The Problem of Dustphthisis in the Granite-Stone

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Problem of Dustphthisis in the Granite-Stone U. S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR JAMES J. DAVIS, Secretary BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS ETHELBERT STEWART, Commissioner BULLETIN OF THE UNITED STATES \ BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS/ •■■■ {No. 293 INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS AND HYGIENE SERIES THE PROBLEM OF DUST PHTHISIS IN THE GRANITE-STONE INDUSTRY By FREDERICK L. HOFFMAN, LL.D. / v \ ygfegf *1 U p H s j M A Y , 1922 WASHINGTON GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1922 Digitized for FRASER http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Digitized for FRASER http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis PREFACE. In continuation of previous investigations into the dust hazard of certain trades/ the present investigation was originally undertaken in behalf of a committee appointed by the National Tuberculosis Association, and while the writer was chairman two preliminary reports were published during 1918 and 1919. It was found imprac­ ticable* however, on the part of the writer to continue his work as chairman of the committee and the investigation was therefore brought to a conclusion entirely on his own responsibility, the strictly medical and radiological work of the inquiry having been assumed by Dr- Edward R. Baldwin, whose report, dated June 11, 1921, is published in Appendix G. This report did not come to my attention until after my own investigations had been completed and on account of its brevity much of the material required for a conclusive opinion is for the time being not available.2 It is to be hoped that sometime in the future the National Tubercu­ losis Association will publish in full detail the results of this investi­ gation, which represents 427 physical and X-ray examinations of stone workers in the Barre district. Of particular interest is the statement that “ expensive silicosis might exist with little or no impairment of health and no manifest physical signs,” a conclusion suggestive of the great practical value of periodical X-ray examina­ tions as a means of disclosing the earliest possible indications of lung damage. My own investigations would have been quite impossible but for the whole-hearted cooperation of the Granite Cutters’ International Association of America and the correlated experience data obtained bulletins Nos. 79, 82, and 231 of the U. S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington, D. C., 1908-1918. 2 Since this report was completed the Barre branch of the Granite Cutters’ International Association has made an agreement with the Presbrey-Leland Co. of Barre, V t., to go into effect Apr. 1,1922, and con­ tinue in force until Apr. 1, 1925. Article VI of this agreement provides as follows: S e c t io n 1. All dust-creating machines must be adequately equipped with dust-removing devices when proven practical, the practicability of such devices to be passed upon in accordance with provisions laid down in Article X X of this agreement [providing for an adjustment committee]. Sec. 2. Within one month from the signing of this agreement a body of six members, to be known as the ‘‘ health committee/’ shall be created. Of the committee three members shall be appointed by the employer and three by the local branch G. C. I. A. It shall be the duty of this committee to investigate, to assist in the development, the perfecting, and the introduction of dust-removing devices; to consider insurance against sickness and improve in every possible way general working conditions. Sec. 3. Funds for the development and experimental work of this committee shall be provided in the following manner: One-hal i o 11 per cent to be deducted weekly from the wage of each member of the local branch G. C. I. A. The employer to set aside each week an amount equal to the total sum derived from the above source. This fund shall be placed in the hands ofa treasurer elected by a majority of the health committee. Should the funds thus provided be either inadequate or more than sufficient for the desired purpose, any necessary modification may be made by mutual agreement. S e c . 4. The health committee shall make a written progress and financial report on or about Apr. 1 and Oct. 1 of each year to the employer and thel ocal branch G. C. I. A. Sec. 5. Should the members of the health committee be unable to agree, any subject in controversy shall be submitted to the adjustment committee in accordance with Article X X of this agreement. This provision is in entire accordance with the results of the present investigation suggesting similar action on the part of other firms or employers desirous of avoiding labor conflicts as the results of prevent­ able conditions affecting the health hazard in particular industries or occupations. The agreement is likewise applicable to other dusty trades subject to an excessive sickness or mortality rate. Ill Digitized for FRASER http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis IV PREFACE. through the courtesy and liberality of the Journeymen Stone Cutters’ Association and the Glass Bottle Blowers’ Association. The field investigations were made by an experienced sanitary engineer, thoroughly familiar with occupational disease problems, and I am also obliged to Mr. Sylvester Schattschneider for the results of his corresponding investigations in the limestone districts of Indiana. Every possible opportunity for investigation was extended to me by the manufacturers of the Barre and Bedford districts, who readily granted permission for a complete inspection of their plants, at the same time giving much valuable advice in the furtherance of the inquiry. I am especially indebted to the United States Bureau of Mines, and particularly to Mr. E. A. Holbrook, assistant director, and to Mr. A. C. Fieldner, supervising chemist at the Pittsburgh Experimental Station, for their invaluable cooperation in technical matters largely outside of the plan and scope of my own investiga­ tions. Preliminary results of the work of the Bureau of Mines are included under Appendix E. It is not claimed for the present in­ vestigation that it has been exhaustive or final upon many important matters, which will require further consideration. But it may be questioned whether any corresponding industry has ever before been subjected to an equally extended inquiry, not only into the medical but also into the correlated social and economic facts affecting the welfare of the employees concerned. The results are certainly extremely suggestive 01 the direction in which it will be necessary to initiate radical reforms if a material reduction in mortality and a consequential improvement in health and longevity are to be brought about through the combined action of the employer, the employee, and the State. Frederick L. Hoffman. East Orange, N. J., April 17, 1922. Digitized for FRASER http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis CONTENTS. Page. Introduction and summary............................................................................................. 1-10 Summary of conclusions.......................................................................................... 1-6 Nonrecognition of the nature of problem............................................................. 6 - 8 Results of investigation of Miners’ Phthisis Bureau of South Africa............. 8 Recommendations of British Medical Research Committee............................ 8 Investigations of Yale Medical School................................................................. 8 , 9 Investigations of United States Public Health Service.................................... 9 Unrealized promises of prevention........................................................................ 9, 1 0 Importance of occupational disease recognition................................................. 10 Scope of inquiry................................................................................................................ 10-14 Method of inquiry..................................................................................................... 11,12 Occupational diseases of the stone industry........................................................ 12 Importance of occupational segregation............................................................... 12,13 Pathology of dust inhalation................................................................................... 13,14 Previous investigations in the stone industry............................................................. 14-22 Ancient origin of the stone industry..................................................................... 14,15 Aberdeen mortality investigations........................................................................ 15-22 Age incidence in dust phthisis....................................................................... 18,19 Effect of pneumatic tools................................................................................. 19-21 Racial and social influences............................................................................ 21 Problem of family infection___ . ............................................ ...................... 21 Importance of stone dust analysis................................................................. 21, 22 Mortality among granite stone workers......................................................................... 22-59 Analyses of Vermont granites................................................................................. 22, 23 Sanitary topography of Barre district, Vermont............................................... 24 Death certificates analyzed......................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Lithics, Landscape and People: Life Beyond the Monuments in Prehistoric Guernsey
    UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON FACULTY OF HUMANITIES Department of Archaeology Lithics, Landscape and People: Life Beyond the Monuments in Prehistoric Guernsey by Donovan William Hawley Thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy April 2017 UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON ABSTRACT FACULTY OF HUMANITIES Archaeology Thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Lithics, Landscape and People: Life Beyond the Monuments in Prehistoric Guernsey Donovan William Hawley Although prehistoric megalithic monuments dominate the landscape of Guernsey, these have yielded little information concerning the Mesolithic, Neolithic and Early Bronze Age communities who inhabited the island in a broader landscape and maritime context. For this thesis it was therefore considered timely to explore the alternative material culture resource of worked flint and stone archived in the Guernsey museum. Largely ignored in previous archaeological narratives on the island or considered as unreliable data, the argument made in this thesis is for lithics being an ideal resource that, when correctly interrogated, can inform us of past people’s actions in the landscape. In order to maximise the amount of obtainable data, the lithics were subjected to a wide ranging multi-method approach encompassing all stages of the châine opératoire from material acquisition to discard, along with a consideration of the landscape context from which the material was recovered. The methodology also incorporated the extensive corpus of lithic knowledge that has been built up on the adjacent French mainland, a resource largely passed over in previous Channel Island research. By employing this approach, previously unknown patterns of human occupation and activity on the island, and the extent and temporality of maritime connectivity between Guernsey and mainland areas has been revealed.
    [Show full text]
  • Graveyard Geology
    GRAVEYARD GEOLOGY A Guide to Rocks in Graveyards and Cemeteries Wendy Kirk Department of Earth Sciences, David Cook University College London & Aldersbrook Geological Society London Geodiversity Partnership Introduction Walk around graveyards and cemeteries (in this case, those of London and the southeast of England) and it becomes apparent that, prior to the latter part of the twentieth century, many memorials were made out of just a few different rock types. These were chosen for reasons of appearance, cost, workability and ease of transport to the cemetery, as well as for resistance to weathering and dependence on local regulations. In the last few decades, a range of different, interesting and beautiful stones have appeared, many brought in from abroad, enhancing the diversity of materials used. The intention of this guide is to help a non-specialist identify the main rock types, to recognize some of the varieties and to know where some of these might have come from. Graveyards are a wonderful resource for those with an interest in geology at any level, wildlife, plants, history or sculpture. We hope you gain as much pleasure as we have done. First things first A useful place to start is to be able to distinguish between igneous, sedimentary and metamorphic rocks. Igneous rocks form from melted rock called magma. If this erupts at the surface, it is called lava. It cools and crystallizes quickly, so the grains are too small to see even with a hand lens (magnifying glass). If the lava erupt explosively to form a spray, the cooled fragments are known as volcanic ash.
    [Show full text]
  • Building Stones of the National Mall
    The Geological Society of America Field Guide 40 2015 Building stones of the National Mall Richard A. Livingston Materials Science and Engineering Department, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA Carol A. Grissom Smithsonian Museum Conservation Institute, 4210 Silver Hill Road, Suitland, Maryland 20746, USA Emily M. Aloiz John Milner Associates Preservation, 3200 Lee Highway, Arlington, Virginia 22207, USA ABSTRACT This guide accompanies a walking tour of sites where masonry was employed on or near the National Mall in Washington, D.C. It begins with an overview of the geological setting of the city and development of the Mall. Each federal monument or building on the tour is briefly described, followed by information about its exterior stonework. The focus is on masonry buildings of the Smithsonian Institution, which date from 1847 with the inception of construction for the Smithsonian Castle and continue up to completion of the National Museum of the American Indian in 2004. The building stones on the tour are representative of the development of the Ameri­ can dimension stone industry with respect to geology, quarrying techniques, and style over more than two centuries. Details are provided for locally quarried stones used for the earliest buildings in the capital, including A quia Creek sandstone (U.S. Capitol and Patent Office Building), Seneca Red sandstone (Smithsonian Castle), Cockeysville Marble (Washington Monument), and Piedmont bedrock (lockkeeper's house). Fol­ lowing improvement in the transportation system, buildings and monuments were constructed with stones from other regions, including Shelburne Marble from Ver­ mont, Salem Limestone from Indiana, Holston Limestone from Tennessee, Kasota stone from Minnesota, and a variety of granites from several states.
    [Show full text]
  • Revisions to the Nonmetallic Mineral Processing Plants (Subpart OOO) NSPS
    Economic and Small Business Analysis – Revisions to the Nonmetallic Mineral Processing Plants (Subpart OOO) NSPS EPA-452/R-09-003 April 2009 Economic and Small Business Analysis – Revisions to the Nonmetallic Mineral Processing Plants (Subpart OOO) NSPS By: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Research Triangle Park, North Carolina U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Health and Environmental Impacts Division Air Benefits and Costs Group Research Triangle Park, NC 2 SECTION 1 INTRODUCTION To meet the requirements of section 111(b)(1)(B) of the CAA, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is currently conducting the second review of the new source performance standards (NSPS) for non-metallic mineral processing plants (NMPP). The NMPP NSPS was promulgated on August 1, 1985 (40 CFR Part 60 subpart OOO, 50 FR 31328) and subsequently reviewed in 1997. Subpart OOO requires new, modified, or reconstructed affected facilities at NMPP to achieve emission levels that reflect the best demonstrated system of continuous emission reduction, considering cost, non-air quality health, environmental, and energy impacts. These emission levels, referred to as “best demonstrated technology (BDT),” are specified in subpart OOO. The purpose of this report is to provide economic and small business impact analyses for the requirements of this NSPS. We include revenue and other economic data for affected industries and businesses in the industry profile for this NSPS, and that profile is included in this report. The analysis will focus on estimating such impacts by providing annualized cost as a percent of sales or revenues for firms in industries likely to be affected by this NSPS.
    [Show full text]
  • Dimension Stone Feasibility Study
    DIMENSION STONE FEASIBILITY STUDY: DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL IN MICHIGAN'S UPPER PENINSULA H. James Bourque and Associates 402 Ashmun Street, P.O. Box 292 Sault Ste. Marie, MI 49783 (906) 635-9191 July 1, 1999 Page 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgements ................................................................................................... 4 Project Background.................................................................................................... 5 In Recent Years . ...................................................................................................... 5 Study Methods............................................................................................................ 7 Geology of the Upper Peninsula................................................................................. 7 Dimension Stone Production ...................................................................................... 8 1997 Dimension Stone Production By Types: ...........................................................9 Dimension Stone Pricing ...........................................................................................11 Sandstone ..............................................................................................................12 Granite...................................................................................................................12 Limestone ..............................................................................................................12 Stone Sites Investigated
    [Show full text]
  • BUIL])ING STON.E O·F WASHINGTON
    BUIL])ING STON.E o·f WASHINGTON By WAYNE S. MOEN Washington Department of Conservation Division of Mines and Geology Bulletin No. 55 1967 State of Washington DANIEL J. EV ANS, Governor Department of Conservation H. MAURICE AHLQUIST, Director DIVISION OF MINES AND GEOLOGY MARSHALL T. HUNTTING, Supervisor Bulletin No. 55 BUILDING STONE OF WASHINGTON By WAYNE S. MOEN STATE PRINTING PLANT. OLYMPI A , WASHINGTON 1967 For sale by Department Pof? ceConsl]SliARYervation, Olympia, Washington. PACIFIC NORTHWEST FOREST AND RANGE EXPERIMENT STATION etnDTLAND. OR£00N CONTENTS Poge Introduction 7 General history .. ...... ...........................•............ 8 Production and vo lue . 10 Forms of building stone . 12 Field stone . 12 Rough building stone . 13 Rubble . • . 14 Flogging (flagstone) . 14 Ashlar . .. ......... ........ , ................. , . , . 15 Crushed stone . 16 Terrozzo . 17 Roofing granules.............. .... ..... ......... 18 Exposed aggregate . 18 Reconstituted stone . • . 19 Landscape rock . 20 Area coverage of bui Iding stone . 21 Acquisition of bui )ding stone . 22 Examination of stone deposits . 23 General quarrying methods . 24 Physical properties of building stone . 26 Strength . 26 Hardness and workabi Iity . • . 27 Color . 28 Alteration ....•...................... , ........... , . 29 Porosity and absorption ...........•. : . 31 Testing of building stone... .. .................... ................ 33 Common building stones of Washington . 34 Granite . 35 Geology and distribution . 35 Physical properties . 38 Varieties
    [Show full text]
  • Marble Industry Role in the Socio Economic Development of Marble Industrial Owners of District Mohmand Federal Administered Tribal Area-Pakistan
    Industrial Engineering Letters www.iiste.org ISSN 2224-6096 (Paper) ISSN 2225-0581 (online) DOI: 10.7176/IEL Vol.9, No.3, 2019 Marble Industry Role in the Socio Economic Development of Marble Industrial Owners of District Mohmand Federal Administered Tribal Area-Pakistan Sajjad Ahmad Institute of Development Studies, The University of Agriculture Peshawar Dr.Naushad Khan Institute of Development Studies, The University of Agriculture Peshawar Abstract The study was carried out in District Mohmand in August, 2018. The major objective was, to find out marble industry role in the socio-economic development of District Mohmand. The study area consists of 7 tehsils while three tehsils namely Safi, Pandiali, Khwezai Bazai were selected on the basis of more marble industries . The total number of marble industries in these tehsils were 140, Safi 40, Pandiali 48 and Khwazia Bazai 48 while all were selected for the present study. Data were collected though questionnaire while Descriptive statistic and paired T-test were used for data analysis. The mean monthly income of the respondents after marble industry was Rs.97286 and before was Rs.49843 while mean monthly expenditure after was Rs.51714 and before was Rs.39479.Similarly the mean monthly saving after marble industrial owners was found Rs.45500 and before was Rs.10786 and the school children were found more than before. Similarly the private school number was found more than before. The monthly mean expenditure on education after marble industry was found Rs.6151 and the expenditure before was Rs.4361. Subsequently the private hospitals were found more than before.
    [Show full text]
  • Geology of Stone
    The Geology of Stone An excerpt from the Dimension Stone Design Manual, Version VIII (May 2016) Produced and Published by the Marble Institute of America 380 East Lorain St. Oberlin, Ohio 44074 Telephone: 440-250-9222 Fax: 440-774-9222 www.naturalstoneinstitute.org © 2016 All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by means electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or by an information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the Natural Stone Institute. The geology of 2.0 STONE CATEGORIES Stone 2.1 Three general rock or stone categories are recognized according to their mode of 1.0 INTRODUCTION origin. This is a genetic classification, and it not only states how and under what general 1.1 Earth is geologically classified as a “stony conditions a stone was formed, but also implies planet,” as it is entirely stone (rock) of various a general compositional range. The basic stone mineral compositions and forms, excluding its groups are: water and atmosphere. 2.1.1 Igneous rock is formed by 1.2 Earth scientists prefer the term “rock,”1 solidification (cooling) or, in some cases, by while the commercial stone industry, prefers solid-state transformation3 of molten or semi- the term “stone”.2 Both words are correct in molten material in the Earth’s upper mantle or their respective frame of reference, and for crust into crystalline rock generally consisting practical purposes, interchangeable. Every of silicates (compounds with SiO4) and some type of rock or stone is composed of one or dark-colored accessory minerals such as iron more minerals.
    [Show full text]
  • Improving Working Conditions at Chinese Natural Stone Companies
    Report Improving Working nr 19 Conditions at Chinese Natural Stone Companies SwedWatch, SOMO and IHLO Improving working conditions at Chinese natural stone companies SwedWatch is a non-governmental organisation that writes reports on Swedish business rela- tions with developing countries. We write about different sectors and focus on environmental and social concerns. SwedWatch consists of five member organisations: The Swedish Society for Nature Conservation, Church of Sweden Aid, Education for Aid Activities, Friends of the Earth Sweden and Fair Trade Center. SwedWatch works in close collaboration with its counterparts in Scandinavia; FinnWatch in Finland, Norwatch in Norway and DanWatch in Denmark. SwedWatch is financed by the Swedish Development Aid Agency (Sida). However, since 007 SwedWatch has also conducted assignments for other parties such as municipalities or authorities in Sweden wanting to monitor their supply chain for certain products. The contract follow-up for the municipalities of Gothenburg, Stockholm, Malmö and Örebro is the first such assignment conducted by SwedWatch. Website www.swedwatch.org Established in 973, the Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO) is a non- profit Dutch research and advisory bureau. SOMO investigates the consequences of multinational enterprises’ policies and the internationalisation of business worldwide. SOMO’s expertise lies in the field of international guidelines, treaties and codes of conduct for multinational enterprises, and it conducts research on compliance with related norms. Focus is placed upon research on labour conditions in the global South and cooperation with local organisations and trade unions. Website www.somo.nl Title: Improving Working Conditions at Chinese Natural Stone Companies. Authors: Kristina Bjurling, SwedWatch, Francis Weyzig, SOMO and Staphany Wong, IHLO.
    [Show full text]
  • The Implementation of Circular Economy in the Portuguese Natural Stone Sector
    The implementation of circular economy in the Portuguese natural stone sector Hans Ricardo Klünter Master in Management Supervisor: Professor Isabel Duarte de Almeida , Department of Marketing, Operation and Management, ISTCE Business School October, 2020 Department(s) of Marketing, Strategy and Operation The implementation of circular economy in the Portuguese natural stone sector Hans Ricardo Klünter Master in Management Supervisor: Professor Isabel Duarte de Almeida , Department of Marketing, Operation and Management, ISTCE Business School October, 2020 The implementation of circular economy in the Portuguese natural stone sector Hans Ricardo Klünter Abstract This Pedagogical Case project was created from an initial case study in a medium enterprise from the ornamental stones industry. The observation and perception of ornamental/natural stones sector processes, from extraction to processing, brought new approaches on the case. Thus, a decision was taken to develop a Pedagogical Case Study hoping to give an understanding of resource scarcity, sustainability, circular economy and the natural stone production. After introducing the terminology and basic concepts the Portuguese natural stone manufacturer Solancis is presented to underline its exemplary position of environmentally responsible operation. Key elements are highlighted and based on current research in the fields of environmental impact analysis of life cycle assessments and the construction sector with building information modelling in order to propose an innovative business strategy in the natural stone industry. Resulting benefits can be observed in all three dimensions of sustainability and guide to overcome the current challenges of implementing the concept. Energy intensive processes such as the quarrying could be smoothed through circular economy and lower environmental impacts, lower costs and benefit the surrounding communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Expert Answers to Technical Questions About Working with Natural Stone
    Expert Answers to Technical Questions About Working with Natural Stone FABRICATION • INSTALLATION • FLOORING • VERTICAL SURFACES • COUNTERTOPS GENERAL TOPICS • EXPLANATIONS • DEFINITIONS • TROUBLESH OOTING Table of Contents I. Installation .............................................................1 Vertical Surfaces ..................................................1 Floors ...................................................................4 II. Fabrication .............................................................9 Marble ..................................................................9 Granite ...............................................................11 Black Granite .....................................................12 Limestone ...........................................................13 Travertine ...........................................................14 III. Countertops & Tabletops ....................................16 IV. General Topics .....................................................21 Sealers & Resins ................................................27 V. Definitions & Explanations .................................28 Finishes .............................................................32 Lippage ...............................................................33 VI. Troubleshooting ...................................................33 VII. Appendix Conversion Tables .............................................36 Disclaimer: The questions in this brochure are among the thousands received each year by the
    [Show full text]
  • Rajasthan Stone Quarries Promoting Human Rights Due Diligence and Access to Redress in Complex Supply Chains
    non-judicial redress mechanisms report series 11 rajasthan stone Quarries promoting human rights due diligence and access to redress in complex supply chains Dr Shelley Marshall MonaSh UniverSity Kate taylor inDepenDent reSearcher Dr Samantha Balaton-chrimes DeaKin UniverSity About this report series this report is part of a series produced by the non-Judicial human rights redress Mechanisms project, which draws on the findings of five years of research. the findings are based on over 587 interviews, with 1,100 individuals, across the countries and case studies covered by the research. non- judicial redress mechanisms are mandated to receive complaints and mediate grievances, but are not empowered to produce legally binding adjudications. the focus of the project is on analysing the effectiveness of these mechanisms in responding to alleged human rights violations associated with transnational business activity. the series presents lessons and recommendations regarding ways that: • non-judicial mechanisms can provide redress and justice to vulnerable communities and workers • non-government organisations and worker representatives can more effectively utilise the mechanisms to provide support for and represent vulnerable communities and workers • redress mechanisms can contribute to long-term and sustainable respect and remedy of human rights by businesses throughout their operations, supply chains and other business re - lationships. the non-Judicial human rights redress Mechanisms project is an academic research collaboration between the University of Melbourne, Monash University, the University of newcastle, rMit University, Deakin University and the University of essex. the project was funded by the australian research council with support provided by a number of non-government organisations, including core coalition UK, homeWorkers Worldwide, oxfam australia and actionaid australia.
    [Show full text]