Navigating the Urban-Rural Divide: the Agency of Rural Chinese Female Higher Education Students in China
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Syracuse University SURFACE Dissertations - ALL SURFACE December 2015 Navigating the Urban-Rural Divide: The Agency of Rural Chinese Female Higher Education Students in China Lifang Wang Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://surface.syr.edu/etd Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Wang, Lifang, "Navigating the Urban-Rural Divide: The Agency of Rural Chinese Female Higher Education Students in China" (2015). Dissertations - ALL. 410. https://surface.syr.edu/etd/410 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the SURFACE at SURFACE. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations - ALL by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Abstract This dissertation explores how rural Chinese female students at urban Chinese higher education institutions conceptualize and negotiate the urban-rural divide that often interplays with gender and the discourse of quality (suzhi) to shape their lives. A substantial body of literature discusses the profound inequalities that rural Chinese people encounter due to the urban-rural divide and household registration system (Chan & Zhang, 1999; Wang & Zuo, 1999; Loong-Yu & Shan, 2007; Tang & Yang, 2008; Whyte, 2010; Han, 2010). An increasing amount of literature also addresses the experiences of rural Chinese migrant women working in urban China (Gaetano & Jacka, 2004; Jacka, 2006; Gaetano, 2004; Gaetano, 2005; Yan, 2008). However, little research has been done on rural Chinese university women. The few articles that do exist tend to blame them or their culture for their failure or struggles (Ren, 2008; Xu, 2007; Wan, 2007), or else focus on the unequal power structures that victimize them (Yu, 2006); but none of these studies incorporates the perspectives of these women. My dissertation fills the scholarly gap by focusing on the voices and perspectives of a group of rural female higher education students who talked about their experiences of negotiating multiple and intersecting power structures. Qualitative methodology and feminist methodology informed this dissertation. To collect data, I conducted open-ended, in-depth interviews with 66 rural female students (51 undergraduates and 15 graduate students) at five public universities and one public college in northern China. This research revealed the profound inequalities that these students experienced in attaining higher education, such as urban primary and secondary schools’ exclusion of rural students, overt and subtle forms of gender discrimination at home and school, regional discrimination reflected in higher education admission policies, and political control and punishment through the National Higher Education Entrance Examination. These had seldom been examined by previous studies. The students that I interviewed also encountered numerous obstacles to their integration into urban campuses; they felt marginalized from mainstream urban life because the dominant culture regarded urban life and people as superior to rural life and people. Despite all these barriers, these women did not allow themselves to be defeated; instead they became active agents by developing strategies to negotiate and resist the barriers when they could. Building upon the work of Daniel G. Solorzano and Dolores Delgano Bernal (2001) and of Tara J. Yosso (2006), I define such agency that my participants exhibited as the ability to navigate the institutional barriers and social norms that constrain their conditions of existence. Though my participants were constrained by the unequal structures of power, they were also aware of the inequalities. They responded by making decisions and devising strategies to become upwardly mobile through educational achievements. It may seem that by striving for educational success, they were merely conforming to the societal norm; but they were also in this way resisting marginalization arising from the dominant cultural capital and the discourse of quality that represents them as inferior or deficient. In response to the discourse of quality, they also exercised their agency by making meaning of their lived experiences with this discourse and/or developing counter-discourses to negotiate it. Furthermore, when they encountered different and sometimes contradictory forms of patriarchy across rural and urban contexts, they expressed their agency by shifting and reformulating their identities. NAVIGATING THE URBAN-RURAL DIVIDE: THE AGENCY OF RURAL CHINESE FEMALE HIGHER EDUCATION STUDENTS IN CHINA by Lifang Wang B.A., Hebei University, 2000 M.S., Syracuse University, 2007 Dissertation Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Cultural Foundations of Education Syracuse University December 2015 Copyright © Lifang Wang 2015 All Rights Reserved Acknowledgments I could not have completed this dissertation without the help and support of many people, including my research participants, professors, mentors, colleagues, friends, and family members. I owe them a huge debt of gratitude. My desire to show my appreciation for them is one of the most important reasons that I have been motivated to carry out this work to the best of my ability. First and foremost, I would like to thank my research participants, 66 rural female students at five universities and one college in northern China, for being willing to share their experiences with me. In order to protect their identities, I cannot list their real names. I want to express my heartfelt gratitude to them. They are the soul of this study. Without them, this dissertation would not have been possible. My deepest gratitude goes to my advisor Professor Susan S. Wadley, who took over my dissertation and provided me with strong support during the most difficult time of my academic life after my first advisor Dr. Sari K. Biklen passed away. Prof. Wadley’s strong support, insightful comments, and inspiring advice for deeper data analysis, development of richer and broader ideas, greater clarity of arguments and writing, and organization of chapters and sections were crucial for the completion of this dissertation. Prof. Wadley’s guidance and mentorship also helped me find confidence in being a scholar. I also thank my committee members Professors Barbara Applebaum and Jing Lei. Prof. Applebaum, to whom I am profoundly indebted, has been supporting and encouraging me ever since I joined the graduate program in the Department of Cultural Foundations of Education. I appreciate her continuous guidance and provocative comments to revise the dissertation. Prof. Lei gave me vi timely help and support whenever I needed them, including contacting faculty in China to help me recruit my participants. I also thank Prof. Lei for her valuable comments and constant encouragement. My gratitude also goes to my two external readers, Professors Louise C. Wilkinson and Julia Maxine White, for their careful reading, thought-provoking questions, and comments on my dissertation. Without a doubt, I am deeply appreciative of my first advisor, Dr. Sari K. Biklen, for her intellectual guidance, energetic encouragement, and unwavering support for me to tap my academic potential. Dr. Biklen was crucial in mentoring me with the development of my dissertation topic and methodology, data collection, and initial data analysis until the time of her critical illness. My sincere appreciation also goes to Professor Dalia Rodriguez for providing me with informative and insightful comments to revise my dissertation chapters and advise me with my research apprenticeship paper which is part of this dissertation. With heartfelt gratitude, I thank American Association of University Women (AAUW) for granting me the 2011-2012 International Fellowship to conduct this research in China. I am also appreciative of Gerald Paul Grant for providing positive and productive comments about my research apprenticeship paper. And, I am grateful to Ms. Maryann E. Barker who has always been there to patiently help and assist me with the administrative procedures. Special thanks go to my Graduate Assistantship supervisors, Ms. Sharon W. Alestalo and Ms. Sandy Trento, the two great women who inspired me to bravely and wisely wrestle with the challenges in life. I am also grateful to Professor Yingyi Ma for co-writing an article with me about how rural Chinese female students navigated the higher education application process in China, which inspired me to develop more specific interview questions and to vii generate ideas for the dissertation. I also thank many professors, mentors, and friends who supported and/or guided me through my doctoral journey: Dr. Feng Cao, Dr. Zhaoyang Chi, Ms. Xin Cui, Ms. Yuan Zhang Dickerson, Ms. Jianhong Dong, Dr. Charles Gao, Ms. Florence A. Di Gennaro, Ms. Mengjun Liang, Dr. Qing Liu, Dr. Kun Lu, Dr. Liangyue Lu, Prof. Chandra Mohanty, Dr. Daniel William Olson-Bang, Dr. Melissa Smith, Dr. Ashley S. Taylor, Dr. Dan Wang, Dr. He Wang, Prof. Hongying Wang, Dr. Li Wang, Mr. Quanfu Wang, Dr. Xiuli Wang, Ms. Yan Wang, Dr. Chung Wan Woo, Ms. Jianping Xu, Dr. Li Yang, Ms. Lily Yu, Ms. Lu Yu, Ms. Jing Zhang, Mr. Jingbin Zhang, Ms. Hongyan Zheng, Dr. Nanzhao Zhou, and Ms. Chunfeng Zou. I want to especially thank my writing group at Syracuse University that comprises three professors: Gesa Kirsch, Brice A. Nordquist, and Patrick W. Berry as well as doctoral fellows: Romeo Garcia, Tamara Bassam Issak, and Katie MacDonald, for reading part of my dissertation and providing constructive