[Korea] Travel Retail
Hotel Shilla
Buy
(008770 KS)
(Maintain)
Additional negatives to be limited
TP: W100,000
Upside: 42.2%
Mirae Asset Daewoo Co., Ltd.
Myoungjoo Kim [email protected] Minjeong Kyeong [email protected]
2Q20 review
Larger-than-expected operating loss
For 2Q20, Hotel Shilla reported consolidated revenue of W523bn (-61.4% YoY) and an operating loss of W63.4bn (turn to loss YoY).
The operating loss was larger than the market expectation. The weak results were attributable to: 1) disappointing sales of unsold duty-free inventory to third parties overseas; and 2) increased commission fees following a recovery in small daigou.
A QoQ rise in the discount rate given to large-scale daigou also contributed to the weak results.
Additional negatives to be limited
Despite lingering uncertainties, additional negatives to be limited
Hotel Shilla suffered a significant operating loss for the second straight quarter despite sharp rent cuts (W56bn; about four months’ worth) at Incheon International Airport (IIA).
Store traffic failed to recover amid the lingering impact of COVID-19. Due to the prolonged effects of the pandemic, uncertainty still surrounds the recovery outlook. That said, we believe additional negatives beyond COVID-19 are limited. Despite the pandemic, sales to daigou are proving resilient, showing that demand for Korean cosmetics and duty-free channels remains solid.
Accumulate on weakness
Maintain Buy and TP of W100,000
We see no additional negatives aside from COVID-19. Hotel Shilla’s stock is trading at a 2021F P/E of 16.0x. Valuation does not look demanding, assuming a normalization in business conditions in 2021.
We believe the current share price reflects all COVID-19-related uncertainties and sluggish earnings. Near-term share price weakness is possible, given the weak 2Q20 results and persistent uncertainties.
We recommend taking any correction as an opportunity to accumulate shares.
Key data
Currentprice(7/31/20,W) OP (20F,Wbn)
70,300
-149 -120
-
Market cap (Wbn) Shares outstanding (mn) Freefloat (%)
2,759
40
160
- Hotel Shilla
- KOSPI
140
120
100
80
ConsensusOP (20F,Wbn) EPSgrowth (20F,%) P/E(20F, x)
77.2
Foreignownership(%) Beta (12M)
21.3
- -
- 1.04
Market P/E(20F, x) KOSPI
15.8
2,249.37
52-weeklow(W) 52-weekhigh(W)
61,800
108,500
60
- 7.19
- 11.19
- 3.20
- 7.20
- Shareperformance
- Earningsandvaluationmetrics
(%) Absolute Relative
1M -1.0 -7.2
6M
-19.6 -24.2
12M -10.7 -19.6
- (Dec.)
- 2016
3,715
79 2.1 28
696 4.0
69.2
2.5
2017 3,515
73 2.1 25
632 3.8
134.3
4.4
2018 4,714
209 4.4 110
2,758
15.4 27.7
3.5
2019 5,717
296 5.2 170
4,243
20.2 21.4
3.5
2020F 3,475
-149 -4.3 -180
-4,501
-21.8
-
2021F 6,876
308 4.5 176
4,395
21.7 16.0
2.8
Revenue(Wbn) OP (Wbn) OP margin(%) NP (Wbn) EPS(W) ROE(%) P/E(x)
- P/B(x)
- 3.4
- Dividend yield (%)
- 0.7
- 0.4
- 0.5
- 0.4
- 0.5
- 0.5
Notes: Under consolidatedK-IFRS; NP is attributable to owners ofthe parent Source: Company data, Mirae AssetDaewoo Research estimates
Analysts who prepared this report are registered as research analysts in Korea but not in any other jurisdiction, including the US.
PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES AND DISCLAIMERS IN APPENDIX 1 AT THE END OF REPORT.
August 3, 2020
Hotel Shilla
Table 1. 2Q20 review
(Wbn, %, %p)
2Q20 MiraeAsset
Daewoo
Growth
- 2Q19
- 1Q20
- Actual
- Consensus
- YoY
- QoQ
Revenue
OP
1,355
79
- 944
- 523
- 535
- 657
- -61.4
TTR
-
-44.6
RR
-
- -67
- -63
- -56
- -53
OP margin(%) NP
5.8
- 52
- -74
- -68
- -54
- -55
- TTR
- RR
Note: NP is attributable to owners ofthe parent. Source: DataGuide; company data, Mirae AssetDaewoo Research
Table 2. Earnings forecast revisions
(Wbn, %)
Previous
2020F
Revised
2020F
% chg.
2020F
Notes
2021F
6,689
303
- 2021F
- 2021F
- 2.8
- Revenue
OP
5,113
31
3,475
-147
-4.2
6,876
308
4.5
-32.0
TTR
-4.8 RR
Lowered2H20 estimates to reflect prolongedimpactof COVID-19
1.7
OP margin(%) NP
- 0.6
- 4.5
- 0.0
- -43
- 182
- -181
- 176
- -3.0
Note: NP is attributable to owners ofthe parent. Source: DataGuide, Mirae AssetDaewoo Research
Table 3. Earnings and forecasts (consolidated)
(Wbn)
- 2019 2020F 2021F
- 1Q18 2Q18 3Q18 4Q18 1Q19 2Q19 3Q19 4Q19 1Q20 2Q20 3Q20F 4Q20F
- 2018
Revenue
Duty-free Downtown Airport
- 1,126 1,175 1,220 1,193 1,343 1,355 1,475 1,544
- 944
849 559 290
94
523
439 394
46
809 1,200 4,714 5,717 3,475 6,876
- 1,014 1,055 1,094 1,072 1,225 1,227 1,339 1,411
- 704 1,062 4,234 5,201 3,055 6,324
581 432 112 594
53
613 442 120 600
51
626 468 127 631
52
621 451 121 637
53
721 504 118 753
56
756 470 128 741
55
856 482 137 861
58
941 470 133 887
57
579 125 105 474
59
791 2,441 3,274 2,322 3,835 271 1,793 1,927 732 2,488 138 480 516 421 553 735 2,462 3,301 2,090 3,970
61 52.2 57.7 60 58
438 2,042 2,121 1,534 2,599
Hotel/leisure COGS
84
588
62
292
- 56
- COGSratio(%)
- SG&A
- 487
44
505
69
521
68
529
27
509
82
534
79
557
57
580
78
422
-67
-49 -18 -93
-74
295
-63
-47 -16 -82
-68
378
-44
-39
-4
- OP
- 26
23
3
209
196
13
296
267
29
-147
-112
-35
308
281
28
Duty-free Hotel/leisure Pretax profit
NP
- 48
- 64
- 59
- 25
- 82
- 70
- 45
- 70
- -3
- 6
- 9
- 2
- -1
- 9
- 12
- 8
- 42
- 65
- 66
- -25
-21
- 67
- 68
- 38
- 54
- -55
-42
- 3
- 147
110
226
170
-227
-181
234
- 176
- 32
- 53
- 47
- 52
- 52
- 28
- 38
- 2
YoY (%) Revenue OP
- 10
- 31
- 14
124 275
127
77
19 85 64
15 14 -1
21 -16 -41
29
182 TTB
-30 TTR TTR
-61 TTR TTR
-45 TTR TTR
-22 -66 -94
34
186 336
21 41 54
-39.2 TTR TTR
97.9 TTB TTB
- 342
- 303
- NP
- 1,074 1,668
- -402
Note: NP is attributable to owners ofthe parent. Source: Company data, Mirae AssetDaewoo Research
Mirae Asset Daewoo Research
2
August 3, 2020
Hotel Shilla
Hotel Shilla (008770 KS)
Income statement (summarized)
(Wbn)
Revenue Costofrevenue Grossprofit SG&Aexpenses OP(adj.) OP Non-operatingprofit
Net financialincome Net incomefrom associates Pretax profit
Balance sheet (summarized)
(Wbn)
Currentassets
Cash&equivalents AR &other receivables Inventory Othercurrent assets
Non-currentassets
Investmentsin associates PP&E
2018
4,714 2,462 2,252 2,042
209 209 -62
-8 0
147
37
110
0
110
110
0
110
110
0
284
76 6.0 4.4 2.3
2019
5,717 3,301 2,416 2,121
296 296 -70
-27
0
226
56
169
0
169
170
0
168
168
0
515 338 9.0
2020F
3,475 2,090 1,385 1,534
-149 -149
-80
-29
0
-229
-49
-180
0
-180
-180
0
-175
-175
0
86 -71 2.5 -4.3 -5.2
2021F
6,876 3,970 2,906 2,599
308 308 -74
-35
0
234
58
176
0
176
176
0
176
176
0
540 203 7.9
2018
1,272
282 203 704
83
1,032
34
697
48
2,304 1,003
350 160 493
536
499
37
1,539
764
200 197 475
1
2019
1,716
508 266 849
93
1,811
48
675
56
3,527 1,438
507 419 512
1,170
1,143
27
2,608
920
200 197 627
0
- 2020F
- 2021F
1,901
459 319
1,019
104
1,856
57
637
1,410
472 207 660
71
1,780
37
654
60
3,190 1,356
394 564 398
1,103
1,082
21
2,458
731
200 197 434
0
Intangibleassets
Totalassets
44
3,757 1,749
608 527 614
1,114
1,082
32
2,864
894
Incometax
Currentliabilities
AP &otherpayables Short-term financialliabilities Othercurrentliabilities
Non-currentliabilities
Long-term financialliabilities Othernon-currentliabilities
Totalliabilities Equity attributabletoowners
Capital stock Capital surplus Retained earnings
Minorityinterests Shareholders'equity
Profit from continuing operations Profit fromdiscontinued operations
NP
Attributableto owners Attributableto minorityinterests
Total comprehensiveincome
Attributableto owners Attributableto minorityinterests
- EBITDA
- 200
197 596
0
FCF EBITDA margin (%) OP margin(%) Net margin(%)
5.2 3.0
4.5 2.6
- 765
- 920
- 731
- 894
- Cash flow statement (summarized)
- Key valuation metrics/ratios
- (Wbn)
- 2018
- 2019
404
169 341 205
15
121 -44 -28
-139 150 -70
-93
-65
0
2020F
95
-180 218 217
18 -17 15 24
191 -99 30
-137
-165
-15 51
2021F
403
176 326 217
15
2018 27.7 10.6
3.5
12.0
2,758 7,201
21,722
350
2019 21.4
7.1 3.5 9.0
4,243
12,764 25,591
350
2020F
-
73.6
3.4
2021F
16.0
5.6 2.8 7.3
4,395
12,535 24,940
350 7.4
Operatingcashflow
NP Non-cashincome/expenses Depreciation
154
110 178
62
P/E(x) P/CF(x) P/B(x) EV/EBITDA (x) EPS(W) CFPS(W) BPS(W) DPS(W) Dividendpayout ratio (%) Dividend yield (%) Revenuegrowth(%) EBITDAgrowth (%) OPgrowth(%) EPSgrowth (%) AR turnover (x) Inventoryturnover (x) AP turnover (x) ROA (%) ROE(%) ROIC (%) Debt-to-equityratio (%) Current ratio(%) Net debt-to-equityratio (%) Interestcoverageratio(x)
45.9
-4,501
955
20,877
350 -7.2 0.5
-39.2 -83.3
-
- Amortization
- 12
- Other
- 104
-117
-16
-230
43 -23
-103
-71
0
94
Chg.inworking capital Chg.inAR&other receivables Chg.ininventory Chg.inAP&otherpayables Incometax
Cashflowfrominvestingactivities
Chg.inPP&E Chg.inintangibleassets Chg.infinancialassets Other
-53 -52
-359 183 -58
-297
-200
0
-97
0
-99
-37
0
11.8
0.5
7.7
- 0.4
- 0.5
34.1 95.9
186.3 336.4
54.8
8.0
21.3 81.3 41.6 53.8 52.4
7.4
97.9
527.9
-
- -
- -
- 20
- 7
- 31.7
4.6 5.4 -5.4
-21.8
-8.3
336.3 104.0 156.9
-3.6
56.3
8.2 9.3
-52
-245
-211
0
-35
-87
903
0
-13
-977
226
282 508
-8
-8
84
0
Cashflowfromfinancingactivities
Chg.infinancialliabilities Chg.inequity
9.4 4.9
9.2
- 5.8
- 5.1
15.4 18.7
201.1 126.9
46.3 11.3
20.2 17.3
283.6 119.3 112.2
7.5
21.7 13.9
320.5 108.7 124.6
6.4
Dividends Other
Chg.in cash
Beginningbalance Endingbalance
-13 -21
-193
474 282
- 0
- -13
-49
-13
472 459
-92
-36
508 472
Source: Company data, Mirae AssetDaewoo Research estimates
Mirae Asset Daewoo Research
3
August 3, 2020
Hotel Shilla
Appendix 1
Important disclosures and disclaimers
Two-year rating and TP history
- Company
- Date
- Rating
Buy
TradingBuy
Buy Buy
No Coverage
Buy
TP(W)
100,000 100,000 100,000 110,000
(W)
Hotel Shilla
- Hotel Shilla(008770)
- 04/27/20
02/02/20 10/28/19 10/01/19 08/07/18 04/29/18
200,000
150,000 100,000
50,000
0
170,000
- Aug 18
- Aug 19
- Aug 20
Stockratings
Buy
Sectorratings
- Overweight
- Expected to outperform the market over 12 months
Expected to perform in line with the market over 12 months
Expected 12-month performance: +20% or greater
- Neutral
- Trading Buy Expected 12-month performance: +10% to +20%