UCC Library and UCC Researchers Have Made This Item Openly Available
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UCC Library and UCC researchers have made this item openly available. Please let us know how this has helped you. Thanks! Title Revisiting Irish poetic modernisms Author(s) Whittredge, Julia Katherine Publication date 2011-03 Original citation Whittredge, Julia Katherine, 2011. Revisting Irish Poetic Modernisms. PhD Thesis, University College Cork. Type of publication Doctoral thesis Link to publisher's http://library.ucc.ie/record=b2006564~S0 version Access to the full text of the published version may require a subscription. Rights © 2011, Julia Katherine Whittredge http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ Embargo information Pages 25-346 have been restricted Item downloaded http://hdl.handle.net/10468/324 from Downloaded on 2021-10-01T07:01:51Z Revisiting Irish Poetic Modernisms Dissertation submitted in candidacy for the degree of doctor of philosophy at the School of English, College of Arts, National University of Ireland, Cork, by Julia Katherine Whittredge, MA Under the Supervision of Professor Patricia Coughlan and Professor Alex Davis Head of Department: Professor James Knowles March 2011 Over years, and from farther and nearer, I had thought, I knew you— in spirit—I am of Ireland. Thomas MacGreevy, “Breton Oracles” 2 For John 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks to my parents for their encouragement, endless support, love, and for sharing their own love of books, art and music, for being friends as well as amazing parents. And for understanding my love for a tiny, rainy island 3,000 miles away. Thank you to my sister, Em, for her life-long friendship. Her loyalty and extraordinary creative and artistic talent are truly inspiring. John Maher deserves ample credit for supporting me through this process, from start to finish. Thank you for travelling so many weekends, for believing in me and for listening to me talk about “my poets” even though I know you’re a numbers guy. I am endlessly proud to be your partner and I admire and deeply appreciate your integrity, kindness and patience. This is for you (of course!). Thank you to my extended family, Tony Elitcher and Andrea Taras and gratitude in memoriam to Elizabeth Gould, Barbara Whittredge, Max and Helene Elitcher and Ruth Douglass Whittredge for her lessons in life and poetry. Thank you also to Marguerite, Stephen, Barry, Steve and Tim Maher, Letty and Patsy Cronin and Philip Ridley for their warmth, support and reassurance through the years. Particular gratitude is owed to Professor Alex Davis and Professor Patricia Coughlan for their advice, patience (particularly with my frequent misuse of the comma!), encouragement, humour and for our often raucous marathon-meetings, which were highlights of my PhD process. Your extraordinary support and example will always be valued and admired. Thank you to Anne Fitzgerald, Elaine Hurley, Jennifer Crowley and Carol Power for their assistance, kindness, patience and warmth. Much gratitude to Lindsey Cates whose friendship has endured distance and change, to Danny Kennedy, for loyalty, true friendship, advice and for your ebullient personality, to Catherine Smith, for wonderful conversation and laughter over many cups of tea— thank you for honest encouragement and support, to Michael Waldron for friendship from the MA and onwards, your pure joy, infectious laughter and creative genius, to Julie-Marie Murphy, fellow-bookworm, brilliant friend and mother, inspiration and lady who lunches, to Avril Buchanan for your energy, optimism, support and strength and Ruth Canning for listening, sharing, laughing and cheering on. Further thank yous to Deborah Mellamphy, Caitlin Brown, Cate Huguelet, Eleanor Flynn, Paul Komoroski, Regina Heller and Louise Denmead. Additional thanks to Dr. Sam Ladkin, Emma Nic Cárthaigh and Colin Lahive for their advice and expertise. Thank you to Shaun Mullen and Rebecca Johnson Melvin at the University of Delaware Archives who allowed generous access to the Coffey papers, to the librarians at Trinity College Manuscripts room and the National Library of Ireland Special Collections, and especially Mary Lombard in Special Collections and Phil O’Sullivan and Garret Cahill in Interlibrary Loans at University College Cork, for their academic support. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction: Considering Irish Poetic Modernisms...................................... 7 I. “Night, and I travelling”: Joseph Campbell and Early Regional Modernism ..........................................................................25 Interchapter: “The dust the scrap-heap and the licking flame”: Ireland, Modernism and War .............................................................79 II. “Those who live between wars may not know”: Thomas MacGreevy’s Poetic Rendering of Ireland .......................................112 III. “Movement by mood conceiving her”: Denis Devlin, Gender and Irish Modernism ...............................................................................166 Interchapter: “H for Hero outdated classic style”: Irish Politics and Masculinity in the Long Poems of Denis Devlin and Brian Coffey .....................................................................................219 IV. “Meanwhile, keep your heart on the thorn”: Brian Coffey, Ireland, Catholicism and the Poet-as-Maker .................................................251 Conclusion ...................................................................................................299 Works Cited ................................................................................................302 5 This thesis is my own work and has not been submitted for another degree, either at University College Cork or elsewhere. 6 Introduction: Considering Irish Poetic Modernisms In the course of his interview of novelist and writer Mervyn Wall for the Lace Curtain in 1971, Michael Smith reflected: I doubt if there was ever a generation of Irish writers so talented, with intelligence and sheer literary know-how, as that which emerged in the Thirties: and yet the ignorance of the reading public about that period is almost complete. Admittedly the work of such poets as Lyle Donaghy and Thomas MacGreevy isn’t easily available, nonetheless there has been incredibly little interest until now, and anyway, republication usually requires such a revival of interest...It has been suggested to me that the work of the period is not Irish enough for the scholars and critics of Anglo-Irish Literature… (Wall 77) Smith’s supposition addresses his contemporaries’ neglect of and disinterest in the Irish “Thirties writers” such as MacGreevy, Wall, Donaghy, Brian Coffey, Denis Devlin and Charles Donnelly. As Smith has observed, these poets were largely overlooked until critical interest was developed by New Writers’ Press in the 1970s, then in the ‘80s and ‘90s by J.C.C. Mays, Stan Smith, Susan Schreibman, Terence Brown, Patricia Coughlan and Alex Davis. This thesis revisits the work of several of these poets with the aim of building upon this earlier research and criticism, helping to gain this material the prominence it deserves. With these aims I explore the poetry of Joseph Campbell (1879-1944), Thomas MacGreevy (1893-1967), Denis Devlin (1908-1959) and Brian Coffey (1905-1995) in individual case-study chapters. I have also written interchapters that contextualise their work and examine connections between them and their 7 contemporaries and near-contemporaries. I begin my study with Joseph Campbell (Seosamh MacCathmaoil) because of his omission from previous discussions of Irish modernism focusing on MacGreevy, Devlin or Coffey. Very little has been written about Campbell until the recent discussions by Alex Davis and Helen Carr. Both critics have recognized him as making valuable contributions to both the Irish Literary Revival and Ezra Pound’s and others’ early incarnation of the Imagist movement in London. Campbell has undoubtedly been a neglected cultural figure. He played a key role in the Ulster Literary Theatre and its accompanying journal Uladh; yet the Ulster literary and cultural revivals have remained marginalized in criticism. With the notable exceptions of FitzSimon and Murphy’s edited collection of essays, The Irish Revival Reappraised (2004), Eugene McNulty’s The Ulster Literary Theatre and the Northern Revival (2008) and Mark Phelan’s forthcoming research. In current Irish studies, Campbell’s valuable contributions to the cultural efflorescence in London and Dublin remain largely neglected. During the first two decades of the twentieth century Campbell’s collections The Rush-light and The Earth of Cualann were displayed at Dublin Arts and Crafts exhibitions as examples of artisan books. The Rush-light was also one of the first publications printed by the quintessential Irish literary revival press, Maunsel & Co. However, now his most widely read texts are his translations of Patrick Pearse’s short stories from Irish to English.1 My analysis shows how Campbell’s stylistic experimentation reveals links between Irish literary and cultural revivalism and pre-war modernism in 1 See Markey. 8 London. His poetry also crucially makes the case that modernism in itself need not be seen as exclusively international but rather, with the incidence of diverse literary communities in pre-war London, as what we might now call transnational. Furthermore, Campbell’s early experimental poetry and simultaneous promotion of nationalist literature is a clear example of Davis and Jenkins’s assertion that modernism and nationalism need not be seen as irreconcilable (“Locating modernisms” 5).