Arxiv:1207.5234V3 [Cond-Mat.Str-El]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Chiral anomaly, Charge Density Waves, and Axion Strings from Weyl Semimetals Zhong Wang1 and Shou-Cheng Zhang1,2 1 Institute for Advanced Study, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China, 100084 2 Department of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305 We study dynamical instability and chiral symmetry breaking in three dimensional Weyl semimetals, which turns Weyl semimetals into “axion insulators”. Charge density waves (CDW) is found to be the natural conse- quence of the chiral symmetry breaking. The phase mode of this charge density wave state is identified as the axion, which couples to electromagnetic field in the topological θE B term. One of our main results is that the “axion strings” can be realized as the (screw or edge) dislocations in· the charge density wave, which provides a simple physical picture for the elusive axion strings. These axion strings carry gapless chiral modes, there- fore they have important implications for dissipationless transport properties of Weyl semimetals with broken symmetry. PACS numbers: 73.43.-f,71.70.Ej,75.70.Tj Introduction. Topological insulators are among the most as the chiral anomaly[11, 12, 23]. Unlike the topological in- active research fields in condensed matter physics recently[1– sulators, whose transport is dominated by topologically pro- 3]. Among the remarkable aspects of topological insulators tected surface states, in the Weyl semimetal the bulk transport is the ubiquitous role played by Dirac fermions. In fact, is most important. Their unique semi-metallic behaviors in 3d most of the recently discovered topological insulators can can potentially be engineered for semiconductor industry. be regarded as massive Dirac fermion systems with lattice Interaction effect plays a fundamental role in the dynam- regularization[3]. When the mass vanishes, we have mass- ics of Weyl fermions. One possibility is the pairing inter- less Dirac fermions, which are two copies of Weyl fermion action which leads to the superconducting instability. Qi, with opposite chiralities. The Dirac fermions, which obey Hughes and Zhang’s fermi surface topological invariant[25] the Dirac equation, are described by spinors with four compo- implies that if the pairing amplitudes have opposite sign for nents, while the Weyl fermions are two-component fermions Weyl points with the opposite chirality, topological supercon- described by the following simple Weyl equation ductors are obtained. Another consequence of interaction, which we will focus in this paper, is the spontaneous chiral v σ kψ = Eψ (1) ± F · symmetry breaking. Chiral symmetry breaking is the phe- where is referred as chirality (+ for left handed, for right nomenon of spontaneous generation of an effective mass of ± − handed), and vF is the Fermi velocity. Since the Dirac fermion Weyl fermions, namely a paring between the fermions (elec- can be decomposed into two copies of Weyl fermion, the lat- trons) and anti-fermions (holes) with different chiralities. Due ter is more elementary building block. In fact, it is our current to chiral anomaly, the Goldstone mode θ is coupled to electro- understanding of nature that the elementary fermions such as magnetic field as θE B, therefore, this Goldstone mode is an · quarks and electrons fall into the Weyl fermion framework be- “axion”[26–29]. cause the left-handed and right-handed fermions carry differ- In this paper, we focus on the chiral symmetry breaking in ent gauge charges in the standard model of particle physics[4]. Weyl semimetal and axion strings in condensed matter con- It is worth noting that in writing down Eq.(1) we have as- text, which have new features absent in particles physics. We sumed that the two “Weyl points”, at which the energy gap would like to mention that axion string can be realized on closes, are both located at k = 0. In the particle physics the surface of topological insulators with a magnetic domain context, this assumption seems to be natural, however, in wall[30], and axionic dynamics has been studied in topologi- condensed matter physics, without imposing symmetry con- cal magnetic insulators[31, 32]. In the present paper we study arXiv:1207.5234v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 14 Apr 2013 straints such as time reversal symmetry and inversion symme- a new route to axionic dynamics through chiral symmetry try, Weyl points are generally located at different points in the breaking induced by interaction effect. The resultant states momentum space. This fact has interesting consequences for are charge density wave (CDW) states, which are experimen- Weyl fermion systems with broken symmetry, as we will show tally observable. One of our main results is that the (screw in this paper. or edge) dislocations of CDW are exactly the “axion strings”, Although Weyl fermion plays a crucial role in the descrip- which are important topological defects carrying gapless chi- tion of elementary fermions in nature, it has been studied ral modes. In these chiral modes electrons move solely in one in the condensed matter context only very recently[5–23]. direction without backscattering. In particles physics, axion Weyl semimetals in three dimensions (3d) are analogous to strings have interesting cosmological implications such as the graphene[24] in 2d in the sense that both are described in gravitational lenses effect[33], but observable evidences are terms of gapless fermions with approximately linear disper- elusive. Axion strings in condensed matter systems have the sion, but the 3d Weyl semimetals are richer in that they are advantage that they are much easier to detect. In the Weyl more closely related to various fundamental phenomena such semimetal studied in the present paper, axion strings have im- 2 portant effects on the transport properties since they provide chiral modes supporting dissipatonless transport. 1 dωd3 p 1 = (5) Dynamical chiral symmetry breaking. We consider the sim- 2g Z (2π)4 ω2 + v2 p2 + m 2 plest model for dynamical chiral symmetry breaking, which F | | + nevertheless captures the most salient physical consequences. from the mean-field relation m(r) = g cr†τ cr . The solution − h i v2 Λ2+ m 2 First let us present the free part H of the Hamiltonian. The 1 1 = 1 2 F 0 to Eq.(5) can be obtained as 3 m ln 2| | , gc g 8π2v m − F | | four-band model studied here is a simplified version of the 2 | | = 8π vF ff model of Weyl semimetal given in Ref.[7, 12]. We have where gc Λ2 . We have taken a Lorentz-invariant cuto p < Λ,ω < vFΛ in the above calculation, but if we take the H0 = c†hc with cuto| | ff only for p but not for the ω, we can check that g takes | | c 3 the same value. Because we are concerned with the cases with h = v Γi( i∂ eA q Γ) eA (2) m << Λ, the solution can be approximated by F − i − i − i − 0 | | Xi=1 1 1 1 v2 Λ2 = m 2 ln F (6) Γµ = 2 3 2 where we have defined the Dirac matrices (µ 0, 1, 2, 3) gc − g 8π vF | | m Γµ, Γν = δµν Γ | | satisfying 2 , is the chirality operator with which shows that dynamical symmetry breaking (or “exciton { Γ2 } = Γ, Γi = the properties 1 and [ ] 0[34], Aµ is the exter- condensation”)occurs only when the interaction is sufficiently = , , nal electromagnetic potential, and q (q1 q2 q3) is a vector strong (g > g ). that shifts the gapless points away from k = 0. The simplest c 3 i 3 i A qualitative understanding of gc is simple. The kinetic en- choices of the Dirac matrices are Γ= τ 1 and Γ = τ σ Λ ⊗ ⊗ ergy per fermion is EK vF , while the interaction energy ( i = 1, 2, 3 ). The low energy modes from the left-hand (Γ = ∼3 3 per fermion is EI gΛ , where Λ accounts for the spatial +1) chirality is described by h+(k) vF Γ (k q) = vFσ (k q) ∼ = ≈ · − · − density of Weyl fermions. To have chiral condensation, we near k q. Similarly, there is a Weyl point at q for the must have E E , or g v /Λ2. To satisfy this condi- right-handed (Γ= 1) chirality. The low energy dynamics− are K ∼ I c ∼ F − = tion, larger EI (stronger interaction) and smaller EK (narrower dominated by these two Weyl points located at Q1 q and bandwidth in Dirac dispersion) is favored. Q = q respectively, with 2 − Axion dynamics and topological theta term. We have seen in the previous section that when g > gc, chiral symmetry h (k) = vFσ (k Qi) (3) ± ± · − is spontaneously broken. From symmetry consideration, the Ginzburg-Landau effective action (omitting chiral anomaly at where the prefactor 1 is the chirality. For later convenience ± 1 2 this stage) of m(r) can be expressed as let us define two operators τ± = τ iτ with the property Γ = ± 1 τ±, 0. = 2 2 2 + 2 + 4 { } S m dtdr[ γ( ∂tm′ va ∂im′ ) δ m′ η m′ ] (7) Now we would like to investigate the effects of four- Z 2 | | − | | | | | | fermion interaction in Weyl semimetals. Let us write down where γ, va, δ, η are phenomenological parameters, and m′ ff iQ r ≡ the e ective action in the imaginary time as me · is the “slow” field. In the symmetry breaking phase, δ < 0 and m develops a nonzero expectation value. The ef- m(r) 2 | | + fective action S m is invariant if we shift the phase of m(r) by S = dτdr c†[∂τ + h + m∗(r)τ + m(r)τ−]cr + | | (4) Z { r g } a spacetime-independent phase factor, but in fact this sym- metry is broken by chiral anomaly, which endows a topo- in which we have written the interaction in terms of the aux- logical theta term to the effective action, as we explain be- iliary field m(r), which can be integrated out to give the four- = + low.