 13 Key Findings for SBOE- and ISD-Authorized Charter School Campuses 13 Key Findings for COE-Authorized Charter School Campuses 15 Study Limitations 16 Section 1: Introduction 17 National Charter School Overview 17 Texas Charter Schools 18 Contemporary Texas Charter Legislation 19 Purpose of the Report 19 Data Sources, Definitions, and Research Methods 20 Study Limitations 24 Organization of the Report 25 Section 2: Description of Charter School Campuses and Traditional Public Schools 26 Student Enrollment 28 Section 3: Aggregate Performance of Charter School Campuses by Authorizer Compared to Matched Traditional Public School Campuses 31 Campuses Included in the Aggregate Performance Analysis 31 Attrition Rates 33 STAAR Results 34 Graduation Rates 42 College, Career, and Military Readiness Outcomes 44 TEA Accountability Domain Scores 47 Section 4: Aggregate Performance of Charter School Campuses by School Level and Authorizer Type Compared to Matched Traditional Public School Campuses 50 Attrition Rates Disaggregated by School Level 51 STAAR Results Disaggregated by School Level 52 TEA Accountability Domain Scores Disaggregated by School Level 59 5 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 Section 5: Analysis of Charter School Campuses Authorized by the COE Compared to Matched Traditional Public School Campuses 64 Campuses Included in the Aggregate Performance Analysis 64 Attrition Rates 66 STAAR Results 66 TEA Accountability Scores 71 Section 6: Discussion of Findings 74 Overview 74 Summary of Results 74 Study Limitations 77 References 78 Appendix A: Detailed Methods Description 80 Appendix B: Aggregate Performance on Additional STAAR Exams for Charter School Campuses by Authorizer Type Compared to Matched Traditional Public School Campuses 85 Appendix C: Campus-Level Performance Results 99 6 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 List of Tables Table 2.1: Texas Public School Campuses by School Type, 2018–19 26 Table 2.2: Student Enrollment in Texas Public School Campuses by School Type, 2018–19 28 Table 2.3: Demographic Characteristics of Students Enrolled in Texas Public School Campuses, 2018–19 30 Table 3.1: Demographic Characteristics of Charter School Campuses and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses That Were Included in Aggregate Performance Analyses, 2018–19 32 Table 3.2: Percent of College, Career, and Military Ready Graduates by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2017–18 46 Table 5.1: Demographic Characteristics of COE-Authorized Charter School Campuses and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses That Were Included in Aggregate Performance Analyses, 2018–19 65 Appendix C Table C.1: Campus-Level Academic Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Elementary School Campuses Evaluated Under Standard Accountability 99 Table C.2: Campus-Level Academic Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Middle School Campuses Evaluated Under Standard Accountability 127 Table C.3: Campus-Level Academic Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, High School Campuses Evaluated Under Standard Accountability 138 Table C.3a: Campus-Level College, Career, and Military Readiness Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, High School Campuses Evaluated Under Standard Accountability 146 Table C.4: Campus-Level Academic Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Campuses Evaluated Under Alternative Education Accountability 154 Table C.4a: Campus-Level College, Career, and Military Readiness Performance Outcomes for Charter School Campuses and Means for Each Charter School’s Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Campuses Evaluated Under Alternative Education Accountability 163 7 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 List of Figures Figure 1.1: Number of Students Enrolled in Charter Schools in the United States, 2005–06 to 2018–19 17 Figure 3.1: Student Attrition Rates Between 2018–19 and 2019–20 for SBOE-Authorized and ISD-Authorized Charter School Campuses and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses 33 Figure 3.2: Percent of Students Achieving the Approaches Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Reading Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 34 Figure 3.3: Percent of Students Achieving the Approaches Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-English I and English II End-of-Course Exams by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 35 Figure 3.4: Percent of Students Achieving the Approaches Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Mathematics Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 36 Figure 3.5: Percent of Students Achieving the Approaches Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Algebra I End-of-Course Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 37 Figure 3.6: Percent of Students Achieving the Masters Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Reading Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 38 Figure 3.7: Percent of Students Achieving the Masters Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-English I and English II End-of-Course Exams by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 39 Figure 3.8: Percent of Students Achieving the Masters Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Mathematics Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 40 Figure 3.9: Percent of Students Achieving the Masters Grade Level Standard on the STAAR-Algebra I End-of-Course Exam by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 41 Figure 3.10: Grade 9 Four-Year Longitudinal Graduation Rates by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Evaluated Under Standard Accountability Provisions, Class of 2018 42 Figure 3.11: Grade 9 Four-Year Longitudinal Graduation Rates by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, Evaluated Under Alternative Accountability Provisions, Class of 2018 43 Figure 3.12: TEA Accountability Domain Scores by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 48 Figure 3.13: TEA Overall Accountability Rating by Charter Authorizer Type and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, 2018–19 49 Figure 4.1: Student Attrition Rates Between 2018–19 and 2019–20 for Charter School Campuses and Matched Traditional Public School Campuses, by Charter Authorizer Type and School Level 51 8 Texas Charter Authorizer Accountability Report, 2018–19 Figure 4.2: Percent of Students Achieving the Approaches Grade Level Standard on the 2018–19 STAAR-Reading and STAAR-Mathematics