Geochemistry of the Granite-Gabbro Complex on Vinalhaven Ismnd, Maine
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Maine Geological Survey Studies in Maine Geology: Volume 4 1989 Geochemistry of the Granite-Gabbro Complex on Vinalhaven Ismnd, Maine Christopher B. Mitchell IEP, Inc. P.O. Box 1136 Portsmouth, New Hampshire 03801 J. Michael Rhodes Department ofGeology and Geography University of Massachusetts Amherst, Massachusetts 01003 ABSTRACT The bimodal granite-gabbro association on Vinalhaven Island, Maine has spectacular textural and structural relationships that are interpreted to have resulted from commingling of contemporaneous mafic and felsic liquids. During this process, the felsic and mafic magmas retained their identities and produced composite zones of chilled basaltic pillows in a granite matrix. Approximately 100 samples have been analyzed for whole-rock major and trace element abundances. These data have been used to classify the rocks and evaluate their relationships. The granites are homogeneous, high Si Oz (72.55-77.35 wt % ), two-feldspar, biotite ±hornblende, I-type, crustal, minimum-melt granites, with similar compositions to other granites from the Maine coastal lithotectonic belt. The mafic rocks, medium-grained gab bros to diorites and fine-grained chilled basalt pillows, have a range in composition (MgO 4.09-11.11 wt % ) that can be explained by varying amounts of crystal fractionation of the proposed parental magma composition accompanied by crystal accumulation and contamination by the surrounding granite melt. The parental composition calculated for the mafic rocks is similar to type I MORB that has been enriched in K, Sr, Rb, Ba, and Al. The mafic magma is probably the product of partial melting and was enriched in these elements during emplacement. A second group of mafic samples is enriched relative to the other mafic samples, in high field-strength elements Ti02, Zr, Nb, along with Sr. The physical differences in composition, temperature, and viscosity between the mafic and felsic magmas allowed the mafic magmas to chill as pillows, which helped prevent mixing between the basalt and the granite melt in the composite zones. The mechanical breakdown of some of the pillow-granite contacts has aided selective mixing, which has produced limited hybridization. These contaminated samples are not the result of simple two-component mixing of the observed granite and proposed parental basalt composition. INTRODUCTION The Island of Vinalhaven lies 15 miles east of Rockland, south western most exposure of the Bays-of-Maine Igneous Com Maine at the southern end of Penobscot Bay. It is made up of a plex (Chapman, I 962a). 361 ± 7 Ma Devonian granite-gabbro association, intruding the The Bays-of-Maine Igneous Complex is a large, essentially 393 ± 6 Ma Silurian-Early Devonian(?) Vinalhaven rhyolite and bimodal Devonian granite-gabbro association that trends 280 km Thorofare andesite (Brookins, 1976). The intrusive rocks are the east-northeast, parallel to tectonic strike, from southern 45 C. B. Mitchell and J. M. Rhodes Penobscot Bay along the coast of Maine into New Brunswick, et al., 1965; Walker and Skelhom 1966; Wiebe 1973, 1974, 1979, Canada. According to Chapman (l 962a) it consists of earlier 1980, 1984; Yoder, 1973; Gamble, 1979; Taylor et al., 1980; Reid gabbroic phases, closely followed by at least two later granitic et al., 1983; Marshall and Sparks, 1984; Cantagrel et al., 1984; phases. Chapman (1962a, 1968) has placed the granites of Vogel et al., 1984; Whalen and Currie, 1984; Brown and Becker, Vinalhaven into the younger group termed the Maine coastal 1986), suggesting that the textures formed are the result of plutons, cutting the earlier phases of the complex. He suggested interaction when both magmas were liquid or largely liquid at that the Maine coastal plutons are post-orogenic and were the same time. Despite the overwhelming field and petrographic emplaced in association with cauldron subsidence. These evidence for the commingling of mafic and silicic magmas, plutons straddle the proposed Acadian suture, and therefore must attempts to document the degree ofliquid-liquid interaction with have been emplaced in the late stages of, or after, the Acadian geochemical data have failed to support simple two-component orogeny (Berry, 1986). Both these conclusions are in accord mixing processes (Gamble, 1979; Taylor et al., 1980; Vogel et with that of Loiselle and Wones ( 1979) who state that the coastal al., 1984; Whalen and Currie, 1984). plutons are anorogenic or A-type granites. This study shows that Other alternatives such as fluidization have been suggested the granites on Vinalhaven were closely associated with the for net-veining of mafic and felsic magmas (Reynolds, 1954). emplacement of the "earlier" mafic phase and that intimate Chapman (1962b) suggested that the composite dikes of Mt. commingling of the two magmas took place during their Desert Island, Maine were formed by net-veining, with a granite emplacement (Mitchell, 1986). liquid intruding a solid gabbro host. Taylor et al. (1980) ex amined the Mt. Desert dikes and interpreted those dikes as having formed through commingling. The Association of Mafic and F elsic Magmas The well developed textural relationships and spectacular shoreline exposures on Vinalhaven Island make this an excellent The relationship between coexisting felsic and mafic mag location to study the commingling of mafic and felsic magmas. mas has been a long-standing controversy in geology (e.g. Hol The purpose of this study is twofold: first to describe the mes, 1931 ; Walker and Skelhom, 1966; Yoder, 1973). Such chemistry of the intrusive rocks on Vinalhaven Island in order to associations have been explained through fractional crystal place them in the regional and tectonic setting, and second to lization of a parental basaltic magma, various degrees of partial relate the chemical variatfon in the zones of commingling to the melting of single or multiple sources, restite contamination, and massive granite-gabbro association that makes up the majority magma-mixing. Each theory has prevailed at some time in the of the island. past, with magma-mixing receiving considerable attention in the Throughout this paper the term commingling will be used current literature. to describe magmas which have mechanically mixed, but have The intimate association of mafic and felsic magmas is well retained their compositional identity. The terms hybridized and documented throughout the geologic record. These associations contaminated will be used interchangeably to describe situations manifest themselves as mixed magma ejecta, net-veined com where the magmas have interacted in such a manner that their plexes, composite dikes and sills, and dikes of incompletely compositions have been changed. mixed, commingled mafic "pillows" in granite hosts. Examples include commingling in the Precambrian Tigalak intrusion, Labrador, Canada (Wiebe and Wild, 1983), the Tertiary Marsco Methods suite on the Isle of Skye, Scotland (Harker, 1904; Wager et al., 1965; Vogel et al., 1984), and mixed magma ejecta in the 1875 During the summers of 1984 and 1985, over 100 samples eruption of Askja, Iceland (Sigurdsson and Sparks, 1981 ). were collected from the granite-gabbro complex on Vinalhaven. Bunsen (1851) first recognized the association of basalt and Sample size for chemical analysis was based on the guidelines rhyolite in the lavas of Iceland. He suggested that the mixing of of Clanton and Fletcher ( 1976) and ranged from approximately these magmas could be responsible for the genesis of the range 100 grams for fine-grained mafic material to 2,000 grams for of igneous rocks of Iceland and other similar associations. In his medium-grained granite. Samples were analyzed for bulk rock classic work on the Tertiary igneous rocks of Skye, Harker chemistry major (Si, Ti, Al, Fe, Mn, Mg, Ca, Na, K, P) and trace ( 1904) interpreted the composite dikes, sills, and ring dikes as a (V, Cr, Ni, Zn, Ga, Sr, Y, Zr, Nb, Ba, La, Ce, Pb, Th, U) elements consequence of the simultaneous intrusion of mafic and felsic using X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (XRF) at the Department magmas. Wager and Bailey ( 1953) examined the details of of Geology and Geography, University of Massachusetts, Am net-veined complexes and attributed the textures to the chilling herst. Standard petrographic thin sections were examined for of mafic magma against a cooler felsic magma, which produced textural relations and mineralogical data. chilled margins on the mafic unit. They called this incomplete Major elements analyses were done following modifica mixing of compositionally distinct magmas "commingling." tions of the methods of Norrish and Hutton (1969). Trace-ele Many subsequent studies support the commingling ment abundances were determined using the methods of Norrish hypothesis (Gibson and Walker 1963; Blake et al., 1965; Wager and Chappell ( 1967). Mass absorption coefficients for the 46 Granite-gabbro complex on Vinalhaven Island, Maine TABLE I. REPRESENTATIVE ANALYSES FROM THE VINALHAVEN GRANITE-GABBRO ASSOCIATION. MGA VG. average of 11 medium grained granites; FGA VG, average of 6 fine grained granites; M, representative granite matrix material (VH-62); E, repre- sentative evolved sample (VH-51): P, five-pillow average representing the starting liquid composition; C, representative cumulate sample (VH-49). Analytical precision estimates ( l cr) expressed as weight percentage or ppm. Complete Vinalhaven analyses are given in Appendix A, Table A I. Sample MCA VG I-std FGAVG I-std M E p c Analytical Precision Si02 74.37 0.62 73.83 0.59 6 l.71 53.34 48.94 47.58 0.16 Ti02 0.32 0.03 0.30 0.02 I.62 2.25 l.26 0.89 0.005 Alz03 13.00 0.18 13.58 0.12 14.26 13.89 17.11 17.69 0.06 Fe20 3* 2.06 0.14 1.91 0. 17 8.59 12.03 9.95 9.18 O.D3 MnO 0.04 0.01 0.04 0.01 0.16 0.20 0.1 7 0.15 0.005 MgO 0.28 0.05 0.39 0.05 1.9 1 5.55 8.26 11.11 0.04 CaO I.IO 0.09 1.23 0.1 I 4.41 7.89 10.82 10.84 0.03 Na20 3.45 0.16 3.56 0.17 3.62 3.2 1 2.70 2.48 0.09 KzO 5.07 0.07 5.08 0.15 3.