The Trained Traditional Birth Attendant: a Study of Her Role in Two Cultures by L
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
L.I. LARTSONETAL. Perspectives in Primary Care The Trained Traditional Birth Attendant: a Study of Her Role in two Cultures by L. I. Lartson*, MD, MSc, O. A. Sodipe*, MB, BS, MSc, G. J. Ebrahim*, FRCP, DCH, and R. Abel**, MD * Tropical Child Health Unit, Institute of Child Health, London ** Rural Unit for Health and Social Affairs, Vellore, India Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/tropej/article/33/1/29/1672468 by guest on 29 September 2021 Summary The training of the traditional birth attendants in the national programme in Liberia and in the innova- tive health programme of RUHSA in south India has been evaluated. There has been an improvement in coverage with prenatal care and immunization with tetanus toxoid associated with a fall in the incidence of low birth weight and neonatal tetanus. The need for repeated refresher courses, for effective back-up in case of emergencies, and for close supervision to prevent risk-taking is stressed. Even though the per- formance of the trained traditional birth attendants (TTBA) improved with regard to the assessment of pregnancy and the identification of risk factors, the TTBA tended to handle complicated births, retained placenta, and prolonged labour by themselves. Whatever the reasons, it stresses the need for the super- visory back-up services to work closely with the TTBA. Introduction maternal and perinatal mortality rates remain high and have not altered much during the last decade. As It is estimated that between 60 and 80 per cent of a rough estimate, 500 000 women die of causes related births in the developing world are attended by tradi- to pregnancy each year—most of them preventable.6 tional birth attendants (TBA).1 Understandably, In a study of maternal mortality in Bangladesh, the there has been a desire to improve the quality of care rate was 7.7 per 1000 live births with 80 per cent of they provide and to upgrade their skills. In a world deaths being due to direct obstetric causes, and wide survey conducted under the auspices of the eclampsia was the most common cause.7 World Health Organization (WHO) 24 out of the 64 In all traditional societies, child bearing is firmly countries (38 per cent) surveyed were reported to have rooted in the cultural milieu and is surrounded with a existing training programmes for the TBA in 1972.2 variety of mystical beliefs and magico-religious prac- Since then case studies in utilization and training of tices.8 Hence, an indigenous practitioner like the TBA the TBA from seven countries have been published,3 from within the same culture is preferred to the skilled and the characteristics of the TBA as well as their professional. Upgrading of the TBA's skills and common practices during pregnancy, at the time of improving her knowledge through training will be a delivery, and in the postnatal period have been de- rational approach. Moreover, expansion of coverage scribed.4 Such studies have provided a momentum for with maternity care through trained professionals change so that the training and utilization of the TBA would mean expanding health services 3-4-fold which constitute a significant part of the national health no country can afford. On the other hand, 'articula- strategies of many countries. tion' of trained TBAs to the formal health service is Coverage with skilled care at delivery is low in most an achievable goal. Hence, a number of countries developing countries and varies from 29 per cent in have adopted such a strategy and developed curricula for the training of TBAs, and the Sudan is one such tropical Africa (Africa average 34 per cent) and 20 per 9 cent in southern Asia (Asia average 49 per cent) to 51 example. per cent in middle America (Latin America average The training of TBAs has to be related to specific 64 per cent).5 The number of pregnant women who problems. Since low birth weight and neonatal receive antenatal care is also low, varying from 5 to 48 tetanus are the two most common causes of neonatal per cent in countries where fewer than half the preg- mortality, their prevention must be stressed. Improve- nant women receive prenatal care to a range of 50-98 ment of maternal nutrition and motivation for immu- per cent in countries where more than half the preg- nization of the pregnant woman with tetanus toxoid nant women receive such care.5 Not surprisingly, are emphasized in most training programmes. Preven- Journal of Tropical Pediatrics Vol. 33 February 1987 © Oxford University Press 1987 29 L. I. LARTSON ET AL. tion of anaemia and the referral of high-risk preg- deliveries performed by TTBAs than UTTBAs. The nancies for more skilled care are the other skills women delivered recently by the two study groups taught to the TBA. Emergencies are likely to arise were traced and were also interviewed using a struc- unexpectedly and their early anticipation for prompt tured questionnaire so designed as to obtain addi- referral as well as simple relevant skills for handling tional evidence for testing the above hypotheses. In them must form part of the training.10 all, 100 mothers were interviewed, of whom 52 had In all traditional birth systems the relationship been delivered by TTBAs and 48 by UTTBAs. between the birth attendant and the 'client', is of a personalized nature. The TBA is treated more like an RUHSA programme, India elder who joins with the rest of the family in assisting The RUHSA programme is characteristic of the di- the woman in labour.11 She is rewarded in cash or lemma in all developing countries in that despite a kind, or both, according to the ability of the family. rising output of skilled professionals who largely Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/tropej/article/33/1/29/1672468 by guest on 29 September 2021 There are no fixed charges. This relationship is differ- enter the private sector, the vast majority of the popu- ent from the professional-client relationship of the lation have little access to modern medical care on midwife or obstetrician. Because of the relationship account of poverty. In the population served by the and the system of reward, the services of the TBA are RUHSA programme 77 per cent are below the more accessible to the disadvantaged groups. Is the poverty line, and hence the need of a maternity service relationship likely to change after training? which is affordable. A national programme of train- The evaluation of training and of the performance ing the TBAs operates in the area in addition to of the trained TBA is necessary to assess the success RUHSA's own programme. The full content of or otherwise of the strategy of extending coverage RUHSA's training is given in Appendix 2. The study with maternity care through modernization of the was carried out in three villages constituting the main traditional systems. We report here on the perform- headquarters village, an intermediate village with a ance of the trained TBA in two cultural settings. One health facility, and a remote village with no health is a national programme in Liberia and our report is facilities. Comparable villages were selected from a part of the process of evaluation currently in progress neighbouring area outside RUHSA's boundary. The 11 in that country. The second is a relatively small-scale method of selection has been described previously. project as part of the RUHSA (Rural Unit for Health An interview based on a structured questionnaire was and Social Affairs) programme of the Christian Medi- conducted with all the TBAs in the six villages to cal College, Vellore.12 assess the size of their clientele, their knowledge and practices concerning prenatal, intrapartum, and post- natal care. Similar interviews were conducted with Methods and Materials mothers who had been delivered by the TBAs. In all Liberia 38 TBAs were interviewed, 28 being from the study The study was part of the national evaluation of the villages, 12 of whom were untrained. Out of the 10 in training of TBAs, and was carried out in four counties the comparison villages, 7 were untrained. In all 223 avoiding the areas where the national evaluation mothers were interviewed, 113 of whom were from teams were operating. Each of the four counties has a the study villages. training programme based on a curriculum formu- lated by the Ministry of Health and Social Welfare (see Appendix 1). Twelve towns were identified in Results which trained and untrained traditional midwives Liberia—national programme were practising. From amongst the trained TBAs who General characteristics of the traditional birth atten- had been identified by their supervisors, 26 were dants. There were no significant differences between selected for the study by the lottery method (TTBA). the TTBAs and the UTTBAs as regards age, literacy Untrained TBAs had to be identified with the help of rate, general education, years of experience, and the community leaders as being the only way since induction into the art of assisting with deliveries. The they are not registered with the midwifery board. A only difference was whether they had attended the group of 24 untrained TBAs (UTTBA) were selected training programme or not. In general, the traditional for the study by the lottery method. In both the birth attendants were between 35 and 55 years old, groups the birth attendants were operating from a were largely illiterate, had been in practice for more distance of 8 km radius from a health centre or district than 10 years, and had acquired their skills through hospital and 40 km radius from a regional hospital.