Sentencing for Criminal Offences Arising from the Death of a Child

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Sentencing for Criminal Offences Arising from the Death of a Child i Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child Final report October 2018 ii Warning to readers This report contains subject matter that may be distressing to readers. Explicit material describing fatal offences against children, drawn from sentencing remarks, is included in this report. If you need to talk to someone, support is available: • Lifeline Australia: 13 11 14 • Kids Helpline: 1800 55 1800 • Victim Assist Queensland: 1300 546 587 (business hours) • MensLine Australia: 1300 78 99 78 For information and assistance about child safety issues, please contact • Queensland Family & Child Commission: 3900 6000 (business hours) Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child: Final report Published by Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council, October 2018 © Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council 2018 This final report is available for download from the Council’s website: www.sentencingcouncil.qld.gov.au This final report is licensed by Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 International licence. CC BY licence summary statement In essence, you are free to copy, communicate and adapt this annual report, as long as you attribute the work to Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 Content from this final report should be attributed as — Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child: Final report, Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council, October 2018. Disclaimer The content of this final report is for the purpose of promoting discussion only and does not represent Queensland Government policy. While all reasonable care has been taken in the preparation of this final report, no responsibility or liability is assumed for any errors or omissions or any loss, damage or injury, financial or otherwise, suffered by any person acting or relying on information contained in or omitted from this publication. This final report follows the Melbourne University Law Review Association Inc, Australian Guide to Legal Citation (3rd ed., 2010) and reflects the law as at 1 October 2018. Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council is established by section 198 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld). The Council provides independent research and advice, seeks public views and promotes community understanding of sentencing matters. The Council’s functions, detailed in section 199 of the Act, include to: • inform the community about sentencing through research and education; • engage with Queenslanders to understand their views on sentencing; and • advise the Attorney-General on matters relating to sentencing, at the Attorney-General’s request. Further information Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council GPO Box 2360, Brisbane Qld 4001 Tel: (07) 3224 7375 Email: [email protected] Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child homicide — final report iii 31 October 2018 The Honourable Yvette D’Ath Attorney-General and Minister for Justice, Leader of the House GPO Box 149 Brisbane Qld 4001 Dear Attorney-General I am pleased to provide the Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council’s, Sentencing for Criminal Offences Arising from the Death of a Child: Final Report. This final report addresses the Terms of Reference you referred to the Council on 26 October 2017. Yours sincerely John Robertson Chair Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child homicide — final report iv Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child homicide — final report v Contents List of figures .................................................................................................................. viii List of tables ..................................................................................................................... ix Contributors ..................................................................................................................... xi Preface ........................................................................................................................... xiii Acknowledgments.......................................................................................................... xvi Abbreviations ................................................................................................................ xvii Glossary ........................................................................................................................ xviii Executive summary ...................................................................................................... xxiv Advice and Recommendations ................................................................................. xxxviii Chapter 1 — Introduction ................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Terms of Reference ............................................................................................................................ 1 1.2 The Council’s approach to the Terms of Reference .................................................................. 2 Chapter 2 — The nature and extent of child homicide ................................................... 6 2.1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 6 2.2 National and international research findings ................................................................................ 6 2.3 Child homicide research ................................................................................................................... 6 2.4 Child homicide offences .................................................................................................................... 9 2.5 Child homicide victims..................................................................................................................... 11 2.6 Child homicide offenders ................................................................................................................ 15 2.7 Child homicide in Queensland ....................................................................................................... 22 2.8 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................................... 24 Chapter 3 — Child homicide offences ........................................................................... 25 3.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 25 3.2 Murder and manslaughter ............................................................................................................... 25 3.3 Associated offences .......................................................................................................................... 32 3.4 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................................... 36 Chapter 4 — Sentencing process and framework ......................................................... 38 4.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 38 4.2 Sentencing hearing ............................................................................................................................ 38 4.3 Sentencing process ........................................................................................................................... 38 4.4 Sentencing purposes ......................................................................................................................... 40 4.5 Sentencing factors ............................................................................................................................. 49 4.6 Aggravating and mitigating factors ................................................................................................ 54 4.7 Sentencing principles in case law ................................................................................................... 65 Sentencing for criminal offences arising from the death of a child homicide — final report vi 4.8 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................................... 67 Chapter 5 — Current sentencing practices for homicide in Queensland ...................... 68 5.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 68 5.2 Methodology ...................................................................................................................................... 68 5.3 Maximum penalties ........................................................................................................................... 68 5.4 Penalties and parole.......................................................................................................................... 69 5.5 Sentencing outcomes for homicide offenders ............................................................................ 74 5.6 Sentencing approach for manslaughter .......................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Additional Estimates 2010-11
    Dinner on the occasion of the First Meeting of the International Commission on Nuclear Non-proliferation and Disarmament Kirribilli House, Kirribilli, Sydney Sunday, 19 October 2008 Host Mr Francois Heisbourg The Honourable Kevin Rudd MP Commissioner (France) Prime Minister Chairman of the International Institute for Strategic Studies and Geneva Centre for Official Party Security Policy, Special Adviser at the The Honourable Gareth Evans AO QC Foundation pour la Recherche Strategique Co-Chair International Commission on Nuclear Non- General (Ret'd) Jehangir Karamat proliferation and Disarmament Commissioner (Pakistan) and President of the International Crisis Director, Spearhead Research Group Mrs Nilofar Karamat Ms Yoriko Kawaguchi General ((Ret'd) Klaus Naumann Co-Chair Commissioner (Germany) International Commission on Nuclear Non- Member of the International Advisory Board proliferation and Disarmament and member of the World Security Network Foundation of the House of Councillors and Chair of the Liberal Democratic Party Research Dr William Perry Commission on the Environment Commissioner (United States) Professor of Stanford University School of Mr Ali Alatas Engineering and Institute of International Commissioner (Indonesia) Studies Adviser and Special Envoy of the President of the Republic of Indonesia Ambassador Wang Yingfan Mrs Junisa Alatas Commissioner (China) Formerly China's Vice Foreign Minister Dr Alexei Arbatov (1995-2000), China's Ambassador and Commissioner (Russia) Permanent Representative to the United Scholar-in-residence
    [Show full text]
  • A Guide for Victims of Crime in Queensland
    Department of www.justice.qld.gov.au Justice and Attorney-General A guide for victims of crime in Queensland Victim Assist Queensland Tomorrow’s Queensland: strong, green, smart, healthy and fair Section 1 Introduction Victim Assist Queensland provides assistance for victims of crime in Queensland to help them to recover from the effects of a violent crime and get their lives back on track. Victim Assist Queensland is part of the Queensland Government’s Department of Justice and Attorney-General. This booklet has been written by Victim Assist Queensland for you, the victim of crime, and your friends and family who may have been directly or indirectly affected by a violent crime. Violent crimes are not just offences like assault, robbery and murder. Violent crimes also include sexual assault or abuse, stalking and kidnapping, death caused by dangerous driving and violence that happens at home or in your family. In this booklet you will find information on support available to you, including information on where to go for counselling and legal support. You will also find information on your rights as a victim of crime and how you may be able to apply for financial assistance from Victim Assist Queensland to help cover the costs of your recovery. This booklet also aims to explain as simply as possible how the criminal justice system in Queensland works for victims of crime, from the time a crime is reported to the police to when a matter is going through court. Contents Section 1 Introduction Page 1 Section 2 The impact of violent crime
    [Show full text]
  • Minimum Standard Non-Parole Period Final Report
    Minimum standard non-parole periods FINAL REPORT September 2011 Minimum standard non-parole periods FINAL REPORT ii Published by the: Sentencing Advisory Council Level 30, 400 George St Brisbane Qld, Australia 4000 GPO Box 2360 Brisbane Qld 4001 Tel: 1300 461 577 Fax: (07) 3405 9780 Email: [email protected] www.sentencingcouncil.qld.gov.au This publication is available for download from the Council’s website. © State of Queensland (Sentencing Advisory Council) 2011 Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study, research, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted by any process without prior permission. Inquiries should be addressed to the Sentencing Advisory Council as the publisher. National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication data: Sentencing Advisory Council (Qld). Minimum standard non-parole periods: final report / Sentencing Advisory Council (Qld). ISBN 978-0-9871456-2-8 (pbk). Prison sentences—Queensland. Sentences (Criminal procedure)—Queensland. Criminal justice, Administration of—Queensland. 364.6209943 This publication follows the referencing style of the Australian Guide to Legal Citation (Melbourne University Law Review Association Inc, 3rd ed, 2010). Disclaimer This report is not intended to provide legal advice, and has been prepared by the Council only to respond to the Terms of Reference issued to it by the Attorney-General. While all reasonable care has been taken in the
    [Show full text]
  • The Task Cards
    HEROES HEROES TASK CARD 1 TASK CARD 2 HERO RECEIVES PURPLE CROSS YOUNG AUSTRALIAN OF THE YEAR The Young Australian of the Year has been awarded since 1979. It Read the story about Sarbi and answer these questions. recognises the outstanding achievement of young Australians aged 16 to 30 and the contributions they have made to our communities. 1. What colour is associated with the Australian Special Forces? YEAR Name of Recipient Field of Achievement 2011 Jessica Watson 2. What breed of dog is Sarbi? 2010 Trooper Mark Donaldson VC 2009 Jonty Bush 3. What is Sarbi trained to do? 2008 Casey Stoner 2007 Tania Major 4. What type of animal has also received 2006 Trisha Broadbridge the Purple Cross for wartime service? 2005 Khoa Do 2004 Hugh Evans 5. In which country was Sarbi working 2003 Lleyton Hewitt when she went missing? 2002 Scott Hocknull 2001 James Fitzpatrick 6. How was Sarbi identified when she was found? 2000 Ian Thorpe OAM 1999 Dr Bryan Gaensler 7. What does MIA stand for? 1998 Tan Le 1997 Nova Peris OAM 8. Which word in the text means ‘to attack by surprise’? 1996 Rebecca Chambers 1995 Poppy King 9. How many days was Sarbi missing for? Find out what each of these people received their Young Australian 10. Why did Sarbi receive the Purple cross? Award for. Use this list of achievements to help you. Concert pianist; Astronomer; Champion Tennis Player; Sailor; Palaeontologist; MotoGP World Champion; Business Woman; World Champion Swimmer; Youth Leader & Tsunami Survivor; Anti-poverty Campaigner; Olympic Gold Medallist Athlete; Victim
    [Show full text]
  • Project KRYSTAL a Strategic Assessment of Organised Crime In
    Queensland Crime Commission Queensland Police Service I~CC Crime Commi"ion Project KRYSTAL A Strategic Assessment of Organised Crime in Queensland JUNE 1999 PUBLIC INFORMATION PAPER The Queensland Crime Commission is charged pursuant to Section 28 (l)(e) ofthe Crime Commission Act 1997 with responsibility for the maintenance ofan effective intelligence service about organised crime and the monitoring of collected intelligence data with a view to forecasting trends in organised crime. Queensland Crime Commission and Queensland Police Service, 1999 lSB~: 0-646-37622-5 Queensland Crime Commission Level 2 Unisys House 147 Coronation Drive Milton Qld 4064 GPO Box 3123 Brisbane Qld 4001 Tel.: (07) 3238 4100 Fax.: (07) 3238 4111 E-mail: [email protected] ii Queensland Crime Commission - Queensland Police Service CONTENTS Abbreviations............................................................................... v Acknowledgements........................................................................ vi Foreword..................................................................................... vii Executive summary........................................................................ ix 1 Introduction............................................................................ 1 Purpose.............................. 1 Methodology. .... .......... ........................... .. ................... ... .. ... .. 1 Parameters ...................................................................... 2 Overview ofchapters .........................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Guide for Victims of Crime in Queensland
    Department of Justice and Attorney-General Victim Assist Queensland A guide for Victims of Crime in Queensland 5825_VAQ_Guide for Victims of Crime A5 BOOKLET.indd 1 13/10/17 10:30 am My important contacts Victim Assist Queensland | 1300 546 587 (Monday–Friday 8.30am – 5.00pm except public holidays) Email | [email protected] For a free interpreting service call: 13 14 50 and ask for Victim Assist Queensland My application number is My Victim Coordination Officer is Queensland Police | 13 14 44 (Policelink for non-urgent enquiries) My local police station My police contact (arresting officer) My police report number is QP Queensland Health Victim Support Service | 1800 208 005 My Victim Support Coordinator is Legal Aid Queensland | 1300 651 188 My Legal Aid contact is Other contacts and important notes A guide for victims of crime in Queensland | 5825_VAQ_Guide for Victims of Crime A5 BOOKLET.indd 2 13/10/17 10:30 am Section 1 Introduction Introduction Victim Assist Queensland (Victim Assist) provides help for victims of crime in Queensland to help them recover from the effects of violent crime and get their lives back on track. Victim Assist is part of the Queensland Department of Justice and Attorney-General. This booklet is a guide for people affected by a violent crime, as well as their family and friends. Violent crimes can include assault, robbery, murder, sexual assault, child abuse, stalking and kidnapping and dangerous driving causing death and serious injury. It also includes victims who have suffered injuries as a result of Domestic and Family Violence (DFV), including those who have suffered emotional or economic abuse.
    [Show full text]
  • Mudrooroo: a Likely Story
    Mudrooroo: A Likely Story Identity and Belonging in Postcolonial Australia A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree Doctor of Philosophy from UNIVERSITY OF WOLLONGONG by Maureen Clark, B.A. (Hons. First Class) Faculty of Arts 2003 Contents Acknowledgments Abstract Introduction i Part I I. Mudrooroo.author 1 II. A Question of Belonging Somewhere 19 III. The Death of the Mother 58 Part II IV. Belonging Nowhere: The Wildcat Trilogy 76 V. Vampirising Oppositional Histories: Long Live Sandawara 122 VI. Shared Histories and Shifting Identities: Doctor Wooreddy’s Prescription for Enduring the Ending of the World 156 VII. Spectral Paradise: The Kwinkan 188 VIII. Violent Histories of Identity and Belonging: Master of the Ghost Dreaming 216 IX. Seductive (In)human(e) Entanglements: 242 The Vampire Trilogy Conclusion 290 Bibliography 303 Acknowledgments A culturally sensitive project such as this could never have been undertaken without the help and support of a number of people. I should like to say here that I am indebted in particular to the unfailingly generous efforts and encouragement of my supervisor Associate Professor Gerry Turcotte, during what has sometimes been an emotionally fraught journey. For his magnanimous responses to my draft chapters, I am also grateful to my second supervisor Associate Professor Paul Sharrad, from whose wise counsel and suggestions I have consistently benefited. Mrs. Betty Polglaze, Mudrooroo’s older sister, deserves special mention and appreciation. The trust she and other members of her family have afforded me during the time taken to complete this work is beyond measure. I would also like to thank Nyoongar Elder Rosemary van den Berg, Head of Aboriginal Studies at Curtin University of Technology Pat Dudgeon, as well as Nyoongar women Glenda Kickett and Tracey Kickett.
    [Show full text]
  • Imprisonment and Recidivism Contents
    AUGUST 2019 SUMMARY REPORT Imprisonment and Recidivism Contents Foreword 01 1 What is the inquiry about? 03 Consultation 05 What stakeholders told us 06 2 Imprisonment is a growing problem 07 3 Reform options 17 Build a better decision-making architecture 17 Reduce the scope of criminal offences 20 Deal with offending in better ways 24 Improve rehabilitation and reintegration 28 Target prevention and early intervention 30 Expand diversionary options 32 Addressing Indigenous overrepresentation 34 Recommendations 37 Queensland Productivity Commission 01 Foreword In September 2018, the Queensland Government directed the Queensland Productivity Commission to undertake an inquiry into imprisonment and recidivism. This report summarises our findings and recommendations. Despite declining crime rates, imprisonment rates in Queensland are increasing. Imprisonment rates for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are high and growing, and the rate of imprisonment of women is also growing. These matters are not unique to Queensland and reflect wider Australian trends. Imprisonment is an expensive response to crime and directly costs the Queensland community almost one billion dollars annually. Incarceration has profound impacts on prisoners, their families and the community. Our findings challenge the notion that community safety is best served by continuing the current approach. We propose a comprehensive suite of recommendations which we believe will improve outcomes, reduce costs and keep communities safer. Our report makes the case for a narrowing of the scope of criminal offences. We argue for some crimes to be punished with non-custodial options. We propose a greater role for restitution and restorative justice. We recommend widening the sentencing options available to the courts.
    [Show full text]
  • Childrens Court of Queensland Annual Report 1997-1998
    Childrens Court of Queensland Fifth Annual Report 1997-1998 CHILDRENS COURT OF QUEENSLAND Chambers of the President November 1998 The Honourable Matt Foley MLA Attorney-General and Minister for Justice and Minister for the Arts Sir, In accordance with the requirements of s.22 of the Childrens Court Act 1992, I have the honour to submit to you for presentation in Parliament the Fifth Annual Report of the Childrens Court of Queensland for 1997-98. Judge McGuire President of the Childrens Court of Queensland Childrens Court, 30-40 Quay Sreet, Brisbane, Q 4000. Telephone: (07) 3365 9841 Facsimile: (07) 3365 9890 Childrens Court of Queensland Annual Report 1997-98 I TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. JUVENILE CRIME: TRENDS IN 1997-98 .............. 6 2. INTRODUCTION .............................. 7 Divided opinion ......................... 7 The role of the Courts ..................... 7 Legislative re-direction .................... 8 Looking back ........................... 8 The horse has bolted ..................... 8 Statistics .............................. 9 Public concern .......................... 9 Key factors ............................ 10 3. REFORMS IN BRITAIN AND CANADA: A MODEL TO FOLLOW. 11 A 'crime ti mebomb' ..................... 11 Proposed reforms ....................... 11 Public protection first .................... 12 Measures in the Crime and Disorder Bill ...... 12 Queensland legislators should take note ...... 13 Strategies - short and long term ............ 14 Governments and the moral issue ........... 14 4. THE AUGUST AMENDMENTS
    [Show full text]
  • Inquiry Into Imprisonment and Recidivism © Queensland Productivity Commission 2019
    August 2019 APPENDICES Inquiry into Imprisonment and Recidivism © Queensland Productivity Commission 2019 The Queensland Productivity Commission supports and encourages the dissemination and exchange of information. However, copyright protects this document. The Queensland Productivity Commission has no objection to this material being reproduced, made available online or electronically but only if it is recognised as the owner of the copyright and this material remains unaltered. This report is available online and in PDF format on our website. WEB qpc.qld.gov.au TEL (07) 3015 5111 email [email protected] ABN 18 872 336 955 Appendix A: Terms of reference Appendix A: Terms of reference Inquiry into Imprisonment and Recidivism Context The growth in prisoner numbers is a serious and growing public policy concern for Queensland. • The imprisonment rate of people in Queensland prisons increased by 40 per cent in the five years from 2012 to 2017, around five times the population growth rate for Queensland. • The imprisonment rate of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders increased by 50 per cent over the same period. • Recidivism is high with more than 60 per cent of new prisoners having been in prison before. • Of further concern is the real increase of imprisonment of women, especially Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women. The growth of prisoner numbers has major social and economic implications for affected individuals and the wider Queensland community. It also has significant financial implications for government. Change is necessary however, the problem is complex. Prisoner numbers reflects underlying forces including long term social and economic factors and community views about criminal justice; but they also reflect the daily activity and decisions at key points within the criminal justice system, sentencing and legislative frameworks, police resourcing and decisions, sentencing practices, court workloads and access to support services including legal aid.
    [Show full text]
  • Record of Proceedings
    PROOF ISSN 1322-0330 RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS Hansard Home Page: http://www.parliament.qld.gov.au/hansard/ E-mail: [email protected] Phone: (07) 3406 7314 Fax: (07) 3210 0182 Subject FIRST SESSION OF THE FIFTY-THIRD PARLIAMENT Page Tuesday, 15 November 2011 ASSENT TO BILLS ........................................................................................................................................................................ 3545 Tabled paper: Letter, dated 28 October 2011, from Her Excellency the Governor to Mr Speaker advising of assent to bills on 28 October 2011....................................................................................................... 3545 Tabled paper: Letter, dated 4 November 2011, from Her Excellency the Governor to Mr Speaker advising of assent to bills on 4 November 2011. .................................................................................................... 3545 SPEAKER’S STATEMENT ............................................................................................................................................................ 3546 Loan of Documents ............................................................................................................................................................ 3546 PRIVILEGE ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 3546 Speaker’s Ruling, Ethics Committee Report .....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Effects of DNA Evidence on the Criminal Justice Process
    The Effects of DNA Evidence on the Criminal Justice Process Author Briody, Michael Published 2005 Thesis Type Thesis (PhD Doctorate) School School of Criminology and Criminal Justice DOI https://doi.org/10.25904/1912/2417 Copyright Statement The author owns the copyright in this thesis, unless stated otherwise. Downloaded from http://hdl.handle.net/10072/366784 Griffith Research Online https://research-repository.griffith.edu.au THE EFFECTS OF DNA EVIDENCE ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE PROCESS Michael Briody Adv Cert Pol, BA(Hons 1) School of Criminology and Criminal Justice Faculty of Arts Griffith University Submitted in fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy November 2004 Confidential Appendix With the approval of the Dean, Graduate Studies, five brief confidential interviews have been removed from the thesis. The author conducted these interviews with investigating police officers in relation to cases where DNA evidence was produced in court, but an acquittal nevertheless resulted. The interviews were removed from the following pages: 104, 127 and 151-2. ii ABSTRACT This research examines the effects of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) evidence on decisions in the courts and on the conduct of criminal investigations. To assess effects on court decisions, quantitative analyses were conducted using primary data from the State of Queensland. A control-comparison method was used to assess the effects in court, and this was made within a context of other evidentiary and extra- legal factors that had a bearing on case outcomes. These other factors included defendant confessions, independent witness testimony and fingerprint and photographic evidence. A sample of 750 cases referred by police for prosecution and finalised past the appeal stage in court, was selected for examination.
    [Show full text]