(2018) Renewable Energy in Scotland: Extending the Transition-Periphery Dynamics Approach
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Munro, Fiona Robertson (2018) Renewable energy in Scotland: Extending the transition-periphery dynamics approach. PhD thesis. https://theses.gla.ac.uk/8714/ Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Renewable energy in Scotland: Extending the transition- periphery dynamics approach by Fiona Robertson Munro Masters in Resource and Environmental Management (Planning), Simon Fraser University, 2013 Bachelor of Arts (Honours) Medial in Environmental Studies and Geography, Queen’s University, 2011 Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Interdisciplinary Studies College of Social Science University of Glasgow August 2017 Abstract Scotland is being transformed as renewable energy resources are being exploited through new developments and infrastructure as part of an energy transition. Scotland has a significant amount of potential onshore and offshore renewable energy available for capture largely located in rural and isolated regions. Some of this potential renewable energy has been developed and contributes to the increasing amount of energy from low carbon sources in the UK, aiding in the UK reaching its greenhouse gas (GHG) emission targets. This thesis responds to four research questions. The first proposes an analytical framework that incorporates the concept of resource peripheries and processes of peripheralization and centralization in the multilevel perspective (MLP) from the sociotechnical transitions literature. The second discusses the transition dynamics during the renewable energy transition in Scotland that are being shaped by a number of drivers including the shift to community ownership in Scotland and a range of policies, targets, and legislation. The third address the relationship dynamics between cores and peripheries created through processes of peripheralization that include relational, multi-dimensional processes that are also multi-scalar. The fourth discusses the uneven multi-scalar dynamics created as a transition occurs with processes of peripheralization and centralization creating resource peripheries as ‘transition-periphery dynamics’. By better understanding these dynamics and relationships during transitions the renewable energy transition can be better informed to deal with possible implications and ensure possible benefits are secured for a more sustainable future. Keywords: sociotechnical transitions; geography; resource periphery; renewable energy; policy ii Table of Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................... ii Table of Contents .......................................................................................................... iii List of Tables ............................................................................................................... vii List of Figures ............................................................................................................. viii Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................ x Author’s Declaration ..................................................................................................... xi Abbreviations ............................................................................................................... xii Chapter 1. Introduction ............................................................................................ 1 1.1. Context: The Existing Energy System ................................................................. 2 1.2. Problem and Significance .................................................................................. 11 1.3. Prior Research .................................................................................................... 14 1.4. Objectives/Research Questions .......................................................................... 18 1.5. Approach ............................................................................................................ 19 1.6. Outline of the Thesis .......................................................................................... 21 Chapter 2. Sociotechnical Transitions .................................................................. 24 2.1. Science, Technology, and Innovation Studies ................................................... 24 2.1.1. Science and Technology Studies (STS) ..................................................... 25 2.1.2. Determinism .............................................................................................. 25 2.1.3. Systems Perspective .................................................................................. 26 2.1.4. Innovation Studies ..................................................................................... 28 Radical and Incremental Innovations ................................................................... 28 Large Technical Systems (LTS) ........................................................................... 29 Path Dependency and Lock-in .............................................................................. 31 2.2. Sociotechnical Transitions ................................................................................. 32 2.3. Sociotechnical Transitions and Energy .............................................................. 42 2.4. Sociotechnical Transitions: What About Geography? ....................................... 51 2.4.1. Science, Technology and Innovation Studies and Geography .................. 51 2.4.2. Geographers and Transition Studies .......................................................... 55 2.4.3. The Bridge ................................................................................................. 59 2.5. Conclusion ......................................................................................................... 62 Chapter 3. Resource Peripheries ........................................................................... 63 3.1. Core-Periphery Relationships ............................................................................ 64 3.2. Nature and Resources ........................................................................................ 73 3.2.1. Resource Making ....................................................................................... 73 3.2.2. The Resource Curse ................................................................................... 75 3.2.3. Green Grabbing ......................................................................................... 77 3.3. Resource Peripheries .......................................................................................... 79 3.3.1. Energy as a Resource ................................................................................. 82 3.4. Alternative Types of Resource Development .................................................... 83 3.5. Resource Peripheries and Sociotechnical Transitions ....................................... 85 iii Chapter 4. Towards an Analytical Framework ................................................... 88 4.1. Sociotechnical Transitions and Resource Peripheries as Separate Concepts .... 89 4.2. Key Terms .......................................................................................................... 91 4.3. Connecting Sociotechnical Transitions and Resource Peripheries .................... 96 4.4. Proposed Theoretical Framework ...................................................................... 97 4.4.1. Peripheralization and Centralization: Processes as part of the Sociotechnical Transition ......................................................................................... 97 4.4.2. Multi-scalar Core-periphery Relationships ............................................. 100 4.5. Challenges and Limitations ............................................................................. 102 4.6. Conclusion ....................................................................................................... 103 Chapter 5. Methods ............................................................................................... 105 5.1. Research Objective and Questions .................................................................. 105 5.2. Research Design .............................................................................................. 106 5.2.1. Qualitative Case Study Approach ............................................................ 107 5.2.2. Case Study Selection ............................................................................... 110 North Yell Tidal Project ..................................................................................... 113 Shetland Interconnector, Shetland to mainland Scotland ................................... 114 Coire Glas and Cruachan Hydro Schemes ........................................................