Arxiv:1603.08409V1 [Math.HO] 1 Mar 2016 On-Line Discussion and Brain-Storming About the Shape
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
October 4, 2021 Journal of Mathematics and the Arts sphericonsdformsarxiv To appear in the Journal of Mathematics and the Arts Vol. 00, No. 00, Month 20XX, 1{9 Sphericons and D-forms: a crocheted connection Katherine A. Seatona∗ aDepartment of Mathematics and Statistics, La Trobe University VIC 3086, Australia (Received 00 Month 20XX; final version received 00 Month 20XX) Sphericons and D-forms are 3D objects created and described by artists, which have separately received attention in the mathematical literature in the last 15 or so years. The attempt to classify a seamed, crocheted form geometrically led to the observation, which appears not to have been previously made explicit, that these objects are related. Instructions to crochet D-forms are given in the Appendix. Keywords: sphericon, D-form, pita form, developable surface, Ravelry, crochet AMS Subject Classification: 51M04; 97M80 1. Introduction In January 2015, a crocheter on the social networking site Ravelry[1] posted images of a coin purse she had made as a Christmas present, and started a discussion thread asking readers of a particular forum if they could help her identify the name of its 3D shape (hereafter termed The Shape). The purse, shown in Figure 1, had been constructed following a pattern[4] by making a flat oval, and attaching a zipper to its edge in such a way that when the zipper closed, the purse was not folded over exactly in half onto itself (flat), but sat up, enclosing an intriguingly-shaped volume. The crocheter had read the German version[19] of an Ian Stewart column on the sphericon[25], and believed that The Shape might be sort-of-but-not-quite a sphericon. However, the paper templates for making one's own sphericons provided in [19, 25] have curved edges only, which her oval did not. In fact oval is rather loose a term, and broadly means egg-like. The purse in question had been constructed from a stadium, the 2D shape made from a rectangle and two semi-circles, as shown in Figure 2. Over the next few weeks, various Ravelry members, including the author of this paper, joined in arXiv:1603.08409v1 [math.HO] 1 Mar 2016 on-line discussion and brain-storming about The Shape. More than 500 of Ravelry's (admittedly 6 million) members read at least part of the thread (before, as threads do, it wandered off to shapes more generally). Patterns for objects with similar construction were pointed out[6]. As well as the sphericon family, D-forms[8, 22] were mentioned. So, was The Shape one of these, and if so, which was it? The sphericon has been described as `[a] solid ... not as widely known as it should be'[27]. An introduction to the history and properties of sphericons and D-forms, and their relatives, thus make up the next two sections of the paper. In the final section, The Shape will be classified, thereby stitching (literally) a connection between sphericons and D-forms. ∗ Email: [email protected] 1 October 4, 2021 Journal of Mathematics and the Arts sphericonsdformsarxiv Figure 1. Photograph of the coin purse, The Shape, made from a crocheted stadium. Courtesy of Annagret. r 2r h Figure 2. A stadium, a rectangle of length h inserted between two halves of a circle of radius r. 2. Sphericons: making things out of solids The sphericon, at least as a mathematical object, came to public attention in Stewart's Math- ematical Recreations column[25] in 1999. Colin Roberts, a joiner who had enjoyed geometry at school, sent Stewart his creation, after seeing him on television. The column was written shortly after this. Roberts had first made a sphericon from mahogany some thirty years earlier in 1967. Independently, in the early 1980s, an Israeli designer Hirsch submitted a patent application for `meander motion' toys constructed on the same principles[12]. Roberts' motivation, however, lay in producing a one-surfaced object, with no hole (unlike the well-known M¨obiusstrip). The sphericon can be constructed from a pair of identical cones of apex angle 90 degrees joined at their bases (a bicone). Cut the bicone in half through the two apices so as to reveal its square cross-section, twist one half through 90 degrees, and then `glue' the square faces together again. Clear diagrams and photos showing this process are plentiful; see for example [17, 19, 25]. Judging from these photos, especially when made of grained wood, it is a beautiful object. It has one continous sinuous[24] surface, and two non-intersecting curved edges, set at right angles. The sphericon rolls in an amusing manner, what Stewart terms `a controlled wiggle'[25], the meander motion of Hirsch's toys[12]. A sphere will roll in a straight line, and a cone rolls in a circle. The sphericon changes direction as the parts of its surface come into contact with the surface it is rolling on, but on average the motion is in a line. Hence the name sphericon. The sphericon featured next in the monthly Feature Column of the American Mathematical Society[17], wherein the Gaussian curvature was shown to be 4π by considering carefully what happens at its edges and the cone apices, and the hexasphericon was introduced. Phillips found connections between such higher order sphericons (to be introduced below) and his work on mazes[18]. Some particular closed space curves were found to lie on the sphericon surface in [14], and an explicit hybrid function form (in cartesian coordinates) is given. Perhaps not surprisingly, given its origins, wood-turners began experimenting with the spheri- con. A special join, called a paper join, enables the cutting-open process to be done without damage. The bicone can be replaced by any solid of revolution with appropriate cross-section symmetry. Some makers introduced different profiles (producing what they termed femispheres) or non-convex cross-sections (the streptohedrons)[23]. Other makers[24] generated some of the 2 October 4, 2021 Journal of Mathematics and the Arts sphericonsdformsarxiv Figure 3. The dual sphericon. convex geometric objects that are classified as the series of N-icons[13]. Sphericons have been made of ceramic, glass, plastic (3D printing) and as metal sculptures, as well as of wood. Think of the bicone as the solid of revolution of a square about its diagonal. Now replace the square by any other N-vertex regular convex polygon, and use one of the symmetry axes to generate a solid of revolution[13]. When N is odd, this axis will run through one vertex and one flat face of the polygon. When N is even, the polygonal cross-section can be rotated about an axis through two opposite vertices or through the centres of two opposing flat faces. For N > 4, different `-icons' can be produced by more than one rotation (in the cut-rotate-reglue process), due to the rotational symmetries of the cross-section; these may be completely different or may come in right- and left-hand pairs. A full classification of the family of solids requires one to kπ specify k 2 N where N is the rotation (in radians) between cutting and regluing, termed the twist in [13]. Two special cases will now be considered: The dual sphericon Rotating a square about an axis through a pair of opposing flat faces results in a cylinder of equal height and diameter. Applying the cutting and twisting process, an object with two surfaces and one continuous edge is produced, as illustrated in Figure 3; this object is dual to the original sphericon (two edges and one surface). Springett described this object, which wood-turners term side-cut, as being `rather unexciting'[23]1. In the cutting process, four semicircles are produced, which are then joined smoothly to the sides of the cylinder. The paper template for this object consists of not one stadium, but two. When this solid is rolled, it will come to rest on a flat semi-circle. It has two surfaces, and thus provides a possible two-sided dice. Indeed, such dice | and various (N; k)-icons | are available from 3D printing artists. The trisphericon A single cone may be created as the solid of revolution of an equilateral triangle, the N = 3 case. It can be cut to produce a triangular cross-section. When one half is rotated through 60 degrees and the form reglued, a self-dual solid with one curved surface, one S-shaped edge and 2 vertices is produced. Following a similar argument to [25] we can establish what the paper template for this object is (Figure 4). This object has also been called the `kleines sphericon'[19], the `conicon'[13] and the `equilaticon'. While `one-sided dice' based on the M¨obius band are available to purchase, and the g¨omb¨ochas been suggested as a more dice-like alternative, the trisphericon has the desirable features of having no hole, and of coming to rest when rolled, sitting stably on one of its semi-circular elements after a wiggly journey. More generally, the N-icons can always be considered as formed by cutting, twisting and N reglueing a solid made of b 2 c sections of cones (possibly including a cone with apex at infinity, a cylinder). In Kaufman's study, he finds that the N-icons for odd N are self-dual and the N-icons for even N have dual forms, generated by the two different symmetry axes[13]. Two stadiums may be present in the dual N-icons, as we can see from the four semicircles created in 1It will become apparent that this author does not share this opinion.