Are Patients with Psoriasis Susceptible to the Classic Risk Factors for Actinic Keratoses?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STUDY Are Patients With Psoriasis Susceptible to the Classic Risk Factors for Actinic Keratoses? Ora Paltiel, MDCM, MSc; Bella Adler, MPH; Klilah Herschko, MD; Boris Tsukrov, MD; Michael David, MD Background: Anincreasedprevalenceofbenignsolardam- skin, hair, and eye color and propensity or history of sun- age (eg, facial wrinkles) but not neoplastic lesions was ob- burn adjusted for age, ethnicity, and sun exposure. served among patients with psoriasis who were exposed to Dead Sea climatotherapy compared with controls. Results: Actinic keratoses were observed in 200 con- trols (27%) and 51 subjects (11%) (PϽ.001). This in- Objectives: To compare the prevalence of actinic kera- creased prevalence occurred in both sexes, participants tosis in psoriatic patients and controls and to assess whether aged 35 years or older, all ethnic groups, smokers, and known risk factors behave similarly in both groups. nonsmokers. The anatomical distribution of lesions did not substantially differ between subjects and controls. In Design: Multicenter cross-sectional study. multivariate analysis, psoriasis conferred a protective effect (odds ratio, Ͻ1), as did dark skin, dark eyes, and a his- Setting: Dermatology clinics in 4 participating Israeli tory of severe sunburn in childhood. However, signifi- hospitals and at a Dead Sea clinic. cant interactions were observed between psoriasis and hair color as well as psoriasis and propensity to sun- Participants: Adult subjects (n=460) with plaque- burn, whereby a linear association was observed for con- type psoriasis were recruited from the Israel Psoriasis As- trols but not for patients with psoriasis. sociation (volunteer sample) and from dermatology clin- ics (convenience sample). The control group (n=738) Conclusions: Psoriasis confers protection against ac- consisted of nonimmunosuppressed patients attending tinic keratosis. Hair color and propensity to sunburn these clinics for benign conditions unrelated to sun ex- exert differential effects among psoriatic patients and posure, such as atopic or contact dermatitis. controls. Main Outcome Measures: Prevalence and distribu- tion of actinic keratoses and odds ratios associated with Arch Dermatol. 2004;140:805-810 HERE IS A CONSENSUS AMONG melanoma skin cancer (NMSC) (espe- the scientific community cially SCC) has been reported in that the 3 major types of individuals with psoriasis who are ex- skin cancer—squamous cell posed to high cumulative doses of psor- carcinoma (SCC), basal cell alen–UV-A.8-11 In one study, climato- From the School of Public Health (Dr Paltiel and Ms carcinoma (BCC), and malignant mela- therapy at the Dead Sea among Danish T 1,2 Adler) and the Department noma—are caused by sun exposure. Fur- of Hematology (Dr Paltiel), thermore, inherited characteristics, such as For editorial comment Hadassah-Hebrew University skin type and propensity to sunburn, may Medical Center, Jerusalem, have a marked effect on the risk of skin can- see page 873 Israel; and the Departments cer.3 It is not known whether the presence of Dermatology, of other dermatologic conditions modi- patients was found to be associated with Hadassah-Hebrew University fies the association between sun expo- an increased risk of NMSC.12 The study re- Medical Center (Dr Herschko), sure, skin type, and actinic damage. sults, however, were possibly con- Rabin Medical Center, Petah Psoriasis is a chronic skin condition founded by the fact that patients selected Tikva, Israel (Drs Tsukrov and 4 David), and Tel-Aviv that affects approximately 2% of the popu- for Dead Sea climatotherapy were those University, Tel-Aviv, Israel lation, but with considerable ethnic and whose psoriasis was improved by sun ex- 5 (Drs Tsukrov and David). The geographic variation. Manifestations of the posure. Treatment with UV-B may also be authors have no relevant disease are often ameliorated by sun ex- associated with a mild increase (2% per financial interest in this article. posure.6,7 An increased incidence of non- year) of NMSC.13 High-dose psoralen– (REPRINTED) ARCH DERMATOL / VOL 140, JULY 2004 WWW.ARCHDERMATOL.COM 805 ©2004 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/30/2021 demographic characteristics, sun exposure, propensity to sun- Table 1. Prevalence of Actinic Keratoses Among Patients burn, and previously diagnosed benign and malignant neo- With Psoriasis and Controls by Sociodemographic Factors plasms. A structured physical examination was performed by a qualified dermatologist who noted skin type, hair color, eye No. (%) color, and the presence and location of suspected malignant skin lesions as well as solar keratosis and other signs of pho- Patients With todamage. Controls Psoriasis (n = 738) (n = 460) P Value STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Sex M 79 (27) 28 (11) .001 We compared characteristics of subjects with psoriasis and con- F 121 (28) 23 (12) .001 trols using the 2 test for categorical variables and the Mann- Prevalence by age, y Whitney test for comparing medians of continuous variables. 20-34 8 (4) 1 (1) .45 Variables included in the analysis were group (patients with 35-49 33 (18) 8 (5) Ͻ.001 psoriasis or controls); skin type (I-IV reclassified into light or 50-59 76 (39) 15 (12) Ͻ.001 Ն60 83 (56) 27 (30) Ͻ.001 dark); eye color (black/brown or blue/green); hair color (black, Ethnic origin brown, or blonde/red); propensity to sunburn (often/always, Asia-Africa 30 (29) 7 (15) .07 sometimes, or never), and history of severe sunburn in child- Europe/America 63 (40) 14 (10) Ͻ.001 hood (yes or no). We also constructed a summary variable of Israel 106 (23) 28 (11) Ͻ.001 “fairness,” which took into account eye color, hair color, and Smoking complexion. We constructed logistic regression models for the Yes 38 (19) 10 (6) Ͻ.001 presence of solar keratosis on examination, controlling for age No 161 (30) 41 (14) Ͻ.001 (continuous variable), country of origin (Israel, Asia, North Africa, or other), yearly hours of sun exposure (recreational and occupational categorized into quartiles), and smoking his- tory (current smoker: yes or no). To these models we added UV-A therapy (1000 J/cm2) has also been reported to be psoriasis/control status and individual measures of sun sensi- associated with an increased risk of actinic keratosis.14 tivity, such as skin color, hair color, eye color, and propensity A cross-sectional study was previously performed to sunburn. The models were slightly modified in terms of the in Israel that compared actinic damage among patients covariates entered according to goodness-of-fit criteria (Hosmer- with psoriasis (87% of whom had undergone climato- Lemeshow test). therapy at the Dead Sea Solarium Clinic, Ein Bokek, Is- We then tested whether there were significant interac- tions between psoriasis/control status and these variables. We rael) and controls (individuals without psoriasis) (M.D., also tested whether solar elastosis and solar keratosis ap- B. T., B. A., et al, unpublished data, 2000). In that study, peared together in the same anatomical locations and mea- the control subjects had higher self-reported rates of pre- sured agreement using the statistic. All analyses were per- vious skin biopsies, removal of benign growth, or pre- formed using SPSS software (Version 10; SPSS Inc, Chicago, vious malignant neoplasms. There was an association be- III). For all tests of significance, a 2-sided P value of .05 was tween extent of exposure to the Dead Sea and benign considered statistically significant. photodamage, such as facial wrinkles, elastosis, solar len- tigo, and poikiloderma. However, solar keratosis was more RESULTS prevalent among controls than among patients with pso- riasis and showed no association with days of exposure at the Dead Sea. This surprising finding prompted a de- UNIVARIATE ANALYSIS tailed analysis of factors associated with the presence of solar keratoses, with a comparison of persons with and The study population consisted of 460 subjects with pso- without psoriasis. riasis and 738 controls (N=1198). Patients with psoria- sis were more likely to be current smokers (34% vs 27%), male (57% vs 40%), and of European origin (31% vs 22%) METHODS than the controls. Of the patients with psoriasis, 49 (12%) had received psoralen–UV-A therapy and 109 (26%) had STUDY POPULATION been treated with UV-B. Very few malignant neoplasms Subjects were patients with plaque-type psoriasis aged 20 to were noted on examination. Six cases of BCC and 3 of 70 years with a disease duration of at least 7 years. They were SCC were suspected among the patients with psoriasis, recruited from among members of the Israel Psoriasis Associa- whereas among the controls the corresponding num- tion at a Dead Sea psoriasis clinic or attended dermatology clin- bers were 11 and 3. Only 5 cases (2 SCCs [1 each among ics at 1 of the 4 participating hospitals. Controls were patients patients with psoriasis and controls] and 3 BCCs [1 among aged 20 to 70 years who were attending dermatology clinics patients with psoriasis and 2 among controls]) were con- for benign skin conditions, eg, contact dermatitis and atopic firmed histologically. Solar keratoses were present among dermatitis. Patients with vitiligo, immunosuppression, auto- 200 controls (27%) and 51 patients with psoriasis (11%) immunity, or suspected malignancy as the reason for the clinic (P=.001). In both psoriatic patients and controls, the visit were excluded as controls. We also excluded controls with skin types V or VI. prevalence of solar keratosis increased with age. At all All participants provided signed informed consent, and the ages, in both sexes, and in all ethnic groups, the preva- study protocol was approved by the institutional review boards lence of solar keratosis was higher among controls than of all participating hospitals. A questionnaire was adminis- among psoriatic patients (Table 1). Among the con- tered to subjects and controls and included items concerning trols, European-American origin was more common in (REPRINTED) ARCH DERMATOL / VOL 140, JULY 2004 WWW.ARCHDERMATOL.COM 806 ©2004 American Medical Association.