Taxonomy Confirmation of Puntius Cf. Binotatus from Gunung Tujuh Lake, Jambi, Indonesia Based on Cytochrome Oxidase-I (COI) Gene
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BIODIVERSITAS ISSN: 1412-033X Volume 20, Number 1, January 2019 E-ISSN: 2085-4722 Pages: 54-60 DOI: 10.13057/biodiv/d200107 Taxonomy confirmation of Puntius cf. binotatus from Gunung Tujuh Lake, Jambi, Indonesia based on Cytochrome Oxidase-I (COI) gene DEWI IMELDA ROESMA♥, DJONG HON TJONG, WILA KARLINA, DYTA RABBANI AIDIL Department of Biology, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Universitas Andalas. Jl. Universitas Andalas, Limau Manih, Pauh, Padang 25163, West Sumatra, Indonesia. Tel. +62-751- 777427. Fax. +62-751-71343, ♥email: [email protected]. Manuscript received: 21 September 2018. Revision accepted: 2 December 2018. Abstract. Roesma D. I, Tjong D. H, Karlina W, Aidil D. R. 2019. Taxonomy confirmation of Puntius cf. binotatus from Gunung Tujuh Lake based on Cytochrome Oxidase-I (COI) gene. Biodiversitas 20: 54-60. The population of Puntius cf. binotatus Gunung Tujuh Lake in considered as an isolated population which found in the 20-30 meters depth under the water Gunung Tujuh Lake, Sumatra Island. The species often exhibit different phenotypic characters and may genetic characters may also different due to their response to habitat/ecological conditions. Previous study on P. binotatus from several locations in West Sumatra showed the complexity of the genetic and morphological characters. A molecular study using COI gene of P. cf. binotatus from Gunung Tujuh Lake in Sumatera has been conducted to determine the taxonomic status of the fish. The distinct morphological characters of Puntius cf. binotatus is one black spot in the middle of the caudal and the absent of black spot on the base of the anterior dorsal ray. The analysis on COI gene showed that the range of sequence divergences between P. cf. binotatus Gunung Tujuh Lake and other Sumatra P. cf. binotatus is 3.1-7.6% and 4.1% to Barbodes banksi. This value represents the differences at the subspecies level of Barbodes banksi. Therefore Barbodes banksi gunungtujuh is proposed as an appropriate name to P. cf. binotatus Gunung Tujuh Lake. Keywords: Morphology, Cyt b gene, COI gene, Gunung Tujuh Lake, Puntius cf. binotatus INTRODUCTION consisting of five rivers (Salibutan, Batang Kuranji, Sungai Asam, Batang Gumanti and Batang Sinamar) and one lake Gunung Tujuh Lake, Kerinci District, Jambi Province is (Lake Maninjau) in West Sumatra showed significant located in Sumatra Island, Indonesia at an altitude of 1,950 morphological differences among the locations. Recent meters above sea level, surrounded by volcanic mountains study, Karlina et al. (2016) using cyt b gene on P. cf. that have seven peaks. There is no river flow into the lake binotatus from Gunung Tujuh Lake and P. cf. Binotatus as the water source for the lake, except for water catchment recommended that P. cf. binotatus from Gunung Tujuh surrounding that entering the lake through the small rivers. Lake as a candidate of a new species. Water flows out of the lake directly forming a 75 meters According to Kottelat (2013), Puntius and Barbodes are high waterfall. It is believed that the fish live in this lake synonymous. Previously Taki et al. (1978), Mohsin and have been isolated for a long period. It has been proven that Ambak (1983), and Rainboth (1996) used the Barbonymus, the population in perfectly isolated habitats that prevent the Barbus, Barbodes, Systomus, Capoeta, and Hypsibarbus as migration of individuals between populations. If there is the generic names. Roesma et al. (2018) reported those limited gene flow between populations, the frequency of genera are not synonym and P. cf. binotatus is suggested as genes in a population will be different from before, in Barbodes banksi from West Sumatra that consist of at least which the genetic mixing between populations still occur three subspecies based on Cytochrome Oxidase-I (COI) (Roesma et al. 2017). Handika et al. (2014) reported that gene. Based on the previous studies, it is crucial to use there is a type of fish with genus Puntius in Gunung Tujuh CO1 gene to identify and verify the taxonomic status of Lake that live in the 20-30 meters depth under the lake. Silver Barb (P. cf. binotatus) from Gunung Tujuh Lake. A Based on the phenotypic characters identified, the species mtDNA gene has been widely used for taxonomic, is similar to P. binotatus, so it is identified as P. cf. phylogenetic and phylogeography studies in the Silver binotatus. According to Champasri et al. (2007) and Barb (John et al. 2013; Singh et al. 2013; Negi et al. 2017). Collins et al. (2012), Silver Barb or Spotted Barb are the The COI gene is a part of mtDNA used for species common names of Puntius, and they are sold for food and identification (DNA barcode). The DNA barcode is ornamental fish. designed to develop a rapid species identification that also Based on molecular studies using the cytochrome b allows detecting new species (Hebert et al. 2003a; Stoeckle gene (cyt b) mitochondrial DNA, Roesma (2011) and 2003; Hebert and Gregory 2005). COI gene has rapid Roesma et al. (2016) reported that P. binotatus from evolutionary rates than other mtDNA genes. Therefore, is several locations in West Sumatra reflected the complex useful for identification at species level, and has been and variable genetic and morphological characters among applied to identify numerous animal taxa (Hebert et al. the locations and considered them as P. cf. binotatus. Vitri 2003a; Clare et al. 2006; Hajibabaei et al. 2007; Smith et et al. (2012) reported that P. binotatus from six populations al. 2008; Frezal and Leblois 2008). ROESMA et al. – Taxonomy confirmation of Puntius cf. binotatus 55 MATERIAL AND METHODS 30 seconds, elongation at 72ºC for 1 minute and a final extension at 72ºC for 10 minutes. The PCR products were A total of 50 individuals of P. cf. binotatus in Gunung visualized in 2% agarose at 100 Volt, 20 W for 50 min. Tujuh Lake, Kerinci District, Jambi Province, Indonesia Good quality PCR product was used as samples for were collected following Cailiet et al. (1986). A piece of sequencing, performed in MacroGen USA DNA the tissue samples collected from individuals and stored in Sequencing Laboratory. Eppendorf tubes (1.5 mL) containing 96% ethanol PA. A total of 46 sequences of COI gene were analyzed Individual samples were temporarily stored in 10% consisted of four sequences Puntius cf. binotatus in formalin and transferred in 70% ethanol for long-term Gunung Tujuh Lake, 17 sequences P. cf. binotatus of other storage. Morphological measurements were done for 29 populations in Sumatra and 25 sequences taken from morphometric and 17 meristic characters following Genbank NCBI included outgroup species (Rasbora Kottelat et al. (1993) and Haryono and Tjakrawidjaja daniconius, Danio choprai, and Botia rostrata) (Table 1). (2006) with additional three characters: Lenght of upper DNA sequences (forward and reverse) were assembled and caudal (LUCL), Lenght of lower caudal (LLCL) and edited using the DNA STAR program (Burland 2000). Lenght of middle caudal (LMCL). Morphometric and DNA sequence of P. cf. binotatus compared with the meristic characters were measured using digital calipers to sequences contained in NCBI, to check the similarity of all the nearest 0.1 mm. sequences in http: //blast.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Blast.cgi. All Total genomic DNA was extracted using Invitrogen sequences were aligned using the Clustal X program PureLinkTM Genomic DNA Mini Kit. The result of DNA (Thompson 1997). The aligned sequences were edited extraction was used for Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using BIOEDIT program (Hall 1999). The number of amplification using thermal cycler (SensoQuest). PCR was polymorphic sequences was analyzed using the DNA conducted in 25 μl volumes containing 2x MyTaq Hs Red Sequence Polymorphism 5.10 (Rozas 2003). Sequence Mix (Bioline), 0.01 mM forward and reverse primer, 35 divergences of all sequences were analyzed using the ng/μl DNA template and 10 μl nuclear-free water. Primer Kimura-2 parameter model (K2P) in the MEGA 6.0 used were forward (Fish F1: 5'TCAACCAACCACAAA program (Tamura 2013). The phylogenetic tree was GACATTGG CAC3') and reverse (Fish R1: reconstructed based on four methods; Neighbors Joining 5'TAGACTTCTGGGTGGCCAAAGAATCA3') (Ward et (NJ), Maximum Evolution (ME), Maximum Likelihood al. 2005). The optimal PCR condition consisting of initial (ML) and Maximum Parsimony (MP) using MEGA 6.0 denaturation at 95°C for 2 minutes, 35 cycles consisting of (Tamura 2013). denaturation at 94ºC for 30 seconds, annealing at 54ºC for Table 1. List of freshwater fish species barcoded along with GenBank Accession Numbers Family Genus Species Location Accession No. Sources Cyprinidae Puntius Puntius binotatus Lampung JQ665834 Wibowo et al. (2012) Puntius binotatus Malaysia JN646096 Sade and Biun (2012) Puntius banksi Malaysia JF781235 Song et al. (2013) Puntius sophore India JX983465 Khedkar et al. (2014) Puntius denisonii India HQ176003 Lakra et al. (2010) Puntius orphoides JF915642 Collins et al. (2011) Puntius sarana India EU417805 Lakra et al. (2008) Puntius sarana India JQ667570 Khedkar et al. (2014) Puntius sarana subnasutus HE664122 Vincent (2012) Barbodes Barbodes binotatus Malaysia KT001028 Meganathan et al. (2015) Barbodes binotatus Thailand KP263421 Panprommin and Chanto (2014) Systomus Systomus sarana India JX983454 Khedkar et al. (2014) Systomus sarana India KJ476776 Lal et al. (2014) Systomus orphoides Thailand KP263417 Panprommin and Chanto (2014) Barbus Barbus matthesi Afrika KR153301 Sakharova (2015) Barbus camptacanthus Afrika HM418123 iBOL (2010) Barbus callipterus Afrika HM418124 iBOL (2010) Barbus brazzai Afrika KT193523 Decru et al. (2015) Barbonymus Barbonymus schwanenfeldii Malaysia KT001008 Meganathan et al. (2015) Barbonymus schwanenfeldii Laos JQ346171 Pasco-Viel et al. (2012) Barbonymus altus Afrika KU568767 Van Der Walt et al. (2012) Barbonymus gonionotus Philipina HQ682667 Aquino et al. (2011) Rasbora Rasbora daniconius India JX983478 Khedkar et al. (2012) Danio Danio choprai Myanmar KX852477 Kullander and Noren (2016) Botiidae Botia Botia rostrata China KM610433 Chen et al.