DOCSLIB.ORG

Changing Discourse on Women and Islam in Turkey in Ethnographic Studies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

CHANGING DISCOURSE ON WOMEN AND ISLAM IN TURKEY IN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDIES A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES OF MIDDLE EAST TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY BY PETEK ONUR IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIOLOGY SEPTEMBER 2016 Approval of the Graduate School of Social Sciences Prof. Dr. Tülin Gençöz Director I certify that this thesis satisfies all the requirements as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Prof. Dr. Sibel Kalaycıoğlu Head of Department This is to certify that we have read this thesis and that in our opinion it is fully adequate, in scope and quality, as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Prof. Dr. Ayşe Nur Saktanber Supervisor Examining Committee Members Prof. Dr. Ayşe Ayata (METU,ADM) Prof. Dr. Ayşe Nur Saktanber (METU,SOC) Prof. Dr. Aksu Bora (HACETTEPE UNI, COMM) Prof. Dr. Elif Ekin Akşit (A.U., ADM) Doç. Dr. Fatma Umut Beşpınar (METU, SOC) I hereby declare that all information in this document has been obtained and presented in accordance with academic rules and ethical conduct. I also declare that, as required by these rules and conduct, I have fully cited and referenced all material and results that are not original to this work. Name, Last name : Petek Onur Signature : iii ABSTRACT CHANGING DISCOURSE ON WOMEN AND ISLAM IN TURKEY IN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDIES Onur, Petek Ph.D., Department of Sociology Supervisor : Prof. Dr. Ayşe Nur Saktanber September 2016, 304 pages This thesis provides an analysis of the change of ethnographic discourse on women and Islam in Turkey. Based on the theoretical framework of feminist postcolonial theory it analyses the ethnographic studies as texts and focuses on the concepts of subjectivity, subalternnes, otherness, and agency in Muslim women's discursive representations and binarism, Eurocentricism, essentialism in the way discourse is produced. It adopts Michel Foucault’s theorization of discourse, knowledge and power as a methodology to present the power relations embedded in the knowledge production process. My analysis takes the social, cultural and political developments in global and Turkish contexts and the paradigm shifts in the feminist postcolonial theory and Middle Eastern women's studies as structural powers that act on knowledge production. With this analyses I present the influence of these powers and also the pathways of development of a counter-knowledge against the formerly dominant Orientalist and Eurocentric ways of knowledge production. Lastly, by providing a general picture of the ethnographic discourse on women and Islam in Turkey, I present the gaps and shortcomings of the discourse and new areas and issues that need to be addressed in the future. Keywords: Women, Islam, Turkey, Discourse, Ethnography iv ÖZ TÜRKİYE'DE KADIN VE İSLAM SÖYLEMİNİN ETNOGRAFİK ÇALIŞMALARDAKİ DEĞİŞİMİ Onur, Petek Doktora, Sosyoloji Bölümü Tez Yöneticisi : Prof. Dr. Ayşe Saktanber Eylül 2016, 304 sayfa Bu tez Türkiye'de kadın ve İslam üzerine ethnografik söylemin değişimini incelemektedir. Feminist postkolonyal teorinin teorik çerçevesine dayanarak etnografik çalışmaları metinler olarak incelemektedir ve Müslüman kadının söylemsel temsillerinde öznelik, madunluk, ötekilik ve faillik kavramlarını ve bu söylemin üretiminde ikicilik, Avrupamerkezcilik, özcülük kavramlarına odaklanmaktadır. Bilgi üretimi sürecinin içinde saklı güç ilişkilerini göstermek üzere Michel Foucualt’nun söylem, bilgi ve güç kuramsallaştırmasını yöntem olarak kullanmaktadır. Yaptığım inceleme küresel ve yerel bağlamladaki toplumsal, kültürel ve politik değişimleri ve feminist postkolonyal teori ve Ortadoğu kadın çalışmaları alanlarındaki paradigma değişimlerini bilgi ürerimindeki yapısal güçler olarak kabul etmektedir. Bu analizle bu güçlerin etkisini ve önceden baskın olan Oryantalist bilgi üretimi biçimlerine karşı bir karşı-bilginin geliştirilmesinin yollarını sunuyorum. Son olarak, Türkiye'de kadın ve İslam üzerine söylemin genel bir resmini ortaya çıkararak söylemin açıklarını ve eksikleriyle birlikte gelecekteki olası yeni araştırma alanlarını ve sorunlarını sunuyorum. Anahtar Kelimeler: Kadın, İslam, Türkiye, Söylem, Etnografi v To my grandmother and my dear friend Melahat Türkili vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS As I started this long journey of thesis work I realized that taking a step back from the field and looking at the produced knowledge from a distance has not been a common research endeavour, particularly in the scholarship on Turkey. I was on a demanding and challenging path, the difficulty of which I realized better as the research progressed. I had to create my own tools, draw my own roadmap, invent my own compass and find out my own directions in order not to lose my way. Throughout this difficult journey Prof. Dr. Ayşe Saktanber has offered me best of her advice, experience, critique, and encouragement with grace and patience. After almost all our meetings I left her room with new perspectives, ideas, and new challenges to face which had enormous contribution not only to this thesis study but to my academic development and my world view. I owe her my deepest gratitude for her academic and personal support. I am very much thankful and honoured that Prof. Dr. Ayşe Ayata, Prof. Dr. Aksu Bora, Prof. Dr. Elif Ekin Akşit and Assoc. Prof. F. Umut Beşpınar have accepted to be part of the evaluation process of this study. Their comments and critiques have opened up new paths of development of my analysis and helped to give the final shape to this thesis study. I could not have find the strength and patience to continue the years of effort to finish this thesis study without the support of my family. I would like to thank my mother Çağlan Becan and my father Can Becan for their endless support throughout my life. Especially towards the latest stages of the submission of my thesis I felt their support everyday with me. They cooked lots of meals brought pots of dishes and various food every week. I cannot forget the night at which they, intuitively knowing that I was tired and hungry, brought me fresh orange juice, sandwiches, coffee and soup, when my grandfather was at the hospital. They even bothered to read through boring academic texts and became the editors of this thesis. What else could they do?! I am grateful for being daughter. My husband, my best friend, my life companion Can Onur has been with me since vii ten years. He encouraged me to do a PhD and witnessed all the ups and downs of these years. With his surprising attitudes to hardships of life he always shifts my mood, makes me push my limits, and cheers me up too. I feel very lucky for sharing a life with this unique man and I am utterly thankful to him for making me a stronger person. Şemistan or Şemis, the cutest cat in the world, my little friend… My source of happiness and positive energy. She was with me all through my tired and sleepless nights and became my sunshine in the depressive mornings. I owe her special thanks and many hours of play. If I conducted a fieldwork for this thesis I would have a chance to meet and touch the lives of many people whom I have not known before but who would perhaps become lifelong memories. Dealing with texts for so many years perhaps made me a desk job sociologist but I still feel that I had the chance to have an insight about many special women scholars who made enormous contributions to the knowledge on women and Islam and who gave many women a voice that will be heard, hopefully, forever. This is a chance for me to pay respect to their valuable works and dedicate this thesis to them and the field they opened up. Lastly, I would like to send my greetings to a colleague whom I never met. For me Hilal Özçetin was only the name of the author of an article that I planned to include in this study. Towards the latest weeks of the thesis study I checked on the Internet to see whether she had any further publications and learned that she was a fresh PhD graduate in Canada when she was diagnosed with a terminal cancer in a short time after she defended her thesis. She passed away after a few weeks’ time –at my age. Her PhD thesis was titled Dressing up Ahlak: A Reading of Sexual Morality in Turkey because she was very much effected by the murder of Özgecan Aslan. I was deeply sad having learned all these and could not sleep that night. So my dear friend, this thesis is also dedicated to you. viii TABLE OF CONTENTS PLAGIARISM………………………………………………….…..…………………iii ABSTRACT………………………………………………………..…….……………iv ÖZ……………………………………………………………...………………………v DEDICATION…………………………………………………..……………………..vi ACKNOWLEDGMENTS………………………………………....………...………..vii TABLE OF CONTENTS………………………………………………………………ix CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION………….…………………………….…………………...…1 1.1. The Background and the Setting…………………………………………...5 1.2. Organization of the Chapters……………………………………………..23 2. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK……………………...………..……………..26 2.1. Colonialism, Postcolonialism, and Postcolonial Theory………………………………………………...……………………….27 2.2. 20th Century Orientalism, the Critics of Orientalism and Neo-Orientalism………………………………………………………………34 2.3. Feminist Postcolonial Theory………….……..……….………………….56 2.4. Discourse on Muslim Women in the Muslim Middle East and North Africa……………………………………...…………………………….…….62 3. METHODOLOGY AND THE KEY CONCEPTS…………..…………………90 3.1. Discourse, Knowledge, Power and Foucaultian Discourse Analysis….........................................................................................................90 3.2. Methodology in Practice.............................................................................98
Recommended publications
  • Islamic Law and Feminism: the Story of a Relationship† Ziba Mir-Hosseini*

    Islamic Law and Feminism: the Story of a Relationship† Ziba Mir-Hosseini*

    32 Islamic Law and Feminism: The Story of a Relationship† Ziba Mir-Hosseini* I am honoured to have been asked to deliver the 2003 Professor Noel Coulson Memorial lecture.1 I was not Professor Coulson’s student, but like so many students of Islamic law, I am very much indebted to his scholarship and insights. In particular, I have found his book, Conflicts and Tensions in Islamic Jurisprudence, an inspiration. Published in 1969, the book contains the texts of six lectures delivered at the newly founded Center for Middle Eastern Studies in the University of Chicago. In these lectures he examined the principal currents of Islamic legal theory through a series of conflicting concepts: six polarities, or areas of tension in Islamic law, namely those between: revelation and reason; unity and diversity; authority and liberty; idealism and realism; law and morality; and finally, stability and change. In this lecture, I shall explore another set of tensions and conflicts in Islamic jurisprudence that was not explored by Professor Coulson – that is, the one stemming from the conflict between, on the one hand, the patriarchal ethos embedded in “orthodox” interpretations of Islamic law, and on the other, Muslim women’s demand for gender justice and equality. This is an area of tension that has come much more into focus since Professor Coulson’s day, in particular since the late 1970s, when Islamist groups came to power in some Muslim countries and started to enforce Islamic law as the law of the land. These developments gave a new lease of life to the tired old debate over the “status” or “position” of women in Islam.
  • Reviews Leila Ahmed. Women and Gender in Islam

    Reviews Leila Ahmed. Women and Gender in Islam

    Reviews Leila Ahmed. Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992. Pp. viii + 296. ISBN 0- 300-04942-0. Reviewed by Valene J. Hoffman-Ladd. This book responds to a genuine need in the fields of Middle Eastern, women's, and Islamic studies for a comprehensive treatment of the sensitive and often controversial subject of women and gender m Islam. Until recently, there have been no book-length works m the English language dealing with Muslim women from a lustorical perspective. Those works that have come to fill that gap have either been collections of essays gUikk1 Keddie and Beth Baron, eds., Women in Middle Eastern History: Shifting Boundaries In Sex and Gender [New Haven: Yale Umversity Press, 1991]) or works dealing with a very limited topic (Judith E. Tucker, Women in Nineteenth-Century Egypt [Cambndge: Cambndge Umversity Press, 1985 ]). Other works dealing with gender issues have usually been heavily weighted with theoretical or apologetic biases that yielded either mcomplete or distorted perspectives on women in Island It is therefore a great pleasure to note that this book is histoncally precise, meticulously wntten, comprehensive m its objectives, nch m details, and unusually well-balanced. The book draws from a broad range of sources-scriptural, legalistic, mystical, historical, anthropological, and literary-m its analysis of the status of women in Islam from the time of Muhammad to the present. Ahmed begms with an inventory of female status and subjugation in pre- Islamic societies of the Middle East and the Mediterranean, a project that is virtually necessitated by the nature of the polemics that surround the issue of I Of these, the best and most ongmal is FatimaMemissi's Beyond the Veil:Male-Female DynamicsIn MuslimSociety (Cambndge, MA: SchenkmanPublishing Co., 1975; revised ed.
  • Islamic Feminism, a Public Lecture By

    Islamic Feminism, a Public Lecture By

    SUDANWORKINGPAPER Islamic Feminism, a public lecture by Liv Tønnessen, Regional Institute of Gender, Rights, Peace & Diversity, Ahfad University for Women, Sudan SWP 2014: 1 Islamic Feminism Public lecture by Liv Tønnessen, Ahfad University for Women, Sudan SVP 2014 : 1 CMI SWP ISLAMIC FEMINISM 2014: 1 In the words of Pakistani-American Asma Barlas, “I came to the realization that women and men are equal as a result not of reading feminist texts, but of reading the Quran.”1 This position has come to be known as Islamic feminism. The term has been heatedly debated and both feminists and Muslims have rejected it as two fundamentally incompatible ideas. Secular feminists reject it because they argue religion generally and Islam in particular is oppressive to women2 and many Muslim women reject it because they feel ‘feminism’ is a secular invention imposed on them from outside, from the West. Islamic feminism is indeed highly contested, but it has also been widely embraced by both activists and scholars. As Margot Badran’s article from 2002 asks, What's in a name? What's behind a name? What is Islamic feminism?3 I will in a humble way attempt to address these questions in this talk. Let me first start by saying that this is a research paper on Islamic feminism. I am not a Muslim, but I find myself fascinated and genuinely interested in the question of women and Islam. I do not under any circumstances start my engagement with the topic from a position which neither reduces Islam to be monolithic and anti-women nor a position which states that secularism is the only route to women’s empowerment.
  • Women's Ijtihad and Lady Amin's Islamic Ethics on Womanhood and Motherhood

    Women's Ijtihad and Lady Amin's Islamic Ethics on Womanhood and Motherhood

    religions Article Women’s Ijtihad and Lady Amin’s Islamic Ethics on Womanhood and Motherhood Ladan Rahbari Centre for Research on Culture and Gender, Ghent University, 9000 Gent, Belgium; [email protected] Received: 13 December 2019; Accepted: 10 February 2020; Published: 13 February 2020 Abstract: Women’s position, identity, and value in Islam have been affected by androcentric interpretations of the Qur’an and hadith throughout Islamic history. Women’s roles in society, as well as their position vis-à-vis Islamic sources and authority, have been shaped by these interpretations. In Shi’a Islam, due to the majority male clergy’s resistance, women have rarely reached the highest loci of Shi’i authority and jurisprudence. However, there have been women scholars who have transgressed these normative frameworks. Lady Amin, who was one of the most prominent Iranian theologians of the 19th and 20th centuries, is a notable example. Lady Amin had great knowledge of jurisprudence and gained the status of mujtahida at the age of forty. Her scholarly work addressed not only interpretations of the Qur’an and hadith, but also women’s issues and gender politics of her time. This study addresses women’s ijtihad in Shi’a Islam and investigates Lady Amin’s teachings on the topics of womanhood and motherhood. This study focuses on Lady Amin’s book of Islamic ethics, titled Ways of Happiness: Suggestions for Faithful Sisters, written as a Shi’i source of guidance with a specific focus on women and gender in Shi’a Islam. Keywords: Women’s ijtihad; Islamic feminism; Lady Amin; motherhood; Shi’a Islam; womanhood 1.
  • The Pennsylvania State University the Graduate School College of The

    The Pennsylvania State University the Graduate School College of The

    The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of the Liberal Arts EXISTENTIALIST ROOTS OF FEMINIST ETHICS A Dissertation in Philosophy by Deniz Durmus Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2015 The dissertation of Deniz Durmus was reviewed and approved* by the following: Shannon Sullivan Professor of Philosophy Women's Studies, and African American Studies, Department Head, Dissertation Advisor, Co-Chair Committee Sarah Clark Miller Associate Professor of Philosophy, Associate Director of Rock Ethics Institute, Co-Chair Committee John Christman Professor of Philosophy, Women’s Studies Robert Bernasconi Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of Philosophy, African American Studies Christine Clark Evans Professor of French and Francophone Studies, Women’s Studies Amy Allen Liberal Arts Professor of Philosophy, Head of Philosophy Department *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. ii ABSTRACT My dissertation “Existentialist Roots of Feminist Ethics” is an account of existentialist feminist ethics written from the perspective of ambiguous nature of interconnectedness of human freedoms. It explores existentialist tenets in feminist ethics and care ethics and reclaims existentialism as a resourceful theory in addressing global ethical issues. My dissertation moves beyond the once prevalent paradigm that feminist ethics should be devoid of any traditional ethical theories and it shows that an existential phenomenological ethics can complement feminist ethics in a productive way. The first chapter, introduces and discusses an existentialist notion of freedom based on Simone de Beauvoir and Jean Paul Sartre’s writings. In order to establish that human beings are metaphysically free, I explain notions of in-itself, for-itself, transcendence, immanence, facticity, and bad faith which are the basic notions of an existentialist notion of freedom.
  • Islamic Feminism Revisited

    Islamic Feminism Revisited

    Islamic Feminism Revisited Haideh Moghissi ver a year has passed since millions of Iranian people poured into the streets pro- testing the rigged presidential elections that reinstated Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in office for a second term. The powerful yet remarkably nonviolent protest movement, in particular the images of beautiful young women at the front rows of street demonstrations, their clearly secular appearances, their courageous encounters with police and plain- clothed thugs, and the killing of a young woman, Neda Agha- Soltan, whose murder was captured on camera, mesmerized the world. These images helped challenge the long- held perceptions about religion- steeped “Muslim” women and the political and emotional attachment of people to the Islamic state and its values and practices. The protests also helped silence, temporarily at least, the cultural relativist academics and commentators who since the mid- 1990s had been beating the drums of secularism’s end in Iran and had tried to push Islamic feminism as the only homegrown, locally produced, and hence culturally suitable project for changing the lot of women in Iran and indeed in Muslim- majority countries. The ebbing of the street protests under the brutal pressure of security forces and the pushing underground of all forms of opposition, however, seem to have resuscitated those who support Islam as the Middle Eastern version of liberation theology. For more than a decade the proponents of the idea, through their “field research,” documentaries, and reports and in total disregard for the loud voices of the overwhelming majority of urban women (and men) with or without faith inside Iran, wittingly or unwittingly lobbied on behalf of Islamists’ proj- of ects.
  • An Historical Overview of Conferences on Islamic Feminism: Circulations and New Challenges

    An Historical Overview of Conferences on Islamic Feminism: Circulations and New Challenges

    Margot Badran* An historical Overview of Conferences on Islamic Feminism: Circulations and New Challenges Conferences bringing people together in face-to-face encounters form an inte- gral part of the history of Islamic feminism and are intimately involved in the shaping and transmitting of Islamic feminist discourse and activist work. At the same time, conferences help consolidate transnational Islamic feminist networks and cement relationships. They also provide valuable records of the work and serve as markers of the trajectory of Islamic feminism1 The conference on “Islamic feminisms: boundaries and politics” that Stephanie Latte Abdullah organized at the Institute de Recherches et d’Études sur le Monde Arabe et Musulman in Aix-en-Provence in December 2009 occurred at a time when Islamic feminism is moving with increased acceleration from a primary focus on * Senior Fellow, The Reza and Georgeanna Khatib Visiting Chair in Comparative Religion at St. Joseph’s College, Brooklyn. 1 On global feminist networking in general see Valentine Moghadam, Globalizing Women: Transnational Feminist Networks (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2005). REMMM 128, 33-39 34 / Margot Badran theorization to the stage of social movement organizing. It is also a moment: (1) when expanding numbers of women affiliated with Islamist political parties and movements are gravitating toward the egalitarian model of religion that Islamic feminism explicates, and (2) when moves toward egalitarian Islam are discernable inside highly conservative Muslim majority societies such as Saudi Arabia. These trends may be seen as the new sociological layer in the quest for the implementa- tion of an egalitarian model of Islam as we get insights into from papers presented in the conference.
  • Religion and Militancy in Pakistan and Afghanistan

    Religion and Militancy in Pakistan and Afghanistan

    Religion and Militancy in Pakistan and Afghanistan in Pakistan and Militancy Religion a report of the csis program on crisis, conflict, and cooperation Religion and Militancy in Pakistan and Afghanistan a literature review 1800 K Street, NW | Washington, DC 20006 Project Director Tel: (202) 887-0200 | Fax: (202) 775-3199 Robert D. Lamb E-mail: [email protected] | Web: www.csis.org Author Mufti Mariam Mufti June 2012 ISBN 978-0-89206-700-8 CSIS Ë|xHSKITCy067008zv*:+:!:+:! CHARTING our future a report of the csis program on crisis, conflict, and cooperation Religion and Militancy in Pakistan and Afghanistan a literature review Project Director Robert L. Lamb Author Mariam Mufti June 2012 CHARTING our future About CSIS—50th Anniversary Year For 50 years, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) has developed practical solutions to the world’s greatest challenges. As we celebrate this milestone, CSIS scholars continue to provide strategic insights and bipartisan policy solutions to help decisionmakers chart a course toward a better world. CSIS is a bipartisan, nonprofit organization headquartered in Washington, D.C. The Center’s 220 full-time staff and large network of affiliated scholars conduct research and analysis and de- velop policy initiatives that look into the future and anticipate change. Since 1962, CSIS has been dedicated to finding ways to sustain American prominence and prosperity as a force for good in the world. After 50 years, CSIS has become one of the world’s pre- eminent international policy institutions focused on defense and security; regional stability; and transnational challenges ranging from energy and climate to global development and economic integration.
  • Islamic Feminism: a Discourse of Gender Justice and Equality

    Islamic Feminism: a Discourse of Gender Justice and Equality

    Linfield University DigitalCommons@Linfield Senior Theses Student Scholarship & Creative Works 5-27-2014 Islamic Feminism: A Discourse of Gender Justice and Equality Breanna Ribeiro Linfield College Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.linfield.edu/relsstud_theses Part of the Comparative Methodologies and Theories Commons, Feminist, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Commons, and the Rhetoric Commons Recommended Citation Ribeiro, Breanna, "Islamic Feminism: A Discourse of Gender Justice and Equality" (2014). Senior Theses. 1. https://digitalcommons.linfield.edu/relsstud_theses/1 This Thesis (Open Access) is protected by copyright and/or related rights. It is brought to you for free via open access, courtesy of DigitalCommons@Linfield, with permission from the rights-holder(s). Your use of this Thesis (Open Access) must comply with the Terms of Use for material posted in DigitalCommons@Linfield, or with other stated terms (such as a Creative Commons license) indicated in the record and/or on the work itself. For more information, or if you have questions about permitted uses, please contact [email protected]. Islamic Feminism: A Discourse of Gender Justice and Equality Breanna Ribeiro Senior Thesis for Religious Studies Major Advisor Bill Millar May 27, 2014 THESIS COPYRIGHT PERMISSIONS Please read this document carefully before sign1ng. If you have questions about any of these permissions, please contact the D1g1taiCommons Coordinator. Title of the Thesis: h!Amir.. fcMi>'liSv\1; A; Dike>JC"l. J'~ J!.M\o.. <Wi ~f'141if- Author's Name: (Last name, first name) 1Zhelrn1 b•UU'lllt>... Advisor's Name DigitaiCommons@Linfield is our web-based, open access-compliant institutional repository tor dig1tal content produced by Linfield faculty, students.
  • Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: a Study Of

    Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: a Study Of

    Fordham International Law Journal Volume 19, Issue 1 1995 Article 5 Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: A Study of Judicial Practice Tayyab Mahmud∗ ∗ Copyright c 1995 by the authors. Fordham International Law Journal is produced by The Berke- ley Electronic Press (bepress). http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj Freedom of Religion & Religious Minorities in Pakistan: A Study of Judicial Practice Tayyab Mahmud Abstract Pakistan’s successive constitutions, which enumerate guaranteed fundamental rights and pro- vide for the separation of state power and judicial review, contemplate judicial protection of vul- nerable sections of society against unlawful executive and legislative actions. This Article focuses upon the remarkably divergent pronouncements of Pakistan’s judiciary regarding the religious status and freedom of religion of one particular religious minority, the Ahmadis. The superior judiciary of Pakistan has visited the issue of religious freedom for the Ahmadis repeatedly since the establishment of the State, each time with a different result. The point of departure for this ex- amination is furnished by the recent pronouncement of the Supreme Court of Pakistan (”Supreme Court” or “Court”) in Zaheeruddin v. State,’ wherein the Court decided that Ordinance XX of 1984 (”Ordinance XX” or ”Ordinance”), which amended Pakistan’s Penal Code to make the public prac- tice by the Ahmadis of their religion a crime, does not violate freedom of religion as mandated by the Pakistan Constitution. This Article argues that Zaheeruddin is at an impermissible variance with the implied covenant of freedom of religion between religious minorities and the Founding Fathers of Pakistan, the foundational constitutional jurisprudence of the country, and the dictates of international human rights law.
  • Muslim Women-Led Networks and the Women's Movement in India

    Muslim Women-Led Networks and the Women's Movement in India

    Claiming Their Space: Muslim Women-led Networks and the Women’s Movement in India By Nida Kirmani 1 Abstract The Shah Bano case of the 1980s was a landmark in the discourse on ‘Muslim women’s rights’ in India. At this time, however, few Muslim women actually participated in the debates, which were dominated by male religious leaders and politicians or by ‘secular’ women’s groups, which had scant Muslim representation. Since the 1980s several Muslim-women led organisations have emerged in urban areas across the country, some of which have formed networks to advocate for Muslim women’s rights. This article looks at the emergence of two networks in particular, the Muslim Women’s Rights Network (MWRN) and the Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan (BMMA), both of which were established during the last ten years. These networks have different but overlapping ideological bases, priorities and strategies. They both aim to challenge the authority of the Muslim religious leadership, represented by institutions such as the All India Muslim Personal Law Board. They also offer a critique of the mainstream women’s movement, either from within the movement or from outside, as not having given sufficient space to the perspectives of women from marginalised communities. Both networks are engaged in struggles to reformulate power relations at the local and national levels, thus challenging the dominant conception of Muslim women as a passive, homogenous group with a common set of interests. Rather, the MWRN and the BMMA demonstrate new forms of political agency and are creating a space for a conceptualisation of identities that complicates the dichotomy between religious and gender-based interests and aims to reconcile the two in a manner that protects and promotes women’s rights without denying the importance of religious identity.
  • Women's Ijtihad and Lady Amin's Islamic Ethics On

    Women's Ijtihad and Lady Amin's Islamic Ethics On

    Article Women’s Ijtihad and Lady Amin’s Islamic Ethics on Womanhood and Motherhood Ladan Rahbari Centre for Research on Culture and Gender, Ghent University, 9000 Gent, Belgium; [email protected] Received: 13 December 2019; Accepted: 10 February 2020; Published: 13 February 2020 Abstract: Women’s position, identity, and value in Islam have been affected by androcentric interpretations of the Qur’an and hadith throughout Islamic history. Women’s roles in society, as well as their position vis‐à‐vis Islamic sources and authority, have been shaped by these interpretations. In Shi’a Islam, due to the majority male clergy’s resistance, women have rarely reached the highest loci of Shi’i authority and jurisprudence. However, there have been women scholars who have transgressed these normative frameworks. Lady Amin, who was one of the most prominent Iranian theologians of the 19th and 20th centuries, is a notable example. Lady Amin had great knowledge of jurisprudence and gained the status of mujtahida at the age of forty. Her scholarly work addressed not only interpretations of the Qur’an and hadith, but also women’s issues and gender politics of her time. This study addresses women’s ijtihad in Shi’a Islam and investigates Lady Amin’s teachings on the topics of womanhood and motherhood. This study focuses on Lady Amin’s book of Islamic ethics, titled Ways of Happiness: Suggestions for Faithful Sisters, written as a Shi’i source of guidance with a specific focus on women and gender in Shi’a Islam. Keywords: Women’s ijtihad; Islamic feminism; Lady Amin; motherhood; Shi’a Islam; womanhood 1.