digitalcommons.nyls.edu

Faculty Scholarship Other Publications

1988 Autonomy and the Miskito Indian Community of Penelope Andrews

Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/fac_other_pubs Vol. 2 ALB No. 32 June 1988 page 7

AUTONOMY AND THE MISKITO INDIAN COMMUNITY OF NICARAGUA

The following article continues ALB's comparative examination of the struggles of other indigenous peoples. Penelope Andrews places the Miskito Indianfight for autonomy within the historicaland political context of the Sandinista revolu- tion. Much can be learntfrom the recent initiative of the Sandinista government in drafting the Autonomy Law which recognises the right of its indigneouspeo- ples to self-determination.

Introduction The American government was dis- enthusiasm for progressive change in pleased with the Sandinista governmen- Nicaraguan society has all but been In 1979 Nicaragua experienced a t's official policy for a whole host of halted. national revolution when the Frente reasons, and these reasons all pointed Sandinista de Liberation National towards Washington's fears about los- The Nicaraguan government and (FSLN) captured the capital, , ing influence in Central and South people have in the last few years and the dictatorship of President America. The administration in the utilised valuable resources in an Anastasio Somoza abruptly came to a White House therefore set in motion a attempt to survive amidst the economic halt. The Somoza family had ruled sophisticated and concerted ideological and social chaos and suffering that have Nicaragua for resulted as a con- many decades and sequence of the had during that contra war. time unleashed Human rights and great suffering civil liberties (of and misery on individuals and almost the entire groups) have been Nicaraguan popu- a heavy casualty lation. of this war.

The official The focus of policy of the international Sandinista gov- attention on ernment was developments in based on the intro- Nicaragua in the duction of a more last few years egalitarian system has, inter alia, into Nicaraguan highlighted the society, and plight of certain indeed the victory indigenous of the Saninistas groups. More brought a host of specifically the radical changes to rights of the the country. These Miskito Indian changes were population on the most prevalent in A Miski to woman at Tasba Pri, 1982 (Photo: Cordelia Dilg) Atlantic Coast the areas of has engendered health, education considerable and land reform. (1) Unfortunately, and material effort to thwart the legiti- debate as the community has found attempts on the part of the government macy and the very existence of the itself emeshed in the conflict between to institute these changes in Nicaragua alleged "Soviet backed communist gov- the contra rebels and the Nicaraguan were met with a hostile response by the ernment" in Managua (2) The government (3) The Reagan adminis- administration in the ; an Washington-orchestrated war by tration has found it propitious to focus administration bent on undermining the counter-revolutionary forces or contra on the tensions between the Sandinista plans of the Sandinista government. rebels has meant that the initial spurt of government and the Miskito communi- Vol. 2 ALB No. 32 June 1988 page 8

ty as an example of their (the obtained permission from the Miskito Coast. (10) Sandinista's) oppressive policies and king (who still had the authority to have touted this as a flagrant violation grant land titles) for the expansion of One of the first activities that the of human rights. This opportunistic and banana plantations throughout the Sandinistas undertook with the indige- simple explanation ignores the very Atlantic Coast region. This heralded nous people was the establishment of complex political reality of the Atlantic the beginnings of United States eco- an organisation, MISURASATA, which Coast and its historical relationship nomic and political involvement, which brought together the Miskito, Sumu and with the Pacific Coast. (4) soon came to dominate not only the Rama people on the Atlantic coast. In region, but Nicaragua itself. In fact, as 1980, MISURASATA, put forward its A Brief History an insignia to their intentions, the programme and claims in a document United States Marines invaded entitled General Directions, a document The Atlantic Coast comprises half Nicaragua in 1912 and remained there which affirmed Nicaraguan sovereignty the land mass of Nicaragua. Tensions on and off until the Somoza dynasty over the Atlantic Coast.(11) between the country's two main regions came to power in 1936. (8) (the Pacific and Atlantic coasts) have In the first year after the setting up their origins in the 17th and 18th cen- Over the succeeding decades, of MISURASATA relations between it turies when the Miskitos allied them- United States companies and the and the government were good. In selves with the British to defend against Somoza families business interests 1981, however, problems began to sur- incursions by the Spanish. Both parties plundered the region's natural resources, face. The reasons were complex and saw the alliance as expedient: the which involved massive quantities of varied, but it appears that a fundamen- British to protect their commercial gold, silver, lumber and seafood. tal source of the conflict was the per- domination of the Caribbean region; Resistance to the pillage was met with ceived insensitivity of the central gov- and the Miskitos sought protection brutality (on the part of Somoza's ernment towards the indigenous peo- from the British against the ravages of agents) or co-option (access to United ples. When Sandinista representatives Spanish imperialism. (5) States goods and relatively high wages) arrived on the Atlantic Coast they and United States cultural values were assumed the social and economic poli- The British secured their position reinforced by missionaries and the cies devised in Managua could apply to in this alliance by entrenching the posi- intense campaign provided by the the Atlantic Coast. In their enthusiasm tion of the Miskito and for Alliance for Progress in the 1960's and and zeal to implement these policies, several decades a line of Miskito kings, 1970's. (9) they ignored the traditions and indeed educated in England and loyal to the the complex history of the region. Their British crown, served British interests The National Revolution narrow focus on redressing economic on the Atlantic coast. Britain supplied In Nicaragua and social problems came to a clash the Miskitos with arms and ammuni- with a growing sense of ethnic identity tion; all the while the resistance of the By the time the Sandinista govern- among the Miskito community, an eth- indigenous peoples was channelled ment came to power in 1979, the nic identity which in fact burgeoned against Spanish colonialism in favor of Atlantic Coast legacy was one of aban- during the days of the struggle for lib- British interests. At the same time the donment and dire deprivation. The eration led by the Sandinistas. This seeds of distrust and prejudice against standard of living of the majority of the conflict was immediately utilised by the Pacific coast, which was to linger inhabitants was miserable, there was indigenous leaders, who, playing on for several decades, was being sown. hardly an infrastructure and in fact the traditional animosity between the coun- (6) indigenous population had no concept try's two coasts, pmmoted a separatist of, and in fact, no faith in the central movement (which the Reagan adminis- In 1838 Nicaragua gained its inde- government in Managua These decades tration found expedient to encourage pendence and in 1860 the Treaty of of neglect had a dual consequence:- and support).(12) Managua was signed between Britian firstly, because they were so isolated, and the new republic. This effectively the coastal peoples were able to devel- It is important to point out that meant that the Atlantic region came op their own traditions, customs, lan- even though the Sandinista government under the sovereignty of the govern- guage, religious and cultural patterns appeared insensitive to the cultural and ment of Managua. The area was desig- which were distinct from those devel- related needs of the Miskito community nated a Miskito reserve and the Miskito oped on the Pacific Coast. Secondly, while implementing their policies of King retained the authority to grant there developed a justifiable mistrust national development, they did achieve land titles. In 1894 the Miskito reserve for the authorities in Managua, which significant improvement in the material was abolished and the Atlantic coast was to prove problematic for the conditions of the community. For incorporated fully into Nicaragua. (7) Sandinista government when they example, for the first time in Between the late 1890's and the attempted to introduce their national Nicaraguan history the central govern- early 1900's, United States companies agenda for development on the Atlantic ment genuinely took full responsibility Vol. 2 ALB No. 32 June 1988 page 9

for the education and health system of Law was passed in 1987. the waters, forests and communal lands the Atlantic region. (13) for the benefit and enjoyment of the The Autonomy Law Atlantic peoples. To certain sections of the Miskito leadership, however, this was not suffi- The principles on which the 4) Promotion of national culture, as cient and in 1981 armed Miskito and Autonomy Law was based were encap- well as the study, preservation promo- other indigenous groups, with the help sulated in the Autonomy Commission's tion, development, and dissemination of the C.I.A. carried out a series of proposals. Amongst others, it stated of the different cultures and traditions attacks against communities and gov- that, of the Atlantic Coast's communities. ernment posts on the Honduran bor- 5) Promotion of the traditional ders. The government responded with '...Our political Constitution holds exchange with the Caribbean countries the evacuation of several communities; that Nicaragua is a multi-ethnic in accordance with the national laws these measures were criticised strongly nation and recognises the right of the and established procedures. in anti-Sandinista quarters and used Atlantic Coast Communities to pre- substantially in Washington's propagan- serve their cultural identity, their lan- 6) Establishment of regional taxes. da campaign against the Sandinsta gov- guages, art and culture, as well as the (Art. 8) ernment. The armed confrontation con- right to use and enjoy the waters, tinued for a few years. forests and communal lands for their Article 11 outlines rights to which own benefit. It also recognises their the inhabitants of the Atlantic Coast are During 1984 negotiations began rights to the creation of special pro- entitled. They include the right to pro- between the indigenous people of the grams designed to contribute to their mote their languages, religions and cul- Atlantic coast and the central govern- development while respecting their tures and to be educated in their own ment. These negotiations revolved not right to live and organise themselves language. They are also entitled to their only around solving the armed conflict, according to their legitimate cultural own forms of communal, collective or but initiatives were also set in motion and historical conditions.'(16) individual ownership and transfer of for the discussion of regional autono- land and have the right to utilise and my for the region. A general amnesty The main provisions in the law are benefit from their natural resources in was declared shortly thereafter by the outlined thus:- accordance with national development government whereby Miskito Indians plans. Article 36 defines communal who had joined the contra rebels could the setting up of autonomous property as land that has traditionally return to Nicaragua without reprisals.(- regime for the regions of the Atlantic belonged to the indigenous communi- 14) The autonomy project was initiated Coast, within the unitary Nicaraguan ties and specifically provides that com- by the setting up of an Autonomy state. The law specifically provides for munal lands cannot be sold, seized, or Commission which prepared a draft two autonomous regions to exercise taxed and that their communal status autonomy proposal containing, inter jurisdiction over the indigenous peo- cannot expire. The law also sets out in alia, a statement of general principles, ples. (Articles 1-6) detail the administration of the the objectives of regional autonomy although Spanish is the official autonomous regions, clearly outlining and a proposal for the structure, func- language of the Nicaraguan state, the how the various authorities are to oper- tions and organisation of the languages of the communities of the ate, their functions, their representation, autonomous regional government. Atlantic Coast will be official within their electoral procedures and particu- the autonomous regions. (Art. 7) larly their co-ordination with and Consultation on the autonomy pro- accountability to the central authorities posal begin in earnest in 1985 (15) and The general functions of the in Managua. in 1986 a multi-ethnic assembly was autonomous regions were to include:- held with representatives of all ethnic 1) Participation in the planning Article 32 outlines the operation of groups and communities of the Atlantic process and programs of national devel- the budget of the autonomous regions. Coast. At that assembly consensus was opment within the region; It makes provision for the setting up of sought on crucial issues such as the regional taxes, an earmarked fund from borders of the autonomous region, the 2) Administration in co-ordination the general budget of the country, and use of natural resources and the struc- with the corresponding ministries, the the establishment of a Special ture and electoral system of the regional programs related to health, education, Development Fund which will be com- government. Thereafter the Autonomy culture, basic goods distribution and posed of national and foreign dona- Commission set to work on the draft of communal services, as well as the tions, as well as extraordinary moneys the Autonomy Law to be ratified in a establishment of economic, social and not included in the budget. later multi-ethnic assembly in 1987, cultural projects in the region. and further debate and ratification by Conclusion the National Assembly. The Autonomy 3) Promotion of the rational use of The law in its draft form represents Vol. 2 ALB No. 32 June 1988 page 10

a unique and important step in the Indigenous Peoples Zed Books, related to land, education, political search for a just solution not only for London (1987) 238; See also Ortiz, participation, economic integration, Nicaragua's indigenous Miskito com- Roxanne Dunbar Indians Of The cultural, linguistic, social, religious, munity, but also for all societies seek- Americas; Human Rights And Self- economic and political rights. See MIS- Determination Zed Books, London URASATA document Linementos ing a just and progressive solution for Generals 1982 cited in Burger op cit. the aspirations of their indigenous pop- (1984) 239. ulations. For Australia this is particular- ly pertinent, as the government tries to 4. See generally Dozier, Craig L. 12. See generally Dixon, Marlene (ed) grapple with various demands put for- Nicagagua's Mosquito Shore; The On Trial; Reagan's War Against ward by the Aboriginal communities Years Of British And American Nicagaua Zed Books, London (1985) throughout the continent. Presence The University of Alabama Press (1985) 13. Zwerling and Martin op cit, 162 What I have outlined is a very brief 5. Ibid. and incomplete sketch of an obviously 14. taped interviews with Miskito Late of women: ABC National Radio, complex and dynamic evolution 6. Ibid. See also Burger op cit. Night Live April 1988. Nicaraguan history; a history which is 7. Burger op cit. 238. still unfolding. But the endeavour has 15. An extensive consultation process been to highlight the struggle of the 8. Ortiz op cit, 210-217 using local volunteers was conducted to indigenous Miskito community, and ensure that all members of the local attempts by the Nicaraguan government 9. Walker, Thomas W. communities were able to voice their to deal with their demands sympatheti- Nicagagua; The First Five Years opinions on the question of autonomy. cally and fairly. The law has only been Praeger (1979) 15-16 See also House to house interviews were con- Zwerling, Philip and Connie Martin ducted, phamplets were distributed in in operation for a few months, and as is Nicagagua; A New Kind Of the case with legislation of this kind, the workplace and peasant communities Revolution Lawrence Hill & Company in the outlying areas were approached. the teething problems will be immense. (1985) 153. But the trial has just begun it is a 16. Autonomy Commission Report model worth scrutinising. 10. See generally Ortiz op cit. preamble to proposed Autonomy Law (April 1987). Footnotes 11. The document contained a series of recommendations which were 1. Black, George Triumph Of The People; The Sandinista Revolution In Nicaragua Zed books, London (1981) 190-222; See also Harris, Richard L. and Carlos M.Vilas Nicaragua; A Revolution Under Siege Zed Books, London (1985) 1-9

2. See Grossman, Karl Nicaragua; America's New Vietnam? The Permanent Press, New York (1984); See also Human Rights And U.S. Foreign Policy: The First Decade 1973 - 1983 Report of the American Association for the International Commission of Jurists (1984).

3. The population of the Atlantic Coast is made up as follows:- 182,000 Mestizos, 67-70,000 Miskitos, 26,000 Creoles, 5-7,000 Sumus, 15,000 Garifonas or Black Caribs and 700 Rama. See Burger, Julian Report From The Frontier; The State Of The Map of Nicaraguan Atlantic Coast