Neuf Cegetel Presentation

Faire Conference 12 June 2007 Disclaimer

ƒ This document has been prepared by Neuf Cegetel S.A. (the "Company") and is being furnished to you personally solely for your information. ƒ This presentation includes only summary information and does not purport to be comprehensive. ƒ The information contained in this presentation has not been subject to independent verification. No representation, warranty or undertaking, express or implied, is made as to, and no reliance should be placed on, the fairness, accuracy, completeness or correctness of the information or opinions contained herein. None of Neuf Cegetel, its affiliates or its advisors, nor any representatives of such persons, shall have any liability whatsoever (in negligence or otherwise) for any loss arising from any use of this document or its contents or otherwise arising in connection with this document or any other information or material discussed. ƒ This presentation contains forward-looking statements relating to the business, financial performance and results of Neuf Cegetel. These statements are based on current beliefs, expectations or assumptions and involve unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to differ materially from those described in such statements. Factors that could cause such differences in actual results, performance or events include changes in demand and technology, as well as the ability of Neuf Cegetel to effectively implement its strategy. Any forward-looking statements contained in this presentation speak only as of the date of this presentation. Neuf Cegetel expressly disclaims any obligation or undertaking to update or revise any forward-looking statements contained in this presentation to reflect any change in events, conditions, assumptions or circumstances on which any such statements are based unless so required by applicable law.

Results and Strategy - June 2007 2 A compléter

ƒ Perception de la marque (étude Ipsos) ƒ 2006 : 1st Sustainable Development Report ƒ AOL ACME

ƒ 1 million de clients de plus et 36 000 sites enterprises

Results and Strategy - June 2007 3 Agenda

1 Overview and Targets

2 Growth Driven by Innovation and Customer Satisfaction

3 Increasing Cash Flow Generation

4 Acceleration of Strategic Projects

Results and Strategy - June 2007 4 The Leading French Altnet Overview

1998-2006 2007+ Market Creation of a Solid #1 Alternative to FT Actively Pursuing Broader Opportunities Environment ƒ IP revolution in all market segments ƒ €23bn fixed line market opening and ƒ Convergence favourable regulation of LLU ƒ €20bn mobile market ƒ €3bn invested in the network ƒ 23m TV homes ƒ Access network (FTTx) ƒ Ebitda positive since inception ƒ Market consolidation

#1 Altnet in France with €2.9bn PF Sales in 2006 Neuf Cegetel Today Wholesale Enterprises Mass Market

ƒ Years active: 9.5 ƒ Years active: 5.5 ƒ Years active: 3.5

ƒ € Market share: 23% ƒ € Market share: 14% ƒ DSL Market share: 23%* ƒ IP Data: >20% * Including Club Internet (acquisition subject to antitrust clearance)

Source: Gartner Dataquest: Fixed Public Network Services Market, August 2006, and Neuf Cegetel estimates for market data

Results and Strategy - June 2007 5 Latest Trends Support Ambitious Targets Overview

Targets Latest Trends (excluding Club Internet) Drivers

Revenue Growth

ƒ Mass Market ƒ +46% yoy in Q1 07 ƒ >40% growth in 2007 ƒ AOL ƒ Market share growth ƒ Enterprises ƒ +6% yoy in Q1 07 ƒ 5-10% growth in 2007 ƒ €35 ARPU by end 07

Profitability

ƒ EBITDA ƒ 20% in H2 06 ƒ 25% by end 2008 ƒ Scale effects in MM ƒ Optimization of G&A ƒ Operating ƒ €212m in FY 06 ƒ Run rate end 07 ƒ Accelerated CAPEX Cash Flow doubled versus plan for FTTx (€300m €17m/month early 06 over 2007-09) ƒ >€400m in FY 08 ƒ No income tax

Dividend ƒ €0.40 per share ƒ Increasing in line ƒ Retaining flexibility Distribution dividend paid in with Operating Cash for strategic projects July on FY 06 Flow results

Results and Strategy - June 2007 6 Agenda

1 Overview and Targets

2 Growth Driven by Innovation and Customer Satisfaction

3 Increasing Cash Flow Generation

4 Acceleration of Strategic Projects

Results and Strategy - June 2007 7 Revenue Growth Accelerating Growth

+10.3% FY 2007 Targets +8.0% +6.2% (excluding Club Internet) yoy +4.5% growth +2.4% 760 781 €m 708 715 713 226 -13% 249 WS 259 268 278

260 +6% +5-10% 251 ES 246 241 233

261 296 +46% >+40% MM 203 206 202

Q1 06 Q2 06 Q3 06 Q4 06 Q1 07 MM switched voice <10% of total revenues

Results and Strategy - June 2007 8 Mass Market Revenue Growth Growth

Market Share Growth ARPU Development Driven by Driven by ƒ Attractive packages ƒ Adoption of “100% Neuf Box” offer ƒ Innovation mixing technology and simplicity ƒ Optional services ƒ Focus on Quality of Service

Customers EOP (k) adds (k) €/month €35 €32.4 2,172 €31.3 €29.9 >190 €26.0 166 156 Target 1,172 >18% 18% 18%

660 16% Target

3% 100

2003 2004 2005 2006 Q106Q107 Q107 ‘Neuf’ 2004 2005 2006 Q4 06* End 07** brand only (excluding BB Market share migrations) * Excluding AOL ** Excluding Club Internet

Results and Strategy - June 2007 9 Innovation: Technology and Simplicity Mass Market

Neuf TV HD VoD ƒ 200 TV channels including ƒ More than 1,000 programs 69 in basic offer New Neuf Box launched early 2007 ƒ Designed in-house ƒ FTTx ready ƒ Plug and play; simple to install and use

WiFi

Phone TWINTM TV on PC ƒ Unlimited USB ƒ 20 TV calls on WiFi Ethernet channels, ƒ Unlimited available Internet for ULL & access non ULL ƒ 20 TV customers channels RoHS Directive Compliant* RoHS*: The RoHS directive limits the effects of increased pollutants and use of harmful substances Results and Strategy - June 2007 10 Customer Relations : Mass Market

Anticipation Of Regulation… Active contribution in the French debate regarding improvements in relations between consumers and operators leads Neuf Cegetel to anticipate regulation and to work on customer subjects in priority. For example, Neuf Cegetel decided at the beginning of the year to : ƒ make written advertisements easier to read ƒ post standardized information forms on line for new offers ƒ post practical electronic communications guides on line aimed at consumers ƒ define quality level standards in its contacts and offer compensation if standards are not met ƒ for customers who have not been able to use the service offering in its contacts, the possibility of terminating the contract at no cost if service is not provided ƒ include into contracts a “best practices” guide for handling disputes ƒ make waiting time free when customers call hotlines ƒ improve quality of telephone support services ƒ … … To Go Further…

Note: all figures are pro forma for the acquisition of Cegetel

Results and Strategy - June 2007 11 Customer Satisfaction: Moving to the Next Level Mass Market

Investment Superior Simple Offers in Customer Care Product Quality* ƒ 100% Neuf ƒ 3,000 operators 100 ƒ Self installation and ƒ 2,000 on-site visits per TV VoIP ADSL self-care week 80 ƒ Internal call center Neuf Free Orange

Reinforced ƒ Your service is activated in less than 4 weeks (or you get 1 Commitments month free) - currently 10 business days on average “NEUF ƒ We solve problems quickly and efficiently S’ENGAGE” ƒ Hotline waiting time is free - currently less than 3 min program ƒ We send a technician to your home free of charge to launched solve complex problems March 2007 ƒ You get a free security package & diagnostic tool

ƒ You are informed when a better offer becomes available

Trends ƒ Customer satisfaction increasing ƒ Churn decreasing (18% in FY06; lower for ‘Neuf’ brand) ƒ Customer management costs decreasing

* Average of weekly performance measured by independent surveyor IP Label between 29/12/05 & 27/12/06 and rebased to 100 for Neuf.

Results and Strategy - June 2007 12 Des outils de suivi en ligne disponibles à tout moment pour l’ensemble de clients A TRADUIRE

Suivi du réseau : un outil qui rend Neuf Assistance, un outil d’aide en ligne transparent l’état du réseau, en ligne, pour diagnostiquer les incidents disponible pour tous les clients

Dépannage à domicile

+ de 2000 interventions par semaine

Results and Strategy - June 2007 13 Enterprises Revenue Growth Enterprises

Steady Market Share Gains Growth Focused on New Technologies Major new contracts signed recently include Enterprises switch from legacy technologies to the Ministry of Defense, FNAIM, UGAP DSL ƒ Explains the decrease in revenue per link ƒ DSL unbundling supports fast reduction of 148 production cost per link 139 €413 103 €358 €312 €286 62 48% 41 43% 35% 32%

2003 2004 2005 2006 Q1 07 H1 05 H2 05 H1 06 H2 06 Data links, EOP (k) ARPL, €/month % unbundled, EoP

Note: all figures are pro forma for the acquisition of Cegetel

Results and Strategy - June 2007 14 Combining Innovation & Services Enterprises

Customer Strategy : SATISFACTION Quality ƒ a “zero default” quality of service to respond to specific constraints of our customers’ complexities IP Convergence ƒ a unique person to respond any telecom demand of our customers : data, mobile, voice Innovation ƒ Constant evolutions in marketing offers to anticipate new needs and usages and to adapt the various changes in the Enterprises’ organization

VoIP : a win-win proposition Quality : a 1st level concern

ARPL, €/month ƒ Dedicated organization for Enterprises customers : PBX 800 employees motivated to ease the relation with our clients (technical and administrative demands) Subscription PBX fees (paid to ƒ Relationship reinforced by Extranet Client Orange) Online availability of indicators such as quality of service, traffic in live, orders €280 intake, resolution of incidents €170 ƒ Supervision of the network highly secured Calls thanks to 2 redundant sites ƒ ISO 9001 v 2000 certification since June 01 for Preselection VoIP national services to majors accounts Note: Approx. figures for a typical SME customer Results and Strategy - June 2007 15 Conclusion

Innovation Accelerated and Customer Combining Disciplined Satisfaction Rising Technology and Investment in the to the Next Level Simplicity Access Network

More Growth and Cash Flow Generation

Results and Strategy - June 2007 16 Appendix Profitable Growth

Cash Flow FY 2006 Key Financials

€m MM ES WS 2005 PF MM ES WS 2006 Change Revenues 738 908 1,106 2,752 872 971 1,054 2,897 +145 +5%** Gross margin 376 316 303 995 464 420 277 1,160 +165 % margin 51% 35% 27% 36% 53% 43% 26% 40% +17% Selling costs (315) (141) (32) (487) (318) (105) (18) (440)

Commercial margin 60 175 272 507 146 315 259 720 +212 % margin 8% 19% 25% 18% 17% 32% 25% 25% +42% G&A (shared) (273)* (176) EBITDA 234 544 +309 % margin EBIT (167) 9% EBIT 136 19% +132% Interest (25) Interest (25) Net income Taxes (2) = (194) Taxes +102 = 213 +407 / share €(1.03) €1.11

ƒ EBITDA margin to reach 25% by end 2008, driven primarily by operating leverage in Mass Market and further optimization of G&A

Note: all 2005 figures are pro forma for the acquisition of Cegetel * Including €(78)m of restructuring cost in 2005 Note: 2006 EBIT is given before reduction of goodwill related to ** 5% excluding the impact of the acquisition of AOL France Internet access activities deferred taxes and 2006 Taxes are net of reduction of goodwill related to deferred taxes Results and Strategy - June 2007 18 Mass Market Rapidly Improving Profitability

Finance Driven by Top-line Growth and AOL integration

Key financials, €m 2005 PF 2006 Trends

Revenues 738 872 +18%* ƒ >40% revenue growth in 2007** Data 336 560 +67% Switched voice 402 312 (22)% ƒ Growth of DSL market share ƒ DSL ARPU at €35 end 2007 COGS (362) (408) ƒ Full year consolidation of AOL Gross margin 376 464 ƒ Switched voice now weighing % margin 51% 53% <30% of total Selling costs (315) (318) Commercial margin 60 146 ƒ Continuous improvement of % margin 8% 17% commercial margin ƒ Unbundling rate back above Evolution of commercial margin, €m 70% end 2007 versus 65% end 127 (42) 2006 (impacted by AOL) 146 ƒ Mix of fully unbundled customers 60 ƒ Selling costs under control ƒ H206 includes non recurring IT costs related to AOL integration 2005 PF Data Switched 2006 * 13% excluding the impact of the acquisition of AOL France Internet access activities (data 58%, switched (25)%) ** excluding Club Internet

Results and Strategy - June 2007 19 Enterprises Profitable and Growing Finance

Key financials, €m 2005 PF 2006 Trends

Revenues 908 971 +7% ƒ 5-10% revenue growth in 2007 Data 396 443 +12% Switched voice 405 408 +1% ƒ IP Data market share growth Other 107 119 +11% ƒ Development of new segments (VSEs) and products (mobile) COGS (592) (551) Gross margin 316 420 ƒ Further improvements of % margin 35% 43% commercial margin Selling costs (141) (105) ƒ Top-line growth Commercial margin 175 315 ƒ Unbundling rate expected to % margin 19% 32% increase over time from current Evolution of commercial margin, €m level of 48% of base ƒ Enterprises division fully 17 2 315 120 restructured in 2006 post 175 acquisition of Cegetel

2005 PF Data Switched Other 2006

Results and Strategy - June 2007 20 Wholesale Managed For Cash Flow Finance

Key financials, €m 2005 PF 2006 Trends

Revenues 1,106 1,054 (5)%* ƒ Full year impact of AOL (transferred Data 256 249 (3)% to mass market) Switched voice 653 588 (10)% Other 198 218 +10% ƒ Activity dependant on a limited COGS (803) (777) number of clients Gross margin 303 277 ƒ Switched voice decline limited % margin 27% 26% by mobile-linked business Selling costs (32) (18) ƒ Take-off of SFR/ DSL Commercial margin 272 259 business % margin 25% 25% ƒ Solid infrastructure sales Evolution of commercial margin, €m ƒ Managed for cash flow 272 (6) (14) 7 259 ƒ Optimization of production cost structure ƒ Cash from infrastructure sales balances non-cash revenues

2005 PF Data Switched Other 2006 * (3)% excluding the impact of the acquisition of AOL France Internet access activities (data +5%)

Results and Strategy - June 2007 21 Innovation: Mobile Offer Gaining Momentum Mass Market

MVNO plans Neuf Liberté including First free no- “Mini forfaits” unlimited calls 30’ from

base commitment Build and SMS from €14/month

customer plan €21.90/month

May June October November December

Extension of TWINTM TWINTM TWIN range First hybrid Extension of WiFi multimedia w/ WiFi-GSM coverage… 30 TV channels

Develop phone and portal convergence

32,000 WiFi hotspots 150,000 hotspots

Mobile customers 100,000 Optimized acquisition cost (c. 75% cross-sell to fixed customers) 10,000

Summer 2006 Early 2007

Trends ƒ Cross sell to existing ADSL and preselection customers

Results and Strategy - June 2007 22 New connection using fiber

FTTx Fiber Technical Architecture Connection to TV & PC via WiFi, PWL, ETH (100Mbit/s)

New fiber wiring

Fiber Connection using existing copper* Connection to TV & PC Copper* via WiFi, PWL, ETH Street level (100Mbit/s) Several fibers POP Existing copper DSLAM*

Horizontal+Vertical Connection+CPE

ƒ Several horizontal fibers to each building in selected deployment areas Connection Process ƒ Customer connected using either fiber or copper

Ö FTTH always available for customers requesting it. Point-to-point vertical fibers installed in any case Ö Other customers will be connected using existing copper and “T-plug”, as it is a more rapid and less invasive process Ö Shift to 100% fiber will happen when optimized home wiring/networking solutions become available * In some buildings

Results and Strategy - June 2007 23 Income Statement Finance

Results and Strategy - June 2007 24 Balance Sheet Finance

Results and Strategy - June 2007 25 Cash Flow Statement Finance

Results and Strategy - June 2007 26 Debt Finance

Results and Strategy - June 2007 27