The Conceptualization and Assessment of Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Conceptualization and Assessment of Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism The Conceptualization and Assessment of Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism: An Investigation of Common and Unique Features Richard C. Davies Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of MPsych/PhD April 24, 2015 Produced on archival quality paper The Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences University of Melbourne ii THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK iii Abstract Researchers agree that there are two narcissism expressions, specifically grandiose and vulnerable narcissism. However, their assessment remains contentious. The Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI; Raskin & Terry, 1988) assesses all aspects of grandiose narcissism for some whereas critics claim it assesses only ‘normal narcissism’. The alternative measure, the Pathological Narcissism Inventory (PNI; Pincus et al., 2009), is proposed to measure all aspects of grandiose and vulnerable narcissism, including that which is clinically-significant, despite inconsistent evidence of the nature of its second-order factors and little empirical validation in clinical populations. The aim of the research reported in this thesis was to adapt the NPI and the PNI to provide more appropriate measures of grandiose and vulnerable narcissism. This was investigated using four separate samples of university undergraduates. A total of 745 students completed a number of measures, including the NPI and PNI, along with self- esteem and Five-Factor personality measures. Additionally, one sample completed a lexical decision task designed to measure self-esteem indirectly (i.e., implicit self- esteem). As the focus of studies previously investigating how best to assess narcissistic grandiosity and vulnerability has been on content that distinguishes each, there has been little exploration of which narcissism features are common to these expressions beyond the investigation of entitlement and exploitative tendencies. It is argued in this thesis that comprehensive assessment of the narcissism expressions involves the identification and measurement of both common and unique features of narcissism. The current research examined the items loading on the subscales of the NPI and PNI before using these adapted subscales to construct new measures of the narcissism iv expressions. Items measuring common features of narcissism were first identified and distinguished from those assessing unique features of the expressions using factor analyses. The results of these analyses were used to construct new measures. The associations of these measures with proposed correlates of narcissism were compared to those of the PNI grandiosity and vulnerability measures. Five separate studies were conducted. In Studies 1 and 2, the factor structures of the NPI and PNI were of interest because the results of previous studies have failed to replicate findings. Accordingly, these scales were submitted to exploratory factor analyses. In most cases, the original subscales of these measures reported by Raskin and Terry (1988) and Pincus and colleagues (2009), established using principal components analyses, were found. The NPI and PNI factors, established in Studies 1 and 2, were then used to compare models of grandiose and vulnerable narcissism. One model used PNI subscales alone (i.e., the PNI grandiosity and vulnerability scales), whilst a new model included NPI and PNI subscales to assess both common and unique features of the narcissism expressions. Studies 4 and 5 compared the relationships of both these new measures of grandiose and vulnerable narcissism and the PNI’s second- order grandiosity and vulnerability factors with measures of implicit and explicit self- esteem and the Big-Five domains. The new measures yielded associations consistent with previous research of Five-Factor model personality domains that distinguish the expressions and also support a proposed moderation of explicit self-esteem by implicit self-esteem reflecting the mask model and inverted mask proposition of narcissism. On balance, predicted findings were more consistently found for the new measures than for the PNI grandiosity and vulnerability scales. Taken together, the results of this research program indicate that the newly-developed measures which consider common features at the core of narcissism are more v appropriate measures of grandiosity and vulnerability than the PNI subscales. It is also concluded that both the NPI and the PNI are required to assess both narcissism expressions. Future research could further examine subsets of characteristics that distinguish the expressions within identified common features. For example, previous research (e.g., Besser & Priel, 2010; Raskin, Novacek, & Hogan, 1991b) suggests that the common feature of attention seeking, is expressed as a craving for admiration in narcissistic grandiosity but as a need for approval, in vulnerability. The new measures, using established NPI and PNI subscales, do not currently target such distinctions. vi THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY BLANK vii Declaration This is to certify that (i) this thesis comprises only my original work, (ii) due acknowledgement has been made in the text to all other material used, (iii) the thesis is less than 100,000 words in length, exclusive of tables, figures, reference lists, footnotes and appendices. _______________________________________ Richard Clarke Davies April 24, 2015 viii THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY BLANK ix Acknowledgement First, I would like to thank my supervisor, Associate Professor Jennifer Boldero, for her great patience, encouragement, generosity and expertise over the course of the last four or so years. Thanks especially for being both my steadfast mentor and when needed, a formidable critic. It really has been an enormous adventure that I may not have completed without you. Secondly, thanks to my PhD committee, which included two esteemed clinical psychologists and researchers, Associate Professor Carol Hulbert and my chair, Professor Henry Jackson. They have remained enthusiastic and supportive as I became tangled up in the intricacies of some of the oldest psychological perplexities. A very special appreciative mention to Professor Nicholas Haslam for being the acting chair on my PhD panel when Henry was unavailable. Thirdly, I’d like to thank the Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences at the University of Melbourne, particularly, the adminstrative staff on the 12th floor who ensure that student research proceeds with a minimum of fuss and interference. Additionally, I’d like to thank the IT staff for their prompt and practical help when my experimental tasks uncovered unforseen technical issues. I’d also like to thank the Personality and Social Psychology team for being an inspiring and friendly group of academics and students. I was honoured to work as an undergraduate tutor of social/personality psychology whilst undertaking this research. Fourthly, I’d like to thank the Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences and the Melbourne Scholarships Office, for their generous financial assistance over the duration of this project. I’d also like to thank Melbourne Research for their understanding and flexibility when things didn’t go to plan. x Fifth, I’d like to thank my Mpsych/PhD colleagues for their comradery during the journey. I am also grateful for the support of my colleagues in the private and public mental health sectors, who have heard me talk many times about finishing the thesis. Likewise, I’d like to thank my friends who remained brave enough to ask “how’s it going?”. Finally, I’d like to thank my partner, Harry Kyriakou, for foregoing many opportunities of day trips or weekends away whilst I wrote and re-wrote this work. We have both now embarked on new careers at a mature age and believe it’s been worth the challenge. …And a special mention to Woody and Tash, a couple of whippets, who have taken me on many a walk to keep my mind alert to the possibilities. xi Table of Contents Abstract .............................................................................................................. iii Declaration ............................................................................................................. vii Acknowledgement ....................................................................................................... ix Table of Contents ......................................................................................................... xi List of Tables ............................................................................................................ xix List of Figures ............................................................................................................ xxi List of Appendices ................................................................................................... xxiii Introduction ................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Justification for the Research ................................................................. 6 1.2 Thesis Outline ........................................................................................ 6 1.3 Terminology .......................................................................................... 8 1.4 Summary ............................................................................................... 9 Chapter 2. The Conceptualization of Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism .......... 11 2.1 Introduction ........................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Teacher Resources – Trauma Responses in Early Teens and Adolescence
    HOW CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE EXPERIENCE AND REACT TO TRAUMATIC EVENTS Booklet produced for the Victorian Bushfire Support and Training for Affected Schools Project May 2010 D1.2 This project was funded by the Australian Government. 1 AUSTRALIAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT TRAUMA, LOSS & GRIEF NETWORK THE AUTHORS JUSTIN KENARDY, ROBYNE LE BROCQUE, SONJA MARCH, ALEXANDRA DE YOUNG Justin Kenardy is Professor of Medicine and Psychology at the University of Queensland and Deputy Director of the Centre for National Research on Disability and Rehabilitation Medicine. He is a clinical psychologist and works primarily with children and adults who have experienced traumatic injury. Robyne Le Brocque is a Senior Research Fellow at the Centre for National Research on Disability and Rehabilitation Medicine. She is a health sociologist. Her interests are in the psychological and developmental impact of trauma on children and families. Sonja March is a Research Fellow at the Centre for National Research on Disability and Rehabilitation Medicine. She is a clinical psychologist and her work has focused on treatment of anxiety in children and adolescents, particularly using the internet. Alexandra De Young is a PhD Scholar at the School of Psychology, University of Queensland. She is a psychologist and her expertise lies in the impact of trauma on very young children. ACATLGN is a national collaboration to provide expertise, evidence-based resources and linkages to support children and their families through the trauma and grief associated with natural disasters and other adversities. It offers key resources to help school communities, families and others involved in the care of children and adolescents.
    [Show full text]
  • Conduct and Behavior Problems: Intervention and Resources for School Aged Youth
    An introductory packet on Conduct and Behavior Problems: Intervention and Resources for School Aged Youth The Center is co-directed by Howard Adelman and Linda Taylor and operates under the auspices of the School Mental Health Project, Dept. of Psychology, UCLA, Box 951563, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1563 (310) 825-3634 Fax: (310) 206-5895; E-mail: [email protected] Permission to reproduce this document is granted. Please cite source as the Center for Mental Health in Schools at UCLA. Please reference this document as follows: Center for Mental Health in Schools at UCLA. (2008). Conduct and Behavior Problems Related to School Aged Youth. Los Angeles, CA: Author. Copies may be downloaded from: http://smhp.psych.ucla.edu If needed, copies may be ordered from: Center for Mental Health in Schools UCLA Dept. of Psychology P.O. Box 951563 Los Angeles, CA 90095-1563 The Center encourages widespread sharing of all resources Overview In this introductory packet, the range of conduct and behavior problems are described using fact sheets and the classification scheme from the American Pediatric Association. Differences in intervention needed are discussed with respect to variations in the degree of problem manifested and include exploration of environmental accommodations, behavioral strategies, and medication. For those readers ready to go beyond this introductory presentation or who are interested in the topics of school violence, crisis response, or ADHD, we also provide a set of references for further study and, as additional resources, agencies and websites are listed that focus on these concerns. 1 Conduct and Behavior Problems: Interventions and Resources This introductory packet contains: I.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Professional Child Care Providers in Preventing and Responding to Child Abuse and Neglect
    CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT USER MANUAL SERIES U.S. Depanment of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families Administration on Children, Youth and Families Children's Bureau Office on Child Abuse and Neglect The Role of Professional Child Care Providers in Preventing and Responding to Child Abuse and Neglect Kathy Karageorge Rosemary Kendall 2008 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families Administration on Children, Youth and Families ChildrenÊs Bureau Office on Child Abuse and Neglect Table of Contents PREFACE ......................................................................................................................................................1 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ....................................................................................................................... 3 1. PURPOSE AND OVERVIEW....................................................................................................... 7 2. RECOGNIZING CHILD ABUSE OR NEGLECT ...................................................................... 9 Types of Maltreatment ..................................................................................................................10 Cultural Diff erences ......................................................................................................................18 3. REPORTING SUSPECTED CHILD ABUSE OR NEGLECT ................................................... 21 Legal Requirements ......................................................................................................................21
    [Show full text]
  • Temper Tantrums
    Temper Tantrums What is a temper tantrum? A temper tantrum is an immature way of expressing anger. No matter how calm and gentle a parent you are, your child will probably throw some tantrums. Try to teach your child that temper tantrums don't work and that you don't change your mind because of them. By 3 years of age, you can begin to teach your child to verbalize his feelings ("You feel angry because...."). We need to teach children that anger is normal but that it must be channeled appropriately. By school age, temper tantrums should be rare. By adolescence, your teenager can be reminded that blowing up creates a bad impression and that counting to 10 can help him regain control. What should I do when my child has a tantrum? Overall, praise your child when he controls his temper, verbally expresses his anger, and is cooperative. Be a good model by staying calm and not screaming or having adult tantrums. Avoid spanking because it suggests to your child that you are out of control. Try using the following responses to the different types of temper tantrums. 1. Support and help children having frustration- or fatigue-related tantrums. Children often have temper tantrums when they are frustrated with themselves. They may be frustrated because they can't put something together. Young children may be frustrated because their parents don't understand their speech. Older children may be frustrated with their inability to do their homework. At these times your child needs encouragement and a parent who listens.
    [Show full text]
  • Statistical Modeling of the Time Course of Tantrum Anger
    Annals of Applied Statistics (in print) STATISTICAL MODELING OF THE TIME COURSE OF TANTRUM ANGER By Peihua Qiu†,‡ , Rong Yang§ and Michael Potegal∗,†,‡ University of Minnesota‡ and Bristol-Myers Squibb§ Although anger is an important emotion that underlies much overt aggression at great social cost, little is known about how to quantify anger or to specify the relationship between anger and the overt be- haviors that express it. This paper proposes a novel statistical model which provides both a metric for the intensity of anger and an ap- proach to determining the quantitative relationship between anger intensity and the specific behaviors that it controls. From observed angry behaviors, we reconstruct the time course of the latent anger intensity and the linkage between anger intensity and the probabil- ity of each angry behavior. The data on which this analysis is based consist of observed tantrums had by 296 children in the Madison WI area during the period 1994–1996. For each tantrum, eight angry be- haviors were recorded as occurring or not within each consecutive 30-second unit. So, the data can be characterized as a multivariate, binary, longitudinal (MBL) dataset with a latent variable (anger in- tensity) involved. Data such as these are common in biomedical, psy- chological, and other areas of the medical and social sciences. Thus, the proposed modeling approach has broad applications. 1. Introduction. Anger is an important emotion that can intrude into daily life as low intensity irritation. At higher intensity, it underlies overt aggression at great social cost. For example, it has long been established that anger can trigger partner abuse and assault (e.g., Burgess et al.
    [Show full text]
  • Rumpelstiltskin Suicide
    Suicidology Online 2011; 2:80-88. ISSN 2078-5488 Essay Rumpelstiltskin Suicide John T. Maltsberger Elsa F. Ronningstam McLean Hospital, Belmont, Massachusetts Harvard Medical School Department of Psychiatry Submitted to SOL: 28th October 2011; accepted: 11th December 2011; published: 23rd December 2011 Abstract: The fairy-tale of Rumpelstiltskin portrays the downfall of a morbid character who dies of suicide when his grandiose pretensions and sense of special entitlement are crushed. This imaginary elf is the model of certain patients who sustain a precarious, inflated self-organization through defensive overweening fantasy, but who are vulnerable to ego regression and suicide when their grandiose façades are compromised. The defensive grandiose-self of these patients is discussed according to Winnicott’s False Self formulation, and in terms of flawed superego structuring. They suffer from ego ideal malformations that invite fluctuations in self-esteem, ranging between profound shame and self-hate on one hand, to omnipotent hauteur on the other. Without reliable ego ideal identifications they must rely on chimerical self-fantasies to keep themselves together, pretending in one way or another to spin straw into gold. Lacking a dependable inner ideal, Rumpelstiltskin characters rely on idealized external objects for self-support. When such objects disappoint, as they almost invariably must, a switch from idealization to debasement occurs (object splitting) and they must be discarded—this is a moment of suicide vulnerability. Yet when reality intrudes too much and the grandiose-self cannot be maintained through the usual operations of distortion, projection, and denial, helped with buttressing from a sustaining external object, affective flooding will occur.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cycle of Tantrums, Rage, and Meltdowns in Children and Youth with Asperger Syndrome, High- Functioning Autism, and Related Disabilities
    The Cycle of Tantrums, Rage, and Meltdowns in Children and Youth with Asperger Syndrome, High- Functioning Autism, and Related Disabilities Professor Brenda Smith Myles University of Kansas, 11400 W. 155 th Terrace, Overland Park, KS, USA 66221 [email protected] Anastasia Hubbard University of Kansas, 7575 W. 106 th Street, Apt #272, Overland Park, KS 66212 USA [email protected] Problems related to stress and anxiety are common in children and youth with Asperger syndrome (AS), high-functioning autism (HFA), and related disabilities. In fact, this combination has been shown to be one of the most frequently observed comorbid symptoms in these individuals (Ghaziuddin, Weidmar-Mikhail, & Ghaziuddin, 1998; Kim, Szatmari, Bryson, Streiner, & Wilson, 2000). Stress and anxiety in these children is often triggered or results from environmental stressors such as having to face challenging social situations with inadequate social awareness, social understanding, and social problem-solving skills; a sense of loss of control; difficulty in predicting outcomes of everyday events and behaviors; as well as an inherent emotional vulnerability; misperception of social events, and a rigidity in moral judgment that results from a very concrete sense of social justice violations (Church, Alisanski, & Amanullah, 2000; Kim et al., 2000). The stress and anxiety experienced by individuals with AS, HFA, and related disabilities may manifest as withdrawal, reliance on obsessions related to circumscribed interests or unhelpful rumination of thoughts, inattention and hyperactivity. It may also trigger aggressive or oppositional behavior, often described as tantrums, rage, and “meltdowns” (Myles, Trautman, & Schelvan, 2004). Educators, mental health professionals, and parents often report that children with AS, HFA, and related disabilities appear to demonstrate aggressive or oppositional behavior with little or no prior warning.
    [Show full text]
  • Behavior Modification in Children with Temper Tantrums
    Behavior Modification in Children With Temper Tantrums by Kay Ireland, Demand Media Avoid reacting to your child's tantrum, which could reinforce the behavior. Related Articles How to Curb a Three-Year-Old's Temper Tantrum Behavior Modification for ADHD Children How to Stop Toddler Tantrums & Misbehaving How to De-Escalate a Tantrum Parenting: Behavior Modification for a 5 Year Old Signs of Abnormal Child Behavior It can happen anytime, anywhere -- your child erupts into a fit of screaming and crying. Your first instinct might be to give her whatever she wants to make the behavior stop, but doing so will just reinforce the behavior. Instead, take steps to stop the behavior quickly and then teach your child that throwing fits is completely ineffective in helping her get what she wants in the future. Sponsored Link 5 Foods you must not eat Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods. trimdownclub.com Redirect Attention When you're in the throes of dealing with a tantrum -- especially in a public place -- you need the behavior to stop as soon as possible. The practice of redirection and distraction often works as a quick fix to calm down your little one until you can address the behavior. The Colorado State University Extension website suggests redirecting your child's attention to something that makes her forget her tantrum altogether, like a toy or activity. While it might not always work, it could stop a minor tantrum from becoming a full-on meltdown. Avoid a Reaction Your child throws a tantrum because she wants to elicit a reaction from you.
    [Show full text]
  • Irritability, Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder, and Bipolar Disorder
    Pediatric Mood Dysregulation: Irritability, Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder, and Bipolar Disorder William P. French, MD March 24, 2018 Disclosure of Potential Conflicts Source Disclosure Pfizer, Shire, & Supernus Research Funding Pharmaceuticals Books, Intellectual Property none Advisor/ Consultant none Speakers’ Bureau Symposia Medicus Employee none In-kind Services (example: travel) Symposia Medicus Stock or Equity none Honorarium or expenses for this Symposia Medicus presentation or meeting Today’s agenda • Irritability • Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder • Severe Mood Dysregulation • Pediatric Bipolar Disorder • Yes, its controversial and rare, but it does exist • DSM 5 diagnostic criteria • Assessment • Medication and non-medication treatments • Take home message Key Points in Today’s Presentation • Irritability and/or “mood swings” don’t equal pediatric bipolar disorder (PBD). Irritability (a potential presenting complaint in bipolar mania) is a non-specific, common symptom present in many childhood psychiatric illnesses. • Multiple factors have led to a significant increase the diagnosis of PBD, leading to inappropriate prescribing of medications (e.g., antipsychotics) with serious side effect burdens. • NIMH research has worked to clarify unique neurobiological substrates and clinical courses in youth presenting with chronic vs. episodic irritability • PBD, while a “zebra” and not a “horse” does occur in youth, especially in the context of a strong family history. • Youth presenting with acute mania, ideally, should
    [Show full text]
  • Best Practices Guide to Intervention
    Teaching Students with Severe Emotional and Behavioral Disorders: BEST PRACTICES GUIDE TO INTERVENTION From Firwood & Oak Grove Schools A Connecting IDEAS Project funded by the Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction, State of Washington A joint venture with the Clover Park School District, Child Study and Treatment Center, and Seattle University School of Education SEATTLE UNIVERSITY Founded I891 lover '70ark SCHOOL fo~TRICT Copyright ©2005 BEST PRACTICES Running head: TEACHING STUDENTS WITH SEVERE EBD Teaching Students with Severe Emotional and Behavioral Disorders: Best Practices Guide to Intervention Clover Park School District Writing Team Bill Christensen Mary Jaeger Rick Lorenz Shirley Morton LuAnn Neuman Eileen Rieke Betty Simpson Carolyn Watkins Seattle University Editors Steven Curtis Holly Galbreath Jane Curtis Project Coordinator, Seattle University Larry Matsuda A Connecting IDEAS Project funded by the Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction, State of Washington A joint venture with the Clover Park School District, Child Study and Treatment Center and Seattle University School of Education Copyright © January 2005 BEST PRACTICES Table of Contents Preface ...................................................................................... vi Part I: Overview of Teaching Students with Severe EBD Introduction .................................................................................1 Definition and Prevalence of EBD ...............................................1 mk:@MSITStore:C:\Program Files\Microsoft
    [Show full text]
  • Five Cycles of Emotional Abuse: Codification and Treatment of An
    YOU ARE HOLDING 1.5 CEs IN YOUR HAND! How it works: Read this CE program and complete the post-test on page 19 and mail it to the Chapter office with your check. Score 80% or better and NASW will mail you a certificate for 1.5 CEs. It’s that easy! Five Cycles of Emotional Abuse: Codification and Treatment of an Invisible Malignancy By Sarakay Smullens, MSW, LICSW, BCD Dear Colleagues, nal exploring the preponderance of emotional abuse in my own life and in the life of my clients. These recordings led to an identifi ca- I presented my codifi cation of fi ve cycles of emotional abuse, the tion and documentation of fi ve cycles of parental and caretaker be- history of how this codifi cation developed, and various successful haviors that constitute emotional abuse. treatment options at the April 2006 NASW-MA Symposium. The fi ve cycles codifi ed—enmeshment, extreme overprotection In that workshop, I suggested that, in order to avoid burnout so and overindulgence, complete neglect, rage, and rejection/abandon- common in the helping professions, attendees embrace their most ment—were fi rst published in Annals, the journal of the American unsettling and painful life experiences and will themselves to learn Psychotherapy Association, in the Fall of 2002. In differing ways, from them. I strongly believe that this determination and focus both each cycle entraps its victim in replicative or reactionary relation- promotes and enhances the energy to cope in diffi cult and traumat- ships with family members, friends, teachers, employers, profes- ic times and, at the same time, enriches personal and profession- sional colleagues, and partners.
    [Show full text]
  • Childhood Traumatic Grief Educational Materials
    Childhood Traumatic Grief Educational Materials From the National Child Traumatic Stress Network Childhood Traumatic Grief Task Force Educational Materials Subcommittee This project was funded by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Childhood Traumatic Grief Educational Materials From the National Child Traumatic Stress Network Childhood Traumatic Grief Task Force Educational Materials Subcommittee Robin F Goodman, PhD, Judith Cohen, MD, Carrie Epstein, CSW, Matthew Kliethermes, PhD, Christopher Layne, PhD, Robert Macy, PhD, Dottie Ward-Wimmer, MA Dr. Goodman is a consultant to the NCTSN and Allegheny General Hospital. Dr. Cohen is with Allegheny General Hospital. Ms. Epstein is with the Safe Horizon-St. Vincent's Child Trauma Care Initiative. Dr. Kliethermes is with the Greater St. Louis Child Traumatic Stress Program. Dr. Layne is with Brigham Young University. Dr. Macy is with the Massachusetts Mental Health Institute. Ms. Ward-Wimmer is with the Wendt Center for Loss and Healing. National Child Traumatic Stress Network www.NCTSNet.org 2004 The National Child Traumatic Stress Network is coordinated by the National Center for Child Traumatic Stress, Los Angeles, Calif., and Durham, N.C. This project was funded by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The views, policies, and opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of SAMHSA or HHS. Childhood
    [Show full text]