Assessing Cumulative Impa Wide-Ranging Species Acro Peace
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Assessing Cumulative Impacts to Wide -Ranging Species Across the Peace Break Region of Northeastern British Columbia Prepared by: Clayton Apps, PhD, RPBio Aspen Wildlife Research Inc. For and in collaboration with: FINAL REPORT Version 3.0 June 2013 This report is formatted for double-sided printing PREFACE This report was prepared under the auspices of the Yellowstone to Yukon Conservation Initiative (Y2Y). The impetus for the assessment herein was concern regarding contribution of the Site-C dam and hydro-electric development on the Peace River toward adverse regional cumulative effects. Because the underlying mandate of Y2Y pertains to advocacy for ecological connectivity from local to continental scales, my focus in this assessment has been on wide-ranging species potentially sensitive to broad-scale population fragmentation. For these species, assessing cumulative impacts specific to any one development must be considered in the context of regional populations and underlying habitat conditions and influential human activities. Hence, it is in the context of regional- scale assessment that this report considers the impacts of the Site-C development and its constraints to future conservation opportunities. While this report may be submitted by Y2Y for consideration in the environmental assessment process for the Site-C development, it is also intended to inform regional conservation planning through a wider audience that includes resource managers, resource stakeholders, private land stewards, environmental advocates, the general public, and other researchers. Recommended Citation: Apps, C. 2013. Assessing cumulative impacts to wide-ranging species across the Peace Break region of northeastern British Columbia. Version 3.0 Yellowstone to Yukon Conservation Initiative, Canmore Alberta. The author may be contacted at: [email protected] Cumulative Impacts to Wide-Ranging Species across the Peace Break Region • C. Apps • 2013 i TABLE OF CONTENTS ACRONYMS & ABBREVIATIONS USED .................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .......................................................................................................... v SUMMARY .............................................................................................................................. vi 1. BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 1 PEACE BREAK ASSESSMENT AREAS ............................................................................................. 2 Biophysical Description ................................................................................................................... 2 Human Use - Historic, Present, and Future Trend ......................................................................... 8 The Proposed Site C Hydro-Electric Dam and Impoundment ...................................................... 10 CUMULATIVE EFFECTS & CONNECTIVITY ................................................................................... 12 The Concept of Cumulative Effects .............................................................................................. 12 Importance of Regional Context ................................................................................................... 13 The Issue of Connectivity ............................................................................................................. 13 2. FOCAL SPECIES PROFILES & REVIEW ...................................................................... 16 FOCAL SPECIES SELECTION ......................................................................................................... 16 SPECIES PROFILES ......................................................................................................................... 17 Grizzly Bear .................................................................................................................................. 17 Caribou ......................................................................................................................................... 23 Fisher ............................................................................................................................................ 28 Wolverine ...................................................................................................................................... 30 Gray Wolf ...................................................................................................................................... 33 Lynx .............................................................................................................................................. 36 Fish Species ................................................................................................................................. 39 3. EVALUATING LANDSCAPE EFFECTIVENESS & CONNECTIVITY FOR FOCAL SPECIES IN THE CONTEXT OF CUMULATIVE EFFECTS ............................................... 44 INTENT & APPROACH ..................................................................................................................... 44 SPATIAL HABITAT & HUMAN-USE DATABASES ........................................................................... 44 ASSESSING CUMULATIVE HUMAN IMPACTS ............................................................................... 46 Modeling Landscape Potential for Focal Species......................................................................... 46 Modeling Human Influence ........................................................................................................... 49 Cumulative Impacts to Landscape Effectiveness and Connectivity for Focal Species ................ 52 RESULTS & DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................ 54 Comparison Among Scenarios & Differences Among Species .................................................... 54 Relevance of Hydro-Electric Impoundments ................................................................................ 68 4. CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................... 70 REFERENCES .................................................................................................................... 73 LITERATURE CITED ......................................................................................................................... 74 PERSONAL COMMUNICATIONS ..................................................................................................... 84 APPENDICES ..................................................................................................................... 85 Cumulative Impacts to Wide-Ranging Species across the Peace Break Region • C. Apps • 2013 ii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. The Peace River Break priority area of northeastern BC within the Y2Y ecoregion. ............. 3 Figure 2. The "Peace Break" region of northeastern BC and both the regional and local areas defined for evaluating the cumulative impact of human activity on select wide-ranging focal species.. ...... 4 Figure 3. Broad physiographic and climatic zones defining the "Peace Break" region of northeastern British Columbia and the regional and local assessment areas addressed herein. ........................ 7 Figure 4. Human population growth projections within the Peace River Regional District. ................... 9 Figure 5. Location of existing hydro-electric projects along the upper Peace River, and the proposed Site C dam and reservoir. .............................................................................................................. 11 Figure 6. Computer generated rendering of the proposed Site C dam and lower portion of the impoundment of the Peace River (www.bchydro.com). ................................................................. 11 Figure 7. A framework for modeling the cumulative effects of human activity on grizzly bears ........... 20 Figure 8. Defined grizzly bear population units, and associated status, across British Columbia ....... 21 Figure 9. Distribution of woodland caribou of the northern ecotype addressed by the Central Rockies Recovery Implementation Group (RIG) (from RICBC 2012).......................................................... 27 Figure 10. Herds and distribution of woodland caribou of the northern ecotype addressed by the North-Central Recovery Implementation Group (RIG) (from RICBC 2012). .................................. 27 Figure 11. Index of human population access/remoteness across the regional assessment area. .... 51 Figure 12. Index of human population access/remoteness across the Peace Break assessment area, projected to year 2036 given expected growth .............................................................................. 52 Figure 13. Theoretical coefficient curves of cumulative impact to each focal species as indicated by the human accessibility/remoteness index. ................................................................................... 53 Figure 14. Change in landscape effectiveness among wide-ranging focal species given current and projected-future year 2036 scenarios. Results pertain to the REGIONAL assessment area. ...... 58 Figure 15. Change in landscape effectiveness