DOCSLIB.ORG

J. Leonen, En Banc]

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
J. Leonen, En Banc] EN BANC G.R. No. 221697 - MARY GRACE NATIVIDAD S. POE­ LLAMANZARES, Petitioner, v. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS and ESTRELLA C. ELAMPARO, Respondents. G.R. No. 221698-700 - MARY GRACE NATIVIDAD S. POE­ LLAMANZARES, Petitioner, vs. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, FRANCISCO S. TATAD, ANTONIO P. CONTRERAS, and AMADO T. VALDEZ, Respondents. Promulgated: March 8, 2016 x---------------------------------------------------------------------~~o=;::.-~ CONCURRING OPINION LEONEN, J.: I am honored to concur with the ponencia of my esteemed colleague, Associate Justice Jose Portugal Perez. I submit this Opinion to further clarify my position. Prefatory The rule of law we swore to uphold is nothing but the rule ofjust law. The rule of law does not require insistence in elaborate, strained, irrational, and irrelevant technical interpretation when there can be a clear and rational interpretation that is more just and humane while equally bound by the limits of legal text. The Constitution, as fundamental law, defines the mm1mum qualifications for a person to present his or her candidacy to run for President. It is this same fundamental law which prescribes that it is the People, in their sovereign capacity as electorate, to determine who among the candidates is best qualified for that position. In the guise of judicial review, this court is not empowered to constrict the electorate's choice by sustaining the Commission on Elections' actions that show that it failed to disregard doctrinal interpretation of its powers under Section 78 of the Omnibus Election Code, created novel jurisprudence in relation to the citizenship of foundlings, misinterpreted and misapplied existing jurisprudence relating to the requirement of residency for election purposes, and declined to appreciate the evidence presented by petitioner as a whole and instead insisted only on three factual grounds j Concurring Opinion 2 G.R. Nos. 221697 and 221698-700 which do not necessarily lead to its inference. The Commission on Elections' actions are a clear breach of its constitutional competence. It acted with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack of as well as excess of jurisdiction. It is our law that a child, abandoned by her parents and left at the doorsteps of a rural cathedral, can also dream to become President of the Republic of the Philippines. The minimum requirements of the Constitution is that she be a natural-born Filipina at the time of the filing of her Certificate of Candidacy and have domicile in the Philippines for at least ten (10) years prior to the elections. 1 Given the facts of this case, petitioner has complied with these requirements. When she filed her certificate of candidacy, this court has yet to squarely rule on the issue of whether a foundling-a child abandoned by her parents-is a natural-born Filipino citizen. There are earlier rulings-Senate Electoral Tribunal Decision2 and the Bureau of Immigration Order3-that clearly state that petitioner is a natural­ born Filipina. She was elected as Senator of the Republic, garnering more than 20 million votes. 4 The position of Senator requires that the person be a natural-born Filipino. 5 The assertion that petitioner made in her Certificate of Candidacy for President that she is a natural-born citizen is a grounded opinion. It does not constitute a material misrepresentation of fact. In much the same way, a Justice of this court does not commit material misrepresentation when he or Const., art. VII, sec. 2 provides: I ARTICLE VII. Executive Department SECTION 2. No person may be elected President unless he is a natural-born citizen of the Philippines, a registered voter, able to read and write, at least forty years of age on the day of the election, and a resident of the Philippines for at least ten years immediately preceding such election. Rollo (G.R. No. 221697), pp. 2706-2736. The Decision was concurred in by Senators Paolo Benigno "Barn" A. Aquino IV, Pilar Juliana "Pia" S. Cayetano, Cynthia A. Villar, Vicente C. Sotto III, and Loren B. Legarda, and dissented from by Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio, Associate Justices Teresita J. Leonardo-De Castro and Arturo D. Brion, and Senator Maria Lourdes Nancy S. Binay. Id. at 3827, Petitioner's Memorandum. 4 COMELEC Official May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections Results <http://www.comelec.gov. ph/?r= Arch ives/Regu larE lections/2013 NLE/Results/SenatorialE lections201 3> (visited March 7, 2016). Const., art. VI, sec. 3 provides: ARTICLE VI. The Legislative Department SECTION 3. SECTION 3. No person shall be a Senator unless he is a natural-born citizen of the Philippines, and, on the day of the election, is at least thirty-five years of age, able to read and write, a registered voter, and a resident of the Philippines for not less than two years immediately preceding the day of the election. Concurring Opinion 3 G.R. Nos. 221697 and 221698-700 she construes the Constitution in an opinion submitted for this case that a foundling is a natural-born citizen absent any clear and convincing evidence to the contrary. In the first place, this is an interpretation of law-not a statement of material fact. Doing justice and discharging our duty to uphold the rule of law require that we conclude that foundlings are natural-born Filipino citizens absent any evidence that proves the contrary. This is the inescapable conclusion when we read the provisions on citizenship in the context of the entire Constitution, which likewise mandates equality, human dignity, social justice, and care for abandoned children. The Constitution requires that either the father or the mother is a Filipino citizen. 6 It does not require an abandoned child or a foundling to identify his or her biological parents. 7 It is enough to show that there is a convincing likelihood that one of the parents is a Filipino. Contrary to the respondents' submissions, it is not blood line that is required. One of the parents can be a naturalized Filipino citizen. 8 The reference is only one ascendant generation. The constitutional provision does not absolutely require being born to an indigenous ethnicity. There is no rational basis to conclude that the loyalty to this country of a foundling, discovered in a rural area and adopted by well-to-do parents, will be more suspect than a child born to naturalized Filipino parents. That a foundling is a natural-born Filipino, unless clear and convincing evidence is shown otherwise, is also the definitive inference from contemporaneous acts of Congress9 and the Executive. 10 This is also the availing conclusion considering our binding commitments in international law. 11 There is clear and convincing evidence from the history of the actual text of the entire Constitution. 6 CONST., art. IV, sec. 1 provides: ,f ARTICLE IV. Citizenship SECTION 1. The following are citizens of the Philippines: (I) Those who are citizens of the Philippines at the time of the adoption of this Constitution; (2) Those whose fathers or mothers are citizens of the Philippines; (3) Those born before January 17, 1973, of Filipino mothers, who elect Philippine citizenship upon reaching the age of majority; and (4) Those who are naturalized in accordance with law. 7 CONST., art. IV, sec. 1. 8 CONST., art. IV, sec. 1. 9 See Rep. Act No. 8552 (1998) and Rep. Act No. 8043 (1995). 10 See Rollo (G.R. No. 221697), pp. 22-26, Petition. Petitioner was granted an order of reacquisition of natural-born citizenship under Republic Act No. 9225 by the Bureau oflmmigration on July 18, 2006. The President of the Philippines appointed her as Chairperson of the Movie and Television Review and Classification Board-a government position that requires natural-born citizenship--on October 6, 2010. 11 On August 21, 1990, we ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. We also ratified the 1966 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights on October 23, 1986. Concurring Opinion 4 G.R. Nos. 221697 and 221698-700 In the case at bar, petitioner discharged her burden to prove that she is natural-born when the parties stipulated as to her status as a foundling found in front of a church in Jaro, Iloilo. 12 When the yardsticks of common sense and statistics are used, 13 it borders on the absurd to start with the presumption that she was born to both a foreign father and a foreign mother. In all likelihood, she was born to at least a Filipino father or to a Filipino mother, or both. Foundlings present the only ambiguous situation in our Constitution. There is no slippery slope. Malevolent actors that wish to avail themselves of this doctrine will have to prove that they are foundlings. They will have to do so with the requisite quantum of proof for immigration purposes. They will have to do so if it is also necessary for them for purposes of being candidates in a relevant election. The Commission on Elections committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction when it went beyond its competence under Section 78 14 of the Omnibus Election Code and the Constitution by not ruling exclusively on whether there was material misrepresentation. The questioned Resolutions of the Commission on Elections En Banc in these cases create a new and erroneous doctrine on this point of law. It is contrary to the text and spirit of the Constitution. Likewise, this court has yet to decide on a case that squarely raises the issue as to whether the period of residency required by the Constitution of a candidate running for public office can only commence after he or she reacquires his or her Filipino citizenship. Neither has this court expressed the ratio decidendi that only when he or she has a resident visa can we commence to count his or her period of residency for election purposes.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1 Angel Locsin Prays for Her Basher You Can Look but Not Touch How
    2020 SEPTEMBER Philippine salary among lowest in 110 countries The Philippines’ average salary of P15,200 was ranked as among the Do every act of your life as if it were your last. lowest in 110 countries surveyed by Marcus Aurelius think-tank Picordi.com. MANILA - Of the 110 bourg’s P198,500 (2nd), countries reviewed, Picodi. and United States’ P174,000 com said the Philippines’ (3rd), as well as Singapore’s IVANA average salary of P15,200 is P168,900 (5th) at P168,900, 95th – far-off Switzerland’s Alawi P296,200 (1st), Luxem- LOWEST SALARY continued on page 24 You can look but not Nostalgia Manila Metropolitan Theatre 1931 touch How Yassi Pressman turned a Triple Whammy Around assi Press- and feelings of uncertain- man , the ty when the lockdown 25-year- was declared in March. Yold actress “The world has glowed as she changed so much shared how she since the start of the dealt with the pandemic,” Yassi recent death of mused when asked her 90-year- about how she had old father, the YASSI shutdown of on page 26 ABS-CBN Philippines positions itself as the ‘crew PHL is top in Online Sex Abuse change capital of the world’ Darna is Postponed he Philippines is off. The ports of Panila, Capin- tional crew changes soon. PHL as Province of China label denounced trying to posi- pin and Subic Bay have all been It is my hope for the Phil- tion itself as a given the green light to become ippines to become a major inter- Angel Locsin prays for her basher crew change hub, crew change locations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Celebrity's Right to Autonomous Self-Definition
    65 THE CELEBRITY’S RIGHT TO AUTONOMOUS SELF-DEFINITION AND FALSE ENDORSEMENTS: ARGUING THE CASE FOR A RIGHT OF PUBLICITY IN THE PHILIPPINES Arvin Kristopher A Razon* Abstract With the Philippines being the top country in terms of social media usage, social media platforms have expanded opportunities for celebrities to profit from their fame. Despite the pervasiveness of celebrity culture in the country and the increasing number of unauthorised celebrity advertisements in such platforms, the right of publicity does not explicitly exist in Philippine law. This paper explains that the lack of an explicit statute-based right of publicity does not mean that it does not exist in common law or other statutory law. Centred on the minimalist path of law reform, the paper argues that the existing right to privacy in Philippine law can justify a right to publicity, anchored on the right to protect unwarranted publicity about oneself regardless of one’s status in the public eye, as well as on the right to autonomous self-definition. The illustrative cases in this paper evidence the hurt feelings celebrities suffer from unwanted publicity. A publicity right also exists as a property right under local intellectual property laws on unfair competition. I. Introduction The opportunity to economically exploit one’s name, likeness or identity, often through celebrity endorsements, is a perk that comes with being a celebrity.1 The internet, particularly social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, has expanded the opportunities for celebrities to profit from their fame, providing them with another channel by which they can endorse brands to a global audience, * BA Organizational Communication (magna cum laude), Juris Doctor (University of the Philippines), LLM (University of Melbourne); Lecturer, De La Salle University.
    [Show full text]
  • Lopez Group Reiterates CSR Commitment At
    Dec. 08-Jan. 09 Available online at www.benpres-holdings.com Christmas greetings from OML, MML and EL3 ...p. 5 Int’l banks show Lopez Group reiterates CSR commitment support for First at Clinton Global Initiative Meeting Gen, First Gas...p. 3 CHAIRMAN Oscar M. Lopez (OML) reiterated the Chairman Lopez and daughter Rina Lopez Group’s commitment to pursue corporate social receive the CGI Certificate of responsibility (CSR) projects that will improve the lives Acknowledgment presented by former of the marginalized, especially in causes for the environ- US President Clinton to Knowledge ment and education. Channel. He announced twin donations worth almost P420 million as the group’s “Commitment to Action” during the first Clinton Global Initiative (CGI) Asia Meeting in Hong Kong in early December. At the same time, the Knowledge Channel Foundation Inc. (KCFI) headed by Rina Lopez-Bautista was one of the six models of commitments presented by former US President Bill Clinton at the closing ceremonies of the CGI meet. Knowledge Channel received the highest commenda- tions from the former US President for its pioneering efforts to provide poor and marginalized but bright chil- dren in far-flung areas in the country free access to com- puter/Internet education. Clinton said the KCFI program should be replicated elsewhere in the world. “I would like to compliment them for what they’re doing A look back at 2008…p. 5 and for others to replicate this in their countries,” he said. Turn to page 7 PHOTO: ROSAN CRUZ ABS-CBN goes beyond TV WHO would have thought, back in Only a year later, in 1958, ABS- the mid-1950s, that a couple of fledg- CBN rolled out what would be the ing radio stations and a TV network first of many innovations under Don under the leadership of a man not Ening and his son Eugenio “Geny” yet 30 years old would grow into the Lopez Jr., then 28, who was tasked country’s largest media conglomerate? to run the company: the country’s ABS-CBN Broadcasting Corp.
    [Show full text]
  • Philippines May Lose Trade Perk
    MAY 2018 Philippines may lose trade perk As Philippines reaches middle income status, European exports may be subject to tariffs MANILA - The Philippines may (EU) which is aimed at poorer middle income status in 2019. Philippine products to enter the region at soon lose its eligibility for a trade nations, in view of a report that zero tariff. perk from the European Union says the country may reach upper Under current rules, the EU’s prefer- TRADE PERK ential trade scheme allows thousands of continued on page 12 Onlookers could not help Spotlight but say that Marian looks AVENIDA RIZAL, 1956 more gorgeous these days, which she would grateful- ly acknowledge with the sweetest smile. Careful not to take the thunder away from the movie’s leads, she humbly said, “I’m here to support the people I love. Barbie who is with me in ‘Sunday Pinasaya,’ Derrick, and of course Direk Lou- ie, our director [in the noontime show], whom I love so dearly. Ex- cited siyempre akong makita yung movie, especially since it was shot in Italy. ‘Di ba kagagaling lang namin sa Europe,” she enthused. The European vacation was SHUT UP another unforgettable experience SUPREME COURT TELLS ROBEREDO, MARCOS for Marian and her family. “We really had fun everywhere we went, visiting most of them for the first time. Nag-enjoy rin si Zia and that’s what’s important—yung JADINE - JADAONE Issue : ma-enjoy niya ‘yung mga lugar na pinupuntahan namin and all the activities we do. Saka ang sarap “Other People Make it Bigger” niyang bihisan kasi ang cute,” Marian dotingly giggled.
    [Show full text]
  • Filipino Centre Toronto's Sexin the PHL Embassies?
    ittle anila LJUNE. - JULYM 2013.Confidential Why are there so many Filipino Centre Toronto’s Filipino Nurses in the US? by Rodel Rodis Pistahan Parada ng lechon, Singing Contests and Santacruzan This was the question posed to me by a are still Popular curious TV reporter on May 7, just three days after a stretch limousine traveling across the San Mateo Bridge carrying nine Filipino nurses to a bridal party suddenly burst into flames killing five of the occupants, including the bride. When she interviewed me in my law office in San Francisco, Ann Notarangelo, the reporter who is the weekend anchor of CBS 5’s Eyewitness News, explained that she was only asking the question because it was on the minds of her viewers. She thought I might know the answer as I taught Filipino American History at San Francisco State University and I am the legal counsel of the Philippine Nurses Association of Northern California. Plus, I Reina delas Flores Nica Victa is one of the reinas at the Santacruzan at FCT’s Pistahan. INSET FROM TOP, Newly-crowned PIDC Little Miss added, I am also married to a Filipino nurse. Philippines Britney Waito sings at the Pistahan; Michael Magali is the winner in the singing contest in the adult division; The Blessed Virgin Mary Ann said that she was frankly surprised to was escorted by the Hermanos and Hermanas; KC Partridge is one of the Ave Maria girls; Reina Banderada, who symbolizes the arrival of learn that 20% of all the registered nurses in Christianity was represented by the 2013 Miss Philippines of PIDC, Lauren Fernandez, is escorted by Philip Beloso.
    [Show full text]
  • 2004 01 Inside Pages
    UP Film Institute Filmography of Filipino Films 2003 Introduced by Lucenio Martin L. Lauzon Compiled by Virginia D. Cuyugan and Lucenio Martin L. Lauzon with assistance from Pol del Mundo of the Movie and Television Review and Classification Board (MTRCB) Ana Fajardo of the Film Academy of the Philippines (FAP) Edwin Joaquin of the MOWELFUND Film Institute The Filipino film celebrates this year its 85th anniversary but its activities and achievements through the years still need to be documented and assessed fully and systematically. Today, the country is still wanting not only in the capability to preserve its film heritage but also in the determined and sustained efforts to collect and preserve existing data on Filipino film for posterity. It does not help that the conservation of Filipino heritage, taxing and tedious as it is already, is appreciated by only a few individuals even within the industry. As an institution dedicated to the study of films, the UP Film Institute (UPFI) shall try to help in the task of gathering, classifying and disseminating data on the Filipino film. As part of its commitment to the public, the UPFI shall make these data available to everyone through the publication of a systematic and comprehensive listing of Filipino films, beginning with those produced in 2003. This year is most apropos as it was also in 2003 that the UPFI was formally established by virtue of the UP Board of Regents resolution. The UPFI realizes that such filmographies are indispensable for anyone who wants to gain an overview of the film landscape in the country and to make necessary, informed and authoritative observations on the state of the Filipino film industry.
    [Show full text]
  • Millennial Traversals Outliers, Juvenilia, & Quondam Popcult Blabbery ALSO by JOEL DAVID
    UNITAS Millennial Traversals Outliers, Juvenilia, & Quondam Popcult Blabbery ALSO BY JOEL DAVID The National Pastime: Contemporary Philippine Cinema Fields of Vision: Critical Applications in Recent Philippine Cinema Wages of Cinema: Film in Philippine Perspective Book Texts: A Pinoy Film Course (exclusively on Amauteurish!) Manila by Night: A Queer Film Classic SINÉ: The YES! List of 100+ Films That Celebrate Philippine Cinema (with Jo-Ann Q. Maglipon; forthcoming) VOLUME 89 • NUMBER 1 UNITASSemi-annual Peer-reviewed international online Journal of advanced reSearch in literature, culture, and Society Millennial Traversals Outliers, Juvenilia, & Quondam Popcult Blabbery PART II: EXPANDED PERSPECTIVES Joel david since 1922 Indexed in the International Bibliography of the Modern Language Association of America Millennial Traversals: Outliers, Juvenilia, & Quondam Popcult Blabbery (Part II: Expanded Perspectives) Original Digital Edition Copyright 2015 by Joel David and Ámauteurish Publishing. All Rights Reserved. Cover still from Tiyanak, © 1988 Regal Films. All Rights Reserved. UNITAS is an international online peer-reviewed open-access journal of advanced research in literature, culture, and society published bi-annually (May and November). UNITAS is published by the University of Santo Tomas, Manila, Philippines, the oldest university in Asia. It is hosted by the Department of Literature, with its editorial address at the Office of the Scholar-in-Residence under the auspices of the Faculty of Arts and Letters. Hard copies are printed on demand or in a limited edition. Copyright @ University of Santo Tomas Copyright The authors keep the copyright of their work in the interest of advancing knowl- edge but if it is reprinted, they are expected to acknowledge its initial publication in UNITAS.
    [Show full text]
  • Searching for Success
    Searching for Success in Judicial Reform TECHNICAL EDITOR: Livingston Armytage NETWORK FACILITATOR: Lorenz Metzner Searching for Success in Judicial Reform Voices from the Asia Pacific Experience Asia Pacific Judicial Reform Forum 1 1 YMCA Library Building, Jai Singh Road, New Delhi 110 001 Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in India by Oxford University Press, New Delhi © United Nations Development Programme 2009 This publication was prepared in partnership with the Asia Pacific Judicial Reform Forum (APJRF) The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization.
    [Show full text]
  • Recruiters to Schools: Revamp Courses
    Msgr. Gutierrez Riz A. Oades Community Summer Vacation REMEMBERING BERNIE OADES: GK’s Tony Meloto to Speak at The Compassionate or Vocation? Musician of Decades USD School of Law July 21st July 17 - 23, 2009 Recruiters to schools: Revamp courses PHILIPPINE NEWS FilAm Debutante Ariel Bautista SERVICE -- THE recruit- Philippine Visit 2004: ment industry yesterday McCarty Comes of Age at 18 challenged the education sector to evaluate their cur- Debutante Ball is a rent course offerings amidst The Philippine showcase the millions of unemployable co llege graduates who are Time-Honored Tradition joining the labor force each year. in Philippine Culture at Villa Escudero Recruitment consultant Lito B. Soriano said that The tradition marks the passage from girlhood to there is a serious gap in the womanhood that is solemnized with a grand ball, education system that per- an even grander cake, a prayer blessing before the sists in having curricula that feast, and the exchange of words of wisdom and are unsuitable to provide their graduates with the pos- affection over 18 candles and 18 roses. sibility of employment. Of the 1,000,000 col- lege graduates annually, only 5-10% are employed in jobs consistent to their course, only 30-40% will find any employment. The vast majority of graduates will remain unemployed. Tens of thousands (possibly two-three hundred thousand) nurses and other medically- trained persons who do not qualify for OFW positions due to lack of hospital ward and practical experience, will have no jobs. Many nurses end up paying for a job in a desperate attempt to get the necessary ward experience.
    [Show full text]
  • Oca Circular No. 06-2004
    Hepublic of tlJe -t1t}i1ippillC9 ~uprcrnt l.ourt <Officl of tlJc (Ollrt ,.AbministrMor mdnila OCA CIRCULAR NO. 06-2004 TO : THE COURT OF APPEALS, SANDIGANBAYAN, COURT OF TAX APPEALS, REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS, SHARl' A DISTRICT COURTS, METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS IN CITIES, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS, SHARI' A CIRCUIT COURTS, 'mE OFFICE OF THE STATE PROSECUTOR, PUBLIC DEFENDERS OFFICE AND THE INTEGRATED BAR OF THE PHILIPPINES SUBJECT: INDEFINITE SUSPENSION OF ATTY. ALAN PAGUIA FROM THE PRACTICE OF LAW For the information and guidance of all concerned, quoted hereunder is the Decision of the Supreme Court En Banc dated November 25,2003 in G.R No. 159486-88 entitled '"President Joseph Ejercito Estrada vs. Hon. Sandiganbayan", to wit: "On 23 September 2003, this Court issued its resolution in the above- numbered case, it read: "The case for consideration has been brought to this Court via a Petition for Certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court filed by Joseph Ejercito Estrada, acting through his counsel Attorney Alan F. Paguia, against the Sandiganbay®, et al. The Petition prays - . "1. That Chief Justice Davide and the rest of the members of the Honorable Court disqualify themselves from hearing and deciding this petition~ "2. That the assailed resolutions of the Sandiganbayan be vacated and set aside~and "3. That Criminal Cases Nos. 26558, No. 26565 and No. 26905 pending before the Sandiganbayan be dismissed fro lack of jurisdiction. 1 <CAttorneyAlan F. Paguia, speaking for petitioner, asserts that the inhibition of the members of the Supreme Court from hearing the petition is called for under Rule 5.10 of the Code of Judicial Conduct prohibiting justices or judges from participating in any partisan political activity which proscription, according to him, the ju'stices have violated by attending the 'EDSA 2 RALLY' and by authorizing the assumption of Vice-president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo to the Presidency in violation of the 1987 Constitution.
    [Show full text]
  • To Clean up the Pasig River in 1999, ABS-CBN Foundation Inc
    May 2009 Celebrate Mother’s Day on May 10! Take a break and treat Mom to Bantay Kalikasan’s Palawan ecotour, indulge in a lunch buffet at the Eugenio Lopez Center (details on page 11) or check out gift ideas from Rockwell Power Plant Mall (on page 12). Available online at www.lopezlink.ph Gina Lopez leads ‘one big push’ to clean up the Pasig River IN 1999, ABS-CBN Foundation Inc. (AFI) did the near impos- “It requires the involvement of a large number of the population; 2008 performance: sible when it successfully took on the management of the reforesta- in fact, most of Metro Manila, if you really want to keep it clean tion of the La Mesa Watershed area through its then newly formed over the long term.” ABS-CBN environmental arm, Bantay Kalikasan. The 27-kilometer Pasig River winds through Metro Manila lumalakas pa! ...p.2 This year, the foundation trains its sights on a bigger and more and connects Laguna de Bay to Manila Bay by way of the Na- ambitious rescue effort—cleaning up Manila’s jewel, the Pasig River, pindan Channel, one of the four major tributaries; the others through Kapit Bisig Para sa Ilog Pasig (KBPIP). are San Juan River, Pateros-Taguig River and Marikina River. ”We have to change the way we look at the river,” AFI man- In all, a total of 47 tributaries, esteros and creeks feed into the aging director Gina Lopez said during the program launch in river. February. “We should use the media to awaken the conscious- Project co-managers ness and the reverence that people should have for the Pasig KBPIP aims to arrest some 80 years of abuse of the Pasig River, River.” which saw the waterway decline steadily from “an important means “This is a massive project because you’re not just talking of the of transport and center of economic activity” during pre-Hispanic Pasig River but also of the tributaries,” stressed KBPIP project Who manager Girlie Aragon in a later interview with LopezLink.
    [Show full text]
  • Sun May 31 11:12:53 2020 SOURCE: Content Downloaded from Heinonline
    DATE DOWNLOADED: Sun May 31 11:12:53 2020 SOURCE: Content Downloaded from HeinOnline Citations: Bluebook 20th ed. Antonio G. M. La Vina, Nico Robert R. Martin & Josef Leroi Garcia, High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence, 90 Phil. L.J. 218 (2017). ALWD 6th ed. Antonio G. M. La Vina, Nico Robert R. Martin & Josef Leroi Garcia, High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence, 90 Phil. L.J. 218 (2017). APA 7th ed. La Vina, A. G., Martin, N. R., & Garcia, J. (2017). High noon in the supreme court: The poe-llamanzares decision and its impact on substantive and procedural jurisprudence. Philippine Law Journal, 90(2), 218-277. Chicago 7th ed. Antonio G. M. La Vina; Nico Robert R. Martin; Josef Leroi Garcia, "High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence," Philippine Law Journal 90, no. 2 (January 2017): 218-277 McGill Guide 9th ed. Antonio GM La Vina, Nico Robert R Martin & Josef Leroi Garcia, "High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence" (2017) 90:2 Philippine LJ 218. MLA 8th ed. La Vina, Antonio G. M. , et al. "High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence." Philippine Law Journal, vol. 90, no. 2, January 2017, p. 218-277. HeinOnline. OSCOLA 4th ed. Antonio G M La Vina and Nico Robert R Martin and Josef Leroi Garcia, 'High Noon in the Supreme Court: The Poe-Llamanzares Decision and Its Impact on Substantive and Procedural Jurisprudence' (2017) 90 Phil LJ 218 -- Your use of this HeinOnline PDF indicates your acceptance of HeinOnline's Terms and Conditions of the license agreement available at https://heinonline.org/HOL/License -- The search text of this PDF is generated from uncorrected OCR text.
    [Show full text]