Mediatique Report

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Mediatique Report Examining trends in editorial standards in coverage of transgender issues IPSO November 2020 Mediatique Limited 65 Chandos Place London WC2N 4HG UNITED KINGDOM www.mediatique.co.uk 2 Contents A. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ....................................................................................................................................... 7 1. INTRODUCTION AND PROJECT OBJECTIVES ....................................................................................................................... 7 2. QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS OF COVERAGE ......................................................................................................................... 8 3. QUALITATIVE CASE STUDY ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................................ 11 a. Coverage types .............................................................................................................................................. 12 b. Our analysis of the articles ............................................................................................................................ 12 c. Terminology ................................................................................................................................................... 14 d. Accuracy (rights and legislation).................................................................................................................... 14 e. Accuracy (statistics) ....................................................................................................................................... 14 f. Pronouns ........................................................................................................................................................ 15 4. DRIVERS OF CHANGE ................................................................................................................................................ 15 B. BACKGROUND MATERIALS ...............................................................................................................................19 1. A NOTE ON LANGUAGE ............................................................................................................................................. 19 2. DEFINITIONS AND SUMMARY OF ISSUES ........................................................................................................................ 19 3. THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK ........................................................................................................................................... 20 4. THE EDITORS’ CODE OF PRACTICE (THE ‘CODE’) ............................................................................................................ 21 5. IPSO GUIDANCE ON TRANSGENDER STORIES (THE ‘GUIDANCE’) ........................................................................................ 22 C. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................23 1. PROJECT BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................................. 23 2. MEDIATIQUE’S APPROACH......................................................................................................................................... 24 a. Quantitative analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 25 b. Manual textual case study analysis ............................................................................................................... 26 c. Interviews ...................................................................................................................................................... 27 d. Secondary research ........................................................................................................................................ 28 e. Notes on methodology .................................................................................................................................. 28 3. REPORT STRUCTURE ................................................................................................................................................. 28 D. TIMELINE OF TRANSGENDER-RELATED EVENTS ................................................................................................29 1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................................... 29 2. TIMELINE OF KEY EVENTS ........................................................................................................................................... 30 E. AGGREGATE ANALYSIS OF COVERAGE OF TRANSGENDER-RELATED STORIES ...................................................37 1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................................... 37 2. COVERAGE VOLUME AND SOURCES.............................................................................................................................. 37 a. The growth of transgender-related stories .................................................................................................... 37 b. The importance of celebrities ........................................................................................................................ 38 c. The emergence of more serious issues .......................................................................................................... 40 d. Engagement in transgender-related issues by the non-broadsheets ............................................................ 41 3. LANGUAGE AND TERMINOLOGY .................................................................................................................................. 42 a. A shift in terminology ..................................................................................................................................... 42 b. Gender identity .............................................................................................................................................. 43 c. Use of terms considered offensive ................................................................................................................. 43 d. ‘Transsexual’ or ‘transgender’ ....................................................................................................................... 44 e. The emergence of ‘non-binary’ ...................................................................................................................... 45 f. Gender reassignment versus sex change ....................................................................................................... 46 g. Gender being assigned at birth versus born male/ female ............................................................................ 46 h. Pre-op / post-op ............................................................................................................................................. 47 i. Male- or female-bodied ................................................................................................................................. 48 j. The trans lobby .............................................................................................................................................. 49 k. The perspective of the transgender community ............................................................................................ 50 l. The perspective of editors .............................................................................................................................. 50 4. CONCLUSIONS ......................................................................................................................................................... 51 F. MANUAL ANALYSIS OF EDITORIAL STANDARDS IN COVERAGE .........................................................................53 1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................................... 53 a. Editorial standards parameters ..................................................................................................................... 53 3 b. Selection of case studies ................................................................................................................................ 53 c. Approach to manual analysis ........................................................................................................................ 54 d. Section structure ............................................................................................................................................ 54 2. COVERAGE TYPES / PHASES ........................................................................................................................................ 54 a. Type I: transgender status as anomaly .......................................................................................................... 54 b. Type II: human interest .................................................................................................................................. 55 c. Type III: policy, rights and children ...............................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • The Flourishing of Transgender Studies
    BOOK REVIEW The Flourishing of Transgender Studies REGINA KUNZEL Transfeminist Perspectives in and beyond Transgender and Gender Studies Edited by A. Finn Enke Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2012. 260 pp. ‘‘Transgender France’’ Edited by Todd W. Reeser Special issue, L’Espirit Createur 53, no. 1 (2013). 172 pp. ‘‘Race and Transgender’’ Edited by Matt Richardson and Leisa Meyer Special issue, Feminist Studies 37, no. 2 (2011). 147 pp. The Transgender Studies Reader 2 Edited by Susan Stryker and Aren Z. Aizura New York: Routledge, 2013. 694 pp. For the past decade or so, ‘‘emergent’’ has often appeared alongside ‘‘transgender studies’’ to describe a growing scholarly field. As of 2014, transgender studies can boast several conferences, a number of edited collections and thematic journal issues, courses in some college curricula, and—with this inaugural issue of TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly—an academic journal with a premier university press. But while the scholarly trope of emergence conjures the cutting edge, it can also be an infantilizing temporality that communicates (and con- tributes to) perpetual marginalization. An emergent field is always on the verge of becoming, but it may never arrive. The recent publication of several new edited collections and special issues of journals dedicated to transgender studies makes manifest the arrival of a vibrant, TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly * Volume 1, Numbers 1–2 * May 2014 285 DOI 10.1215/23289252-2399461 ª 2014 Duke University Press Downloaded from http://read.dukeupress.edu/tsq/article-pdf/1/1-2/285/485795/285.pdf by guest on 02 October 2021 286 TSQ * Transgender Studies Quarterly diverse, and flourishing interdisciplinary field.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Rights, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in the Commonwealth
    Human Rights, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in The Commonwealth Struggles for Decriminalisation and Change Edited by Corinne Lennox and Matthew Waites Human Rights, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in The Commonwealth: Struggles for Decriminalisation and Change Edited by Corinne Lennox and Matthew Waites © Human Rights Consortium, Institute of Commonwealth Studies, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 2013 This book is published under a Creative Commons Attribution- NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NCND 4.0) license. More information regarding CC licenses is available at https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/ Available to download free at http://www.humanities-digital-library.org ISBN 978-1-912250-13-4 (2018 PDF edition) DOI 10.14296/518.9781912250134 Institute of Commonwealth Studies School of Advanced Study University of London Senate House Malet Street London WC1E 7HU Cover image: Activists at Pride in Entebbe, Uganda, August 2012. Photo © D. David Robinson 2013. Photo originally published in The Advocate (8 August 2012) with approval of Sexual Minorities Uganda (SMUG) and Freedom and Roam Uganda (FARUG). Approval renewed here from SMUG and FARUG, and PRIDE founder Kasha Jacqueline Nabagesera. Published with direct informed consent of the main pictured activist. Contents Abbreviations vii Contributors xi 1 Human rights, sexual orientation and gender identity in the Commonwealth: from history and law to developing activism and transnational dialogues 1 Corinne Lennox and Matthew Waites 2
    [Show full text]
  • Transgender Representation on American Narrative Television from 2004-2014
    TRANSJACKING TELEVISION: TRANSGENDER REPRESENTATION ON AMERICAN NARRATIVE TELEVISION FROM 2004-2014 A Dissertation Submitted to the Temple University Graduate Board In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY by Kelly K. Ryan May 2021 Examining Committee Members: Jan Fernback, Advisory Chair, Media and Communication Nancy Morris, Media and Communication Fabienne Darling-Wolf, Media and Communication Ron Becker, External Member, Miami University ABSTRACT This study considers the case of representation of transgender people and issues on American fictional television from 2004 to 2014, a period which represents a steady surge in transgender television characters relative to what came before, and prefigures a more recent burgeoning of transgender characters since 2014. The study thus positions the period of analysis as an historical period in the changing representation of transgender characters. A discourse analysis is employed that not only assesses the way that transgender characters have been represented, but contextualizes American fictional television depictions of transgender people within the broader sociopolitical landscape in which those depictions have emerged and which they likely inform. Television representations and the social milieu in which they are situated are considered as parallel, mutually informing discourses, including the ways in which those representations have been engaged discursively through reviews, news coverage and, in some cases, blogs. ii To Desmond, Oonagh and Eamonn For everything. And to my mother, Elaine Keisling, Who would have read the whole thing. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Throughout the research and writing of this dissertation, I have received a great deal of support and assistance, and therefore offer many thanks. To my Dissertation Chair, Jan Fernback, whose feedback on my writing and continued support and encouragement were invaluable to the completion of this project.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Annual Report 2015
    Annual Report 2015 We support those who feel wronged by the press, upholding the highest professional standards and providing redress where they have been breached. ipso annual report 2015 1 Contents 2 Our Vision, Mission, and Values 3 Statement from the Chairman 6 Statement from theChief Executive 8 IPSO Board 10 IPSO Complaints Committee 12 IPSO’s work: September 2014 to December 2015 15 IPSO’s complaints process and case studies 20 How does IPSO work? 22 IPSO’s complaints statistics 2015 23 List of regulated publishers and complaints 25 Financial information 26 Looking forward ipso annual report 2015 2 Our Vision A trusted, thriving, free and responsible press, reinforced by independent, effective regulation. Our Mission To support those who feel wronged by the press. To uphold the highest professional standards in the UK press. To determine whether standards have been breached and provide redress if so. Our Values Independent: IPSO will carry out its work free from control or interference by the press, parliament, interest groups or individuals. Bold: IPSO will act without fear or favour. Fair: IPSO will reach judgements according to its rules based on the evidence it has gathered and its actions and sanctions will be proportionate. Accessible: IPSO will make it as easy as possible to access its services and to engage with it. Transparent: IPSO’s work will be in the public domain, ensuring its actions and processes are clear and visible, while fulfiling any duty of confidentiality. ipso annual report 2015 3 Statement from the Chairman Rt Hon Sir Alan Moses, Chairman I was appointed Chairman in the spring of 2014.
    [Show full text]
  • Adjudication of Ofcom Content Sanctions Committee
    Ofcom Content Sanctions Committee Consideration of sanction against Channel Four Television Corporation in respect of its service Channel 4. 1 For Breaches of the Ofcom Broadcasting Code: • Rule 2.3 – Broadcasters must when applying generally accepted standards ensure that material which may cause offence is justified by the context; and • Rule 1.3 – Children must also be protected by appropriate scheduling from unsuitable material. On 15, 17, 18, 19 January 2007 Decision To direct Channel Four (and S4C) to broadcast a statement of Ofcom’s findings in a form determined by Ofcom immediately before the start of the broadcast of the first programme of the eighth series of Big Brother on Channel 4; immediately before the start of the broadcast of the first re- versioned programme of the eighth series of Big Brother on Channel 4; and immediately before the start of the broadcast of the programme in which the first eviction from the eighth series of Big Brother occurs on Channel 4. 1 This sanction also applies to Sianel Pedwar Cymru (“S4C”) which transmits Channel 4’s (Celebrity) Big Brother series on its service. 1 Contents Section Page 1 Summary 3 2 Background 6 3 Legal Framework 8 4 Issues raised with Channel Four and Channel Four’s Response 12 5 Ofcom’s Adjudication: Introduction 36 6 Not In Breach 42 7 Resolved 55 8 In Breach 57 9 Sanctions Decision 66 2 1 Summary 1.1 On the basis detailed in the Decision, under powers delegated from the Ofcom Board to Ofcom’s Content Sanctions Committee (“the Committee”), the Committee has decided to impose a statutory sanction on Channel Four (and S4C) in light of the serious nature of the failure by Channel Four to ensure compliance with Ofcom’s Broadcasting Code.
    [Show full text]
  • Code De Conduite Pour Le Water Polo
    HistoFINA SWIMMING MEDALLISTS AND STATISTICS AT OLYMPIC GAMES Last updated in November, 2016 (After the Rio 2016 Olympic Games) Fédération Internationale de Natation Ch. De Bellevue 24a/24b – 1005 Lausanne – Switzerland TEL: (41-21) 310 47 10 – FAX: (41-21) 312 66 10 – E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.fina.org Copyright FINA, Lausanne 2013 In memory of Jean-Louis Meuret CONTENTS OLYMPIC GAMES Swimming – 1896-2012 Introduction 3 Olympic Games dates, sites, number of victories by National Federations (NF) and on the podiums 4 1896 – 2016 – From Athens to Rio 6 Olympic Gold Medals & Olympic Champions by Country 21 MEN’S EVENTS – Podiums and statistics 22 WOMEN’S EVENTS – Podiums and statistics 82 FINA Members and Country Codes 136 2 Introduction In the following study you will find the statistics of the swimming events at the Olympic Games held since 1896 (under the umbrella of FINA since 1912) as well as the podiums and number of medals obtained by National Federation. You will also find the standings of the first three places in all events for men and women at the Olympic Games followed by several classifications which are listed either by the number of titles or medals by swimmer or National Federation. It should be noted that these standings only have an historical aim but no sport signification because the comparison between the achievements of swimmers of different generations is always unfair for several reasons: 1. The period of time. The Olympic Games were not organised in 1916, 1940 and 1944 2. The evolution of the programme.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tavistock's Experimentation with Puberty Blockers
    A collection of articles by Dr. Susan Matthews THE CURIOUS WORLD OF GENDER MEDICINE The Curious World of Gender Medicine “When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty who don't fit sex stereotypes: all the odd kids like I said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it was - all the ones who are the outsiders, the ones means just what I choose it to mean who get le� out, the ones who get bullied, the — neither more nor less.’ slightly vulnerable kids, the ones with mental health issues that…You know I really feel like I get those ’The ques�on is,’ said Alice, ‘whether kids.’ Like Stephanie, I wanted to find out why kids you can make words mean so many were being sent off for medical interven�ons and different things.’ why our culture had bought into this answer to distress. ’The ques�on is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — Through the Looking Glass with that’s all.” Mermaids ― Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass My first three pieces for Transgender Trend took me through the looking glass into the mythic world of The Care Quality Commission found that staff at GIDS Mermaids. (the NHS gender service for children and adolescents) were trained on incident repor�ng. But the GIDS had When ITV announced that Anna Friel was starring as an odd understanding of what cons�tutes an a lightly fic�onalised version of the Susie and Jackie ‘incident’. An audit of pa�ent records in March 2020 Green story, we knew we had to provide an examined the way that ‘capacity, competency and alterna�ve view.
    [Show full text]
  • “We Live in in a House of Blo- in a Block of Flats.” – Self-Repair
    “We live in in a house of blo- in a block of flats.” – Self-repair in EFL Spoken Language MA Thesis Department of Modern Languages English Philology University of Helsinki 29.4.2010 Anu Lonkila Contents 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 2 2 Self-repair ..................................................................................................................... 6 2.1 Self-repair as a Term ............................................................................................ 10 2.2 Fluency and Self-repair ........................................................................................ 11 2.3 Categorization According to Self-repair Types ................................................... 13 2.3.1 Levelt‟s Taxonomy ....................................................................................... 13 2.3.2 Bredart and Kormos‟ Additions to Levelt‟s Taxonomy ............................... 16 2.3.3 The Categorization Used in This Thesis ....................................................... 18 2.4 Categorization in Relation to Correctness of Self-repairs ................................... 20 3 Language Assessment and CEFR ............................................................................... 22 3.1 What Is Assessment? ........................................................................................... 22 3.2 CEFR in Language Assessment ..........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • George Floyd Protests Lead to Reckoning As Black Employees Speak out on Racism and Discrimination in the Workplace Jessica Guynn USA TODAY
    George Floyd protests lead to reckoning as Black employees speak out on racism and discrimination in the workplace Jessica Guynn USA TODAY Last week, Apple CEO Tim Cook posted a video on Twitter announcing a $100-million initiative to fight racism and break down barriers to opportunity, including inside his own company. Tanya Faison, who is Black and for five years worked in technical support at Apple, says she’s skeptical of these expressions of solidarity from corporations that for years stayed silent on systemic racism while perpetuating racial inequality by failing to hire, promote or fairly pay Black people and people of color. “It’s very nice that he’s decided to take this moment to start focusing on Black folks, when he is in a company with Black employees who are not being taken care of,” Faison said of Cook. From Silicon Valley to Wall Street, corporations from nearly every sector of the American economy have taken to social media proclaiming their support for the Black Lives Matter movement and condemning police killings as protests over the death of George Floyd still flood American streets. Seizing an opportunity to be heard, Black employees are responding on social media with painful stories of workplace racism that they say they were too fearful to discuss before. The wave of firsthand accounts and activism has led to resignations, drawing parallels to the #MeToo movement. “We need more than performative, symbolic or superficial statements. We need action,” says Aerica Shimizu Banks, one of two former Black employees who went public this week with charges of racial discrimination against social media service Pinterest.
    [Show full text]
  • Adjudication of Ofcom Content Sanctions Committee
    Ofcom Content Sanctions Committee Consideration of sanction against Channel Four Television Corporation in respect of its service Channel 4. 1 For Breaches of the Ofcom Broadcasting Code: • Rule 2.3 – Broadcasters must when applying generally accepted standards ensure that material which may cause offence is justified by the context; and • Rule 1.3 – Children must also be protected by appropriate scheduling from unsuitable material. On 15, 17, 18, 19 January 2007 Decision To direct Channel Four (and S4C) to broadcast a statement of Ofcom’s findings in a form determined by Ofcom immediately before the start of the broadcast of the first programme of the eighth series of Big Brother on Channel 4; immediately before the start of the broadcast of the first re- versioned programme of the eighth series of Big Brother on Channel 4; and immediately before the start of the broadcast of the programme in which the first eviction from the eighth series of Big Brother occurs on Channel 4. 1 This sanction also applies to Sianel Pedwar Cymru (“S4C”) which transmits Channel 4’s (Celebrity) Big Brother series on its service. 1 Contents Section Page 1 Summary 3 2 Background 6 3 Legal Framework 8 4 Issues raised with Channel Four and Channel Four’s Response 12 5 Ofcom’s Adjudication: Introduction 36 6 Not In Breach 42 7 Resolved 55 8 In Breach 57 9 Sanctions Decision 66 2 1 Summary 1.1 On the basis detailed in the Decision, under powers delegated from the Ofcom Board to Ofcom’s Content Sanctions Committee (“the Committee”), the Committee has decided to impose a statutory sanction on Channel Four (and S4C) in light of the serious nature of the failure by Channel Four to ensure compliance with Ofcom’s Broadcasting Code.
    [Show full text]
  • Short Course Records
    Licensed To: Mount Kelly HY-TEK's TEAM MANAGER 8.0 22/06/2021 Page 1 Mount Kelly Swim Squad RECORDS 2021 Short Course SC Meters-Female 9-9 50 Free 35.08 5-Sep-09 KC Victoria A. Moore at Exeter May Meet 2009 100 Free 1:22.15 11-Jun-16 MKS Alice Kinsey at Devon County Development Gala 2016 200 Free 2:46.20 14-Feb-04 KC Danielle Shrosbree at Devon County 2004 Championships 400 Free 6:08.02 18-Jul-09 KC Victoria A. Moore at Plymouth Leander Open Meet 2009 50 Back 42.16 4-Oct-14 MKS Stephanie Carpenter at City of Plymouth 2014 Meet 100 Back 1:39.89 8-Jun-19 MKS Olivia Purnell at Devon County ASA Development Gala 200 Back 3:11.91 8-Feb-09 KC Victoria A. Moore at Devon County 2009 Championships 50 Breast 49.68 15-Apr-17 MKS Louisa K. Hess at The Two Counties Spring Open Meet 2017 100 Breast 1:51.29 7-Dec-19 MKS Caoimhe Dolby at Plymouth Leander Xmas Meet 2019 200 Breast 3:43.40 3-Feb-08 KC Emily G. Ackford at Devon County 2008 Championships 50 Fly 40.67 18-Jul-09 KC Victoria A. Moore at Plymouth Leander Open Meet 2009 100 Fly 1:43.06 7-Dec-19 MKS Caoimhe Dolby at Plymouth Leander Xmas Meet 2019 200 Fly 3:30.00 18-Jul-09 KC Victoria A. Moore at Plymouth Leander Open Meet 2009 100 IM 1:28.46 14-Feb-04 KC Danielle Shrosbree at Devon County 2004 Championships 200 IM 3:12.18 18-Jul-09 KC Victoria A.
    [Show full text]
  • Gender Identity Bibliography
    Gender Identity Ideology – A Partial Bibliography of Online Coverage Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities - Voltaire What good is a gender outlaw who is still abiding by the law of gender? - Janice Raymond Section 1- Actions and Resistance (speaking out, naming, refusing to be silent: this entire bibliography is filled with examples of resistance...these are just a few) http://manfridayuk.org/blog/ started off as one woman going to her local swimming pool on “men-only” day to demand they accept her as a man on her say-so https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5780623/Female-protesters-break-men-lido-leap- pool.html https://www.telegraph.co .uk/news/2019/10/23/stonewall-splits-accused-promoting-trans- agenda-expense-gay/ https://womansplaceuk.org/2019/10/24/misogyny-in-action-a-rebuttal-of-statement-by- trans-action-oxford/ https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/jenni-murray-transgender-real- women-sunday- times-magazine-womans-hour-a7612781.html longtime BBC TV program host who speaks of her anger at trans “women” claiming to be women https://www.feministcurrent.com/2019/02/11/interview-amy-eileen-hamm-and-holly- hutton-demonstrate-regular-women-can-change-the-conversation/ https://conatusnews.com/stephanie-davies-arai-transgender-trend-john-maddox-prize/ very significant short-listing for very prestigious science award to founder of Transgender Trend https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/politics/joanna-cherry-calls-labour- candidate-apologise-sharing-terf-image-824843 https://www.holyrood.com/inside-politics/view,cofounder-of-stonewall-calls-for-
    [Show full text]