Functional Mapping in the Human Brain Using High Magnetic Fields
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Functional mapping in the human brain using high magnetic ®elds Kaª mil Ugurbil, Xiaoping Hu, Wei Chen, Xiao-Hong Zhu, Seong-Gi Kim and Apostolos Georgopoulos Center for Magnetic Resonance Research, University of Minnesota, 2021 6th Street SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA An avidly pursued new dimension in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) research is the acquisition of physiological and biochemical information non-invasively using the nuclear spins of the water molecules in the human body. In this trial, a recent and unique accomplishment was the introduction of the ability to map human brain function non-invasively. Today, functional images with subcentimetre resolution of the entire human brain can be generated in single subjects and in data acquisition times of several minutes using 1.5 tesla (T) MRI scanners that are often used in hospitals for clinical purposes. However, there have been accomplishments beyond this type of imaging using signi¢cantly higher magnetic ¢elds such as 4 T. E¡orts for developing high magnetic ¢eld human brain imaging and functional mapping using MRI (fMRI) were undertaken at about the same time. It has been demonstrated that high magnetic ¢elds result in improved contrast and, more importantly, in elevated sensitivity to capillary level changes coupled to neuronal activity in the blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) contrast mechanism used in fMRI. These advantages have been used to generate, for example, high resolution functional maps of ocular dominance columns, retinotopy within the small lateral geniculate nucleus, true single-trial fMRI and early negative signal changes in the temporal evolution of the BOLD signal. So far these have not been duplicated or have been observed as signi¢cantly weaker e¡ects at much lower ¢eld strengths. Some of these high-¢eld advantages and accomplishments are reviewed in this paper. Keywords: fMRI; BOLD contrast; human brain imaging; functional mapping; brain function ¢rst functional image of the human brain was based on 1. INTRODUCTION measurements of task-induced blood volume change The phenomenon of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) assessed by intravenous bolus injection of an exogenous was described in landmark papers over 50 years ago MRI contrast agent, a highly paramagnetic substance, (Rabi et al. 1938, 1939; Purcell et al. 1945; Bloch et al. into the human subject and tracking the bolus passage 1946). Because of its ability to obtain discrete resonances through the brain with consecutive, rapidly acquired sensitive to the chemical environment, NMR rapidly images (Belliveau et al. 1991). However, this method was evolved to become an indispensable tool in chemical and quickly rendered obsolete with the introduction of totally biological research focused on molecular composition, non-invasive methods of functional MRI (fMRI) of the structure and dynamics. In 1973, a novel concept using brain (e.g. Bandettini et al. 1992; Kwong et al. 1992; NMR of the hydrogen atoms in the human body as an Ogawa et al. 1992; Edelman et al. 1994; Kim 1995). These imaging modality was introduced (Lauterbur 1973). new methods permitted examination of functional While all NMR applications of the time were singularly specialization in the human brain with unprecedented concerned with eliminating inhomogeneities in magnetic spatial resolution. ¢eld magnitude over the sample, this new concept Historically, one of the earliest compelling arguments embraced them and proposed using them to extract for the existence of regional specialization of human spatial information. From this early concept emerged brain function was presented by Broca (1855) in the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) which is now solidly middle of the 19th century. Broca (1855) examined a established as a non-invasive technique which permits the patient who was unable to speak as a result of a stroke but visualization of human anatomy with high spatial resolu- who was otherwise normal. Based on an autopsy tion and the ability to distinguish di¡erent types of performed subsequent to the patient's death, Broca & tissues. Brown-Sequard (1855) concluded that the seat of the An avidly pursued new dimension in MRI research is damage was an egg-sized lesion located in the inferior the acquisition of physiological and biochemical informa- frontal gyrus of the frontal lobe in the left hemisphere; tion non-invasively using the nuclear spins of the water this general area is now commonly referred to as Broca's molecules in the human body. In this trial, a recent and area although its precise topographical extent remains unique accomplishment was the introduction of the ambiguous. This type of lesion study and later intra- ability to map human brain function non-invasively. The operative mapping e¡orts with electrodes were, until Phil.Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B(1999)354, 1195^1213 1195 & 1999 The Royal Society 119 6 K. Ugurbil and others Functional mapping in the human brain recently, the primary source of our current understanding recovery (FAIR) technique (Kim 1995; Kim & Tsekos of functional compartmentation in the human brain. 1997; Kim & Ugurbil 1997), frequency-selective inversion The language area ¢rst identi¢ed by Broca & Brown- pulses are used to invert the longitudinal magnetization Sequard (1855) can now be visualized with previously within a `slab' along one direction (typically axial); in the unavailable spatial resolution and detail using fMRI in absence of blood £ow, the spins relax back to thermal data collection times that last only a few minutes. Figure 1 equilibrium only by spin-lattice relaxation mechanisms displays the three-dimensional (3D) result of such a study characterized by the time constant T1. If £ow is present, (P. Erhard, P. Strick, J. Strupp, A. K. Helms Tillery, however, the relaxation becomes e¡ectively faster as S. Naeve-Velguth and K. Ugurbil, unpublished results). unperturbed spins outside the inverted slab £ow in and The grey-scale picture is an anatomical image. Super- replenish the net magnetization within the slab. Conse- imposed onto the anatomical image in colour is the quently, the e¡ective spin-lattice relaxation in FAIR, as functional map generated during a covert task where the well as in other £ow-sensitive techniques (Detre et al. subjects were shown pictures of objects and were asked to 1992, 1994; Roberts et al. 1994; Kim 1995; Kwong et al. name them. The left and right sides of the brain are seen 1995), becomes characterized by a shorter time constant à in ¢gure 1a,b. Figure 1c illustrates the 3D image from a T1 , which is related to blood £ow. It also follows naturally di¡erent angle, looking onto the left side and the top of that, if the inversion pulse in FAIR does not de¢ne a slab the brain. In these images, we see only the activation on but inverts everything in the whole body (i.e. it is non- the outer cortical surface. When the anatomical image is selective), blood £ow does not enter into the problem at rendered partially transparent, activation in the interior all. Thus, in the FAIR technique two images are acquired of the brain and within its numerous folds (sulci) also consecutively, each after a ¢xed delay period subsequent becomes visible, albeit with diminished intensity to the inversion pulse; in one the inversion pulse is slab (¢gure 1d ). selective and in the other it is non-selective. The di¡er- These images are based on blood oxygen level dependent ence image generated from this pair is a £ow-sensitive (BOLD) contrast, which was ¢rst described by Ogawa & image. Figure 2 illustrates the results of such a `blood Lee (1990) and Ogawa et al. (199 0a,b) in rat brain studies £ow'-based functional imaging study in the human brain and subsequently applied to generate functional images in acquired at 4 tesla (T) during a ¢nger movement task. the human brain (Bandettini et al. 1992; Kwong et al. The grey-scale image depicts CBF which is high in the 1992; Ogawa et al. 1992). BOLD contrast originates from `grey' matter areas that contain the cell bodies and the the intravoxel magnetic ¢eld in homogeneity induced by dendrites and low in the white matter which is primarily paramagnetic deoxyhaemoglobin sequestered in red composed of axons connecting the neurons. As expected, blood cells, which in turn are compartmentalized within these CBF images resemble anatomical images that the blood vessels. Magnetic susceptibility di¡erences distinguish the grey and white matter in the brain. between the deoxyhaemoglobin-containing compart- However, in the case of the blood £ow image illustrated ments versus the surrounding space devoid of this strongly in ¢gure 2, the signal intensity can be quantitated and paramagnetic molecule generate magnetic ¢eld gradients assigned a number in terms of millilitres of blood deliv- across and near the boundaries of these compartments. ered per minute to a gram of brain tissue (Kim 1995; Therefore, signal intensities in magnetic resonance Kim & Tsekos 1997). T he colour map describes regions in images sensitized to BOLD contrast are altered if the the brain where blood £ow increased in response to the regional deoxyhaemoglobin content is perturbed. This execution of the ¢nger movement task; this is the `activa- occurs in the brain because of the spatially speci¢c tion' or `functional' image. Note the excellent correspon- metabolic and haemodynamic response to enhanced dence between the colour map and the grey matter areas neuronal activity; it has been suggested that regional in ¢gure 2; this is expected from a good functional image blood £ow (CBF) increases while the oxygen consump- at this spatial resolution and is evidence of the accuracy tion rate (CMRO2) in the same area is not elevated of these maps because blood £ow is high to begin with commensurably (Fox & Raichle 1986; Raichle 1987; Fox et and increases more in the grey compared to the white al.