Legislative Assembly Hansard 1902
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Queensland Parliamentary Debates [Hansard] Legislative Assembly THURSDAY, 4 SEPTEMBER 1902 Electronic reproduction of original hardcopy 478 Questions. [ASSEMBLY.] Elections Ads Amendment Bill. The TREASURER replied- ! have no objection to the collectron of any money owing to the Treasury. RAILWAY ADVERTISEMENTS. Mr. LESINA asked the Secretary for Rail ways- l. Vl'hat is the total value to the State of the adver tisements so far accepted since the appointment of }fr. John Ure }le~ aught as advertising manager to that department r 2. 1Vhat proportion of the total is due to contracts made with ~fessrs. Gm·don and Gotch, his late em ployers? The SECRETARY FOR RAILWAY& (Hon. J. Leahy, B"lloo) replied- ! cannot give the definite information asked for,_ seeing ther~ is no time stated and the gentleman named is out collecting now ; but I can give it up to the 30th June last, lip to that date the answer to the first question is £1,168; and to the second question~ £860 4s, 9d, HARBOcR BOARD BILL FOR CAIRNS. HoN. A. S. COvVLEY (Herbert), for. Mr. Lyons, asked the Treasurer- Is i.t the intention of the Government to introduce a Harbour Board Bill for Cairns at an early date? The TREASURER replied Yes. ELECTIONS ACTS AMENDMENT BILL. SECOND READING-RESUMPTION OF DEBATE. * Mr. BLAIR (Ipswich): I had not originally intended to speak on this Bill, but a remark made in the Cbamber that a "conspiracy of silence., seemed to prevail on a certain side determined me to offer my opinion on the measure in order that I should not afterwardE be twitted with having remained silent. Objec tion seems to have been taken that the preamble of this Bill is worded in such a way as to lead THURSDAY, 4 SEP'l'EMBER, 1902. hon. members to believe that the framer of it desired to follow in the wake of federal legisla tion. I have no desire to follow legislation that does not make for the well-being and pros The SPEAKER (Hon. Arthur Morgan, Warwick) perity of the State, but inasmuch as a preamble· took the chair at half-past 3 o'clock. is in its nature rather an explanatory than ::tn integral portion of a Bill, I think an argu ment of that kind ought not to have weight, PAPER. more especially when it simply savours of those The following paper was laid on the table : imperfections or lack of perfectne;;s in detail Return to an Order made by the House showing alluded to by the Secretary for Agriculture and the amount paid fur advertising in certain news the Home Secretary, which can be left to be papers at Charters Towers. settled in committee. A promise was made in the Governor's Speech to the effect that we should have a measure of this kind. I am glad that that promise was included, and I hope that QuESTIONS. measure will be introduced in the <'Vent of this STAl\IP DUTY ON VVAGES RECEIP'rS. being thrown out. But, although a promise of that kind was made, we are not entitled for Mr. COOPER (Mitchcll) asked the Trea that reason alone to refuse to discuss this Bill. surer·- Now, what I propose to deal with more par 1. Is it a. fact that, contr:uy to the Act, casual ticularly is the extension of the franchise hands in the employ of the Government have been to women. [The HOME SECRETARY : Includ pa:_, lug stamp duty on their wages receipts? ing blackfellows.] Probably the hon. gentleman 2. U so, have steps been taken to refund the amount paid, and to prevent further charges in this way? is speaking for himself. [The HoniE SECRE· TARY: No, for the Bill.] That is a matter The TREASURER (Hon. T. B. Cribb, of detail which can be amended in com Ipswich) replied- mittee. It may be a question whether women should embark in the maelstrom of politics. It ! am not aware of any stamp dut:y having been collected from men in the employ of the Government has been Fair! by Bryce, in his admirable book on contrary to the Act, the American Commonwealth, that a measure of this kind, extending the franchise to women, deadens and roughens the innate sweetness of NIONEY OWING TO 'l'HE TREASURY. their lives which go to make us respect them. Mr. LESIN A ( Clcrmont) asked the Treasurer Although it may have a tendency to unsex them What objection has he to the collection of a certain and encroach on the privileges of men in the sum of money owing to the Treasury by an Assyrian sphere of politics, surely when we consider the named Lahood 1-' work they d0 in our hospitals, our infirmaries, Elections Acts [4 SEPTEMBER.] Amendment Bill. ourshopo, and so on, it i.,atleast debatable whether that they are entitled to a voice in the affairs of they should not have extended to them, as a matter the country. vVe know that in the efforts of the of right, the privilege of having a voice in making States to get abreast of the time.•, endeavours the laws by which they are governed. It was have been made to pass legislation of this kind. once aeserted that a measure of this kind had a Victoria endeavoured fonr times to do so-in tendency to lower women in social position. I 1898 189jl, 1900, and 1901-and each time combat that statement. I think it has the it was blocked by the Legisbtive Council. effect of elevating them, by giving them a Ta";mania made a similar endeavour, and it was privilege which undoubtedly should be theirs, blocked by the Legisl>ttive Council; but in New and also that it will have a tendency towatds ~ealand we find that it passed. Adult suffrage elevating, ennobling, and purifying political life. exists there. It was passed in 18[)3. In South One objection has been that it vitally affects the Australia it was passed in 1S!J4, and in \V estern position of relative representation. That is Australia in 1899, and I think it has passed in undoubtedly a serious objection, but after look New South \Vales. Queen"bnd has a popnla ing into it carefully I conclude it is one which tion of about 503,000; the adult males number really might be made to any proposed amendment 157,000, and the adult females 104,000. On the in our electoral law. It is really a matter roll there are about 105.000 men. and there are which is unavoidable in its sequence that 104,383 females without a vote. I am aware of a matter of this kind should perhaps unsettle the old quotation- the electoral system under which we live; but 'rhe .best of all we do and are. surely that in itself-especiaily when in com Just God forgive. · mittee it c:m be ajusted-is no reason why a measure of this kind should not pass. Further, But many of us are not ashamed to stand up and a more vital point seems to be the difference m say that the best of what we do and are i.< very ofcen type bet we en men and women, which is a social due to the influence of women. Their intinence distinction differing from the powers of man goes largely to sweeten, ennoble, and purify the which are more variative; but even that is not sum total of that inexplicable thing called "life;'' a consideration which should preclude us from and I think history pomts the finger of reproach giving them a share in political representation. at us that we have lived to such a date without It is a matter which deserves the gre ttest con giving them political emaricipation. [Honour sideration; but where the franchise has been able members: Hear, htar !] granted in municipal matters to women we have The SECRETARY FOE RAILWAYS: The been shown that the ill-effects have not been such question before the House is one wh;ch we have as to jmtify us in refusing to consider the exten bad brought up in the same al stract manner on sion of that franchise to parliamentary elections. former occasions. The osten,ible purpose of this Further, it seems, according to the rppouents Bill, as laid down by the hon. member who intro of this measure, that granting or conceding such a duced it, is to extend the franchise. The term privilege as the franchise will injuriously modify "extension of the franchise" is som8what rela.ti ve, the relations of life. It is said that woman's and we should be go;·erned to a large extent in sphere is the home; that there she has ample considering this matter by what has been d,me in opportunity for ex:ercising a beneficent influence. other places. The hon. member, as far as I know, That may be true. She may possibly in that did not give any instances of what they do in other sphere of life soften the asperities of her bus places, but we have had some figures from the band, if he has asperities, and ennoble and guide h'Jn. member for Bowen and other h<•ll. mem the ambitions of her children. Undoubtedly bers, which were gro~t-ly inaccurate; and it is that is a splendid work for women; bnt surely, if rnainly for the purpost> of ..;etting theHe figures right we look at it in the converse view, she has also thati rise to speak, The hou. member for Ipswich the power of softening the asperities and guiding delivered Ml excellent sp• ech on the desirableness the ambitions of legislators or ameliorating the of 0xtending the franchise to women ; but I conditions of humanity were she given a voice thought that was a foregone conclusion.