View Full Issue As
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
4 • 6 6 6 6 6 6 IN Step • LCBT Wisconsin's Community Newspaper • Founded in 1984 March 25, 1999 • Vol. XVI, Issue VI • $2.95 outside of Wisconsin SECTION ONE: NEWS: Clinton Endorses Hate Crime Bill PLUS: UW Fees Case Moves to U.S. Supreme Court PLUS: Qups E Quotes • Straight Answers • OUT Right • The Latest Dish and Much More! SECTION Q: INTERVIEW: Sandra Berhnard PLUS: Cempazuchi Flowers on Brady Street Film Review: The Out-of-Towners • Ink: Self-Help Books • Music: Dusty Springfield Robert's Rules • The (lassies •The Calendar • Keepin' IN Step with Jamie • The Guide -rr r ••••iim"le [f Last Year, Mary Messerlie Helped Give Away Over $17,000 to Wisconsin LGBT Organizations... Find Out Why in Our Interview on Page 4 Clinton Endorses IN Hate Crime Bill by Kevin Galvin Washington (AP) — President Clin- UW Religious Right Case Goes To U.S. Supreme Court ton has endorsed a bill that would expand federal hate crime laws to include offenses educational mission that as a based on sexual orientation, White House by Mike Leon Two religious right legal foundations University's subsidizes a wide range of ideas. officials said on April 5. of the IN Step staff are aiding the plaintiffs in Southworth: The whole is called "public Congress failed to act on similar legis- Arizona-based Alliance Defense Fund and This legal reasoning Madison — The future of subsidized the Virginia-based Northstar Legal Center. forum," "forum-creation" or "metaphysi- lation last year. student groups at colleges across the Clinton also will direct that colleges be The Alliance Defense Fund (ADF) is cal forum" analysis. nation may depend on the judicial inter- her dissent- required to report hate crimes annually closely aligned with major religious right Judge Diane P. Wood in pretation of the constitutionality of a petition in and announce a public-private partnership organizations, and has contributed some ing opinion on the en banc public forum in a university setting. $70,000 to this litigation, according to the Seventh Circuit agreed. "In my view, designed to educate middle school stu- In a potentially landmark case accept- dents against intolerance. the plaintiffs' attorney, Jordan Lorence of there is a dispositive difference for First ed for argument by the U.S. Supreme the Northstar Legal Center. Amendment purposes between requiring The partnership will involve AT&T, Court on March 29, the funding of stu- Court TV, Cable in the Classroom and the On its Web site, the ADF boasts of a someone to fund a forum, and requiring dent groups by mandatory student fees is coordinated national strategy to implement someone to support the speech of any or being challenged in Southworth v. Grebe. its Christian ideology as legal doctrine, all speakers who come to use the forum," Five University of Wisconsin gradu- fighting "radical activists (who) are waging wrote Wood. ates are plaintiffs in the case. They suc- legal warfare against people of faith." Universities have long subsidized stu- cessfully argued in federal court in 1996 Although the Christian plaintiffs dent groups as a means of informal learn- that funding as part of their tuition of 18 sound like civil libertarians in their decla- ing outside the classroom. In her dissent- student groups they disapprove of — ration of First Amendment rights, their ing opinion on the en banc petition, including the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and right-wing, homophobic Christian con- Judge Ilana Diamond Rovner acknowl- Transgender Center, Amnesty Interna- cerns in Southworth are further revealed in edged this aspect of a higher education: tional and the Campus Women's Center interviews when they espouse a world view "Numerous courts have recognized that — violates their First Amendment right which sees liberal universities, LGBT orga- the free expression of a wide range of not to engage in compelled political and nizations, and groups like the A.C.L.U., ideas is central to the educational mission ideological speech, and their right to free- an amicus party to the Court, as doing bat- of a university, teaching students to sepa- dom of association. tle with their Christian nation. rate the `wheat from the chaff.'" The case represents a legal front in the "The ACLU is going to take a fall. Another amicus party, the Lambda religious right's can't-stop culture war at col- They're better named, `the Anti-Christian Legal Defense and Education Fund, leges where diversity, and tolerance of dif- Lawyers Union'. They take cases against framed the controversy as consisting of ferent sexual orientations are both conspic- Christians. And my faith has motivated. those supporting open forums and diverse uous cultural features — student groups me to take a stand. We should not be views and those, like right-wing Chris- President Clinton being among the most visible incarnations. forced to fund liberal ideologies against tians, who can't stand opposing views. In a controversial decision, a three- National Middle Schools Association our beliefs," says UW law school graduate "Just as taxpayers cannot request a judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals Scott Southworth, now working as a leg- refund when the Mall in Washington, working with the Justice and Education for the Seventh Circuit, with jurisdiction departments to develop curricula to com- islative aide in the Wisconsin Legislature. D.C., is used to hold a rally they dislike, over three midwestern states, unanimously "The University has admitted if the the objecting students can't be exempted bat intolerance. affirmed the decision on Aug. 10, 1998. A "The president is signing this directive KKK and the Nazi's form student groups, from supporting a campus forum that UW petition for an en banc hearing, a they would force Black and Jewish students allows expression on all sides of the polit- to increase public awareness and informa- hearing before the full circuit, was denied tion about hate crimes among young peo- to fund these groups. That's wrong." ical spectrum," said Lambda Legal Direc- in late October by a seven-to-four vote. The plaintiffs' constitutional argu- tor Beatrice Dohrn. ple and doing whatever he can in his The Seventh Circuit's ruling for the power to advance this cause while we.wait ment centering on its interpretation of Heading into the new millennium, Christian plaintiffs concludes: "Funding funding student groups rests upon the the public academy is faced with the per- for Congress to act," said Bruce Reed, the of private organizations (the student White House director of public policy. well established corollary First Amend- verse prospect of a primary_educational groups) which engage in political and ide- ment right not to be compelled to subsi- mission, serving as an open forum for The idea for the middle schools program ological activities is not germane to a uni- grew out of a White House conference on dize another's speech. ideas, being court-ordered to consider- versity's educational mission, and even if The Wisconsin Department of Justice ably dismantle by reason of religious con- hate crimes that generated a lot of anecdotal it were, there is no vital interest in com- information about ethnic and racial insensi- representing the UW System, and the servatives' aversion to modern culture in pelled funding, and the burden on the ACLU of Wisconsin, an Amicus party, the name of the First Amendment. tivities among school children, officials said. plaintiffs' First Amendment right to 'free- The aim, said a White House official argued that the fee system encouraging dom of belief' outweighs any governmen- the formation of student organizations is who spoke on condition of anonymity, is tal interest." to "nip intolerance in the bud" by educat- a non-spatial public fore vital to the ing _children about its consequences. In addition, Clinton will direct the Justice and Education departments to nized prayer at public school football games. require that college campuses provide spe- Yet Bush also has avoided taking stands on specific legisla- cific information about hate crimes in• the Bush's Anti-Gay Stance tion that would enact into law some of these positions that are campus crime statistics they provide to law unpalatable to many American voters. enforcement each year. The result has been a barrage of attacks from the right and the The information will be used to gener- Leaves Log Cabin Cold left. Gay rights and civil rights groups have attacked Bush on his ate hard data on how crimes of violence Austin — The first litmus relate to intolerance on college campuses, test of Texas Gov. George W. the official said. Bush's quest for the Republi- Bush has said that: he opposes Clinton's hate crimes legislation died in can presidential nomination committee in the House and Senate last year. has just arrived. gay people being able to adopt The initiative was reintroduced last month While Texans and some by a bipartisan group of children and he opposes includ- lawmakers, includ- • 4 Republicans may have a firm ing Sens. Edward M. Kennedy, D-Mass., and image of who Bush is, on the Arlen Specter, R-Pa., and Reps. ing sexual orientation in a list of John Cony- stage of national politics he is ers, D-Mich., and Connie Morella, R-Md. largely unknown. characteristics included in a Under the bill, current law would be Texas Gov. George W. Bush In that vacuum, Bush's expanded so the Justice Department could friends and enemies have been rapidly trying to define his image [Texas] hate-crimes prosecute crimes based on a person's sex, as a conservative, a moderate, in the mainstream, out of the sexual orientation or disability. Now, the mainstream, against abortion rights, soft on ending abortions.