DOCSLIB.ORG

UCLA Electronic Theses and Dissertations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
UCLA Electronic Theses and Dissertations UCLA UCLA Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title From Community to Humanity: Dance as Intangible Cultural Heritage Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1hj6h8px Author Petkovski, Filip Publication Date 2021 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles From Community to Humanity: Dance as Intangible Cultural Heritage A dissertation completed in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Culture and Performance by Filip Petkovski 2021 © Copyright by Filip Petkovski 2021 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION From Community to Humanity: Dance as Intangible Cultural Heritage by Filip Petkovski Doctor of Philosophy in Culture and Performance University of California, Los Angeles, 2021 Professor Anurima Banerji, Co-Chair Professor Janet O’Shea, Co-Chair Abstract My dissertation project examines the gradual phases of recontextualizing, folklorizing, heritagizing, and choreographing dance in Macedonia, Serbia, and Croatia, and in the Former Yugoslavia in general. In order to demonstrate how dance becomes intangible cultural heritage, I combine UNESCO archival materials with ethnographic research and interviews with dancers, choreographers, and heritage experts. While I trace how the discourses around folklore and intangible cultural heritage were used in the construction of the Yugoslav, and later in the post- Yugoslav nation states, I also write about the hegemonic relationship between dance and institutions. I emphasize dance as a vehicle for mediating ideas around authenticity, distinctiveness, and national identity, while also acknowledging how the UNESCO process of safeguarding and listing culture allows countries such as Macedonia, Serbia, and Croatia to achieve international recognition. By studying the relationship between dance, archives, and UNESCO conventions, we can understand the intersection between institutions and issues ii around nationalism, but also how discourses of dance shifted dance production and reception in various historical and political contexts during and after the existence of the Yugoslav state. In the first chapter, I explore the creation of the folkloric discourse and the processes of constructing national archives, based on fears of disappearing culture amidst of modernization. I also elaborate on the institutionalization of dance through folklore research and the emergence of specific methods of study that conceptualized social dances as of national importance. In the second chapter, I discuss the transformation of the archive into a choreographed repertoire that depicts issues around authenticity, exoticism, and stylization. I show the development of amateur and professional dance ensembles that were responsible for popularizing dance as heritage and further demonstrate how heritage is safeguarded through performance. Finally, in the third chapter, I uncover the bureaucratic process through which dance becomes intangible cultural heritage. I demonstrate how through the process of heritagization, dance becomes both a commodity and a medium through which post-Yugoslav nation states can market their cultures in a global arena and affirm their national identities. Keywords: dance, intangible cultural heritage, UNESCO, choreography, folkorization, heritagization. iii The dissertation of Filip Petkovski is approved. Elsie Ivancich Dunin Anthony Shay Janet O’ Shea, Committee Co-Chair Anurima Banerji, Committee Co-Chair University of California, Los Angeles 2021 iv I dedicate this dissertation to my dearest friend Ana Mojsovska, my eternal ray of sunshine. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract of the Dissertation i List of Figures viii Acknowledgements x Vita xiii Introduction 1 Main argument and significance 4 The Balkans and Yugoslavia 8 Key discussions 12 Methodology 38 Chapter breakdown 41 Chapter 1: Searching for Dance Heritage 45 Kolo 52 Kopachkata 55 Nijemo Kolo 58 In search for folk culture (19th and early 20th century research on dance) 63 Developing the “folk dance” discourse through the formation of ethnochoreology 73 Institutionalizing folklore and dance research 78 Reframing the folkloric discourse post- 1990 86 Concluding remarks 92 Chapter 2: Choreographing Dance Heritage 93 Heritage as choreography 100 vi Early attempts of choreographing dance heritage 106 Choreographing Yugoslav socialist ideology 110 Stylizing and spectacularizing dance heritage 116 National dance ensembles 121 Choreographing authenticity 132 Local dance groups 144 Towards a new aesthetic: Contemporizing heritage choreography 153 Concluding remarks 158 Chapter 3: Safeguarding Dance Heritage 160 Heritagizing dance 166 Inscribing dance as ICH 174 Safeguarding identity 188 Commodifying heritage in the face of globalization 198 Safeguarding dance heritage for the future 204 Concluding remarks 209 Conclusion 211 Bibliography 219 vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1.1. Dancers performing Kolo during festive occasion in 2013 54 Figure 1.2. Dancers performing Kopachkata during festive occasion in 2014 58 Figure 1.3. Dancers performing Vrličko Kolo during festive occasion in 2017 62 Figure 2.1. Dancers from Posavski Bregi— members of Seljačka Sloga, photographed in the 1930s 107 Figure 2.2. Dancers from the Rashtak group, performing on the “Oceania” boat in Hamburg in 1937 109 Figure 2.3. Dancers from The Serbian National Ensemble “Kolo” performing Kolo from the region of Šumadija in 2019 122 Figure 2.4. Dancers from The Macedonian National Ensemble “Tanec” performing Kopachkata in 2009 125 Figure 2.5. Dancers from The Croatian National Ensemble “Lado” performing Vrličko Kolo in 2019 129 Figure 2.6. Dancers from ensemble “Branimir 888” performing a custom that includes Nijemo Kolo in 2018 148 Figure 2.7. Dancers from the dance group “Kopachka” performing Kopachkata at a festival in Pehchevo in 2016 149 Figure 2.8. Dancers from the Croatian national ensemble “Lado” performing Kontrada in 2010 155 Figure 2.9. Dancers from the folk dance department in Novi Sad performing Melting Pot in 2018 156 viii Figure 3.1. Screenshot from www.blic.rs that reads “UNESCO: The Serbian Kolo is new cultural heritage of humanity” 167 Figure 3.2: Screenshot from www.kultura.gov.mk that reads “The Macedonian dance “Kopachka” on the Representative List of UNESCO 168 Figure 3.3: Screenshot from www.hkm.hr that reads “Nijemo Kolo- From the Dalmatian Hinterland to the world stage” 169 Figure 3.4: DVD disc of a documentary movie about “Kopachkata in UNESCO” 202 Figure 3.5: A group of singers from Split, Croatia selling CDs of “Traditional Dalmatian Singing protected by UNESCO” in 2018 203 ix ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS As I come to the culmination of this dissertation, I am reminded of the generous help and support of many people who made this process easier and more enjoyable. I would first like to thank the faculty and staff at the World Arts and Cultures/Dance Department at UCLA for giving me the opportunity of a lifetime. At UCLA, I had the opportunity to work as a Teaching Assistant at three different departments: The Department of World Arts and Cultures/Dance, The Department of Art History and The Department of Slavic Languages and Literatures. I thank the professors with whom I worked for giving me an opportunity to teach, and for mentoring me in becoming a future professor and scholar. In 1966, a young woman named Elsie Ivancich (now Ivancich Dunin) wrote her Master’s thesis on the Silent Dances of Yugoslavia at UCLA. Later on, she would begin her career as an emerging dance ethnologist, conducting research in Croatia and Macedonia. Her work on the National Ensemble of Folk Dances and Songs of Macedonia “Tanec,” as well as her works on Romani dances have been influential not only for me, but for many generations of ethnochoreologists in the Balkans and throughout the world. During my Master’s studies at the Choreomundus Program, I decided to continue her research on “Tanec” and write about choreographing dance in Macedonia. While I was conducting research about my Master Thesis, I came across the works of Anthony Shay, who wrote about choreographing dance in the Former Yugoslavia and the Middle East. His works have inspired me to continue my research on the relationships between dance, ethnicity and nationalism. I thank Elsie and Tony for motivating me to continue researching dance in the Balkans, but also for reassuring me about the importance of my project. By writing this dissertation, I am continuing their legacy. x I also thank my two co-chairs, Janet O’Shea and Anurima Banerji, who introduced me to the fields of dance and performance studies and helped me to successfully navigate through my Ph.D. studies. Their scholarship on dance and performance opened my eyes to new perspectives and new ways of analyzing cultural performances. I thank Janet O’Shea for helping me shift from the British into the American system of writing, for teaching me how to strengthen my analysis, and for giving me expert advice needed to engage with my materials. I also thank Anurima Banerji for giving me useful comments, whether about my writing process, or academia in general, for her many questions, notes, and suggestions that strengthened my dissertation, and for imposing high standards when it comes to producing scholarly work. I thank them for their support, patience, and the willingness to read my work at every stage of the process. My research would not be possible without the help of many professors, scholars, dancers, choreographers,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Media and Literature in Multilingual Hungary 1770–1820
    Media and Literature in Multilingual Hungary 1770–1820 Edited by Ágnes Dóbék, Gábor Mészáros and Gábor Vaderna reciti Budapest 2019 Reciti Conference Books . 3 Edited by Zsuzsa Török Supported by the “Lendület” (“Momentum”) program of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, “Literary Culture in Western Hungary, 1770–1820” Research Group Proofreaders: Bernhard Heiller, Thomas Edward Hunter, Andrew C. Rouse This book is licenced under the terms of the Creative Commons License Attribution–NonCommercial–ShareAlike 2.5 Hungary (CC BY-NC-SA 2.5 HU), which permits any noncommercial use, sharing, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format (https://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc-sa/2.5/hu/deed.en). Visit our website for free download: http://reciti.hu HU ISSN 2630-953X ISBN 978-615-5478-70-3 Published by Reciti, Institute for Literary Studies of the Research Centre for the Humanities, Hungarian Academy of Sciences 1118–Budapest, Ménesi út 11–13, Hungary Publisher: Gábor Kecskeméti, Director of HAS RCH Institute for Literary Studies Graphic design, layout: Zsuzsa Szilágyi N. Printing Press: Kódex Könyvgyártó Kft. Contents 1 Contents Gábor Vader na Language, Media and Politics in the Hungarian Kingdom between 1770 and 1820 ........................................................................... 9 István Fried Mehrsprachigkeit in den ersten Jahrzehnten der ungarischen Zeit- 17 schriftenliteratur ................................................................... Suzana Coha History of Journalism in the Croatian Lands from the Beginnings 41 until the Croatian National Revival ......................................... Eva Kowalská Die erste slowakische Zeitung Presspůrské nowiny zwischen Journalis- 55 mus und Patriotismus ................................................................ Andrea Seidler Höfische Berichterstattung in derPreßburger Zeitung Reflexionen über die mediale Präsenz des Kaiserpaares Franz I. Stephan 69 und Maria Theresias in den frühen Jahren des Periodikums ..................
    [Show full text]
  • The Hungarian Historical Review “Continuities and Discontinuities
    The Hungarian Historical Review New Series of Acta Historica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae Volume 5 No. 1 2016 “Continuities and Discontinuities: Political Thought in the Habsburg Empire in the Long Nineteenth Century” Ferenc Hörcher and Kálmán Pócza Special Editors of the Thematic Issue Contents Articles MARTYN RADY Nonnisi in sensu legum? Decree and Rendelet in Hungary (1790–1914) 5 FERENC HÖRCHER Enlightened Reform or National Reform? The Continuity Debate about the Hu ngarian Reform Era and the Example of the Two Széchenyis (1790–1848) 22 ÁRON KOVÁCS Continuity and Discontinuity in Transylvanian Romanian Thought: An Analysis of Four Bishopric Pleas from the Period between 1791 and 1842 46 VLASTA ŠVOGER Political Rights and Freedoms in the Croatian National Revival and the Croatian Political Movement of 1848–1849: Reestablishing Continuity 73 SARA LAGI Georg Jellinek, a Liberal Political Thinker against Despotic Rule (1885–1898) 105 ANDRÁS CIEGER National Identity and Constitutional Patriotism in the Context of Modern Hungarian History: An Overview 123 http://www.hunghist.org HHHR_2016_1.indbHR_2016_1.indb 1 22016.06.03.016.06.03. 112:39:582:39:58 Contents Book Reviews Das Preßburger Protocollum Testamentorum 1410 (1427)–1529, Vol. 1. 1410–1487. Edited by Judit Majorossy and Katalin Szende. Das Preßburger Protocollum Testamentorum 1410 (1427)–1529, Vol. 2. 1487–1529. Edited by Judit Majorossy und Katalin Szende. Reviewed by Elisabeth Gruber 151 Sopron. Edited by Ferenc Jankó, József Kücsán, and Katalin Szende with contributions by Dávid Ferenc, Károly Goda, and Melinda Kiss. Sátoraljaújhely. Edited by István Tringli. Szeged. Edited by László Blazovich et al. Reviewed by Anngret Simms 154 Egy székely két élete: Kövendi Székely Jakab pályafutása [Two lives of a Székely: The career of Jakab Székely of Kövend].
    [Show full text]
  • Examination of Otis T. Mason's Standard of Authenticity| Salvage Ethnography and Indian Baskets at the Smithsonian Institution
    University of Montana ScholarWorks at University of Montana Graduate Student Theses, Dissertations, & Professional Papers Graduate School 2002 Examination of Otis T. Mason's standard of authenticity| Salvage ethnography and Indian baskets at the Smithsonian Institution Zachary T. Androus The University of Montana Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umt.edu/etd Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Androus, Zachary T., "Examination of Otis T. Mason's standard of authenticity| Salvage ethnography and Indian baskets at the Smithsonian Institution" (2002). Graduate Student Theses, Dissertations, & Professional Papers. 2282. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/etd/2282 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at ScholarWorks at University of Montana. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Student Theses, Dissertations, & Professional Papers by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks at University of Montana. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Maureen and Mike MANSFIELD LIBRARY The University of Montana Permission is granted by the author to reproduce this material in its entirety, provided that this material is used for scholarly purposes and is properly cited in published works and reports. **Please check "Yes" or "No" and provide signature** Yes, I grant permission __ No, I do not grant permission __ Author's Signature; Date: Any copying for commercial purposes or financial gain may be undertaken only with the author's explicit consent. 8/98 An Examination of Otis T. Mason’s Standard of Authenticity; Salvage Ethnography and Indian Baskets at the Smithsonian Institution by Zachary T.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hungarian Historical Review
    Hungarian Historical Review 5, no. 1 (2016): 5–21 Martyn Rady Nonnisi in sensu legum? Decree and Rendelet in Hungary (1790–1914) The Hungarian “constitution” was never balanced, for its sovereigns possessed a supervisory jurisdiction that permitted them to legislate by decree, mainly by using patents and rescripts. Although the right to proceed by decree was seldom abused by Hungary’s Habsburg rulers, it permitted the monarch on occasion to impose reforms in defiance of the Diet. Attempts undertaken in the early 1790s to hem in the ruler’s power by making the written law both fixed and comprehensive were unsuccessful. After 1867, the right to legislate by decree was assumed by Hungary’s government, and ministerial decree or “rendelet” was used as a substitute for parliamentary legislation. Not only could rendelets be used to fill in gaps in parliamentary legislation, they could also be used to bypass parliament and even to countermand parliamentary acts, sometimes at the expense of individual rights. The tendency remains in Hungary for its governments to use discretionary administrative instruments as a substitute for parliamentary legislation. Keywords: constitution, decree, patent, rendelet, legislation, Diet, Parliament In 1792, the Transylvanian Diet opened in the assembly rooms of Kolozsvár (today Cluj, Romania) with a trio, sung by the three graces, each of whom embodied one of the three powers identified by Montesquieu as contributing to a balanced constitution.1 The Hungarian constitution, however, was never balanced. The power attached to the executive was always the greatest. Attempts to hem in the executive, however, proved unsuccessful. During the later nineteenth century, the legislature surrendered to ministers a large share of its legislative capacity, with the consequence that ministerial decree or rendelet often took the place of statute law.
    [Show full text]
  • Franz Boas's Legacy of “Useful Knowledge”: the APS Archives And
    Franz Boas’s Legacy of “Useful Knowledge”: The APS Archives and the Future of Americanist Anthropology1 REGNA DARNELL Distinguished University Professor of Anthropology University of Western Ontario t is a pleasure and privilege, though also somewhat intimidating, to address the assembled membership of the American Philosophical ISociety. Like the august founders under whose portraits we assemble, Members come to hear their peers share the results of their inquiries across the full range of the sciences and arenas of public affairs to which they have contributed “useful knowledge.” Prior to the profes- sionalization of science in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the boundaries between disciplines were far less significant than they are today. Those who were not experts in particular topics could rest assured that their peers were capable of assessing both the state of knowledge in each other’s fields and the implications for society. Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and George Washington were all polymaths, covering what we now separate into several kinds of science, humanities, and social science in ways that crosscut one another and illustrate the permeability of disciplinary boundaries. The study of the American Indian is a piece of that multidisciplinary heri- tage that constituted the APS and continues to characterize its public persona. The Founding Members of the Society all had direct and seminal experience with the Indians and with the conflict between their traditional ways of life and the infringing world of settler colonialism. On the one hand, they felt justified in exploiting Native resources, as surveyors, treaty negotiators, and land speculators. On the other hand, the Indians represented the uniqueness of the Americas, of the New World that defined itself apart from the decadence of old Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • National Report to the ICA 14Th General Assembly, Moscow, 2007
    National Report to the ICA 14th General Assembly, Moscow, 2007 Prepared by Miljenko Lapaine Croatian Cartographic Society www.kartografija.hr [email protected] Cartography in Croatia 2003-2007, National Report to the ICA Cartography in Croatia 2003–2007 National Report to the ICA 14th General Assembly, Moscow, 2007 Prepared by Miljenko Lapaine Croatian Cartographic Society [email protected] Assistant Vesna Poslončec Petrić CD layout by Dražen Tutić Translator and Proof Reader Valentin Lapaine Reviewer Prof. Emeritus Nedjeljko Frančula Sponzored by State Geodetic Administration of the Republic of Croatia Published on CD by Croatian Cartographic Society Zagreb, August 2007 2 Cartography in Croatia 2003-2007, National Report to the ICA Contents 1. Introduction 4 2. Official Cartography 5 State Geodetic Administration 5 Croatian Geodetic Institute 7 Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Croatia 10 Hydrographic Institute of the Republic of Croatia 11 National and University Library 13 Lexicographic Institute “Miroslav Krleža” 16 Institute of Social Sciences “Ivo Pilar” 17 Institute of Migrations and Nationalities 17 Croatian Institute for History 17 3. Academic Cartography 18 Centre for Geoinformation and Cartography of the 18 Croatian Academy of Engineering Faculty of Geodesy of the University of Zagreb 19 Geographic Department of the Faculty of Science 22 of the University of Zagreb Department of Geography of the University of 24 Zadar Soil Science Department at the Faculty of 25 Agriculture, University of Zagreb Department for History of the University of Zadar 26 Faculty of Civil Engineering of the J. J. 26 Strossmayer University in Osijek Scientific Projects Financed by the Ministry of 26 Science, Education and Sport 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Medical Tourism in Zagreb
    GLOBAL health CONSULTING When we invite you to Zagreb, we want you to share with us: the taste the feeling the passion the hospitality the heritage the beauty the spirit of a city of great opportunities FLORA ART Medical Tourism in Zagreb THE CATHEDRAL CROATIAN NATIONAL THEATRE THE CATHEDRAL Cathedral tells the long tale of Croatian history because many We help make a change in The Mission of the GHC is to gather important Croats are laid to rest in its crypt. managing healthcare decision team of exceptional professionals The Croatian medical training model After the destructive earthquake in 1880, Our affiliations with carefully se- that are able to offer the highest is based on that of the U.S. and other architects Fridrik Schmidt and Herman lected private practitioners of various western countries, so doctors have Bolle began the reconstruction, giving the quality healthcare service. new one neo-Gothic features. specialties, private hospitals, private Our participating providers have received numerous years of training. CHURCH OF ST. MARK dates from ambulance transportation, pharma- been credentialed and certified and Many have received training abroad 1256. when King Bela IV permitted that cists and laboratories, enabled us the quality of care and service they and in our PPO network, all will be fairs can be held in Gradec, in the Upper to establish our highly integrated provide to our clients is constantly able to converse with you in English. Town. The colourful roof displays the coats of national provider physician network monitored through our auditing arms of Zagreb, kingdom of Croatia, Slavo- (PPO).
    [Show full text]
  • 9. Dancing and Politics in Croatia: the Salonsko Kolo As a Patriotic Response to the Waltz1 Ivana Katarinčić and Iva Niemčić
    WALTZING THROUGH EUROPE B ALTZING HROUGH UROPE Attitudes towards Couple Dances in the AKKA W T E Long Nineteenth-Century Attitudes towards Couple Dances in the Long Nineteenth-Century EDITED BY EGIL BAKKA, THERESA JILL BUCKLAND, al. et HELENA SAARIKOSKI AND ANNE VON BIBRA WHARTON From ‘folk devils’ to ballroom dancers, this volume explores the changing recep� on of fashionable couple dances in Europe from the eighteenth century onwards. A refreshing interven� on in dance studies, this book brings together elements of historiography, cultural memory, folklore, and dance across compara� vely narrow but W markedly heterogeneous locali� es. Rooted in inves� ga� ons of o� en newly discovered primary sources, the essays aff ord many opportuni� es to compare sociocultural and ALTZING poli� cal reac� ons to the arrival and prac� ce of popular rota� ng couple dances, such as the Waltz and the Polka. Leading contributors provide a transna� onal and aff ec� ve lens onto strikingly diverse topics, ranging from the evolu� on of roman� c couple dances in Croa� a, and Strauss’s visits to Hamburg and Altona in the 1830s, to dance as a tool of T cultural preserva� on and expression in twen� eth-century Finland. HROUGH Waltzing Through Europe creates openings for fresh collabora� ons in dance historiography and cultural history across fi elds and genres. It is essen� al reading for researchers of dance in central and northern Europe, while also appealing to the general reader who wants to learn more about the vibrant histories of these familiar dance forms. E As with all Open Book publica� ons, this en� re book is available to read for free on the UROPE publisher’s website.
    [Show full text]
  • Hrvatski Nacionalizam I Revolucija Godine 1848
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Juraj Dobrila University of Pula Digital Repository Sveučilište Jurja Dobrile u Puli Filozofski fakultet Martin Arbanas Hrvatski nacionalizam i revolucija godine 1848. Završni rad Pula, 2016. Sveučilište Jurja Dobrile u Puli Filozofski fakultet Martin Arbanas Hrvatski nacionalizam i revolucija godine 1848. Završni rad JMBAG: 0303047819, redoviti student Studijski smjer: preddiplomski studij povijesti Predmet: Hrvatska misao u XIX. st. Znanstveno područje: humanističke znanosti Znanstveno polje: povijest Znanstvena grana: hrvatska i svjetska moderna i suvremena povijest Mentor: prof. dr. sc. Nevio Šetić Pula, rujan 2016. IZJAVA O AKADEMSKOJ ČESTITOSTI Ja, dolje potpisani Martin Arbanas, kandidat za prvostupnika povijesti (jednopredmetne) ovime izjavljujem da je ovaj Završni rad rezultat isključivo mojega vlastitog rada, da se temelji na mojim istraţivanjima te da se oslanja na objavljenu literaturu kao što to pokazuju korištene bilješke i bibliografija. Izjavljujem da niti jedan dio Završnog rada nije napisan na nedozvoljen način, odnosno da je prepisan iz kojega necitiranog rada, te da ikoji dio rada krši bilo čija autorska prava. Izjavljujem, takoĎer, da nijedan dio rada nije iskorišten za koji drugi rad pri bilo kojoj drugoj visokoškolskoj, znanstvenoj ili radnoj ustanovi. U Puli, 1. rujna 2016. Student ______________________ IZJAVA o korištenju autorskog djela Ja, Martin Arbanas dajem odobrenje Sveučilištu Jurja Dobrile u Puli, kao nositelju
    [Show full text]
  • Are No Longer So Certain. Much of Current Anthropological Research Is
    AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY OF NATIVE AMERICAN AUTOBIOGRAPHIES AND LIFE HISTORIES Allen G. Pastron University of California, Berkeley During the past decade, a significant crisis of confidence has been steadily developing within the field of anthropology. Many anthropologists, particularly the younger members of the profession, have become increasingly distressed by what is felt to be a distinct lack of humanistically oriented or socially relevant research in many contemporary programs of study. Whereas once most anthropologists were of an accord that our profession represented the most humanistic and socially progressive aspects of the social sciences, today many of us are no longer so certain. Much of current anthropological research is so directed toward statistical analysis and the mathematical parameters that have been outlined by the mechanical computations of computers, that a human essence can often only barely be detected. While such innovations have their place in the social sciences as elsewhere, many anthropologists are beginning to re-evaluate the moral and aesthetic price that the discipline must pay to attain such "'modernization". As a result, a large number of scholars have recently been consciously attempting to employ research strategies and methods which they hope will help to restore man to a position of prominence within the study of Man. 144 The recording of the autobiographical life histories of selected informants as an ethnographic tool provides a number of benefits to anthropological research. The use of life history offers the field researcher the opportunity to combine the collection of reliable ethnographic data with an unmistakably humanistic orientation. Further, the narrator is allowed to interpret his own culture without the necessity of a middleman, in this case the social scientist.
    [Show full text]
  • Soundscapes: Toward a Sounded Anthropology
    AN39CH20-Samuels ARI 13 August 2010 18:8 Soundscapes: Toward a Sounded Anthropology David W. Samuels,1 Louise Meintjes,2 Ana Maria Ochoa,3 and Thomas Porcello4 1Department of Music, New York University, New York, NY 10003; email: [email protected] 2Departments of Music and Cultural Anthropology, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina 27708-0665; email: [email protected] 3Department of Music, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027; email: [email protected] 4Department of Anthropology, Vassar College, Poughkeepsie, New York 12604; email: [email protected] Annu. Rev. Anthropol. 2010. 39:329–45 Key Words First published online as a Review in Advance on aurality, film sound, listening, music, recording technology, sound art June 21, 2010 The Annual Review of Anthropology is online at Abstract anthro.annualreviews.org A generation of scholars in multiple disciplines has investigated sound in This article’s doi: ways that are productive for anthropologists. We introduce the concept Access provided by Duke University on 06/05/16. For personal use only. 10.1146/annurev-anthro-022510-132230 of soundscape as a modality for integrating this work into an anthropo- Copyright c 2010 by Annual Reviews. Annu. Rev. Anthropol. 2010.39:329-345. Downloaded from www.annualreviews.org logical approach. We trace its history as a response to the technological All rights reserved mediations and listening practices emergent in modernity and note its 0084-6570/10/1021-0329$20.00 absence in the anthropological literature. We then trace the history of technology that gave rise to anthropological recording practices, film sound techniques, and experimental sound art, noting productive inter- weavings of these threads.
    [Show full text]
  • Bartulin's Tilting at Windmills
    BARTULIN’S TILTING AT WINDMILLS: MANIPULATION AS A HISTORIOGRAPHIC METHOD (A reply to Nevenko Bartulin’s “Intelectual Discourse on Race and Culture in Croatia 1900-1945”) Tomislav JONJIĆ∗ In this article, which is written in a polemical tone, the author is making an eff ort to problematize a point of view from which the ideology of Croatian nationalism, the Ustasha movement and the Independent State of Croatia are even today being obsereved by a part of historiography. According to the au- thor, the ideology of Croatian nationalism has not suff ered much vital modi- fi cation since the mid-19th century until the end od the Second World War, rather it has kept itself occupied with justifying the right of Croats as a multi- confessional European nation to establish an independent state. Not just po- litical manifestations, but also literary and cultural achievements of the na- tionalist ideology protagonists clearly speak in that direction. Th e geopolitical position of Croatian lands, as well as the infl uence of foreign powers have not made the achievement of such a right of Croatian people and the evolution of Croatian nationalist ideology possible. As a result, that same nationalist ideol- ogy sometimes takes on foreign ideological and political infl uences which are visible only on its surface and purely out of tactial reasons. Th e Ustasha move- ment, being one of the manifestations of Croatian nationalism, is also charac- terized by ideological eclecticism. Th us, diff erent and sometimes contrastive statements made by the leading persona of Ustasha movement regarding their attitude towards the ideologies dominating Europe in the time aft er the First World War are therefore understandable.
    [Show full text]