<<

Key Issues Report

Notice of Requirement and Resource Consent applications for the Project Transport Authority, City Council, and Transpower NZ Limited

Greater Regional Council

Commissioned by the Environmental Protection Authority under Section 149G(3) of the Resource Management Act

6 September 2011

Report Author Date Tracey Grant Team Leader

Contributor Date Richard Percy Senior Resource Advisor

Peer Reviewer Date Alistair Cross Manager, Environment Regulation

Contents

1. Purpose 1

2. Terms 1

3. Scope 1

4. Relevant plan provisions 2

5. Summary of Consents 15

6. Activity status of all proposed activities 17

7. Confirmation of the status and weighting of any relevant regional policy statement, and or relevant plan 17

8. Permitted baseline 18

9. Any other key issues 21

Appendices Appendix A - Plan Change – Draft Decision wording of Policies

Appendix B – National Environmental Standards

Appendix C - Permitted activities – Wellington Regional Council Plans

Appendix D – Active resource consents

Appendix E – Approximate location of resource consents

Appendix F - Pending resource consents

1 PURPOSE

1.1 To prepare a report pursuant to section 149G(3) of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the Act) to contextualise the Transmission Gully proposal (TGP) within GW‘s planning framework and instruments and to identify any key issues.

2 TERMS Act Resource Management Act 1991 EPA Environmental Protection Authority GW Greater Wellington Regional Council KCDC District Council NES-AQ National Environmental Standards for Air Quality NES-DW National Environmental Standards for Sources of Human Drinking Water NOR Notices of Requirement NPSET National Policy Statement on Electricity Transmission NPSFM National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management NPSREG National Policy Statement for Renewable Electricity Generation NZCPS New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 NZTA New Zealand Transport Authority PCC Porirua City Council Plan Change NZTA Plan Change on Regional Freshwater Plan lodged 6 September 2011 pRPS Proposed Regional Policy Statement for the RAMP Regional Air Quality Management Plan for the Wellington Region RFP Regional Freshwater Plan for the Wellington Region RPS Regional Policy Statement for the Wellington Region RSP Regional Soil Plan for the Wellington Region TGP Transmission Gully Proposal UHCC Upper Hutt City Council WCC

3 SCOPE

3.1 This report identifies the key issues that arise in relation to the proposal, as they relate to the land and matters within GW‘s jurisdiction, including

(a) any relevant provisions of a national policy statement, a New Zealand coastal policy statement, a regional policy statement or proposed regional policy statement, and a plan or proposed plan; and

(b) a statement on whether all required resource consents in relation to the proposal to which the matter relates have been applied for; and

(c) if applicable, the activity status of all proposed activities in relation to the matter.

(d) confirmation of the status, and weighting if proposed, of any relevant regional policy statement, and or relevant plan; and

(e) detail of the permitted baseline and existing environment for the resource consents applied for within GW including:

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 24

The permitted baseline, and details of any resource consents held in the area that form the existing environment within GW‘s jurisdiction.

Comment on whether the proposed consents applied for within GW jurisdiction will affect any relevant existing consent holder‘s ability to implement their existing consents should the proposed consents be granted.

Any other matter which is relevant to the key issues associated with the applications.

3.2 This report is not in the nature of a submission on the proposal, and does not advocate for a particular outcome.

3.3 While this report may comment on draft conditions it is not within the scope of this report to provide a detailed assessment of the proposed/draft conditions.

3.4 This report does not cover any Key Issues with regard to Transpower Transmission Line Relocation project. The applications relate solely to consents required by territorial authorities, and no regional council consents have been applied for as part of this application.

4 RELEVANT PLAN PROVISIONS

4.1 The following statutory documents and provisions are considered relevant to TGP:

National Policy Statements

Regional Policy Statements

District Plans

National Environmental Standards

Others

To avoid unnecessary duplication I have referred to the applicants statutory assessment, and provided further detail if considered necessary.

4.2 National Policy Statements

4.2.1 New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 (NZCPS)

The NZCPS came into effect on 3 December 2010. It provides policies to achieve the purpose of the Act in relation to the coastal environment. Policies in the NZCPS address the coastal marine area and the wider coastal environment. The coastal marine area is land, water and air below mean high water springs. TGP does not directly encroach into the coastal marine area, or directly discharge into the coastal marine area, however the marine environment is the ultimate receiving environment for sediment laden water from construction of the project, and stormwater runoff from road surfaces from the operation of the project (refer Section 9.2 below). I therefore concur with the applicants comments in Section 32.4.2 of the application documents that the NZCPS is a relevant consideration.

PAGE 2 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

The coastal environment includes the coastal marine area but its landward boundary is not clearly defined, although criteria on its extent and characteristics are identified in Policy 1 of the NZCPS. It is difficult to provide clear guidance on whether the proposal will have a direct or indirect impact on the coastal environment.

NZCPS contains 7 objectives and 29 policies. A full copy of the NZCPS and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail at: http://www.doc.govt.nz/publications/conservation/marine-and-coastal/new- zealand-coastal-policy-statement/new-zealand-coastal-policy-statement-2010/.

All the objectives are considered relevant to TGP. They are summarised as follows:

Safeguarding and sustaining the coastal environment (Objective 1);

Preserve natural character and protecting natural features and landscapes (Objective 2);

Taking account of the Treaty of Waitangi and recognising Tangata whenua as kaitiaki (Objective 3);

Maintaining and enhancing public open space and recreation opportunities (Objective 4);

Managing coastal hazard risks (Objective 5);

Enabling people and communities to provide for their social, economic and cultural wellbeing through subdivision, use and development in the coastal environment (Objective 6); and

Ensuring compliance with New Zealand‘s international obligations (Objective 7).

The relevant policies of the NZCPS for this proposal are detailed in Section 32.4.2 of the application. Policies that are relevant to this proposal are: Policies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 11, 15, 18, 21, 22 and 23.

I note that Section 32.4.2 does not identify the following policies: 3, 5, 11, 15 and 18.

I consider Policy 3 to be relevant, as it stresses the need to adopt a precautionary approach towards proposed activities whose effects on the coastal environment are „uncertain, unknown, or little understood, but potentially significantly adverse‟. The applicants have undertaken investigations on the , in particular the processes within the Inlet, and have modelled the likely impact of the proposal on the coastal environment (Technical Reports 11, 14, and 15). Due to the size of the proposal, and the stage of detailed design, there is always an element of uncertainty, and the effects on the Harbour have the potential to be significant – particularly in extreme weather events.

Policy 5 is relevant as it covers land or waters managed or held under other Acts – including any acts for conservation or protection purposes. Pauatahanui Inlet is listed in the Wellington Conservation Management Strategy 1996 which was

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 3 OF 24

prepared under the Conservation Act 1987. The Strategy recognises the importance of the Inlet.

I consider Policy 11 is relevant. Policy 11 refers to the need to protect indigenous biological diversity in the coastal environment. The Horokiri, Ration and lower Pauatahanui Streams are recognised in Policy 4.2.10 of the RFP as having a High Degree of Natural Character. These streams drain into the Pauatahanui Inlet which has many of the characteristics listed in Policy 11. The applicants have investigated the likely impacts of TGP on the coastal environment, and the results are found in Technical Reports 10, 11 and 15.

Policy 15 refers to the need to protect natural features and landscapes of the coastal environment from inappropriate development. If the proposal is considered to be within the coastal environment, it is a matter for the Board to decide whether this represents appropriate or otherwise development in the coastal environment.

Policy 18 recognises the need for public open space within and adjacent to the coastal marine area. This includes ensuring that the location and treatment of public open space is compatible with the natural character, natural features and landscapes, and amenity values of the coastal environment. If it is considered that the TGP traverses the coastal environment, or is visible from the coastal environment, this policy may be relevant.

4.2.2 National Policy Statement on Electricity Transmission (NPSET)

The NPSET was Gazetted on 13 March 2008. It addresses the need to operate, maintain, develop and upgrade electricity transmission networks. Its policies recognise the national benefits of electricity transmission, manage the environmental effects of electricity transmission, manage the adverse effects of third parties on the transmission network, require territorial authorities to map the electricity transmission network, and require decision makers (including regional councils) to provide for long-term strategic planning of transmission assets.

The proposal involves the relocation of transmission lines. Transpower has lodged a Notice of Requirement (NOR) for this work. No regional council consents have been applied for as part of the transmission line relocation project yet. It is understood that NZTA have been working closely with Transpower on the effect of TGP on the existing transmission lines.

4.2.3 National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management (NPSFM)

The NPSFM came into effect on 1 July 2011 and sets out the objectives and policies for freshwater management in accordance with the Act. It is relevant to TGP because of the proposed direct and indirect effects on waterways in the area.

NPSFM contains 8 objectives and 13 policies. A full copy of the NPSFM can be viewed in detail at: http://www.mfe.govt.nz/publications/rma/nps-freshwater- management-2011/index.html.

The objectives considered most relevant to TGP are summarised as follows:

Safeguarding the life-supporting capacity of freshwater (Objective A1);

PAGE 4 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Maintaining or improving the overall quality of freshwater (Objective A2);

Sustainably managing the taking, using, damming, or diverting of freshwater (Objective B1);

Protecting significant values of wetlands (Objective B4);

Ensuring that the values and interests of Tangata whenua are identified and reflected in the management of freshwater (Objective D1).

The staged implementation programme set out by the NPSFM is summarised in Section 32.2.1 of the application.

Policy A4 requires consent authorities when considering an application for a discharge, to have regard to the extent to which the discharge would avoid contamination that will have an adverse effect on the life-supporting capacity of fresh water including on any ecosystem associated with fresh water and the extent to which it is feasible and dependable that any more than minor adverse effect on fresh water, and on any ecosystem associated with fresh water, resulting from the discharge would be avoided.

TGP involves large scale earthworks which have the potential to adversely effect the receiving environment. The application includes an assessment of the likely effects on water quality from discharges, and the likely ecological effects in Technical Reports 9, 10, 11 and 15.

Policy B4 requires consent authorities when considering an application, to have regard to the extent to which the change would adversely affect safeguarding the life-supporting capacity of fresh water and of any associated ecosystem and the extent to which it is feasible and dependable that any adverse effect on the life-supporting capacity of fresh water and of any associated ecosystem resulting from the change would be avoided.

TGP involves large scale earthworks that will discharge sediment laden water into streams. TGP also involves a concrete batching plant, which will discharge onto land where it may enter water. Policy B4 is relevant because of the possible effect these discharges may have on the life supporting capacity on streams in the vicinity of the proposal.

The applicants have provided an assessment against this policy in Section 32.2.2 of the application and have assessed the likely effects in Technical Reports 9, 10, 11 and 15.

Objective D1 and Policy D1 of the NPSFM provides for the involvement of and hapu in the management of freshwater resources. The applicants have provided an assessment against this objective and policy in Section 32.2.3 of their application. Section 10.7.1 of the application summarises the involvement of tangata whenua in the process and a Cultural Impact Assessment has been provided in Technical Report 18. The Cultural Impact Assessment report was used to inform Chapter 24 of the application which includes the areas of cultural significance to tangata whenua in the area.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 5 OF 24

4.2.4 Other National Policy Statements

The Proposed National Policy Statement on Indigenous Biodiversity was released in January 2011. Because it is proposed only, and has not been approved, it is not relevant to the consideration of this application.

The National Policy Statement for Renewable Electricity Generation (NPSREG) came into effect on 13 May 2011. It seeks to ensure a consistent approach is undertaken to planning for renewable electricity generation in New Zealand. The NPSREG is not considered to be relevant to the current TGP. As noted in Section 3.4 above, the transmission line relocation project does not fall within the ambit of consents applied for under regional council jurisdiction. Though as noted in the draft decision for the Plan Change (refer Section 4.5 below), the NPSREG does include reference to the offset which may be of limited benefit to the Board.

4.3 Regional Policy Statements

There is an operative regional policy statement (RPS) and a proposed regional policy statement (pRPS) for the Wellington Region. TGP falls entirely within the Wellington Region. In Section 32.7 of the application documents it states that the pRPS is considered to carry greater weight than the RPS. Because there are outstanding appeals on the pRPS, both the RPS and pRPS remain relevant. The relevant objectives and policies of both documents are summarised below:

4.3.1 Operative Wellington Regional Policy Statement (RPS)

The RPS for the Wellington region was made operative in May 1995

The RPS contains a number of objectives and policies that apply region-wide. Chapters of most relevance to TGP are:

Iwi Environmental Management System (Chapter 4);

Freshwater (Chapter 5);

Soils and Minerals (Chapter 6);

Coastal Environment (Chapter 7);

Air (Chapter 8);

Ecosystems (Chapter 9);

Landscape (Chapter 10);

Natural Hazards (Chapter 11); and

Built Environment and Transportation (Chapter 14).

While there are a number of broad objectives and policies, no objectives or polices specifically refer to TGP.

The relevant objectives and policies of the RPS for this proposal are summarised in Technical Report 21 of the application. Objectives and policies that can be considered relevant to this proposal are:

PAGE 6 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Iwi (Objectives 2 and 3 and Policies 2 and 4);

Freshwater (Objectives 2 and 3 and Policies 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 101, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16);

Soils and Minerals (Objectives 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 and Policies 1, 3, 6, 8 and 9);

Coastal Environment (Objectives 1 and 3 and Policies 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7);

Air (Objectives 1, 3 and 4 and Policies 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12)

Ecosystems (Objectives 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 and Policies 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9 and 10);

Landscape (Objectives 1, 2, 3 and 4 and Policies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8);

Natural Hazards (Objective 1 and Policies 1, 2 and 4); and

Built Environment (Objectives 1, 2 and 3 and Policies 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 8).

A full copy of the RPS and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail at:

http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/importedfiles/1566_regionalpolicyst_s3033.pdf.

I note that Technical Report 21 identifies Freshwater Objective 1 as being relevant. Objective 1 is that the quantity of fresh water meets the range of uses and values for which it is required, safeguards its life supporting capacity, and has the potential to meet the reasonably foreseeable needs of future generations. Though the proposal has the potential to affect the quality of water in the catchment, the applicants are not applying for any consents for taking water. Therefore Freshwater Objective 1 is not considered relevant. I do note, however, that the applicants are proposing to impound water in Duck Creek during storm events. The applicants have advised that there is a predicted 2% increase in peak flows as a result of this proposal, however, this is expected to be mitigated by restricting the flow of the stream (page 89 Technical Report 14). Therefore quantity of water is not considered an issue in this instance. Likewise with Policies 1,2 and 3 – the applicants are not applying for any consents associated with the use of freshwater (including groundwater).

I note that Technical Report 21 has not identified a number of policies that are considered relevant. These are Freshwater Policy 16, Soils and Minerals Policies 6 and 9, Coastal Policies 2 and 3, Air Objective 4, Policies 7, 8, 9, Landscape Policy 8, Natural Hazards Policy 4. These are summarised below.

Freshwater Policy 16 is considered relevant as it covers access to and along water bodies. It recognises that through changes in land use, there are likely to be

1 I note that in the explanation of Policy 10 it explans that the policy is to provide protection for the listed sites, but not to exclude protection of regional significance that have not been identified. The Pauatahanui inlet is considered to be covered by this.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 7 OF 24

situations where existing access points (to water) are sought to be removed or altered. The proposal involves extensive piping and/ or realignment to watercourses. It also traverses through regional parks and other areas which serve as public access to watercourses. The applicants have assessed the effects of the proposal on public access in section 27.3.3 of the application.

Soils and Minerals Policy 6 is to avoid, remedy or mitigate the adverse effects of harmful waste and contaminants on soil, and to dispose of these in ways which respect the assimilative capacity of the soil and which comply with relevant standards set for water quality and air quality. As detailed in Technical Report 16, TGP traverses through a number of contaminated sites. This includes the Porirua Gun Club. The methods proposed to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects associated with the disturbance of contaminated sites, has been provided in Technical Report 16. Conditions have been proposed that intend to finalise the handling of contamination through a Contaminated Land Management Plan (Proposed condition G15 – refer Section 9.5 below regarding draft conditions).

Soils and Minerals Policy 9 is to ensure, when planning for and making decisions on new subdivision, use and development on Class I and Class II land (as defined by the Land Use Capability Survey), that there is a net benefit to the local community which includes consideration of environmental standards, the needs of future generations, and any matters of significance for the Region. TGP traverses through land covered by this Policy, and therefore the policy is considered relevant.

Coastal Environment Policy 2 is to consider, where relevant and to the appropriate extent… the degree to which the proposed activity will impose effects additional to those resulting from existing subdivision, use and development, and the extent to which such cumulative adverse effects on natural character may be avoided, remedied or mitigated… Coastal Environment Policy 3 is to restore and rehabilitate the natural character of the coastal environment where appropriate. As discussed above, TGP may impact on the coastal environment. The applicants have discussed this issue in Chapter 20 and Technical Report 15 of the application.

Air Objective 3 is that the output of gases which potentially promote climate change is at a level which is consistent with central government climate change policy. The proposal is for a roading project and therefore this objective is relevant. The applicants have assessed air quality effects in Technical Report 13.

Air Policies 7, 8 and 9 are as follows:

To promote the use of energy sources and transport fuels that are low or non-polluting of the atmosphere (Policy 7);

To avoid, remedy or mitigate the adverse effects of local and global air pollution on human health (Policy 8);

To promote measures that achieve a net reduction in the emission of greenhouse gases and ozone depleting human substances (Policy 9)

As summarised above, the proposal is for a roading project that will result in changes in transport patterns for many individuals. This may impact (either positively or negatively) on air pollution. The applicants have provided an

PAGE 8 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

assessment of air quality effects in Technical Report 13 and concluded that the effects will not be significant.

Landscape Policy 8 is to promote, on behalf of future generations, the protection of the potential for recreation of open space, indigenous and exotic vegetation, water bodies, the coast, and regionally outstanding landscapes, and any other regionally or nationally outstanding natural features. TGP traverses regional parks and water bodies, and ultimately any discharge into the watercourses will discharge into the coastal marine area – including the Pauatahanui Inlet. It is considered this policy is relevant for all these reasons. The applicants have discussed the effects on landscapes, waterbodies etc. throughout the application. This is also an area that will be considered as part of the city council Key Issue Reports (refer Section 4.6 below).

Natural Hazards Policy 4 is to ensure that human activities which modify the environment only change the probability and magnitude of natural hazard events where these changes have been explicitly recognised and accepted. The application identifies the hazards associated with the proposal in Section 6.4 of the application. This includes earthquakes and storms. These are discussed further in Technical Report 13.

4.3.2 Proposed Wellington Regional Policy Statement (pRPS)

As summarised above, the pRPS was notified in March 2009 and a decision was released in May 2010. There are a total of eight appeals that cover a wide range of matters lodged with the Environment Court on the pRPS. The status of the appeals may well change prior to the Board hearing TGP, and therefore an update may be required at the time of the hearing.

The pRPS contains a number of objectives and policies that apply region-wide. In addition it includes objectives and policies on regionally significant infrastructure. The meaning of regionally significant infrastructure incorporates the Strategic Transport Network, as defined in the Wellington Regional Land Transport Strategy. TGP is identified as being part of the Region‘s Strategic Transport Network, hence TGP is regarded as regionally significant infrastructure under the pRPPs. In addition, the pRPS specifically refers to the importance of the Pauatahanui Inlet and directs councils with jurisdiction to recognise the importance of the inlet.

A full copy of the pRPS and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail: http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/Plans--Publications/Regional-Policy- Statement/Proposed-RPS-May-2010-Incorporating-changes-from-Decision.pdf.

The following sections are considered most relevant to TGP:

Air Quality (Section 3.1);

Coastal environment (including public access) (Section 3.2);

Energy, infrastructure and waste (Section 3.3);

Freshwater (including public access) (Section 3.4);

Historic heritage (Section 3.5);

Indigenous ecosystems (Section 3.6);

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 9 OF 24

Landscape (Section 3.7);

Natural hazards (Section 3.8);

Regional form, design and function (Section 3.9);

Resource management with tangata whenua (Section 3.10); and

Soils and minerals (Section 3.11).

The relevant objectives and policies of the pRPS for this proposal are summarised in Technical Report 21 of the application.

I note that Technical Report 21 has not identified a number of policies that I consider relevant, and does not reflect the recent changes to the pRPS. These policies (including recent changes) are summarised below:

Policy 5A – recognises the regional significance of the Porirua Harbour (including Pauatahanui Inlet and Onepoto Arm). Porirua Harbour is the ultimate receiving environment for TGP and therefore this policy is relevant;

Policy 6 – has been amended to recognize the benefits from regionally significant infrastructure. As discussed above, TGP can be considered regionally significant, and therefore Policy 6 is relevant;

Policies 34 – 37 – regarding the preservation of natural character and safeguarding the life supporting capacity of coastal ecosystems, is also considered relevant due to the potential impact TGP may have on the inlet;

Policy 46 – managing effects on indigenous ecosystems and habitats with significant indigenous biodiversity values.

4.4 Regional Plans

4.4.1 Regional Freshwater Plan for the Wellington Region (RFP)

The RFP came into effect on 17 December 1999. Since that time there have been four plan changes – three of which have been approved and form part of the RFP. The fourth plan change relates to the proposed Transmission Gully Plan Change. This is discussed further in Section 4.5 below.

A full copy of the RFP and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail:http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/Plans--Publications/Regional-Freshwater- Plan/3866_RFPFreshwaterPla_s7744.pdf

The RFP applies to all freshwater in the Wellington region, including water in streams, lakes, wetlands, aquifers and rivers. The RFP applies to all types of activities that use freshwater or that are in the beds of rivers and lakes. It is relevant to TGP due to the proposed stream works, and the proposed discharges to watercourses.

PAGE 10 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Objectives and policies relevant to TGP are identified in Technical Report 21. The following additional policies are also considered relevant:

Water Quality Policy 5.2.16 – To minimise the adverse effects of accidental spills on water quality. The application involves the use of chemical flocculation for treatment of sediment laden discharges and discharges from a concrete batching plant. During construction the application will also involve a large number of machinery on site, and potentially fuel storage areas. The use of flocculation, batching plant substances, fuel storage and machinery, all will require careful management to ensure no accidental spills occur.

Use of Rivers Policy 7.2.10 – To ensure that all structures in or on the beds of rivers and lakes which are visible are adequately maintained so that the structure is safe and any adverse effects on the visual amenity of the area are minimised. This policy is relevant due to the large amount of piping, bridges, and stilling basins etc.. proposed within the watercourses.

Use of Rivers Policy 7.2.14 – To ensure that the deliberate introduction of plants to a river or lake bed for… habitat restoration … will not result in the displacement of desirable species which are already present. Mitigation planting is proposed as part of TGP and this policy is therefore relevant.

I note that Technical Report 21 also identifies the following policies as being relevant. I do not consider this is the case for the reasons summarised:

General Objective 4.2.14 – mitigation of trout habitat in areas identified in Appendix 4. The streams affected are not listed in Appendix 4.

General Objective 4.2.15 – water bodies identified in Appendix 5. The streams affected are not listed in Appendix 5.

Water Quality Policy 5.2.3 – management of areas identified in Appendix 4. The streams affected are not listed in Appendix 4.

Water Quantity Objective 6.1.2 – relating to the taking and use of groundwater. The applicants are not applying for any consents associated with groundwater abstraction or use.

Water Quantity Policy 6.2.1 – relating to the allocation of water and flows in the river. The applicants are not applying for any consents associated with abstraction of water, and are not applying for any consents associated with damming.

4.4.2 Regional Air Quality Management Plan for the Wellington Region (RAMP)

The RAMP came into effect on 8 May 2000. Since that time there has been one plan change which was made operative.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 11 OF 24

A full copy of the RAMP and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail: http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/Plans--Publications/Regional-Air-Quality- Management-Plan/737airplans1383.pdf.

The RAMP applies to all discharges to air in the Wellington region, except in the coastal marine area. Because TGP requires resource consent for an air discharge associated with the concrete batching plant, the RAMP contains a various objectives and policies relevant to TGP.

All the objectives and policies relevant to TGP are listed in Technical Report 21.

4.4.3 Regional Plan for Discharges to Land for the Wellington Region (DLP)

The DLP came into effect on 17 December 1999. Since that time there has been one plan change which was made operative.

A full copy of the DLP and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail: http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/Plans--Publications/Plan-for-discharges- to-Land/741dtlplans1389.pdf.

The DLP applies to the whole of the Wellington region and identifies objectives and policies so that discharges to land can be sustainably managed. TGP requires resource consents for the discharges of sediment laden water to land (from sediment retention ponds). Consent is also being obtained for discharging contaminants to land from a concrete batching plant.

Technical Report 21 lists relevant objectives and policies associated with the proposed discharge from sediment ponds. It is noted, however, that Technical Report 21 and Section 32.11 of the application do not refer to the need for consent for the proposed discharges from the concrete batching plant. As discussed in Section 5.6, it is unclear whether the discharge is proposed to occur to land or to water, however, the section of the act identified in Table 3.3 relates to discharge to land, therefore the DLP is considered relevant.

The relevant objectives and policies of the DLP have been identified and discussed in regard to the discharge from the ponds. It is considered the following objectives and policies are also considered relevant for the concrete batching plant discharge:

Objectives 4.1.5, 4.1.7 and 4.1.8

Policies 4.2.19, 4.2.24, 4.2.27, 4.2.28, 4.2.30, 4.2.31, 4.2.35 and 4.2.41

I note that the application also involves contaminated sites. The applicants have advised that no consent is required under GW jurisdiction, for works associated with the contaminated material.

4.4.4 Regional Soil Plan for the Wellington Region (RSP)

The RSP came into effect on 9 October 2000. Since that time there has been one plan change which was made operative.

A full copy of the RSP and relevant objectives and policies can be viewed in detail: http://www.gw.govt.nz/assets/Plans--Publications/Regional-Soil- Plan/722_soil_s1365.pdf.

PAGE 12 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

The RSP applies to the whole Wellington region, except the coastal marine area. It covers the effects of soil disturbance and vegetation clearance. The RSP is of relevance to TGP because of the large amount of roading and tracking that is proposed, as well as the forestry removal that is required.

Technical Report 21 identifies the objectives and policies of RSP relevant to TGP. The following additional policies are also considered relevant:

Objectives 4.1.1- 4.1.3 – these are general objectives regarding maintaining the potential for the soil and its life supporting capacity. Given the volume of earthworks, and the fill sites proposed, these are considered relevant to TGP.

Policy 4.2.2 – regarding locating activity on soils of low versatility where possible. This is considered relevant for TGP in particular the fill sites.

4.4.5 Regional Coastal Plan for the Wellington Region (RCP)

As stated in Section 32.10 of the application, the proposal does not require any resource consents in accordance with the RCP. It is acknowledged, however, that the proposal does have the potential to influence the coastal marine area through discharges during construction and ongoing discharges during operation of the road.

Section 32.10 of the application lists the Objectives and Policies relevant to TGP.

4.5 NZTA plan change – RFP

On 6 September 2010, NZTA lodged a request for changes to the RFP with the EPA. The request sought changes to existing policies, the insertion of a new policy and two new definitions into the RFP. NZTA indicated in the accompanying documentation that the changes were intended to better enable the consideration of future resource consents under the RFP for NZTA‘s TGP.

Following a submission and hearing process the Board of Inquiry released a draft decision in August 2011. A full copy of the draft decision can be viewed at: http://www.epa.govt.nz/Resource-management/tgpc/Pages/report-and- decision.aspx.

The draft decision has been provided to NZTA, GW, WCC, PCC, UHCC, KCDC, the submitters and the Minister for the Environment. These parties are invited to provide comments on minor or technical aspects of the report. Comments close on 23 September. They will then be considered by the Board before the Board makes the final Decision. The Board is expected to provide its final report to the EPA in October 2011.

The decision on the plan change will affect the wording of existing Policies 4.2.10, 7.2.1 and 7.2.2 and will result in the insertion of new Policy 4.2.33A. In the draft decision, the Board found that:

The Freshwater Plan in its present form potentially precludes consideration of the merits of any resource consent applications for TGP in accordance with s104 as a consequence of the operation of s104D due to the lack of flexibility in the relevant policies;

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 13 OF 24

Changing the RFP to include provision for a wider range of management methods than just avoidance of adverse effects is the appropriate option to achieve sustainable management of the water bodies and allow consideration of resource consent applications for TGP on their merits…

The wording of these policies (as they appear in the draft decision) is contained in Appendix A. The final decision will influence the assessment of TGP against Policies 4.2.10, 7.2.1 and 7.2.2.

4.6 District Plans

TGP traverses through 4 territorial authorities. These are under the jurisdiction of Kapiti Coast District Council (KCDC), Upper Hutt City Council (UHCC), Porirua City Council (PCC) and Wellington City Council (WCC). The applicants have provided an assessment against the District Plans in Technical Report 21.

While the relevance of these plans is recognised, I have not provided an assessment of the key issues of the proposal on these plans because representatives from the respective territorial authorities are also writing Key Issue Reports.

4.7 Relevant National Environmental Standards

4.7.1 National Environmental Standards for Air Quality (NES -AQ)

NES-AQ were gazetted in September 2004. The standards are relevant to TGP due to the proposed air discharge from the concrete batching plant, rock crushing activities, dust during construction and ongoing air discharges from operation of the road.

The applicants have applied for a discharge to air permit associated with the concrete batching plant and therefore s14(2) of the NES-AQ is relevant (refer Appendix B).

An assessment of TGP in relation to the NES-AQ is provided in Section 32.14 of the application.

4.7.2 National Environmental Standards for Sources of Human Drinking Water (NES – DW)

NES-DW came into effect on 20 June 2008. Its purpose is intended to reduce the risk of contaminating drinking water sources such as rivers and groundwater. It is relevant to TGP because of the bulk earthworks and streamworks that are proposed and the potential for these activities and associated discharges to impact on drinking water sources.

The applicants have identified the relevant provisions of NES-DW in Technical Report 21 of the application. As shown in Section 5.3 below, there are no existing resource consents for water takes for drinking purposes immediately downstream of TGP. I do note, however, that Rule 7 of the RFP provides for the minor abstractions of fresh water as a permitted activity subject to conditions (refer Section 8.2.4 below). It is therefore possible that drinking water takes occur in the catchments affected by TGP. GW does not hold records of water takes undertaken as a permitted activity.

PAGE 14 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

4.8 Other legislation

The applicants have provided an extensive list of relevant legislation and other matters in Section 4.9 of the application documents.

5 SUMMARY OF CONSENTS

5.1 Twenty resource consents have been lodged with the EPA pursuant to Sections 87 to 139 of the Act for this application. All the consents fall within Greater Wellington jurisdiction. A table of the consents applied for is included in Table 3.3 (pg 54) of the application and a helpful summary has been provided in Table 3.2 page 53 of the application.

5.2 Table 3.3 is considered to be a comprehensive list of all necessary resource consent applications for the proposal, with 3 possible exceptions. The possible exceptions are outlined in Sections 5.3 – 5.5 below. In addition it is considered that further information could be provided on two additional applications to help clarify what is being applied for. These are outlined in Sections 5.6 and 5.7 below.

5.3 Piping, reclamation and diversion associated with fill sites.

Section 8.9.3 of the application describes the proposed fill sites for the project. This involves approximately 510 000m3 of fill in 6 potential locations.

Page 186 of the application states that ‗the four sites around the Kenepuru Interchange contain existing streams, most of which are ephemeral. Subsoil drains will be aligned at the base of these fill sites. Following completion of works water will either drain around the edge of the fill area or across the surface‘. Land use consent for reclamation has been applied for approximately 870m of subsoil drains associated with the proposed Kenepuru fill sites (RC11).

One proposed fill site appears to be located over several waterways and truncates the catchment above the fill site. This fill site is located between bridges 22 and 23 (refer plan GM20). Piping/reclamation of the streams associated with this fill site (in accordance with Section 13(1)(a) of the Act) does not appear to be applied for or included in the list of culverts (Schedule A or Table 7.6).

I consider that further information on the fill sites (particularly the fill site located between bridges 22 and 23) is necessary for the Board to identify whether the appropriate consents are being sought, and also to confirm whether the assessed effects and mitigation account for any stream loss due to proposed fill sites.

5.4 Damming/Diversion of flood flow

Section 19.5.4 of the AEE states that mitigation for the potential flood risk on Duck Creek is proposed by ‗reducing the size of particular culverts so they store water upstream during … Q50 and Q100 events. .. Both upstream storage options would involve temporary inundation of parts of the Duck Creek valley on land owned by GWRC‘.

Managing downstream flows by reducing the size of culverts allows control of downstream flood levels by reducing peak flow rates to that predicted to occur prior to the proposed development.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 15 OF 24

‗Damming‘ is not defined in RFP or in the Act.

Damming (in accordance with Rule 16 and Rule 17 of the RFP) does not exclude dams that are formed by culverts. Consents have been granted previously in the Wellington region for pipes that will impound a significant amount of water during storm events.

The application does not include detail on the extent and depth of flooding, and it is not clear to the reader how much impoundment will occur and how long water will be impounded for.

The Board may wish to seek this information, in order to assess whether consents are required in relation to damming and diversion of flood flows in accordance with Rule 16 or Rule 17 of the GW Regional Freshwater Plan.

I note that paragraph 27 of the TGP plan change draft decision (refer Section 4.5 above) states ‗The consents required will include land use consents under s13 to carry out activities within waterways and consents to dam and divert and discharge to water‟ (emphasis added).

5.5 Reclamation and diversions associated with permanent piping of streams

The applicants have applied for consents for the piping (in accordance with Section 13(1)(a)) and realignment of streams (including reclamation and diversion) in accordance with Section 13(1)(e) and s14(1). Technical Report 18 states that ‗the totals have taken account of the length of watercourse that is eliminated when straight culverts remove meandering stream sections. This quantity has been added to the total stream habitat affected‘ (page 88, Technical Report 18). Clarification of the wording of consents for reclamation and diversion (in accordance with s13(1)(e) and s 14(1) of the Act) to make it explicit that the applicants are applying for reclamations and diversions associated with the placement of pipes in streams is helpful in defining the scope of consent.

I note that the use, placement and erection of temporary culverts (RC14) is being applied for in accordance with s13(1)(a). Given that it is the intention that culverts will be placed in existing stream channels, and the channels will be filled such that the land above the pipe can be used, it can therefore be said that the bed has been retrieved, covered and/or brought under cultivation (Oxford English Dictionary definition) and therefore it is considered that the land has been reclaimed. It is not clear whether the consents applied for cover the reclamation and diversion associated with the temporary culverts.

5.6 Concrete batching plant

NZTA is applying for two consents associated with the concrete batching plant – RC15 and RC16 (refer page 58 of the application).

Very little information has been provided with respect to these consents, with much of the information proposed to be provided as conditions of consent (CBP 1 -38 on pages 539 – 542). Section 8.3.1 and 20.4.4 of the application provides an outline of the concrete batching plant, however, does not provide any detail on size of the plant and quantities of discharge involved.

I consider that further detail on the plant, the size of the plant and the quantities involved (in processing, and corresponding discharges) prior to any consent being granted will assist the Board in determining the scale of effects from the

PAGE 16 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

plant, and adequacy of mitigation proposed. In addition, clarification of where the proposed discharges will occur will assist the Board in assessing the effects on the catchment.

I note that proposed condition CBP provides for a discharge standard with ph between 6 and 9. It is not clear if assessment has been made on the effects of this discharge on the receiving environment.

As a minor note, the activity is described in the application (page 58) as a discharge to water, however, the scope of the application (page 58) is described as a discharge to land (with corresponding Act reference).

5.7 Forestry

The application includes the removal of plantation forestry (RC1). Very little information is provided about the amount of forestry that is proposed to be removed and the removal method. As identified in Section 23.4.4 of the AEE, forestry clearance is associated with high sediment runoff. Forestry removal is required within the Kenepuru SSEMP which forms part of the wider watershed of the Porirua Harbour. The Harbour is recognised by GW as being nationally significant.

Likewise it is unclear whether replacement planting is proposed following the removal of the trees, and the timeframe for such planting. Section 8.3.2 of SSEMP6 suggests a mixture of pine and native planting, and proposed condition E36 refers to an ‗approved landscape plan‘, but no clarification is provided.

Further information on the forestry harvesting may assist the Board in determining the associated scale of the effects.

6 ACTIVITY STATUS OF ALL PROPOSED ACTIVITIES

6.1 The activity status of all proposed activities applied for in relation to the matter is provided in Table 3.3 (pg 84) of the application. The activity status listed ranges from Restricted discretionary to non complying activities. Based on the information given, the activity status as listed is considered correct.

6.2 As detailed in Section 5 above, further consents may be required. Insufficient information has been provided to determine the activity status of these consents, should they be applied for.

7 CONFIRMATION OF THE STATUS AND WEIGHTING OF ANY RELEVANT REGIONAL POLICY STATEMENT, AND OR RELEVENT PLAN

7.1 Section 4 of the application documents provides an accurate assessment of the status of Wellington Regional Council Plans. The only exception is the operative Regional Policy Statement. As discussed in Section 4.3 above, the RPS still is operative, and needs to be considered as part of this proposal.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 17 OF 24

8 PERMITTED BASELINE

8.1 The permitted baseline is a concept which allows the effects on the environment that are permitted by a plan or have been consented to be disregarded. It is up to the discretion of the decision maker as to whether the permitted baseline test is applied. If the baseline is applied then the relevant permitted baseline is: what lawfully exists on the site at present; the activities that could be conducted on the site as of right, without having to obtain a resource consent; and activities which could be carried out under a granted, but as yet unexercised resource consent.

Section 8.2 below lists the relevant permitted activities that are provided for the GW plans. Section 8.3 below identifies consents that GW has granted within the vicinity of TGP. I have also listed in Section 8.4, consents that are currently being processed by GW in the vicinity of TGP.

8.2 Permitted Activities

Below is a summary of relevant permitted activities provided for in the Wellington Regional plans.

8.2.1 Stormwater Discharge

Rule 1 of the RFP provides for the discharge of contaminants or water into surface water (other than the discharge of stormwater) as a permitted activity provided the discharge complies with specified conditions (refer to Appendix C). The rule specifically excludes discharges of stormwater. Stormwater is defined in the plan as water and contaminates from land or the external surface of any structure as a result of rainfall2.

This Rule is not relevant baseline for the proposed earthworks, as the rule excludes discharge as a result of rainfall (stormwater) and therefore excludes discharges from earthworks sites during rainfall.

Rule 1 specifies the contaminants and concentrations that are provided for within the scope of this rule. The applicants have also applied for consent for discharge from the concrete batching plant. Discharge from the concrete batching plant may be high in lime which is not provided for within the ambit of this rule.

Rule 2 of the RFP provides for the discharge of stormwater into surface water as a permitted activity, provided with the discharge complies with a number of conditions (refer to Appendix C). This rule specifically excludes discharges from industrial or trade premises. It also excludes discharges from an area of bulk earthworks greater than 0.3ha (Rule 2 condition 3a). This rule is the primary rule triggering the need for discharge consent in GW region. The earthworks proposed as part of TGP includes 6.3 M m3 of excavated material, and will require approximately 5.8 M m3 of material to be placed for fill embankments. Key assumptions around the construction of the project are that the total area of open road will be limited to 3 km in any one catchment (Section 3.1 Technical Report 15). I note that this does not include open areas associated with fill sites etc…

Because the earthworks proposed are significantly greater than those provided for in Rule 2 (0.3ha), I consider it inappropriate to apply the permitted baseline test with regard to discharges from earthworks.

2 The meaning of stormwater is subject to a reference to the Environment court

PAGE 18 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

8.2.2 Diversion of water

Rule 9 of the RFP provides for the diversion of less than 1.5m3/sec of fresh water from any intermittently flowing river or stream including associated disturbance, deposition and placement of a structure as a permitted activity provided a number of conditions are met (refer to Appendix C). The proposal involves approximately 6.6km of permanent stream realignment (refer Section 7.14 of application) significant amount of proposed stream diversions. While this rule could be applied in some instances of TGP – it is difficult to ascertain at this stage which instances of proposed diversion would meet the conditions of the permitted activity.

8.2.3 River Crossings

Rule 25 of the RFP provides for the placement and use of any river crossing in an intermittently flowing stream as a permitted activity subject to conditions. The rule specifies that the crossing should be of a ‗width necessary for the crossing‘. As identified above, TGP involves a large amount of stream piping. While this rule might be applied in some instances of TGP – it is difficult to ascertain at this stage which pipes that are proposed which meet the conditions of permitted activity.

8.2.4 Water takes

Rule 7 provides for the taking or use of less than 20,000 litres per day of fresh water (including fresh water from any aquifer), as a permitted activity provided the conditions are met. Conditions include limiting the rate of take to no more than 2.5l per second, and that there is only one abstraction point for each block of land (as described in each certificate of title). It is recognised that any new intake structure or bore may need consent.

The applicants are not yet applying for any consents associated with water take, however, I note that TGP will require water during construction for the concrete batching plant, general earthworks and dust suppression purposes. The source of water for construction associated with this proposal has not been established. As identified in Section 8.5 of the application, the peak water demand for this proposal is estimated to be 1.2 million litres a day.

Because the water take required is significantly greater than those provided for in Rule 7, I consider it inappropriate to apply the permitted baseline test with regard to water take.

8.2.5 Forestry – Vegetation disturbance on erosion prone land

Rule 3 of the RSP provides for vegetation disturbance of an area of more than one hectare on erosion prone lane as a permitted activity subject to conditions. The conditions include the need to re-establish the area of vegetation disturbance within 18 months.

TGP involves the clearance of a forest area to enable construction of the road carriageway and associated works. It is unknown how much of the area currently in pine forest will be replanted, (refer Section 5.7 above), however, because vast areas associated with the road carriageway can not be replanted, I do not consider the permitted baseline applies to Rule 3.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 19 OF 24

8.2.6 Concrete batching plant – discharge to land

Rule 1 of the DLP provides for the discharge of any contaminant onto or into land as a permitted activity - provided the contaminants are stormwater discharged into a pipe, the discharge is not regulated by any rule, and the discharge will not result in that contaminant entering water in any water body.

8.3 Existing resource consents

Appendix D contains a list of all active3 resource consents within 5km of TGP alignment. A 5km zone was chosen as a nominal figure that encapsulates existing consents that are located within the receiving environments (in particular Pauatahanui Inlet). Graphics of the approximate location of these consents are given in Appendix E.

A small proportion of the total consents shown in Appendix D are located directly under the proposed alignment of the designation. Most of these relate to consents either held by NZTA, Transpower, or the current occupier of the land, and they relate to the maintenance of the access track adjacent to Te Puka Stream. TGP involves extensive changes to this area, and includes alternative access routes.

Of the resource consents listed in Appendix D, a large number relate to existing consents to discharge sediment laden water. This includes as part of subdivisions and forestry works. These works are in various stages of construction, and if desired, GW can provide the Board with an update of the level of completion of these works. Other than land directly required for TGP, these consents will not be affected by TGP, however exercising the existing consents will add to the cumulative impact on water quality in the area.

A large number of resource consents listed in Appendix D relate to stream works – including piping, erosion protection and dams. The applicants have advised that there will be changes to the existing hydrology of streams from land use changes and changes in stream morphology. The detail of the exact location of stream crossings, and proximity to existing consented stream works has not been provided and therefore it is difficult to ascertain the true effects of TGP on these structures.

8.4 Current resource consent applications

Appendix F contains a list of resource consent applications currently being processed in the vicinity of TGP. Particularly relevant is the current application by Whitby Coastal Estates (refer Section 8.4.1 below).

While it is recognised that these applications do not form part of the permitted baseline, it is considered that the applications may be processed before the Board hearing for TGP.

3 ‘Active’ consents refers to applications that have not been surrended, cancelled or have expired. The consents may not have been given effect to. Note: Coastal permits were removed from this list, including 115 boatsheds and 58 swing moorings. School Boiler air discharge permits were also removed.

PAGE 20 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

8.4.1 Whitby Coastal Estates

GW and PCC are jointly processing an application by Whitby Coastal Estates to undertake various activities associated with the subdivision and residential development of part of the Duck Creek floodplain at Duck Creek South. The proposal includes the permanent diversion of two large sections of Duck Creek, bulk earthworks, reclamation, bulk earthworks, bridges, and subdivision of 49h of land into various lots.

The application was jointly notified on 6 August 2011 with a hearing scheduled to occur in October 2011.

The site of the application is located downstream from TGP.

Because the Whitby application is located within a floodplain and involves extensive realignment of the existing stream, floodplain modelling is a critical part of the Whitby application.

As part of TGP, the flow of water down Duck Creek could increase by 2% (refer Technical Report 14). To reduce this effect, TGP includes culverts in Duck Creek that impound the flow of water during storm events. Any increases in the flow regime of Duck Creek downstream from TGP could have implications on the flood modelling undertaken by WCE as part of their application.

9 ANY OTHER KEY ISSUES

9.1 The following section sets out those matters which are considered key issues relevant to Greater Wellington Regional Council jurisdiction. It should be noted that this report does not purport to address all relevant issues; rather it targets and addresses several key resource management issues of which are considered to be of significant public interest. In that regard, it is noted that the Board can commission a separate s42A report to be prepared at a later stage by independent planner to review any other issues of note.

9.2 Construction Discharges - Earthworks

As discussed above, the application involves a substantial amount of earthworks during construction of the project. Detail on the earthworks proposed can be found in Section 7.9 of the application and Technical Reports 11 and 15.

Large scale earthworks associated with construction work generate sediment. This occurs as a result of rain generated erosion and sediment laden runoff from construction site. The resulting runoff has the potential for elevated concentrations of suspended solids in the receiving environment.

The ultimate receiving environment for the project is the Porirua Harbour (comprising the Pauatahanui Inlet and the Onepoto arm) and Kapiti Coast (comprising the mouths of the Wainui and Whareroa Streams). The Porirua Harbour will be the receiving environment for approximately 80% of the discharges associated with the project.

As discussed above, the Porirua Harbour is recognised as being of regional significance in the pRPS, and some tributaries of the Porirua Harbour are listed in the Appendices of the RFP as having a high degree of natural character.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 21 OF 24

Technical Report 15 of the application, provides detail on how sediment discharge is proposed to be managed from the site. This includes ensuring that discharges from the site are treated to a 75% performance rate for removal of sediment. The performance rate provided is proposed to be achieved by ensuring all ponds have a minimum size of 3% of the contributing catchment area and a chemically treated. Where ponds can not be installed, other measures will be implemented to achieve a 75% performance rate.

The proposal will result in sediment laden water entering into the Harbour. In events larger than a Q10 event the performance of the sediment control ponds will be compromised (Section 9.5, Technical Report 15) and this could mean larger amounts of sediment entering into the Harbour. This is a key issue because of the importance of the Porirua Harbour, the amount of earthworks proposed, the length of the construction period (and therefore the likelihood of a Q10 event) and the detail design for the erosion and sediment control measures not being undertaken (and therefore the ability to achieve 75% performance rate not been certain).

The applicant has modelled the likely effects of increased sediment into the Harbour and this is summarised in Section 20.4.3 of the application.

9.3 Ecological impact

In total, approximately 10.5km of stream habitat will be affected through stream realignment and/or armouring as a result of the proposal. This includes:

Approximately 112 permanent stream crossings (either bridges or culverts);

9412m of culvert length (Table 7.5) plus an additional 20m upstream and downstream of each culvert for erosion control and protection structures (Section 7.13 of the application);

Permanent realignment of 6.5km of stream (pg iii of application);

Approximately 61 temporary culverts for construction access (Table 8.1 of application).

The proposed stream works will result in significant lengths of stream which are proposed to be piped. This will result in extensive habitat loss, and in some cases loss of fish passage. This includes streams that are identified in Appendix 2, Part B of the RFP as having a high degree of natural character.

The impact of the stream works is a key issue because of the importance of the Porirua Harbour and its tributaries and the cumulative effects from ongoing stream loss in the Wellington Region.

9.4 Mitigation and offsetting

A summary of the proposed mitigation is provided in Table 28.2 of the application and includes mitigation for impacts on air quality, contaminated land, hydrology, water quality, freshwater ecology, and marine ecology. Further, in Chapter 32 of the application, states that,

PAGE 22 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

‗the approach to managing adverse ecological effects, either through avoiding, remedying, mitigating or offsetting has been adopted to consider the effects of the Project as a whole... This allows a much wider geographical consideration of opportunities to manage effects. In some instances different catchments will realise a much greater overall benefit from mitigation of effects than the catchment where adverse effects occur‟.

From the information provided, it is clear that the application provides only abroad description of the proposed mitigation and that it is intended mitigation measures will occur at points not directly associated with an adverse effect.

The application uses the terms compensation, mitigation and offset-mitigation interchangeably. It is noted that compensation is not anticipated in the draft decision on Regional Freshwater Plan changes (policy 4.2.33A) and any possible compensation option would need to be addressed separately from mitigation or offset mitigation. This use of the terms compensation, mitigation and offset- mitigation interchangeably makes it difficult to determine when and where offset-mitigation and/or compensation are to be used as alternatives to mitigation. For instance, in Section 22.5.1 of the application it states that the total planting required to compensate for both the terrestrial and freshwater habitat loss will restore and protect approximately 30km of stream. Very few details have been provided on the areas of stream restored or protected and whether this is proposed as mitigation or offset mitigation. Also, whether the mitigation or offset mitigation will be in areas that are listed in Appendix 2 of the RFP or not.

In the draft decision on Transmission Gully Plan Change it states that in policy 4.2.33A,

“offsetting” means the provision of a positive effect in one location to offset adverse effects of the same or similar type caused by the transmission Gully Project at another location with the result that the overall adverse effects on the values of the water bodies are remedied or mitigated. Where offsetting is to be applied, there should be a clear connection with the effect and the offsetting measure. … The adequacy of a proposed offsetting measure should be transparent in that it is assessed against a recognised methodology‟.

In the context of the draft decision report (policy 4.2.33A) and uncertainty about what and when compensation, offset-mitigation and mitigation are to be used, the applicants have provided very little detail on the how it will achieve a connection between offsetting and the location and extent of adverse effects they are intended to address.

9.5 Uncertainty

The applicants are applying for NOR and Resource consents for TGP. Owing to the size and complexity of the application, and the current stage of the detailed design, the applicants intend to finalise a great deal of the specificity of the proposal through conditions of consent, and the Outline Plan process.

The use of monitoring and management plans as conditions of consent is consistent with GW‘s general approach to large scale applications and earthworks sites. Typically draft plans are provided as part of the application documents and are finalised by way of conditions of consent. The draft plans are required to give enough detail for the processing officer to be able to ascertain the likely effects, and how they could be mitigated. These are then finalised as a conditions of

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 23 OF 24

consent. This process recognises that the processing officer needs to understand what can be undertaken to mitigate the effects, areas of risk, and provides a good reference document when final plans are submitted for approval. It also helps establish clear expectations with the consent holder about what is expected for the management plans.

TGP proposed conditions include requirement for a large number of management and monitoring plans. These include:

Concrete Batching Management Plan;

Construction Environmental Management Plan;

Contaminated Land Management Plan;

Erosion and Sediment Control Plan;

Chemical Treatment Plan; and

Ecological Management and Monitoring Plan

While drafts of some of the plans have been provided, they are typically incomplete and lack specificity on matters such as locations for activities, methodologies to be used and contingencies in the case of failures. For example, the application refers to the use of ‗adaptive management‘ as responses to indicators of significant events, however little detail is included on what these ‗triggers‘ and ‗indicators‘ are, or how they will be developed.

The lack of specificity is also identified in Section 9.4 above, with regard to proposed mitigation. The proposed mitigation location, ongoing protection etc... is unclear from the documentation provided. Some of the mitigation (especially avoidance) appears to be left to contractors to implement. It is not clear what requirements will be placed on suitable contractors to undertake these works, how this will be supervised or monitored and what will happen if contractors do not meet these environmental objectives.

It is the Board‘s decision to make over whether this lack of certainty around the regional council consenting matters is an issue.

PAGE 24 OF 24 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Appendix A Plan Change – Draft Decision Policy Wording

Regional Freshwater Plan Chapter 4 - General Objectives and Policies

Policy 4.2.10 To avoid adverse effects on wetlands, and lakes and rivers and their margins, identified in Appendix 2 (Parts A and B), (with the exception of the Transmission Gully Project and its effects on the Horokiri, Ration and lower Pauatahanui Streams where Policy 4.2.33A applies), when considering the protection of their natural character from the adverse effects of subdivision, use, and development. For the avoidance of doubt Rule 50 applies to the Transmission Gully Project, in relation to the Horokiri, Ration and lower Pauatahanui Streams.

Explanation. Wetlands, and lakes and rivers and their margins, are identified in Appendix 2 as having a high degree of natural character when assessed against the characteristics outlined in Policy 4.2.9.

The preservation of natural character in this policy is achieved by avoiding adverse effects. In this policy "to avoid adverse effects” means that when “avoiding, remedying or mitigating adverse effects”, as identified in subsection 5(2)(c) of the Act, the emphasis is to be placed on avoiding adverse effects. “To avoid adverse effects" means that only activities with effects that are no more than minor will be allowed in the water bodies identified unless Policy 4.2.33A applies. Further elaboration of the meaning of “minor” is contained in Policy 4.2.33 (Policy 4.2.33A provides the approach to be considered in relation to the Transmission Gully Project that includes avoidance, remediation, or mitigation of adverse effects). Activities can occur in the water bodies listed in Appendix 2 but the emphasis in this policy is on preserving the natural character of these water bodies.

In this context “To avoid … when considering” relates to consideration during the preparation of, variation to, or change to, district and regional plans, or the consideration of any relevant resource consent application.

The wetlands, rivers and lakes which are identified in Part A of Appendix 2 are to have their water quality managed in its natural state according to Policy 5.2.1. The wetlands, rivers and lakes that are identified in Part B of Appendix 2 are to have their water quality managed for aquatic ecosystem purposes according to Policy 5.2.6.

The characteristics of a water body that are commonly perceived to contribute to its natural character are identified in the previous policy.

Policy4.2.33A To manage adverse effects of the development of the Transmission Gully Project, in accordance with the following management regime: (1) Adverse effects are avoided to the extent practicable; (2) Adverse effects which cannot be avoided are remedied or mitigated.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 4

Explanation: This policy recognises that the Transmission Gully Project is identified in various statutory and policy documents as having both national and regional significance. In achieving the sustainable management objectives of the Act, resource managers and decision makers have the option of applying avoidance, remediation and mitigation in managing adverse effects. Accordingly, the adverse effects of aspects ofthe Project may be acceptable, even though they cannot be completely avoided, remedied, or mitigated. Remedying or mitigating can include the concept of offsetting.

In this policy “offsetting” means the provision of a positive effect in one location to offset adverse effects of the same or similar type caused by the Transmission Gully Project at another location with the result that the overall adverse effects on the values of the waterbodies are remedied or mitigated.

Where offsetting is to be applied, there should be a clear connection with the effect and the offsetting measure. The offsetting measure should preferably be applied as close as possible to the site incurring the effects. Hence, there should be a focus on offsetting occurring within the affected catchments along the Transmission Gully route and to specifically address the effects at issue.

Offsetting should, as far as can be achieved maintain and enhance the particular natural values affected by the Project when assessed overall.

The adequacy of a proposed offsetting measure should be transparent in that it is assessed against a recognised methodology.

In this policy “to the extent practicable” requires consideration of the nature of the activity, the sensitivity of the receiving environment to adverse effects, the financial implications and adverse effects of the measure considered compared with other alternative measures, the current state of technical knowledge and the likelihood that effects can be successfully avoided, remedied or mitigated.

Regional Freshwater Plan Chapter 7 - Use of the Beds of Rivers and Lakes and Development on the Floodplain

Policy 7.2.1 To allow the following uses within river and lake beds: • structures or activities for flood mitigation or erosion protection purposes; • structures for transportation and network utility purposes; or • structures for activities which need to be located in, on, under, or over the beds of rivers and lakes; or • structures for cultural harvest (e.g., pa tuna); or • the maintenance of any lawful structure; or • the removal of aquatic weeds from farm drains and urban drains for drainage purposes; or • the extraction of sand, gravel, or rock; or • the diversion of water associated with activities that are otherwise authorised; or • the enhancement of the natural character of any wetland, lake or river and its margins;

PAGE 2 OF 4 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

provided that any adverse effects are avoided, remedied or mitigated andthat the significant adverse effects identified in Policy 7.2.2 are avoided (unless the effects are of activities for the Transmission Gully Project and are addressed in accordance with Policy 4.2.33A).

Explanation. Policy 7.2.1 lists criteria for appropriate uses within the beds of rivers and lakes. "Uses" refers to those activities identified in subsections 13(1)(a), 13(1)(b), 13(1)(c), 13(1)(d) and 13(1)(e) of the Act.

Structures or activities that do not meet the criteria listed in the policy are inappropriate. For example, any structure associated with a use that does not have to be located in or on the bed of a river or lake is considered inappropriate.

While a particular use of a river or lake bed may meet the criteria listed in the policy, it may need to comply with environmental controls, and is subject to Policy 7.2.2. The policy recognises that adverse effects of activities for the Transmission Gully Project can be considered according to Policy 4.2.33A.

Policy 7.2.2 To not allow the use of river and lake beds for structures or activities that have significant adverse effects on: • the values held by tangata whenua; and/or • natural or amenity values; and/or • lawful public access along a river or lake bed; and/or • the flood hazard; and/or • river or lake bed or bank stability; and/or • water quality; and/or • water quantity and hydraulic processes (such as river flows and sediment transport); and/or • the safety of canoeists or rafters; unless the structures or activities are for the Transmission Gully Project and addressed in accordance with Policy 4.2.33A.

Explanation. This policy lists characteristics of rivers and lakes that should not be significantly affected by uses of river and lake beds which are identified as "appropriate" in the previous policy. "Uses" has the same meaning as in Policy 7.2.1.

When a new use of any river or lake bed is considered, due regard must be had to avoiding, remedying, or mitigating adverse effects on these characteristics.

In the context of this policy deciding on what are “significant adverse effects” is in part a value judgement which will be determined by the decision makers on resource consents, i.e., Regional Councillors or Hearing Commissioners. When deciding whether an adverse effect is significant or not, decision makers will have regard to: • the significance of any values identified; and • the scale/magnitude of any adverse effects on the values identified;and • the reversibility of any adverse effects on the values identified; and • any other relevant provisions in the Plan.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 3 OF 4

Reference in the policy to “the Transmission Gully Project and adverse effects that would otherwise be significant” recognises that these potential effects shall be addressed through Policy 4.2.33A.

“Transmission Gully Project” is a strategic transport route shown on Plan [x] running from MacKays Crossing to Linden and the term includes works in proximity that are associated with the implementation of that project.

PAGE 4 OF 4 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Appendix B National Environmental Standards

National Environmental Standards on Air Quality 14 Application of standards (1)The ambient air quality standard for a contaminant applies at any place— (a)that is in an airshed; and (b)that is in the open air; and (c)where people are likely to be exposed to the contaminant. (2)However, if the discharge of a contaminant is expressly allowed by a resource consent, the ambient air quality standard for the contaminant does not apply to the site on which the resource consent is exercised

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 1

Appendix C GW Regional Plans – Permitted Activities

1 Regional Freshwater Plan for the Wellington Region 1.1 Interpretation Stormwater means the water and contaminants from land or the external surface of any structure as a result of rainfall.* * The meaning of stormwater is subject to a reference to the Environment Court

1.2 Rules 1.2.1 Rule 1 – Discharge of water and minor contaminants The discharge of contaminants, or water, into surface water, other than the discharge of stormwater, is a Permitted Activity provided the discharge complies with the conditions specified below. Conditions (1) the discharge is not to any wetland, lake or river being managed in its natural state (Appendix 2, part A); and (2) the discharge shall not contain any contaminants other than contaminants at concentrations specified in conditions (3) to (7) below; and (3) concentrations of free or combined residual chlorine in the discharge shall be no more than 0.5 g/m3; and (4) concentrations of suspended solids in the discharge shall be no more than 50 g/m³; and (5) concentrations of acid-soluble aluminium in the discharge shall be no more than 0.15g/m³; and (6) concentrations of fluoride in the discharge shall be no more than 1.5 g/m3; and (7) the discharge temperature shall not differ from the ambient temperature of the receiving water by more than 5° Celsius; and (8) the discharge does not cause erosion at the point of discharge; and (9) the discharge does not alter the natural course of the river or stream.

1.2.2 Rule 2 – Stormwater discharges The discharge of stormwater into surface water is a Permitted Activity provided that the discharge complies with the conditions specified below. Conditions (1) The discharge does not contain drainage from a stockyard; and (2) The discharge does not [originate from industrial or trade premises] where hazardous substances are stored or [used] unless: (a) hazardous substances cannot enter the stormwater system; or (b) there is an interceptor system in place to collect hazardous contaminants or divert contaminated stormwater to a trade waste system; and (3) The person responsible for the discharge shall ensure that, after reasonable mixing, the stormwater discharge will not give rise to any of the following effects: (a) the production of any conspicuous oil or grease films, scums or foams, or floatable or suspended materials; or

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 5

(b) any conspicuous change in the colour or visual clarity; or (c) any emission of objectionable odour; or (d) the rendering of fresh water unsuitable for consumption by farm animals; or (e) any significant adverse effects on aquatic life; and (3a) The discharge does not originate from an area of bulk earthworks greater than 0.3 ha; (3b) Concentrations of acid-soluble aluminium in the discharge shall be no more than 0.15g/m³;] (4) The discharge does not cause erosion at the point of discharge; and (5) The discharge does not alter the natural course of the river or stream.

Note: Discharges that do not comply with this rule are discretionary activities in accordance with Rule 5, unless they are provided for by Rule 3. Note: Bulk earthworks means the cut to fill, excavation, and blading required to regrade an area.

1.2.3 Rule 9 – Minor diversion of water from an intermittently flowing stream The diversion of less that 1.5 m³/sec of fresh water from any intermittently flowing river or stream including any associated: • disturbance of the river bed; or • deposition on the stream bed; or • erection or placement of a structure, which; (1) has a catchment area above the diversion of not more than: • 200 ha in any catchment in the Region on the eastern side of the Ruamahanga River; or • 50 ha in any catchment in the Region on the western side of the Ruamahanga River; and (2) is located more than 50 metres from a property boundary; and (3) does not reduce the ability of the stream to convey flood flows or debris carried by floods is a Permitted Activity, provided that it complies with the conditions specified below. Conditions (1) No contaminants (including but not limited to oil, petrol, diesel, paint, or solvent) shall be released to water from equipment being used for the construction of the diversion and no refuelling of equipment shall take place on any area of stream bed. (2) All material used to construct the diversion but which is not part of any diversion structure shall be removed from the river or stream bed and disposed of in an appropriate manner. (3) All reasonable steps shall be taken to minimise the release of sediment to water during construction. (4) The diversion shall be maintained so that there is no accumulation of debris.

1.2.4 Rule 25 – River Crossings in intermittently flowing streams The placement and use, including any associated; • disturbance of any river bed; or • deposition on the river bed; or • temporary diversion; of any river crossing of a width necessary for the crossing, excluding any river crossing that dams a river, that is fixed in, on, under, or over the bed of any

PAGE 2 OF 5 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

intermittently flowing river or stream which; (1) has a catchment area above the crossing of not more than: • 200 ha in any catchment in the Region on the eastern side of the Ruamahanga River; or • 50 ha in any catchment in the Region on the western side of the Ruamahanga River; and (2) does not alter the natural course of the stream, including any diversion of water from the natural course during floods; and (3) does not reduce the ability of the river to convey flood flows (4) meets any requirements under the Freshwater Fisheries Regulations 1983 and the Building Act 1991; is a Permitted Activity provided it complies with the conditions specified below. Conditions (1) No contaminants (including but not limited to oil, petrol, diesel, paint, or solvent) shall be released to water from equipment being used for the construction of the river crossing and no refuelling of equipment shall take place on any area of river or lake bed. (2) All material used during construction, but which is not part of the river crossing shall be removed from the river or stream bed and disposed of in an appropriate manner. (3) All reasonable steps shall be taken to minimise the release of sediment to water during construction. (4) The river crossing shall be maintained so that there is no accumulation of debris.

1.2.5 Rule 7 – Minor abstractions The taking or use of less than 20,000 litres per day of fresh water (including fresh water from any aquifer), other than the taking of water from the Groundwater Zone, is a Permitted Activity, provided that it complies with the conditions specified below.

Conditions (1) The water shall be taken at a rate of no more than 2.5 litres per second. (2) In the case of groundwater, there are no adverse effects on the take from adjacent bores. (3) There shall be no more than one abstraction point serving the land described in a particular certificate of title. (4) Fish, including small fish, are prevented from entering the reticulation system.

Note: For these permitted activities, a consent for any new intake structure or bore may be required (see Rule and 15 and the rules in section 7, Uses of the Beds of Rivers and Lakes, and Development on the Floodplain).

2 Regional Soil Plan for the Wellington Region 2.1 Interpretaion Vegetation disturbance Means the clearance or destruction of vegetation by physical/mechanical or chemical means and includes logging, felling or harvesting of trees and the burning of vegetation. Vegetation disturbance does not include: • vegetation disturbance associated with a roading or tracking activity or a soil disturbance activity;

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 3 OF 5

• root raking; • grazing or cutting of grass; • pruning, thinning or layering; • plant pests (as identified in Table 2 of the Regional Pest Plant Management Strategy, Wellington Region 1996-2001 (WRC/WAG- 96/38) cut by hand; • clearance of scattered or intermittently occurring regenerating bush or scrub on existing pastoral land; • the collection of plants for traditional medicinal or cultural use; • the trimming of vegetation (for example, along existing private and public roads, railway lines, and under or over a public utility network, or within public reserves and land held under the Conservation Act 1987); • the removal of vegetation for the purposes of creating a building site; • vegetation disturbance undertaken by a mine or quarry operation which either had a currently valid mining licence, or was lawfully established at 26 April 1997 (the date the Regional Soil Plan was publicly notified); or • spraying of annual pasture weeds and all thistles, including biannual thistles. Note: The spray application of agrichemicals is addressed in the Regional Air Quality Management Plan for the Wellington Region

2.2 Rules 2.2.1 Rule 3 – Vegetation disturbance on erosion prone land Vegetation disturbance, excluding vegetation disturbance undertaken in accordance with conditions on a subdivision consent, of a continuous area of more than one hectare on erosion prone land is a Permitted Activity provided the following conditions are met: Conditions (1) The Wellington Regional Council‘s Regional Soil Conservator is notified in writing at least 21 days prior to the vegetation disturbance being undertaken. Notification is to include details of the site location and timing of the vegetation disturbance operation. (2) The area of vegetation disturbance will be re-established in woody vegetation within 18 months from the start of the vegetation disturbance operation. (3) Where ground-based methods are used, best management practices as described in the New Zealand Forest Code of Practice (LIRO 1990, revised 1993) are adopted. (4) No vegetation or slash with a diameter of greater than 100 mm shall be allowed to remain in any watercourse and when removed, shall be placed in a position where that material cannot enter any watercourse. Explanation. The terms ―vegetation disturbance‖, ―erosion prone land‖ and ―watercourse‖ are defined in the Interpretation in section 3 of the Plan.

3 Discharge to Land Plan for the Wellington Region

3.1 Rules 3.1.1 Rule 1 – Discharge of contaminants not entering water The discharge of any contaminant onto or into land is a Permitted Activity provided (a) the contaminants are stormwater discharged into a pipe which then discharges to surface water; or

PAGE 4 OF 5 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

(b) with the exception of Rule 2, the discharge is not regulated by any rule in this Plan; and (c) the discharge will not (i) result in that contaminant (or any other contaminant emanating as a result of natural processes from that contaminant) entering water in any water body, water supply race, farm drain, or the coastal marine area; or (ii) create a contaminated site.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 5 OF 5

Appendix D Active Resource Consents ID FILE NAME APPLICATION COMMENCE EXPIRY PURPOSE DESCRIPTION FURTHER GRID REF GRID REF DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION 26040 WGN000007 Tatana Contracting LUC - 04/02/2000 28/05/2012 To deposit 300mm of concrete quarry material and clean fill of between 1.2 and Southern Taupo 1757080 5450786 Limited RECLAMATION 1.8 metres in height, associated with the formation of a platform for industrial Swamp development in the bed of the Taupo Swamp. 26048 WGN000007 Tatana Contracting LUC - 04/02/2000 28/05/2012 To extract peat to an average depth of 1 metre from the bed of Taupo Swamp, Southern Taupo 1757080 5450786 Limited STREAMWORK associated with the formation of a platform for industrial development. Swamp 20020 WGN000025 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 24/08/1999 24/08/2034 To construct to two stream crossings (using culverts) Hydro Valley, Whakatikei Whakatikei Forest 1768449 5458166 CROSSING Forest. 20083 WGN000037 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 22/09/1999 22/09/2034 To construct, use and maintain four boardwalk bridges in the bed of Mitchell Mitchell Stream, 1752280 5441887 CROSSING Stream, to enhance public access to Spicer Botanical Park. Spicer Botanical P 20090 WGN000037 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 22/09/1999 22/09/2034 Place, use and maintain a stepping stone crossing of a weir. Five natural river Mitchell Creek, 1752280 5441887 CROSSING rocks 200x300mm attached by a steel pin. Linden 20117 WGN000045 Telecom New Zealand LUC - GENERAL 22/10/1999 22/10/2034 To lay power and telecommunication cables beneath the river bed in a plastic Jacobson Property, 1764480 5447085 Ltd S30163 STRUCTURE conduit. 20325 WGN000056 Wellington Regional LUC - RIVER 11/02/2000 27/10/2034 To replace an existing bridge with a ford. Whareroa Stream 1766581 5462985 Recreat CROSSING 20161 WGN000059 Miller, J LUC - RIVER 03/11/1999 03/11/2034 To add two pipe lengths to a existing culvert to allow driveway to be constructed. 44 Ames Street, 1763781 5460485 CROSSING 20162 WGN000060 Transpower New LUC - RIVER 15/12/1999 15/12/2034 To replace an existing bridge with a culvert. The new culvert will be a twin pipe 331 Valley Road 1768581 5464785 Zealand Ltd CROSSING culvert using 2 9.6m sections of 1050mm diamter piping. 20163 WGN000061 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 01/11/1999 01/11/2034 To pipe a section of the stream. Tangare Drive, 1754280 5445786 STRUCTURE Takapuwahia 20198 WGN000069 Whitby Coastal LUC - RIVER 19/05/2000 19/05/2035 To fill and culvert gullies to allow access road and building platforms Navigation Drive, 1760080 5446786 Estates CROSSING Witby 20478 WGN000069 Whitby Coastal WP - SURFACE 19/05/2000 19/05/2035 Divert the stream flow from the bed of an unnamed tributary of Pauatahanui Navigation Drive, 1760080 5446786 Estates WATER Stream, through a culvert and diversion channel to return to that same stream. Whitby DIVERSION 20222 WGN000080 Wharfe, KP & LP LUC - 09/12/1999 09/12/2034 Construction of a diversion channel to divert the stream around a quarry. Unnamed Tributary 1762379 5443686 STREAMWORK Of The Pauatahanu 20223 WGN000080 Wharfe, KP & LP WP - SURFACE 09/12/1999 09/12/2034 To divert the stream around the quarry working area through a constructed Unnamed Tributary 1762379 5443686 DIVERSION channel to reduce sediment run-off Of The Pauatahanu 20259 WGN000093 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 19/01/2000 19/01/2035 To erect boardwalk across pond and modify existing weir to allow for fish Aotea Lagoon Reserve 1755880 5446186 STRUCTURE passage. 20273 WGN000098 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 31/01/2000 31/01/2035 Stream bed wil be shaped to receive culvert, and 50 metres of 900mm culvert will Pa Road 1759381 5455986 CROSSING be laid, backfilled, and planted. 20275 WGN000100 Gray, Joy LUC - HAZARD 10/02/2000 10/02/2035 Iinstall 5 sets of 4 concrete blocks using a digger. Kakaho Stream 1759280 5449886 MITIGATION 20365 WGN000121 Kim Schwass And WP - SURFACE 20/03/2000 17/03/2035 To divert a section of Horokiri stream associated with crossblading works. Horokiri Stream 1761080 5449586 Anthony Murch DIVERSION 20331 WGN000125 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 09/03/2000 09/03/2035 To extend one culvert to enable road to be widened. Transit New Zealand 1767281 5464185 Transport Agency CROSSING 20366 WGN000140 Vink, Ronald J. LUC - HAZARD 21/03/2000 21/03/2035 Place and maintain a rock rip rap wall of up to 3 metres. 172 Hill Road, 1759679 5441686 MITIGATION Belmont 20367 WGN000141 Steiner, Dr Charles LUC - 23/03/2000 23/03/2035 To enlarge an existing pond to use as a water feature and for stock watering Dr Steiner 1762789 5446078 STREAMWORK purposes. 20487 WGN000150 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 23/05/2000 06/04/2035 To install an additional culvert under SH58 for flood prevention State Highway 58 1760380 5447886 CROSSING 20398 WGN000158 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 17/04/2000 17/04/2035 To enlarge a 25m section of stormwater pipe and build an intake structure in an Wellington City 1753679 5438987 Council STRUCTURE unnamed stream. Council 20479 WGN000176 Carpenter, David LUC - DAM 26/05/2000 26/05/2035 Maximum dimensions are 3m high and 10m wide, will store about 20 m3 of Paekakariki Hill Road, 1762681 5457585 STRUCTURE water. Porirua 20480 WGN000176 Carpenter, David WP – DAM 26/05/2000 26/05/2035 Damming about 20m3 of water by small dam, high in catchment in an unnamed Paekakariki Hill Road 1762681 5457585 tributary of the Horokiri Stream 20481 WGN000176 Carpenter, David WP - SURFACE 26/05/2000 26/05/2035 To divert water in a spillway of a small dam to prevent scouring downstream. Paekakariki Hill Road, 1762681 5457585 DIVERSION Porirua 20568 WGN000184 Wellington City LUC - HAZARD 19/06/2000 09/06/2035 Place bank protection structure, including gabions, in Porirua Stream, for Porirua Stream 1752579 5437387 Council - Streetwor MITIGATION stabilisation of the Middleton Road embankment.

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 19

20598 WGN010007 Transit New Zealand WP –WATER 09/06/2004 05/11/2036 To take, use, dam and divert water, including surface water, stormwater and Pauatahanui & 1764480 5446285 groundwater, for construction, operation, maintenance and repair activities. Stream 21305 WGN010007 New Zealand LUC - 09/06/2004 09/06/2039 To carry out activities in, on, under or over the beds of lake or river, for Pauatahanui & 1764480 5446285 Transport Agency STREAMWORK construction, operation, maintenance and repair activities Haywards Stream 21306 WGN010007 New Zealand LUC - SOIL 09/06/2004 09/06/2039 To disturb and remove soil and other material including excavation, filling and Haywards Hill Area 1764480 5446285 Transport Agency DISTURBANCE roading and tracking activities. 21307 WGN010007 New Zealand DP - CONTAM 09/06/2004 09/06/2019 Discharge contaminants and water (which may contain contaminants) to water in Pauatahanui & 1764480 5446285 Transport Agency STORMWATER the Haywards Stream, Manor Park Golf Course Stream, Pauatahanui Stream. Haywards Stream 20668 WGN010028 New Zealand LUC - HAZARD 21/09/2000 21/09/2035 To place rip rap on the streambank for erosion protection and minor diversion Te Puka Stream, State 1765381 5461485 Transport Agency MITIGATION Highway 1 20669 WGN010028 New Zealand LUC - GENERAL 21/09/2000 21/09/2035 Streambank near culvert of Te Puka Stream, Paekakariki State Highway 1 1765381 5461685 Transport Agency STRUCTURE Culvert, Te Puka St 20701 WGN010041 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 11/09/2000 11/09/2035 To construct and maintain box-gabion bank protection works on a 25 metre Pauatahanui Stream 1760780 5447686 MITIGATION section of the true right bank of Pauatahanui Stream to prevent under mining of the public toilets. 20702 WGN010042 Porirua City Council LUC - 13/10/2000 13/10/2035 To reshape up to 55 metres of stream bank on the Hukarito Stream, to improve Tangare Drive 1754280 5446386 STREAMWORK safety and the visual amenity value of the stream and to enhance the area for Reserve public use. 24248 WGN010067 Building Research DP - DISCHARGE 03/11/2000 03/11/2015 Discharge of contaminants to air associated with a fire testing laboratory. Branz Research 1763788 5446870 Association Of Nz TO AIR Centre 20821 WGN010081 Lunn, David LUC - HAZARD 10/11/2000 10/11/2035 Tethered willows planted and anchored along 10 metre stretch of stream Horokiri Stream 1762880 5451985 MITIGATION 20976 WGN010098 Mcgavin, W & D LUC - RIVER 31/01/2001 31/01/2036 To use and maintain a water diversion structure and a ford constructed from Horokiri Stream 1762180 5450985 CROSSING river bed material 20984 WGN010139 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 12/02/2001 12/02/2036 In an unnamed stream flowing along the edge of Flighty's Road, Judgeford, Flighty's Road, 1762380 5446686 CROSSING Porirua. The stream is a tributary of the Pauatahanui stream. Judgeford 21006 WGN010139 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 12/02/2001 12/02/2036 On either side of a culvert in the bed of the stream Flighty's Road 1762380 5446686 MITIGATION 21146 WGN010150 Wellington Regional DP - SEWAGE / 23/03/2001 23/03/2016 Re use the Humes RD 5000 Eco tank currently located at the existing toilet block. Southern End Of QE 1765081 5462585 Recreat SLUDGES Rock filter internal material will be removed and replaced with a Zabel or similar Regional Park, P filter on the outlet pipe. 21020 WGN010153 Watt, Derek LUC - RIVER 26/02/2001 26/02/2036 Remove existing old swing bridge and replace with new arch footbridge to 150 Hill Stream. 1760631 5439087 CROSSING provide access to dwelling. 21042 WGN010162 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 02/01/2003 13/02/2037 To undertake activities in, on, under or over the bed of Whareroa Stream, and the Mackays Crossing 1766681 5462685 Transport Agency CROSSING adjoining mackays Crossing Wetland Reserve, and related areas 21706 WGN010162 Transit New Zealand WP - SURFACE 02/01/2003 13/02/2037 To take, use, dam, and divert water, including surface water for construction, Mackays Crossing 1766681 5462685 DIVERSION operation, maintenance and repair activities 25117 WGN010162 Transit New Zealand LUC - SOIL 13/02/2002 13/02/2037 To undertake earthworks to disturb and remove soil, including excavation of a Mackays Crossing 1766681 5462685 DISTURBANCE cutting, building batters , roading structures on top of the batters and all associated roading activities. 21107 WGN010182 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 29/03/2001 29/03/2036 To divert streamwater through a re-aligned culvert Flighty's Road, 1762380 5446686 DIVERSION Judgeford 21168 WGN010198 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 04/05/2001 04/05/2036 Natural channel will be tapered and a layer of stones laid in concrete will be 9 Court Road, Tawa 1753479 5440487 Council STRUCTURE placed over the stream beds and banks. Intake structure extended to include scraping platform, weir 21195 WGN010202 Building Research DP - SEWAGE / 30/05/2001 30/05/2021 To discharge secondary treated domestic sewage into surface water in the BRANZ Site, 1763830 5446775 Association Of Nz SLUDGES Pauatahanui Stream catchment Judgeford 21207 WGN010206 Crosland, M LUC - RIVER 28/05/2001 28/05/2036 A culvert placed in the stream to provide access to subdivision section 1122 Paekakariki 1763381 5457485 CROSSING Road 21260 WGN010218 Hawkins, Tracy LUC - RIVER 17/05/2001 17/05/2036 To place, use and maintain a culvert in an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Unnamed Tributary 1762780 5448385 CROSSING Stream for access purposes, and to undertake associated disturbance of the bed. Of The Pauatahanu 21261 WGN010218 Hawkins, Tracy WP - SURFACE 17/05/2001 17/05/2036 Water is to be diveted through a culvert being constructed for access purposes. Unnamed Tributary 1762780 5448385 DIVERSION Of The Pauatahanu 21308 WGN010224 Wellington Regional LUC - RIVER 16/07/2001 16/07/2036 A concrete foundation slab (500mm x 1000mm) will be poured under the pre- Whareroa Stream 1765881 5464185 Recreat CROSSING cast culverts (upstream and downstream) to provide scour protection. 21354 WGN010229 Morrissey, Anthony WP – SURFACE 27/07/2001 27/07/2036 To divert an unnamed tributary of the Horokiri Stream for access purposes. An Tributary Of The 1762981 5456785 Warren DIVERSION Horokir 21355 WGN010229 Morrissey, Anthony LUC - RIVER 27/07/2001 27/07/2036 To place, use and maintain a culvert in an unnamed tributary of the Horokiri Horokiri Stream 1763181 5457185 Warren CROSSING Stream for access purposes, and to undertake associated disturbance of the stream bed. 21419 WGN010229 Morrissey, Anthony LUC - 27/07/2001 27/07/2036 To disturb the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Horokiri Stream for the 1122 Paekakariki Hill 1762981 5456785 Warren STREAMWORK purpose of realigning two sections of the stream. Road 23494 WGN020002 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 18/07/2001 18/07/2036 Removal of existing access consisting of two culverts and fill material (permitted Taupo Stream 1756880 5450286

PAGE 2 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

CROSSING activity) and replacement of that strucutre with a bridge (discretionary activity). 21457 WGN020026 Leacroft Nurseries WP - SURFACE 06/09/2001 06/09/2011 To abstract water from the Horokiri Stream for horticultural purposes. Horikiri Stream 1760780 5449086 Ltd WATER TAKE 21479 WGN020032 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 28/11/2001 28/11/2036 To erect a debris arrestor in the Takapu Stream to collect debris and prevent it Takapu Stream 1753579 5439287 Council STRUCTURE blocking the SH1 motorway culvert. 21493 WGN020037 Hutt City Council LUC - GENERAL 03/09/2001 03/09/2036 To place a stormwater discharge outlet structure in the bed of a stream. Hill Road, Belmont 1760654 5439078 STRUCTURE 22127 WGN020044 Wrc, Resource LUC - GENERAL 14/09/2001 14/09/2036 To lay a pre-cast concrete slab in the streambed then a V notch weir will be Horokiri Stream 1761780 5450686 Investigations STRUCTURE constructed on top of the slab 21521 WGN020045 Martin, Philip LUC - RIVER 19/09/2001 19/09/2036 To place, use and maintain a culvert in the bed of Takapu stream for access Takapu Stream 1755579 5441186 CROSSING purposes, and to undertake associated disturbance of the stream bed. 21555 WGN020049 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 28/09/2001 28/09/2036 Upgrade of road section - install erosion protection measures and cut a channel Flightys Road, 1762780 5447985 STRUCTURE from road culvert outlet to stream. Judgeford 21575 WGN020053 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 30/10/2001 30/10/2036 To construct a debris arrestor struture in an unnamed water course. 11 Court Road, Tawa. 1753479 5440387 Council STRUCTURE 21622 WGN020064 Ranchod, Harry LUC - RIVER 05/11/2001 05/11/2036 To install a 6 metre, 600mm diametre culvert with headwalls in an unnamed Stratton St 1758379 5438086 CROSSING stream. 21636 WGN020068 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 20/12/2001 20/12/2036 Construct 600mm diameter culvert in an unnamed stream under Grays Road Grays Rd, 1760280 5448886 CROSSING Pauatahanui 21646 WGN020072 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 05/11/2001 05/11/2036 Replace existing box culvert and concrete lined channel with double culvert. James Street, 1757180 5450186 CROSSING Install new culvert between existing stream and farm drainage channel. 21667 WGN020075 Transit New Zealand WP - SURFACE 22/11/2001 22/11/2036 To divert the flow of a tributary of Taupo Stream through a new open drain along Sh1 Plimmerton 1757280 5450786 DIVERSION the toe of a fill embankment on the eastern side of SH1 Plimmerton. 22086 WGN020095 Baker-Underhill, Ray LUC - RIVER 10/12/2001 10/12/2036 Construct culvert in intermittently flowing stream to provide building platform Unnamed 1757080 5447586 And Daneen CROSSING for a dwelling. Intermittently- Flowing Stre 21740 WGN020100 Gwrc, Flood LUC - HAZARD 05/12/2001 05/12/2036 To place 5 concrete blocks in the bed of Duck Creek, to reinstate 2 existing gabion Duck Creek 1759180 5445886 Protection MITIGATION baskets, place 2 new gabion baskets and to divert a small section of Duck Creek 21764 WGN020108 Wrc, Bulk Water LUC - GENERAL 10/01/2002 10/01/2037 200mm diameter ductile iron potable water main will be laid at least 750mm Taupo Stream 1756980 5450586 Dept. STRUCTURE below the bed of Taupo Stream. 21805 WGN020109 Belvista Subdivisions WP - SURFACE 11/01/2002 11/01/2037 Divert 190m of stream to allow bed to be reclaimed to provide vehicle access and Unnamed Tributary 1760279 5438186 Limted WATER building platforms. Of Hutt River DIVERSION 21944 WGN020109 Belvista Subdivisions LUC - RIVER 11/01/2002 11/01/2037 Extra gabion bank protection structures downstream of culvert outlet. Unnamed Tributary 1760279 5438186 CROSSING Of Hutt River 21786 WGN020113 Transpower New LUC - 21/02/2002 21/02/2037 To undertake works in the bed of a tributary of Wairiri Stream in association with Wairiri Stream 1765381 5460785 Zealand Ltd STREAMWORK the permanent diversion of the stream to protect an access road from further erosion. 21787 WGN020113 Transpower New WP - SURFACE 21/02/2002 21/02/2037 To divert a 50 metre section of a tributary of Wairiri Stream away from the ture Wairiri Stream 1765381 5460785 Zealand Ltd WATER right bank. DIVERSION 21837 WGN020132 Judgeford Golf Club WP - SURFACE 08/03/2002 08/03/2012 Take water from the Pauatahanui Stream for irrigation Judgeford Golf Club 1762980 5446086 WATER TAKE 21853 WGN020135 Wrc, Forestry Dept. WP - SURFACE 04/04/2002 04/04/2037 To dam and divert water in a tributary of the Horokiri Stream in association with Battle Hill Regional 1763080 5452985 DIVERSION the construction of four ponds within Battle Hill Regional Park. Park 21926 WGN020135 Wellington Regional LUC - DAM 04/04/2002 04/04/2037 To construct five earth dams in an unnamed tributary of the Horokiri Stream in Battle Hill Regional 1763080 5452985 Recreat STRUCTURE association with the construction of four ponds in Battle Hill Regional Park 21879 WGN020147 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 06/03/2002 06/03/2037 Culvert headwall structure installed in Pauatahanui Stream to prevent Pauatahanui Stream 1762624 5446430 CROSSING stormwater flooding on SH58. 21911 WGN020158 Lockett, Riley LUC - VEG 10/04/2002 10/04/2017 Vegetation disturbance in connection with harvesting 108.4 hectares of radiata Silverwood Forest, 1758680 5444186 DISTURBANCE pine. Whitby. 21911 WGN020158 Lockett, Riley LUC - VEG 10/04/2002 10/04/2017 Vegetation disturbance in connection with harvesting 108.4 hectares of radiata Silverwood Forest, 1758680 5444186 DISTURBANCE pine. Whitby. 21947 WGN020170 Whitby Coastal WP - SURFACE 16/04/2002 17/04/2012 To take and use water from Duck Creek for golf club irrigation purposes Duck Creek 1759080 5446786 Estates WATER TAKE 21948 WGN020171 Gwrc, Flood LUC - GENERAL 12/04/2002 12/04/2037 To upgrade and repair an existing debris arrestor and the eroded bank edge, and Porirua Stream 1753279 5438387 Protection STRUCTURE to undertake associated disturbance of the bed of the Porirua Stream. 21972 WGN020175 Wellington Regional LUC - RIVER 02/05/2002 02/05/2037 Existing structure will be removed and bed material reshaped. Concrete blocks Western Branch Of 1762680 5452985 Recreat CROSSING will be placed perpendicular to the stream's flow and finished to the same height Horokiri Stream as the existing structure. 21986 WGN020178 Deuss, Eberhard WP - DAM 27/05/2002 27/05/2037 To provide a pond for the applicant 462 Paekakariki Hill 1762780 5451485 Road

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 3 OF 19

21987 WGN020178 Deuss, Eberhard WP - SURFACE 27/05/2002 27/05/2037 To provide a stable overflow for a dam 462 Paekakariki Hill 1762780 5451485 DIVERSION Road 21988 WGN020178 Deuss, Eberhard LUC - 27/05/2002 27/05/2037 An earth dam and overflow diversion to make a pretty pond for the applicant, and 462 Paekakariki Hill 1762780 5451485 STREAMWORK to provide something to stick a boundary fence on. Road 22027 WGN020195 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 30/05/2002 30/05/2037 To construct 4 bridges over the Kenepuru Stream and to undertake associated Kenepuru Stream 1755680 5444686 CROSSING disturbance of the bed. 22038 WGN020201 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 07/06/2002 07/06/2037 Reclaim and place pipe in open stormwater drain. Unnamed Stormwater 1756780 5449486 Transport Agency CROSSING Drain 22054 WGN020206 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 21/06/2002 21/06/2037 To divert the Mitchel Stream back to its original alignment, to prevent further Mitchell Stream 1752580 5442287 DIVERSION erosion of the bank in an area wher a public footpath is present. 22116 WGN020239 Wrc, Bulk Water LUC - GENERAL 15/07/2002 15/07/2037 To install a headwall in the bed of an unnamed stream. Unnamed Tributary 1756879 5441986 Dept. STRUCTURE Of The Takapu Str 22117 WGN020239 Wrc, Bulk Water LUC - GENERAL 15/07/2002 15/07/2037 To install a headwall and a debris trap in Duck Creek. Duck Creek 1758079 5442786 Dept. STRUCTURE 22180 WGN030018 Wellington City LUC - RIVER 09/09/2002 09/09/2037 To place, use and maintain a stormwater outlet structure, and to undertake Porirua Stream 1753880 5442786 Council CROSSING associated disturbance of the bed of the Porirua Stream. 22232 WGN030034 Wellington City LUC - HAZARD 30/09/2002 30/09/2037 Construct concrete blockwall and realign small reach of Takapu Stream Takapu Stream 1753779 5439537 Council - Drainage MITIGATION 22233 WGN030034 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 30/09/2002 30/09/2037 Divert flow of Takapu Stream in connection with construction of a concrete Takapu Stream 1753779 5439537 Council - Drainage DIVERSION blockwall and realignment of a small reach of the stream. 22238 WGN030036 Whitby Coastal LUC - GENERAL 25/11/2003 25/11/2038 To install three stormwater outlet structures in the bed of duck creek. College Rise 1759380 5446386 Estates STRUCTURE 22313 WGN030036 Whitby Coastal LUC - GENERAL 31/10/2003 25/11/2038 Install a sewer pipe across Duck Creek in order to link up with the existing Part Of Former Duck 1759380 5446386 Estates STRUCTURE infrastructure on the southern side of Duck Creek. Creek Golf Cour 23992 WGN030055 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 08/11/2002 08/11/2037 To place and maintain erosion protection works at five locations along the banks Kenepuru Stream 1754980 5444386 MITIGATION of the Kenepuru Stream. 22336 WGN030057 Ballandean Properties LUC - HAZARD 05/06/2007 05/06/2042 To place and maintain erosion protection works along the banks of the Takapu 47 Takapu Road, 1753879 5439587 Limited MITIGATION Stream. Tawa 22351 WGN030061 Alois, Heigl WP - DAM 09/01/2003 09/01/2038 Water damed to create four ponds 53 Murphys Road 1762280 5446086 22352 WGN030061 Alois, Heigl LUC - 09/01/2003 09/01/2038 Four earth dams 58 Murphys Road 1762280 5446086 STREAMWORK 22364 WGN030061 Alois, Heigl LUC - RIVER 09/01/2003 09/01/2038 Driveway culvert 58 Murphys Road 1762280 5446086 CROSSING 22365 WGN030061 Alois, Heigl WP - SURFACE 09/01/2003 09/01/2038 Diversion of stream through series of dam overflows 53 Murphys Road 1762280 5446086 DIVERSION 22484 WGN030078 Porirua City Council WP - DAM 09/05/2003 09/05/2038 To permanently dam water in association with the construction of a permanent Aotea Block 1755580 5445486 sediment retention pond. Development 22577 WGN030078 Porirua City Council LUC - DAM 09/05/2038 To construct a permanent dam in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Aotea Aotea Block 1755580 5445486 STRUCTURE Lagoon. Development 22399 WGN030082 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 06/12/2002 06/12/2037 To place and maintain a floating platform over the bed of the Whitby Lower Lake. Whitby Lakes 1758880 5446486 STRUCTURE 22416 WGN030088 Whitby Coastal LUC - RIVER 24/12/2002 24/12/2037 Place an 825 mm diameter culvert extension, and to retrospectively authorise Tributary Of 1760380 5446886 Estates CROSSING another section of 825 mm diameter culvert, and also associated works, including Pauatahanui outlet structure(s). 22417 WGN030088 Whitby Coastal WP - SURFACE 24/12/2002 24/12/2037 Divert the stream flow from the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Tributary Of Pauatah 1760380 5446886 Estates DIVERSION Stream, through sections of an 825 mm diameter culvert, and to return flow to that same stream 22492 WGN030120 Clarke, Stephen LUC - RIVER 12/02/2003 12/02/2038 To place, use and maintain a pipe culvert for access purposes in the bed of an 50 Flightys Road, 1762580 5446786 CROSSING unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream, and associated disturbance of that Pauatahanui tributary. 22498 WGN030121 Taare, L And R M, LUC - RIVER 19/03/2003 19/03/2038 To place, use and maintain a culvert in the bed of an unnamed stream for vehicle 795 Moonshine Road, 1767080 5448485 Opie CROSSING access purposes, and to undertake associated disturbance of that streambed. Porirua 22528 WGN030129 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 19/02/2003 19/02/2038 To place, use and maintain a 1000mm dia pipe culvert in the bed of an unnamed Curtis Flat, Puketiro 1765880 5452985 CROSSING tributary of the Wainui Stream for road access for logging trucks. Forest 22560 WGN030146 Gwrc, Flood LUC - 10/03/2003 10/03/2018 Land use consent to extract gravel from the bed of the Porirua Stream to Porirua Stream, 1754680 5443886 Protection STREAMWORK maintain the flood carrying capacity of the stream. Porirua City Centre 22601 WGN030166 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - 26/03/2003 26/03/2038 To extend an existing culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Wainui Curtis Flat, Puketiro 1765880 5452985 STREAMWORK Stream for logging road purposes. Forest 22602 WGN030167 Juchnovicz, Stan LUC - GENERAL 21/10/2003 21/10/2038 Car deck and stormwater outlet over the bed of the Porirua Stream. Porirua Stream 1753277 5440562 STRUCTURE 22610 WGN030173 Wrc, Biosecurity LUC - RIVER 15/04/2003 15/04/2038 To replace an existing bridge; to install retaining walls; and to undertake Belmont Regional 1756880 5442886 Dept. (Upper Hutt) CROSSING associated disturbance of the bed of Cannon's Creek. Park

PAGE 4 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

22642 WGN030188 Belvista Subdivisions LUC - GENERAL 08/04/2003 08/04/2038 To place, use and maintain a sewer pipe bridge over the bed of an unnamed 144 Tirohanga Road, 1759479 5437786 STRUCTURE watercourse. Lower Hutt 22643 WGN030188 Belvista Subdivisions LUC - RIVER 08/04/2003 08/04/2038 To place, use and maintain a pipe culvert in the bed of a watercourse to allow 144 Tirohanga Road, 1759479 5437786 CROSSING road access. Lower Hutt 22770 WGN030261 Gwrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 10/06/2003 10/06/2038 To lower and reconstruct an existing concrete ford, to place, use and maintain Whakatikei River 1769381 5456785 Dept. STREAMWORK rock rip-rap at the toe of the ford at unnamed tributary of the Whakatikei Ri 22847 WGN030293 Gwrc, Parks & Forests DP - SEWAGE / 08/09/2003 08/09/2018 To discharge sullage and septic tank effluent from a 4-cubicle toilet block to land Whareroa Beach, 1765781 5464085 Dept. SLUDGES via a soakage field Queen Elizabeth 22848 WGN030293 Gwrc, Parks & Forests DP - SEWAGE / 08/09/2003 08/09/2018 To discharge sullage and septic tank effluent from a 6-cubicle toilet block to land Mckays Crossing, 1766481 5462685 Dept. SLUDGES via a soakage field Queen Elizabeth 22873 WGN040005 Rodgers, Gary LUC - 22/07/2003 22/07/2038 35 gabion baskets will be installed in total. 20 will be placed over a 30m stretch Te Puka Stream 1765381 5461485 STREAMWORK of the true-left bank and 10 will be placed on the true-right bank over a 10m stretch. 22884 WGN040008 Turner, Keith LUC - GENERAL 22/07/2003 22/07/2038 To place and maintain an energy dissipation structure in the bed of an unnamed Turners Property 1759081 5455586 STRUCTURE watercourse at the end of the pipe outlet for the periodic diversion of the unnamed watercourse. 22896 WGN040013 Gray Family Trust LUC - RIVER 27/08/2003 27/08/2038 To place, use and maintain a culvert in a tributary of Speedy's Stream. 228 Hill Road, 1760479 5439486 CROSSING Belmont 22987 WGN040021 J & M J Walsh LUC - GENERAL 21/11/2003 21/11/2038 Precast headwall and gabion basket energy 206 Park Road, 1760579 5438786 Grandchildren STRUCTURE Belmont Hills, 25508 WGN040021 J & M J Walsh LUC - GENERAL 21/11/2003 21/11/2038 To construct and maintain a sewer main beneath the bed of an unnamed 206 Park Road 1760579 5438786 Grandchildren STRUCTURE tributary of the Hutt River, and to undertake the associated disturbance of the bed of that tributary. 22984 WGN040053 Leslie, Warren DP - DISCHARGE 29/09/2003 29/09/2013 Discharge from abrasive blasting involved with glass frosting operation Metal Immersions, 1753980 5442986 TO AIR Tawa 23035 WGN040073 Porirua City Council LUC - 21/10/2003 21/10/2038 To reclaim a section of the bed of the Kenepuru Stream with the placement and Kenepuru Stream, 1755180 5444586 STREAMWORK maintenance of erosion protection works Porirua 23100 WGN040073 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 21/10/2003 21/10/2038 To permanently divert the Kenepuru Stream, and to undertake associated Kenepuru Stream 1755180 5444586 DIVERSION disturbance of the bed of that stream. 23094 WGN040101 Ferguson, Scott DP - DISCHARGE 05/11/2003 05/11/2013 To discharge contaminants to air associated with the operation of a concrete 5 Kinleith Grove, 1753280 5442687 TO AIR batching plant producing ready-mix concrete. Kenepuru, Porirua 23289 WGN040115 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 09/12/2003 09/12/2038 To take, by means of an underground drainage system, groundwater Northern Landfill 1753379 5437687 Council WATER TAKE contaminated with leachate for disposal to the sewerage system. 23387 WGN040115 Wellington City DP - LANDFILL 09/12/2003 09/12/2038 To change condition 14 and cancel condition 16 - To discharge contaminants into Northern Landfill 1753379 5437687 Council DISCHARGE land, groundwater and air following closure of the Northern Landfill. 23130 WGN040122 Kapiti Coast District WP - 04/10/2003 31/07/2015 Water permit to take water from an existing bore to supplement the Paekakariki Paekakariki Water 1765614 5461343 Council GROUNDWATER public water supply. Treatment Plant 23143 WGN040129 Porirua City Council LUC - 03/11/2003 03/11/2038 To construct and maintain a concrete block wall in, and to carry out the Moonshine Road, 1766580 5448185 STREAMWORK associated disturbance of, the bed of Moonshine Stream Judgeford 23148 WGN040134 Sang Sue Limited, WP - 20/02/2007 20/02/2017 To take groundwater from an existing bore for the irrigation of vegetables. 347 Sh1, Paekakariki 1765646 5461467 Kevin GROUNDWATER 25839 WGN040134 Sang Sue Limited, WP - 20/02/2007 20/02/2017 To take groundwater from an existing PVC bore for domestic and shop use. 347 State Highway 1 1765649 5461465 Kevin GROUNDWATER Paekarariki 23194 WGN040159 Turner, I C LUC - RIVER 27/11/2003 27/11/2038 To place, use and maintain an abutment structure, a retaining wall structure and 405 Paekakariki Hill 1762280 5451085 CROSSING a concrete tongue/nose structure in the bed of Horokiri Stream. Road, Porirua 23213 WGN040168 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 08/12/2003 08/12/2038 3 small culverts in small tributaries of Wainui Stream. Puketiro Forest, 1765780 5453185 CROSSING Akatarawa 23213 WGN040168 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 08/12/2003 08/12/2038 3 small culverts in small tributaries of Wainui Stream. Puketiro Forest, 1765780 5453185 CROSSING Akatarawa 23317 WGN040178 J Miller & Rg & Jm LUC - HAZARD 11/02/2004 11/02/2039 Removal of existing erosion protection structures, and construction of a new 44 And 40 Ames 1763875 5460500 Thornton MITIGATION retaining wall in the bed of the Waikakariki Stream, Paekakariki Street, Paekakariki 23318 WGN040207 Gwrc, Parks & Forests LUC - RIVER 26/01/2004 26/01/2039 To reinstate two washed out footbridges across the Horokiri Stream Horokiri Stream 1762480 5453585 Dept. CROSSING 23339 WGN040217 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 09/02/2004 09/02/2039 To replace a culvert to improve the control of stormwater during heavy rainfall North Of Mackays 1767181 5463585 Transport Agency CROSSING and to reduce flooding on State Highway 1. Crossing 23370 WGN040228 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 16/06/2004 16/06/2039 To install and maintain rock rip-rap in two locations along an unnamed tributary Moonshine Road, 1765980 5448085 MITIGATION of the Pauatahanui Stream to repair road washouts and for erosion protection Pauatahanui purposes 23371 WGN040228 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 16/06/2004 16/06/2039 To install and maintain concrete blocks in three locations along an unnamed Moonshine Rd, 1766580 5448185 MITIGATION tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream to repair road washouts and for erosion Pauatahanui protection purposes 23372 WGN040228 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 16/06/2004 16/06/2039 To divert the flow of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream (at Location 1, 1765580 5447785 DIVERSION Location 1) for erosion protection purposes. Moonshine Rd,

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 5 OF 19

23373 WGN040228 Porirua City Council LUC - 16/06/2004 16/06/2039 To undertake works to construct a new channel and install and maintain rock rip- Location 1, 1765580 5447785 STREAMWORK rap in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream (at Location 1) Moonshine Rd, 23413 WGN040244 Transpower New LUC - 12/02/2004 12/02/2039 To undertake flood repair works, including the placement and maintenance of Te Puka Stream 1765681 5461385 Zealand Ltd STREAMWORK erosion protection works, in the bed of Te Puka Stream 1 23414 WGN040244 Transpower New WP - SURFACE 12/02/2004 12/02/2039 To undertake both permanent and temporary diversions of fresh water in the bed Te Puka Stream 1765681 5461385 Zealand Ltd DIVERSION of Te Puka Stream to enable basic four wheel drive access for maintenance and emergency works 23450 WGN040244 Transpower New LUC - 12/02/2004 12/02/2039 To reclaim part of the bed of Te Puka Stream to enable basic four wheel drive Te Puka Stream 1765681 5461385 Zealand Ltd RECLAMATION access for maintenance and emergency works associated with the Paekakariki- Takapu Road 23451 WGN040244 Transpower New LUC - RIVER 12/02/2004 12/02/2039 To place and maintain river crossings in the bed of Te Puka Stream to enable Te Puka Stream 1765681 5461385 Zealand Ltd CROSSING basic four wheel drive access for mainteance and emergency works 23883 WGN040246 Rodgers, Gary LUC - GENERAL 15/03/2004 15/03/2039 To place, use and maintain a high-pressure gas pipeline in the bed of a tributary Tributary Of 1766781 5462585 STRUCTURE of the Whareroa Stream and an unnamed watercourse Whareroa Stream 23419 WGN040247 Doran, Mr Terry LUC - RIVER 25/05/2007 25/05/2042 To use and maintain a footbridge over the bed of the Pauatahanui Stream, and 346b - 1763397 5446113 CROSSING the associated disturbance of the bed of that stream during the works. Haywards Road 23510 WGN040263 Cox, Ron LUC - 01/06/2004 01/06/2039 To, use and maintain a weir and concrete intake structure in the bed of the Little Little Waitangi 1762280 5450485 STREAMWORK Waitangi Stream, and the associated disturbance of the bed during the additional Stream works. 23473 WGN040266 Aquaheat Industries LUC - 11/03/2004 11/03/2039 To construct and maintain erosion protection works (i.e. Concrete blocks) in the Porirua Stream 1753179 5439987 Limited STREAMWORK bed and banks of the Porirua Stream, and to undertake associated disturbance 23520 WGN040284 Humpheries, Barry LUC - GENERAL 05/04/2004 05/04/2039 Land use consent to use and maintenance a pipe in the bed of a tributary of the Titahi Bay Golf Course 1755580 5448686 STRUCTURE Onepoto Stream. 23522 WGN040286 Doran, Mr Terry LUC - GENERAL 25/05/2004 25/05/2024 Concrete block erosion protection structure, gabion baskets and riparian 346b State Highway 1763380 5446085 STRUCTURE planting. 58, Judgeford 23560 WGN040295 Best Farm Limited LUC - SOIL 12/05/2004 12/05/2014 Land use consent to disturb soil on erosion prone land. Best Farm Limited 1751179 5438487 DISTURBANCE 23562 WGN040295 Best Farm Limited DP – STORMW TO 12/05/2004 12/05/2014 To discharge sediment laden stormwater to land from areas of bulk earthworks in Best Farm Ltd 1751179 5438487 LAND circumstances where it may enter water. 23657 WGN040295 Best Farm Limited WP - SURFACE 12/05/2004 12/05/2039 Diversion of intermittent watercourses associated with filling of streambeds as Best Farm Ltd 1751179 5438487 DIVERSION part of earthworks. 26430 WGN040295 Best Farm Limited DP - STORMW TO 08/10/2007 08/10/2014 To discharge sediment laden stormwater to land from areas of bulk earthworks in Amesbury Drive, 1751378 5438589 LAND circumstances where it may enter water. Churton Park 23623 WGN040307 Porirua City Council LUC - 12/05/2004 12/05/2039 To construct, use and maintain a pipe in, and carry out the associated disturbance 13 And 13A Te Hiko 1753980 5445786 STREAMWORK of, the bed of Takapuwahia Stream. Street, Porirua 23631 WGN040310 Dow, MR A LUC - RIVER 02/08/2004 02/08/2039 To construct, use and maintain a bridge over the western branch of the Horokiri 998 Paekakariki 1762681 5455685 CROSSING Stream. Road, Porirua 23653 WGN040310 Dow, MR A LUC - 02/08/2004 02/08/2039 To reshape the true right bank of the western branch of the Horokiri Stream, and 998 Paekakariki Hill 1762681 5455685 STREAMWORK to install and maintain concrete blocks and rock rip-rap for erosion protection Rd, Porirua purposes. 23639 WGN040315 Building Research LUC - 10/06/2004 10/06/2024 Replace temporary erosion protection with gabion baskes below pedestrian Building Reseach 1763880 5446785 Association Of Nz STREAMWORK bridge at Moonshine Road, Judgeford Association New Ze 23677 WGN040327 Carrus Limited WP - SURFACE 03/06/2005 03/06/2040 To dam and divert ephemeral tributaries of the Pauatahanui Stream associated Silverwood Block, 1759780 5446186 DIVERSION with the construction and maintenance of five sediment retention ponds. Whitby, Porirua C 23678 WGN040327 Carrus Limited DP - STORMW TO 03/06/2005 03/06/2015 To discharge contaminated stormwater to land in circumstances where Silverwood Block, 1759780 5446185 LAND contaminants, namely sediment, may enter the water of unnamed tributaries of Whitby, Porirua C the Pauatahanui Stream. 23956 WGN040327 Carrus Limited LUC - DAM 03/06/2005 03/06/2040 To construct and maintain five dams in ephemeral tributaries of the Pauatahanui Silverwood Block, 1759780 5446185 STRUCTURE Stream associated with the construction and maintenance of five sediment Whitby, Porirua C retention ponds. 23960 WGN040327 Carrus Limited LUC - 03/06/2005 03/06/9999 To reclaim the beds of four ephemeral tributaries of the Pauatahanui Stream. Silverwood Block, 1759780 5446185 RECLAMATION Whitby, Porirua C 23837 WGN050020 Tawa School LUC - 22/09/2004 22/09/2024 Gabion protection structure to prevent further erosion at an area where a slip has Porirua Stream 1753247 5440186 STREAMWORK occured. 23919 WGN050051 Colonial Knobb Farm WP - SURFACE 30/09/2004 30/09/2039 To divert the flow of two unnamed tributaries of the Mitchell Stream in 32 Broken Hill Rd, 1753080 5442887 Holdings Ltd DIVERSION association with the operation of a cleanfill. Porirua 23923 WGN050053 Milsom, Murray A LUC - 29/09/2004 29/09/2024 To place, use and maintain two reno mattress ford structures, gabion baskets and Pearce Stream, 96 1761280 5445886 STREAMWORK rock rip-rap in the bed of Pearce Stream a tributary of Pauatahanui Stream Belmont Road 23926 WGN050056 Elms, Peter J LUC - RIVER 21/12/2005 21/12/2040 To extend a culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui 17 Scoresby Grove, 1760680 5447186 CROSSING Stream. Whitby 23927 WGN050057 Budgen, Graham & LUC - 21/02/2005 21/02/2040 To place, use and maintain erosion protection structures in the true right bank of 346a State Highway 1763485 5446102 Wendy STREAMWORK the Pauatahanui Stream. 58, Pauatahanui, 23998 WGN050089 Wellington City LUC - 23/11/2004 23/11/2039 Land use consent to place and maintain rock rip-rap and concrete blocks in the Porirua Stream, 1753280 5440887

PAGE 6 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

Council STREAMWORK Porirua Stream for erosion protection purposes Behind Oxford St, T 24049 WGN050116 Aqua Installations & LUC - 17/12/2004 17/12/2014 To construct a trench under a pipeline in order to gain access to it to carry out Takapu Stream 1753979 5439687 Maintenance STREAMWORK blasting. 24056 WGN050121 Luke Lee & Jacqui WP - DAM 17/12/2004 17/12/2039 To construct a permanent dam in the bed of an intermittently flowing tributary of 107-119 Flightys Road, 1762480 5447186 Fairbrother the Pauatahanui Stream. Pauatahanui 24058 WGN050121 Luke Lee & Jacqui LUC - 17/12/2004 17/12/2039 To place, use and maintain a 525mm pipe and dam in the bed of an intermittently 107-119 Flightys Road, 1762480 5447186 Fairbrother STREAMWORK flowing tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream. Pauatahanui 24060 WGN050123 Porirua City Council LUC - 01/12/2004 01/12/2039 To lay a water pipe across the kenepuru Stream, under the streambed. Kenepuru Stream, 1755024 5444429 STREAMWORK Porirua 24081 WGN050131 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 21/12/2004 21/12/2039 To construct and maintain a concrete cleaning apron beneath the existing debris Court Road, Tawa 1753479 5440487 Council STRUCTURE arrestor in the bed of an unnamed stream, to construct and maintain an access ramp 24097 WGN050141 Wharfe, KP & LP LUC - 15/02/2005 15/02/2040 Land use consent to remove, replace, use and maintain an existing culvert and to Haywards/Wharfe's 1762222 5443492 STREAMWORK regrade a section of bed in an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream. Quarry 24142 WGN050165 Barry Humphreys & LUC - 16/03/2005 16/03/2040 To place, use and maintain two 7.5 metre pipe culverts for access purposes in the 10 Paekakariki Hill 1761073 5447706 Rhys Phillips STREAMWORK bed of an unnamed watercourse, and to undertake associated disturbance in the Road, Pauatahan bed of that watercourse. 24148 WGN050170 Wellington City LUC - RIVER 03/02/2005 03/02/2040 To pipe approximately 30 metres of an unnamed tributary of Porirua Stream, and 44 And 46 Handyside 1753980 5442586 Council CROSSING to upsize approximately 23 metres of existing pipe in the bed of the same stream, St, Tawa for flood protection purposes. 24153 WGN050173 Kapiti Coast District LUC - 20/01/2005 20/01/2020 To extract gravel to create a sediment retention pond and to maintain cross Te Puka Stream, 1765368 5461090 Council STREAMWORK sections at pre Oct 2003 bed levels. Paekakariki 24161 WGN050173 Kapiti Coast District LUC - 26/01/2005 26/01/2020 To extract gravel from behind two gravel retention weirs in an ephemeral Unnamed Tributary 1763928 5459475 Council STREAMWORK tributary of the Waikakariki Stream. Of The Waikakarik 24162 WGN050173 Kapiti Coast District LUC - HAZARD 26/01/2005 26/01/2020 To improve and legalise two existing sediment retention weirs across an Unnamed Tributary 1763928 5459475 Council MITIGATION ephemeral tributary of the Waikakariki Stream. Of The Waiakakari 24272 WGN050179 Judd, Darren WP - SURFACE 06/04/2005 06/04/2040 Permantent diversion of the unnamed intermittanlty flowing tributary of Speedys 76 Sweetacres Drive, 1759979 5438786 DIVERSION Stream through a sub soil drain in the base of the cleanfill Belmont, 24282 WGN050179 Judd, Darren LUC - 06/04/2005 06/04/2040 To place a pipe in the form of a sub soil drain in the bed of an unnamed 76 Sweetacres Drive, 1759979 5438786 STREAMWORK intermittanly flowing tributary of Speedys Stream Belmont 24245 WGN050206 Janis, Mr Mark LUC - 20/04/2005 20/04/2040 To place and maintain rock rip-rap along the bank of the Horokiri Stream, and to Horokiri Stream, 1762745 5451525 STREAMWORK disturb gravels in the bed of the Horokiri Stream, for erosion protection Paekakariki Hill R purposes. 24247 WGN050208 Heather Phillips & LUC - HAZARD 21/04/2005 21/04/2040 To construct an associated bed control structure in the tributary for erosion 930 Moonshine Road 1766166 5448125 Donald Love MITIGATION protection. 24258 WGN050212 Carrus Limited LUC - 12/05/2005 12/05/9999 To reclaim sections of three ephemeral tributaries of Kenepuru Stream. Stage Iv Aotea Block 1756380 5445186 RECLAMATION 24266 WGN050215 Jacobson, Michael LUC - GENERAL 12/07/2005 12/07/2020 To install gabions in the bed of Moonshine Stream for erosion protection 1119 Moonshine Rd, 1764380 5447985 STRUCTURE purposes, and to undertake the associated disturbance of the bed of that stream. Porirua 24273 WGN050217 Colonial Knobb Farm LUC - RIVER 01/04/2005 01/04/2040 To place, use and maintain a culvert in the bed of Mitchell Stream for vehicle 32 Broken Hill Road, 1752880 5442587 Holdings Ltd CROSSING crossing purposes, and to undertake associated disturbance of the bed of that Porirua stream. 24289 WGN050224 Lennon, Barry & LUC - RIVER 03/05/2005 03/05/2040 To construct a footbridge over the Pautahanui Stream and undertake associated Pauatahanui Stream, 1764695 5446133 Claire CROSSING disturbance of the streambed. 24295 WGN050226 Porirua City Council LUC - 21/06/2005 21/06/2040 Place, use and maintain concrete blocks along the true right bank. Unnamed Tributary 1766780 5448355 STREAMWORK Of The Pauatahanu 24326 WGN050235 Gwrc, Plantation LUC - RIVER 01/04/2005 01/04/2040 To replace and extend a culvert in an unnamed tributary to the Wainui Stream Puketiro Forest Block 1766580 5452885 Forestry CROSSING (East) 24345 WGN050246 New Zealand WP - SURFACE 09/06/2005 09/06/2040 To permanetly divert the stream Paukumu/Reservoir 1765230 5461363 Transport Agency DIVERSION Stream 24346 WGN050246 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 09/06/2005 09/06/2040 To place, use & maintain a culvert, debris arresting structures & concrete ford in Paukumu/Reservoir 1765230 5461363 Transport Agency CROSSING the bed of the stream Stream 24372 WGN050252 Gwrc, Parks & Forests WP - SURFACE 29/04/2005 29/04/2040 To divert water into existing damp areas during periods of high flows in the Whareroa Stream 1766391 5464354 Dept. DIVERSION Whareroa Stream 24385 WGN050257 Gwrc, Strategy & LUC - 06/05/2005 06/05/2040 To realign a section of a tributary of the Takapu Stream and construct erosion Tributary Of The 1754382 5439657 Assets STREAMWORK protection works to protect the Te Marua water supply main Takapu Stream 24386 WGN050257 Gwrc, Strategy & WP - SURFACE 06/05/2005 06/05/2040 To divert the flow of a tributary of the Takapu Stream away from the Te Marua Tributary Of Takapu 1754356 5439710 Assets DIVERSION water supply main Stream 24438 WGN050257 Gwrc, Strategy & LUC - To reclaim a section of the bed of a tributary of the Takapu Stream Tributary Of The 1754356 5439710 Assets RECLAMATION Takapu Stream 24535 WGN050263 Kapiti Coast District LUC - 12/07/2005 12/07/2020 To extract gravel from the Waikakariki Stream, and undertake assocaited Waikakariki Stream, 1764377 5460003 Council STREAMWORK disturbance of the stream bed. Paekakariki

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 7 OF 19

24408 WGN050267 Cox, Ron WP - USE 25/05/2005 25/05/2015 To take and use surface water from Little Waitangi Stream. Little Waitangi 1763180 5450185 Stream, Paekakariki 24424 WGN050273 Gwrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 08/08/2005 08/08/2040 To realign a section ofa tributary of the Whareroa Stream and to construct 3 Whareroa Stream, 1766401 5463095 Dept. STREAMWORK culverts in the bed of that stream and associated disturbance to the stream bed Queen Elizabeth Pa 24425 WGN050273 Gwrc, Parks & Forests WP - SURFACE 08/08/2005 08/08/2040 To divert the full flow of a section of a tributary of Whareroa Stream Queen Elizabeth Park 1766381 5463085 Dept. DIVERSION 24450 WGN050280 Tortell, Philip & LUC - 26/05/2005 26/05/2025 A rock ramp in the Waikakariki Stream Waikakariki Stream 1763851 5460483 Dorothy STREAMWORK 24477 WGN050294 Mana College DP - DISCHARGE 30/08/2005 30/08/2020 Discharge of contaminants into the air from natural fas fired boilers with a total Mana College, Porirua 1753746 5445486 TO AIR combined energy rating of 950 kw 24515 WGN050346 Rattray, Ian LUC - 14/07/2005 14/07/2040 To place, use and maintain retaining walls on both banks of an unnamed Between 39 And 41 1753580 5441487 STREAMWORK watercourse in the Porirua Stream Catchment and undertake the associated Duncan Street, Ta disturbance 24629 WGN060016 Deery, Raymond & LUC - RIVER 23/08/2005 23/08/2040 Place, use and maintain a culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Hutt 144 Tirohanga Road 1759584 5437963 Marie CROSSING River to provide vehicle access. 24672 WGN060029 Clarke, Bruce DP - DISCHARGE 15/03/2006 15/03/2016 To discharge contaminants to air from a wallpaper manufacturing operation and 6 Mohuia Cres, 1753980 5444986 TO AIR associated activities. Elsdon, Porirua 24686 WGN060033 Gray, Joy LUC - 29/11/2005 29/11/2040 To install and maintain concrete block groynes along the banks of the Kakaho Kakaho Stream, 269 1759423 5450310 STREAMWORK Stream for erosion protection purposes Grays Rd 24891 WGN060038 Porirua City Council LUC - 08/12/2005 12/10/2040 To extract gravel and debris from the Kakaho Stream and the Horokiri Stream, Kakaho & Horokiri 1759080 5449786 STREAMWORK including any temporary diversion and associated disturbance of the stream beds. Stream Bridges, G 24891 WGN060038 Porirua City Council LUC - 08/12/2005 12/10/2040 To extract gravel and debris from the Kakaho Stream and the Horokiri Stream, Kakaho & Horokiri 1759080 5449786 STREAMWORK including any temporary diversion and associated disturbance of the stream beds. Stream Bridges, G 24702 WGN060042 Vries, Frank De LUC - 17/10/2005 17/10/2040 2 sections of conc block and crib walls (2 rows conc blocks with crib wall above). Porirua Stream, 82-86 1753179 5439987 STREAMWORK Planting in crib walls. Removal of gravel beach. Main Rd, Tawa 24706 WGN060043 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 19/10/2005 19/10/2040 To place, use and maintain two culverts alongside an existing culvert (located at Grays Road, 1760280 5448986 CROSSING Site C), including any temporary diversion and associated disturbance of the Pauatahanui Inlet, stream bed. 24717 WGN060049 Whitby Coastal LUC - GENERAL 10/08/2006 10/08/2041 To place, use and maintain various structures in, and over the bed of an unnamed Unnamed Tributary 1759480 5446286 Estates STRUCTURE tributary of Duck Creek Of Duck Creek 24718 WGN060049 Whitby Coastal WP - SURFACE 10/08/2006 10/08/2041 To permanently divert the full flow of an approximate 105 metre section and a 60 Unnamed Tributary 1759480 5446286 Estates DIVERSION metre section of an unnamed tributary of Duck Creek. Of Duck Creek 24719 WGN060049 Whitby Coastal DP - STORMW TO 10/08/2006 10/08/2016 To discharge stormwater (including stormwater treated by flocculation treatment Unnamed Tributary 1759480 5446286 Estates WATer systems) originating from an area of bulk earthworks greater than 0.3 of a Of Duck Creek hectare 24827 WGN060049 Whitby Coastal LUC - 10/08/2006 10/08/2016 To reclaim an approximate 105 metre length and a 60 metre length of an Unnamed Tributary 1759480 5446286 Estates RECLAMATION unnamed tributary of Duck Creek. Of Duck Creek 24780 WGN060064 Porirua City Council LUC - 14/11/2005 14/11/2040 Place concrete blocks in true right bank of stream where there are exisitng Unnamed Tributary 1766762 5448317 STREAMWORK concrete blocks. Of Pautahanui Str 24791 WGN060070 N Manthel & Jim LUC - 01/12/3005 01/12/2040 Land use consent to extend an existing culvert in an unnamed tributary of the Unnamed Tributary 1764541 5446156 Mcmenamin STREAMWORK Pauatahanui Stream, including the temporary diversion of the stream during Of The Pauatahanu construction 24826 WGN060086 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 15/11/2005 15/11/2015 To take water from two lakes in order to eradicate pest fish and plant species. Whitby Lakes, 1758768 5446156 WATER TAKE Discovery Drive, 24839 WGN060093 Pikarere Farm Ltd WP - DAM 18/11/2005 18/11/2040 Water permit to dam water at three locations in Mill Creek, at one location in an Pikarere Farm, 1750759 5443999 unnamed tributary of Mill Creek and at one location in an unnamed stream on Pikarere Road, Pikarere Farm. 24840 WGN060093 Pikarere Farm Ltd LUC - 18/11/2005 18/11/2040 Land use consent to construct and maintain three dams in Mill Creek, one dam in Pikarere Farm, 1750759 5443999 STREAMWORK an unnamed tributary of Mill Creek and one dam in an unnamed stream on Pikarere Road, Pikarere Farm, 24869 WGN060110 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 14/12/2005 15/12/2040 To construct use and maintain a bridge over an unnamed tributary of the Unnamed Tributary 1760124 5449124 CROSSING Horokiri Stream, including any associated disturbance of the bed of the stream. Of The Horokiri S 24875 WGN060113 Simpson, Barry LUC - GENERAL 06/12/2005 06/12/2040 To place use and maintain a pipeline over the Horokiri Stream 465 Paekakariki Hill 1762695 5451445 STRUCTURE Road, Pauataha 24917 WGN060138 Tony Oliver LUC - 03/11/2008 03/11/2043 To pipe a 15-metre section of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Inlet and 40 Staithes Drive 1757516 5447435 Construction STREAMWORK carry out associated disturbance of the stream bed. North, Whitby 24918 WGN060138 Tony Oliver DP - STORMW TO 03/11/2008 03/11/2013 To discharge contaminants, namely sediment, to land which may enter water, 40 Staithes Drive 1757516 5447435 Construction LAND from the development of an access crossing in the Pauatahanui Inlet catchment North, Whitby 25030 WGN060194 Gray Family Trust LUC - 14/02/2006 14/02/2041 228 Hill Road 1760615 5439497 STREAMWORK Belmont 25050 WGN060207 Porirua City Council LUC - 23/02/2006 23/02/2041 To extract gravel from various water bodies within the Pauatahanui and Horokiri Bridges/Culverts In 1760930 5447665 STREAMWORK Stream catchments, including associated disturbance of the stream beds Porirua 25072 WGN060215 Barber, MR J D LUC - GENERAL 07/03/2006 07/03/2041 1 Pre cast Hynds outlet servicing a 150mm UVPC pipe that will be set into the Unnamed Tributary 1753011 5440677

PAGE 8 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

STRUCTURE ground 1 rock structure using 300mm rocks that will support a 100mm UVPC Of The Porirua St pipe 25099 WGN060231 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 11/09/2006 11/09/2041 To place, use and maintain retaining walls and pole structures within the bed of Taupo Stream, 1756880 5450260 STRUCTURE the Taupo Stream and boardwalks over the Taupo Stream Plimmerton 25138 WGN060245 Porirua City Council LUC - 30/03/2006 30/03/2041 15m timber retaining wall and poles set into concrete blocks on the true right Horokiri Stream, 838 1762812 5454441 STREAMWORK bank of the Horokiri Stream Paekakariki Hi 25181 WGN060269 New Zealand LUC - 28/04/2006 28/04/2041 Installation of retaining wall and gravel extraction SH58 - Pauatahanui 1761280 5446586 Transport Agency STREAMWORK And Judgeford 25303 WGN060274 Wareham, Mr Grant WP - SURFACE 29/05/2006 29/05/2041 To permanently divert the flow of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Tributary Of The 1762786 5448307 Douglas DIVERSION Stream into two ponds, to improve the aesthetic appeal of the property. Pauatahanui 25671 WGN060284 Hayes, Barry LUC - RIVER 03/01/2007 03/01/2042 To place, use and maintain a culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of 118 Sweetacres Drive, 1760024 5438893 CROSSING Speedy Stream. Belmont, 25711 WGN060284 Hayes, Barry WP - SURFACE 03/01/2042 To divert water from the bed of an unnamed tributary of Speedy Stream, to 118 Sweetacres Drive, 1760024 5438893 DIVERSION undertake associated distubance and to discharge sediment laden water Belmont associated with that activity. 25258 WGN060290 Gwrc, Flood LUC - 11/05/2006 11/05/2016 To mow the batter slopes of the Lower Porirua Flood Protection Scheme with a Porirua Stream 1753953 5442896 Protection STREAMWORK tractor mounted reach mower to maintain a healthy grass cover for erosion and flood mitigation 25266 WGN060292 Charles, Leanne LUC - 09/08/2006 09/08/2021 To replace and lengthen a gabion basket structure in the bed of the Porirua Porirua Stream 1752369 5437021 STREAMWORK Stream, including any associated disturbance of the stream bed. 25300 WGN060304 Paekakariki DP - SEWAGE / 07/07/2006 07/07/2016 To discharge of contaminant-bearing effluent from an on-site wastewater 2 Beach Road, 1764181 5460785 Development SLUDGES treatment system into land Paekakariki 25301 WGN060305 Wellington City LUC - HAZARD 19/05/2006 19/05/2021 To place, use and maintain a gabion basket erosion protection wall in the bed of Takapu Stream, 1753541 5439137 Council STRUCTURE Takapu Stream, including any associated disturbance of the bed and temporary Willowbank Park, diversion of water. 25321 WGN060317 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 14/09/2006 14/09/2041 Land use consent to place, use and maintain a sewer pipeline at five crossings 6-54 Champion St, 1755135 5444448 STRUCTURE under the Kenupuru Stream. Porirua 25399 WGN060348 Marsden, Lindsay LUC - RIVER 07/09/2006 07/09/2041 To construct abridge over the Takapu Stream. Takapu Stream, 321 1755501 5441107 CROSSING Takapu Rd, Takap 25422 WGN070005 Simpson, Barry LUC - RIVER 09/08/2006 09/08/2041 Place, use and maintain a bridge across a tributary of the Horokiri Stream 465 Paekakariki Hill 1762720 5451485 CROSSING Road, Porirua 25488 WGN070028 Comerford, Bryan LUC - RIVER 19/10/2006 19/10/2041 To construct a culvert in the bed of the an unnamed tributary to the Pauatahanui 96 Belmont Rod 161 1761395 5445910 CROSSING stream catchment. State Hwy 58 25543 WGN070054 Marty Cook & Ritchi DP - STORMW TO 04/10/2006 04/10/2011 To discharge sediment laden stormwater from areas of bulk earthworks to land in 247d Paekakariki Hill 1760780 5450086 Smith LAND circumstances where it may enter surface water. Road, Pauatah 25548 WGN070057 Porirua City Council DP - STORMW TO 12/10/2006 12/10/2011 To discharge sediment laden water onto landwhere the contaminants may enter Elsdon Park, Porirua 1754074 5445491 LAND an unnamed tributary of the Porirua Stream. 25559 WGN070063 Jensen, Colin LUC - GENERAL 12/10/2006 12/10/2041 To place, use and maintain a pipe outlet and wing wall structure in the bed of the Takapu Stream 1753960 5439590 STRUCTURE Takapu Stream, and undertake assocoiated disturbance to the bed of that stream. 25646 WGN070099 Carrus Limited LUC - GENERAL 29/11/2006 29/11/2041 Watermain pipeline underneath Kenepuru Stream Bothamley Park, 1756645 5444750 STRUCTURE Kenepuru Stream 25647 WGN070100 Takapu Island WP - SURFACE 28/03/2007 28/03/2042 To permanently divert an unnamed trib of the Porirua Stream and an unnamed Takapu Island 1753496 5438847 Developments Ltd DIVERSION trib of the Takapu Stream 25649 WGN070100 Takapu Island LUC - 28/03/2007 28/03/2012 To fill a portion of the bed of an intermittanly flowing tributary of Porirua Stream Takapu Island 1753480 5438640 Developments Ltd RECLAMATION in conjunction with the earthworks for a commercial development 25650 WGN070100 Takapu Island DP - STORMW TO 28/03/2007 28/03/2012 Bulk earthwork over 6 hectares of a site the discharge may enter water of the Takapu Island, Tawa 1753496 5438847 Developments Ltd WATER Porirua and Takapu Streams or their tributaries 25695 WGN070120 Carrus Limited LUC - 30/03/2007 30/03/2012 To lay a pipe and to divert the flow of an unnamed stream that discharges into the Stage 8 Aotea Block, 1756010 5445904 RECLAMATION Porirua Harbour, associated with bulk earthworks for a subdivision. Whitford 25696 WGN070120 Carrus Limited WP - SURFACE 30/03/2007 30/03/2042 To permanently divert a section of an unmaend trib that discharges into Porirua Stage VIII Of The 1756003 5445892 DIVERSION Harbour Aotea Block 25941 WGN070120 Carrus Limited LUC - GENERAL 30/03/2007 30/03/2042 To place inlet and outlet structures in the stream bed Aotea Block, Whitford 1756016 5445827 STRUCTURE Brown 25707 WGN070124 Staithes Drive WP - DAM 24/05/2007 18/06/2012 To temporarily divert the full flow of Browns Stream and its permanently flowing Staithes Drive, Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd southern tributary associated with the construction and use of two ponds 2, Whitby 25708 WGN070124 Staithes Drive WP - SURFACE 24/05/2007 18/06/2042 To permanently divert the full flow of a permanently flowing tributary and six (6) Staithes Drive - Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd DIVERSION intermittently flowing tributaries of Browns Stream through pipes 2 25709 WGN070124 Staithes Drive DP - STORMW TO 24/05/2007 18/06/2012 To discharge storm water contaminated with sediment and chemical flocculant, Staithes Drive - Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd WATER 2 25797 WGN070124 Staithes Drive WP - DAM 18/06/2007 18/06/2042 To permanently dam the water of Browns Stream associated with the Staithes Drive - Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd construction and use of a permanent wetland. 2 25799 WGN070124 Staithes Drive LUC - 18/06/2007 To drain and reclaim sections of the beds of the permanently flowing southern Staithes Drive - Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd RECLAMATION tributary of Browns Stream and the permanently flowing Browns Stream. 2

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 9 OF 19

25802 WGN070124 Staithes Drive LUC - 18/06/2007 18/06/2042 To construct, use and maintain a permanent wetland in the bed of Browns Staithes Drive - Stage 1757538 5447290 Development Ltd STREAMWORK Stream, and associated pipes, and outlet and energy dissipation structures in the 2 bed of that stream 26008 WGN070124 Staithes Drive LUC - GENERAL 18/06/2007 18/06/2012 To construct, use and maintain two temporary sediment retention ponds in the Staithes Drive, Stage 2 1757280 5447186 Development Ltd STRUCTURE bed of Browns Stream and in the bed of its permanently flowing southern tributary 26009 WGN070124 Staithes Drive WP - SURFACE 18/06/2007 18/06/2042 To permanently divert the full flow of Browns Stream through an open channel, Staithes Drive - Stage 1757480 5447386 Development Ltd DIVERSION including any associated temporary diversions of this stream during construction 2 of this channel. 30563 WGN070124 Staithes Drive LUC - GENERAL 18/06/2007 18/06/2042 To place and use: pipes and associated inlet structures and outlet structures to Staithes Drive Stage 2 1757757 5446871 Development Ltd STRUCTURE those pipes, in the beds of intermittently flowing tributaries of Browns Stream;pipes and associated inlet 25744 WGN070135 M Shrimpton & A LUC - RIVER 12/01/2007 12/01/2042 The bridge span will be 13m and 4m wide. It is to be constructed of Hollowcore 61 Jones Deviation 1761414 5452363 Robb CROSSING units resting on concrete abutments. 25753 WGN070141 Budgen, Graham & LUC - 19/06/2008 19/06/2043 To place and use pipes and a concrete outlet structure in the bed of an unnamed 346c Paremata- 1764048 5445603 Wendy STREAMWORK stream of the Pauatahanui Stream catchment. Haywards Road 25754 WGN070141 Budgen, Graham & DP - DISCHARGE 19/06/2008 19/06/2018 To discharge to air contaminants arising from the periodic stockpiling of organic 346c Paremata- 1763940 5445895 Wendy TO AIR material, to be used on the cleanfill site for site rehabilitation. Haywards Rd 25850 WGN070141 Budgen, Graham & DP - DISCHARGE 19/06/2008 19/06/2018 To discharge contaminants to air arising from the operation of a cleanfill 346c Paremata- 1763940 5445895 Wendy TO AIR Haywards Rd 27120 WGN070141 Budgen, Graham & LUC - 19/06/2008 19/06/2013 To reclaim sections of the bed of an unnamed stream of the Pauatahanui Stream 346c Paremata- 1764048 5445603 Wendy RECLAMATION catchment, in association with the placement and use of pipes in the unnamed Haywards Rd stream. 27122 WGN070141 Budgen, Graham & DP - STORMW TO 19/06/2008 19/06/2018 To directly discharge sediment-laden water, which may contain traces of 346c Paremata- 1764048 5445603 Wendy WATER aluminium, from a flocculated sediment retention pond to the waters of an Haywards Rd, unnamed stream of the Pauatahanui 25786 WGN070150 Building Research LUC - 04/04/2007 04/04/2027 To reinstate 4 dislodged gabion baskets, and place additional gabions and erosion Branz, Moonshine 1763825 5446800 Association Of Nz STREAMWORK protectionin an unnamed tributary of Pauatahanui Stream Road, Judgeford 25801 WGN070159 Transit New Zealand LUC - GENERAL 29/05/2007 29/05/2042 Precast stormwater pipe outlet structure Southbound Sh1 1757280 5450986 STRUCTURE Plimmerton 25805 WGN070162 Pauatahanui School DP - SEWAGE / 28/02/2007 28/02/2017 To discharge a maximum of 5,040 litres/day of effluent onto land from a school Pauatahanui School 1761028 5447771 Bot SLUDGES Board Of Trustee 25831 WGN070173 Carrus Limited LUC - 14/03/2007 14/03/2012 To reclaim an unnamed tributary of Kenepuru stream associated with bulk Aotea Block, Whitford 1756000 5445354 RECLAMATION earthworks for a subdivision Brown 25951 WGN070208 Hunters Hill Limited LUC - 30/04/2007 30/04/2042 To culvert sections of two permanently flowing unnamed streams in the Porirua Lincolnshire Farm 1753870 5437411 RECLAMATION Stream catchment, associated with the construction of an access track. 25952 WGN070208 Hunters Hill Limited LUC - ROADING / 30/04/2007 30/04/2027 To construct and maintain a 1.2km long access track. Lincolnshire Farm 1753870 5437411 TRACKING 25975 WGN070214 Absolute Exterior Ltd DP - DISCHARGE 05/07/2007 05/07/2017 To discharge contaminants to air arising from the operation of a waste transfer 6 Kapuni Grove, 1753280 5442787 TO AIR station and resource recovery centre. Porirua 26074 WGN070251 Stressfactor DP - SEWAGE / 26/06/2008 26/06/2013 To discharge treated wastewater to land. Rushes Restaurant 1761031 5448128 Investments SLUDGES 26118 WGN070258 Wrc, Bioworks DP - DISCHARGE 11/07/2007 11/01/2020 To aerially discharge sodium monofluoroacetate (1080 poison) to land in a cereal 14500ha In 1758280 5446686 Business Unit TO LAND bait form Akatarawa Forest 26153 WGN070267 Robbins, Susan LUC - 08/08/2007 08/08/2012 To permanently reclaim approximately 20m of the beds of two intermittently Harris Road, 1764179 5444085 STREAMWORK flowing tributaries of the Pauatahanui Stream, for the purposes of establishing an Judgeford amenity area. 26195 WGN080013 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 02/08/2007 02/08/2042 To construct and use two footbridges over the bed of the Kenepuru Stream. Kenepuru Stream, 1757080 5445386 CROSSING Porirua 26340 WGN080094 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - 21/09/2007 21/09/2042 To construct 3 culverts in the bed of the Wainui Stream and 2 tributaries, Wainui Stream And 2 1766087 5453245 STREAMWORK including any associated disturbance to the stream beds and banks Tributaries 26906 WGN080138 Carrus Limited DP - STORMWTO 18/03/2008 18/03/2013 To discharge stormwater contaminated with sediment and chemical flocculant Aotea Block Stage Ix 1755341 5445409 WATER directly to an unnamed tributary of the Kenepuru Stream, 26907 WGN080138 Carrus Limited DP - STORMW TO 18/03/2008 18/03/2018 To discharge stormwater contaminated with sediment and chemical flocculant Central Recreation 1755962 5445406 WATER directly to unnamed tributary of the Kenepuru Stream Reserve 26908 WGN080138 Carrus Limited LUC - 18/03/2008 18/03/2043 To place subsoil drainage and reclaim a section of the bed of an intermittently Central Recreation 1756022 5445098 RECLAMATION flowing tributary of the Kenepuru Stream Reserve 26454 WGN080151 New Zealand LUC - 30/11/2007 30/11/2042 To undertake the following works within the bed of the Horokiri Stream: Place a Horokiwi Stream, 1763967 5453502 Transport Agency STREAMWORK rock rip-rap erosion protection structure; Proposed Transmisi 26513 WGN080187 Kelson Heights DP - STORMW TO 19/03/2009 19/03/2044 To discharge stormwater originating from an area of bulk earthworks greater Kaitangata Crescent & 1762096 5440193 Limited WATER than 0.3 ha 77 Waipounamu 26514 WGN080187 Kelson Heights WP - SURFACE 19/03/2009 19/03/2044 To divert (via pumping) the full flow of tributaries of Speedy's Stream Kaitangata Crescent & 1762096 5440193 Limited DIVERSION 77 Waipounamu

PAGE 10 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

26515 WGN080187 Kelson Heights LUC - 19/03/2009 19/03/2044 To reclaim the bed of permanent and intermittently flowing streams Kaitangata Crescent & 1762096 5440193 Limited RECLAMATION 77 Waipounamu 26545 WGN080209 Budgen, Graham & LUC - 21/12/2007 21/12/2042 To place, use and maintain a ford crossing on the Pauatahanui Stream 346c Paremata 1763468 5446106 Wendy STREAMWORK Haywards Road, 26579 WGN080228 Wellington City LUC - 13/02/2008 13/02/2028 To place, use and maintain a gabion basket erosion protection wall and rock rip- Porirua Stream 1753676 5442165 Council STREAMWORK rap in the bed of the Porirua Stream. 26585 WGN080234 Collyns, Jeremy LUC - ROADING / 07/03/2008 07/03/2013 To conduct works including earthworks associated with the removal of 15 729 Paekakariki Hill 1762064 5453858 TRACKING hectares of mature pine forest at 729 Paekakariki Hill Road. Road, Porirua 26657 WGN080280 Fogarty, J D LUC - RIVER 06/03/2009 06/03/2044 To construct a land bridge across a tributary of Mitchells Stream Colonial Knob, 1752226 5443570 CROSSING Porirua 26658 WGN080280 Fogarty, J D WP - DAM 06/03/2009 06/03/2044 To re-install a larger pipe under a land bridge to reduce ponding Colonial Knob, 1752226 5443570 Porirua 26688 WGN080305 Crestani, Bede WP - SURFACE 20/03/2008 20/03/2043 To permanently divert the full flow of the Ohariu Stream. 1029 Ohariu Valley 1751224 5440694 DIVERSION Road, Wellington 26689 WGN080305 Crestani, Bede LUC - RIVER 20/03/2008 20/03/2043 To undertake the following works: - place and use a culvert structure in the bed in 1029 Ohairu Valley 1751224 5440694 CROSSING the Ohariu Stream; and - reclaim a section of the stream bed of the Ohariu Road, Wellington Stream 26758 WGN080305 Crestani, Bede LUC - RIVER 05/06/2008 05/06/2043 To place and use a culvert structure in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the 1029 Ohariu Valley 1751206 5440693 CROSSING Ohariu Stream, including any associated disturbance of material in that stream Road bed 26760 WGN080357 Draper, Richard And LUC - RIVER 16/02/2009 16/02/2044 To construct a bridge structure over the bed of the Horokiri Stream including any 850c Paekakariki Hill 1763090 5454774 Carolyn CROSSING associated disturbance or deposition of material in that stream Road, Pauatah 26761 WGN080357 Draper, Richard And LUC - GENERAL 16/02/2009 16/02/2014 To construct two piped river crossings across a tributary of the Horokiwi Stream 850c Paekakariki Hill 1763152 5454789 Carolyn STRUCTURE Road, Pauatah 26762 WGN080357 Draper, Richard And DP - STORMW TO 16/02/2009 16/02/2014 To discharge sediment-laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks 850c Paekakariki Hill 1763090 5454774 Carolyn LANW associated with a rural residential subdivision to Horokiri Stream. Road, Pauatah 26763 WGN080357 Draper, Richard And LUC - SOIL 16/02/2009 16/02/2014 To construct a road with an upslope batter of 2 metres or more for a length over 850c Paekakariki Hill 1763090 5454774 Carolyn DISTURBANCE 200 metres. Road, Pauatah 27460 WGN080357 Draper, Richard And WP - SURFACE 16/02/2009 16/02/2014 To permanently divert the full flow of an unnamed tributary within the Horokiri 850c Paekakariki Hill 1763090 5454774 Carolyn DIVERSION Stream catchment. Road, Pauatah 26767 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber LUC – VEG 22/09/2008 22/09/2015 To undertake vegetation disturbance on erosion prone land associated with 314 Flightys Road, Rd 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) DISTURBANCE harvesting approximately 126.4 hectares of exotic pine forest. 1, Porirua 26879 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber LUC - SOIL 22/09/2008 22/09/2015 To undertake soil disturbance on erosion prone land with harvesting 314 Flightys Road, 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) DISTURBANCE approximately 126.4 hectares of exotic pine forest. Judgeford, Porir 26880 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber LUC - ROADING / 22/09/2008 22/09/2015 To disturb soil in association with constructing tracks with an upslope batter 314 Flightys Road, 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) TRACKING greater than 2 metres extending for a length greater than 200 metres. Judgeford, Porir 26881 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber LUC - RIVER 22/09/2008 22/09/2043 To place and use culvert structures and debris arrestors in unnamed tributaries of 314 Flightys Road, 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) CROSSING the Horokiri Stream Judgeford, Porir 26882 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber WP - SURFACE 22/09/2008 22/09/2043 To divert the full flow of a permanently flowing unnamed tributary of the 314 Flightys Road, 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) DIVERSION Horokiri Stream through a culvert structure. Judgeford, Porir 27187 WGN080361 Nzsf Timber DP – STORMW TO 22/09/2008 22/09/2015 To discharge sediment-laden water to land in circumstances where it may enter 314 Flightys Road, 1762930 5449080 Investments (No.3) LAND unnamed tributaries of the Horokiri Stream, in association with harvesting Judgeford, Porir plantation forestry. 27342 WGN080369 Carrus Corporation LUC - GENERAL 07/04/2008 07/04/2043 To place and use the following structures within the bed of an unnamed tributary Aotea Block 1756058 5444872 Limited STRUCTURE of the Kenepuru Stream Development, 27343 WGN080369 Carrus Corporation WP - SURFACE 07/04/2008 07/04/2043 To permanently dam and divert the flow of an unnamed tributary of the Aotea Development, 1756058 5444872 Limited DIVERSION Kenepuru Stream and associated wetland. Porirua 26787 WGN080372 Globe Holdings DP - STORMW TO 15/05/2008 15/05/2013 To discharge sediment laden water to land where it will enter an unnamed 52a Oakleigh Street, 1757311 5437282 Limited LAND tributary of the Korokoro Stream. Maungaraki 26788 WGN080373 Globe Holdings DP - STORMW TO 18/09/2008 18/09/2013 To discharge sediment laden water to land where it will enter water, from an area 32 Adventure Drive, 1758272 5446266 Limited LAND of bulk earthworks associated with a residential subdivision. Whitby 26824 WGN080396 Hoare, Graham LUC - 09/05/2008 09/05/2043 To use an erosion protection structure and culvert inlet and outlet wingwall 85a Belmont Road, 1761732 5445748 STREAMWORK structure in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream. Judgeford RETROSPECTIVE. 26901 WGN080446 New Zealand DP - SEWAGE / 12/09/2008 12/09/2023 To discharge up to 4,000 litres of treated wastewater effluent per day from an on- Belvedere Motel 1764157 5460493 Transport Agency SLUDGES site wastewater treatment plant to land. 26945 WGN080479 Preston, Judy & Scot WP - SURFACE 13/06/2008 13/06/2043 To permanently divert flood flows of the Horokiri Stream with a stopbank. 461 Grays Road, 1760304 5448950 DIVERSION Pauatahanui 27004 WGN080519 Transit New Zealand LUC - GENERAL 11/09/2008 11/09/2043 To place, use and maintain approximately 200m3 of rock erosion protection and Pauatahanui Stream 1764159 5446377 STRUCTURE a fish pass at the outlet of the Pauatahanui Stream Culvert No.1 27006 WGN080520 Hunters Hill Limited WP - SURFACE 22/12/2010 To permanently divert the full flow of three tributaries of the Porirua Stream Car Haulaways, 1753426 5437829 DIVERSION through sub-soil pipes. Grenada North 27007 WGN080520 Hunters Hill Limited LUC - 22/12/2010 To undertake activities within the beds of three tributaries of the Porirua Stream Car Haulaways, 1753426 5437829

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 11 OF 19

RECLAMATION in association with the development of a subdivision Grenada North 27009 WGN080522 Cameron, Kathryn LUC - 20/10/2008 20/10/2028 Land use consent to place and use an erosion structure in the bed and bank of an 50-52 The Drive, 1752604 5440370 STREAMWORK unnamed urban stream, and to undertake the associated disturbance of the Tawa stream bed and bank. 27021 WGN080533 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 15/07/2008 15/07/2043 To extend an existing culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Wainui Unnamed Tributary 1766087 5453245 CROSSING Stream (East) Of Wainui Stream 27059 WGN090003 Hunters Hill Limited DP - STORMW TO 25/08/2008 25/08/2013 To discharge stormwater contaminated with sediment, originating from areas of Lincolnshire Farm 1753649 5437014 WATER bulk earthworks exceeding 0.3 hectaress. 27372 WGN090009 Pater Estate Ltd DP - SEWAGE / 18/09/2008 18/09/2018 To discharge up to 8,460 litres of treated wastewater effluent per day from an on- Paekakariki Shopping 1764154 5460671 SLUDGES site community wastewater treatment plant to land. Centre 27088 WGN090021 Budgen, Graham & WP - SURFACE 01/09/2008 01/09/2018 To take and use surface water from the Pauatahanui Stream using an existing Pauatahanui Stream 1763535 5446144 Wendy WATER TAKE intake structure for irrigation of pasture and dust control associated with the operation of a cleanfill. 27103 WGN090031 Best Farm Limited LUC - 13/08/2008 13/08/2043 To place, use and maintain a 160mm diameter OD HDPE sewer pipe under the Unnamed Tributary 1752725 5437791 STREAMWORK bed of an unnamed tributary of the Porirua Stream Of Porirua Stream 27189 WGN090034 Silverwood Forest LUC - 07/10/2008 07/10/2043 To place subsoil drainage and to reclaim a section of the bed of a tributary of the Silverwood Block, 1760579 5446484 Corporation Ltd RECLAMATION Pauatahanui Stream Whitby 27191 WGN090082 Wellington City LUC - GENERAL 07/10/2008 07/10/2043 To replace and use a stormwater outlet in the bed of Porirua Stream, including By Melville Street 1753312 5440726 Council STRUCTURE any associated disturbance of the bed of that stream during construction. Bridge, Tawa 27248 WGN090116 Ontrack - Nz Railways LUC - 27/11/2008 27/11/2043 To work in the bed of a water course (culvert extension) Pre-Load Area 2 1767291 5463871 STREAMWORK 27249 WGN090116 Ontrack - Nz Railways DP - STORMW TO 27/11/2008 27/11/2013 To discharge sediement laden water that may potentially enter water Pre-Load Area 1 & 2 1767034 5462894 WAT 27256 WGN090119 Wearne And Jacobsen DP - DISCHARGE 22/04/2009 22/04/2019 To discharge to air from the operation of a natural gas-fired cremator 17 Kenepuru Drive, 1754638 5443971 Ltd TO AIR Porirua 27263 WGN090128 Porirua City Council LUC - 27/11/2008 27/11/2043 To install timber pole retaining walls and associated works in the bed of a stream Champion Street & 1755085 5444384 STREAMWORK Mepham Place, Por 30249 WGN090136 Best Farm Limited WP - SURFACE 01/03/2010 01/03/2045 To permanently divert the flow of Stebbings Stream in association with works for Stebbings Road, 1751766 5433087 DIVERSION a residential subdivision. Chuton Park 30250 WGN090136 Best Farm Limited LUC - 01/03/2010 01/03/2045 To place subsoil drainage and reclaim a section of the bed of various tributaries of Stebbings Road, 1751696 5437943 RECLAMATION the Stebbings Stream Churton Park 27446 WGN090160 Whitby Coastal DP - STORMW TO 15/01/2009 15/01/2014 Stormwater to water from bulf earthworkds greater in 0.3ha Resolution Drive, 1759343 5446519 Estates WATER Whitby, Porirua 27447 WGN090160 Whitby Coastal LUC - 15/01/2009 15/01/2044 To install stormwater outlets in bed of stream Resolution Drive, 1759343 5446519 Estates STREAMWORK Whitby, Porirua 27477 WGN090160 Whitby Coastal DP - STORMW TO 15/01/2009 15/01/2014 To discharge stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks greater than 0.3ha into Flotilla Place 1759343 5446519 Estates WATER Duck Creek. Subdivision 30118 WGN090160 Whitby Coastal LUC - 15/01/2009 15/01/2012 To place and use a temporary crossing across the bed of Duck Creek. Resolution Drive, 1759343 5446519 Estates STREAMWORK Whitby, Porirua 27325 WGN090161 Five Ways Holding LUC - 16/11/2009 16/11/9999 To conduct the following works within the bed of the Pauatahanui Stream: re- 161 State Highway 58, 1761677 5446534 Limited STREAMWORK contouring of the true left bank; and installing a stormwater outlet structure, Judgeford, Po including the associated discharge to and disturbance of the stream during construction. 27326 WGN090161 Five Ways Holding DP - STORMW TO 16/11/2009 16/11/2014 Discharge permit to discharge sediment-laden stormwater from an area of bulk 161 State Highway 58, 1761677 5446534 Limited LANE earthworks to land and directly to the waters of the Pauatahamui Stream. Judgeford, Po 27535 WGN090161 Five Ways Holding DP - SEWAGE / 16/11/2009 16/11/2019 To discharge treated sewage and greywater effluent to land. 161 State Highway 58, 1761677 5446534 Limited SLUDGES Judgeford, Po 27389 WGN090202 Spencer Holmes Ltd LUC - 14/01/2009 14/01/2044 To construct a rock rip-rap structure in the bed of the Porirua Stream, Willow Willowbank Park, 1753376 5439126 STREAMWORK Bank Park, Tawa, including any associated disturbance of the stream bed. Tawa 30534 WGN090221 Pikarere Farm Ltd WP - SURFACE 27/08/2009 27/08/2019 To take and use water from a tributary of Mill Creek for stock and domestic use in Pikarere Farm 1751680 5444587 WATER TAKE four houses. 27429 WGN090226 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 31/05/2010 31/05/2045 To divert the full flow of a section of the Stebbings Stream to a new channel. Westchester Drive 1752246 5437041 Council DIVERSION 27449 WGN090239 Tangney, Peter LUC - SOIL 12/02/2009 12/02/2012 To conduct earthworks on erosion prone land associated with the construction of 134 State Highway 58, 1761396 5446405 DISTURBANCE a housing platform. Haywards Hill 27546 WGN090281 Ontrack - Nz Railways LUC - GENERAL 20/04/2009 20/04/2044 To construct a culvert in the bed of the Whareroa Whareroa Stream, 1767358 5464253 STRUCTURE Waterfall Road, Pa 27547 WGN090281 Ontrack - Nz Railways LUC - RIVER 20/04/2044 To extend an existing bridge over the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Whareroa Stream, 1766755 5462649 CROSSING Whareroa Stream. Mackays Crossing 27537 WGN090301 Jimbob Trust LUC - GENERAL 28/05/2009 28/05/2044 To use and maintain an existing stormwater outlet within an unnamed tributary 400a Paremata Road, 1760289 5447875 STRUCTURE of the Pauatahanui Stream. Pauatahanui 27551 WGN090310 Ontrack - Nz Railways LUC - GENERAL 04/05/2009 04/05/2044 To extend and maintain a culvert including any associated disturbance of, and Whareroa Stream 1767235 5463545 STRUCTURE deposition onto, the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Wareroa Stream. Mackays Crossing

PAGE 12 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

30009 WGN090376 Wrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 11/08/2009 11/08/2044 To realign a short section of Wainui stream and install and maintain stream bank Queen Elizabeth Park 1765235 5462111 Dept. STREAMWORK erosion protection works 27648 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees LUC - GENERAL 28/10/2009 28/10/2044 To place and use a culvert crossing structure in the bed of Mitchell Stream, 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753304 5443249 Ltd STRUCTURE Porirua. 27649 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees DP - STORMW TO 28/10/2009 28/10/2014 To discharge sediment-laden stormwater from bulk earthworks associated with 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753115 5442942 Ltd LAND the development of Lots 1 - 10 of the Broken Hill 27650 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees LUC - DAM 28/10/2009 28/10/2014 To intermittently dam the flood flow of Mitchell Stream in times of high rainfall, 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753304 5443249 Ltd STRUCTURE and to divert the full base-flow of Mitchell Stream through a culvert crossing pipe. 27651 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees LUC - ROADING / 28/10/2009 28/10/2014 To conduct earthworks on erosion-prone land on immediately adjacent to 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753304 5443249 Ltd TRACKING Mitchell Stream, Porirua. 30029 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees DP - STORMW TO 28/10/2009 28/10/2014 To discharge sediment-laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks where 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753252 5443186 Ltd WATER it may enter Mitchell Stream, Porirua. 30184 WGN090379 Broken Hill Nominees LUC - 28/10/2009 28/10/2014 To place and use a temporary stormwater outfall structure in the bed of Mitchell 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753304 5443249 Ltd STREAMWORK Stream. 30007 WGN100003 Ministry Of Education LUC - CULVERT 03/08/2009 03/08/2044 Land use consent to install, use and maintain a pipe structure in an unnamed Mana College, 1 1753671 5445538 tributary to the Takapuwahia Stream. Awarua St, Elsdon 30011 WGN100003 Ministry Of Education LUC - 03/08/2009 03/08/2044 To place, use and maintain a gabion basket structure in the bed of an unnamed Mana College, 1 1753671 5445537 STREAMWORK tributary to the Takapuwahia Stream including any associated disturbance to the Awarua St, Elsdon bed of that stream. 30046 WGN100025 Porirua City Council LUC - 09/08/2010 09/08/2045 To install a new outfall pipe into the bank of the Porirua Stream Porirua Stream, 1754682 5444169 STREAMWORK Lyttelton Ave 30047 WGN100026 Ministry Of Education LUC - 31/08/2009 31/08/2044 1 Awarua Street, 1753646 5445558 STREAMWORK Elsdon 30063 WGN100042 Welsh, John And DP - DISCHARGE 04/09/2009 04/09/2014 To discharge sediment laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks 70 Bing Lucas Drive, 1753912 5440021 Mary TO LAND associated with a residential development to land in the Porirua Stream. Grenada 30139 WGN100094 Bryant, Len & Josie LUC - CULVERT 30/11/2009 30/11/2044 To place a culvert in the bed of an unnamed tributary of the Ohariu Stream, Boom Rock Road, 1749350 5439360 including any diversion, deposition and disturbance of the stream bed. Ohariu Valley 30160 WGN100114 Wrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 06/11/2009 06/11/2029 To place rock rip rap on adjacent banks of the Horokiri Stream including any Battle Hill Farm 1762795 5452790 Dept. STREAMWORK associated disturbance of the stream bed or diversion of water Forest Park 30161 WGN100115 Complete Contracting DP - DISCHARGE 23/10/2009 23/10/2019 To discharge contaminants to air associated with and arising from stationary and 8 Kinleith Grove, 1753146 5442516 Limited TO AIR mobile dry abrasive blasting activities in the Wellington Region. Porirua 30170 WGN100124 Broken Hill Nominees DP - STORMW TO 14/05/2010 14/05/2020 To discharge sediment laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks and a 8 Broken Hill, Porirua 1753438 5443710 Ltd WATER commercial cleanfill operation, to and and to Mitchell Stream. City 30285 WGN100175 Ila Phillips LUC - BORES 21/12/2009 21/12/9999 To construct and maintain a bore (R27/7222) for domestic use. 8 Ahoroa Road, Rd 1, 1764872 5447408 Porirua 30307 WGN100186 Crimp, John LUC - 05/05/2010 05/05/2045 Retrospective land use consent to place a pipe and associated structures in the 333 Grays Road, 1759809 5449587 STREAMWORK bed of an intermittently flowing stream Pauatahanui 30332 WGN100197 Whitby Coastal LUC - PIPING 04/03/2010 04/03/2045 To construct a stormwater outlet in the bank and rock rip-rap in the bed of an James Cook Drive, 1759628 5447469 Estates Limited unnamed tributary of Duck Creek, including any associated disturbance or Whitby, Porirua deposition. 31146 WGN100197 Whitby Coastal LUC - BRIDGE 04/03/2010 04/03/2045 To construct a bridge and aerial sewer line over an unnamed tributary of Duck James Cook Drive, 1759628 5447469 Estates Limited Creek, including any associated disturbance or deposition. Whitby, Porirua 30347 WGN100207 Chevron New Zealand LUC - BORES 11/02/2010 11/02/9999 To construct and maintain bores (R27/7409, R27/7410, R27/7411 and R27/7412) 9 Paekakariki Hill Rd, 1760924 5447779 for groundwater monitoring purposes. Pauatahanui 30380 WGN100219 Whitby Coastal DP - DISCHARGE 01/11/2010 01/11/2015 To discharge treated sediment laden water and chemical flocculant directly to Spyglass Lane, 1759387 5445946 Estates Limited TO LAND water, and to land where it may enter water, in association with bulk earthworks. Whitby, Porirua 30490 WGN100281 Whitby Coastal DP - DISCHARGE 18/06/2010 18/06/2015 To discharge sediment laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks to land Lower Nine Duck 1759600 5447543 Estates Limited TO WATER where it may enter Duck Creek and James Cook Stream Creek Golf Course 30507 WGN100294 Gwrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 29/06/2010 29/06/2045 To place, use and maintain a culvert and rock rip-rap mattress in the bed of the Queen Elizabeth Park, 1766758 5464375 Dept. STREAMWORK Whareroa Stream. Whareroa 30509 WGN100296 Benis Flexible DP - DISCHARGE 29/06/2010 29/06/2020 To discharge contaminants (namely odour and volatile organic compounds) to air 101 Collins Ave, 1754697 5441546 Packaging TO AIR arising from the operation of a printing facility. Linden, Tawa 30511 WGN100298 Kapiti Coast District LUC - 01/07/2010 01/07/2020 To extract up to 350m3 per yer of gravel,, including any associated disturbance or Te Puka Stream, 1765393 5461910 Council STREAMWORK discharge, from the Te Puka Stream for the purpose of flood prevention purposes. Middle Run Farm 30515 WGN100300 Transit New Zealand LUC - 28/07/2010 28/07/2045 To remove vegetation from within and from the banks of the Pauatahanui Pauatahanui Stream, 1762268 5446569 STREAMWORK Stream, adjacent to State Highway 58 for flood protection purposes SH 58 30524 WGN100306 Wrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 12/07/2030 To place, use and maintain a gabion basket erosion protection structure and a Battle Hill Regional 1762446 5453536 Dept. STREAMWORK gabion basket groyne in the bed of the Horokiri Stream. Park 30598 WGN110040 Mulholland, Mr LUC - CULVERT 20/08/2010 20/08/2045 To place, use and maintain a culvert and erosion protection structures in the bed 384 Takapu Road, 1755954 5441499 Stephen of the Takapu Stream. Grenada 30600 WGN110042 Nz Transport Agency LUC - ROADING / 10/09/2010 10/09/2015 To disturb soil in association with construction of roading with an upslope batter Emerald Glen Road 1767454 5463375 TRACKING greater than 2 metres extending for a length greater than 200 metres. To Mackays Crossi

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 13 OF 19

30601 WGN110042 Nz Transport Agency LUC - CULVERT 10/09/2010 10/09/2045 To place permanent and temporary culverts, bridge structures and rock rip-rap in Emerald Glen Road 1767454 5463375 and over four unnamed tributaries of the Whareroa Stream. To Mackays Crossi 30602 WGN110042 Nz Transport Agency DP - STORMW TO 10/09/2010 10/09/2015 To discharge sediment laden stormwater directly to water, and to land where it Emerald Glen Road 1767454 5463375 WATER may enter unnamed tributaries of the Whareroa Stream. To Mackays Crossi 30702 WGN110111 Carrus Limited DP - STORMW TO 27/10/2010 27/10/2015 To discharge sediment laden stormwater from an area of bulk earthworks to land Aotea Block Stage 10 1755257 5445599 LAND where it may enter Okowai Lagoon. 30706 WGN110115 Price, Roger LUC - SOIL 28/10/2010 28/10/2012 To undertake soil disturbance on erosion prone land associated with the Maungakotukutuku 1769913 5464883 DISTURBANCE construction of landing sites and pads. Road, Paraparaumu 30715 WGN110115 Price, Roger LUC - ROADING / 28/10/2010 28/10/2012 To disturb soil associated with constructing tracks. Maungakotukutuku 1769913 5464883 TRACKING Road, Paraparaumu 30732 WGN110127 Porirua City Council LUC - 10/11/2010 10/11/2045 To place, use and maintain an erosion protection structure in the Kenepuru Kenepuru Stream 1754766 5444516 STREAMWORK stream including self maintenance of rip-rap. 30743 WGN110133 Gwrc, Parks & Forests LUC - 02/12/2010 02/12/2045 To place, use and maintain a concrete block erosion protection structure in the Battle Hill Bush 1762446 5453536 Dept. STREAMWORK bed of the Horokiri Stream. Reserve, Bridge 2 30745 WGN110134 Porirua City Council DP - DISCHARGE 14/01/2011 14/01/2016 Discharge permit to discharge treated stormwater contanimated with sediment to Westwater Plant, 1752485 5445420 TO WATER land (a stormwater gully) from the Porirua Waste Wate treatment Plant. Porirua 30744 WGN110135 Kiwirail LUC - CULVERT 26/11/2010 26/11/2045 To upgrade an existing culvert (culvert 2) in the bed of an unnamed tributary of NIMT Btwn Tunnel 2 1760084 5456659 the Plimmerton stream And Tunnel 7 30761 WGN110145 New Zealand WP - SURFACE 18/01/2011 18/01/2046 Water permit to temporarily and permanently divert the flows of the Te Puka Te Puka Stream 1765371 5461236 Transport Agency DIVERSION Stream (but not including disturbance) 30762 WGN110145 New Zealand LUC - 18/01/2011 18/01/2046 Land use consent to deposit material and place structures in the bed of the Te Te Puka Stream 1765371 5461236 Transport Agency STREAMWORK Puka Stream (but not including disturbance) 30763 WGN110145 New Zealand LUC - 18/01/2011 18/01/9999 Land use consent to reclaim sections of the Te Puka Stream (but not including Te Puka Stream 1765371 5461236 Transport Agency RECLAMATION disturbance) 30845 WGN110145 New Zealand LUC - 18/01/2011 18/01/2016 Land use consent to disturb the bed of the Te Puka Stream and unnamed Te Puka Stream 1765371 5461236 Transport Agency STREAMWORK tributaries of the Te Puka Stream 30822 WGN110177 Roil, Patrick & Tracey LUC - 09/03/2011 09/03/9999 Land use consent (part retrospective) to reclaim a section of the bed of an un- 110a Mulhern Road, 1763604 5447258 RECLAMATION named intermittently flowing tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream Porirua 30823 WGN110177 Roil, Patrick & Tracey LUC - 09/03/2011 09/03/2046 Land use consent to place, use and maintain various structure in the bed of an 110a Mulhern Road, 1763604 5447258 STREAMWORK un-named tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream Porirua 30824 WGN110177 Roil, Patrick & Tracey WP - SURFACE 09/03/2011 09/03/2046 Water permit to permanently divert the full flow of an unnamed intermittently 110a Mulhern Road, 1763604 5447258 DIVERSION flowing tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream into a newly constructed channel. Porirua 30825 WGN110177 Roil, Patrick & Tracey DP - STORMW TO 09/03/2011 09/03/2013 Discharge permit to discharge sediment laden stormwater to land where it may 110a Mulhern Road, 1763225 5447354 LAND enter unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream from the area of bulk Porirua earthworks. 30850 WGN110199 Nz Transport Agency LUC - SOIL 20/07/2011 20/07/9999 Land use consent to reclaim approximately 8m of Wainui Stream including Mackays Crossing To 1764234 5460678 DISTURBANCE associated disturbance of and deposition of material on the stream bed Paekakariki 30851 WGN110199 Nz Transport Agency LUC - CULVERT 20/07/2011 20/07/2046 Land use consent to place permanent culvert extensions and rock rip-rap in and Mackays Crossing To 1764234 5460678 over Wainui Stream and Smiths Creek, including associated disturbance of and Paekakariki deposition of 30852 WGN110199 Nz Transport Agency DP - STORMW TO 20/07/2011 20/07/2016 Discharge permit to discharge sediment laden stormwater directly to water, and Mackays Crossing To 1764234 5460678 WATER to land where it may enter Wainui Stream and Smiths Creek Paekakariki 30865 WGN110205 Wellington City LUC - 06/04/2011 06/04/9999 Land use consent to pipe and reclaim 190 m of two intermittently flowing 2 Stebbings Road, 1752142 5437526 Council RECLAMATION tributaries of the Stebbings Stream, including placement of outlet structures in Glenside the stream beds. 30940 WGN110205 Wellington City DP -STORMW TO 06/04/2011 06/04/2016 Discharge permit to discharge treated sediment laden stormwater and chemical 2 Stebbings Road, 1752142 5437526 Council WATER floculent from an area of bulk earthworks to land where it may enter Stebbings Glenside Stream. 30898 WGN110226 Carrus Corporation WP - SURFACE 05/04/2011 05/04/2046 To permanently divert surface water from an unnamed wetland to the coastal Aotea Block, Whitby, 1755340 5445711 Limited DIVERSION marine area. Porirua 30899 WGN110226 Carrus Corporation LUC - 05/04/2011 05/04/2046 To place an inlet structure and rock rip-rap, and to undertake associated Aotea Block, Whitby, 1755340 5445711 Limited STREAMWORK disturbance, in the bed of an unnamed wetland. Porirua 30979 WGN110226 Carrus Corporation DP – STORMW TO 05/04/2011 05/04/2016 To discharge stormwater contaminated with sediment and chemical flocculant to Aotea Block, Whitby, 1755340 5445711 Limited LAND land where it may enter an unnamed tributary of Okowai Lagoon. Porirua 30904 WGN110230 Best Farm Limited LUC - 16/03/2011 16/03/2046 To place, use and maintain two stormwater headwell structures, associated 6 & 55 Melksham 1751640 5437387 STREAMWORK wingwalls and rock riprap structures in the bed of two unnamed tributaries of Drive, Churton Park Stebbings Stream 30977 WGN110291 Dick, Graeme LUC - BORES 01/04/2011 01/04/9999 To construct and maintain a bore (BP32/0001) for domestic, stock water and 85 Belmont Road, 1761624 5445597 irrigation purposes. Pauatahanui 31038 WGN110342 Clark, James LUC - BORES 09/05/2011 09/05/9999 To construct a new bore (BP32/0004) for gardening purposes. 40b Matai Road, 1766999 5466572 Raumati South 31060 WGN110357 International Waste DP - DISCHARGE 14/07/2011 14/07/2026 To discharge contaminants to air (namely odour) arising from the operation of a 12 Broken Hill Road, 1752968 5442613 Limited TO AIR waste sterilisation facility. Porirua

PAGE 14 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

4954 WGN75052701 Ministry Of Works & WP - SURFACE 07/11/1992 01/10/2026 Divert stream for road realignment work. An Un-Named Stream 1764080 5446385 Development DIVERSION 4955 WGN75052801 Ministry Of Police WP - SURFACE 06/12/1972 01/10/2026 To divert and discharge stormwater Stromwater Drain 1755180 5446186 DIVERSION 4950 WGN84001201 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 08/10/1984 01/10/2027 Divert and discharge by culverting Glenside Stream Glenside Stream 1751579 5437287 Council - Cityworks DIVERSION 3059 WGN91011301 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 27/03/1992 05/03/2027 To construct a replacement bridge Pauatahanui 1764530 5446985 CROSSING 3628 WGN92008201 Transit New Zealand LUC - 12/02/1993 23/12/2027 Realignment of 1.7 km of state highway State Highway 58 1761980 5446686 STREAMWORK 3044 WGN92014801 Upper Hutt City LUC - RIVER 22/03/1993 15/02/2027 To reconstruct the Hulls Creek road bridge Eastern Hutt Road 1762781 5459185 Council CROSSING 4936 WGN93021802 Gwrc, Flood WP - SURFACE 04/02/1994 02/02/2029 To construct a straight flood wall-diversion of water Wellington Regional 1754330 5443086 Protection Wellington DIVERSION Council 21367 WGN940046 Porirua City Council DP - LANDFILL 12/05/1996 30/06/2030 To discharge contaminants (domestic, commercial and industrial) onto landfill Spicer Landfill 1752480 5440987 DISCHARGE 1381 WGN94004602 Porirua City Council DP - DISCHARGE 12/09/1996 30/06/2030 To discharge landfill gas to air. Spicer Landfill 1752480 5440987 TO AIR 4964 WGN94004603 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 12/09/1996 30/06/2030 To divert and discharge stormwater run-off Spicer Landfill 1752480 5440987 DIVERSION 5975 WGN94004604 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 12/09/1996 30/06/2030 To take leachate for disposal off site Spicers Landfill 1752480 5440987 WATER TAKE 4729 WGN94011301 Pauatahanui Wildlife WP - DAM 20/07/1992 19/10/2029 To fill a pond for wildlife and irrigation Pauatahanui Wildlfe 1760980 5447686 Committee Committee. 3196 WGN94011302 Pauatahanui Wildlife LUC - DAM 28/10/1994 19/10/2029 To build a dam to raise the water level Pauatahanui Wildlife 1760980 5447686 Committee STRUCTURE Commitee 5991 WGN94012401 Wellington City WP - GROUNDW 08/11/1994 08/11/2029 Take water from a bore Wellingotn City 1753479 5437987 Council - Solid Was TAKE Council 2762 WGN94013803 Kapiti Coast District LUC - BORES 09/02/1996 To identify an acquifer by drilling a 100m bore for water supply. Poplar Ave 1767181 5466085 Council 2763 WGN94013804 Kapiti Coast District LUC - BORES 09/02/1996 To create an exploratory bore near the Whareoa Stream for water supply. Whareroa Park 1766681 5464385 Council 2764 WGN94013805 Kapiti Coast District LUC - BORES 09/02/1996 To construct one of six bores to find water for domestic supply Mackays Crossing 1 1765981 5462585 Council 2765 WGN94013806 Kapiti Coast District LUC - BORES 09/02/1996 To construct One of six bores to find water for the KCDC water supply. Mackays Crossing 2 1765981 5462185 Council 4392 WGN95001501 Stebbings Farmland LUC - RIVER 04/04/1995 20/03/2030 To extend an existing culvert. By w.c.c drainage dept standards. Churton Park 1751579 5437067 Limited CROSSING 4982 WGN95001502 Stebbings Farmland WP - SURFACE 23/03/1995 20/03/2030 Water permit to divert an unnamed tributary. Stebbigs Stream 1751579 5437067 Limited DIVERSION 3073 WGN95003801 Wellington City LUC - RIVER 12/05/1995 20/04/2030 To refurbish an existing bridge. Oxford St 1753380 5441087 Council - Northern CROSSING 3030 WGN95006501 Bryant, R G LUC - RIVER 17/07/1995 23/06/2030 To replace existing bridge. Willowbankoad 1753379 5438787 CROSSING 3574 WGN95008101 Trotter, Sir Ron & LUC - GENERAL 24/07/1995 30/06/2030 To lay water main piping under a streambed. Sir Ron And Lady 1753989 5439371 Lady Margaret STRUCTURE Margaret Trotter 4408 WGN95010601 Wellington City LUC - RIVER 26/09/1995 04/09/2030 To construct culvert and lower road by Lowering the existing culvert, lag and Johnsonville 1751899 5437067 Council - Drainage CROSSING backfill, add 14m pipe. 5001 WGN95010602 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 26/09/1995 04/09/2030 Water permit to divert stream through new culvert. Tributary Of Porirua 1751899 5437067 Council - Drainage DIVERSION St 3347 WGN95011301 Transalta New LUC - HAZARD 11/10/1995 19/09/2030 Erosion repair of retaining wall. Co: wall of stacked gabons, backfilled with Right Bank Porirua 1752429 5437037 Zealand Limited MITIGATION compacted hardfill. Stream 4414 WGN95014401 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 18/01/1996 01/12/2030 To remove an old bridge and replace a ford. Co: remove old bridge Akatarawa Block 1769381 5456785 CROSSING 4772 WGN95016101 P & P Savage Limited WP - DAM 28/11/1995 06/11/2030 To construct a Dam to act as silt trap. P And P Savage 1761480 5448036 3036 WGN95016102 P & P Savage Limited LUC - RIVER 28/11/1995 06/11/2030 To construct a bridge over Pauatahanui stream. State Highway 58 1761480 5448036 CROSSING 3037 WGN95017101 Stevenson, Dougal LUC - RIVER 02/02/1996 18/12/2030 To construct a bridge to service a dwelling. Paekakariki Hill Road 1760880 5449486 CROSSING 3493 WGN95017201 Trotter, Sir Ron & LUC - GENERAL 25/01/1996 08/12/2030 Land use consent to construct a stormwater pipe into stream. Sir Ron And Lady 1753880 5442087 Lady Margaret STRUCTURE Margaret Trotter 3522 WGN96002001 Saturn LUC - GENERAL 11/03/1996 16/02/2031 To install fibre optic cable across wetland on existing poles Saturn 1765481 5462785 Communications STRUCTURE Communications

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 15 OF 19

3494 WGN96003101 Wellington Regional LUC - GENERAL 10/04/1996 15/03/2031 To install & maintain water supply intake structures. Battlehill Farm Forest 1762780 5453085 Council STRUCTURE Park 4781 WGN96007701 Shaw, R M & J D WP - DAM 21/06/1996 29/05/2031 To create a dam water in two ponds for landscaping purposes. R And J Shaw 1762430 5446786 3209 WGN96007702 Shaw, R M & J D LUC - DAM 21/06/1996 29/05/2031 To Construct a dam culvert and walkbridge R And J Shaw 1762430 5446786 STRUCTURE 3483 WGN96010801 Goh Realty LUC - GENERAL 08/07/1996 14/06/2031 To install sormwater outlet and drain Goh Realty 1753280 5443087 STRUCTURE 3082 WGN96011601 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 01/08/1996 10/07/2031 Install a Bailey bridge at Perham Rd in the Whakatiki Forest Perham Road 1769581 5460485 CROSSING 5024 WGN97000601 Robbie Ker WP - SURFACE 05/02/1997 03/12/2031 To divert Porirua stream for realignment Porirua Stream 1753079 5439587 Contractors Ltd WATER DIVERSION 3839 WGN97000602 Robbie Ker LUC - 05/02/1997 03/12/2031 To realign Porirua Stream through old A C Hatrick Site CO: Construct channel, 42 - 66 Main Road 1753079 5439587 Contractors Ltd STREAMWORK divert water, fill in old channel. 3840 WGN97000603 Robbie Ker LUC - 05/02/1997 03/12/2031 To construct new channel for realignment of Porirua Stream CO: Create new 42 - 66 Main Road 1753079 5439587 Contractors Ltd STREAMWORK channel, divert water, fill in old channel 2134 WGN97000604 Robbie Ker DP - DISG TO 05/02/1997 03/12/2031 Discharge hydrocarbons at low levels as part of earthworks SC: Hydrocarbons 42-66 Main Road 1753079 5439587 Contractors Ltd LAND PR: Remediated NA: Earthworks DM: Earthworks 4453 WGN97002401 Lucas, R D LUC - RIVER 25/09/1996 25/09/2031 To construct 2 1800mmm culverts in a concrete precast head with tail walls. Belmont Road 1761380 5445786 CROSSING 3090 WGN97004501 Wellington Regional LUC - RIVER 25/10/1996 03/10/2031 Upgrading and maintenance work on bridge structures. Korokoro Cachment 1756980 5437308 Recreat CROSSING 3088 WGN97004901 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 10/10/1996 10/10/2031 To widen an existing bridge at Judgeford Pauatahanui Stream 1764180 5446485 CROSSING 3089 WGN97005601 Lucas, Ron LUC - RIVER 10/12/1996 10/12/2031 To construct a bridge for access Paekakariki Hill Road 1762280 5451085 CROSSING 3092 WGN97006901 Aquaheat Industries LUC - RIVER 23/10/1996 23/10/2031 To construct a bridge over the Kenepuru Stream. Kenepuru Stream 1753279 5440087 Limited CROSSING 4458 WGN97007301 P & P Savage Limited LUC - RIVER 16/10/1996 16/10/2031 To construct a culvert in an unnamed watercourse Pauatahanui 1762480 5447086 CROSSING 5035 WGN97007801 Lincolnshire Farms WP - SURFACE 29/07/1997 29/07/2032 To divert Belmont Gully stream beneath proposed earthworks Belmont Gully 1753459 5437237 Limited DIVERSION 4467 WGN97007802 Lincolnshire Farms LUC - RIVER 29/07/1997 29/07/2032 To place a culvert beneath proposed earthworks with the bed excavated, pipes, Horokiwi Road 1753459 5437237 Limited CROSSING inlet, outlet laid, backfilled 5036 WGN97008301 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 03/12/1996 03/12/2031 To divert water through 3 culverts An Un-Named 1760480 5447086 DIVERSION Watercourse 4469 WGN97008302 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 03/12/1996 03/12/2031 To construct 3 culverts in a stream. Eastern Whitby 1760480 5447086 CROSSING 4784 WGN97008401 Mclaughlin, Gavin & WP - DAM 14/11/1996 14/11/2031 To provide a habitat for native flora and fauna. G And C Mcglauglin 1764280 5447085 Christine 3210 WGN97008402 Mclaughlin, Gavin & LUC - DAM 14/11/1996 14/11/2031 Construct an earth dam for aesthetic purposes. G And C Mclaughlin 1764280 5447085 Christine STRUCTURE 3114 WGN97009001 Brian Long Catering LUC - RIVER 09/12/1996 09/12/2031 To construct a pipe bridge to carry sewer to on-site plant Lodge At The Inlet 1761080 5449386 CROSSING 4471 WGN97009002 Brian Long Catering LUC - RIVER 09/12/1996 09/12/2031 To install a temporary culvert in an ephemeral drainage channel Pauatahanui 1761080 5449386 CROSSING 2273 WGN97009003 Brian Long Catering DP - INDUST 09/12/1996 09/12/2031 To discharge surface water runoff diverted via open channel into an unamed Pace Ltd - Lodge At 1761080 5449386 WASTE TO WTR tributary of the Horokiri Stream. The Inlet 3897 WGN97009004 Brian Long Catering LUC - 09/12/1996 09/12/2031 Periodic maintenance of stream bed - weeding & silt removal CO: Manual Lodge At The Inlet 1761080 5449386 STREAMWORK weeding & bank maintenance 3527 WGN97009005 Brian Long Catering LUC - GENERAL 09/12/1996 09/12/2031 Excavate trench in stream bed to lay electric cable conduit. Pace Ltd 1761080 5449386 STRUCTURE 3116 WGN97010101 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 07/02/1997 07/02/2032 To construct a bridge across Porirua Stream Titahi Bay Road 1754660 5444246 CROSSING 21193 WGN970103 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 27/11/1997 27/11/2032 Works in Taupo Stream bed - culverts, channels, dams. 1757780 5451086 Transport Agency CROSSING 20828 WGN97010301 Transit New Zealand WP - SURFACE 17/11/2001 27/11/2032 To take, use, dam, divert, surface & Groundwater from the Taupo Stream and Taupo Stream 1757780 5451086 WATER swamp for upgrade. DIVERSION 21194 WGN97010301 New Zealand WP - SURFACE 27/11/1997 27/11/2032 To take, use, dam, divert, surface & Groundwater from the Taupo Stream and Taupo Stream 1757780 5451086 Transport Agency DIVERSION swamp for upgrade. 3902 WGN97011601 Judgeford Golf Club LUC - 04/03/1997 04/03/2032 To conduct maintenance in the moonshine stream CO: various - removal of Moonshine Stream 1763980 5446285 STREAMWORK shingle, bank protection works.

PAGE 16 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

3118 WGN97011602 Judgeford Golf Club LUC - RIVER 04/03/1997 04/03/2032 To replace an existing bridge over the moonshine stream. Moonshine Stream 1763980 5446285 CROSSING 24832 WGN970117 Cryovac/Sealed Air DP - DISCHARGE 11/11/2005 30/07/2017 To discharge various odours and volatile organic compunds from a Plastic film Mohuia Cres, Prosser 1753580 5444886 (Nz) Limited TO AIR extrusion and printing process. St, Porirua 4076 WGN97011801 Macdonald, Fiona LUC - 24/12/1997 24/12/2032 Works in the bed of a tributary to Pauatahanui Stream CO: Dig new course to E61 Moonshine Road 1766880 5448385 STREAMWORK form channel, dam old course. 4536 WGN97011802 Macdonald, Fiona LUC - RIVER 24/12/1997 24/12/2032 Placement of a culvert Puatahanui 1766880 5448385 CROSSING 4481 WGN97013801 Dennis, R W LUC - RIVER 20/02/1997 20/02/2032 To relocate a culvert, and construct a retaining wall Pauatahanui 1763480 5448085 CROSSING 3924 WGN97018701 Sudfeldt, M LUC - 01/05/1997 01/05/2032 To crossblade Moonshine Stream and plant willows CO: Push gravel onto the Corner Of Moonshine 1763780 5446485 STREAMWORK bank to stabilise it, and plant willows Road 5052 WGN97019501 Wellington City WP - SURFACE 05/05/1997 05/05/2032 To divert stormwater Stromwater Drain 1753980 5442286 Council - Drainage DIVERSION 2129 WGN97019502 Wellington City DP - STORMWTO 05/05/1997 05/05/2032 To discharge more than 1.5m3 of stormwater. Tributary To Porirua 1753980 5442286 Council - Drainage WAT Stream 3588 WGN97020203 Halverson Luke LUC - 30/04/1998 20/09/2033 Directly South Of 361 1755779 5441486 Contracting Ltd RECLAMATION Takapu Rd 5061 WGN97020204 Halverson Luke WP - SURFACE 30/04/1998 30/04/2033 To divert water through a pipe under the proposed cleanfill from a tributary of Halverson Luke 1755779 5441486 Contracting Ltd DIVERSION Takupu Stream. Contracting Ltd 5074 WGN97022601 Transit New Zealand WP - SURFACE 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To take, use, dam, & divert water for realignment of Taupo stream. Taupo Stream 1756980 5450486 DIVERSION 2294 WGN97022602 Transit New Zealand DP - STORMW TO 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge contaminants (silts, etc) to land and water including the Taupo Transit New Zealand 1756980 5450486 WAT Stream. 3589 WGN97022603 New Zealand LUC - 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 Use, erect, alter remove structures, excavate, deposit,recla CO: divert and From Plimmerton 1756980 5450486 Transport Agency RECLAMATION excavate stream bed, reclaim stream bed. Drive/Ulric St 5075 WGN97022604 Transit New Zealand WP - SURFACE 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To take, use, dam,divert storm, surface & ground water. Taupo Stream 1757180 5450186 DIVERSION 2295 WGN97022605 Transit New Zealand DP - STORMW TO 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge silts, etc to land and water including the James St Stream adjacenet Transit New Zealand 1757180 5450186 WATER to Taupo Stream. 5088 WGN97022607 New Zealand WP - SURFACE 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To divert Taupo Stream for construction purposes. Taupo Stream 1756780 5449686 Transport Agency DIVERSION 2299 WGN97022608 New Zealand DP - STORMW TO 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge washwater including some possible detergent into taupo stream. Transit New Zealand 1756780 5449686 Transport Agency WATER 1541 WGN97022609 New Zealand DP - DISCHARGE 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge dust and vehicle fumes to the air from industrial premises during Transit NZ 1756780 5449686 Transport Agency TO AIR construction. 21692 WGN97022610 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 26/06/1998 26/06/2033 To Place structures, excavate, plant in Taupo Stream. Paremata 1756780 5449686 CROSSING 3270 WGN97022611 New Zealand LUC - SOIL 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To undertake soil disturbance during construction activities with earthmoving Transit New Zealand 1756780 5449686 Transport Agency DISTURBANCE machines. 2300 WGN97022612 Transit New Zealand DP - STORMW TO 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge washwater including possible detergent into the Taupo Stream. Transit New Zealand 1756880 5450036 WATER 3147 WGN97022613 Transit New Zealand LUC - RIVER 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To construct a Bridge over stream with related construction activities. 83 St Andrews Road 1756880 5450036 CROSSING 2301 WGN97022614 New Zealand DP -STORMW TO 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To discharge washwater with possible detergent inti into the Taupo Stream. Transit New Zealand 1756980 5450486 Transport Agency WATER 3148 WGN97022615 New Zealand LUC - RIVER 20/07/1998 26/06/2033 To Reconstruct a footbridge across Taupo Stream. Taupo Stream 1756980 5450486 Transport Agency CROSSING 3217 WGN97024101 Mccallum, Bruce LUC - DAM 04/06/1997 04/06/2032 To constuct a dam and excavate the stream Bruce Mccallum 1751680 5442087 STRUCTURE 4791 WGN97024102 Mccallum, Bruce WP - DAM 04/06/1997 04/06/2032 To create a dam for stock water suppy. Bruce Mccallum 1751680 5442087 3237 WGN97025201 Royal, Antony LUC - SOIL 26/06/1997 26/06/2032 To undertake earthworks and Soil disturbance in connection with property Anotny Royal 1756680 5446286 DISTURBANCE development. 4499 WGN97025701 Orme, Martin LUC - RIVER 22/07/1997 30/06/2032 To culvert a small tributary to Hutt River. Lower Hutt 1760379 5438986 CROSSING 4498 WGN97026501 Fahey, Peter J LUC - RIVER 01/08/1997 10/07/2032 To Place a Nova flow pipe in head of gully and fill over. Lower Hutt 1759279 5438086 CROSSING 3244 WGN98000101 Whittaker, A LUC - SOIL 31/07/1997 31/07/2032 To construct Earthworks relating to housing platform, up to 2500 m3 soil Andrew Whittiker 1761380 5445786 DISTURBANCE 4510 WGN98001801 Trotter, Sir Ron & LUC - RIVER 10/11/1997 10/11/2032 The placement of eight culverts in unnamed tributaries Tawa 1754779 5441386 Lady Margaret CROSSING 4050 WGN98002201 Fahey, Peter J LUC - 09/09/1997 09/09/2032 Excavate g/wacke to extend 2 existing cut platforms CO: Clear veg. Excavate G/Wacke To 1759279 5438086 STREAMWORK Strip/stockpile soil, cut/fill, soil & seed. Extend 2 Existi

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 17 OF 19

4514 WGN98002401 Judgeford Golf Club LUC - RIVER 29/10/1997 29/10/2032 To extend a culvert under fill material State Highway 58 1763980 5446285 CROSSING 2399 WGN98002402 Judgeford Golf Club DP - LANDFILL 29/10/1997 29/10/2032 To deposit cleanfill in a gully to widen fairway New Judgeford 1763980 5446285 DISCHARGE Golfcourse 3136 WGN98003101 Martin, David LUC - RIVER 23/09/1997 23/09/2032 To raise an existing steel and concrete bridge by 0.5 metres 10 Lyndhurst Road 1752780 5440687 CROSSING 4793 WGN98003202 C Mummery & G WP - DAM 12/09/1997 12/09/2032 To create a dam for a wetland area C Mummery And G 1762792 5447589 Dowse Dowse 3249 WGN98004101 W R Grace (Nz) LUC - SOIL 19/09/1997 19/09/2032 To excavate 1000m3 of soild disturbance for a new accessway and pavement. Wr Grace Nz Ltd 1753680 5444886 Limited DISTURBANCE 3393 WGN98007801 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 07/11/1997 07/11/2032 Reinstate banks and floodplains -7 Moonshine Stream sites CO: Bulldozer used Seven Locations 1766680 5448085 MITIGATION to recover eroded material and reinstate bank Along Moonshine 3253 WGN98008101 Sunlink LUC - SOIL 28/01/1998 28/01/2033 To undertake approximately 61,000m3 of earthworks part of subdivision Sunlink 1757480 5450086 Developments Ltd DISTURBANCE involving the striping of topsoil, cut and progressively fill, re-topsoil, grass Developments Ltd 3591 WGN98008102 Sunlink LUC - 28/01/1998 28/01/2033 Placement of fill in gully and intermittent watercourse CO: fill placed to required Off Grays Road 1757480 5450086 Developments Ltd RECLAMATION level, topsoiled, grassed 4523 WGN98008103 Sunlink LUC - RIVER 28/01/1998 28/01/2033 To construct and sue a culvert for an intermittant stormwtaer course. 904 1757480 5450086 Developments Ltd CROSSING 1536 WGN98008302 Porirua City Council DP - DISCHARGE 31/05/2000 28/06/2014 To discharge contaminants associated with the sewerage treatment plant into the Porirua Wastewater 1753180 5447886 TO AIR air. Treatment Plant 4527 WGN98009101 Moody, Hudson LUC - RIVER 02/07/1998 02/07/2033 To pipe ephemeral watercourses through new culverts for a subdivision Tawa 1753380 5442587 CROSSING 3257 WGN98009102 Moody, Hudson LUC - SOIL 02/07/1998 02/07/2033 To disturb more than 2,000 m3 of soil in earthworks. Resource Holdings Nz 1753380 5442587 DISTURBANCE Ltd 4528 WGN98009701 Moody, Hudson LUC - RIVER 16/01/1998 16/01/2033 To construct a culvert under a new tennis court Tawa 1752680 5440487 CROSSING 3140 WGN98011201 Glovers Farm Ltd LUC - RIVER 06/03/1998 06/03/2033 To construct a bridge and place two culverts, Horokiri Stream Horokiwi Stream 1761580 5450586 CROSSING 3619 WGN98011501 Turner, I C LUC - 08/01/1998 08/01/2033 To reinstate and support a bank by willow planting CO: Willow trees will be laid Pukeawa Farm, 1762180 5451185 STREAMWORK lengthwise and cabled together 4549 WGN98011701 Woodman, Stuart LUC - RIVER 13/01/1998 13/01/2033 To construct 15m of culvert pipe. Wellington 1755779 5441486 CROSSING 3471 WGN98012303 Walsh, J & M LUC - GENERAL 26/01/1998 26/01/2033 To construct a stormwater outlet in Takapu Stream. John And Mary Walsh 1753679 5439487 STRUCTURE 4539 WGN98013701 Wellington City LUC - RIVER 30/01/1998 30/01/2033 To place a culvert in an open drain to Porirua Stream. Tawa 1753480 5442187 Council - Culture & CROSSING 3146 WGN98015001 Wotton, Laurie LUC - RIVER 14/04/1998 14/04/2033 To construct a bridge over a tributary to Pauatahanui Stream Moonshine Stream 1764080 5447085 CROSSING 3408 WGN98018201 Wellington Regional LUC - HAZARD 20/04/1998 22/04/2033 Build gabion erosion protection & retaining struture CO: dig trench, place Wainui Stream 1765281 5461885 Recreat MITIGATION gabions & fill, replant 5119 WGN98018202 Wellington Regional WP - SURFACE 20/04/1998 22/04/2033 To divert the Wainui Stream for construction works. Wainui Stream 1765281 5461885 Recreat DIVERSION 3542 WGN98018901 Porirua City Council LUC - GENERAL 28/04/1998 28/04/2033 Extend stormwater pipe & pipe lower reaches of Ohangao Creek. Porirua City Council 1754180 5447786 STRUCTURE 3278 WGN98019001 Whitby Coastal LUC - ROADING / 01/05/1998 01/05/2033 To undertake the construction of a road to provide access to allotments in Whitby Coastal Estate 1758880 5446486 Estates TRACKING accordance with the plans provided with the application 3281 WGN98021401 Donald, R LUC - ROADING / 16/06/1998 16/06/2033 To construct a right of way using earthworks to strip top soil, file sites prepared, R Donald And M 1762480 5446786 TRACKING compaction Cottle 4559 WGN98022701 Riddell, RJ & MG LUC - RIVER 20/05/1998 20/05/2033 Placing culvert for access road Tawa 1756479 5441886 CROSSING 4110 WGN98023201 Wellington Regional LUC - 18/05/1998 18/05/2033 To realign a section (20m) of Horokiri West Stream CO: By a small digger Battle Hill Farm 1762780 5452985 Recreat STREAMWORK Forest Park, 5094 WGN98023202 Wellington Regional WP - SURFACE 18/05/1998 18/05/2033 To divert a 20 m section of Horokiri West Stream Horokiri West Stream 1762780 5452985 Recreat DIVERSION 3614 WGN98023203 Wellington Regional LUC - 18/05/1998 18/05/2033 To plant willows and native trees along Horokiri West Stream CO: By hand Battle Hill Forest 1762780 5452985 Recreat STREAMWORK Farm 3411 WGN98023701 Woodman, Stuart LUC - HAZARD 29/06/1998 29/06/2033 Bank reinstatment works CO: excavator Takapu Road 1755379 5440886 MITIGATION 5100 WGN98023702 Woodman, Stuart WP - SURFACE 29/06/1998 29/06/2033 To divert water in Takapu Stream to reinstate bank to protect water main. Takapu Stream 1755379 5440886 DIVERSION 2665 WGN98024801 Wellington Regional DP - SEWAGE / 17/03/1999 17/03/2014 To discharge sludge and effluent to land Queen Elizabeth Park 1765581 5464085 Recreat SLUDGES 3418 WGN99001101 Hyde, Neil & Lloyd LUC - HAZARD 31/07/1998 31/07/2033 To undertake erosion control works along Takapu Stream banks CO: Digger place 110 Takapu Road, 1754479 5439687

PAGE 18 OF 19 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

MITIGATION 2 ton blocks along bank, backfill and plant Grenada North, 3293 WGN99001401 Stickney, Phil LUC - SOIL 24/07/1998 24/07/2050 To undertake earthworks to disturb soil for building platform (775m3) Health Care Nz Ltd 1754973 5444188 DISTURBANCE 4572 WGN99004801 Sue Hobbs & Chris LUC - RIVER 30/09/1998 30/09/2033 To Place a culvert in the bed of a stream Kelson 1762579 5440486 Streatfield CROSSING 3603 WGN99009301 Cheriton, Wayne LUC - 23/02/1999 23/02/2034 To construct a building platform in a wetland area CO: Excavate peat, construct 68 Poplar Avenue 1766881 5466285 RECLAMATION retaining wall, backfill with sand. 4578 WGN99009501 Barriball, Grant LUC - RIVER 15/12/1998 15/12/2033 To create ford over stream for relocation of house. CO: Already completed. Used 1 Willowbank Road 1753279 5438887 CROSSING machinery for heavy work. 3166 WGN99009502 Barriball, Grant LUC - RIVER 15/12/1998 15/12/2033 To Construct a bridge over Porirua Stream - access to house. 1 Willowbank Road 1753279 5438887 CROSSING 3431 WGN99009503 Barriball, Grant LUC - HAZARD 15/12/1998 15/12/2033 Construction and Maintenance of gabion baskets. CO: Refer to application and 1 Willowbank Road 1753279 5438887 MITIGATION officers report. 4581 WGN99010901 Wrc, Forestry Dept. LUC - RIVER 08/01/1999 08/01/2034 Place 9 culverts in stream beds for logging track access Upper Hutt 1767981 5458285 CROSSING 3433 WGN99012102 Wellington Regional LUC - HAZARD 12/01/1999 12/01/2034 To place up to 2 m of gabion baskets and rock rip rap CO: By a digger Horokiri Stream, 1762680 5452985 Council Recreat MITIGATION Battle Hill 4584 WGN99012103 Wellington Regional LUC - RIVER 12/01/1999 12/01/2034 To reinstate two 900m culverts Battle Hill Farm 1763080 5452985 Recreat CROSSING 4583 WGN99012201 Walsh, J & M LUC - RIVER 13/01/1999 12/01/2034 To extend exisiting culverts. Tawa 1753679 5439487 CROSSING 4585 WGN99012901 Porirua City Council LUC - RIVER 22/01/1999 22/01/2034 To construct a culvert Takapuwahia 1754180 5445786 CROSSING 3479 WGN99014001 Moody, Hudson LUC - GENERAL 03/02/1999 03/02/2034 Replace stormwater intake structure with concrete wingwall Resourceholdings NZ 1753480 5442587 STRUCTURE LTD 4223 WGN99015801 Porirua City Council LUC - 26/03/1999 26/03/2034 Remove vegetation and debris from Whitby lakes CO: Lake levels lowered and Upper And Lower 1758880 5446286 STREAMWORK mechanical digger used Whitby Lakes 4222 WGN99015901 Porirua City Council LUC - 26/03/1999 26/03/2034 Remove vegetation and debris from lake bed CO: Material removed with long Cannons Creek Lake 1756780 5443786 STREAMWORK reach mechanical digger Reserve 4234 WGN99018701 Transit New Zealand LUC - 20/04/1999 20/04/2034 To undertake drainage works in the Inlet. CO: Machinery and by hand. 750m West Of The 1760280 5447886 STREAMWORK Pauatahanui 4241 WGN99020101 Porirua City Council LUC - 06/05/1999 06/05/2034 Removal of 20-40m3 of gravel from bed of Kakaho Stream CO: Digger removed Kakaho Stream 1759180 5449786 STREAMWORK gravel & placed most on stream true left bank 6311 WGN99020901 Kapiti Coast District WP - SURFACE 31/07/2000 31/07/2015 Surface water take for Paekakariki town water supply Wainui Sream 1766181 5460585 Council WATER TAKE (Smiths Creek) 6312 WGN99020902 Kapiti Coast District WP - SURFACE 31/07/2000 31/07/2015 Surface water take for Paekakariki town water supply Paekakariki 1766051 5461025 Council WATER TAKE 3516 WGN99020903 Kapiti Coast District LUC - GENERAL 31/07/2000 31/07/2015 Erect new secondary intake structure for town water supply. Kcdc 1766231 5460585 Council STRUCTURE 3457 WGN99022501 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 31/05/1999 31/05/2034 To install and repair bank protection works Moonshine Stream 1766580 5448085 MITIGATION 3461 WGN99023901 Porirua City Council LUC - HAZARD 07/07/1999 07/07/2034 To install concrete blocks and rip rap for stabilisation CO: foundations dug, Paekakariki Hill Road 1762680 5451585 MITIGATION digger realigning stream 3620 WGN99023903 Porirua City Council LUC - 07/07/1999 07/07/2034 To remove three fallen trees and plant willows CO: by hand 8g4 Paekakariki Hill 1762680 5451685 STREAMWORK Road 4604 WGN99024401 Cooper, AG & RL LUC - RIVER 25/06/1999 25/06/2034 Installation of a culvert inc works in the bed of a stream Judgeford 1762280 5445886 CROSSING 3183 WGN99024601 Pope, Campbell LUC - RIVER 30/06/1999 30/06/2034 To construct and maintain a bridge over Porirua Stream Porirua Stream 1753179 5439387 CROSSING 3187 WGN99024602 Pope, Campbell LUC - RIVER 30/06/1999 30/06/2034 To construct bridge abutments in the Porirua stream floodway Porirua Stream 1753179 5439387 CROSSING 4603 WGN99024901 Robinson, Peter LUC - RIVER 25/06/1999 25/06/2034 Works in the Takapu Stream to install a culvert. Tawa 1755629 5441236 CROSSING 4258 WGN99025703 Porirua City Council LUC - 04/02/2000 04/02/2035 To create two wetlands in Taupo Stream CO: Digger in the stream Taupo Stream, 3-29 1757080 5450786 STREAMWORK Ulric Street, 5131 WGN99025704 Porirua City Council WP - SURFACE 04/02/2000 04/02/2035 To divert water as a reult of extraction of peat and deposition of cleanfill for Southern Taupo 1757080 5450786 DIVERSION playing fields. Swamp

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 19 OF 19

Appendix E Approximate Location of Active Resource Consents

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 5

PAGE 2 OF 5 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 3 OF 5

PAGE 4 OF 5 WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 5 OF 5

Appendix F – Resource Consents Being Processed

FILE ID CONTACT ID CONSENT APPLICATION DESCRIPTION PURPOSE DESCRIPTION FURTHER DISCRIPTION MAP MAP TYPE COORD COORD WGN95019107 2580 Wellington Regional Discharge DP - SEWAGE / SLUDGES To discharge effluent from septic tank into 50m trenches. Queen Elizabeth Park 1765181 5462185 Council Recreat WGN96059002 1055 Porirua City Council Coastal CP - GENERAL STRUCTURE To construct and maintain two jetties inthe coastal marine area. Jetty X60J 1754980 5446786 WGN95019105 2578 Wellington Regional Discharge DP - SEWAGE / SLUDGES To discharge effluent from septic tank into 50m trenches. Queen Elizabeth Park 1764881 5462185 Council Recreat WGN090009 27602 Discharge DP - SEWAGE / SLUDGES Paekakariki Shopping 1764154 5460671 Centre WGN110508 31261 Whitby Coastal Estates Water Use WP - DAM The permanent diversion of the full flow of two reaches of Duck Creek into newly constructed stream channels, being Duck Creek South, Limited approximately 125 metres and 960 metres in length. Resolution Drive WGN110508 31263 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To place a stormwater pipe under the bed of an un-diverted section of Duck Creek and a sewer pipe under the bed of a Duck Creek South, Limited diverted section of Duck Creek, including the associated disturbance of, and deposition of material on, the streambed. Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31264 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - BRIDGE To construct a temporary bridge over the bed of Duck Creek, including the associated disturbance of the streambed. Duck Creek South, Limited Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31265 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - BRIDGE To construct two permanent bridges over the realigned bed of Duck Creek, including the associated disturbance of the Duck Creek South, Limited streambed Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31267 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - RECLAMATION To reclaim the bed of Duck Creek in two reaches, being 155 metres and 1070 metres in streambed length, the beds of Duck Creek South, Limited three intermittently flowing tributaries of Duck Creek each with a streambed length of between 50 and 200 metres. Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31323 Whitby Coastal Estates Discharge DP - DISCHARGE TO WATER To discharge sediment and chemical flocculant in treated stormwater runoff to Duck Creek, and to land where it may enter Duck Creek South, Limited Duck Creek, in association with bulk earthworks for a residential subdivision. Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31324 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - SOIL DISTURBANCE To undertake bank stabilisation works within a 260 metre un-diverted section of Duck Creek, including the associated Duck Creek South, Limited disturbance of, and deposition of material on, the bed of the stream. Resolution Drive, WGN110508 31325 Whitby Coastal Estates Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To remove material from the beds of the four stormwater ponds associated with the maintenance of the forebay and Duck Creek South, Limited wetland ponds, including the associated disturbance of the beds of those ponds. Resolution Drive, WGN110347 31252 Pauatahanui Forest Discharge DP - CONTAMINATED To discharge stormwater contaminated with sediment, originating from areas of bulk earthworks exceeding 0.3 hectares, 346a Paremata Haywards Limited STORMWATER TO LAN into water, and onto land where it may enter water, from sediment control and treatment measures Road WGN110347 31254 Pauatahanui Forest Water Use WP - DAM To dam and divert an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui Stream 346a Paremata Haywards Limited Road WGN110347 31048 Pauatahanui Forest Land Use LUC - CULVERT To extend culvert currently in place in an un named side stream of the Pauatahanui stream and build a fill above the 346a Paremata Haywards Limited culvert to provide a road suitable for logging truck access Road WGN110347 31255 Pauatahanui Forest Land Use LUC - SOIL DISTURBANCE For disturbance and deposition associated with the cable hauling of logs through an unnamed tributary of the Pauatahanui 346a Paremata Haywards Limited stream Road WGN110347 31253 Pauatahanui Forest Land Use LUC - ROADING / TRACKING To disturb soil in association with constructing roading and tracking with an upslope batter greater than 2 metres 346a Paremata Haywards Limited extending for a length greater than 200 metres Road WGN110347 31345 Pauatahanui Forest Land Use LUC - RECLAMATION To reclaim a 10m section of stream bed length 346a Paremata Haywards Limited Road WGN080142 26435 Crosco Construction Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To construct a culvert 317 Flightys Road, 1762747 5449404 Limited Judgeford WGN070141 25755 Budgen, Graham & Discharge DP - CONTAMINATED To discharge sediment-laden stormwater and organic leachate to land where it may enter the waters of an unnamed stream 346c Paremata-Haywards 1763940 5445895 Wendy STORMWATER TO LAN of the Pauatahanui Stream catchment. Rd, Judgefor WGN080098 26354 Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To pipe 31m of an unnamed tributary of Duck Creek, including any associated disturbance to the stream bed and banks. James Cook Drive, Whitby, 1759655 5444425 Porirua WGN060295 25274 Roil, Pat Water Use WP - SURFACE WATER To partially divert the full flow of an unamed tributary onsite into a pipe 110a Mulhern Road, 1763488 5447363 DIVERSION Judgeford WGN080142 26434 Crosco Construction Land Use LUC - GENERAL STRUCTURE To construct a culvert 317 Flighty's Road, 1762747 5449404 Limited Judgeford WGN080098 26355 Water Use WP - SURFACE WATER To temporarily divert water during construction of a culvert James Cook Drive, Whitby 1759655 5447425 DIVERSION WGN060295 25275 Roil, Pat Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To place a pipe in a section of the bed of a watercourse and to divert the flow of the watercourse into that pipe 110a Mulhern Road, 1763488 5447363 Judgeford WGN110365 31069 Camp Elsdon Inc Land Use LUC - STREAMWORK To divert a small tributary of the Porirua Stream, up to 3 metres away from an eroding bank which will be protected by six 18 Raiha St, Porirua 1753310 5444410 2 metre long gabions arranged along the bank WGN120031 31315 Leacroft Nurseries Ltd Water Use WP - SURFACE WATER TAKE To abstract water from the Horokiri Stream for horticultural purposes. Horikiri Stream 1760780 5449086

WGN_DOCS-#960551-v1 PAGE 1 OF 1