Fossil Ridge Wilderness Indigenous Fish And

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Fossil Ridge Wilderness Indigenous Fish And a Forest Service U.S. Department of Agriculture In Partnership with Western Colorado University Indigenous Fish and Wildlife Management Strategy Fossil Ridge Wilderness, Gunnison National Forest “Like winds and sunsets, wild things were taken for granted until progress began to do away with them. Now we face the question whether a still higher ‘standard of living’ is worth its cost in things natural, wild, and free.” – Aldo Leopold Indigenous Fish and Wildlife Management Strategy Fossil Ridge Wilderness, Gunnison National Forest Tobias Nickel Wilderness Fellow Master in Environmental Management (MEM) Candidate [email protected] October 2020 Grand Mesa, Uncompahgre, and Gunnison National Forests Gunnison Ranger District 216 N. Colorado St. Gunnison, CO 81230 Western Colorado University The Center for Public Lands 1 Western Way Gunnison, CO 81231 ON THE FRONT COVER Top: Henry Mountain, the highest point in the wilderness at 13,254 feet, as seen from an expansive, subalpine grassland meadow along the Van Tuyl Trail (Tobias Nickel, July 4, 2020) Middle left: Bighorn ram (CPW) Middle right: Southern white-tailed ptarmigan in fall plumage (Shawn Conner, BIO-Logic, Inc.) Bottom left: Colorado River cutthroat trout (Photo © Alyssa Anduiza, courtesy of Aspiring Wild) Bottom right: Adult boreal toad (Brad Lambert, CNHP) ON THE BACK COVER The shores of Henry Lake in the heart of the Fossil Ridge Wilderness. Rising to over 13,000 feet, the granite peaks of the Fossil Ridge tower in the background (Tobias Nickel, June 16, 2020) ii iii Dedication This publication is dedicated to all past, present, and future defenders of wilderness. Your efforts safeguard the Earth’s wild treasures from our species’ most destructive tendencies and demonstrate that humility and restraint are possible in an age of overconsumption and unfettered development. I also dedicate it to all those who venture responsibly into the Fossil Ridge Wilderness – may you find the inspiration, solitude, and tranquility that you seek. “When despair grows in me and I wake in the night at the least sound in fear of what my life and my children's lives may be, I go and lie down where the wood drake rests in his beauty on the water, and the great heron feeds. I come into the peace of wild things who do not tax their lives with forethought of grief. I come into the presence of still water. And I feel above me the day-blind stars waiting for their light. For a time I rest in the grace of the world, and am free.” – Wendell Berry, The Peace of Wild Things iv Contents Page Figures .................................................................................................................................................viii Tables ..................................................................................................................................................viii Appendices ............................................................................................................................................ ix Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................... 1 Acknowledgments .................................................................................................................................. 2 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 4 Purpose and Need for Action ......................................................................................................... 4 Scope .............................................................................................................................................. 5 Brief Description of the Fossil Ridge Wilderness .......................................................................... 6 Overview of Wilderness Character ...................................................................................................... 10 Defining Wilderness Character .................................................................................................... 10 Fish and Wildlife Management from the Perspective of Wilderness Character .......................... 12 Balancing the Natural and Untrammeled Qualities of Wilderness Character .............................. 13 Wilderness-Wildlife Interrelationships ................................................................................................ 16 Fish and Wildlife as a Measure of Wilderness Character ............................................................ 16 A Wilderness Role in Fish and Wildlife Conservation ................................................................ 17 Managing Fish and Wildlife in Designated Wilderness ...................................................................... 18 Laws, Policies, and Forest Planning ............................................................................................. 18 Concurrent Jurisdiction between State and Federal Agencies ...................................................... 20 Cooperation between State and Federal Agencies: Memoranda of Understanding ..................... 21 Minimum Requirements Analysis ................................................................................................ 22 A Framework for Evaluating Proposals for Ecological Intervention in Wilderness .................... 23 Priority Species for the Fossil Ridge Wilderness ................................................................................. 25 Defining Priority Species ............................................................................................................. 25 Process Used for Identifying Priority Species .............................................................................. 25 List of Priority Species and Rationales for Selection ................................................................... 27 v Wilderness Management Strategy – Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep ................................................ 30 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 30 Current Status in the Fossil Ridge Wilderness ............................................................................. 33 Management Objectives ............................................................................................................... 35 Management Recommendations .................................................................................................. 36 Adaptive Management and Contingency Planning ...................................................................... 43 Wilderness Stewardship Considerations ...................................................................................... 46 Effectiveness Monitoring ............................................................................................................. 48 Wilderness Management Strategy – Southern White-tailed Ptarmigan ............................................... 50 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 50 Current Status in the Fossil Ridge Wilderness ............................................................................. 53 Management Objectives ............................................................................................................... 59 Management Recommendations .................................................................................................. 60 Adaptive Management and Contingency Planning ...................................................................... 64 Wilderness Stewardship Considerations ...................................................................................... 65 Effectiveness Monitoring ............................................................................................................. 66 Wilderness Management Strategy – Colorado River Cutthroat Trout ................................................. 67 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 67 Current Status in the Fossil Ridge Wilderness ............................................................................. 71 Management Objectives ............................................................................................................... 73 Management Recommendations .................................................................................................. 74 Adaptive Management and Contingency Planning ...................................................................... 79 Wilderness Stewardship Considerations ...................................................................................... 82 Effectiveness Monitoring ............................................................................................................. 86 Wilderness Management Strategy – Boreal Toad ................................................................................ 88 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 88 Current Status in the Fossil Ridge Wilderness ............................................................................. 90 Management Objectives ..............................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • New Core Study Unearths Insights Into Uinta Basin Evolution and Resources
    UTAH GEOLOGICAL SURVEY SURVEY NOTES VOLUME 51, NUMBER 2 MAY 2019 New core study unearths insights into Uinta Basin evolution and resources CONTENTS New Core, New Insights into Ancient DIRECTOR’S PERSPECTIVE Lake Uinta Evolution and Uinta Basin • Exploration and development of Energy Resources ..........................1 by Bill Keach unconventional resources. Oil shale Drones for Good: Utah Geologists As the incoming Take to the Skies ...........................3 director for the Utah and sand continue to be a provocative Utah Mining Districts at Your Fingertips . .4 Geological Survey opportunity still searching for an eco- Energy News: The Benefits of Utah (UGS), I would like to nomic threshold. Oil and Gas Production.....................6 thank Rick Allis for his Glad You Asked: What are Those • Earthquake early warning systems. Can Blue Ponds Near Moab?....................8 guidance and leader- they work on the Wasatch Front? GeoSights: Pine Park and Ancient ship over the past 18 years. In Rick’s first • Incorporating technology into field Supervolcanoes of Southwestern Utah....10 “Director’s Perspective” he made predic- Survey News...............................12 tions of “likely hot-button issues” that the mapping and hazard recognition and UGS would face. These issues included: using data analytics and knowledge Design | Jenny Erickson sharing in our work at the UGS. Cover | View to the west of Willow Creek • Renewed exploration for oil and gas in core study area. Photo by Ryan Gall. the State. The last item is dear to my heart. A large part of my career has been in the devel- State of Utah • Renewed interest in more fossil-fuel-fired Gary R.
    [Show full text]
  • Land Areas of the National Forest System, As of September 30, 2019
    United States Department of Agriculture Land Areas of the National Forest System As of September 30, 2019 Forest Service WO Lands FS-383 November 2019 Metric Equivalents When you know: Multiply by: To fnd: Inches (in) 2.54 Centimeters Feet (ft) 0.305 Meters Miles (mi) 1.609 Kilometers Acres (ac) 0.405 Hectares Square feet (ft2) 0.0929 Square meters Yards (yd) 0.914 Meters Square miles (mi2) 2.59 Square kilometers Pounds (lb) 0.454 Kilograms United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service Land Areas of the WO, Lands National Forest FS-383 System November 2019 As of September 30, 2019 Published by: USDA Forest Service 1400 Independence Ave., SW Washington, DC 20250-0003 Website: https://www.fs.fed.us/land/staff/lar-index.shtml Cover Photo: Mt. Hood, Mt. Hood National Forest, Oregon Courtesy of: Susan Ruzicka USDA Forest Service WO Lands and Realty Management Statistics are current as of: 10/17/2019 The National Forest System (NFS) is comprised of: 154 National Forests 58 Purchase Units 20 National Grasslands 7 Land Utilization Projects 17 Research and Experimental Areas 28 Other Areas NFS lands are found in 43 States as well as Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. TOTAL NFS ACRES = 192,994,068 NFS lands are organized into: 9 Forest Service Regions 112 Administrative Forest or Forest-level units 503 Ranger District or District-level units The Forest Service administers 149 Wild and Scenic Rivers in 23 States and 456 National Wilderness Areas in 39 States. The Forest Service also administers several other types of nationally designated
    [Show full text]
  • Papilio Series) @17 2006
    (NEW April 28 PAPILIO SERIES) @17 2006 PROPOSALS FOR A NEW INSECT STUDY, COMMERCE, AND CONSERVATION LAW THAT DEREGULATES DEAD INSECTS, AND PROPOSALS FOR FIXING THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT AS APPLIED TO INSECTS By Dr. James A. Scott, 60 Estes St., Lakewood, Colorado, 80226 (Ph.D. in entomology, University of California, Berkeley) Why Do We Need New Insect Laws? The current laws regulating insects (and plants) in the U.S. are very bad. They were made for deer, and are only incidentally being applied to insects, because no legislators ever thought to make laws specifically targeted at insects that are not agricultural pests. These laws are not serving the conservation of insects well, and the laws are retarding the taxonomic study of insects, and are making criminals out of harmless hobbyist insect collectors. Basically, large animals like deer and Bighorn Sheep can be managed by controlling the numbers hunted using bag limits and exclusion areas etc., and roping and corraling them and transporting them to new sites. Large animals tend to have low population numbers, so might need to be protected from hunting (after all, at the end of the shooting spree in the late 1800s, the U.S. reached a low of population numbers for Bison and deer and nearly every other large animal, and their numbers have gradually recovered since). But insects are tiny by comparison, and their population sizes are huge by comparison. The average insect may be a thousand or a million times more numerous than your average deer'. Insect population sizes cannot be "managed" like deer, because population sizes vary hugely mostly depending on the weather and other uncontrollable factors, and their survival depends on the continued survival of their habitat, rather than useless government intervention.
    [Show full text]
  • VGP) Version 2/5/2009
    Vessel General Permit (VGP) Version 2/5/2009 United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) VESSEL GENERAL PERMIT FOR DISCHARGES INCIDENTAL TO THE NORMAL OPERATION OF VESSELS (VGP) AUTHORIZATION TO DISCHARGE UNDER THE NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM In compliance with the provisions of the Clean Water Act (CWA), as amended (33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq.), any owner or operator of a vessel being operated in a capacity as a means of transportation who: • Is eligible for permit coverage under Part 1.2; • If required by Part 1.5.1, submits a complete and accurate Notice of Intent (NOI) is authorized to discharge in accordance with the requirements of this permit. General effluent limits for all eligible vessels are given in Part 2. Further vessel class or type specific requirements are given in Part 5 for select vessels and apply in addition to any general effluent limits in Part 2. Specific requirements that apply in individual States and Indian Country Lands are found in Part 6. Definitions of permit-specific terms used in this permit are provided in Appendix A. This permit becomes effective on December 19, 2008 for all jurisdictions except Alaska and Hawaii. This permit and the authorization to discharge expire at midnight, December 19, 2013 i Vessel General Permit (VGP) Version 2/5/2009 Signed and issued this 18th day of December, 2008 William K. Honker, Acting Director Robert W. Varney, Water Quality Protection Division, EPA Region Regional Administrator, EPA Region 1 6 Signed and issued this 18th day of December, 2008 Signed and issued this 18th day of December, Barbara A.
    [Show full text]
  • Papilio 0 0000 ..;)
    1 NEW :ft{t 2 Nov. 15,1982 SERIES • $1.50 PAPILIO 0 0000 ..;) THE Lil'E HISTORY AND l!XlOLOGY f!F AN ALPINE RELICT, BOLORIA !MFR.OBA ACROCNEMA (LEPIDOP.rEltA: NYMPHALIDAE), ILLUSTRATING A NE.W MATHEMATICAL POPULATION CENSUS MEl'HOD Dr. James A. Scott, 60 Estes St., Lakewood, Colorado, 80226 Abstract. The egg, larva, and pupa of B. improba acrocnema are described and illustrated. The larval foodplant Is Salix nivalis. There are five instars; overwintering occurs in the fourth instar, and perhaps also in the first instar. Adults fly slowly near the ground, and are very local. Males patrol to find females. Adults often visit flowers, and bask on dark soil by spreading the wings laterally. A binomial method is derived and used to determine daily population size. Daily population size may be as large as 655, and yearly population size may reach two thousand in a few hectares. Introduction Boloria improba (Butl.) is a circumpolar butterfly, occurring from northern Scandinavia eastward to northern Siberia and arctic America. In North America it occurs from Alaska to Baffin r., south to central Alberta, and a relict subspecies acrocnema G. & s. occurs in the alpine San Juan Mts. of Colorado. The life history and ecology of improba were nearly unknown. This paper presents the complete life history and details of the. life cycle, ecology, and behavior, studied from 1979 to 1981. In addition, a new method of computing the population size of one continuous mark­ recapture sample is presented, which is useful for quick survey work on colonial animals like insects.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendices, Browns Canyon National Monument
    BLM Mission The Bureau of Land Management's mission is to sustain the health, diversity, and productivity of public lands for the use and enjoyment of present and future generations. USFS Mission The mission of the USDA Forest Service is to sustain the health, diversity, and productivity of the nation’s forests and grasslands to meet the needs of present and future generations. BLM/CO/PL-20/008 Cover photo credit: Logan Myers Browns Canyon National Monument Proposed Resource Management Plan / Final Environmental Impact Statement Volume 2: Appendices Prepared by U.S. Department of the Interior Bureau of Land Management Royal Gorge Field Office Cañon City, Colorado and U.S. Department of Agriculture U.S. Forest Service Pike and San Isabel National Forests and Cimarron and Comanche National Grasslands Salida, Colorado April 2020 This page intentionally left blank. Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS Appendix A. Bibliography Appendix B. Glossary Appendix C. Key Word Index Appendix D. Maps Appendix E. Laws, Regulations, Policies, Guidance, and Monument Resources, Objects, and Values Appendix F. Consultation and Coordination Appendix G. Best Management Practices Reference List Appendix H. Updated Evaluation of Relevance and Importance Criteria Appendix I. Wild and Scenic River Study Appendix J. Cumulative Impact Methodology and Past, Present, and Reasonably Foreseeable Future Actions Appendix K. Mitigation Strategy, Adaptive Management, and Monitoring Measures Appendix L. Management Zones Frameworks for Recreation and Visitor Services Appendix M. USFS Wilderness Inventory Suitability Determination Appendix N. Draft RMP/EIS Comment Analysis Report Browns Canyon National Monument i Proposed Resource Management Plan/Final Environmental Impact Statement April 2020 Table of Contents This page intentionally left blank.
    [Show full text]
  • Profiles of Colorado Roadless Areas
    PROFILES OF COLORADO ROADLESS AREAS Prepared by the USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Region July 23, 2008 INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK 2 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ARAPAHO-ROOSEVELT NATIONAL FOREST ......................................................................................................10 Bard Creek (23,000 acres) .......................................................................................................................................10 Byers Peak (10,200 acres)........................................................................................................................................12 Cache la Poudre Adjacent Area (3,200 acres)..........................................................................................................13 Cherokee Park (7,600 acres) ....................................................................................................................................14 Comanche Peak Adjacent Areas A - H (45,200 acres).............................................................................................15 Copper Mountain (13,500 acres) .............................................................................................................................19 Crosier Mountain (7,200 acres) ...............................................................................................................................20 Gold Run (6,600 acres) ............................................................................................................................................21
    [Show full text]
  • Summits on the Air – ARM for USA - Colorado (WØC)
    Summits on the Air – ARM for USA - Colorado (WØC) Summits on the Air USA - Colorado (WØC) Association Reference Manual Document Reference S46.1 Issue number 3.2 Date of issue 15-June-2021 Participation start date 01-May-2010 Authorised Date: 15-June-2021 obo SOTA Management Team Association Manager Matt Schnizer KØMOS Summits-on-the-Air an original concept by G3WGV and developed with G3CWI Notice “Summits on the Air” SOTA and the SOTA logo are trademarks of the Programme. This document is copyright of the Programme. All other trademarks and copyrights referenced herein are acknowledged. Page 1 of 11 Document S46.1 V3.2 Summits on the Air – ARM for USA - Colorado (WØC) Change Control Date Version Details 01-May-10 1.0 First formal issue of this document 01-Aug-11 2.0 Updated Version including all qualified CO Peaks, North Dakota, and South Dakota Peaks 01-Dec-11 2.1 Corrections to document for consistency between sections. 31-Mar-14 2.2 Convert WØ to WØC for Colorado only Association. Remove South Dakota and North Dakota Regions. Minor grammatical changes. Clarification of SOTA Rule 3.7.3 “Final Access”. Matt Schnizer K0MOS becomes the new W0C Association Manager. 04/30/16 2.3 Updated Disclaimer Updated 2.0 Program Derivation: Changed prominence from 500 ft to 150m (492 ft) Updated 3.0 General information: Added valid FCC license Corrected conversion factor (ft to m) and recalculated all summits 1-Apr-2017 3.0 Acquired new Summit List from ListsofJohn.com: 64 new summits (37 for P500 ft to P150 m change and 27 new) and 3 deletes due to prom corrections.
    [Show full text]
  • Yukon Butterflies a Guide to Yukon Butterflies
    Wildlife Viewing Yukon butterflies A guide to Yukon butterflies Where to find them Currently, about 91 species of butterflies, representing five families, are known from Yukon, but scientists expect to discover more. Finding butterflies in Yukon is easy. Just look in any natural, open area on a warm, sunny day. Two excellent butterfly viewing spots are Keno Hill and the Blackstone Uplands. Pick up Yukon’s Wildlife Viewing Guide to find these and other wildlife viewing hotspots. Visitors follow an old mining road Viewing tips to explore the alpine on top of Keno Hill. This booklet will help you view and identify some of the more common butterflies, and a few distinctive but less common species. Additional species are mentioned but not illustrated. In some cases, © Government of Yukon 2019 you will need a detailed book, such as , ISBN 978-1-55362-862-2 The Butterflies of Canada to identify the exact species that you have seen. All photos by Crispin Guppy except as follows: In the Alpine (p.ii) Some Yukon butterflies, by Ryan Agar; Cerisy’s Sphynx moth (p.2) by Sara Nielsen; Anicia such as the large swallowtails, Checkerspot (p.2) by Bruce Bennett; swallowtails (p.3) by Bruce are bright to advertise their Bennett; Freija Fritillary (p.12) by Sonja Stange; Gallium Sphinx presence to mates. Others are caterpillar (p.19) by William Kleeden (www.yukonexplorer.com); coloured in dull earth tones Butterfly hike at Keno (p.21) by Peter Long; Alpine Interpretive that allow them to hide from bird Centre (p.22) by Bruce Bennett.
    [Show full text]
  • Papilio (New Series) #1, P
    NEW c;/;::{J:, 11 Feb. 20, 1998 PAPILIO SERIES qj::f? $1.00 NEWWESTERN NORTH AMERICAN BUTT£RFLl£S BY DR, JAMES A, SCOTT 60 Estes Street, Lakewood, Colorado 80226, and one taxon by MICHAEL S, FISHER 6521 S. Logan Street, Littleton, Colorado 80121 Abstract. New subspecies and other geographic tax.a from western U.S. are described and named. INTRODUCTION Scott (1981) named various new subspecies of butterflies from western U.S. Since then a few other butterflies have come to my attention that deserve to be named. They are named below. NEWTAXA HIPPARCHIA (NEOMINOIS) RIDINfiSII WYOMIN60 SCOTI 1998, NEW SUBSPECIES (OR SPECIES?) (Figs 1-2) DIAGNOSIS. This subspecies is distinguished by its very late flight, L Aug. to M Sept., versus June fer ordinary ridingsii (Edwards), and by its mate-locating behavior (at least in central Wyoming including the type locality), in which males perch in swales in early morning to await females, versus ridgetops for ordinary ridingsii. This butterfly is not a freak late-season occurrence; it flies every year, is very widespread in distribution, and around the end of August it is the commonest butterfly in Wyoming (except perhaps Hesperia comma). I examined valvae of this ssp. and June ridingsii, and the first few comparison pairs of examined males had a different curl on one dorsal shoulder of the valva, but as more additional males were examined, some were found to have the shape of the other, and after a dozen males of wyomingo were examined and compared to a dozen June ridingsii, it appeared that this trait was sufficiently variable that it is not a consistent difference.
    [Show full text]
  • Tympanal Ears in Nymphalidae Butterflies: Morphological Diversity and Tests on the Function of Hearing
    Tympanal Ears in Nymphalidae Butterflies: Morphological Diversity and Tests on the Function of Hearing by Laura E. Hall A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Biology Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario, Canada © 2014 Laura E. Hall i Abstract Several Nymphalidae butterflies possess a sensory structure called the Vogel’s organ (VO) that is proposed to function in hearing. However, little is known about the VO’s structure, taxonomic distribution or function. My first research objective was to examine VO morphology and its accessory structures across taxa. Criteria were established to categorize development levels of butterfly VOs and tholi. I observed that enlarged forewing veins are associated with the VOs of several species within two subfamilies of Nymphalidae. Further, I discovered a putative light/temperature-sensitive organ associated with the VOs of several Biblidinae species. The second objective was to test the hypothesis that insect ears function to detect bird flight sounds for predator avoidance. Neurophysiological recordings collected from moth ears show a clear response to flight sounds and chirps from a live bird in the laboratory. Finally, a portable electrophysiology rig was developed to further test this hypothesis in future field studies. ii Acknowledgements First and foremost I would like to thank David Hall who spent endless hours listening to my musings and ramblings regarding butterfly ears, sharing in the joy of my discoveries, and comforting me in times of frustration. Without him, this thesis would not have been possible. I thank Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter Alaska Entomological Society
    Newsletter of the Alaska Entomological Society Volume 10, Issue 1, May 2017 In this issue: DNA barcoding Alaska’s butterflies . 10 Notes on using LifeScanner for DNA-based iden- Upcoming Events . .1 tification of non-marine macroinvertebrates . 18 Western Flower Thrips and Alaska . .3 Highlights of the 10th annual meeting of the Orthosia hibisci (Guenée), the speckled green fruit- Alaska Entomological Society . 27 worm: confirmed causing extensive hardwood defoliation in Southcentral and Western Alaska5 Upcoming Events Figure 1: Graphic from Kluane Bioblitz flyer. Kluane BioBlitz, June 23–25, 2017 tional Park and Reserve. If you’d like more informa- tion, contact Bruce Bennett at [email protected]. Come join us for the Yukon’s BioBlitz in the Kluane re- Project website: http://www.inaturalist.org/projects/ gion. All are welcome to participate for the event which is kluane-bioblitz-2017-bioblitz-de-kluane-2017. part of Canada’s 150th anniversary celebrations. BioBlitz Canada and the Canadian Wildlife Federation are sup- porting a series of public BioBlitz’s across the nation and Eleventh Annual Meeting, January 2018 the Yukon Conservation Data Centre and Parks Canada in partnership with the Kluane First Nation and Cham- The eleventh annual meeting of the Alaska Entomologi- pagne and Aishihik First Nations are hosting the Yukon’s cal Society will take place in Anchorage in January 2018. 150BioBlitz in the Kluane area, including the Kluane Na- Check for updates on our events page as the meeting date approaches. Volume 10, Issue 1, May 2017 2 Western Flower Thrips and Alaska doi:10.7299/X7ST7Q01 of obligate diapause, and cryptic habit (Kirk and Terry, 2003).
    [Show full text]