DOCSLIB.ORG

The Role of Religion in the Arab-Israeli Conflict

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Role of Religion in the Arab-Israeli Conflict MASARYKOVA UNIVERZITA FACULTY OF SOCIAL STUDIES The Role of Religion in the Arab-Israeli Conflict Bachelor' s Thesis XIN RAN XIN Supervisor: Mgr. Vladimir Bizik, Mgr. Deparment of International Relations and European Studies International Relations and European Politics Brno 2021 THE ROLE OF RELIGION IN THE ARAB-ISRAELI CONFLICT MUNI FSS Bibliographie Record Author: Xinran Xin Faculty of Social Studies, Masaryk University Department of International Relations and Euro• pean Studies Title of Thesis: The Role of Religion in the Arab-Israeli Conflict Degree Programme: International Relations and European Politics Supervisor: Mgr. Vladimir Bizik Academic Year: 2021 Number of Pages: 40 Keywords: Arab-Israeli Conflict, Judaism, Islam, Jewish religi ous parties, Arab parties, Palestinian Organiza tions. Abstract The research paper aims at identifying the role of religion in the Arab- Israeli Conflict, from the perspective of Judaism and Islam tenets, Jewish Religious parties in Israel, Israeli Arab parties, and Palestinian organi• zations. The research is based on a case study and uses qualitative data as a researching method, analyzing academic literature and work. The analysis is conducted in four separate perspectives. The research ends with the conclusion that religion did influence the Arab-Israeli Conflict to a large extent. Statutory Declaration I hereby declare that I have written the submitted [select type of docu• ment] concerning the topic of The Role of Religion in the Arab-Israeli Conflict independently All the sources used for the purpose of finishing this thesis have been adequately referenced and are listed in the Biblio• graphy In Brno 27 December 2020 Xinran Xin Table of Contents List of Terms and Acronyms 1 Introduction 7 2 Research questions and objectives 9 3 Methodology 10 3.1 Scope and limitations 4 Literature Review 12 5 Analysis 14 5.1 General Overview of the Arab-Israeli Conflict 5.2 Tenets of Islam and Judaism 15 5.3Jewish Religious Parties in Israel 20 5.4 Arab Parties in Israel 23 5.5 Palestinian Organizations 26 6 Conclusion 32 Bibliography 34 List of Terms and Acronyms PLO Palestine Liberation Organization Hamas Islamic Resistance Movement Fatah Palestinian National Liberation Movement PIJ Palestinian Islamic Jihad UN United Nations Quran Religious text of Islam Talmud Central text of Judaism WW2 World War Two NRP National Religious Party UTP United Torah Party 1 Introduction The military and political conflicts between Arab countries and Israel have lasted for decades, causing casualties and regional turmoil. The par• ticularity of the conflicts is not only due to its geographic, economic, po• litical, military, but also its history, ethnicity and religion. Therefore, it is especially significant to find out and analyze the underlying reasons to solve the situation in this region. The conflicts and disputes caused by territorial issues between Palestine and Israel are important reasons that can not be ignored and usually recognized by the public. However, whether the religious reason is also an important factor in conflicts is of• ten overlooked. Academic research on related topics is also lacking. When it comes to religious topics, most of the articles are analyzed in conjunction with the news, lacking all aspects of discussion. As the holy places of Judaism and Islam, the Palestine region and Jerusalem contain special religious significance. Whether religion also influences other fields such as politics still needs to be explored. Therefore, the purpose of this article is to analyze the extent to which religion has an impact on Arab-Israeli conflicts, the later political negotiations, and the political arena of Palestine and Israel. Four aspects will be elaborated in the thesis. First, the research focuses on the interpretation of Judaism and Islam for land sovereignly and vio• lence. If the tenets of both religions indicate the attributes of the land or support the use of violence to regain lost land, it will inevitably lead to conflicts and violence to a certain extent. Second, the status and influence of Israeli religious parties in the Israel political arena will be analyzed. Israeli religious parties are practitioners of Judaism. The strength of reli• gious parties will inevitably lead to their influence on Israel's foreign pol• icy towards Palestine and the stagnation of the land for the peace plan. Besides, the influence and status of Israeli Arab parties will also be men• tioned. As pagan parties, the status of Arab parties in the Israeli political arena precisely reflects Israel's attitude towards Islam. The analysis later shows that Arab political parties are struggling, which indicates Israel's distrust and rejection of Islam related factions. Finally, the relation be• tween the Palestinian organizations and Islam will be analyzed. Whether these organizations use Islamic tenets to justify violence is the key to prove the connection between religion and the Arab-Israeli conflict. 7 Research questions and objectives will be proposed firstly, following the Methodology part explaining the data gathering method. Subsequently previous academic literature will be reviewed and drawbacks of them will be introduced. The main analysis including four individual parts to identify religion's influence on Arab-Israeli conflict will be conducted, and the research conclusion will follow up as the end. 8 2 Research questions and objectives The thesis focuses on the following questions: Are tenets of Judaism and Islam justify violence and war, and the belong• ing of Palestinian territory? Do Jewish religious political parties in Israel impede the peace process? Are Arab parties in Israel given special treatments due to the religion? Do the tenets of Islam influence the act of Palestinian organizations? The objectives of the research are: To review existing academic literature and documents related to the above questions. To evaluate to what extent does the religion factor influences both the Palestine and Israel. 9 3 Methodology The research paper uses a case study as the research method, giving a detailed study of the research question on how religion affects Palestine and Israel. The reason why the case study was chosen as the research method is that the case study can focus on the case of the Arab-Israeli conflict specifically. When elaborating the topic with a case study re• search design, qualitative data was collected, focusing on historical and analytical structure. This kind of research method can best analyze the given questions in the paper, and can best evaluate in what field and to what extent does religion affected Palestine and Israel. It allows the re• searcher to explore key meanings of relevant cases. The thesis is mainly based on the existing literature to provide practical evidence and specific data. Primary and secondary sources will be analyzed to achieve a clearer perspective. Qualitative data collection method using books, news articles, reports, government documents, and other literature to collect relevant informa• tion to support subsequent analysis. The literature will be selected accor• ding to the relevance of the topic. Secondary sources are given preference due to their specially and sufficient analysis, for example, academic lite• rature that is recognized by academia. Online academic literature have been gathered from JSTOR, Masaryk University's Online archive, Re• search Gate, Google Scholar, Library Genesis, and Palestine-Israel Journal. The specific primary sources concerning election results are obtained from the official website of the Israeli government such as gov.il, Knes- set.gov.il, the democracy institute. The online database such as Israel/Pa• lestine Center for Research and Information, the Carter Center, Wilson Center also provides valuable information and data. 3.1 Scope and Limitations The purpose of this thesis is to analyze the extent of religion's influence on Palestine and Israel through the existing literature. The influence of Judaism and Islam on Palestine and Israel will be discussed. The other three parts focus on Israeli religious parties, Israeli Arab parties, and Pa• lestine authorities like PLO, Hamas, and PIJ. The expected contribution of this paper would be the filling of vacancy of such topic, attracting more researchers to explore this area. The author admits that this thesis has a certain degree of limitations. Due to the limited longitude and maximum 10 word limit, although Arab countries have largely influenced the Arab-Is• raeli conflicts, they have not been mentioned in this thesis. This thesis without a broader scope only focuses on Palestine and Israel. Moreover, this paper lacks comparative perspectives in examining the influence of religion on the politics in the whole Middle East region. Finally, due to the language proficiency of the author, qualitative data collected in this paper is in English, without Arabic and Hebrew perspectives. 11 4 Literature Review Previously, research on the Arab-Israeli conflict mainly focused on com• bining facts and news to conclude whether religion has an impact on the conflict. For instance, Sabrina analyzed the impact of religious concepts through specific events in the West Bank. (Sabrina, 2002) The same goes for Anshel's research, explaining that the Arab-Israeli conflict is not only a struggle over land but also a struggle based on religion. (Anshel, 2014) Although the discussion of these two researchers involved religion, they did not conduct a multidimensional analysis based on this topic.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • An Israeli Labor Party Perspective on Peace | the Washington Institute
    MENU Policy Analysis / PolicyWatch 1818 An Israeli Labor Party Perspective on Peace by Isaac Herzog Jun 20, 2011 ABOUT THE AUTHORS Isaac Herzog Isaac Herzog is chairman of the executive at the Jewish Agency for Israel. Brief Analysis n June 16, 2011, Isaac Herzog addressed a Policy Forum at The Washington Institute to discuss Israel's next O steps in the wake of Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu's recent visit to Washington. A member of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Mr. Herzog has served in a number of senior positions in the Israeli government, most recently as minister of welfare and social services. He is currently a candidate for the Labor Party chairmanship. The following is a rapporteur's summary of his remarks. Given the huge uncertainties created by the Arab Spring, many Israelis believe that the best response is a "wait and see" approach. That is a narrow, short-term view, however. A better response is to shape the region's changes in Israel's interest, based on the view that it is better to influence history than be swept along as a passive participant. From that perspective, President Obama's recent speech hit on the crux of the difference between the Israeli right and left. The current government chose to focus on a few controversial words in the speech and, in the process, deepened the tension between Israel and the United States. On the other hand, the Israeli opposition -- especially the Labor Party -- welcomed the address as another evolutionary step from the 2000 Clinton Parameters toward the goal of ending the conflict with the Palestinians.
    [Show full text]
  • Inequality, Identity, and the Long-Run Evolution of Political Cleavages in Israel 1949-2019
    WID.world WORKING PAPER N° 2020/17 Inequality, Identity, and the Long-Run Evolution of Political Cleavages in Israel 1949-2019 Yonatan Berman August 2020 Inequality, Identity, and the Long-Run Evolution of Political Cleavages in Israel 1949{2019 Yonatan Berman∗ y August 20, 2020 Abstract This paper draws on pre- and post-election surveys to address the long run evolution of vot- ing patterns in Israel from 1949 to 2019. The heterogeneous ethnic, cultural, educational, and religious backgrounds of Israelis created a range of political cleavages that evolved throughout its history and continue to shape its political climate and its society today. De- spite Israel's exceptional characteristics, we find similar patterns to those found for France, the UK and the US. Notably, we find that in the 1960s{1970s, the vote for left-wing parties was associated with lower social class voters. It has gradually become associated with high social class voters during the late 1970s and later. We also find a weak inter-relationship between inequality and political outcomes, suggesting that despite the social class cleavage, identity-based or \tribal" voting is still dominant in Israeli politics. Keywords: Political cleavages, Political economy, Income inequality, Israel ∗London Mathematical Laboratory, The Graduate Center and Stone Center on Socio-Economic Inequality, City University of New York, [email protected] yI wish to thank Itai Artzi, Dror Feitelson, Amory Gethin, Clara Mart´ınez-Toledano, and Thomas Piketty for helpful discussions and comments, and to Leah Ashuah and Raz Blanero from Tel Aviv-Yafo Municipality for historical data on parliamentary elections in Tel Aviv.
    [Show full text]
  • Women in the Knesset: Compilation of Data Following the Elections to the Twenty-Third Knesset
    Women in the Knesset: Compilation of Data Following the Elections to the Twenty-third Knesset Written for International Women’s Day 2020 Review Written by: Ido Avgar and Etai Fiedelman Approved by: Orly Almagor Lotan Design and production: Knesset Printing and Publications Department Date: 12 Adar 5780, 8 March 2020 www.knesset.gov.il/mmm The Knesset Research and Information Center Women in the Knesset: Compilation of Data Following the Elections to the Twenty-third Knesset Table of Contents Summary ................................................................................................................................ 1 .1 Female Knesset Members over Time........................................................................ 3 .2 Female Candidates and Elected Members, Sixteenth–Twenty-third Knessets . 4 .3 The Twenty-third Knesset—Analysis by List ........................................................... 9 .4 Female Knesset Functionaries ................................................................................. 11 .5 Comparing Israel to the Rest of the World ............................................................ 15 .6 Quotas for the Fair Representation of Women in Political Parties .................... 17 6.1 The Situation in Israel ............................................................................................. 18 www.knesset.gov.il/mmm The Knesset Research and Information Center 1 | Women in the Knesset: Compilation of Data Following the Elections to the Twenty-third Knesset Summary This document
    [Show full text]
  • Benjamin Netanyahu's Long Premiership and the Rise of The
    POLISH POLITICAL SCIENCE YEARBOOK, vol. 47(2) (2018), pp. 201–214 DOI: dx.doi.org/10.15804/ppsy2018203 PL ISSN 0208-7375 www.czasopisma.marszalek.com.pl/10-15804/ppsy Artur Skorek Jagiellonian University in Kraków (Poland) Benjamin Netanyahu’s Long Premiership and the Rise of the New Political Center: Is there a Qualitative Change in the Israeli Party System? Abstract: Israel’s party system has been characterized by the bipolar rivalry between the left-wing and right-wing blocks since the late 1970s. In recent years we could have seen at least two trends that seem to diverge from this model. For the last 9 years the Likud party has formed three successive governments which has made Benjamin Netanyahu the longest continuously serving prime minister in the history of Israel. Another new occurrence is the preservation of a significant representation of the center parties for four Knesset terms in the row. The aim of the paper is to verify whether Israel’s party system has departed from the two-blocs bipolar model. Based on the empirical data (election results, government formation, party’s political platforms) it examines whether the parties’ rivalry in the years 2009 – 2018 differed qualitatively from the previous period. To answer this question the pa- per investigates three hypotheses. First – Likud has become a dominant party in Israel. Sec- ond – a dominant and stable Israeli right-wing parties’ bloc has formed. Third – an enduring and relevant center sector has emerged in Israel’s party system. Keywords: Likud; Israel; party system; center; right-wing; left-wing Introduction The history of the Israeli party system can be divided into at least two phases.
    [Show full text]
  • SHOULD PALESTINIAN CITIZENS of ISRAEL BOYCOTT the ELECTIONS?: an AL-SHABAKA DEBATE by Nijmeh Ali and Yara Hawari
    Al-Shabaka Roundtable Al-Shabaka September 2019 SHOULD PALESTINIAN CITIZENS OF ISRAEL BOYCOTT THE ELECTIONS?: AN AL-SHABAKA DEBATE By Nijmeh Ali and Yara Hawari Overview ensure that suitable political ground is created, as the act of rejection without constructing a solid alternative Palestinian citizens of Israel earlier this year organized establishes a political passivity that is dangerous for a a campaign to boycott the April Knesset elections. colonized, occupied, and oppressed people. Under the banner of the “Popular Campaign for the [email protected] Boycott of the Zionist Elections,” the campaign called For instance, boycotting the elections could result in on Palestinians to refuse participation in the Israeli the dwindling of the Arab parties, which would lead to general elections so as not to recognize the Knesset as a a leadership vacuum. Despite criticism and frustrations, legitimate entity. parties still operate as the main organizing mechanism for political, social, civil, and national issues. Weakened As a result – and also due to disillusionment with parties would likely lead to the strengthening of the Arab Joint List, which had split from four united familial and sectarian communities and their political parties into two competing pairings – Palestinian voter organizing mechanisms, such as the hamula (clan) and turnout dropped below 50 percent. (Such turnout had mukhtars (elders). These mechanisms have historically been, for instance, 63 percent in 2015). In the run-up been vulnerable to co-optation by the Israeli regime to the September 17 elections, the Joint List has again and encourage fragmentation. fused, with the hope for a larger Palestinian turnout.
    [Show full text]
  • Chronology of Events in Israel and Palestine Appendices Iemed
    Chronologies Chronology of Events in Israel Appendices and Palestine In Israel, 2019 is a year with an elec- iteinu. And the other is the centrist can- the hope of avoiding a possible trial toral focus, with the country holding two didate Kajol Lavan (Blue and White) and, in turn, refloating negotiations to legislative elections. The economic formed by Benny Gantz’s centrist Ho- form a government, given that the three slowdown, the corruption scandals in- sen L’Israel (Resilience for Israel), Yahir court cases constitute one of the main volving the Prime Minister and Likud Lapid’s Yesh Atid (There Is a Future) stumbling blocks. However, after the leader Benjamin Netanyahu and the and Moshe Yaalon’s Telem (National hearings, in November the public pros- relentless divisions in the most con- Statesmanlike Movement). A draw in ecutor decides to officially indict Net- servative coalition government in Is- the elections, with both alliances taking anyahu for accepting bribes, fraud and Chronology in Events of Israel and Palestine raeli history formed by Likud (Consoli- 35 seats each, forces Netanyahu to ne- breach of trust. At the end of December, dation, conservative), Kulanu (All of Us, gotiate a coalition government again the sitting Prime Minister announces his centre-right), HaBayit HaYehudi (Jew- with the ultra-Orthodox and extreme intention to file an appeal before the ish Home, ultra-nationalist), Yahadut right-wing parties. An agreement is not Knesset in order to safeguard his par- Hatorah (United Torah Judaism, ultra- forthcoming, and so on 29 May new liamentary immunity. orthodox Ashkenazi) and Shas (World- elections are scheduled for 17 Septem- The successive demonstrations of the wide Association of Torah-Observant ber.
    [Show full text]
  • The Way Forward
    The Way Forward Israel and India as the two leading parliamentary democracies have traveled a long and difficult electoral terrain in the past 70 years toward political independence. Sharing commonalities on various socio- economic, religious and political issues, Israel and India also exhibit distinct differences on these issues. The successful holding of parliamen- tary elections from independence to date—twentieth in Israel and six- teenth in India—strengthens the spirit of their democratic survival. The political governance in the two nations in the twenty-first century assumes significance in view of transformation from politico–emotive issues to economico–pragmatic issues, especially in the aftermath of globalization of the 1980s. Their polities witness a unique feature of a shift from ‘one- party dominance’ to ‘multiparty coalition’, which came to be character- ized by the term, ‘Coalitional Multipolarity’. The focus of the book has been more on the changing dynamics of the parties and party systems of Israel and India. As both the countries share common historical and colonial experiences, the party formations in the two nations before and after independence get unprecedented signifi- cance. Researchers on parties and party systems might not have witnessed extensive commonalities in the systems of two parliamentary democratic © The Author(s) 2018 343 S.K. Choudhary, The Changing Face of Parties and Party Systems, DOI 10.1007/978-981-10-5175-3 344 The Way Forward nations in terms of their electoral behavior, democratic pattern of gover- nance, party dominance and uniform shifts in party systems. From this perspective, comparing democracies, parties and governance of Israel and India leave good scope for the new researchers to delve into the actual dynamics of the two systems.
    [Show full text]
  • Netanyahu and Erdogan Agree: Their Political Foes Are Traitors and Terrorists
    1/26/2021 Haaretz.Com Netanyahu and Erdogan agree: Their political foes are traitors and terrorists Both Turkey and Israel face elections, and both leaders are playing from the same ethno-nationalist political playbook. But in Turkey, the leftist opposition is still alive and kicking - even from jail Louis Fishman | Mar. 27, 2019 | 3:21 PM | 3 It was a rare occasion: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu - famously averse to being grilled by Israeli reporters – late last week made a surprise visit to the country’s most popular TV news outlet for an impromptu interview. The channel’s two political reporters seized the rare moment and interrogated him about yet more accusations of corruption and other campaign queries. But they certainly didn’t ask him to justify his calling the Arab parties in the Knesset supporters of terrorism. And they certainly didn’t challenge his recent remark that, "Israel is not a state of all its citizens. According to the Nation-State Law that we passed, Israel is the nation-state of the Jewish People - and them alone." >> For Turkey, All Kurds Are Terrorists >> For Netanyahu and His Ilk, Hatred Is Essential That comment sparked international condemnation, not least from Turkey. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s top aide, Ibrahim Kalin, tweeted: "I strongly condemn this blatant racism and discrimination. 1.6 million Arabs/Muslims live in Israel. Will Western governments react, or keep silent, under pressure, again?" Both Israel and Turkey are deep in election season, with Turkey’s municipal elections coming up on March 31, and Israel’s national elections on April 9.
    [Show full text]
  • Parties in Israel: Between Law and Politics
    Parties in Israel: Between Law and Politics ARIEL L. BENDOR* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRO DUCTIO N ................................................................................................... 115 II. ISRAELI POLITICAL PARTIES AND THE LAW ......................................................... 116 III. ISRAELI LAW STRENGTHENS THE STATUS OF THE POLITICAL PARTIES ................. 119 IV. ISRAELI LAW DIMINISHES THE STATUS OF THE POLITICAL PARTIES ..................... 123 V . THE O VERALL PICTURE ...................................................................................... 125 V I. C ONCLUSION ............................................................................................... ..... 126 I. INTRODUCTION The decline in the prestige and influence of Israeli political parties, particularly the larger parties, has become a source of distress for many in Israel. Similarly, in the United States, where the significance of parties is also recognized,' many have shown concern for weakening of the dominant political parties In the U.S. system where politics are ruled by two strong national parties, many fear possible damage to * Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, Haifa University, Israel. LL.B., LL.D., Hebrew University of Jerusalem. This essay was written during my stay at the Yale Law School in 1998-99. I am grateful to the Yale Law School for its hospitality, and to Michal Lebenthal-Andreson and Yael Talmon for their help. 1. See LEON D. EPSTEIN, POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE AMERICAN MOLD 9-39 (1986). 2. See Brian L. Porto, The Constitution and Political Parties: Supreme Court Jurisprudenceand Its Implicationsfor Partybuilding,8 CONST. COMM. 433 (1991). smaller parties and independent candidates.' But, in Israel, the nature of politics is becoming increasingly sectoral, personal, superficial and populist.4 As is often characteristic of public discourse in Israel, many hold the legal system responsible for this phenomenon.5 This Essay examines this contention by comparing Israeli and U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Israeli Labor Party and Its Palestinian "Partner"
    The Israeli Labor Party and Its Palestinian "Partner" by Prof. Shmuel Sandler BESA Center Perspectives Paper No. 891, July 11, 2018 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The low standings of the Zionist Camp list in public opinion polls floated a new demand for change at the top. As a result, the Labor party, the Zionist Camp’s senior partner, is again challenging its newly elected chairman, Avi Gabai. Despite replacing its leaders with each election campaign, Labor has never made a comeback to govern Israel. Because it is identified with Ramallah’s demands in any future settlement, Labor has suffered electoral punishment. An analysis of Labor’s performance over the past two decades reveals that its leadership has not yet internalized that instead of replacing its frontrunner, it should replace its alleged partner for a durable peace in the Arab-Israeli conflict. The low standings of the Zionist Camp list, formed before the last elections in 2014 by Labor, headed by Yitzhak Herzog, and the Movement party, headed by former foreign minister Tzipi Livni, floated a new demand for change at the top. The Labor party is thus once again challenging its newly elected chairman, Avi Gabai. But if Labor leaders want their party to become a real contender for the office of Prime Minister and an alternative to Likud rule, they should replace their partner for a durable solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict rather than replace their own leaders. What made the situation more acute was the election of Herzog, the former leader of Labor, as Chairman of the Jewish Agency.
    [Show full text]
  • Amir Peretz - Chairman Eran Hermoni - Secretary General Hilik Bar - International Secretary Israeli Labor Party
    Amir Peretz - Chairman Eran Hermoni - Secretary General Hilik Bar - International Secretary Israeli Labor Party Brussels, 13 May 2020 Dear Comrades, In this time of coronavirus pandemic, I hope you and your family are well. The COVID-19 virus has hit the whole world hard, Israelis and Palestinians included. We were happy to see the cooperation you showed to face this pandemic and we express our solidarity with you in this difficult time. I am writing to you concerning the coalition agreement signed by Benjamin Netanyahu for the Likud and Benny Gantz for Kahol Lavan. Now that the Knesset approved the amendments to the laws in order to allow the fulfilment of the agreement, and the High Court allowed Mr. Netanyahu to form a government, we suppose that the government will be set up. We understand that the decision to form a unity government is due to the need to fight against the COVID-19 pandemic in the best way. But we are very concerned by the coalition agreement itself, which includes annexation of parts of the occupied West Bank. We think that this move will damage forever the two-states solution, as will the Trump administration’s plan for the region. It is going against the fundamental principles of international law and UN resolutions on the Middle East peace process. We saw as well that you, as economy Minister, and Itzik Shmuli taking the welfare portfolio, will be part of the government. All PES members parties in the EU are committed to support the two-states solution and the Middle east peace process, as stated in UN resolutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparison of the Policies of Israel's Labor Party and the Likud On
    International Relations and Diplomacy, January 2017, Vol. 5, No. 1, 20-33 D doi: 10.17265/2328-2134/2017.01.002 DAVID PUBLISHING Comparison of the Policies of Israel’s Labor Party and the Likud on Palestinian Refugee Song NIU Shanghai International Studies University, Shanghai, China Xuan ZHANG Shanghai International Studies University, Shanghai, China Since its origin in the first Middle East War in 1948, the Palestinian refugee problem has not been properly resolved. Over the years, the key stakeholder Israel has put forward a variety of plans and countermeasures on refugee issues in multilateral and bilateral diplomatic stages. Researches on these policies of Israel on Palestinian refugees are crucial for solving this problem. The right wing and the left wing of political parties in Israel—Israel’s Likud and Labor Party had the longest and most influential rulings in the country. The refugee policies they have taken during their administrations have an impact on the development of the peace process in the Middle East, and also play a direct role in solving the problem of refugees. Through the analysis on refugee policies of the ruling party in various stages of the evolvement of the Arab-Israeli conflict, we can compare the Labor Party’s and the Likud Party’s policies for Palestinian refugees, and found that the policies of these two parties are consistent and similar on the issue of refugees, for example, neither of them recognize the responsibility of Israel on refugees, and they both denied the “right to return” of refugees, etc. In terms of the specific implementation of the policies, there are differences between them: the Likud Party was significantly tougher than the Labor Party.
    [Show full text]