1B (16Th February 1970)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA DEBATES 16TH FEBRUARY, 1970 Vol. I No. 2 OFFICIAL REPORT CONTENTS Monday, the 16th February, 1970 Contents Pages Starred Questions and Answers (2)1 Written Answers to Starred Questions laid on (2)20 the Table of the House under Rule 45 Unstarred Questions and Answers (2)43 Withdrawal of Notice of No Confidence Motion (2)160 Adjournment Motion (2)160 Announcement by the Secretary (2)161 Call Attention Notice (2)161 Walk-out (2)164 Papers laid on the Table of the House (2)164 Presentation of Supplementary Estimates (2)166 Presentation of Report (2) 166 Discussion on Governor’s Address (2)166 HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA Monday, the 16th February, 1970 The Vidhan Sabha met in the Hall of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha, Vidhan Bhawan, Chandigarh, at 2.00 P.M. of the Clock. Mr. Speaker (Brig. Ran Singh) in the Chair. STARRED QUESTION AND ANSWERS Repair of Rohtak Road *540. Smt. Chandravati: Will the Minister for Agriculture and Labour be pleased to state:- Whether any amount has been spent on the repair of Rohtak Road between Rohtak-Kalanaur and Panipat-Rohtak during the year 1969; and If the answer to para (a) above be in the affirmative, details showing separately, the amount spent on earth work, coaltar and other material, item-wise. Agriculture and Labour Minister (Ch. Ran Singh): (a) Yes. Rohtak-Kalanaur Road Rs. i. Earth Work 11271 ii. Tar Coal 8293 iii. Bajri 11708 iv. Painting and lettering 1000 Total 32272 (b) Rohtak-Panipat Road (in Rohtak District) i. Earth Work 28444 ii. Bajri 9443 iii. Binder (Bitumen) 10400 iv. Fuel Woods 693 Total 48980 Jhefr pUnzkorh% Lihdj lkfgc] D;k othj lkfgc crk;saxs fd lM+dsa cuus ds ckn mlds nksuksa fdukjksa ij tks feV~Vh Mkyrs gSaa ml ij izfr o’kZ vkSj ij&ekby VksVy fdruk [kpZ gqvk gS \ pkS/kjh j.k flag% tks loky vkujscy esEcj lkfgck us iwNk gS ml ls ;g lIyhesaVjh iSnk ugha gksrkA Jhefr pUnzkorh% eSaus tks loky iwNk Fkk mldk eryc rks ;gh FkkA eq[; ea=h ¼Jh calh yky½% feV~Vh Mkyus ds fy;s jsxqyj xSUx gksrk gSA ogh lM+dksa ij feV~Vh Mkyrk gSA Jhefr pUnzkorh% og xSUx dksbZ eq¶r esa rks feV~Vh ugha Mkyrk] og ru[okg oxSjg rks ysrs gh gksaxsA ml ij tks [kpZ gS og gh crk;k tk;sA pkS/kjh j.k flag% ;fn vkujscy esEcj lkgfck xSUx dh ru[okg oxSjg Hkh iwNuk pkgrh gS rks vyx ls uksfVl nsa] rks mldk mrj ns fn;k tk;sxkA Smt. Chandravat: I am not concerned with the pay of the Gangmen. I am concerned with the earth work done every year or every half year, which goes with the wind. Jh calh yky% vkujscy esEcj lkfgck us tks iz”u iwNk gS og lu~ 1969 essa tks [kpkZ gqvk gS mldk iwNk gSA blfy;s gj lky ds fo’k; esa rks bl iz”u esa ugha iwNk tk ldrkA Jhefr pUnzkorh% v/;{k egksn;] eSaus tks loky iwNk gS mldk eryc rks ;gh Fkk fd lM+dsa cukus ij vkSj feV~Vh ocSjg Myokus ij D;k [kpkZ gksrk gS \ Jh calh yky% vkujscy esEcj lkfgck us tks dqN fy[k dj iwNk Fkk mldk eryc rks ;gh gSA Jhefr pUnzkorh% ;fn othj lkfgc vkSj eq[; ea=h th esjs iz”u dk vFkZ u le>s arks nwljh ckr gS ijUrq esjk vFkZ rks iwNus dk ;gh Fkk fd lM+dksa ds fdukjksa ij fdrus :I;s dh feV~Vh Mkyh xbZ gSA Sh. Bansi Lal: Mr. Speaker, Sir, the question put by the hon. Lady Member reads:- a) Whether any amount has been spent on the repair of Rohtak Road between Rohtak-Kalanaur and Panipat- Rohtak during the year 1969; and b) If the answer to part (a) above be in the affirmative, details showing separately, the amount spent on earthwork, coal-tar and other material item-wise? So, it is particularly for the year 1969 the question has been asked and that has been replied to. Mr. Speaker: Let me seek clarification from teh hon. Lady Member as to what does she want to know. Is it her intention to know the cost of repairs for the year 1969? Smt. Chandravat: Yes, Sir, the cost of repairs as well as..... Sh. Bansi Lal: That has been replied to. Smt. Chandravati: Mr. Speaker, let me complete the question before it is replied to by the Chief Minister or the Minister concerned. esjk eryc ;g gS fd dkLV vkQ jhis;j vkSj vFkZodZ tks gqvk ml ij vk;s lky eghus okj D;k [kpZ gqvk \ Mr. Speaker: As it appears, Smt. Chandravati Ji, some repairs were required on these two roads given in the questin and for these extra amount was spent by the Depatment concerned. For the normal repairs it is the gang or whatever that be, which carries out those repairs. Jhefr pUnzkorh% ;fn Lihdj lkgc vki btktr nsa rks eSa fQj Li’V :i ls cryk nwaA vHkh rks ge us ml lM+d dks ns[kk ugha gS ijUrq ml lM+d ij ges”kk dke pyrk jgrk gSA bldk D;k dkj.k gS fd vk;s lky bruk :i;k [kpZ djus ds i”pkr~ Hkh og lM+d Bhd ugha gksrh gSA bldk eryc rks ;g gqvk fd gqdejku ;k bathfu;jksa dh ykijokgh gSA Jh calh yky% Lihdj lkgc] ;g tks DoS”pu gS og iVhZdqyj bZ;j ds fy;s gSa ------- as to whether any amount has been spent on the repairs of these roads and that question has been amply replied. pkS/kjh j.k flag% Lihdj lkgc] eSa rks ;gh dguk pkgrk gaw fd vkujscy eSEcj us tks iwNk gS og ;gh iwNk gS fd ctjh ij] rkjdksy ij vkSj vFkZodZ ij fdruk [kpZ gqvk gS og eSaus crk fn;k gSA ijUrq tks mUgksaus lIyhesaVjh fd;k gS fd fdruh feV~Vh Mkyh gS bldk rks dksbZ fglkc fdrkc ugha j[kk tkrkA D;ksafd dgha ij feV~Vh T;knk Mkyh tkrh gS vkSj dgha ij deA tSlk fd QYM ls dksbZ lM+d MSest gks tkrh gS rks mldks nkskjk cuk;k tkrk gS blfy;s ml feV~Vh dk fglkc oxSjg ugha j[kk tkrkA gka tSlk fd phQ fefuLVj lkgc us crk;k gS fd ;g fglkc t:j j[kk tkrk gS fd feV~Vh Mkyus ij fdruk [kpZ gqvk gSa] rkjdksy ij fdruk [kpZ gqvk vkSj ctjh ij fdruk [kpZ gqvkA Mr. Speaker: In other words, the truth is that no per mile expenditure on the earthwork is worked out and the noraml repair on the roads is normally done by the gangmen. That is what the answer appears to be. Major Amir Singh Chaudry: Mr. Speaker, Sir, it is only the work-charged labour that is responsible for the maintenance of the raods and the gangs are simply responsible to look after casual repairs. Mr. Speaker: In other words whenever any roads require earthwork or repairs on the site depending on the amount of work required labour is employed and the work is done. So really you cannot work out the cost per mile per year. It is not possible to work it out. That is what appears to be the answer. Major Amir Singh Chaudhry: Average can be worked out. Mr. Speaker: It is very difficult, Major Sahib, you will agree because it will probably depend on different roads and the difference in width of each road etc. Major Amir Singh Chaudhry: That is worked out in the Public Works Department. I am saying this because I have remained associated with them and they work out every year as to how much money has been spent. Jh calh yky% estj lkgc vkius tks edku cuk;s Fks os rks lc feV~Vh gks x;sA pkS/kjh j.kchj flag% eSa ea=h egksn; ls ;g tkuuk pkgrk gwa fd vxj odZ pkftZt dk Qh ekby dk fglkc ugha] rks nks ehy] pj ehy ;k nl ehy dk rks dksbZ fglkc gksxk] ;fn gS rks og crkus dh d`ik djsaA pkS/kjh j.k flag% ;fn vki vyx ls bl iz”u ds fy;s uksfVl nsa rks mrj ns fn;k tk;sxkA Jh eaxy lSu% Lihdj lkgc] esjk lIyhesaVjh cM+k flEiy lk gSA eSa cfgu th dks eqckfjdkn nsrk gwa tks os Hkh pkS/kjh fjtd jke th ds jkLrs ij py jgh gSaA Jh v/;{k% DoS”pu vkoj ds fy;s le; cgqr de gSA blfy;s vki deSUVjh u djsa vkSj viuk lIyhesaVjh djsaA Jh eaxy lSu% Lihdj lkgc] eSa rks cM+k [kq”k gks jgk Fkk fd cfgu th us fjis;j] vFkZodZ vkSj rkjdksy ds kjs esa lu~ 1969 dk [kpkZ iwNk gSA Lihdj lkgc] vki dh xkM+h Hkh ml jksM ij tkrh jgrh gS vksj vkids uksfVl esa Hkh ;g ckr vkbZ gksxh fd gj lky lM+d ds nksuksa fdukjksa ij feV~Vh MyokbZ tkrh gS] xSUx Hkh Bhd djrh jgrh gS ijUrq fQj Hkh og lM+d VwVh gqbZ jgrh gS vkSj ckfj”k ds fnuksa esa rks og [kjkc gh jgr gSA rks eSa ea=h egksn; ls ;gh iwNuk pkgrk gwa fd bldk D;k dkj.k gS \ Jh v/;{k% vkius rks bl iz”u dks cgqr yEck dj fn;k] “kkVZ djds crk;saA Jh eaxy lSu% Lihdj lkg] pkS/kjh fjtd jke okyh ckr rks vyx Fkh esjh rks dsoy bruh lh ckr gS fd D;k ea=h egksn;k ds uksfVl eas ;g ckr gS fd vFkZodZ] rkjdksy vkSj ctjh oxSjg ij bruk iSlk [kpZ djus ds i”pkr~ Hkh lM+d ds nksuksa fdukjs VwVs gq, gSa \ pkS/kjh j.k flag% gekjh xouZeSaV ds uksfVl esa rks ;g ckr gS ijUrq tc mudh ljdkj Fkh ml oDr muds uksfVl esa ugha jgrh gksxhA pkS/kjh j.kchj flag% eSa ea=h egksn; ls tkuuk pkgrk gwa fd fdlh lM+d ij tks doZpktZ dk [kpkZ gS D;k og fji;tZ eas ;k eqjEer esa “kkfey ugha gS vkSj vxj “kkfey ugha gS rks D;kas ugha gS \ D;k og [kZ eqjEer dk fgLlk ugha gS \ pkS/kjh j.k flag% dqN rks ijekusaV LVkQ j[kk tkrk gS vkSj dqN ,ejtSalh dh otg ls tSls QyM~t esa lM+d VwV tkrh gS mudh otg ls Lis”ky lSad”ku nsuh iM+rh gSA blfy;s vyx vyx tks dke gSa os blds lkFk tksM+us okyh ckr ugha gSA pkS/kjh j.kchj flag% iz”u dks i<+us ls ;g ckr lkQ tkfgj gksrh gS fd dksbZ Lis”ky fjis;j ds ckjs esa gh tokc ugha pkfg;sA ml esa ;g iwNk gS fd fjis;j ds Åij fdruk [kpZ gqvk gSA eSa ekurk gwa fd ea=h egksn; ds ikl ;s vkadM+s t:j gkasaxs fd odZpktZ ds Åij fdruk [kpZ gqvk gS vksj og eqjEer dk fgLlk Hkh t:j gksxk ;k og lM+d cukus dk fgLlk ugha gS] rks D;k ea=h egksn; eqjEer dk iwjk [kpZ crkus dk d’V djsaxs \ pkS/kjh j.k flag% odZ pktZ ds vkadM+s iwNs ugha x, Fks blfy;s ugha yk;kA vxj ;s vyx ls iwNs tk;sa rks crk, tk ldrs gSaA pkS/kjhj j.kchj flag% esjk iz”u fcYdqy lkQ gSA bl easa ;g ekuk x;k gS fd odZ pktZ ds [kpsZ dks NksM+ dj loky ugha iwNk x;k gSA bl eas lnu dks] v?;{k egksn; vkids laj[k.k dh t:jr gSaA bl loky ds vUnj fcYdqy lkQ gS D;ksafd odZ pktZ tks gS] mldk dke eqjEer dk gS rks muds Åij ;g vkuk pkfg;s Fkk fd fdruk odZ pktZ ds Åij [kpkZ gqvk gS og ijekusaV gS ;k dPpkA loky esa ;g ugha iwNk x;k fd ijekusaV vkSj VSEiksjsjh LVkQ ij fdruk [kpkZ gksxk \ Jh calh yky% eSa le>rk gwa fd bl loky ds tokc eas vFkZodZ ij vyx] ctjh ij vyx] fcMj] fcpqeSu vkSj fQ;wy ij vyx [kpkZ crk;k x;k gS ysfdu tks ;s xSaxeSu dks isesaV djrs gSa] og bu enksa ls ,DlVªk [kpkZ gksrk gS vkSj ogh bl loky ds tokc esa fn;k x;k gSA pkS/kjh j.kchj flag% v/;{k egksn; eSa eq[; ea=h vkSj ea=h egksn; ls vkids }kjk iwNuk pkgrk gwa fd ;g tks iz”u dk mrj fn;k x;k gS] og vke eqjEer dk bl esa bUoywM gSA Disparities in Electricity charges in respect of Agricultural Connections *571.