FFRF Jesus Shrine Protest Sets Off Firestorm
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Complimentary Copy Join FFRF Now! Vol. 28 No. 9 Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. November 2011 Photo: Jeff Yardis Photo: Jeff FFRF Jesus shrine protest sets off firestorm A letter from the Freedom From Religion Foundation to the U.S. For- est Service protesting an unconstitu- tional Jesus shrine in the middle of Big Mountain in Montana’s Flathead National Forest has ignited a Religious Right firestorm. On behalf of one of its Montana Catherine Fahringer Student Activist awardee Harrison Hopkins addresses a packed house at the 34th annual national members, FFRF Staff Attorney Stepha- FFRF convention in Hartford, Conn. For more convention photos, see Pages 10–15. nie Schmitt sent a letter in May point- ing out that religious symbols may not be posted on federal property. She The Forest Service had quietly ing “public comment,” FFRF also sent the ski area, it points out. filed a Freedom of Information Act re- agreed this summer not to renew the Tidwell representative samplings of The insensitive Rehberg went so quest to review the leasing agreement lease to the conservative Roman Cath- its vicious hate mail on the issue (see far as to create a link, veteransjesus.com, with the Knights of Columbus Council olic men’s club. The violation has been Crank Mail, Page 17), showing how which takes people to his congression- #1328. The lease refers to the purpose going on since the mid-1950s with the statue has given believers a sense al website. In November, he intro- “to provide a site for a religious shrine.” “leases” renewed every 10 years. The that they are political insiders, and that duced legislation to swap private land Documents reveal the government permit was up for renewal this year. nonbelievers are outsiders worthy of from the resort atop Big Mountain for charged no money for the special lease Then, U.S. Rep. Denny Rehberg, deportation or even death. the 625 feet of federal land beneath permit for use of 625 square feet of R-Mont., got into the act. In October, The concrete statue is one of thou- the shrine. land near Whitefish Mountain Resort’s he wrote Forest Service Chief Tom sands manufactured by the Knights Chair 2. Tidwell: “Removal of this symbol of of Columbus to place on their lawns. Urgent Action Alert! hope and faith is an insult to the sac- “They overstep their rights when they rifices they so willingly gave our great appropriate federal property to broad- The U.S. Forest Service’s official country.” cast their religious message,” said FFRF “comment period” for whether to re- Forest Supervisor Chip Weber ca- Co-President Annie Laurie Gaylor. new the lease for the Jesus shrine lasts Inside This Issue pitulated and announced Oct. 21 that The record shows the idea for the through Dec. 8, 2011. Send your objec- Flathead National Forest was withdraw- shrine apparently originated with re- tions by email to: Thomas ing its decision not to renew the permit turning Catholic veterans from Ka- comments-northern-flathead-tally-lake@ Jefferson and would “formally seek public com- lispell, Mont., who aimed to recreate fs.fed.us Student Activist ment.” Also getting into the act is the the experience of seeing other shrines Please include “Knights of Colum- Jessica Ahlquist Montana State Historical Preservation to Jesus in the Alps. bus Special Use Permit Reauthoriza- Pages 2–3 Office, which absurdly claims “the site “The Knights of Columbus is a very tion Project” in the subject line. in question is eligible for listing on the wealthy organization with ample land Emailed comments will be con- National Register of Historic Places.” where it may place Jesus statues pri- firmed by return email. Only the first FFRF immediately wrote Tidwell to vately, where they belong,” said Dan email from each sender will receive a protest the notion that public opinion Barker, FFRF co-president. confirmation. Atheist in can supersede the Constitution. The The Catholic club demurs and says Mail or fax comments to: Foxhole majority does not rule in matters of the statue is too fragile to be moved. Project Leader Derek Milner awardee personal conscience. Just because a vi- “It’s hardly a Michelangelo!” Gaylor Tally Lake Ranger District olation is long-lasting does not dimin- quipped. 650 Wolfpack Way Steve Trunk ish the violation, FFRF further pointed Forest Service Employees for Envi- Kalispell, MT 59901 Pages 8–9 out — quite the contrary. By that rea- ronmental Ethics, in a Nov. 15 letter of Fax: 406-758-5367 soning, the longer an abuse goes on, objection to the permit, pooh-poohed Please take a moment to comment, the less egregious it becomes. the idea that the statue would be dam- because Religious Right groups such as FFRF also called it a “sham” that the aged. “For a nation that successfully Pat Robertson’s ACLJ have delightedly FFRF shrine to Jesus is belatedly being called put several men on the moon, this latched onto this issue to raise money honors a World War II memorial. The shrine does not appear to be a significant en- and muster their forces. We ask every “Annie” promotes one religion’s deity and ex- gineering hurdle.” FSEEE pointed out FFRF member to chime in and coun- cludes all non-Christians, including the “statue’s historic identity would ter the religious hotheads so reason composer “the many ‘atheists in foxholes’ who be preserved by locating the statue at will prevail! If you are a veteran, please Charles have served our country with distinc- a private location within the ski area mention that status in your comment. Strouse tion and valor,” FFRF wrote Tidwell. resort’s footprint.” In fact, the applica- Sign FFRF’s official White House Page 24 Courts have rejected such ruses. tion’s first choice for locating the stat- petition to President Obama to remove Since the Forest Service was seek- ue in 1953 was on private land within the Jesus shrine: wh.gov/Th8 Page 2 Freethought Today Madison, Wisconsin November 2011 Thomas Jefferson Youth Activist honoree Teen stands tall for First Amendment All photos: Jeff Yardis All photos: Jeff Jessica Ahlquist, 16, who is a plaintiff in an ACLU federal lawsuit to force removal When I identified of an 8-foot-tall prayer banner from her Rhode Island high school, spoke at FFRF’s myself as an 34th national convention Oct. 8, 2011, atheist, someone in Hartford, Conn., where she received the Thomas Jefferson Youth Activist Award of gasped. $1,000. This award is endowed by a West Coast couple. The painting was donated to Cranston West by the class of 1963, the first graduating class. [of the School Committee of the city of Cranston] after a parent filed a for- mal complaint with the ACLU. I had been doing research on the prayer, on prayers in schools in general, and dur- ing that time over the summer, another parent kind of beat me to it and made a complaint. There were subcommit- tee meetings because the school didn’t Jessica accepts the $1,000 Thomas Jefferson Youth Activist Award presented on want to just remove it right away. behalf of FFRF by Webmaster Scott Colson. My friend was a student representa- tive on the subcommittee. I spoke at atheist. When I did, someone gasped their breath that I was a “little witch.” the meeting and identified myself as an and someone else whispered under [Jessica is 5 feet tall.] So I didn’t feel very welcome there, obviously, from the very beginning. I attended another meeting, where there were a lot more people wear- ing signs around their necks that said, “Keep original banner.” They were pretty angry. I don’t think all of them knew why they were there though. Some of them seemed really confused. They just said, “Someone’s trying to de- stroy God,” and then they all jumped in a van or something. By Jessica Ahlquist A lot of irrelevant stuff came up at the meetings. People were talking about abortion and how prayers in schools somehow lowered the teen I’m a junior in high school at Cran- pregnancy rate. This was all coming ston West, which is in Rhode Island. from people who didn’t really know You don’t tend to think that Rhode that the prayer mural existed before. I Island is a very religious place. It usu- spoke at that meeting also and could ally has more of a secular connotation feel how much people hated me. They to it. However, I found out that wasn’t stared and glared at me. exactly true. They were angry from the very start, All of this started when I was a soph- and that was reflected at school. After omore, but I first noticed the prayer it was on the news, weird things started when I was a freshman after a friend happening. I would sneeze in class and told me there was one on the wall in people would scream, “God bless you!” the auditorium. I was surprised to see it in my face. and didn’t think that my school would At the final meeting, the full com- have something like that. mittee voted to keep the prayer. The I’ve been an out-of-the-closet athe- ACLU had contacted me, and I told ist only since this started. Before that, I them that I would become the plaintiff didn’t want to talk about it. I didn’t re- in a lawsuit. In April, we filed a lawsuit ally identify myself as an atheist to oth- against the city of Cranston to take the er people.