Lok Sabha D.Ebates
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
'. MolWa1, J1I.e :l3'~1~. Seveath S.lel, Y01. V~ No. 1'1 As.db. 3, 1902 (IMa) LOK SABHA t D.EBATES 2.6) G ~~ . g~ ~~() --- (~ol. V contains Nos. 11··30) LOK .ABIIA SBORBTARlAT, MB"DBUD "~SeyeQda Serlel, Vol. V, IN Set.l_ J tio/IIOI (SaI&a) No.' II-M",",lIY, ,.", ZI, ''''l~laalza I, ."., (8.-) Columda OBITUARY REFERENCES. , . I~I6 '; (Shri Sanjay Ga'ltdh i, M.P.) Shri Kama1apati Tripathi \, . ' . 1_:'5 Shri Charan Singh . "5 , Shri Samar Mukherjee . ' . ~S-6 Prof. Madhu Dandavate . #, Shri C.T. Dhandapani 6-, Shri Atal Bihari \"ajpayee 1....;8 Shri Indrajit Gupta 8-9 Shri Yashwantrao Chavan 9-10 Shri A. Neelalohithadasan 10-11 Shri Mani Ram Bagri 11-12 Shri G.M. Bartatwalla 12-13 Shri Amar Roy Pradhan I3 Shri Ghulam RasooJ Kochak . 13-14 Shri N. Soundararajan 14 Shri Frank Anthony 14-IS LOIC SABRA DEBATES - I 2 LOK SAB,HA 'let, ~ If?:fIT ~ «< file. (4i '( ¥f1f'l.1at(, 8lh ~ "" ifiT ~ ~ Monday, June 23, 1980/ Asadha 2, q;T~~"~(, 1902 (Saka). m ~, aml ttCfi ~ q~.. "1!"l ci t\tati,( {f 1f1i I ~ fCijCfifijd ~ t:arT the Lok Sabha met at EleVen of the Clock. ~, "' Cfft ~"an If q(ff ,{:Ill \ ~, ~ ~ ~ {t~, ~ [MR, SPEAK~:R in the Chair] ~~e6~.n8lh~11i~ lft ~ ~:\f' aIh ~ CfiT ~ ~ OBITUARY REFERENCES ~I ~ q:tf ~ ~ (f11I' ~ t DEAT:::i OF SaRI SANJAy GANDm, XvI.P. ~ mr W 8lh ~"" WI ~ ~"(tan~~~~~ ~ ~ MR. SPEAKER: It is with most pro fqiiil{1 {T;f eIi~, ~ ~ tn: 41'\ found sorrow that I rise to announce tmr ~ ~ aft:;{ 1f {t ~ ~ {1' the untimely death of Shri Sanjay Gandhi, a Member of this House. It 'flIT I is a tragedy of human life that many a time a most promising career IS cut ~~, ~1"'4q(, ~ ~ cfi ~ short before it fulfils the high expccta ~, ~ ~~~r.nr~ ~ ticns and promises. He stood like a II ...1:- ~ I ~ ~ t{C!fi q I r~~"I ¥i;oar''''f (4 " ~ ~ ... rock by his mother, the Prime Minis~ ter, in times of great stress and strains ~ ~ anTlf CfiT m (, ~ ~ ~ through wlhich she was passing. lie ~fq;~~rnn ~t~ ~ came to symbolise the growing power lfft rn cfi ~ ~ ~ {::t ~ ~ of the younger generation of the coun ~~I rn~~~ ~ try and it was he who tried to mould ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ft4qIClI~C ~ 1f his youlfi powers intc, constructive and Q';f Cf)T ;;-r11 ~ ~ ~, \3"f 1fi nation-building actiyities: He was a promising young parliamentarian ~ arrm ~ ri (, ~ ~~ and made his mark rapidly into this q~dl{1" ~ r( atn: ~ ~I W 1f sphere. We had expected great f., tSqi~ Efi arh fit ctrt4 ~ t t nr t'fR things from him and we were quite ~ cfttt arh ~ rtt ~ 8Ih atta· sure that he would be able to fulfil these expectations With abu.ndant ~cfiaT~~tfl ~" ci confidence. Words fall short to ex "fG4ttl .. l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f.iC~4I\i press our sorrow. Our hearts go out to '3'; 1i" tn' I ~ ci 6Q flR'i N ;f 1.6( ~, the Prime Ministefr and 'We can onlY .,r'31 q MY Cfli ~ fcRT I assme her in this great moment of shoc'k and' tragedy that we will try to fulfil the promise and the dreamS which Sanjay Gandhi put before the youth of this country. " ..., (tft .1t4,,,h ""'141): *,1*"14(, ~ ~ 1(- ~ ~. ~ ":(f ~ ~I ~ ..., ,,==n II'l1fr 3. 'Obituartl References JUNE 23, 1980 Obituartl Reference, 4 [$Jft' ifi+H1iQf6. f~.qi6'] W'rl q 1t1t;ft ;fi ~ 1f" """ I If.r ~ srtr.f ;fm- aftt ~ ~ Cfi ~ 1t ~ ~, ~~~q1~t.T~ctt~ an'1: ~t.r ifi11f ~ ~'~£,.~(, cr.-r m srtr.f em ~'~qm~1 ~1f-cr~~ ¥4IWlq(, 1f' anfr-anft fqf("j44'"1 3flq'_ ~, ~ ~~,~ ~rn~ w ~df)I< ~ 'If" lt1n 'fT I ~ m lEi d... (1;f arr< - ~~(, q:~Hrn(1 -ctzf ~ m~ ~ ~ ~ f~~~" ~, ~ l""4E4 <, If ~ e6 fqm ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ao~:qlf {:arTl ~ ~_ trNt ~ m'1 ~ ~ ~ ~ I \1ft z;n ~ ~ +ft ~ 1l11T (I ~ 11t..rt -:r c6 ~ 1f- cfi 311 \4l 1&1 '11 If" if ~ ~, ~ qfVH( e6 ~ arN ~ ~, n- m"tf _" ~r I ~ ~ dll"4 r~ ~ ~, 1 921 cr~~~~~~~ 1m ~ dllf'Cl I~'f It aT ~, ~ ~ ct1 ~ tft«rr ~ mt1 t ~ qi ~, ~ ~. ~ ~ dUw:({ r(?l~ ~ ~ 1 30 cfi, 32 ~ ~'T ~ ~ cfi m-~ fif~(1 ~ ~ ~ 40 cfi, 42 cfi atl"<I~1'111f" 1f"u ~~~eftt ~~~~ ~ m~ ~I cf ~ c6 i1«n ~ '*1 -ft, ~ " ~?fi, +i1ri4i1(, ~ at ~ enn:vr ~, +i1'"44 <, ~ qf<41{ ~ ~ (f lTlI'Ti 1f- ~ ~ ~ orh ~ cfifG41 ~, " efi1 ~ lfl1f +t, q: ~ ~.~ Pc6 ~ ijl1lf if ~ rn ~, 'G(f~~I'1 ~ arh ~ qrr 1ft ~ t ~ ~ C1ft CflJT h~ {T ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ (f~(1 ~ cfi ~ ~~? ~, ~ qf(qll( 1f- tf I ~ If- fqtH''''''dl, :q.tiI q <, If'" ~ cfi m'tf ~ ~ ~arh~~~~~CfiT. , ~ fCfi • qf(cH( ~ lhJ ~ q_:u;rr ~~~~I 5fTCO ~ ~~, ~ ~ ~ I~ q~¥i(I"lIijl"r ~ ~~: (, 1:1 i1 t 1 92 1 t I~ < i 1Jt~... ~ ~ ~:'I ~~ ~ ~ ~ qio' ~ ~~, "q;l ~ Cfi ~ If" ian~, +i1~q<1 ~ q-~ 1f Wll'(' ~ CfiT, an1f ~ c:nr, ~ mnr ~ ~ ~ ~I ~ tf~ Cfii ~ ~, itT ~ ~ qfu;t.( ~ ~ (I srm ~~ qft ~ ~, ~uf P.1T , q ,~q (, If;f ~ l1hfr <1l11 ~ efi ~~ 1 arJijf~.~~~~ ~ If Cfil11 ~I # ~ fen ~ (I~~~:~~~ ~ "" rn ~, ~ erft ~ ~, ~ \ire1 (I \l'f 1f ~ anreT ( , GlfC?l«lii ~ ~ cfi cr ~ iT'i tnt ~I artl ~ (I ~ ~ ~ ct::~ ~I am:i\ren ~ ~ If, ~ 1930 ~ ~~~(~qIT~qrorr~ ~ ~ If ~ ~3fT:1 ~ en CfK1 ~ ~ (I ~ err lff (, ~1'"4q(1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ CfiTl1 ~ ~ \iff ~ \1fIT ( , arN10 ~~~, ~~~~~~ qt:'oq.~, ~ 1f- ~ ~ ~ tt ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r~<?tdl 'IT I ci ~ ~ '(I ~ ~ rn:- ~ ~ ~I({fjll ~ ~ c6 mm ~ ~ C\~ ~ ~ '( fct; q ~ q-(~, ~ ~ ~ q1 m ~ ~ ~ ~'f'«(1 ~ <:fiT, ~ ~~, ~ ar~;Q"&1 ~I ~ ~ ~ arh ~ ~ m ~ (, ~ .~ emf ~ qrr ~ r¥:l~(11 ~I CQf cnr ~ cni ~ ~, w ((... Ef«'G'11 Cifi1 w:rr.~ ~11\ tfttl• '""I ~ :qk: <f>T ~ en« ~ ~ ~ 1f ,I; 1;:lIIt (, If";f {f"tt (I \(t cnT \3'ij" ~ ~~, 1f' ~ "" ctrr ~ '~ ~ ~ \ifGr cr ~ ~ tftr # ~~~~tcn~~1f-('f 1JNt ~ GIft ~ 1f ~ ~ rn, ~ r:~ (, mu ~ ~ -':1 arN ~"n1?lt~,~, ~~rn' ~~(, ~(, ~arrqqi~ « ~'~d"'dl ~ cn1 ~ c6 ~ Cfi1 ~~ ~ ~ ~I arrtr r tN (, 11'" ~'~ (I tf;t ~ ~ 1942 ~ ~~~~£' ~~~ .".l".~" ~f 1{(1~'CiUq, qft, ;NT ~ ~ .~:. tf" ~:.n- '( arh: ~ ~:,~ ctrt ~ 6 t't' ~ arN ~ ~ ~ qf'( .. this shock which hi,s· family has got, ~or this grea.t tragedy, we have very '~.*"" ~ t1iT. ~ Cffl ~ deep sympathy. We'-request you to ~~I convey sorrow to the mother as' well as. to the relatives of Mr. Sanjay (1r n ~ m arcr;ft' ~q)(9t1l ~ Gandh'l. ctrot £ arh ~ ~:. 1f ~en: PROF. MADHU DANDA:VATE ~ ,,~rCfi tfm. ~ ;t I m (Rajapur): Sir, in this House, when ever you make obituary reteMnces, ( '" .. .. ~, (~): ~~ ~ the Prime Minist~ rises from her ~ arN"f arh ¥i Iij ;ft4 r~ q loi \;ft .r seat. to 'join you and the House. To t w "• q G9t I afi ~ 1f" ~ 'Cfl'lJ~ ~ ~~'q' day, we find that seat vacant and ( 'If arq;f ctiT ark ~ ~ Cf)f ~ rtoday, we have to console the Prime ~'f ~ art1'ht C(ijff~.t(r! ~ ~ Minister for the great loss that she bas ·sruffered. I am sure, we all Win CI q: 4i1¥\,J} ~ ~ ~ (I j oi'n you in conveying to the Prime ~ "1~qlij ~ '~ ~ ~ Cfi1 arrmarl Minister and the member:;. of the if)f e6fO«fit '<", tJT, \iff ~ ~ t.f11 bereaved family OUr heart.,.felt .coni ~ n- r.fi ~ ~ -~ cfi ~ arcr;f dolences. As Chaudhury ~b r~ghtly said, man ha~ to pass away ~ 1f- ~ ~ ~, ell ~ 1fllT (I one day or the other. But i~ the" \fltrT at ~ 'aft {t ~ ~, ~ arTlIT prime of youth, Sanjay Gandhi has ~Cf(~~1 ~~ ~ IPass'ed away. He had the shortest (I ~ ~ ~ ~ (I ~ ~:lf1f pOlitical life and the briefest parlia ~(, ~~~c:f)l'~ ( mentary career, He had an element ~ mft Cfi ~ '\iff ¥idl,¥ili ~ ~ ~ lOf adventur,~ in his political life and the same spirit of adventure 'he q;r ~ ~ ~I rq~ltS4Gf) ( \itT ~ displayed in his death. That is the ~ct1 ~~(~ ~ ~ irony of hiS' life·. But I am sure that .. f1: (1 ~, ~ ~, ar:;:qr at anft that spirit of adventure will enthuse ,iGltt:r '(, ~ ~: ~ t.flT f\6~1' ~ tf the ~emaining )71DUth to S'ae that the qirf;r ;r{r f'ct;lrr ~ ~ I ~ Pen youth power is developed. ~ do not want to say anything more. But I ,",,,;fl ~ r~~fl61 \ill ~ 1[- +it ~ .r can well imagine the anguish and arh ~ ~ CiFil am: ~ ~lrCif)ij M ~ the agony of the Prime Minister. It is m ~ Sff'6" ijq'>it'1I' ~ ~ ~ ~ not the agony and anguish of .a Prime atm ~ ~ fq:) arrcr ~ ijq1{ijl CfIT Minister alone, but it ~s the agony 01 atf '6C6 q ii.. ~ 'if I " ~ m~ (t q (Ii I,Ii I \a mother. I am sure, not only the ~ srN;n Cfi«IT ~ ~ ct{ ~ ~ members of this House, but all the children in this land, al'I sons and ~ ~ fq) ef ~ arrcrn; cnr ~ "I daug.hters will join you ill! conveying our condolences to her, the mother of SHRI SAMAR MUKHERJEE Sanjay Gandhi. (Howvah): W,~ eXpl"ess our very deep SOlTOW at the su~n demise of sUch. SHRI C.· T. DHANDAPAN'I a young man, who had already (Pollac'hi): We lost one of the developed himself' to be a topic of greatest pelrsonaUties of this country. the (I.'()UI1try. The news was so sudden We find ita very difftcult to recov'er jtlhat when W'€I ~ it, we could not from the shock which we had in the believe that such a tragedy can hap m,orning. Mr. Sanjay was one of the. pen so suddenly. His memory is Igreatest sparks of the Nehru family. very ~esh in our minds because the aHe revitalised the political pattern of . ~her day' also, he was amongst US this country.