Tom Kilburn (1921–2001) Determined to See Projects Through to Completion

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Tom Kilburn (1921–2001) Determined to See Projects Through to Completion news and views Obituary scientists at this time, his wartime experience in radar made him Tom Kilburn (1921–2001) determined to see projects through to completion. Kilburn’s enthusiasm for By 1947 the theory of general-purpose, implementation became the hallmark of stored-program computers was familiar to computer science at Manchester. Kilburn several research groups on both sides of was accorded the scientific accolade of the Atlantic. However, the lack of suitable fellowship of the Royal Society in 1965. high-speed memory devices stopped them Kilburn was a modest individual who turning theory into practice. To quote actively shunned publicity. In 1968 he was Nathaniel Rochester of IBM, writing in the asked why computer science textbooks premier US electronics journal (Proc. IRE, seldom mentioned the early pioneering p. 374; April 1950): “The most difficult work at Manchester. Kilburn paused, and problem in the construction of large-scale then replied mysteriously: “Because those digital computers continues to be the who need to know, do know.” Such question of how to build a memory, and isolationism was sometimes the despair of MANCHESTER DEPT COMPUTER SCIENCE, UNIV. the few papers written do not reflect the his more gregarious colleagues, but greatness of the effort which is being Kilburn’s ability to remain focused on a exerted.” It was in this context that Tom problem enabled him to lead his team Kilburn began working for his PhD at the from the front. University of Manchester. His task was to In a field of scientific endeavour perfect a new form of digital memory. characterized by transitory, ad hoc The starting point was an observation by developments, it is not easy to explain F. C. Williams of the stored patterns of in simple terms the contributions to electrostatic charge inside a cathode-ray Designer of the computer design made at Manchester tube. first stored-program between 1948 and 1975. If there was an By the autumn of 1947 Kilburn had computer underlying theme, it was the pursuit of constructed a practical random-access hardware assistance for efficient scientific memory device, later known as the 1948 and 1975. The fourth of these, Atlas, computation. Although some of Kilburn’s Williams–Kilburn tube. Williams and was the world’s most powerful computer engineering innovations were soon made Kilburn decided to incorporate the tube when it came into operation in December obsolescent by subsequent technologies into a small-scale experimental computer, 1962. Although this pre-eminence lasted (the advent of semiconductors, for “to subject the memory system to the most but a few months, several innovative instance), other ideas have stood the test searching tests possible”. This small-scale concepts that remain in use today were of time. Among them are hardware computer, sometimes called the ‘Baby’, pioneered in Atlas, including virtual assistance for accessing structured data first ran a program on the morning of memory. Kilburn (seen here at the such as arrays (the index register, 1949); Monday 21 June 1948. The event was keyboard of Atlas) was particularly proud hardware implementation of floating- described in a letter to Nature published that all five designs led to industrial point arithmetic (1954); hardware later that year (162, 487; 1948). derivatives. Fruitful links with companies management of heterogeneous storage The 1948 Manchester computer such as Ferranti and ICL meant that only systems (associative page-address contained only a few words (128 bytes) of one of the projects required an initial translation, 1962); and hardware storage. It was built from war-surplus injection of public funding from Britain’s management of local scalars in electronic components, the rudimentary Science Research Council. In 1964 the block-structured high-level languages input being via push-buttons recycled Manchester group evolved into the (the name store, 1974). from the radio-channel selector panels department of computer science, with In June 1948, the information of Spitfire aircraft. Yet this small Kilburn at its head. revolution took its first tentative steps. By machine provided the first convincing But what of the man himself? Born in the end of 1949 there were probably still demonstration of the stored-program the no-nonsense county of Yorkshire, only four prototype computers coming principle, which is the basis of every Kilburn was christened plain ‘Tom’ (not into hesitant operation anywhere in the modern computer. From this prototype, Thomas). Encouraged at school by an world — two in Britain (at the universities the British company Ferranti Ltd outstanding mathematics teacher, Kilburn of Cambridge and Manchester), one in the developed the world’s first commercially won a scholarship to the University of United States (at the Eckert–Mauchley available computer, known as the Ferranti Cambridge in 1940. He graduated with Computer Corporation, Philadelphia) and Mark I. The first production model was first-class honours in a two-year wartime one in Australia (at the Commonwealth delivered in February 1951, marginally mathematics course, and was given a Scientific and Industrial Research ahead of the much larger UNIVAC 1 quick introduction to electronics in Organisation, Sydney). Like its designer, computer developed by Eckert and London and sent to work at the the first Manchester computer was a Mauchley in the United States. Telecommunications Research creation of few words in a new world. Designing and building computers is a Establishment, Malvern. Here he joined Kilburn died on 17 January, aged 79, but team activity combining hardware and Williams, who headed a special his ‘few words’ will continue to resonate software skills. When Williams moved on engineering group solving electronic widely. Simon Lavington to other things, Kilburn built up a circuit problems for radar applications. Simon Lavington is in the Department of research team at the University of Although originally a mathematician, Computer Science, University of Essex, Colchester Manchester that completed a total of five Kilburn soon came to regard himself as CO4 3SQ, UK. increasingly powerful computers between an engineer. As with many young British e-mail: [email protected] 996 © 2001 Macmillan Magazines Ltd NATURE | VOL 409 | 22 FEBRUARY 2001 | www.nature.com.
Recommended publications
  • Who Did What? Engineers Vs Mathematicians Title Page America Vs Europe Ideas Vs Implementations Babbage Lovelace Turing
    Who did what? Engineers vs Mathematicians Title Page America vs Europe Ideas vs Implementations Babbage Lovelace Turing Flowers Atanasoff Berry Zuse Chandler Broadhurst Mauchley & Von Neumann Wilkes Eckert Williams Kilburn SlideSlide 1 1 SlideSlide 2 2 A decade of real progress What remained to be done? A number of different pioneers had during the 1930s and 40s Memory! begun to make significant progress in developing automatic calculators (computers). Thanks (almost entirely) to A.M. Turing there was a complete theoretical understanding of the elements necessary to produce a Atanasoff had pioneered the use of electronics in calculation stored program computer – or Universal Turing Machine. Zuse had mad a number of theoretical breakthroughs Not for the first time, ideas had outstripped technology. Eckert and Mauchley (with JvN) had produced ENIAC and No-one had, by the end of the war, developed a practical store or produced the EDVAC report – spreading the word memory. Newman and Flowers had developed the Colossus It should be noted that not too many people were even working on the problem. SlideSlide 3 3 SlideSlide 4 4 The players Controversy USA: Eckert, Mauchley & von Neumann – EDVAC Fall out over the EDVAC report UK: Maurice Wilkes – EDSAC Takeover of the SSEM project by Williams (Kilburn) UK: Newman – SSEM (what was the role of Colossus?) Discord on the ACE project and the departure of Turing UK: Turing - ACE EDSAC alone was harmonious We will concentrate for a little while on the SSEM – the winner! SlideSlide 5 5 SlideSlide 6 6 1 Newman & technology transfer: Secret Technology Transfer? the claim Donald Michie : Cryptanalyst An enormous amount was transferred in an extremely seminal way to the post war developments of computers in Britain.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Construction and the British Computer Industry in the Post-World War II Period
    The rhetoric of Americanisation: Social construction and the British computer industry in the Post-World War II period By Robert James Kirkwood Reid Submitted to the University of Glasgow for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Economic History Department of Economic and Social History September 2007 1 Abstract This research seeks to understand the process of technological development in the UK and the specific role of a ‘rhetoric of Americanisation’ in that process. The concept of a ‘rhetoric of Americanisation’ will be developed throughout the thesis through a study into the computer industry in the UK in the post-war period . Specifically, the thesis discusses the threat of America, or how actors in the network of innovation within the British computer industry perceived it as a threat and the effect that this perception had on actors operating in the networks of construction in the British computer industry. However, the reaction to this threat was not a simple one. Rather this story is marked by sectional interests and technopolitical machination attempting to capture this rhetoric of ‘threat’ and ‘falling behind’. In this thesis the concept of ‘threat’ and ‘falling behind’, or more simply the ‘rhetoric of Americanisation’, will be explored in detail and the effect this had on the development of the British computer industry. What form did the process of capture and modification by sectional interests within government and industry take and what impact did this have on the British computer industry? In answering these questions, the thesis will first develop a concept of a British culture of computing which acts as the surface of emergence for various ideologies of innovation within the social networks that made up the computer industry in the UK.
    [Show full text]
  • ATLAS@50 Then and Now
    ATLAS@50 Then and now Science & Technology Facilities Council The origins of Atlas In the years following the Second World War, there was huge interest in nuclear physics technologies both for civilian nuclear energy research and for military nuclear weapons. These technologies required ever-increasing amounts of computer power to analyse data and, more importantly, to perform simulations far more safely than would be possible in a laboratory. By 1958, 75% of Britain’s R&D computer power was provided by the Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) at Aldermaston (using an American IBM 704), Risley, Winfrith and Harwell (each using a British Ferranti Mercury). These were however what we would now call The advisory panel for the super-computer single-user systems, capable of running only included Freddy Williams (a pioneer in radar and Foreword one program at a time, so were essentially very computer technology) from Victoria University large desktop calculators. Indeed, the name of Manchester, Maurice Wilkes (designer of It is now known as Rutherford Appleton Laboratory buildings R26 and R27, but over “computer” referred to the human operator; EDSAC, the Electronic Delay Storage Automatic its 50+ year history, the Atlas Computer Laboratory in the parish of Chilton has been the machinery itself was known as an Calculator) from Cambridge, Albert Uttley of the “automatic calculating machine.” RRE (Royal Radar Establishment), and Ted Cooke- part of many seminal moments in computing history. Yarborough (designer of the Dekatron and CADET British manufacturers of automatic calculating computers) from AERE Harwell; Christopher Over its 50+ year history it has also housed It was cleaned and restored as far as we could, machines were doing well until IBM announced Strachey (a pioneer in programming language many mainframe and super-computers including and took pride of place at an event held to that their first transistorised computer was to design) was in charge of design.
    [Show full text]
  • ASAP 2020 Opinion
    Message from the Conference Chairs ASAP 2020 We welcome you to the 31st IEEE International Conference on Application-specific Systems, Architectures and Processors (ASAP 2020). This year’s event was supposed to take place in Manchester, United Kingdom, a major city in the northwest of England with a rich industrial heritage. Manchester has transformed the modern world through a boom in textile manufacturing during the industrial revolution in Victorian England. In the 1880s, 80% of the world cotton production went through Manchester for trade and manufacturing, making Manchester the first industrialized city in the world. To master the enormous logistics, the 58 km Manchester Ship Canal connected Manchester with the Irish Sea in 1894, and the world’s first steam-powered, inter-urban railway for transporting both passengers and goods was completed between Manchester and Liverpool in 1830. Its Manchester terminus is now part of the Science and Industry Museum where we planed the ASAP 2020 banquet. ASAP 2020 is hosted by the Department of Computer Science at The University of Manchester, which is one of the oldest in the UK. The University of Manchester played an important role in the development of computing. This includes the development of the first electronically stored program computer, the first floating-point machine, and the Atlas computer, which was once the world’s most powerful computer and the first machine to use paged virtual memory. The school and department of Computer Science was home to Alan Turing and Tom Kilburn; and in November 2018, the 1 million processor SpiNNaker neuromorphic supercomputer went into service under the supervision of Steve Furber.
    [Show full text]
  • Systems Architecture of the Ferranti Mark I and Mark I* Computers
    Version 1, August 2011. CCS-F1X2 Systems Architecture of the Ferranti Mark I and Mark I* computers. Contents. 1. Historical development. 2. The early Manchester University computers, 1948 – 1949. 3. Overview of the Ferranti Mark I. 4. Summary of the main differences between the Ferranti Mark I and the Mark I*. 1. Historical development. These Ferranti machines were the fully-engineered production versions of prototype computers designed and built at the University of Manchester. The first of the prototypes was called the Small Scale Experimental Machine (SSEM), also known as the Baby. The SSEM first ran a program on the morning of Monday 21st June 1948, thereby being the world‟s first electronic stored-program computer to become operational. The SSEM was a minimal computer, primarily intended to test a novel storage system that had been developed by F C Williams and T Kilburn, first at the Telecommunications Research Establishment and then, from January 1947 at the Electro-technical Department of the University of Manchester where Professor Freddie Williams moved to become head of Department. Tom Kilburn was seconded to Manchester, to help with the storage research. The novel storage system, later to be called the Williams-Kilburn tube, depended upon regenerating a pattern of electrostatically- charged spots on the inner surface of a cathode ray tube. The system is thus sometimes called CRT storage, or electrostatic storage. Each charged spot represented a binary one or zero. Two varieties of spots were tried: dot-dash, and focus-defocus, the latter being used on the Ferranti computers. The system was patented and eventually used under licence on several early computers, including the IBM 701 and 702.
    [Show full text]
  • Università Degli Studi Di Padova Padua Research Archive
    Università degli Studi di Padova Padua Research Archive - Institutional Repository Seventy Years of Getting Transistorized Original Citation: Availability: This version is available at: 11577/3257397 since: 2018-02-15T16:02:20Z Publisher: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc. Published version: DOI: 10.1109/MIE.2017.2757775 Terms of use: Open Access This article is made available under terms and conditions applicable to Open Access Guidelines, as described at http://www.unipd.it/download/file/fid/55401 (Italian only) (Article begins on next page) Historical by Massimo Guarnieri Seventy Years of Getting Transistorized Massimo Guarnieri acuum tubes appeared at the germanium. His device resembled the War II. Ohl, an American researcher break of the 20th century, giv- previous work of Julius Edgar Lilienfeld at Bell Labs, had invented the doping Ving birth to electronics [1]. By the (1882–1963) and Russell Shoemaker technique and produced the first p–n 1930s, they had become established as a Ohl (1898–1987) [5]. Lilienfeld was a junction in 1939. The patent applica- mature technology, spreading into areas German physicist who had migrated to tion for the transistor was submitted such as radio communications, long- the United States in 1921, where he had in June 1948. Although Shockley led distance radiotelegraphy, radio broad- patented a field-effect-transistor-like the team of Bardeen and Brattain at the casting, telephone communication and device in 1925. However, he had been Solid-State Physics Group, they devel- switching, sound recording and play- unable to make a working prototype be- oped their two devices independently ing, television, radar, and air navigation cause of a lack of sufficiently pure crys- because of the strong antagonism be- [2].
    [Show full text]
  • Lean, Tom. "Electronic Brains." Electronic Dreams: How 1980S Britain Learned to Love the Computer. London: Bloomsbury Sigma, 2016
    Lean, Tom. "Electronic Brains." Electronic Dreams: How 1980s Britain Learned to Love the Computer. London: Bloomsbury Sigma, 2016. 9–33. Bloomsbury Collections. Web. 28 Sep. 2021. <http://dx.doi.org/10.5040/9781472936653.0004>. Downloaded from Bloomsbury Collections, www.bloomsburycollections.com, 28 September 2021, 05:11 UTC. Copyright © Tom Lean 2016. You may share this work for non-commercial purposes only, provided you give attribution to the copyright holder and the publisher, and provide a link to the Creative Commons licence. CHAPTER ONE Electronic Brains n June 1948, in a drab laboratory in the Gothic surroundings Iof the Victoria University of Manchester, a small team of electronics engineers observed the success of an experiment they had been working on for months. The object of their interest was an untidy mass of electronics that fi lled the tall, bookcase-like racks lining the walls of the room. At the centre of this bird ’ s nest of cables, radio valves and other components glowed a small, round display screen that allowed a glimpse into the machine ’ s electronic memory, a novel device sitting off to one side hidden in a metal box. This hotchpotch assembly of electronic bits and bobs was offi cially known as the Small- Scale Experimental Machine (SSEM), but has become better known as the ‘ Manchester Baby ’ . It was the world ’ s fi rst electronic stored program computer, a computer that used an electronic memory to store data and the program that instructed it what to do, the basic architecture still used by most computers today. Baby ’ s creators, Tom Kilburn, Geoff rey Tootill and Freddy Williams, were all electronics engineers seasoned by years of work developing wartime radar systems under great secrecy and urgency.
    [Show full text]
  • TURING and the PRIMES Alan Turing's Exploits in Code Breaking, Philosophy, Artificial Intelligence and the Founda- Tions of Co
    TURING AND THE PRIMES ANDREW R. BOOKER Alan Turing's exploits in code breaking, philosophy, artificial intelligence and the founda- tions of computer science are by now well known to many. Less well known is that Turing was also interested in number theory, in particular the distribution of prime numbers and the Riemann Hypothesis. These interests culminated in two programs that he implemented on the Manchester Mark 1, the first stored-program digital computer, during its 18 months of operation in 1949{50. Turing's efforts in this area were modest,1 and one should be careful not to overstate their influence. However, one cannot help but see in these investigations the beginning of the field of computational number theory, bearing a close resemblance to active problems in the field today, despite a gap of 60 years. We can also perceive, in hind- sight, some striking connections to Turing's other areas of interests, in ways that might have seemed far fetched in his day. This chapter will attempt to explain the two problems in detail, including their early history, Turing's contributions, some of the developments since the 1950s, and speculation for the future. A bit of history Turing's plans for a computer. Soon after his involvement in the war effort ended, Turing set about plans for a general-purpose digital computer. He submitted a detailed design for the Automatic Computing Engine (ACE) to the National Physics Laboratory in early 1946. Turing's design drew on both his theoretical work \On Computable Numbers" from a decade earlier, and the practical knowledge gained during the war from working at Bletchley Park, where the Colossus machines were developed and used.
    [Show full text]
  • Tom Kilburn: a Tale of Five Computers
    Tom Kilburn: A tale of five computers One of the pre-eminent figures in the early history of computer design was Tom Kilburn. Over the course of some thirty years, he made significant contributions to the development of five important computers. Although a natural team leader possessed of a somewhat dominating personality, who inspired in those who worked closely with him great loyalty and affection, Kilburn was, on casual acquaintance, a self- contained man who chose his words with care. As F.C. Williams put it “What you must always remember is that Tom is a Yorkshireman.”1 Early Days Tom Kilburn was born on the 11th August 1921, near Dewsbury in West Yorkshire, England. His father, John William Kilburn, was a statistical clerk who rose to become a company secretary.1 Tom had a somewhat specialized education at Wheelwright Grammar School having been permitted by his headmaster to study almost nothing else from around the age of 14. It was hardly surprising therefore he emerged from school as something of a mathematical specialist. In 1940, Kilburn went up to Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge, with State, Dewsbury Major, and Minor Open Scholarships. Wartime courses at Cambridge were somewhat truncated and in 1942, Kilburn graduated with First Class Honors in Part I of the Mathematical Tripos and in the preliminary examination for Part II. During the Second World War, many Cambridge mathematics dons were absent from the university serving at Bletchley Park and elsewhere. In spite of this, there remained a lively mathematical community in which Kilburn played a full part part.
    [Show full text]
  • Was the Manchester Baby Conceived at Bletchley Park?
    Was the Manchester Baby conceived at Bletchley Park? David Anderson1 School of Computing, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, PO1 3HE, UK This paper is based on a talk given at the Turing 2004 conference held at the University of Manchester on the 5th June 2004. It is published by the British Computer Society on http://www.bcs.org/ewics. It was submitted in December 2005; final corrections were made and references added for publication in November 2007. Preamble In what follows, I look, in a very general way, at a particularly interesting half century, in the history of computation. The central purpose will be to throw light on how computing activity at the University of Manchester developed in the immediate post-war years and, in the context of this conference, to situate Alan Turing in the Manchester landscape. One of the main methodological premises on which I will depend is that the history of technology is, at heart, the history of people. No historically-sophisticated understanding of the development of the computer is possible in the absence of an appreciation of the background, motivation and aspirations of the principal actors. The life and work of Alan Turing is the central focus of this conference but, in the Manchester context, it is also important that attention be paid to F.C. Williams, T. Kilburn and M.H.A. Newman. The Origins of Computing in Pre-war Cambridge David Hilbert's talk at the Sorbonne on the morning of the 8th August 1900 in which he proposed twenty-three "future problems", effectively set the agenda for mathematics research in the 20th century.
    [Show full text]
  • Chilton Atlas Hardware at the National Museums Scotland
    Chilton Atlas hardware at the National Museums Scotland. Simon Lavington. November 2013. [email protected] Contents. Summary 2 1. Origins: Atlas in its historical context. 3 2. Atlas in the market-place. 4 3. Relative performance, then and now. 5 4. The Atlas Computer Laboratory at Chilton, Berkshire. 6 5. Technical details of the Chilton Atlas. 9 6. Physical details of equipment layout at Chilton. 10 7. The Atlas artefacts in store at the National Museums Scotland. 14 8. Condition of the units in the NMS Granton store. 19 9. The historical significance of Atlas. 21 Appendix A: Surviving Atlas hardware at other museums. 23 Appendix B: Bibliography and other sources of Atlas information 27 Acknowledgements. Several former Atlas people have helped with technical details. Particular mention should be made of Bob Hopgood, Ted Doubtfire and Yao Chen, all of whom worked on the Chilton Atlas. Picture credits to copyright holders. National Museums Scotland Figures 1(a) and 4. Museum of Science & Industry, Manchester Figure 2. STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory Figures 3, 5, 6, 7 and 8 Simon Lavington Figures 1(b), 9 to 16(a), 17(a), Table A2 Science Museum, London Figure 16(b), Table A1 D B G Edwards Figure 17 (b) Computer History Museum, California Table A3. 1 Chilton Atlas hardware at the National Museums Scotland. Summary. In 1962 the British-designed Ferranti Atlas supercomputer was, briefly, the world’s most powerful computing system. In 1973 Dr A G Thomson, Keeper of the Department of Technology at the Royal Scottish Museum, asked the Science Research Council to donate some representative sections of a redundant Atlas for preservation and eventual display.
    [Show full text]
  • The Atlas Story
    The Atlas story. Simon Lavington. Second edition, 6 th December 2012. Contents. Introduction page 1 Birth pains 1 Atlas at Manchester 1 Ferranti and the market place 5 Timeline 6 Technical innovations: facts and figures 6 The London Atlas 8 The Chilton Atlas 9 The Atlas 2 developments 11 Titan at Cambridge 13 Atlas 2 at AWRE Aldermaston 13 Atlas 2 at the CAD centre 13 More technical details of Atlas installations 15 Physical layout 17 Organisation of the Atlas storage hierarchy 17 Format of an Atlas instruction. 19 Guide to the Atlas Supervisor 20 People and places 21 More information 22 Originally produced for the Atlas Symposium held on 5 th December 2012 in the School of Computer Science, Kilburn Building, University of Manchester. It is a pleasure to acknowledge the help given by many former Atlas pioneers in the writing of this brochure. Comments on the text are welcomed and should be sent to Simon Lavington : [email protected] Picture credits to copyright holders. Computer Laboratory, University of Cambridge: Figure 9 Graham Penning: Figure 10 Simon Lavington: Figure 3 Iain MacCallum: Front cover Museum of Science & Industry, Manchester Figures 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory: Figures 7a, 7b, 8 (On 5 th December the original printed version of this document had a cover design based on photographs of the Atlas at Manchester University in 1963). i By the end of 1955 there were less than 16 production digital computers in use in the UK. They were of five British designs, from five different companies, and were single-user systems with practically no systems software.
    [Show full text]