DOCSLIB.ORG

1 the Palestine Exception to Free Speech

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
1 the Palestine Exception to Free Speech The Palestine Exception to Free Speech: Intertwined Stories from the Frontlines of UK-Based Palestine Advocacy by Malaka Mohammed Shwaikh and Rebecca Ruth Gould Although we only later came to realise its significance in our lives and for Palestine advocacy generally, February 2017 turned out to be a watershed month for those of us on the frontlines of the Palestine advocacy movement within the UK. During this month, amid a wave of cancellations of events critical of Israel, we were attacked in the media, smeared as antisemitic, and both supported and censored by our universities. The following month was marked by unprecedented censorship of Israel-critical events across the UK. As we now know, these events were linked to the UK government’s adoption of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism.1 While many communities and activists were affected by the event cancellations and the many different forms of censorship linked to the IHRA adoption, to our knowledge, we are the only UK- based academics who were directly targeted as a result of our written statements relating to Israel during this tumultuous year. Malaka was based at the University of Exeter, and completing her PhD on Palestinian hunger strikers at the time of the attack. Rebecca had recently moved to the University of Bristol, where she was a Reader (Associate Professor) in Translation Studies and Comparative Literature. Rebecca would like to thank Kate Gould, Riz Mokal, Mike Joseph, Yair Wallach, Tom Sperlinger, and Seth Anzieska for help and insights, without implicating any of them in the views expressed here. Malaka would like to thank Yara Hawari, Ilan Pappe, Katie Natanel, Nadia Najjab, Cameron Rose, Ben Jamal, as well as family, friends, and colleagues who supported her throughout this difficult time and beyond. Copies of all materials quoted herein are in the present authors’ possession unless otherwise indicated. 1 For further background on the working definition and its adoption within the UK, see Rebecca Ruth Gould, “Legal Form and Legal Legitimacy: The IHRA Definition of Antisemitism as a Case Study in Censored Speech,” Law, Culture and the Humanities (https://doi.org/10.1177/1743872118780660). 1 Two years after these events, we are telling our stories together. Although we did not know each other at the time when we were attacked, we have since become allies, co-authors, and academic collaborators with a common interest in Palestine.2 The better we came to know each other, the more struck we were by the elements that brought our stories together. We were attacked by the same organisation in the days leading up to Israel Apartheid Week, in both cases for statements we had made about Israeli politics several years earlier. In both cases, too, the media systematically distorted what we had said, and our universities failed spectacularly to support us while we were under attack. Few observers at the time recognized the links between what was happening to us, but in retrospect the timing and other parallels in the attacks makes them appear like part of a coordinated effort to silence Israel-critical speech.3 The intertwining of our stories sheds light on the pervasive media and institutional complicity in silencing dissent across Europe and North America every day. This is not however the only reason for considering how our stories intersect. Our intertwined stories—their simultaneity, their parallels, and their divergences—also provide material for reflection for activists who recognise their reliance on free speech as a condition of possibility for their activism. Our encounters with censorship shed new light on the dynamics that the US-based advocacy organisation Palestine Legal has termed “the Palestine exception to free speech,” whereby special interest groups “pressure universities, government actors, and other institutions to censor or punish advocacy in support of Palestinian rights.”4 They also reveal how hate speech wounds within the particular logic of the Palestine 2 Our first co-authored publication is Malaka Mohammed Shwaikh and Rebecca Ruth Gould, Prison Hunger Strikes as Civil Resistance: Protesting Imprisonment in Palestinian Prisons (Washington, DC: International Center on Nonviolent Conflict Research Monograph Series, 2019). 3 These efforts arguably reached their peak the following year, in the explosive controversy relating to antisemitism within the Labour Party. For further background see Jamie Stern-Weiner, “Labour’s fabricated anti-Semitism crisis,” in Corbyn and the Future of Labour (London: Verso, 2016). 4 “The Palestine Exception to Free Speech,” Executive Summary p. 3 https://ccrjustice.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/09/Palestine%20Exception%20Report%20Executive%20Su mmary%20Final.pdf). 2 exception to free speech.5 By exploring the intersections of free speech and Palestinian rights in these pages, we shed light on the specific pressures that advocates face, and reveal how even liberal democracies with robust traditions of supporting free speech tend to fall short when it comes to supporting the rights of activists and academics in their campaigns for Palestinian rights. We narrate our stories consecutively, beginning with Malaka’s and followed by Rebecca’s, and then consider the similarities and differences that marked our experiences. We conclude by reflecting on how universities and academics can respond to such attacks while respecting the academic freedom of their faculty and students and being attentive to the challenges faced in particular by minority members of the community and by Palestinians when they come under attack. The ways in which we were targeted and attacked were related—having occurred simultaneously—and different, given our distinct positions within the academy’s hierarchy. In co-authoring each other’s narratives, we reshaped our respective experiences, which were isolating in the extreme when they first occurred, away from the politics of recrimination, and towards new solidarities, that could only have emerged based on what we experienced separately during this political targeting. The co-authoring of our narratives thereby became a co-authoring of each other’s life story, and a means of linking our individual experiences to a broader collective goal. Malaka’s Story: Guilt by Association I was targeted first, on the last day of the elections for the Vice-President of the Exeter Student Guild. The Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA), an organisation that subsequently came to dominate much of the conversation in the UK concerning antisemitism within Labour and university contexts, tagged me in a tweet on 17 February. They complained that antisemitic graffiti, including swastikas, sprayed on university residence 5 We are indebted to Julie Rak for this formulation. 3 halls, had been ignored by the university. On that day, an exchange took place between CAA and the University of Exeter’s official Twitter account, which made clear that the group was seeking to implicate me in these antisemitic events, notwithstanding a total absence of evidence. “As @UniofExeter brushes off antisemitic incidents,” CAA wrote, “we reveal that @MalakaMohammed is about to be elected unopposed.”6 The link proposed was spurious; I had no knowledge of the graffiti and was in no way a party to it. But no one bothered to examine the data critically. Like the media, the university accepted uncritically the guilt-by-association tactics put in place by CAA, and failed to challenge the spurious link drawn between the antisemitic incidents and my six-year-old tweets. To CAA’s tweet complaining about my upcoming elections, the university responded “Hi, you can read a statement on antisemitism from our Vice-Chancellor here.”7 CAA’s complaint was retweeted by CAA chairman, and the university reposted the same statement, never once consulting with me concerning their media strategy or taking my interests into consideration.8 Notably, the statement from the Vice-Chancellor referred to an entirely different and unrelated series of antisemitic incidents, which were completely unrelated to my controversial tweets. While both CAA and the university Twitter account conflated the antisemitic incidents with my Twitter feed, there was no evidence to support this linkage, which appears to have been crafted to intensify the hostility of the attack on me. While the attacks against me were mounting, I won the elections. In my victory speech a few days later, I spoke out against all forms of racism, including antisemitism: I want to tell all those people who have been attacking and threatening me throughout the past few weeks, you are dealing with a Palestinian woman […] who will never feel weak in front of your Islamophobic attacks. I will resist, we will resist. I will continue to fight for freedom, justice and equality of my people in Palestine. I will continue to fight 6 Campaign Against Antisemitism, @antisemitism (18 February). Tweet. 7 University of Exeter, @UniofExeter. https://twitter.com/UniofExeter/status/832684063303442433 (17 February, 8:12PM). Tweet (thread containing the tweets in n7 and n8 below). 8 The tweet can be accessed here: https://twitter.com/GideonFalter/status/832600252498731012 and here: https://twitter.com/UniofExeter/status/832683661652791296. 4 all forms of racism and fascism. And I hope you will join me in this because together we are stronger, together we will win. Together our world will be brighter and more inclusive for all regardless of our difference, where we come from,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Making of Englishmen Studies in the History of Political Thought
    The Making of Englishmen Studies in the History of Political Thought Edited by Terence Ball, Arizona State University JÖrn Leonhard, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg Wyger Velema, University of Amsterdam Advisory Board Janet Coleman, London School of Economics and Political Science, UK Vittor Ivo Comparato, University of Perugia, Italy Jacques Guilhaumou, CNRS, France John Marshall, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA Markku Peltonen, University of Helsinki, Finland VOLUME 8 The titles published in this series are listed at brill.com/ship The Making of Englishmen Debates on National Identity 1550–1650 By Hilary Larkin LEIDEN • BOSTON 2014 This is an open access title distributed under the terms of the CC BY-NC 4.0 license, which permits any non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited. Further information and the complete license text can be found at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by-nc/4.0/ The terms of the CC license apply only to the original material. The use of material from other sources (indicated by a reference) such as diagrams, illustrations, photos and text samples may require further permission from the respective copyright holder. An electronic version of this book is freely available, thanks to the support of libraries working with Knowledge Unlatched. More information about the initiative can be found at www. knowledgeunlatched.org. Cover illustration: Titian (c1545) Portrait of a Young Man (The Young Englishman). Galleria Palatina (Palazzo Pitti), Florence, Italy. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Larkin, Hilary. The making of Englishmen : debates on national identity, 1550-1650 / by Hilary Larkin.
    [Show full text]
  • May All Our Voices Be Heard
    JUST THE TONIC EDFRINGE VENUES 2019 FULL LISTINGS AND MORE 1st - 25th August 2019 EDINBURGH FRINGE PROUDLY SPONSORED BY NO ONE - TOTALLY INDEPENDENT 7 venues 8 Bars 4000 performances 98.9%* 19 performance spaces 182 shows comedy *THE OTHER 1.1% ARE FUN AS WELL… CHALLENGE: GO FIND THE OTHER 2 SHOWS INSIDE! MAY ALL OUR VOICES BE HEARD www.justthetonic.com Big Value is the best Big Value compilation show at The Fringe. It’s an Comedy Shows excellent barometer of The longest running stand up compilation show on the fringe. We ask promoter people who are going Darrell Martin to take a look at at it’s fine heritage. to go on to big things. Starting in 1996, with a line up that included The show is currently produced by Darrell And I’m not just saying Milton Jones and Adam Bloom, the Big Value Martin, who runs Just the Tonic. It wasn’t Comedy Shows have been selecting the always that way. Many years ago Darrell was that because I did it. stars of the future for almost 25 years. a keen performer that was desperate to be part of the show. Comedians such as Jim Jeffries, Pete Harris was the person who set it all up. Sarah Millican, Jon Richardson and He ran a chain of clubs called Screaming ROMESH Romesh Ranganathan are some of Blue Murder. According to Adam Bloom, it all RANGANATHAN came out of a conversation where Adam said Big Value Comedy Show 2011 + 2012 those who were first exposed to the to Pete that he wanted to go to Edinburgh but couldn’t afford it.
    [Show full text]
  • Communications Review
    Communications Review 2017 Quarter 2 July - September Executive Summary Q2 Communications overview The new Police and Crime Plan priorities provide a framework for communications activity in 2017. Media summary Website, news and features • This quarter we focused on quality rather than quantity work, because we have carried four vacancies in the team and gap whilst we recruited a fifth team member • We ran a 5 week burglary campaign over the summer to support operational policing; we managed all the ticketing for the Open Day, ran a high profile sexual assault campaign and have invested heavily in planning for Hate Crime Awareness Week • Having a reduced team has impacted on the number of articles on the website and therefore the number of views and referrals (- 10 articles from Q1) • Due to time pressures and an increase in demand for appeals, the Press Team has often put CCTV/picture-led appeals directly onto social media rather than the website (-33 news stories) Social media • Our reduced capacity as a team can also be seen in the decrease in Facebook posts issued. Although we issued 16% fewer posts, our engagement only fell by 14% and our link clicks by only 11%. This shows that our average engagement and link clicks per post is actually increasing • Our Facebook audience continues to increase (+5%) despite our slower output, showing that our content continues to be relevant and engaging • The Press Team are increasingly issuing appeals directly on Twitter rather than hosting them on the website as a news story. So despite the vacancies, the number of Tweets issued remains steady • We’ve also seen an increase in link clicks from Twitter, indicating that when a story is hosted on our website, Tweeting a link is more efficient than sending a press release • Our Instagram account is run by a team off officers from the Ops Training, Mounted, and Dog sections.
    [Show full text]
  • Orr, Jennifer (2011) Fostering an Irish Writers' Circle: a Revisionist Reading of the Life and Works of Samuel Thomson, an Ulster Poet (1766- 1816)
    Orr, Jennifer (2011) Fostering an Irish writers' circle: a revisionist reading of the life and works of Samuel Thomson, an Ulster poet (1766- 1816). PhD thesis http://theses.gla.ac.uk/2664/ Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Fostering an Irish Writers’ Circle: a Revisionist Reading of the Life and Works of Samuel Thomson, an Ulster Poet (1766-1816) A thesis presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Scottish Literature at the University of Glasgow, December 2010 by Jennifer Orr © Jennifer Orr December 2010 Contents Acknowledgements i. Abstract ii. Abbreviations iii. Introduction 1-7 Chapter 1 The Patrons and the Pundits 8-40 Chapter 2 Revising Robert Burns for Ireland: Thomson and the Scottish Tradition 41-79 Chapter 3 ‘For you, wi’ all the pikes ye claim’: Patriotism, Politics and the Press 80-125 Chapter 4 ‘Here no treason lurks’ – Rehabilitating the Bard in the Wake of Union 1798-1801 126-174 Chapter 5 ‘‘Lowrie Nettle’ – Thomson and Satire 1799-1806 175-211 Chapter 6 Simple Poems? Radical Presbyterianism and Thomson’s final edition 1800-1816 212-251 Chapter 7 The Fraternal Knot – Fostering an Irish Romantic Circle 252-293 Conclusion 294-301 Bibliography 302-315 i Acknowledgements First and foremost, my sincere thanks to Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Fashion Artsp23 Camsay Street
    The rollercoaster of life, Jim love and personal tragedy Broadbent continues tells us about growing Camsay old Street profi tably A garden full of hats p31 and worms Artsp23 Fashionp18 Issue No 661 Friday October 12 2007 varsity.co.uk e Independent CambridgeStudent Newspaper since 1947 UNIVERSITY STATEMENT Rob Wallach, secretary of the senior tutors’ Dons respond to committee “There is no reason why students should fi nd themselves in such severe fi nancial diffi culty that they would have to resort to prostitution. However the University and Colleges are aware prostitution report that students can fi nd themselves in fi nancial diffi culty and give support where they can. There is a range of support mechanisms, including hard- » CUSU President calls national press coverage ‘ridiculous’ ship fund allowances and, as in all UK universities, a bursary scheme for » Former prostitute: advert in local newspaper got me started students from lower income families which has just been extended sub- stantially by the University. Katy Lee “We have no way of knowing whether News Editor various aspects of the article in Var- sity are in fact true. The claim that Varsity’s investigation last week ‘hundreds’ of students are involved is into how far Cambridge students highly unlikely and the result of pure will go to make money has provoked speculation. We are most concerned a concerned response from the Uni- by the report and College Senior Tu- versity and a storm of interest from tors would do everything they could the international press. to give support to students well be- The investigation found that fore any found themselves in such a almost one in twenty Cambridge situation.
    [Show full text]
  • The Adventure of Living
    The Adventure of Living John St. Loe Strachey The Adventure of Living Table of Contents The Adventure of Living..........................................................................................................................................1 John St. Loe Strachey.....................................................................................................................................1 PREFACE TO THE AMERICAN EDITION...............................................................................................3 POSTSCRIPT TO AMERICAN PREFACE.................................................................................................4 CHAPTER I. HOW I CAME TO THE SPECTATOR .............................................................................5 CHAPTER II. HOW I CAME TO THE SPECTATOR (Continued).......................................................9 CHAPTER III. MY PHYSICAL HOME, MY FAMILY, AND MY GOOD FORTUNE THEREIN........14 CHAPTER IV. MY FATHER.....................................................................................................................20 CHAPTER V. MY FATHER'S STORIES OF THE STRACHEY FAMILY.............................................27 CHAPTER VI. MY CHILDHOOD AND SOME PSYCHOLOGICAL INCIDENTS...............................35 CHAPTER VII. MY CHILDHOOD ( Continued)......................................................................................40 CHAPTER VIII. THE FAMILY NURSE...................................................................................................45
    [Show full text]
  • Osmond-Williams, Philippa (2019) Changing Scotland: a Social History of Love in the Life and Work of Edwin Morgan
    Osmond-Williams, Philippa (2019) Changing Scotland: A social history of love in the life and work of Edwin Morgan. PhD thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/75142/ Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Changing Scotland: A Social History of Love in the Life and Work of Edwin Morgan Philippa Osmond-Williams M.A. (Hons), M.Phil. Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Arts) Department of Scottish Literature School of Critical Studies College of Arts University of Glasgow June 2019 Abstract Examining love in the life and work of Edwin Morgan (1920-2010), this thesis argues that Morgan’s literary and artistic demonstrations of love inherently respond to the legal, political, and social changes of Scotland in the twentieth and twenty-first century. By mapping Morgan’s biographical contexts within Scotland’s wider social history and culture, the impact of the nation and its shifting attitudes on Morgan’s collected works is delineated. An examination of material only available to researchers, including Morgan’s correspondence and scrapbooks held in Archives and Special Collections at Glasgow University Library, supplements this comprehensive exploration of the significance of love in Morgan’s life and work.
    [Show full text]
  • Independent Commission on Freedom of Information
    Independent Commission on Freedom of Information Independent Commission on Freedom of Information: Responses from organisations to Call for Evidence: R – Z Contents The Radio Independents Group (RIG) .................................................................................................... 3 The Renewable Energy Foundation ........................................................................................................ 6 Reprieve ................................................................................................................................................10 Request Initiative ...................................................................................................................................16 The Royal Historical Society..................................................................................................................20 Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust .................................................................................................22 The Royal National Institute of Blind People (RNIB) .............................................................................24 The Royal Statistical Society (RSS) ......................................................................................................28 Russell Group of Universities ................................................................................................................29 Save FOI UK .........................................................................................................................................32
    [Show full text]
  • The Work and Play of Rhyme in Victorian Verse Cultures, 1850-1900 by Adam Martin Mazel a Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfi
    The Work and Play of Rhyme in Victorian Verse Cultures, 1850-1900 by Adam Martin Mazel A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (English Language and Literature) in the University of Michigan 2014 Doctoral Committee: Professor Yopie Prins, Chair Associate Professor Kali Israel Professor Marjorie Levinson Professor Adela Pinch Dedication To my Mom and Dad With Love ii Acknowledgments I am so grateful for Professor Yopie Prins, my dissertation chair, for helping me, for being patient with me, and for encouraging me throughout this project. The merits of my dissertation are largely due to her intellectual generosity. I am also particularly grateful for my wonderful dissertation committee: Professors Adela Pinch, Marjorie Levinson, and Kali Israel. They were always available when I needed support, and the generous time and energy they gave me fed the growth of this project and my growth as an intellectual. I also owe special thanks to Professor Kerry Larson, for helping the development of Chapter One, and Professor Sid Smith, as well as the Poetry and Poetics Workshop—Professor Gillian White and Professor Petra Kuppers and Julia Hansen and Aran Ruth—for helping the development of Chapter Four. To my writing group—the “A. B. C.’s of D.”: Ben Pollak and Carolyn Dekker—you are such a great team and great friends! I thank the members of my second writing group—Ben Graham, Tim Greene, and Sylvia Tita—as well as Paul Barron and Ray McDaniel of the Sweetland Writing Center, all of whom helped my writing considerably.
    [Show full text]
  • Mayor's March 2017 Appointments
    Mayor Rees’ Diary March 2017 Wed 1st March 09:15 Speak at South Multi Agency Network Meeting 09:45 Travel 10:30 Media: Sunday Times interview 11:00 Meeting Places for People re Dove Lane development 12:00 Travel including call placed to Global Parliament of Mayors’ team 12:30 Attend pre WECA Committee Meeting with Combined Authority Leaders 13:30 Attend WECA Committee Meeting 15:30 Travel 16:00 Meeting with Chair of Bristol Labour Party as Leader 16:30 Briefing re Second Big Housing Conversation 17:00 Meeting re Bristol Leadership Challenge 18:00 Attend Bristol City Youth Council Meeting Thu 2nd March 09:00 Attend Local Enterprise Partnership Nominations Committee 11:00 Travel 11:30 Meeting officers re Member Support Services 12:00 Meeting with Cabinet Member for Education and Skills 12:45 Meeting with Constitutional Working Group 13:30 Meeting with Chief Executive 14:00 Briefing on electrification delay on rail network 14:30 Briefing on Student Accommodation 15:30 Media: recording audio ahead of People, Places and Spaces conference 16:00 Regular HR team catch up 17:00 Follow up with local mosque imams re Clean Streets Campaign 18:00 Attend Second Big Housing Conversation M a y or’s Office Bristol City Council Marvin Rees Website PO Box 3176 Mayor of Bristol www.bristol.gov.uk Bristol BS3 9FS Fri 3rd March 08:00 Attend colleague engagement event ‘Hot Coffee, Hot Topics’ 09:00 Attend WECA Committee Member Briefing 10:00 Travel 10:30 School Visit to Easton Church of England Academy 11:00 Travel 11:45 Attend Bijan Ebrahimi Tree Planting
    [Show full text]
  • CELEBRATING 25 YEARS of EPIGRAM Spring 2014
    THE UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL MAGAZINE // SPRING 2014 CELEBRATING 25 YEARS OF EPIGRAM Spring 2014 Welcome Contents The Features nonesuch nonesuch 3 Spring 2014 ed to ed 7 Editors Hilary Brown The red nonesuch, Climate of opinion 10 Catherine Lee the ‘Flower of Bristol’, Lines of duty 17 Nick Riddle gave its colour to the Contributing Editors University’s academic Changing faces 22 Hannah Ford hoods and its name The continuing story 25 Freya Sterling to the University’s first Managing Editors student magazine, David Alder // Director of Marketing and The Bristol 5 Communications Nonesuch, in 1911. 7 Jill Cartwright // Nonesuch, in its Head of Public An editor is born current magazine Relations Office Tania Jane Rawlinson // form, was first Director of Campaigns published in 1991 for and Alumni Relations ‘all those who share a Contact common interest in the Many happy returns to Epigram – Bristol’s student [email protected] University of Bristol’. +44 (0)117 394 1046 newspaper – which is celebrating its 25th anniversary (Campaigns and Alumni this year. Relations Office) +44 (0)117 928 8895 I hope you enjoy reading about Bristol University and journalism, and then (Public Relations Office) take up your own pen or keyboard. Denis Burn (BSc 1975), Bristol’s Chair of Design Council, is seeking alumni, staff, student and Court members’ views about pelotondesign.co.uk the University’s future. Produced by News Public Relations Office Alumni responses now will inform the search for the University’s next Senate House Tyndall Avenue Vice-Chancellor, who will take over from Professor Sir Eric Thomas Latest from Bristol 2 Bristol BS8 1TH (Hon LLD 2004) in autumn 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • A L U M N I a L U M
    U n i v e r s i t y o f B r i s t o l B o a t C l u b A L U M N I C h r i s t m a s 2 0 1 6 Welcome to the pre-Christmas read you knew you wanted. From the philosophy of life and how to find a job having pulled a blade, through to the rise of the UBBC women and a Palaeolithic coach, this edition has the lot. The Club is to be congratulated on their achievements and competitiveness It is a settling in period for the (newish) Vice Chancellor and an increasing realisation that a complete education and preparation for life after academia includes sport. Ask the question of where the fondest memories lie and the longest lessons learnt, more often than not the boat house will feature. Perhaps you could share these for the next edition? There is no getting away from Henley Royal Regatta as a focus for heartbreak and heroics and so it is right that we laud the 1991 crew. Champagne in the boat The Flower of Bristol tents was a memorable highlight of HRR 2016 - along with those umpiring The Lychnis Chalcedonica has been When UBBC's Alumni first began racing moments. associated with the city and people of in the late 00's Nonesuch BC was the Bristol since the 1600's. The dye this vivid racing name adopted (Concorde ‘go little flower produced amazed supersonic or explode' BC being a close You can look forward to some stellar contemporary commentators more used runner up).
    [Show full text]