Charity, Louisiana Section 106 Programmatic Agreement

Home , Earhart Expressway, Freret Street, Kimono, McDonoghville

PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

WHEREAS, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), 16 U.S.C. §470f, and its implementing regulations at 36 CFR Part 800 (Section 106), require Federal Agencies to take into account the effects of their Undertakings on historic properties and provide the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) a reasonable opportunity to comment on those Undertakings;

WHEREAS, Hurricanes Katrina and Rita (Disaster) resulted in significant damage to healthcare infrastructure and severely limited medical training opportunities in New Orleans, Southern Louisiana, and the Gulf South area; and

WHEREAS, re-establishing healthcare infrastructure and medical training opportunities is critical to the recovery and vitality of New Orleans, Southern Louisiana, and the Gulf South area; and

WHEREAS, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) of the Department of Homeland Security, pursuant to Section 406 of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. §5121-5206) and implementing regulations in 44 CFR Part 206, proposes to provide Federal disaster assistance (Public Assistance) to the State of Louisiana, Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control (FP&C), through the Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (GOHSEP), in response to damages to the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) caused by the Disaster; and

WHEREAS, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) proposes to replace the VA Medical Center of New Orleans (VAMC) addressed at 1601 Perdido Street, New Orleans, LA that were damaged as a result of the Disaster; and

WHEREAS during the consultation process, the City of New Orleans (City) and the State of Louisiana negotiated and then executed a Cooperative Endeavor Agreement identifying the City as the "Responsible Entity" as the ultimate recipient of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds; and

Page 1 of 36

WHEREAS, the City, was invited to participate in the current Section 106 process at its initiation; and, if the Regional Planning Commission (RPC) Site is selected by the VA, the City will perform various actions to include but not be limited to acquisition, demolition, and site preparation, described in this Programmatic Agreement (PA), including mitigation, and the City, as the recipient of CDBG funds, will be the Responsible Entity for complying with environmental and historic preservation legal requirements (24 CFR Part 58) for the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD); and, the City is participating in this consultation and will execute the PA as a Signatory; and

WHEREAS, the City, in compliance with HUD regulations , intends to adopt the findings of the Section 106 consultation process upon the conclusion of the current study being conducted by VA and FEMA in cooperation with the Louisiana State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO); and

WHEREAS, FEMA, VA, and the City, in the event CDBG funds are used by the City (collectively referred to as the “Responsible Agencies”) have agreed to jointly fulfill their responsibilities under Section 106 of the NHPA for the MCLNO (FEMA Undertaking), the VAMC (VA Undertaking), and the use of CDBG funding (City Undertaking) required to repair or replace medical facilities in Orleans Parish damaged as a result of the Disaster through the development and implementation of a PA under 36 CFR §800.14(b) of the ACHP regulations; and

WHEREAS, the project alternatives under analysis by FEMA and FP&C are (1) Repair/Renovation of Existing Facilities, New Orleans, LA; and (2) Relocation to an area bounded by Tulane Avenue, Canal Street, South Galvez Street, and South Claiborne Avenue, New Orleans, LA (Proposed New LSU Site); and

WHEREAS, the project alternatives under analysis by VA are (1) Relocation of VAMC to the RPC Site bounded by Tulane Avenue, Canal Street, South Galvez Street, and South Rocheblave Street, New Orleans, LA; (2) Relocation of VAMC to the Ochsner Site bounded by Earhart Expressway, Jefferson Highway, Osterly Street, Betz Street, and Coolidge Street, Jefferson Parish, LA; and (3) Relocation of VAMC to the Lindy Boggs Site bounded by North Carrollton Avenue, Conti Street, North Pierce Street, Bienville Street, North Jefferson Davis Parkway, Saint Louis Street, North Telemachus Street, and Toulouse Street, New Orleans, LA; and

WHEREAS, VA and FEMA have defined the Undertakings’ Areas of Potential Effect (APE) for the various alternatives as illustrated in Appendix 1; and

WHEREAS, VA and FEMA have consulted with the SHPO and determined that the Undertakings have the potential to affect historic properties that may be eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places (Historic Properties) as illustrated in Appendix 2; and

Page 2 of 36

WHEREAS, the Chitimacha Tribe of Louisiana, Coushatta Tribe of Louisiana, Jena Band of Choctaw Indians, Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians (MBCI), and Tunica- Biloxi Tribe of Louisiana are federally recognized sovereign Indian Nations that have a government-to-government relationship with the United States and an interest in the lands included in the Undertakings, and the Responsible Agencies have notified these Indian tribes of the development of this PA and invited the Tribes to participate in the consultation, and MBCI has requested Consulting Party status and is invited by the Responsible Agencies to execute this PA as a Concurring Party; and

WHEREAS, FEMA has consulted with FP&C, the Subgrantee of FEMA Public Assistance, and in recognition that FP&C will assume responsibilities to perform various actions described by this PA, FEMA has invited FP&C to participate in this consultation and sign this PA as an Invited Signatory; and

WHEREAS, FEMA has invited GOHSEP, the Grantee of FEMA Public Assistance, to participate in this consultation and sign this PA as a Concurring Party; and

WHEREAS, the Responsible Agencies have invited the City of New Orleans, Historic District Landmarks Commission (HDLC), and the Louisiana State University (LSU) to participate in this consultation and sign this PA as Concurring Parties; and

WHEREAS, the Responsible Agencies have invited 2400 Canal LLC; City of New Orleans, City Council; City of New Orleans, Mayor's Office; City of New Orleans, Office of Recovery Development Administration; Committee to Reopen Charity Hospital; Common Knowledge; Deutsches Haus; Downtown Development District of New Orleans (DDD); Foundation for Historical Louisiana; Friends of New Orleans Cemeteries; Friends of the Lafitte Corridor; Louisiana Chapter of the International Working Party for Documentation and Conservation of Building Sites and Neighborhoods of the Modern Movement (DOCOMOMO/NOLA); Louisiana Landmarks Society; Lower Mid-City Residents and Business Owners Affected by the LSU/VA Hospitals; LSU Site United Property Owners; Mid-City Neighborhood Organization; National Trust for Historic Preservation (NTHP); Orleans Parish School Board; Parkview Neighborhood Association; Phoenix of New Orleans; Preservation Resource Center; RPC; Sewerage & Water Board; State of Louisiana, Office of Community Development; and Tulane/Canal Neighborhood Development Corporation to participate in this consultation as Consulting Parties; and

WHEREAS, VA and FEMA notified Allard Boulevard Association; American Institute of Architects, Louisiana Chapter; Archdiocese of New Orleans, Cemetery Office; Delgado Community College, Charity School of Nursing; Churchill Downs; District 5 Neighborhood Recovery Group; Esplanade Ridge and Treme Civic Association; Faubourg St. John Neighborhood Association; Historic Resources Inc.; Jefferson Historical Society of Louisiana; Jefferson Parish Historical Commission; Louisiana Recovery Authority; Save Our Cemeteries; Tulane University School of Medicine; and Victory Real Estate of the Undertakings and the opportunity to participate in this consultation, but they either did not respond or declined to participate; and

Page 3 of 36

WHEREAS, in keeping with 36 CFR §800.2(d), VA and FEMA have sought and considered the views of the public, and the Responsible Agencies held meetings with the Consulting Parties on 24 June 2008, 23 July 2008, 12 August 2008, 25 September 2008, and 27 October 2008, and collected comments from the Consulting Parties during and following each meeting; and

WHEREAS, VA and FEMA provided an overview of their Section 106 compliance responsibilities at National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) scoping meetings held on 26 June 2008, 17 July 2008, 11 August 2008; and a joint NEPA/NHPA meeting to collect and consider commentary on 28 October 2008; and the VA and FEMA published advertisements in The Times-Picayune and the Louisiana Weekly to obtain the views of the public regarding the identification of historic properties in the APE for each alternative and input regarding potential effects to historic properties within the APE for each alternative, as well as publishing information regarding this project at http://www.valsumedcenters.com, and made information available to Consulting Parties at http://www.consult106.org (Website) [username=c106consultant, password=c106consultant], and employed a dedicated email address for the distribution of information to and the collection of comments from Consulting Parties; and

WHEREAS, if the VA selects its RPC Site Alternative and/or FP&C selects the proposed new LSU Site Alternative, the SHPO will develop and implement a program to promote the preservation and rehabilitation of contributing elements within the Mid-City National Register Historic District, which would be adversely affected by these alternatives; VA, the City and FP&C will support the eligible historic preservation costs of the program up to $1,400,000; the SHPO shall consult with interested parties to develop guidelines for defining eligible preservation and rehabilitation projects to be supported by the program; the program will continue until all funds are expended or for a period of time not to exceed 3 years; and

WHEREAS, the ACHP has elected to participate in the Section 106 consultation process pursuant to 36 CFR §800.2(b)(1) and will execute this PA as a Signatory; and

NOW, THEREFORE, the Responsible Agencies, ACHP, and Louisiana SHPO agree that the implementation of the following stipulations evidence that the Responsible Agencies have taken into account the effects of these Undertakings upon historic properties, and that this PA evidences compliance with Section 106 of the NHPA in accordance with 36 CFR §800.6 (c) and 36 CFR §800.14.

STIPULATIONS

I. APPLICABILITY

A. The stipulations of this PA describe treatment measures for all site alternatives under consideration. It is understood that following Site Selection, stipulations proposed for non-selected sites for each Undertaking are not applicable. Upon

Page 4 of 36

Site Selection, the Responsible Agencies will notify the Consulting Parties of the Site Selection decisions by e-mail and posting to the Website.

B. The City is only responsible for ensuring implementation of the stipulations associated with its Undertaking should the VA select the RPC site.

C. VA is only responsible for ensuring the implementation of the stipulations associated with its Undertaking.

D. FEMA is only responsible for ensuring the implementation of the stipulations associated with its Undertaking.

II. GENERAL

A. The Signatory and Concurring Parties will send and accept receipt of official notices, comments, requests for further information and documentation, and other communications required by this PA by e-mail.

B. Time designations shall be in calendar days. Failure to comment within specified time designations will be treated as concurrence.

C. The Responsible Agencies will ensure that Federal, State, or contractor staff who meet the Secretary of the Interior’s (SOI) Professional Qualification Standards as determined by FEMA’s and VA’s Federal Preservation Officers (FPO) and/or in the case of the City, HDLC or designees, will participate in the decision making required by this PA.

D. Although the projects have been reviewed and evaluated jointly, the VA project to replace its medical facilities and the FEMA and FP&C project to repair or replace healthcare services and medical training are separate projects, and each may be commenced, built and completed independently of the other.

III. TRIBAL CONSULTATION

A. The Responsible Agencies recognize the United States government-to- government relationship with Indian tribes, and have notified the Chitimacha Tribe of Louisiana, Coushatta Tribe of Louisiana, Jena Band of Choctaw Indians, Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, and Tunica-Biloxi Tribe of Louisiana regarding the development of this PA and invited each Indian tribe to sign this PA as Concurring Parties.

B. The Responsible Agencies shall take steps to protect confidential information in accordance with Section 304 of NHPA and 36 CFR §800.11(c).

Page 5 of 36

C. An Indian Tribe may determine that it has no interest in consulting on certain types of Undertakings included in this PA and may notify the Responsible Agencies of its determination.

IV. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION

A. The Responsible Agencies recognize the public interest in their respective Undertakings, and will make reasonable efforts to inform the public of the progress of these Undertakings in a timely manner. Additional public forums include but are not limited to City Council Meetings or various Council Sub- Committee Meetings.

B. The Responsible Agencies have used various media outlets including The Times-Picayune and the Louisiana Weekly to request input from the public to inform their determinations of eligibility for historic properties. The Responsible Agencies will continue to use these outlets as well as the Baton Rouge The Advocate to seek input from the public at appropriate times during the implementation of this PA.

C. The Responsible Agencies shall accept responses to its requests for public comments through the U.S. mail and e-mail submittals.

D. The Responsible Agencies will maintain the Website to provide the Consulting Parties with project information and deliverables as stipulated in this PA. The Responsible Agencies will notify the Consulting Parties via e-mail when they post new information to the Website.

E. VA, the City and FP&C will each identify a single point of contact to act as an community point of contact to the Consulting Parties regarding the implementation of their respective treatment measures stipulated in this PA. Contact information for these individuals will be provided by e-mail to the Consulting Parties within 30 days of the execution of this PA.

V. ARCHITECTURAL TREATMENT MEASURES: US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS

A. This Stipulation sets forth treatment measures for standing historic properties adversely affected by the VA’s Undertaking. Archaeological historic properties are addressed in Stipulation VII.

B. RPC Site

1. Should the RPC site be selected by VA, VA and the City shall ensure that the following measures are carried out to avoid, minimize, or mitigate adverse effects to historic properties.

Page 6 of 36

2. Measures to Avoid Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Site Security: The owner of the site shall ensure that reasonable measures to provide adequate site security are accomplished. Adequate site security shall prohibit to the extent possible, looting and vandalism to historic properties contained within the site. Security measures may include supplemental exterior lighting, on-site security, and regular monitoring of historic properties.

b) Secure and Ventilate: VA will continue to secure and ventilate the former VAMC addressed at 1601 Perdido Street, to avoid further deterioration of the buildings.

c) Retention of Historic Properties:

i. VA will retain and rehabilitate the Pan-American Life Insurance Company Building addressed at 2400 Canal Street and integrate this historic building into the design of the new VAMC.

ii. If feasible, VA will retain and rehabilitate the Dixie Brewery addressed at 2401 Tulane Avenue and integrate this historic building into the design of the new VAMC. VA, in consultation with the SHPO, will first assess the structural stability of the Dixie Brewery and determine if it will be feasible to retain the structure in its entirety. If it is concluded that it is not possible to retain and rehabilitate the entire structure VA will identify the significant features of the Dixie Brewery and integrate those features of the historic building in the design of the new VAMC.

iii. Prior to any repair or renovation efforts at the Pan-American Life Insurance Company Building and the Dixie Brewery, VA will document the exterior elevations, interior, and significant architectural and iconic details of both buildings. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography, and be performed by or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

d) Design of New Construction:

Page 7 of 36

of the design, construction, and operation of the proposed medical facilities. Acquisition of all land within the boundaries of the selected site may commence upon site selection.

ii. VA, FEMA, FP&C, and the City acknowledge and recognize that design plans for the VA and LSU Medical Centers may involve both plans for the immediate construction and utilization of facilities within the selected sites and may also involve long-term planning goals and objectives to accommodate future needs for expansion of the respective campuses.

iii. For a period of 30 days following site selection, VA will receive comments from interested Consulting Parties concerning methods to incorporate and/or integrate into the design historic properties on the periphery of the selected site.

iv. VA will consider in its schematic design plans the comments received during this 30-day comment period and a range of facility development solutions which will utilize setbacks, materials selections, landscaping, site layout, modification to building footprints, massing and other appropriate techniques to improve compatibility with the Mid-City National Register Historic District. No demolition of historic properties on the selected site will take place during this 30-day comment period.

v. VA will convene 2 design review sessions where all interested Consulting Parties that participated in the Section 106 process, including the SHPO, are invited and welcome to participate. The design team will provide a presentation on the design progress, discuss design options, explain what steps were taken to meet the design goals outlined in Stipulation VI.B.2 and solicit Consulting Party input. The sessions will be held in New Orleans, and the Consulting Parties will be given at least 14 days prior notice for each design review session.

vi. Consulting Parties may provide written comments for a period of 14 days after design review sessions. Comments will be posted on the Website. After considering all timely comments, within 30 days of the end of the comment period, VA will post on the Website a summary response to the substantive comments provided by Consulting Parties.

3. Measures to Minimize Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Moving Historic Properties

Page 8 of 36

i. VA will support the SHPO by reimbursing up to $600,000 and the City will reimburse up to $200,000 for a total of up to $800,000 for moving one-story residential buildings of exceptional architectural importance to the Mid-City National Register Historic District from their current locations within the RPC Site to new sites within the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

ii. If and when VA selects the RPC site, the SHPO will undertake an evaluation of contributing elements to the Mid-City National Register Historic District within the RPC Site, utilizing the data prepared for this Section 106 consultation, and prioritize the buildings of the most exceptional architectural importance, apparent structural integrity, and physical condition that may affect suitability for moving.

iii. During the acquisition process, each of the property owners of the candidates for moving will be notified in writing that up to $40,000 of the monies described in Stipulation V.B.3(a)(i) may be available to cover costs associated with moving the building.

iv. The City through its redevelopment agency may provide further assistance to the property owner by making available at cost of transaction fee or legal fee only a vacant lot within the Mid-City National Register Historic District suitable to receive the moved building.

v. The owner of a candidate building deemed eligible for moving must agree to move the candidate building within the timeframe established during the acquisition process and must agree to any other terms and conditions established by the SHPO in administration of the Mid-City National Register Historic District Mitigation Program. b) Interim Treatment of the Dixie Brewery and the Pan-American Life Insurance Company Building: Subsequent to Site Selection, and within 6 months of acquisition, the City will secure and ventilate these structures to minimize deterioration of the resources until the transfer of ownership to VA.

i. Such stabilization will secure the exterior of the building and character-defining features and ornamentation.

ii. The City will forward 2 copies of summary reports detailing the stabilization measures to the SHPO for comment. If the SHPO does not comment within 14 days of receipt of adequate documentation, the City may assume that SHPO concurs with the

Page 9 of 36

plan. The City will finalize the stabilization measures after considering the SHPO’s comments and implement those measures.

iii. The City will post summary reports of stabilization measures to the Website.

iv. VA will continue to secure and ventilate these structures after acquisition until commencement of rehabilitation work. c) Vibration Monitoring. Prior to the commencement of any construction, demolition or site disturbance, VA and the City will establish, in consultation with the SHPO, a Vibration Tolerance and Monitoring Program (Program) to safeguard historic properties within the APE from inadvertent damage from vibration due to ground disturbing activities. A structural engineer experienced in traditional materials will develop this program and will take into consideration current soils conditions, strength and duration of disturbance, cumulative effects of ongoing vibration, construction type and current condition of built resources within the APE. The Program will reference the Bureau of Mines’ and Federal Transit Administration’s vibration standards and justify any discrepancies with these authorities due to site or location specific conditions.

i. The Program will define:

• acceptable ranges of vibration within the APE based on geographic proximity to resources, • existing baseline vibration levels, • protocols for regular on-site monitoring, • stop work protocols, • protocols for further reducing vibrations, as necessary, and • specific protocols to address vibration at St. Louis Cemetery No. 2 addressed at 1600 St. Louis Street.

ii. VA and the City will submit the Program to SHPO for comment. If SHPO does not comment in a 14-day review period, VA and the City may assume that SHPO concurs with the Program. VA and the City will complete the Program after considering the SHPO’s comments, post it to the Website, and implement the Program. d) Phased Demolition and Construction: The City will phase demolition and VA will phase construction activities to avoid concentrated indirect adverse effects to surrounding neighborhoods to the extent practicable.

Page 10 of 36

4. Measures to Mitigate Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Participation in the SHPO Mid-City Historic Preservation Mitigation Program:

i. Should VA select the RPC Site Alternative, VA will support the SHPO in its effort to develop and implement a program, described in the preamble to this PA, to promote the preservation and rehabilitation of contributing elements within the Mid-City National Register Historic District, which would be adversely affected by these alternatives. The VA will remit to the SHPO a total cost not to exceed $700,000 for eligible historic preservation project costs incurred within the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

ii. Should VA select the RPC Site Alternative, the City will support the SHPO in its effort to develop and implement a program, described in the preamble to this PA, to promote the preservation and rehabilitation of contributing elements within the Mid-City National Register Historic District, which would be adversely affected by these alternatives. The City will remit to the SHPO a total cost not to exceed $400,000 for eligible historic preservation project costs incurred within the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

b) Recordation:

i. Prior to any transfer or sale of VAMC, VA in consultation with the City, will document the former VA Hospital and the VA Managers and Nurses Quarters of the VAMC addressed at 1601 Perdido Street. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

ii. The recordation will include the documentation of the exterior elevations, interior, pumping equipment, and architectural and iconic details of Sewerage Pumping Station No. 15 addressed at 2431 Palmyra Street. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

iii. Prior to demolition or architectural salvage, VA will document all historic properties within the project footprint that will not be retained. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix

Page 11 of 36

3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

iv. VA will post the recordation data and resulting materials to the Website. c) Architectural Salvage: Prior to the demolition or substantial alteration of historic properties that will not be retained, VA and the City shall ensure that the salvage of historic architectural elements from historic properties proposed for demolition in the Mid-City National Register Historic District occurs in accordance with the Architectural Salvage plan stipulated in Appendix 4. d) Public Interpretation: VA will design and implement a public interpretation program related to the Mid-City National Register Historic District and the history of the VAMC.

i. This program may include:

• oral histories; • museum quality, publically accessible, permanent displays; • traveling exhibits; • publically accessible website; and/or • popular publications.

ii. VA will post the public interpretation program to the Website for comment by the Consulting Parties and notify Consulting Parties via e-mail of the posting. If these parties do not comment within 14- days of receipt, VA may assume that these parties concur with the program and schedule. VA will finalize the public interpretation program after considering the comments and implement the program.

iii. VA will post the final public interpretation program and resulting materials to the Website. e) Local Historic District Designation: The City will assist local interest citizen organization(s) in pursuing the local historic district designation of the Mid-City National Register Historic District by doing the following:

i. Within 60 days of receipt of a letter from a Mid-City neighborhood representative in support of local designation, the HDLC will

Page 12 of 36

appoint a study committee to prepare a report on the local designation of the Mid-City National Register Historic District;

ii. FEMA will provide the HDLC with the data that was gathered and prepared for identification and evaluation of the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

iii. Within 9 months of receipt of the FEMA data and the receipt of a letter from a neighborhood representative in support of local designation, the HDLC will submit a report that could be used to nominate the Mid-City National Register Historic District as a New Orleans HDLC local historic district, should any neighborhood group choose to pursue such a designation, per the appropriate City regulations.

C. Lindy Boggs Site

1. Should the Lindy Boggs Site be selected, VA shall ensure that the following measures are carried out to avoid, minimize, or mitigate adverse effects to historic properties.

2. Measures to Avoid Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Secure and Ventilate: VA will continue to secure and ventilate the former VAMC addressed at 1601 Perdido Street to avoid further deterioration of the buildings.

b) Design for New Construction:

i. Immediately following the announcement by VA of a site to replace the VAMC (site selection), VA and FEMA will begin preparation of joint or separate site specific environmental assessments (EAs) in accordance with NEPA and the programmatic environmental assessment (PEA) to analyze the potential environmental impacts of the design, construction, and operation of the proposed medical facilities. Acquisition of all land within the boundaries of the selected site may commence upon site selection.

ii. VA, FEMA, FP&C, and the City acknowledge and recognize that design plans for the VA and LSU Medical Centers may involve both plans for the immediate construction and utilization of facilities within the selected sites and may also involve long- term planning goals and objectives to accommodate future needs for expansion of the respective campuses.

Page 13 of 36

iv. VA will consider in its schematic design plans the comments received during this 30-day comment period and a range of facility development solutions which will utilize setbacks, materials selections, landscaping, site layout, modification to building footprints, massing and other appropriate techniques to improve compatibility with the Mid-City National Register Historic District and Parkview National Register Historic District. No demolition of historic properties on the selected site will take place during this 30-day comment period.

v. VA will convene 2 design review sessions where all interested Consulting Parties that participated in the Section 106 process, including the SHPO, are invited and welcome to participate. The design team will provide a presentation on the design progress, discuss design options, explain what steps were taken to meet the design goals outlined in Stipulation VI.C.2. and solicit Consulting Party input. The sessions will be held in New Orleans, and the Consulting Parties will be given at least 14 days prior notice for each design review session.

3. Measures to Minimize Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Vibration Monitoring. Prior to the commencement of any construction, demolition or site disturbance, VA will establish, in consultation with the SHPO, a Vibration Tolerance and Monitoring Program (Program) to safeguard historic properties within the APE from inadvertent damage from vibration due to ground disturbing activities. A structural engineer experienced in traditional materials will develop this program and will take into consideration current soils conditions, strength and duration of disturbance, cumulative effects of ongoing vibration, construction type and current condition of built resources within the APE. The Program will reference the Bureau of Mines’ and Federal Transit Administration’s vibration standards and justify any discrepancies with these authorities due to site or location specific conditions.

Page 14 of 36

i. The Program will define:

ii. VA will submit the Program to SHPO for comment, and will post the results of the program to the Website. If SHPO does not comment in a 14-day review period, VA may assume that SHPO concurs with the Program. VA will complete the Program after considering the SHPO’s comments and implement the Program.

b) Phased Demolition and Construction. VA will phase demolition and construction activities to avoid concentrated indirect adverse effects to surrounding neighborhoods wherever practicable.

4. Measures to Mitigate Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Recordation

i. Prior to any transfer or sale of VAMC, VA will document the former VA Hospital and the VA Managers and Nurses Quarters of the VAMC addressed at 1601 Perdido Street. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

ii. VA will post the recordation data and resulting materials to the Website.

b) Public Interpretation: VA will design and implement a public interpretation program related to the history of the VAMC.

i. This program may include:

• oral histories; • museum quality, publically accessible, permanent displays; • traveling exhibits; • publically accessible website; and • popular publications.

Page 15 of 36

iii. VA will post the final public interpretation program and resulting materials to the Website.

D. Ochsner Site

1. Should the Ochsner Site be selected, VA shall ensure that the following measures are carried out to avoid, minimize, or mitigate adverse effects to historic properties.

2. Measures to Avoid Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Secure and Ventilate: VA will continue to secure and ventilate the former VAMC addressed at 1601 Perdido Street, to avoid further deterioration of the buildings.

b) VA will provide sufficient notice to the owners of the Steam Locomotive 745 to allow them to secure a new location and to move the engine to a location outside the proposed Ochsner site. VA will request that the owner of Steam Locomotive 745 notify the SHPO of the new location once it has been determined.

3. Measures to Mitigate Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Recordation

ii. VA will post the recordation data and resulting materials to the Website.

Page 16 of 36

b) Public Interpretation: VA will design and implement a public interpretation program related to the history of the VAMC.

i. This program may include:

• oral histories; • museum quality, publically accessible, permanent displays; • traveling exhibits; • publically accessible website; and • popular publications.

iii. VA will post the final public interpretation program and resulting materials to the Website.

VI. ARCHITECTURAL TREATMENT MEASURES: FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA)

A. This Stipulation sets forth treatment measures for standing historic properties adversely affected by FEMA’s Undertaking. Archaeological historic properties are addressed in Stipulation VII.

B. Repair/Renovation of Existing Facilities

1. Should the Repair/Renovation alternative be selected by FP&C, FEMA will ensure the following measures are carried out to avoid, minimize, or mitigate adverse effects to historic properties.

2. Measures to Avoid Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Site Security: FP&C shall ensure that reasonable measures to provide adequate site security are accomplished following Site Selection. Adequate site security shall prohibit to the extent possible, looting and vandalism to historic properties contained within the site. Security measures may include supplemental exterior lighting, on-site security, and regular monitoring of historic properties.

Page 17 of 36

b) Secure and Ventilate: Within 6 months of Site Selection, FP&C shall secure and ventilate all 9 historic properties within the MCLNO campus to avoid further deterioration. These buildings are Charity Hospital addressed at 1532 Tulane Avenue, the Dibert Memorial Building addressed at 340 North Claiborne Avenue, the Lepeyre-Miltenberger Building addressed at 1550 Tulane Avenue, the General Services Building addressed at 1508 Gravier Street, the Power House addressed at 422 Freret Street, the Maintenance Shop addressed at 433 LaSalle Street, the Delgado Building addressed at 1545 Tulane Avenue, the Butterworth Building addressed at 1541 Tulane Avenue, and the Laundry Building addressed at 405 LaSalle Street.

i. Such stabilization will secure the exterior envelope of the building and character-defining features and ornamentation.

ii. FP&C will forward 3 copies of summary reports detailing the stabilization measures to FEMA. FEMA will provide comments within 14-days of receipt of plan. FP&C will consider the comments provided by FEMA on the draft submissions to the extent possible and then submit the revised summary to the SHPO and Consulting Parties. If the SHPO and Consulting Parties do not comment within 14 days of receipt, FP&C may assume that SHPO and Consulting Parties concur with the plan. FP&C will finalize the stabilization plan after considering the comments and implement the plan.

iii. FP&C will post summary reports of stabilization measures to the Website.

3. Measures to Minimize Adverse Effects

a) Vibration Monitoring: Prior to the commencement of any construction, demolition or site disturbance, FP&C will develop a Vibration Tolerance and Monitoring Program (Program) to safeguard historic properties within the APE from inadvertent damage from vibration due to ground disturbing activities. This Program will be developed by a structural engineer experienced in traditional materials and will take into consideration current soils conditions, strength and duration of disturbance, cumulative effects of ongoing vibration, construction type and current condition of built resources within the APE.

i. The Program will define:

• acceptable ranges of vibration within the APE based on geographic proximity to resources, • existing baseline vibration levels, • protocols for regular on-site monitoring,

Page 18 of 36

• stop work protocols, and • protocols for further reducing vibrations, as necessary, and

ii. FP&C shall submit the Program to SHPO for comment and notify FEMA in writing. If SHPO does not comment in a 14-day review period, FEMA / FP&C may assume that SHPO concurs with the Program. FP&C will finalize the Program after considering the SHPO comments, post it to the Website, and implement the Program.

b) Design of Repair/Renovation: Designs for repair by FP&C will consider the SOI Standards for Rehabilitation with emphasis on preservation of the exterior front entrance and interior lobby.

i. FP&C will submit design drawings to the SHPO for comment during the schematic design and design development stages of the design process, and notify FEMA in writing.

ii. If the SHPO does not provide comments to FP&C within 14-days of receipt of design drawings, FP&C may assume that SHPO concurs with the plans. FP&C will finalize the design plan after considering the comments, and implement the plan.

4. Measures to Mitigate Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Recordation

i. Prior to any repair or renovation efforts to Charity Hospital, FP&C will document the Charity Hospital building. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

ii. FP&C will post the recordation data and resulting materials to the Website.

C. Relocation to the Proposed New LSU Site

1. Should the Proposed New LSU Site be selected by FP&C, FEMA will ensure the following measures are carried out to avoid, minimize or mitigate adverse effects to historic properties.

2. Measures to Avoid Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

Page 19 of 36

a) Site Security: FP&C shall ensure that reasonable measures to provide adequate site security are accomplished following Site Selection and acquisition to prohibit, to the extent possible, looting and vandalism to historic properties contained within the site. Security measures may include supplemental exterior lighting, on-site security, and regular monitoring of historic properties. b) Secure and Ventilate

i. Within 6 months of Site Selection, FP&C shall secure and ventilate all 9 historic properties within the MCLNO campus. These buildings are Charity Hospital addressed at 1532 Tulane Avenue, the Dibert Memorial Building addressed at 340 North Claiborne Avenue, the Lepeyre-Miltenberger Building addressed at 1550 Tulane Avenue, the General Services Building addressed at 1508 Gravier Street, the Power House addressed at 422 Freret Street, the Maintenance Shop addressed at 433 LaSalle Street, the Delgado Building addressed at 1545 Tulane Avenue, the Butterworth Building addressed at 1541 Tulane Avenue, and the Laundry Building addressed at 405 LaSalle Street.

ii. Such stabilization will secure the exterior of the building and character-defining features and ornamentation.

iii. FP&C will forward 3 copies of summary reports detailing the stabilization measures to FEMA. FEMA will provide comments within 14-days of receipt of plan. FP&C will consider the comments provided by FEMA on the draft submissions to the extent possible and then submit the revised summary to the SHPO. If the SHPO does not comment within 14 days of receipt, FP&C may assume that SHPO concurs with the plan. FP&C will finalize the stabilization plan after considering the SHPO comments and implement the plan.

iv. FP&C will post summary reports of stabilization measures to the Website. c) Retention of Historic Properties: FP&C will retain to the extent feasible, either through avoidance or integration into the design plan, the Deutsches Haus addressed at 200 South Galvez Street and Orleans House addressed at 1800 Canal Street.

i. In its feasibility evaluation, FP&C will consider a multitude of factors including the spacing requirements for the project construction, future site development/use needs, set back requirements, local ordinances and Federal regulatory requirements, structural integrity

Page 20 of 36

and characteristics of the property, cost to retain the property, and feasibility of use of the property.

ii. FP&C shall provide written explanation to FEMA and the SHPO of its decision on the retention of Deutsches Haus and Orleans House and post on the Website. iii. If FP&C determines that it is feasible to retain the Deutsches Haus and Orleans House, the schematic design and design development plans for the rehabilitation and re-use will be included in the overall site design review described in Stipulation VI.C.2(d)(i) of this PA.

iv. Prior to any repair or renovation efforts at the Deutsches Haus and Orleans House, FP&C will document the exterior elevations, interior, and architectural and iconic details of both buildings. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

v. If FP&C determines that it is not feasible to retain the Deutsches Haus, FP&C will assist Deutsches Haus in relocating their cultural activities to a different, suitable location within the Mid-City National Register Historic District. In addition, in the event that demolition of the Deutsches Haus cannot be avoided, FP&C will feature Deutsches Haus in the public interpretation program described in VI.C.4(d) of this PA and will document the building. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

vi. If FP&C determines that it is not feasible to re-use Orleans House, FP&C will evaluate the feasibility of moving the building to a new location within the Mid-City National Register Historic District, preferably with frontage on Canal Street. If FP&C determines it is feasible to move Orleans House, FP&C will notify SHPO and HDLC for comment on an appropriate location. FP&C will consider the comments submitted by SHPO and HDLC, if received within 14 days of notification, before selecting a suitable location. FP&C will then move Orleans House.

vii. If FP&C determines it is not feasible to either retain or move Orleans House, FP&C will document the building. The recordation

Page 21 of 36

will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture. In addition, FP&C will feature Orleans House in the public interpretation program described in VI.C.4(d) of this PA.

viii. If FP&C determines that neither the retention nor the removal of Orleans House is practicable, after documentation, FP&C will consider permitting a non-profit historic preservation third-party organization to dismantle and remove the structure, provided they can come to an acceptable agreement to use the structure in a manner sympathetic with its historic significance, and to do so without impeding FP&C’s timeframe for site clearance and construction. d) Design of New Construction:

i. Immediately following the announcement by FP&C of a site to replace the MCLNO (site selection), FEMA will begin preparation of joint or separate site specific EAs in accordance with NEPA and the programmatic environmental assessment (PEA) to analyze the potential environmental impacts of the design, construction, and operation of the proposed medical facilities. Acquisition of all land within the boundaries of the selected site may commence upon site selection.

iii. For a period of 30 days following site selection, FP&C will receive comments from interested consulting parties concerning methods to incorporate and/or integrate into the design historic properties on the periphery of the selected site. FP&C will consider in its schematic design plans the comments received during this 30-day comment period and a range of facility development solutions which will utilize setbacks, materials selections, landscaping, site layout, modification to building footprints, massing and other appropriate techniques to improve compatibility with the Mid-City National Register District. No demolition of historic properties on the selected site will take place during this 30-day comment period.

Page 22 of 36

iv. FP&C will convene 2 design review sessions where all interested Consulting Parties that participated in the Section 106 process, including the SHPO, are invited to participate. The design team will provide a presentation on the design progress, discuss design options, explain what steps were taken to meet the design goals outlined in Stipulation VI.C.2(d) and solicit Consulting Party input. The sessions will be held in New Orleans, and the Consulting Parties will be given at least 14 days prior notice for each design review session. Consulting Parties may provide written comments for a period of 14 days. Comments will be posted on the Website. Within 30 days of the end of the comment period, VA will post on the Website a summary response to the substantive comments provided by Consulting Parties.

3. Measures to Minimize Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

i. The Program will define:

• acceptable ranges of vibration within the APE based on geographic proximity to resources, • existing baseline vibration levels, • protocols for regular on-site monitoring, • stop work protocols, and • protocols for further reducing vibrations, as necessary. • specific protocols to address vibration at St. Louis Cemetery No. 2 addressed at 1600 St. Louis Street.

ii. FP&C shall submit the Program to SHPO for comment and notify FEMA in writing. If SHPO does not comment in a 14-day review period, FEMA / FP&C may assume that SHPO concurs with the program. FP&C will finalize the Program after considering the SHPO comments, post it to the Website, and implement the Program. b) Phased Demolition and Construction

Page 23 of 36

i. FP&C will phase demolition and construction activities to avoid concentrated indirect adverse effects to surrounding historic properties wherever practicable.

ii. FP&C will phase demolition and construction activities as required to ensure that treatment measures stipulated in this PA can be implemented including:

a. Evaluation of the feasibility of the retention of the Deutsches Haus and the retention or relocation of the Orleans House (Stipulation VI.C.2.c) b. Recordation of historic properties to be demolished (Stipulation VI.C.4.b) c. Architectural Salvage (Stipulation VI.C.4.c) d. Identification and evaluation of historic archaeological properties and treatment measures associated with these properties such as Data Recovery (Stipulation VII)

iii. FP&C will provide the ACHP Chairman with a notification in writing that funding stream for design and construction has been identified and a business plan has been approved for the proposed hospital. No demolition activities will be undertaken until such notice has been sent and received.

4. Measures to Mitigate Adverse Effects to Historic Properties

a) Participation in SHPO Mid-City Historic Preservation Mitigation Program:

i. Should FP&C select the proposed new LSU Site Alternative, FP&C will support the SHPO in its effort to develop and implement a program, described in the preamble to this PA, to promote the preservation and rehabilitation of contributing elements within the Mid-City National Register Historic District, which would be adversely affected by the project. FP&C will remit to SHPO a total cost not to exceed $300,000 for eligible historic preservation project costs incurred within the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

b) Recordation

i. Prior to demolition and architectural salvage, FP&C will document all historic properties within the project footprint that will not be retained. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography and narrative reports, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual

Page 24 of 36

who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

ii. Prior to any transfer or sale of Charity Hospital, FP&C will document the building. The recordation will include the documentation of exterior elevations, interior spaces and iconic details of the building. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

iii. The recordation will include the documentation of the exterior elevations, interior, and architectural and iconic details of McDonogh School No. 11. The recordation will proceed in accordance with Appendix 3, include digital photography, and be performed by, or under the direct supervision of, an individual who meets the SOI Professional Qualification Standards (48 FR 44716) for history, architectural history, or historic architecture.

iv. FP&C will post the recordation data and resulting materials to the Website. c) Architectural Salvage: Prior to the demolition or substantial alteration of historic properties, FP&C shall ensure that the salvage of historic architectural elements from historic properties proposed for demolition in the Mid-City National Register Historic District occurs in accordance with the process stipulated in Appendix 4. d) Public Interpretation: FP&C will design and implement a public interpretation program related to the Mid-City National Register Historic District, Charity Hospital, McDonogh School No. 11, Deutsches Haus, and Orleans House.

i. This program may include:

• oral histories; • museum quality, publically accessible, permanent displays; • traveling exhibits; • publically-accessible website; and • popular publications.

ii. FP&C will post the public interpretation program to the Website for comment by the Consulting Parties and notify Consulting Parties via e-mail of the posting. FP&C will forward 2 copies of the program for the public interpretation program with an implementation schedule to

Page 25 of 36

the SHPO for comment and notify FEMA in writing. If the SHPO does not comment within a 14-day review period, FP&C may assume that the SHPO concurs with the program and schedule. FP&C will finalize the public interpretation program after considering the SHPO comments and implement the program.

iii. FP&C will post the final public interpretation program and resulting materials to the Website. e) Local Historic District Designation: In partnership, FEMA and the City will assist local interest citizen organization(s) in pursuing the local historic district designation process for the Mid-City National Register Historic District by doing the following:

i. Within 60 days of receipt of a letter from a Mid-City neighborhood representative in support of local designation, the HDLC will appoint a study committee to prepare a report on the local designation of the Mid-City National Register Historic District;

ii. FEMA will provide the HDLC with the data that was gathered and prepared for FEMA identification and evaluation of the Mid-City National Register Historic District.

iii. Provided the VA selects the RPC Site, within 9 months of receipt of the FEMA data and the receipt of a letter from a neighborhood representative in support of local designation, the HDLC will submit a report that could be used to nominate the Mid-City National Register Historic District a New Orleans HDLC local historic district, should any neighborhood group choose to pursue such a designation, per the appropriate city regulations.

f) Reuse and/or Disposition of Historic Buildings in the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO)

i. FP&C and LSU will develop a strategic plan to foster and encourage adaptive reuse of 9 historically significant buildings that were part of the 23 buildings that made up the former MCLNO that were damaged by Hurricane Katrina. These historic properties already have been identified, and they are: Charity Hospital, the Dibert Memorial Building, the Lepeyre-Miltenberger Building, the General Services Building, the Power House, the Maintenance Shop, the Delgado Building, the Butterworth Building, and the Laundry Building.

ii. LSU will determine which of the above-mentioned 9 historic properties may be suitable for its use. For those historic properties

Page 26 of 36

LSU determines are not suited for its use, FP&C will offer these buildings to other state agencies in accordance with State law. For those buildings not needed by other State agencies, FP&C will consult with the SHPO on the key historic elements of each building prior to making those remaining historic properties available to other interested parties, all in accordance with state law. The SHPO will have 14 days to respond. iii. FP&C will endeavor to promote adaptive reuse for those nine historically significant buildings that neither it nor other state agencies use. During this process, FP&C will give notice to the SHPO and to those groups and individuals who participated in this Section 106 process as Consulting Parties. Additionally, public meetings and/or forums will be held at no less than 2 points in the process of evaluating the reuse or transfer of these properties from State control, to solicit input and comments from the interested parties.

iv. If it is determined that Charity Hospital is not suitable for use by a state agency, FP&C and/or LSU will take input from the City, the DDD, the RPC, and the SHPO with respect to the future use of Charity Hospital. FP&C and/or LSU will prepare a marketing study that will consider state or municipal tax incentives, grants, financing, or other development incentives in addition to the potential for Federal historic preservation income tax credits for the rehabilitation of historic income producing properties.

a. FP&C and/or LSU will provide the Signatory and Concurring Parties documentation of the marketing study and its use and will also post this documentation on the Website to inform the public.

b. FP&C and/or LSU will develop the marketing study upon the conclusion of the design process for the new facility, and will actively attract and encourage offers from public or private entities to rehabilitate and re-use the existing historic Charity Hospital building for a minimum of 3 years following completion and publication of the marketing study.

c. Conditioned upon legislative approval, the State will deed an exterior and selective interior preservation easement to an appropriate third-party non-profit historic preservation organization prior to transferring ownership to a municipal or private entity and stipulate in the property transfer that any rehabilitation or improvements to the property be made in accordance with the SOI Standards for Rehabilitation.

Page 27 of 36

d. If after publication of the marketing study and attempting to attract a qualified purchaser for a minimum of 3 years, the State has been unsuccessful, the State may dispose of the property as it sees fit, up to and including transfer without easement or stipulations and/or demolition of the building, with no further obligations under this PA.

iv. FP&C will contract for the individual National Register nomination of Charity Hospital, and will ensure that the appropriate documentation for that nomination is submitted to the SHPO within 12 months of the execution of this PA.

VII. CONSIDERATION OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL PROPERTIES: U.S. DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS (VA) AND THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA)

A. Timing and Responsibilities

1. Immediately following site acquisition, the owner of the site will take steps to ensure that adequate site security is established to prohibit, to the extent possible, vandalism to archaeological sites. For the properties acquired by FP&C, the Louisiana Archaeological Resources Act (R.S. 41:1601 et seq.) applies to state land.

2. VA, FEMA, and FP&C will work to research the probable location of National Register-eligible archaeological properties; identify National Register-eligible archaeological properties; evaluate any such identified sites to determine if they retain integrity and meet the National Register criteria; and avoid, minimize, or mitigate National Register-eligible archaeological sites. These steps may be undertaken as right of entry becomes available or as identification and evaluation efforts are completed.

3. VA, FEMA, and FP&C may elect to collaborate in the development of background documentation and other steps to evaluate and mitigate National Register archaeological properties. If the agencies do not jointly develop materials required by this stipulation, each agency remains responsible for completing each step outlined by this stipulation for the site selected for that agency’s Undertaking. FEMA will ensure that FP&C implements mitigation measures associated with the FEMA Undertaking. VA and FEMA, with FP&C may elect to pursue joint consultation, and this will be subject to the requirements of Stipulation II.C.

B. Identification of Archaeological Sites.

Page 28 of 36

1. Background Research and Sensitivity Modeling: VA and/or FP&C will research and delineate the locations, within the APE, for each project which are known to possess a high potential to contain archaeological sites. This research and delineation will be based upon analyses of existing data on geomorphology and topography, historic maps, previous cultural resources investigations, cartographic information on the history of public works improvements, oral histories, and census, deed and tax records. VA and/or FP&C will also correlate geological and soils data with prehistoric, protohistoric, and historic land use patterns. These data will be recorded and analyzed using geographic information systems (GIS) technology. The background research will be used by VA and/or FP&C to develop a prehistoric and historic context that will be the basis for evaluating the National Register eligibility of archaeological properties that may be identified.

2. Disturbance Study: VA and/or FP&C will review archival and cartographic materials and will conduct a block-by-block inspection of the sites selected for the Undertakings as a part of the Disturbance Study. VA and/or FP&C will identify those portions of the selected sites that have been sufficiently disturbed by previous construction, development, grading and demolition in order to determine where there is a low potential for National Register-eligible archaeological properties.

3. Development of an Archaeological Probability Model: VA and/or FP&C will use the prehistoric and historic context, background research and the disturbance study to map the locations within the area of potential effects that have a high or low potential for containing National Register-eligible archaeological properties. After providing the prehistoric and historic context, background research, and the disturbance study, VA will consult with SHPO and MBCI regarding the results of the probability modeling. FP&C will provide information, including background documentation, showing its determinations to FEMA for a 7-day review. If FEMA does not comment within 7 days of their receipt of adequate documentation, FP&C may assume concurrence. Following FEMA concurrence, FP&C will consult with SHPO and MBCI on the results of the probability modeling. If SHPO does not comment within 14 days of their receipt of adequate documentation, VA, FP&C and FEMA will proceed with field investigation described below. VA, FP&C and FEMA will consult with SHPO and/or MBCI to address any comments.

4. Field Investigations for Identification: VA and/or FP&C may use a range of field investigation techniques to identify archaeological properties and to determine if they possess integrity and may be eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places, in so far as possible. Techniques may include shovel, auger, or mechanical testing, as appropriate and archaeological monitoring of demolitions in those areas determined to have a high potential for National Register-eligible archaeological sites. Fieldwork to identify archaeological sites and features will commence at site acquisition or

Page 29 of 36

receipt of rights-of-entry. Historic archaeological sites will be delineated as a city block, with NR eligibility evaluated for individual loci defined as tax lots within each site.

5. Reporting: VA and/or FP&C will forward a weekly field report to FEMA, SHPO, and MBCI during each field investigation step. Each weekly report will include a brief description of the field methods used, the locations investigated, sites identified, and features found, if any. Draft site forms will be submitted to SHPO. Following the completion of field investigation, VA and FP&C will prepare a Management Summary Report. The Management Summary Report will include preliminary evaluations of archaeological sites and provide recommendations for further work.

6. VA will provide the Management Summary Report for Identification to the SHPO and MBCI for consultation. FP&C will provide the Management Summary Report for Identification to FEMA for review and comment. If FEMA does not provide comment within 7 days of their receipt of adequate documentation, FP&C may assume concurrence with the Report. Following FEMA review, FP&C will forward the Management Summary Report for Identification to SHPO and MBCI. VA, FEMA, and FP&C will consult with SHPO and/or MBCI to address any comments on the Management Summary Report. If SHPO does not comment within 14 days of receipt of a complete report, VA and/or FP&C may proceed with field investigation described below.

C. Evaluation of Archaeological Sites, Assessment of Effects, and Evaluation of Means to Avoid, Minimize, or Mitigate Adverse Effects

1. Field Investigation for National Register Eligibility: VA and/or FP&C will evaluate those sites identified in the Management Summary Report for Identification that it determines in consultation with the SHPO and MBCI require further investigation and will apply the National Register criteria for evaluation (36 CFR 60.4 [a-d]) to determine their significance and integrity. Such evaluations will apply standard archaeological methodologies, as defined in Louisiana Division of Archaeology Guidelines for Field Methods. Evaluation will identify those sites and individual loci that possess research potential under National Register criteria and the Louisiana Comprehensive Archaeological Plan and that retain those qualities of integrity and significance defined by the National Register criteria. This process will analyze field data within the appropriate prehistoric and historic context for the site. Fieldwork to evaluate archaeological sites and features may commence concurrently with identification efforts as necessary to allow for efficient completion of the work provided that the Responsible Agency consults with SHPO and MBCI.

2. VA and FEMA, in consultation with SHPO and MBCI, will assess the effects of their Undertakings on any archaeological sites which it finds to be National

Page 30 of 36

Register-eligible. VA and FEMA will evaluate means to avoid or minimize any such adverse effects to National Register-eligible archaeological sites. Measures to be evaluated include but are not limited to encapsulation, preservation in situ, and construction fencing. If adverse effects to National Register-eligible archaeological sites may not be avoided, VA and FEMA will develop appropriate mitigation as described in Stipulation D.

3. VA and FEMA, in consultation with SHPO and MBCI, may consider a range of mitigation measures for adverse effects on National Register-eligible archaeological sites, such as individual site data recovery, representative site data recovery, education and public involvement efforts, or other reasonable and good faith efforts commensurate with the scale of the Undertaking, its effects on archaeological sites, and the significance of the adversely affected National Register-eligible archaeological sites.

4. Reporting: VA will forward a weekly field report to SHPO and MBCI during each field investigation step. FP&C will forward a weekly field report to SHPO, FEMA, and MBCI during each field investigation step. Each weekly report will include a brief description of field methods used, findings, preliminary recommendations and field investigation progress.

5. VA will provide Management Summary Reports to the SHPO and MBCI. The Management Summary Report/s will document the Responsible Agency’s determination of eligibility for the archaeological site(s), its assessment of adverse effects, and its consideration of means to avoid, minimize, or mitigate any adverse effects on the archaeological site(s). VA and/or FP&C may elect to prepare multiple Management Summary Reports to allow for the phased completion of the evaluation effort. FP&C will provide the Management Summary Reports to FEMA for review and comment. If FEMA does not provide comment within 7 days of receipt of adequate documentation, FP&C may assume concurrence with the Report. Following FEMA review, FP&C will forward the Management Summary Report to SHPO and MBCI for consultation. VA, FEMA, and FP&C will further consult with SHPO and/or MBCI to address any comments. If SHPO does not comment within 14 days of receipt of a complete report, VA and/or FP&C may proceed with field investigation described below.

D. Treatment Strategies for Archaeological Properties.

1. Data Recovery Plan: If the Responsible Agency determines in consultation with the SHPO and MBCI that data recovery is required for individual or representative National Register-eligible archaeological sites, VA and/or FEMA and FP&C will develop one or more archaeological Data Recovery Plans. Data Recovery Plans may be developed separately by the individual agencies or in a joint document. VA and/or FEMA and FP&C will forward 2 copies of each Data Recovery Plan to SHPO and MBCI. If SHPO does not

Page 31 of 36

comment within a 14-day review period of receipt of the plan, VA and/or FEMA and FP&C will assume that SHPO concurs with the plans. VA and/or FEMA and FP&C will finalize and implement the Data Recovery Plans after consultation with SHPO and MBCI.

a) The Data Recovery Plan may employ a sampling strategy to achieve the objectives of the data recovery and promote the efficient completion of the Undertakings.

b) Oral Histories. If appropriate to enhance the Data Recovery Plan, VA and/or FP&C will conduct oral history interviews, in accordance with Oral History Association Principles and Standards, with members of the public that may contribute to the research goals of the data recovery effort or record knowledge of the local history of the selected site. The oral histories will be deposited at a public depository or archive.

c) Public Outreach. VA and/or FP&C will incorporate a public archaeology program into the public interpretation plan required in Stipulations V.B.4(d), V.C.4(b), V.D.3(a), and VI.C.4(d). SHPO may assume responsibility for hosting and maintaining the website and for maintaining and distributing exhibits and printed matter upon completion of the projects.

4. Data Recovery. If required, VA and/or FP&C will execute the data recovery as specified in the Data Recovery Plan(s). Data recovery may commence concurrently with evaluation efforts as necessary to allow for efficient completion of the work provided that the Responsible Agency consults with the SHPO and MBCI. Data recovery will be conducted in accordance with the Louisiana Division of Archaeology field standards.

5. Reporting. VA and/or FP&C will ensure that a comprehensive report for each project, including the results of the archival research, sensitivity modeling and probability mapping, field identification methods and results, site evaluation methods and results, and data recovery methods and results is prepared. Final Louisiana Division of Archaeology site forms for all sites identified will accompany these reports. These reports will follow the standards of the Louisiana Division of Archaeology, and, in the case of FP&C, will be provided to FEMA, for a review and comment period, before submission to SHPO and MBCI.

6. VA will curate all archaeological materials, reports and associated records from their project accordance with 36 CFR 79 at a federally approved facility. FP&C will curate all archaeological materials, reports and associated records from their project in accordance with the standards of the Louisiana Division

Page 32 of 36

of Archaeology, and all collections and associated records will be curated with the Louisiana Division of Archaeology.

VIII. TREATMENT OF HUMAN REMAINS

A. If, in the course of the Undertakings, human remains are uncovered the Responsible Agencies shall direct their contractor to stop work immediately in the vicinity of the discovery.

B. The Responsible Agencies shall require that the ACHP’s 2007 “Policy Statement Regarding Burial Sites, Human Remains, and Funerary Objects” or any subsequent Policy Statements that are issued after the execution of this PA are considered.

C. If, at the time of discovery, human remains are located on federally owned land and are determined to be American Indian, the Responsible Federal Agency shall consult relevant federally recognized tribes within 3 days and shall develop and implement a plan for the appropriate treatment of those remains in accordance with the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) (25 USC § 3001 et. seq. as appropriate). The plan shall include provisions for in-place preservation, excavation, and analysis, in accordance with a data recovery plan approved pursuant to this Agreement, and disposition of the remains as appropriate. The Responsible Federal Agency shall, in good faith, consult with the relevant parties in accordance with applicable law. If the remains are determined to be non-native, the Responsible Agencies shall follow the procedures outlined in Louisiana Unmarked Human Burial Sites Act (R.S. 8:671 et seq).

D. If, human remains are uncovered and not located on Federally owned land, the Responsible Agencies shall follow the procedures outlined in the Louisiana Unmarked Human Burial Sites Act (R.S. 8:671 et seq). Pursuant to the law the Responsible Agency shall notify the City Attorney’s Office, the New Orleans Police Department, and the Orleans Parish Coroner’s Office within 24 hours of the discovery. The local law enforcement officials shall assess the nature and age of the human remains. If the coroner determines that the human remains are older than 50 years of age and are not a crime scene, the Responsible Agency shall ensure that the notice of the discovery required by Louisiana Unmarked Human Burial Sites Preservation Act (R.S. 8:671 et seq.) is given to the Secretary of Culture, Recreation, and Tourism (CRT) or the Secretary’s designee by contacting the Louisiana Division of Archaeology at 225-342-8170 within 72 hours of the discovery. Following the notification, the Louisiana State Archaeologist, as the designee of the Secretary of CRT, will administer the remainder of the requirements of the law including but not limited to permits for excavation and disposition of the human remains.

Page 33 of 36

IX. POST REVIEW DISCOVERIES

A. If potential historic properties are discovered or unanticipated effects on historic properties are found in a VA alternative, VA shall notify the SHPO, City, relevant federally recognized tribes, and the ACHP within 48 hours of discovery. If potential historic properties are discovered at the RPC site, and the City is the current owner of the property at that time, the City shall notify VA, SHPO, the relevant federally recognized tribes, and the ACHP within 48 hours of the discovery. If potential historic properties are discovered or unanticipated effects on historic properties are found in a FEMA / FP&C alternative, FP&C shall notify FEMA immediately. Within 48 hours of notification, FEMA will contact the SHPO, City, relevant federally recognized tribes, and the ACHP.

1. VA (in the case of the VA Undertaking) or FP&C (in the case of the FEMA Undertaking) immediately shall secure the jobsite and suspend work in the vicinity of the affected resource. VA or FEMA will consult with the Signatory Parties, relevant federally recognized tribes, and the ACHP to resolve adverse effects. The Responsible Agency shall take into account the recommendations of these parties and take appropriate actions and provide a report of the actions when they are completed.

B. VA and FP&C shall insure that all construction contractors are made aware of the requirements of the PA.

X. DISPUTE RESOLUTION

A. Should a Signatory, Invited Signatory, or Concurring Party object to the implementation of the provisions of this PA, they shall notify in writing the Responsible Agencies, who will seek to resolve such objection through consultation.

B. If the dispute cannot be resolved through consultation, the Responsible Agencies shall forward all documentation relevant to the dispute to the ACHP, including any proposed resolution identified during consultation. Within 7 days after receipt of all pertinent documentation, the ACHP may:

1. Provide the Responsible Agency with recommendations to take into account in reaching a final decision regarding the dispute; or

2. Notify the Responsible Agency that it will comment pursuant to 36 CFR §800.7(c) with reference to the subject of the dispute.

C. If the ACHP does not provide the Responsible Agency with recommendations within 7 days, the Responsible Agencies may assume that the ACHP does not object to its recommended approach and shall proceed accordingly.

Page 34 of 36

D. Any recommendation provided by ACHP shall pertain only to the subject of the dispute, and the responsibilities of the Responsible Agencies to fulfill all actions that are not subject of the dispute shall remain unchanged.

E. Any dispute regarding National Register eligibility that is not resolved pursuant to this Stipulation will be resolved in accordance with 36 CFR § 800.4(c)(2).

XI. ADMINISTRATION AND DURATION OF THIS PA

A. This PA shall become effective immediately upon signature by all Signatory Parties. For all Signatory Parties, this PA shall be executed in counterparts, with a separate signature page for each Signatory party, and the Responsible Agencies shall provide each Consulting Party with a complete copy of the executed PA including all signature pages.

B. This PA will remain in effect for 5 years from the date of execution, unless extended for a 2 year period by written agreement negotiated by all Signatories.

C. The Responsible Agencies shall provide all Signatories with semi-annual Interim Progress Reports, which will be submitted every 6 months from the execution of this PA.

XII. AMENDMENT AND TERMINATION

A. Any of the Signatory Parties to this PA may request an amendment. The PA may be amended when such an amendment is agreed to in writing by all Signatory Parties. The amendment will go into effect on the date of the signature by the final Signatory.

B. The Signatory Parties may terminate the PA by providing a 30 day written notice to the other parties provided that the parties consult during this 30 day time frame to seek amendments or other actions that would prevent termination. Should consultation fail, the Responsible Agencies will notify the other parties in writing of the termination.

C. Termination of the PA will require FEMA to comply with the 2004 executive Statewide Programmatic Agreement and will require VA and the City to comply with 36 CFR Part 800. This PA may be terminated without further consultation by the execution of a subsequent agreement that explicitly terminates or supersedes this PA.

EXECUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION of the Programmatic Agreement pursuant to 36 CFR §800.14(b) evidences that the Responsible Agencies have afforded ACHP a reasonable opportunity to comment on the Undertaking and its effects on historic properties, that the Responsible Agencies have taken into account the effects of the Undertaking on historic properties, and that the Responsible Agencies have satisfied

Page 35 of 36

their responsibilities under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and applicable implementing regulations.

This PA shall become effective immediately upon signature by all Signatory Parties. For all Signatory Parties, this PA shall be executed in counterparts, with a separate signature page for each Signatory Party, and the Responsible Agencies shall provide each Consulting Party with a complete copy of the executed PA including all signature pages.

Page 36 of 36 PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

Signatories:

ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION

By: 1/4N-. 11/4:2 —aft Date: We'll' el John L u III, Chairm n PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

Signatories:

US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS

By: Date: I1 /ZoAS Donald H. Orndoff, Director, Office of Cons ru acilities Management PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

Signatories:

FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY

By: Date: A71/ 21, Itk/2 Jam . Stark Director, Louisiana Transitional Recovery Office Assistant Administrator for Gulf Coast Recovery PROGRAMMATICPROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENTAGREEMENT AMONGAMONG THETHE USUS DEPARTMENTDEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THETHE FEDERALFEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THETHE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER,OFFICER, ANDAND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATIONPRESERVATION REGARDINGREGARDING THETHE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCAREHEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THETHE VAVA MEDICALMEDICAL CENTERCENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEWNEW ORLEANSORLEANS

Signatories:

CITY OF NEWNEW,ORLEANS ORLEANS

By: \.) By: ______Date: ______C. RayRay Nagin, Nag. MayorMayor,

FPRJ j4ic Mr AM APPROVED:

1/, ^

(N f n; is :' .Per1J PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

Signatories:

LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CULTURE, RECREATION, & TOURISM

By: Date: I ) 2-D (OK Scott Hutcheson, State Historic Preservation Officer PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT AMONG THE US DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY, THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, THE LOUISIANA STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER, AND THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HISTORIC PRESERVATION REGARDING THE FUNDING TO REPAIR OR REPLACE HEALTHCARE FACILITIES COMPRISING THE VA MEDICAL CENTER AND THE MEDICAL CENTER OF LOUISIANA AT NEW ORLEANS

Invited Signatories:

STATE OF LOUISIANA, DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATION

6c) Date: itZE2(0g ant Co sioner of Administration

PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT

APPENDIX 1:

FINDINGS OF AREAS OF POTENTIAL EFFECT

DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Office of Construction & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

July l 7, 2008

Pamela A. Breaux State Historic Preservation Officer Department of Culture, Recreation & Tourism P.O. Box 44247 Baton Rouge, LA 70804

RE: Repair or Replacement of I-kaki-ware Facilities Comprising the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs New Orleans Medical Campus that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans, LA

Dear Ms. Breaux:

As a result of damages from Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) decided to repair or replace the New Orleans VA Medical Center located at 1601 Perdido Street, New Orleans, Louisiana. VA recently notified you that it was initiating consultation pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act for this Undertaking.

VA has identified three Alternatives. VA will analyze the three Alternatives as part of the Section 106 review for its proposed Undertaking and has identified an Area of Potential Effect (APE) representing the area(s) in which standing structures may be affected for each of these three Alternatives. VA has determined the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each APE. VA will consult with the State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) regarding the delineation of APEs for areas in which archeological properties may be affected as well as identification and evaluation of archaeological properties in a subsequent step of the Section 106 review.

This letter requests SHPO's concurrence on VA's determination of the Standing Structures APE for each of the three Alternatives and VA's determinations regarding the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each APE. These APEs are subject to change as more information about the project is developed and we will consult with your office at that time. l't Alternative: Rebuild VA Hospital in Place:

The APE for this alternative includes the existing VA campus as well as those blocks bounded by the140 elevated interstate, Poydras Street, Loyola Avenue, and Cleveland Avenue, as illustrated in Figure 1. This APE is based on the assumptions that all of the buildings within the campus will be demolished and rebuilt and that the new buildings will not exceed twenty (20) stories_ MW, Pam Breaux July 17, 2002 Paget

The APE lies within the New Orleans Medical Historic. District, a district determined to be eligible by FEMA in consultation with SILK)

• g. 4.1%-. l Ve - . 2006 I Roughly bounded b7 L10, Tulare Avenue, South Liberty Street. and Tulone aidanue

The following individually eligible or listed properties are located within the APE:

• " 7.7.L.r, ',,0 2- • „...:or mtTlgTr- 7?3.7.1717.frroso.. .#4.- - ' ----;A :t li .1. ;Ft?7 tr:m't,"4. k- .747-Ir.cirrrirt'i7f -r..7" 7,-Ilt- r.,77tn .lite.441.tr"." ' Charity Hospital Determined r. igible 2005 1632 TulanG Avenue Slitter Startislaus 2003 450 i South Claiborne Avenue MernwtS Buidly StaleMoe Building Determined Eligible 325 Loyola Avenue 2001 State Office Building Determined Eligible 301 Loyale Avenue Annex 2006 Civil Courts Bulking Determined Ergot 421 Loyola Avenue 2007 New Orleans Public Detonated Eligible 219 Loyola Avenue Ubraw

VA bas determined that the following pmpettles within Ur APE contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District.

• _Dr 11.. 9.7(5.:1•91> -* • - - •,.. ' ,1 .+:• ' ♦ •?.!....!: oi. ' s' t rev(' :• ;4' 'IC' `x.it'aelb3litiliatieksio 1532 ruiatio Avenue i Eligible I New Orleans Medical 300 even South Claiborne Avenue Eligible New Orteens Medical 45C scum CalbOttle Avenue EigIble New omens Methcat 1430 Titlarks Avenue -M tie New Orleans Modica 1504-02 Gioia Street Eigible New Orleans Medical 1541 Tulare Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1542 Tisane Avenue Eligible Naw Orleans medico+ 1544 Thiene Avenue ...nitbie `New Orleans Medical 1695 'Tolima Avenue Bleb% ) New Orleans Medical [ 1600 Bremer Street Eligible I New Orleans Medical 1601 Perdido Street Eligible I Now Orleans Medical

Ms. Porn rtfleaLN July 17, 2008 PW 3

Perdido Shag Elio% New Ortenne Mei:Hoof 405 LaSalle Street Ellulle NOIN O,ltaits .42A Freml.Stmat Ellele New Means Medicai 43Z taBeite Wee Fliginte , New Orleans Medical 445 OSalle Street Filletle Now I:Jenne

A has deterniked ihnl th fellawIng arupenies withlti the APE do iuir conTritpute ta a ihiteAl a. eligible NAV/Mai Rggisur iiismit Distrust nor are they intlIviduatly for !WEFT in the NftfiP,

t6-2 Pordick areal NN aigib-e N&A Orins MealLal Graver Street Net El tie , Now Orleans Medi= FPorditto gtingt Not E110121e Itiekr.• Orleans Medical

2." Alit tnativel nst.nu,cr Fecititicadithg Oeleiver Site

The APE for the Ocits tier alternative b Emhart Exptesmvay, JLiks A vmue, _Warm' Highway, !Inez Rmd, arm] tirrkbar illustrated in Fig‘trFt, Z. the APE la hosed crp en rho inunnollen that the height of omyri bnadlniei will lint exneed six (6) !lei im

The AFE dew not inretseet any'lining Clr PICIPONC4 tinttetla Regi5 ter 14111C4C niiniels. the APE dorks nit cacnin;Plig3 CRY PTOPerria pintottialiy eligible for liming In the NTU-n3

3"I AfternatIve: CeastnIct Rovhacentetu' Far tier at the RPC,30,1;

VA iitI9 ideittilkd tt EiTIM proposal by Itt Regional Planntng Ccirntnision 4kP inki hounded by South Rochablava Sera., Canal street, 'Ainoth Galva StreN. anti Tiitene Avenue as a feasible site lbi fir 00112iltUratin pri.q.Plactirrinnt raakka, Illusrlrattd in F igure _3.

The APE Cry• tlsn new construction alternative Is bOrderrai by the Brood Street Overpass„ St, Loniii SUeet, North Rolxrisen Street. Toil= Averum and the I-1G ekvalegi intemere. The APE I bored up on the assumption new buildings will not exEced 4,1r stories and there wit' no additional v.,ibretery CETrLT.

The APE contains port-into of the existing Mid-City National RogIster itistarie UlNirfot and the propostd Ntvy (Means Meilirei Ris' ratio District Ms Pam Bram July 17, 2008 ?Bee 4 ekcirrl - 4,- fieyat.E.,;.37.6 Mid-City Historic District 1993 Roughly beimcled by Petloy Street Conti Street City Palk Avenue. and 1-10 New Orleans Medici Proposed Roughly bounded by 1-10, Tulane Avenue, South Melly Historic District 2006 Street, and Tulane Avenue

The following indivithutgy eligible or listed properties are located within the APE;

.111,E,9ettkii: 'OPP 1 ' TftristS.rfvltygritt -r/ . - :- - i. _,..t -I,. 1 tt • ti-- .-.-,-)-:::•$4 . %.,"4 4 ,i; ..,..x - ),,q.... zr-c7 -9fi'cc-'ilril'• - ''-'0y ..-2, 1.-: ....2,sael'Atii di e±." -I .41.0.., Ca= Ig' Pen American Sulking 2007 2400 Canal Street St Jansen /WE Church 1982 Za i Nutt!' Roman Street St, Louis Cemetery No. 2 1976 too sc. LowaStreat Charity Hospital Determined Eligible 1632 1 elan, Avenue 2005 Sister Stanielaus Memono 2003 450 Suuth Claiborne Avenue Bundler)

VA has determined that the following properties with the ME contributed to a listed or eligible National Register Flistotio District.

4 fit " :WA . c ." .. bilA IC. :-.1 4. a 1 • ' •ilk 7- r 2201 Banks Street Bode I• Mid-Ciht 2205.07 l Boma Street Eligible 1 mid-City 2209-11 Banks Street EllgIble I Mid-City 2213-113 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2217. Banks Street Bailie Mid-City 2221 Banks Street .7 itile MId-Cily 2301 Banks Street EJglbe Mid-Clhi 230607 Banks Street ESItte Mid-City 2215 Berke Street Eligible Mid-City 2321 A43 D Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 240547 Banks Street Babe haid-City 2409 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 24'11.13 I Banks Street Delve Md-City 2415-17 Banks Street Diablo MktClly 242143 Banks Street _g_gibIe Mid-City 2425-27 Banks Street Eligible Mid-Clly 2609 Banks Street Eligible MId-City 2511.13 Banks Street Eligbe Nfid-City 2515 Banks Street agave ifflid-Cily 2517-19 Banks Street Eligible Mid-Cilii 2621-28 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City

Ms. Pam Emus July 17. 2008 Page 5

4 .{:-i7 ti ' -- - ' .:-T:4 2b25-27 Banks Street Eligible MIOCIty 2633-95 Banks Street Egble Mid 2639 Banks Street Eigible Lid 2541-48 Bunke Slued Eligible , Mid-City 2549 Banks Street IJ21 ibie Mid-City 260042 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2804 Banks Street agerta Mid-OW f--F805-07 Banks Street Elkilble 2808-10 Banks Street Eligible 2812-14 Banks Street LE6gfole Md-City 2613 Bunks Steel Ell ale wow 2820 Banks Street Eligible Md-City 2621 Banks Strew Eligible Mid-Clly Banks Street Eligible Mid-City Banks Street able M-tituy Banks Steel Eligible Mid-City 2658 Barks &trete Eligible Mid-City 1723 Menville Avenue Eligible MId-Ctty 1729 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-Crtv 173143 BlunvIlle Avenue Eligible Mal-City 1804-08 Ellenvaile Avenue kliE 9ible Mid-City 1817-19 DenvilleAvenue Eligible Otd-CD 1023-27 Bleriville Avenue Bettie Mid-City 1026-28 B Eilenville Avenue ENgIblo Mid-City 1.3042 Manville Avenue Eligible 1836-36 El Blenvtlie Avenue Stay Mtd-Citv 1908 ElionvilleAvenue eta Mld-City 1922 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2004-08 I Manville Avenue EN Ude Lk4d-City 2022-24 MenvilleAvenue Mid-Cdt 2028.30 Melville Avenue Eligible thd City 2108-10 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2114 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2115 the-ovals Ayetwe . lAkt•City 2117-19 filefiville Avenue Sigible Mit14:11y 2120 ManvilleAvenue Bribe Mal-City 2121-23 ! Bienville Avenue Bettie 2125 &env& Melt* Eligible Mid•Clty 2127-29 thernalle Avenue Elam* Mits-Cey 2136 Blenvflle Amenn110We Mid-City 2204-05 BliMville Avenue i Eligible Mid-City ..-- MI I 221749 Manville Avenue Eligible Mso-City 2210 Dienville Avenue Eligible 4 lAciCity 7220-22 Melville Avenue I Eligible Md-City Ms. ?sus Breaux July l7, 2008 Page

•-;-' i. . - , .„ . .. . }. , t. . . 2221 Glenville Avanue Eligible Mighty 2229 Denville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 223143 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2300-02 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-CIty 230444A BlenvIlle Avenue Sable MISCIty 2309.11 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City . 2313 I BienvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 Manville Avenue Inglis Mid-City 2318 Glenville Avenue Eligible MisCity l• 2318 Manville AVOW.lb Eligible MId-Clly 211-22 BienVille Avenue Eligible MidiCity 2321 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2326 Bianwile Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2326-30 I Glanville Avenue Eligible MIc1City 2394 Glanville Avenue Eligible MId-City 2336 I Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City I .2336 Manville Avenue Steele Mld-City 39 Glenville Avenue butte MitliCity 23321'400 Gisnville Avenue alba Mid-City 2404 I Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-Clty 241547 I Ben& Avenue Mible Mid-City 2416-16 I Mona° Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2420 BlenviRe Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2423-26 Siena° Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2424 Glenville Avenue Eligible MISCIV 2429 Glenville Avenue Eligib'e Mid-City 2430 Blenvile Avenue 'Mail * Mid-Clty 243149 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2434 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2500-a. Glanville Avenue Eligible Mid-City i 210143 Elietude Avenue EDnbe Mitt-City 250448 Slanvfle Avenue J Efigible Mid-City 2507 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 250549 Glanville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2509-11.5 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-CS 2612-14 13ienvillo Avenue Elgible PialticatY 2515 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2618 Glenville Avenue ESIble Mid-City 2620-22 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 203-28 INenville Avenue Eigible Mid-City 2530-32 Gionville Avenue Eligible Mid-City I 2534-36 I Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2536-40 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2541-43 Biarilie Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2642-44 i Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Pagel

•;,i 1-1,531110.1, ' 2546-48 &anville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2600 fliemdUe Avenue Eagle* 1 Mid-City 2608 A-10 B Melnik, Avenue Eligible 4Ald-City 2612-14 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2816-18 Glenville Avenue _Eligible Mid-City 2820-22 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2628-28 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2848-50 Renville Avenue Betio Mid-att 138 Hole Broad Avenue eigte1/4 Mid-City 300-02 South Broad Avenue Eigible Mid-City 306 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 308-10 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 312-14 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 325 South Broad Avenue amble Mid-City 3313-38 ! South Breed Avenue Eligthle Mid-CI 942 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-Cler 410 South Broad Avenue Elltbre Mid-City 418 §outh Broad Avenue Eligthie Mid-City 422-22.6 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 538 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1800 Carat Street ie mid-city 1801 Canal Stoat a Mtd-ajy 1816 Canal Street : Eligible Mid-City 1838 Canal Street I agibta Mid-City 1901 Canal Street Eitglble Mld-City 1928-34 Cartel Street Eligible Mid-City 1936 Canal Shoat Eligible Mid-City 2041 Canal Street Eligible MISCity 2120 Canal Street Bebe Mid-City 2311 Canal Strout inigtiNe Mid-City 2317 A-H Canal Street ta bib Mtd-Ctly 2331 Canal Strout EP lble Mid-City 713s Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 2501-07 Canal Sheet Eligible Mid-City 2540 Canal Sete( Ratio Mid-City 1805-07 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1808-10 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mkt-City 1809-11 Cleveland Avenue Ellgtble Mid-City 190547 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 19213-28 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1932-34 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1933.35 Cleveland Avenue Eligible als1-21k 1938-38A Clevelinel Avenue Eligible Mid-City 193941 Cleveland Avenue Erieible Mic-City Ms. Nun Breaux July 17.2008 Page 8

... - i i- • $,' ,40140 'patpriitifitkii. r 1.., is. .,_.• , i-,it 1 , • r• t • , , or, :-.--.., 4 ... •• „...-,- ...”:- ... „. ...; ..y.-.-: , : . g:"F- nal .„,-- . V: '2:1-1. 2000-02 Cleveland Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2008-10 Cleveland Avenue Eligible .1 Mid-CitY 2018-20 ' Cleveland Avenue Eligible I Lfi A a 2024 Cleveland Avenue Eggible 1 Mld-Sar 203436 Cleveland Avenue Eigibie Ned-City 2038-40 t Cleveland Avenue CS! ible I Mio-ON 2100-02 Cleveland Avenue I Eligible Mid-City 2104 1 Cleveland Avenue : Eligible I Mid-City

21113-081 I Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mlei-City 1 2114 ' Cleveland Avenue Eligible 1 Mict-City 2118 Glevetand Avenue Ekiible I Mid-City 2200 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2228-28 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2310-12 ' Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 22114-16 Cleveland Avenue Eagitle Mld-City 2318-20 Cleveland Avenue Del-4e Mid-City 2328-30 Cleveland Avenue Eligitle Mid-City 2336 Cleveland Avenue Eligkie Mld-Oty 2400 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mod-City 2402 Cleveland Avenue Elialble NVd-City 2410-12 Cleveland Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2416 Cleveland Avenue Eligible I biltd-City 2416-20 Cleveland Avenue MSS 1 Mid-City 2422 Cleveland Avenue Eli, Ada Mid-City 2430 Cleveland Avenue Eligible j MId-City 2434 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mld-City 2436 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 260042 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MId-City 2501-03 Cleveland Avenue Deem Mid-City 2604 Cleveland Avenue Eligible t Mid-City 2505-07 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mld-City 2508 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2508-11 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2512 Cleveland Avenue Fag** MIdtity 2613 Cleveland Avenue ERAS Mid-CRY 2514 Cleveland Avenue Eligible ilitd-Qty 2518 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2519 Cleveland Avenue Eligible, Mid-City 2521 Cleveland Avenue iagible Mid-City 2522-24 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MICA-City 2526 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2527 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2530 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2532-34 Cleveland Avenue Ellett:4o L Mkt-City 2638 Cleveland Avenue1 Eligible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 0 ...... ' 4 .; , • '',...rge*. , f• ' 2542 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2544-45 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2547 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MId-City 2500-02 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2804,08 Cleveland Avenue Ell;fole Mid-City 2807-09 Cleveland Avenue ealbte Mu-City 2610 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2614 -Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2821.23 Cleveland Avenue Eligible M4-City 2522 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2826 Cleveland Avenue Ejuible Mid-City 2832 Clevatani Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2838-38 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1800 Conti Street Eligible 1813-15 COO Street Eligible Mid-City 1818 Corgi Street I Eligible Mid-City 1818-21 Conti amen Eactible mid-City 1820-22 Conn Street Eligible Md-City 1833-35 Conti Street Eligible 1834 Conti Sheet I Eligible Mid-City 1836 I Conti Sinai EYglble Mid-City 1837-39 I Conti Stray Etiglble Mid-City mo2432 a Cord) Wok Eligible Mid-City 1913 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 1922 A-B Conti Sliest ESIble Mid-Qty 1928 Come Sheet Eligible Md-City 1632-34 Conti Street Eligible Mkt-City 193339 Conti Street Bale 1/10-City 2013-15 Cm% Street Eligible ged-City 2017-18 Gong Streei, I Eligible Md-CS 2021 Conti Stool-1 Eligible Mid-City 2026-27 ' Cann Street Eligible Md-City 2029 Contt Street Eligible M11-City 2100-02 Condi Stile! Eligible 2101_03 Conti Strea Eligible 993-City 2104-05 Conti Street Eligible 2108-10 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2171-13 Conti Street Eligible Md•City 2112-14 Conti Street Eligible FM0-City 2116-18 Conti Meet Barbie 2116-18 Gong Street Ell tea Mid-01ty 2209-11 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2213-15 Conti Sheol Eligible Mkt-City 2218 ) Cone sues! Eligible Mkt-City 2217-19 Gong Street had-city Ms. Pam Stens July 17, 2008 Paige 10

I r !. 141,4/4.4 - t"_ A ." (r."tir r• i'740/lker 2221-21.5 Conb Steel Eliotle PAct-CIty _ 2224-28__ Conti Steel_ Eligible ad-0V 2225-23 Coati Sleet Eligible lad-City 2227-29 Conti Street Ell tie MILICIty 2231-33 Conti Street Big$e !*14:11y 230143 Conti Steed Eligible Md-Oty 2305-07 Coriti Street Ellabe 'Viet-City 2303 Conti Sliest Eligible MId-City 2311-13 Conti Street Debbie PAISCity 2315-17 Conti Steel agiUe tiadatv 2319.21 Conti SIC0111 _Eligible 14thgt, 2320 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2322 Conti Street Vigihie Mid- CIty 2327 Coma Street Eligible Mid-City 2330 Conti Street El!gibe MIO-CitY 233t Conti Sueei Eligible Mid-City 2334 1 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 3a 5 Cone Stoat Eligible Mid-City 233648 Conti Steel Eligible MU-City 233749 Conti Street Eligible Mil-Qty 2412 Conti Steel Eligible Md-City j 2415-15 A Conti Street Eligible rMd-City 2500 Cott Steel ' Eligible 1 Mid-City 2604-05 Conti Street I Eligible Med•City 2507 Conti Sheet 'Eligible 1 Md-City 2508-10 Conti Street I Eligible Md-City 2511-15 cont Street , Eligible Mel-Clhf 2512-14 Conti Street Eligibie Mtd-Gly 261719 Conti Street SW° Mil-City 252022 Conti Street El ible Md-City 2521-23 Conti Street Egli Me Md-City 2524-28 Conti Street Ennio Md-City 2530-32 Conti Street Eligible tilieSt 262547 Conti Stool Eligible I Md-Clly 125 North Derbigny Street Igilble Md.City 306 North Derbigny Street EJ/lible im-City 316.17 North Derbigny Street Eligible Md-City 32143 North Derbigny Street Eligible Mcl-City 131 South Derbigny Street Eligible Mei City 314-10 1 Sloan Corgenots Street Eligible Md-City 318-20 North DOrgends Street Eligible lied-Crty 116-18 South Dorgenois Street EAlible MO-City 120-22 South Doruende Street Eligible Md-City 130-32 South Doreer.ois Street Eligible Mid-CIty 216 South Dorgends Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pain Breaux July 17, 200A Pagc I I

0' • 217-19 • South Corot:note Street Mid-City 218 South Qorgenots Street Mid-City 222-24 South Goriiel101e Street Mitt-Ctty 223 South Dorpenole Street Mid-City 226 mirth Dorgenoie Street Eligible Mid-City 312 South IlLgar enals Street 4l d City 316 South Dorponaie Street Mcla 318-20 South fitwengla Street Elf ible Mid-City 326-28 South Comments Street Eligible Mid-City 512 South , Dorgenets Street Eligible Mid City 516-16 South yenols Street Eligible Mid-C1ty 530 South Dor-glumly Street Eligible Mid-City 532 South Dorgertole Street Eligible Mid-City 534 South Dorgenole Street Eligible Mid-City 638 South Dorgerrole Street Mid-Qty 124 North Galvez Street Eligible Middy 126-28 that Galva. Street 1 Eligible MId-Clty 214-16 North tIvez Street Eligible Mid-City 218-20 North Galva. Street Eigoble Mid-City 312.14 North Calvet Street BIAS povd4744- , 318.18 North Calvet Street EAgtble Mid-City 320-22 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City ota•15.5 North Calvet Street Eligible Mid-City 417-19 Narth GEN= Sleet Bottle 112d h 421.23 North GeNez Street Eligible Mid-City 424-28 North Calvet Street Eligible Mid-City 425-27 North Calvet Street EllgItte Mkt;Ctly 42840 North Gatvez Sne4 Mid-Ctly 125 South Galvez Street Eligible Mld-City 129.33 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 200 South Galvez Street Eligible 217 South Calvet Street Mid-City 223-23 C South Galvuz Street Sega% Mid-City 224 South Calvet Street Eligible 226 South GaNciz Street Eligible Mld-City 227 South Galvez Street Elicible Mid-Qty Manz Street Mid-CI 230-32 South Gahm Street Eligible Mid-City 233 South Cravat Street ESIbie Mid-City 237 South Calvet Street Ellett° Mid-City 301.03 South Satz Street Eligible MId-City 305-07 South Calvet Street EVIDle Mid-Ctly 309 South Calvet Street algible _Mid-City 31143 South I Gan Street Eligible i_Mld-City 321 South Gov& Street Eligible tAtd-Clty Ms. Pam Breaux July 11, 2008 Page 12

South I Gah182. Street 523 Seth Gatvisz Street , Ellgtoie Mid-City 627 South Gelvez Street Eligible Mid-CIty 620 South Galva Street Eligible MId-City 533-35 South Eleivez Street Eligible MidSyll 2208 Gravier-Street Eligible Mid-City 2212-14 GraviesSeal I Made Mld-City 2228 Grave Street i ammo Mtd-Oty 7304-09 Gravies Street EliCaltle Mid-City . 2307 Gravier Street _gall* Mid-City 2308-10 Gravier Street EllgIbe Mid-City 2300.11 Grader Street Eligible Mid-OW 2312 Gaylen Street Eliglile Mid-City 2317-10 Grevier Street Eligib:e Mid-City 2318 Grave Street Bode Mid-City 2321-23 Gravter Street Ellethe MId-Clq, 2322-24 Grave Street _NitileE MID-City 2326-27 Grevier Street Er% Micsaty 2328 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2328-30 Clavier Street Rale Mid-City 2232 A-I3 Gravier Street Edible Mid-City 2338-38 Omar Street Eligible Mid-City I 2409 1 Greeter Street Erigtble Mid-City i 2410 Graver Street Ellett Mid-Cilv 1 2414 Gravity Street Filgibia Mid-City 2417-19 Growler Seel Eligible Mid-City 2418 atter Street Eligible Mid-City 2420-22 Gravies Street Eligible Mid-City 2421 GraviesSireet Bigible Mld-City 2429-31 Clavier Street Mayas Mid-City 2432.34 Gravier Street Bettie Mid-City 2433-35 Gravier Street Eitgibte Mid-City 2437-39 Oravles Street Eligible MId-City 25013 Gray ler Street Eligible Mid-City 2807 GraviesStreet ' Eligible Mid-City 2509-11 Grave Street Eligible Mid-City 2513-15 Gretna Street Bantle Mid-City 2517-19 Gravier Street Bride Mid-City 2518 Gravier Street c Eligible Mid-City 2523 Gravier Street I Eligible Mid-City -, 2624 i Grainier Shoot I Eligible Mid-City 2531-33 I Gravier Street I Eligible Mid-City 2535-37 Gravier Street 1 Eligible Mid-City 2539-41 I Grave Street Eligible Mid-City 2543.451 Grave Street I Debts Mid-City

Ma. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 13

tt541 . •::.; T I MISCity 2800 Gravier Street Eligible MEd-City 2800 Gravier Street Eligible 2801 Growler Street Eligible Mid-City 2601 Graver Street Eligible Mlo-City 1818 lberville Street Bede Mid-City 1900-02 Igor/111e Street Eligible Mld-City 1904 ibarvele Street Eligible mid-city 1919 lb/Mlle Street Eligible Mid-city 1921-23 Ibervllle Street ible Mid City 1925-27 iteivele Street Eligible Mid-City 1929 ibervele Sheet Babe Mid-City 1931 lbarville Street agRale Mid-City 1932 ibelvile Street Eligible Mid-City 1933-39 WOW Street Eligible Mid-City 2000-02 Igandle Street Mid-City 2001 Ibuvne Street EDAM Mid-City 2020 leaven /Breed Elegfde Mid-CITY 2022 ibervile Street Eligible Mid-Oty Ell ible Mid-Cit 2028-30 tbeiville Street Eligible Mid-City 2036-38 lbw/ft Street Eligible Mb -City 2100 Wane Street Eligible Mid-Cty 210103 Ligon/jam Street Ell !Ible Mid-Cay 2104 'heroine Street Eligible Mid-Cay 2106 ibetivilm Street Mgible Mid-Ca 2108-10 !gentle Street Mid-City 2111.13 ibeivIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2112-14 Iberviie Street I Eligible Mid-Ctry 2116.17 Igen/Ike Street Eligible MW-City 211648 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2120.22 igende Street Eligible Mid-City 2123 Mentlre Strout @Nair Mid-Cray 2124-26 ibervIte Street agible Mid-CRY 2127-29 ibeivite Street Eligible Mid-City 212830 IgervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2217 lbervilie Street Eligible Mid-City 2220 tondo Street Eligible Mid-City 2221 ibeivtre Street 222242.6 lbeiville Street Eiglbte Mtd-City 222448 ibendlie Street Eligible Mlel-Ctry 222547 iberville Strout Eligible Mid-City 2228-30 Igerville Street Eligible Mid-City 2222 Igennue street I Mille Mld-Chy 2232-34 I lberviDe Street Eigabie rbileCtty Ms. Para Brmix July 1'i.2008 Page 1.4

• IP C*.

417Ain'],•:;%i idr .•tr ] ' lborvlUe Street Eligible Mid-City lbenatte Street Eligibie Mid-Clly 230143 !bangle strea EROS Mid-City 2304-06 Weenie Slices Elgibie Mid-City 2305 iberVIlle Street abbe 2307-00 lberville Street EllgINe Mid-City 2311.13 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 lbervUle Street Eligible Mid-City 2319-21 Menge Street COW Mid-City 2326-26 (invite Street Ellgtbre Mid-City 2330-32 'boner %met Betas • Mitt Cl 2401.03 ibenhile Street ERgIble I Mid-City 2407 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2411.13 lbervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2416.17 Mona' Street Eigible Mid-City 2421.23 •JbenrAte Street Elgllile Mild City 2431 'bereft Street Elgthle Mid-CRS+ 2435 lberville Street I Eligible 2609 lbervOle Street I Eligible Mid-Clly 262749 'bemoan Street I Eligible Mid-City 2653 lbervile Street I Eugrole Mid-City 2655-57 'berate Street . Bebe Mid-City ---17659 lbervtila Street Stiate Mid-City 2663 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 20641 I North Johnson Street Eligible i Mld-City 217 North Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 221.23 North Johnson Street Bgble Mid-City 312-19 North Johnsen St _ Mid-City 321-25 North Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 212 South Johnson Street _Eig' Ible Mid-Crty 216 South Johnson Street itihle Mid-City 220-22 South Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 22446 South Johnson Street Eligible 1 Mkl-City 325 Sat Johnson Street Eigtble t Mkt-City 414-16 Marasseu Plate Spelt Mid-City 415 Menasses Pleas Eigibla MId-Cibr 419 Marmoset' Place Eligible Mid-Oly 421 Manassas Placa Eligible Mid-City 426 Stases Place Eligible Mid-Clly 427 Manatees Place rglibl Weedy 116-18 Norm Miro Street ELgihfe Mid-City 117 North Miro Street Mid-City 120-22 North Mire Street Eligible Mid-City 123-25 North Miro Street Ellgldo ] Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 15

• .: . • :.:% a 4 3 al 1 .: - PI4 ce A:5-,ty...4..1 ... ..S•tri . . 1 IL.A.li 129 1 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 213 1 North Miro Street 1 Eligible I Mid-City 216 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 217 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 218 I North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City • 221 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 222-24 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 314-16 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 315-17 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 318-20 L North I Miro Street Ell ible Mid-City 310-21 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 322-24 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-CiN 323.25 North Miro Sheet Eligible Mid-City 404 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 409 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 412.14 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 413-15 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 414.5 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 416 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 417-19 North Miro Skeet Eli. ibis Mid-City 420-22 North Mira Sheet Eligible Mid-City 428-28 North I Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 432-34 I North I Miro Street Eligible Mfd-CIty 200 1 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 218 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 219 South Miro Street Eligible Mld-City 222-24 L South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 226 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 227-29 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City k 228-30 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 23234 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-aly 236 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 1--300-02 1 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 310-12 South Miro Street Eligible _ Mid-City 314-16 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 315 South Miro Street Eiigible • Mld-City 318-20 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 319.21 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 322-24 South Miro Street EligIbte DAId.city 323-25 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 329 South Mire Street Eligible Mid-City 53244 South Miro Street Eft Ible 1 Mid-City 538-38 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 620-22 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 623 South Miro Street Elie ible Mid-City Ms. Pam c.-r.u. July IL 2008 Page 16

Tr; 1 . e . a ii 4ft- 6: i iii 624-26 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-city 626-27 South Miro Street Eligible I Mid-City 828-30 South Mitt Street Eligible Mid-City 829 South Mine Street Saint:Ile Mid-City 2411-13 Oak Place Elllitder Mid-City 2415-17 Otik Race Eligible Mid-City 1823 Palmyra Street Elleible Mtd-Oly 1829.31 Palmyra Street Ellgrain Mid-City 1837 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1914-18 Pairnyra Street EllgIble Mid-City 1915-17 Palmyra Street ggible Mid-City 1919 Peenyre Street Eligible Mid-City 1921.23 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1925-27 Palmyra Street tEllgtbre Miti-CIV 1933-37 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2009 Palmyra Street Eligible Mrd-Crty 2028-30 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2101-03 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2212-14 Palmyra Street Eligible - Mid, City 2216 Palmyra Street Ell ible Mid-City 2217-19 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2220 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2224.24 A Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City • 2225-29 Palmyra Street Eligible I Mid-City 2301-03 Palmyra Street Eligible Mb -oty 2306-07 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2310 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2313 Patrnyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2314 Palmyra Street Eligible MidiCIty 2316 Palmyra Street lirsIble , M10-01ty 2317 Palmyra Stmt Eligible Mid-City 2319-21 PalmyLe Street Bathe _ Mid-City 2320 Palmyra Street Mt; MId-Cdy 2322 Palmyra Street Eligible Mla-City a 2323 A-13 Palmyra Street Eligible MIdiCity 2328 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2327_, I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2329-31 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2339 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2401 Palmyra Street Eligible Mkt-City 2404 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2405 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-thW 2407-09 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2408 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2411 Palmyra Street Eilgible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 17

,t, v Aq,....:,-•''..,,,, ...''•-. , —" '. t 't.", .''' :Z:. ', • ),:, i.;.' ••• I - 2.': Pi •,, - '!lb,e"..1=-1,,-- ,'). -'.4 -di pr . 11,11,, • 4,3 1,;s,-.... c ,`,1,1; , ,,‘1,,,f., •>,/?; .,.. , 4..;. 2412 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2414 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2415 Palmyra Street Eligible . Mid-City 2419-21 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2420 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2422-24 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2423-25 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2426 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2427 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2431 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2500-02 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2501-03 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2504 A-B Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2605-07 Palmyra Street Eligible Mld-City 2508 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2512 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2513-15 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2516 Palm ra Street Eligible Mid-City 2517 Myra Street Eligible Mid-City 2520-22 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2521 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2523-25 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2524 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2526 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2527 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2529-31 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2532-34 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2533-35 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2537-41 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2543 Palmyra Street _ Eligible Mid-City 2547 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2601 . Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2604 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2605-07 Palmyra Street Eligible Mld-City 26D8 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2611 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2612-14 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2613-17 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2619-21 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2620 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2622 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2623-25 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2626-28 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2627-29 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2631-33 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Memo July 17, 2008 Page 18

trt-,' -1* • - -:.„; ...... ,, .. z•,,:•.-:••••,,p —o,;„, _ • .. . 7‘.e.ctit••;•/Yr-TFIS ._ _ 4: 1 =•.- --;•••T. til; .1::',..<, . L7•17:7 :441 V:4111&154:Vitea fi'4 .:14%;ii C.-.Vi. '' C4 • . . re Street— o t lble Mid-City 2838 Palmyra Street Ekelble Mid-City 3 P m Street E • Ida Mid-C ' 217 No* Pharr Sheet Bede Mid-City 221 North Nem Steel 1 Elaihe Mid-City 314-18 North Pneur Street Entitle Wd-Ctly 822-24.5 North Pneur Street Elgible Mid-City 328 North Priem Street Witlible MIO-City 416.18 North Rrleur Street glIgIble Mid-City 419-21 North Priem Street Bolt* Mid-City 215.17 South PrIeur Street Ellothe Mid-City 218 South Prieur Sheet Elialthe Mid-CIty 210 South Prleur Street Eligible Mid-City 219 A-21 B South Prieto Street Eligible Mid-City 22022 A South PriamSheet Eligible Mtd-City 223.28 A South Pneur Street Eligible Mid-City Rocheblave 201 North street Bettie Md-Clty Rocheblave 215 North Street Eligible Mid-Cay Rocheblave 310.12 North Street Ell. iblo Mid-City Rocheblowe 316-18 North Street bible Mid-City Rocheblave 320 Moan Street Ertgble Md-City Rocheblave 321 North Street Eligible Mid-Oty Rocheblave 323.25 North Street Eligible Mid-City Roctiebleve 324-28 North Street Eigtbia tia•li Rocheblave r 328 Not StreM _ttle yhd-City 411 North RachStreeebt 'av° Eligible Mid-City Rocheblave 424-26J North Street Elgible Mid-City t Rocheblave 115-17 South ' Street Pith. Mid-City Rizehebteve 214 South Street EIgnie Nlid-Oty Rocheblave 217 South Street Eligible Mid-City Rochablave 218 South Street Eligible Mk..1-CIty Rocheblave 219-21 I Satin Street Salve Mid-Crty Ms. Pant Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 19

' '''' /-4-r4 5. • .;‘ ,..- ' . a...)...' . -' 7-.% '41,7 , .11i :...4 it ",...... „...4;..,.. ..._. , r ,i, s. ,, . 3 ILI ai, •Ss; V•ro• 44.9r):, r '• ,-1 ..a..-:.:. :..Vira .• .1";:?"!• . '. • Roo to love 223 South Shoat ESIble Mid-City Rochobleye I 224 South Street Eligible Mid-City Rochebiave 227-29 South Street Eligible Mid-Cky Rocheblaye 317-19 South Street Ell Itte Mid-City Rechebiave 318_ South Street Eligible Mid-City Roctiebiaye 323 South Street Still* Mid-City Rochebiave 513 South Street Eligible Mld-City Recheblave 619 South Street Eligible Mid-City Rocheblave 521.23 South Street Eligibe Mid-City Rechebiaye 624 South , Steel Eklbe Mid-City 1 Rochablavo 628 South i Street Eligible Mid-City Rocheblaye 531 South i Street 1 Eligible Mid-City ROcheeiaye 634 South Stmt ailible Mid-City Ruchobave 536 South Street Eligible MM-City Rochebiavo 537-39 South Street Eligible Mid-City Rucheblave 613 South Street Eligible Mid-City Ftochebtave B13 South Street Eligible Mel-CUy RocheblErve 81547 South Street Eligible Mid.City 'Rocheblave 641-43 South Street Eligible MIti•City 127 North Rattan Street Eligible Mid-CIty 203-05_ North Roman Street Eligible Mirt-City 207-09 Wirth Roman Shea Efigible Mkt-City 211-13 North Roman Street Efigibie Mid-City 216 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 219 North Rattan Street Eligible MIti-City 222 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 222 North Ronan Street Efigtre Mfd-City 309.11 North Raman Stint Eligible Mid City 316-17 North Roman Street Eligible Midaty 318-18 A North 1 Ronan Street Eligible Mid-City MS. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 20 ._ .,. . - r•-. _ -D. --- -- .:),r-. t" krZli%i;".•i -. • ; IF: ir i . - ' •i-- a2:i;- ,i8fZI1 319-21 l4 North • Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 320.22 I North Roman Street ' Eligible Mid-City 323-28 North Roman Street Ell ible Mid-CIty 324-244 Muth Roman Street Be be Mid-City 401 Ninth Rumen Street agate Mid-Cite 121 South Roown Street Eligible I Mid City 301 South Romeo Street BlplUe lifel•Clly 303-03 South Roman Street Eligible 11.41c1-City 1924-26 ' 1 SOini Louis Street ellgIble MId-City 2210-18 ' Saint Lade Street Eligible Mid-City 2328 t Sant Louis Street Eligible Mid-City --1 2400.02 Saint Lode Street PAW Mid-City 2404 OS Saint Louis Street Sable Mal-City 240810 Saint Louie &real Eligible Mid-City 2412-14 Saint Louie Street ffligibla Mid-City 2416.10 sart Lea Seal Eligible MM-City 2420-22 1 Saint thugs SS! Etat& Mid-City 2424-28 Saint late Street Botta Mid-City 2428-30 Saint Louis Street EigIbla Mid-City 2432.34 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2436-38 Saint LOUIS Street Eligible Mid-City 120-22 North Two Strom EMU& Mid-City 124 North Tenn Sawa ,-a7be Mid-City 212 North Tqhb Sleet ague Mad-aty 214-18 North Tonll Skeet Enable Mid-City 218.20 North Tonti Seed EY Ible Mid-City 219-21 El I North Teti Street Eligible MEnCity 222 Nom Tantl Street Ellaltle IIM-City 310 r Nati Tani Sant Bade Mid-City 320 I North Tontt Street Duthie Mb-City 322 North Teti Skeet Eligible Mid-City 1/6-19 North Tell Street Engem Mid-City 329 North Ted Street Eligible Mid-City 333-35 r North Tall Street Eligible rind-City 337-39 r North Tont Steet Mtge Mid-City 408-10 North Tarti_Street ' Eibille MISCIty 413. North Teti Street Eligible Mid-Cky 414 North Tonti Street Ell Rile Mid-City 421.23 North Tell Street Eligible Mid-City 428-27 North Tang Street Siilble Mid-Gtr 21244 South Ted Street alit* Mict•Zily 213 South Tmt Street Ektbie kEd-City 217 South Tan! Street Meek, Mid-City .21040 South rood Street Eitlitile Mid-City 223 South I Toe Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July I7, 2008 Page 21

....

TIC` Ir• 1 4 t'r dr 'S ..1.11);',i'il 4“" t • ' ' -ilt2ti::71.:: 7ii . ' '''S 1:•.',:?:•46.7 • i •91 da.i.Z•i•Miliet 4*. • • 224. South Tonti Street ' Eligible • Mid-City 228-30 South Tonti Street I Eligible i MitaCity 310 South Tonti Street .1 Eligibin I Mid-City 314 South Tonti Street 1, Digits.) 1 MId-City 317 South Tint Street Benue I Mid-City 319 South TonU Shut' Ellgible Mid-Caly 323 South Tang Street Eligible Mid-City 325 South Tonll Shiest Eli ible Mid-City 539 South Tonti Street Eligible Mid-City 541-43 South bull Street Eligible Mid-City 544-46 South T. r Street Rale Mid-City 552-54 South anti Street Egcltio , Mid-City 1802 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-CIty 2234 Tulane Avenue El r ible Mid-City 2309 Tularre Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2324 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2336 Tulano Avenue I Belau Mid-City 2400 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2401 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2500-02 Tubule Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2508-10A Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2518 Tulane Avenue DIPS Mid-City 2522-24 Tutene Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2626-28 Tutene /venue Eligible Mtri-erly 2530-32 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2537 Tulane Avenue Eligible MNICIty 2542-44 Tulane Avenue elkitble I Mid-City 300 even South Claiborne Avenue Eligible , 1 New Orleans Medical 450 1 South Claiborne Avenue Eligible New Ot leans Mecliwi 422 Frei& Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 1504-08 i Smith Skeet glIgible New Orleans Medical 1600 Growler Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 406 LaSalle Street Eligible New Orion Medical 439 LaSalle Street Elaitde New Orleans Medical 445 LaSalle Street - Eligible New Orleans Medical 1801 Perdido Sheet Eligible New Orleans Medicrel 1601 ' Perdido Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 1430 Tulane Avenue Ell Ible New Orleans Medicat 1541 Tutene Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1642 Tulare Avenue . fble New Orleans Medical 1644 Tans Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1546 I Tulane Avenue Still Ible I New Orleans Medical Ms_ Pam Bream July 17, 2008 Page 22

VA has determined that the following properties within the APE do not contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District nor are they individually eligible for listing in the NRHP.

,... V : p ;-i,, - , .ftC iiiI -, ,_:,,r,..car.f .,..d '. ..;,:v,,';„‘ • 4';. ' ' '' , . , : ,... W..?,? -) -A-7 . - .. '' • 1 tkr 'in rot, N. q , TI , 4 ''' ' . ' % V ' "110 % ' 1 • 0 ' • t. -‘ 't Ai I ink 1 4 f6 'it 'h. ''' 18 •1 . 1 ' WIT4 4 r ;J' : ' ' ' • ' 8:- k . e. ".' .. 2101 Banks Street Not Elimible 2107-09 Banks Street Not Elig ible 2111 Banks Street Not Eiiglbie 2121 Banks Street Not Efigibfe 2223 Banks Street Nat Eliiibie Mid-City 2231 gible Mid-City 2325-27 Banks Street Not Efigibie Mid-City 2435 Banks Street Not Eii_• bie Mid-Cit 2520 Rants Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2615 Banks Street Not Eliglbie Mid-City 2630 Banks Street Not Elitible Mid-Ci 2631 B-anks Street Not Eligible Mid-Ci 2633 Banks Street Not Eltgible Mid-City 1808-10 Bienviile Avenue Not Ei2ible Mid-Ci 1814-16 Bienville Avenue Not ©igii le Mid-City 1818 Eligible Mid-City 1828 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1538 Bienvilie Avenue Nat Eligible Mid-City 1929 Bienville Avenue Not • Mid-Cif 001 Mid-City_ ! BiarvilleAvenue Not Eligible Mid-City 21! Bienvllle Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 22! Blenullle Avenue Not Ei.lble Mid-Ci 2206 gible Mid-City 2210 A- Bienville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2307 Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 BienviDe Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2323 Bienvilie , Mid-City 2401 Eligible Mid-City 2438 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-CV 2529 Blenvirie = Not Eli! ible Mid-Ci 2536 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2506 A-E Blenville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-Ci 433 B-olivar Street Not Ellg ibla 533 . Bolivar Street Not Eii•ible 2426 Bradish Piece Not Eli•ible y 130-38 southBroad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 138 A North 200 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 210 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 2.4

12-0' , st ' - - 4 . - - 1-• '44 1 ft?.01." • *:.. i ri ..4,...tWOOr .. .".4 illfriF14i - - 'a 1 i • •-t • 214 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 218-20 SoUth Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 230 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 300 SO Brood Avenue Not EWA. Mid-City 316 South_ Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 320 Soutti_i, Bivad Avenue I Not Eligible Mitt-City 332 South I Broad Avenue I Not einibla Mid-City 400 North Broad Avenue iNot Eligible Mid-City eel) North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 518 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 522 South Broad Avenue NsfiEsl ibisi Mid-City 638 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mlo-City 1830 Canal Street Not Eligible 1061 Canal Street Not Eligible 1700 even Canal Street Not FJI 'bre 1806 Cana! Street Not Eligible MW-City 1820 Canal Street Nat Elite Mid-City 1832 Canal Street Notgglitee Mid-City -1900 I Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1912-16 I Canal Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 1915 Canal Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 1939 Canal Street Not Eh ilea Mid-City 2000 Canal Street Not Untie Mid-City 2001 Canal Street Notglable MId-City 2017-21 Canal Street Not Faigible Mid-City 2024.30 I Canal Street Not Eligible Mld-City 2025 Canal Street Nat Eligible Mid-City 2032 Cam' Street Not FJIgible Mid-City 2.116 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2201 Canal Street Not Eligible . Mid-0.ty 2216-22 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2220 Canal Sheet Not Eligible Mid-City 2233-95 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2301 Canal Street Not DigIble Mb-City 2322 Canal Street Not amble MW-Cit y 2323 Canal Street Not eligible 1 Mid-City 2330 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2337 Canal Street Not Eligible MId-City 2476 I Canal Street Not Eligerie Mid-City 2500 Canal Street Not eigible Mkt-City 2512 Canal Street Not B ebe Mkt-City 2515 Canal Street Not Elielble Mid-Ctty 2525 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-Chy 2526 1 Canal Sheaf Not eilble MloiCify 2530 Canal Steel Nat Eligible Mid-City My. Para Bream July 17, 20CS Page 24 tcti-it,z, -. .b.: tz 2538.3a Camel Simet Not Eligible Mid-City 2542 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2601 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City Canal Street Not Ellett° Mid-City 2619-2 Canal street Not Eliglule Mid-City Carve Street Not Eli bte Mid-City Canal Burnet Not EllgIblo Mid-City Canal Street Not Beide Mid-City 2661 Canal Street Na Elicatue Mid-City 111 North Claiborne Avenue Not Eligtle 201 Werth Claiborne Avenue Not Elijrs 217 North Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible 301 North Claiborne Avenue Not El tee 401A-C South Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible 406.10 North Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible 426 North Claiborne Avenue Not lgible 600 South Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1631 Cleveland Avenue Not Eli ble 1801 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1817 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1925 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2030 Cleveland Avenue Not BOW Mid-City 2101-09 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible 2204 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2208 Cleveland Avenue Nat Babel Mid-City 2212 Cleveland Avenuo I Not Mid-City 2224 Cleveland Avenue Not MO* Mbd-City 2322-24 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-Clary 2326-284 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2426 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible 2620 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City land Avenue Not Eligible 1700 Conti Street Not Eligible 1804 Cone Street Not Eligible MId-City 1806-12 Coral Ries' Not Eligible Mid-City 1817 1 Conti &Mei I Nol Eligible Mid-City 1626 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1904 Conti street Not Eligue Mid-Chy 1926 I Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2009 I Corni Street Not Eligible Mkt-City 2228 Conb Street Not Eligible I Mid-City 2312 Cone Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2318 Conti Street Not Eligible Mld-Clly 2328 Conn Street Nal Eligible I Mid•Cily 2410 . I Conti Street Not Eligible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Brett July 17.7008 Page 25

7t. Fr I. I. giltfr:41 4. a, .ed,1Kiiii- -7, ji-SIAi;!r ." : itLIS.A.-7..a4 A ' i.t14:- "i- ' z4 -0: 2411.13 I Corsi Street Not fnIgible I Mid-City 2417-19 Cony Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2425-27 Conti Stem Not Eligible Mlatity 2429-31 Conti Street Not Eligible M1cl-C4y 2433-35 Conti Street Not Elleible Mid-City 2437-39 Conti Sheet Nol Eiletbie MId-Crty 2525 Conti Street Not Eligible I 2538 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2538 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2540 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-Qty 2615 Conti Street Not Eligible MM-City 2617 Conti Street Not Eiltabte Mid-City 2619 CoMi Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2837 Cart Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2845 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-Clly 223-23 G North Derbacpy Steel Not elgiblo Mid-City 318 North Derbagny Sheet Not Eligible Mid-Clay 322 North Dableny Street NOt Eligible MId-City 327 North Detriarty Street Not SIMS Mid-City 329-31 North Dettrigny Street Nat Eligtbie Mid-Ot 121 23 North Dorgenois Street Not Eligible arsi-City 122 North Doigenuts Street Not Eligible Mid-City 127 North I Dorgenols Street Not Ellgthta tad-City 135 South Dorgenols Street Not Eligible Mil-Crty 204-08 North Dorgenols Street Not Eligible Mid-City 216-17 8 South Dorgenois Street Not Ellgible Mld-Qty 218 North Dorgenols Street Nut Eligible Mid-City 221 North Dorgenois Street Not Eligible Ml-City 322 North Dorgenols Street Not Eligible Mid-City 324 A-F South Dorgenols Street Nol Eligible Mid-OtY 329 South Dorgenois Stmet Not EligIbie Mid-City 412. South Dorgenols Street Not Eligible Mid-City 626 South Dorgenols street Not Eligible Mid-City 100 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 119 North Gthel Shutt Not Eligible Mid-City 119 South Galvez Street Not Eligible MidCity 120 North Gayer Street Nat Eligible Mid-City 129 North 1 Gelvez Street Not Eligible MW-City 141 North Salver Street Not Eligible Mid-City 200 North Galva Street Not Eligible Mid-City 201 North Galvez Street Not Sigible Mid-City 201-03 South _I Glantz Street Not Eligible Mid-City 213 North Garyez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 221 . North Osevez Street Nat Eggdle MId-City 239-41 South Galan Street Not Eligible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 26

' r VICII:A ':.0 A ' ' ' .1.' N,..12k,.1;1- )5..!, . 4154 .ltjtc 11. ,.1 fiil .' 14 10....1 ' k.,* "1f AilaV16! l :J. ' 1. •420A1.5.%" ' ,.is , , 4: 17 ' !I:nr4i;2.41` ft t; _, .. ;,____,4„ „fP,,' - 310 South Gaivez Street Not Eligible Mld-City 315 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 319 South Gaivez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 328-30 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 331 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 400 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 401.03 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 414 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 420-22 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 424-26 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 428-30 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 432 North Galvez Street Not Eligible 435 North Gaivez Street Not Eligible Mld-C4 436-38 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 450 South Galvez Street Not Etlble 455 South Gaivez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 508-10 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 538 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 555 South Gaivez Street Not Eligible 601 (Bi South Galvez Street Not Eligible 601 {A} South Galvez Street Not Eligible 826 South Gaivez Street Not Eligible 649 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 745 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 1661 Gravier Street Nat Eligible New Orleans Medical 1800 Gravier Street Not Eligible 1900 Gravier Street Not Eligible 2020 Gravier Street Not Eligible 2025 Gravler Street Not Eligible 2233-35 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mld-City 2300 Grevier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2314 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2400 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2413 Granter Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2425 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2501 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2510 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2527 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2528-30 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2619 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2635-37 Gravler Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2641 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2545-47 Grevier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2649 Gravier Street Not Eligible Mfol-Ci ty 2655-61 Gravier Street Not Eligible _ Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Pose 27

.IP At _ .• voi 1804 Iben/Ille Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1836 iberylile Street Not Eligible Mil-CRY 1911-13 lbervIllo Street Not Eligible Anickatf 2039 lberville Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2011 monde Street Not Eligible Mid-CIty 2019 1 bereft Strout Not Eligible folid-City 2314 I Itionilite Street Not 0 r Hate pmdcis 2323 Itrivflie Street Not Elgt1 Mic-City 2405 lbennee Sheol Not ElejUe MiciCity 2516 tbeNfIle Street Not Etigible MW-City 2525 ibeNille Street , Not Ellaibr Mia-City 2545 lbervele Straw Not Elluibte Mid-City 2801 iperyllie Street Not Elitle Mid-City 2604 IbeNlIle Street 1112tffligii Vie Mid-City 2624 ibervIlle Street Not aiplble MItt-Cily 2825 iberyllle Street Not Eligible , Mid-City 127-29 North Johnson Street Not Eligible Mld-City 128-30 North Johnson Street Nat Eligible Mtd-City 210 North Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 214 North Johnson Street Not Eligible MIdsCIty 217 South Johnson Street Not Dolt* Mid-Clty 219 South Johnson Street Not Eigitke MIcl-City 223 North Johnson Street Not Bgibili Mid-City 223-25 South Johnson Street Not E2Pcible Mid-City 415-17 North Johnson Street Not Etifrels M141-Ctty 417 South Johnson Street Not Eligiblu 418-20 North IS mann Street Not Eligible MIcsCily 430 North Johnson Street Not Eligible 436 South Johnson Street Not Eligible 500 odd South Johnson Street Not Eligible 2301 Julia Street I Not Eligible 2400 odd Julia Street Not Eligible 2036 laftWelba Street I Not Eligible 2047.51 Lafayette Street 1 Not Baltic 121-21 B Nati ' Mko Street Not Eligible Mid-City 201 South 1 Miro Sheet Not Beide Mio-City 208-08 Soutn I Miro Street Not Eigible M.ci-City 223 North I Miro Street Not Eligible Pita-(Qty 306 South ( Miro Street Not Eilgibto Mid-City 328 North I Mao Street Not Biotic MId-City 612 South Miro Street Not Bloibte Mid-City 619 SouthMiro Street Not Eligible MId-CIty 832.34 South_ Mho Street Not Eligible MEd-City 2408.10 I Oak Place Not Eligible Mid-City 2419-37 r Oak Place Net Clielble Mid-City Ms. ram Banos July 17, 2008 Page 28

...... ,1 ...... i

1027 1 Palmyra Slreal Not EiiElbte Mid•City 1911 I i Palmyra Stant ' Not Robe . Mid-Qty 1939-39.5 Palmyra Street NM Ekitible reid-CRY 2105 Palmyra Sues! INot Efaibla Mid-City 2113 1 ?sacra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2146 I Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2110-21 Palmyra Slreot Not Eligible I M!d•City 2123 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2127 Palmyra Street Not Eligible i Mid-City 2332 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2338 Palmyra Street Not Eligible And-City 1 2609 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2837 paimyra Street Not Ellgibta Mkt-City 2644 Palmyra Street Not Eligible mid-City 2657 Palmyra Skeet Not Eligible Atict-City 1523 Perdido Street Not Eligible New Orlearut Medical 1900 Penlido Street Nat Eligible 1901 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2021 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2100 Perdido Street Not z iplble 2120 Peretteo Strom Not Eligible 2125 Perdido Street Not egible 2126 Perddo Street Not Eligible 2130 Perdido Street Not Elate 2222-27 Pen5do Street Not Bata 2300 Perdido Street Not Elktble 2310 I Perdido Street Not Eligible 2427 Penedo Same Not Eligible 2429 1 Perdido Seem Not BRAM° 2431 Perdido Skeet Not BAIA° 2605 V1Perdido Street Not Eligible 2507 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2626 Pardkto Street Not Eligible 2527 Perdido Strain Not Eligible 2060 Paydays Street Not Eligible 2066 Kw**, Street Not Eligible 2070 Poydres Street Not Eligible 2100 Poydres Street Not Eligible 2100 odd Pdydres Skeet Not Eligible 212D Poydras Skeet Not Eligible 2133 PaymaaSUeet Not Eligible 2138 Poydras Street Not El cjible 2200 even Poydres Street Not EltIble 2222 NelmsStreet Nat Eligible 2235 Poydam Strut Not Eligible

Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page29

•••

2237 Poydras Street Not BOA 2239 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2532 Poydras Street Not Ekabce 2538 Poydras Street Not Eta*, 2600 Poydras Street Nat Eights 2654 Poydras Street Not Eigibie Street Not Eligible Mid-CI 218-18 North Prieur Street Not Eligible MId-.44f. 220-22 North Hour Street Not Elicibie MIcloCiar 422 North Prism Street Made Mid-City 433 North PrIeur Street li_1111le Racbabiave 114-18 North Street Not Eligible Mid-City Rocheblave 218 North Street Not Mole SAM-City Rocheblave 300 South Street Not Eligible Mtd-City Rochebleve 313-15 North Street Not Eligible Mid.Clty Rochubleve 314-18 South Sheet Not Eligible Mid-City Rochebime 315 A-F South Street Not Eltgalle Mid-City Rocheblave 324-24 A South Street Not Eigble MId-City Rochebleve 530 South Street Not Ellg,ble Mid-City Rocheblove 541.) S oullt Sheet Not Eligible Mld-City Rochebleve 634 South Street Not Eligible Mid-City Rethebleve 640 South Street Not Et! ble Mid-C 120 Nerdt Raman Street Net DI le South Not El 'e M 138 South Roman Street Not BIG Ida Mid-City 201 North Roman Street Not 6t le Mid South Roman Street Not El. e 218 South Roman Street Not Eligible 22.5 North Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 22$ 28.5 South Roman Street Not E e Mid-City 32E-20 North Roman Street Not SigIble Mid-City 400 odd South Roman Shoal Not Viable 526 South Roman Street Not EN 600 even South Roman Street Not acts* Mtd-Crty 633 South Roman Street Not tie Mid-Qty /912-20 Saint Louie Street I Not Eigiole Mid-Clty Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 30

2212-t4 Saint Louie Street Not Ellgole re21)-22 2304 AS Saint Louis Street Not Eigible Mitttlty 2320 Sohn Wait Stre Noirettie Mid-City 2336 Stint Louis Street j Not Eligible Mid-City 2500 SaIM Louis Street Not Eligible 2606 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2620 Saint Lolls Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2628 Saint Louie Street Not Eligible MILICity 215-17 North Tone Street Not Eigible Mid-Ctly 311 South Total Street Not Eligible MIthCity 313 South Tend Steel Not Eligible i Mid-City 318-18 North Tong Street I Not Eligible • Mid•City 401.03 North Tone Street I Not Ellgibie Mitl•City 405-07 North rants shay, LPL'Eligible Mid-City 409 Nuttti. Throb Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 614 South Tont Street Not Eligible Mkt-CIty 730 South Tont' Sheet Not agible 1635 Intent Avenue Not Eligible 1831 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible MISOW 1909 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2000 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2017 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2100 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2100 Mock Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 210406 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2122 Tulano Avenue Not Eligible 2201 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2222 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible MW-City 2231 Thiene Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2315 Tulane Avenue Not Ruble Mid-City 23201 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible I Mid-City 21441—,4 Titian, Avenue Not El able 2424 1 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2504 I Tulane Avenue Not Elioibie Mid-City 2509 I Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-C1N 2514 I Talent Avenue I Not Eligible Mid- 2601 . Thiene Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2614 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible MISCItY 2642 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2644 WaneW Avenue Not Eligible i Mid-City 2647 , Tulune Avenue Not Eligible I Mid-Cey

M. hay 117. Page 31

2d55 _1 Warm AveothL_i Not1E1 .1Nuil.C1ty 3.110 I Ttla.ia Avo-ur Nta

VA hes itlentlftEct the following props within ti /OE thrg may be eligible 1114t hp1 ire the NR IV. VA. will CDIMIt with your ofike on that eligibility ar flack propertit srihen Mir evEi [nations tire complete.

wimar DV2P+Flui trerag t., r arso4 744A: " AM."J.1 r/74.1 1 rikin erewary 2401 Tulam Avsmie Faistall Brewery Cl-ervier Steel Orleans Home 18N1 , Canal Street P-Lrep SITiticio No, 15 24311—Pairnyr4 McDoriowil tio_ 11 2931 Pa[rnyre Slyest Dokitsehes DAIS _11311 Souit GadhPm Strike: St, Joseph's Clitirch 1/302 Avenwt Si John's Evorig$111 uriheran 2001 Itanrylie erepd United Church MaDnri h No. 30 2220 ! Gravior avow

VA re:not:as S1 O's curietulenee is determinations regarding the APE thr each Alternative: du: skps VA has takim to identify and eviiingte staicrufas within each APE; and VA's application of the Naiontil lk,gister et iterka ond do tcrtritnations of National Itr-ghtor for $rnoeling structuret within each APE,

Plosce coW.sct (202) 565.6740 or liCeilgeon.Scharnal2gva.ativii you hove any que5tians ar 11r 11LiCrali information.

rely.

liers Worm] reddrai Praservidian Mao US. Deplartrrlarti of Veterow Mrsure,

Cc- Don Marne, Advisory Council on Hi;tortePresergailun John Ketchum, Federal Emergency Managernialt Agentry It Pam Breaux July 17, 200* Pair 12

The SfIPO reviewer for standing structures concurs with VA's determination regarding the APE for each Alternative; the steps VA has taken to identify and evaluate standing structures within each APE; and VA's application of the National Register criteria and determinations ofNational Regmer eligibility for standing structures within each APE.

%WO Reviewer for Standing Structures Date Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 33 Pens Breakie. July 17, 20i,M Page 34 ML Alen Stailit July ;7, 2006 'age 35 J. LArd.DRit tats o 1 Knuisiluta Nom Din oviiix t.4 cipAg•ir ogrevE 'COVE LIEUTENANT GoVEII#No14 latch START 1E-PAR-I-PAIENI O Cui.Tunz, REEREATioN Tountapot or-rie-c QR cuLTU.RAL DEVELOPtell 441`

August 5.2008

Ms Kathleen Schrum! F ederal Preservation Officer Deparimeni of Veteran Affairs Orrite of Construction and Facilities Management (O0 FM Washington. DC 20420

Re: Request for SHP° Concurrence U.S. Demi-meat of Veteran Afrain Medical Campos (VAIVICt Arcs of Pe tentiai Effects (APE) and National Register of ilisiorie Places (NRHP) Determination of Eligibility Assessment New Weans, Orleans Parish, LA

Dear Ms. Scharnel:

Thank you for your letter or July 17, 21)08 that we received on July 22. 2008, concerning the above-referenced undertaking. We concur with your assessment of the VA.MC Alternatives set forth below. We note dint all were assessed based on a list of ii.iittiptions dim included is -ii.es3t,ich as elevation., visual cilia, construction vibration, aging emu, and dem-o:itinn that were discumed at our informal meeting on July 9, 20013, and further discus sv.1 as the meeting among all consulting picnics on July 23. Please tic aware that ottr unnerstandinit of the assumptions underlying the PrErvision APEs for those Alternatives (lam; iilightty from thase in your letter. We would alao tune that events have overtaken our earlier conversations in Oral your office has now advised us that ii has now been offered, and ir4 considering, a new potential site for VlOVIC Thai new site i the former Lindy Boggs Medical Center at 301 N, Jefferson Davis Parkway. At this writing. we have not bad a chance to offer our advice about that new site. We look forward to doing so in the neat futuw

We list below, the three ahemative approacha to the prujmi you outline in your letter, our understanding of the provisional APE for each, and illus. undersimuliTIE of the assumptions Per each provisional APE. The scope of each 1-uxivilimani APE i& tandenrund to speak to buildings only. with tirchseoiogical resource issues t4.) worked out separately

i"is. 00.4 A4TA7 P Off #LoyDL. LiPul$3CANis 70104 .411'41 P141211Z rZ-Z155) .3a4? 'C • IFAX 4ZU5,4 al Oltriri Ineyopi.crirmTATE-:LA.um At Suum Drpnrrnatirrr glf5P1/111211 Ms. Kathleen Scheme! August 5, 2008 Page 2

1. Alternative I—Rebuild VA Hospital in Place: The APE for this alternative Includes the existing VA campus as well as those blocks bounded by the I-10 elevated Interstate, Poydras Street, Loyola Avenue,. and Cleveland Avenue. Assumptions for Alternative I's Provisional APE: a. Wholesale demolition of VAMC in its entirety b. Staging areas are included within the APE c. Now construction limited to 20 stories in height d. Controlled range of vibration associated with repincementkonstiuction, to be agreed upon through subsequent consultation.

7. Alternative 2—Construct Replacement Facilities at the OcIssner Site The APE for this alternative is Emhart Expressway. Jules Avenue, Jefferson Highway, River Road, and Deckbar Avenue. Assumption for Alternative 2's Provisional APE: a. New construction limited to no more than six stones in height.

3. Alternative 3-Construct Replacement Facilities at the RPC Site: VA has identified the area associated with the Regional Planning Cumin ission (RPC) and bounded by South Rocheblave Street, Canal Street, South Galvez Street, and Tulane Avenue as a feasible she for the construction of replacement facilities. The Provisional APE for this alternative is encompassed by: the Broad Street overpass, Sr. Louis Street, North Robertson Street, South Robertson Street, /Mane Avenue. the 1-10 elevated Interstate, and the boundaries of the Now Orleans Medical Historic District. That set of boundaries differs only slightly from that stated in your letter of July 17, and we would think the difference was inadvertent on the part of the VA. Assumptions for Alternative 3's Provisional APE: a. New construction limited to no more than six stories in height. b. Controlled range of vibration associated with replacement/construction, to be agreed upon through subsequent consultation (slight difference here In ow phraseology and VA*4), e. If historic properties were moved from the APE to other locations, the receiving locations would constitute part of the Provisional APE.

In regard to the eligibility of NRHP historic districts and properties individually eligible or listed in the NRHP we costetir with VA's assessment_ Ms. Kathleen Schamel, except for the exceptions that follow.

In reference to National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) Districts, Alternative l's APE is within the boundaries of the Lower Central Business District (LCBD). In addition, our information is that the New Orleans Public Library is not an individually listed NRHP property, but rather is a contributing element of the LCBD. We would also note that we believe that New Orleans City Hall, 1300 Poydras, is within the boundaries Ms. Kathleen Scheme] August 5, 2008 Page 3 of Alternative l's APE and is considered by SHPO and FEMA as eligible for listing in the NRHP. We expressed our opinion on that in a SHPO concurrence letter to FEMA dated December 8, 2005. Also, of the three properties under Alternative I listed as not eligible for the NRHP, we respectildly disagree with the Veteran Administration's assessment of the property referenced as 1601 Perdido. Ina letter dated January 23, 2006, we concurred with FEMA that the property listed as 1601 Perdido Street (VA Administration Hospital Building) was eligible for listing in the NRHP as a contributing element of the New Orleans Medical Historic District.

In reference to the nine properties within Alternative 3's APE that are identified as potentially eligible for individual listing in the NRHP, we look forward to further consultation with your office on that subject.

If you have arty questions, please contact Mike Varna& in the Division of Historic Preservation at (225) 219-4596.

Sincerely,

Robert Collins Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer

RC:MV:s cc by email: Secretary Pain Breaux Assistant Secretary Scott Hutcheson Pam Perkins, Facility Planning and Control John Ketchum, FEMA Laetitia Rankin, FEMA Don Klima, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Katry Hauls, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Jeff Durbin, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Consulting Panics U.S. Devittmat of HomelandSecurity Unaliana Transitional Recovery Office One Seine Coen Ws Oilcan. LA 70114 0043 762-20111 office *DO 762-209 fax FEMA

July 17. 2008

Pamela A. Breaux State Historic Preservation Officer Department of Culture, Recreation & Tourism P.O. Box 44247 Baton Rouge, LA 70804

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans. LA Applicant: Louisiana Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control

Dear Ms. Breaux:

As a result of damages from Hurricanes Katrina (DR-1603-LA) and Rita (DR-1607-LA), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) received a request from the State of Louisiana. Division of Administration. Facility Planning and Control (FP&C) to provide assistance to the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) located at 1532 Tektite Avenue, New Orleans, LA. FEMA recently notified you that it was initiating consultation pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act for this Undertaking.

FEMA has identified four Alternatives, including the No Action Alternative. FEMA has determined that the No Action Alternative is not an Undertaking subject to Section 106 review. FEMA will analyze the three remaining Alternatives as part of the Section 106 review for its proposed Undertaking and has identified an Area of Potential Effect (APE) representing the area(s) in which standing structures may be affected for each of these three Alternatives. FEMA has also determined the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each APE. FEMA will consult with the State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) regarding the delineation of APRs for areas in which archeological properties may be affected as well as and identification and evaluation of archaeological properties in a subsequent step of the Section 106 review.

This letter requests SHPO's concurrence on FEMA's determination of the Standing Structures APE for each of the three Alternatives and FEMA's determinations regarding the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each APE pursuant to "Programmatic Agreement Among the FEMA, the SHPO. the Louisiana Office of Homeland Security and M. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 2

Emergency Preparedness. and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation" executed in December 2004 (2004 Statewide PM These APEs are subject to change as more Information about the project is developed and we will consult with your office at dun time.

I° Alternative: Repair MCLNO in Place:

The APE for this alternative is the existing footprint of the MCLNO campus, as illustrated in Figure 1. This APE is based upon the assumptions that repair work will not require pile driving and that no new construction will take place.

The APE lies within the New Orleans Medical Historic District, a district determined to be eligible by FEMA in consultation with SHPO.

Eligible National Register Historic Districts S Name Detorminafinn Boundaries of Eligibility New Orleans Medical 2008 Roughly bounded uy 1- to, t inane Avenue, South Liberty Historic District Street, end Tulane Avenue

The following individually eligible or 1 sted properties are located within the APE:

Properties Indivlduidly Eligible or Listed In NRHP Ruilding Name I_ Data on Register Address. Street Charity Hospital Determination of Eligthillty 2005 1532 Tulane Avenue i Sister Stanislaus Listed 2003 450 South Claiborne Avenue Memorial Building 1

1- et • has determined hat the following properties within the APE Contribute to a listed or eligible National Register His oric District

Sbtrit,Nurnber ,1111readon Street Name Detanninellon _ Historic Districang .150 South Claiborne Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 300 even South Claiborne Avenue Eligible Now Orleans Medical 422 Freret Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 1504-0E1 Gravier Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 405 LaSalle Street EllsOble New Orleans Medical 439 LaSalle Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 445 LaSalle Street _Eligible New Orleans Medical 1532 Tulane Avenue Akiible New Orleans Medical 1541 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1542 Tulane Avenue I Eligible New Orisans Medical 1544 Tulane Avenue I Eligible New Orleans Medical 1545 Tulane Avenue I Eligible New Orleans Medical

Ma Pam Breaux July 17. 2008 Page 3

PT.MA has deterntined that the following properties within the APE do not contnbut to the Ncw Oteans Medical Historic District nor are they individually eligible for listing in the NRHP.

lieteripMeLlit le OW** 433 Bolivar Street NOI Stable. 533 Bolivar Street Not Eligible 1 1E61 Griwler Street Not Eligible New Orleans Madinat 1900 Gravies. &mot Not Eligible 2020 l Grater Street Not Eligible 2025 I Gravies. Street Not Eligible 500 odd I South Johnson Street Not Spa* 1529 Perdido Street Not Eligible Now Orleans Medical 1900 Perdido Street Not Eligible 1901 PertldQ Street Not rlialble 2021 Perdido Strew Nat Eiglble 2101) Perdido Street Not Eligible l 136 I South Roman Street Not tile 1 L 400 add I South Roman Street 1 Nol Eligible 1

2" Alternative: Replace Existinr fv1CLNO Facilities on the Existing Site:

The APE for this alternative includes the existing MCLNO campus as well as those blocks bounded by the 1-10 elevated late:1state, Poydras Street, Loyola Avenue and Cleveland Avenue, as illustrated in Elgiur 2. This APE is based upon the assumpttont that all of the buildings within the campus will be demolished and rebuilt and that new buildings will not exceed twenty ;20/ stones.

The APE contains the New Orleans Medical Historic District and portions of the Lower Central Business District, the-Lower Central Business District Extension and the Middelly Historic Distrtct.

Limos, and Eligible National Register Historic Districts

Name t Date I Boundaries Lower Central Business ' Listed 1E6 Roughly bOtirtcled ny Cana, Street. Tchoupinautes Street. mast] Poydras Street fr Keels Avenue. Common Street S. Saratoga Street Lower Central Business 2008 Roughly bounded by LaSalle, Grainer Street, Leyola Avenue, DistIct Extension S. Rampart Street, Elk Place and Common Street; and Common Street between O'Keefe Avenue and Baronne Street Mr. Pam Breaux July 17. 2008 Page 4

Now Orleans Medical Determination Roughly bounded by 1-10, Tulane Avenue, South Ubetty Historic. District Of Eligibility 'Street, and Tulane Avenue 2006 Mid-City Historic District 1993 Roughly bounded by Derbigny Street, Conti Street. elly Park Avenue. and 1-10

The following individually eligible or listed properties arc located within the APE:

Properties Individually Eligible or Listed In AIRHP 1111111 Building Name Date I Address : iirsaL-Street ... Charity Hospital Determination of Eligibility 1532 Tubes Avenue 2005

Staler Slanistaus 2003 1 450 South Claiborne Avenue Memorial Building Stale Office Building Determination al trigibility 325 Loyola Avenue 2007 Slate Office Building Determination of Eligibility 301 Loyola Avenue Annex 2006 Civil Courts Building Determination Ot Eligibility 421 Loyola Avenue t - 2007 1

14MA has determined That the following properties within the APE contribute-to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District. i StmeillAatsur Oncigt1 Street-Name al Determination Historic District —.11 450 South Claiborne Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 300 even South Claiborne Avenue Eligible Now Orleans Medical 422 Frerat Sues! j_lligible New Orleans Medical _1600 Gravier Street Bale Now Orleans Medical 1504.08 Gravler Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 405 LaSalle Street Eligible Now Orleans Medical 439 LaSalle Street Eligible New Urbane Medical 445 LaSalle Steel Eligible New Orleans Medical Lower CBD 219 Loyola Avenue Eligible Extension 1601 Perdido Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 1601 Perdido Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 1430 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1532 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1541 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1542 Tulane Avenue Ellejble New Orleans Medical 1544 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1545 Tulane Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 1802 Tulane Avenue Eligible 1 Mid.City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17. 2008 Page 5

FEMA hos determined that the following propenies within the APE do not contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District nor are they individually eligible for listing in the NRHP.

Street — Number Direction Street Name -DeterDetermination —17Distant - Mettle; 433 Bolivar Street Not Eligible 533 Bolivar Street Not Eligible 600 South Claiborne Avenue Not Elkelle 401A-C South Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible 450 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 538 South Galvez Street Nol Eligible 626 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 420.22 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 42426 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 42840 South Salver Street Not Eligible 436.38 I South Galvez Street Not Eligible 508-10 I South Galvez Street I Not Eligible 1 1661 Gravier Street Not 0 i. ible I New Orleans Medical 1800 Gravfer Street Nat Eligible 1900 Gander Street Not Eligible 2020 Gravler Street Not Eligible 2025 Gravier Street Not Eligible 411 South Johnson Street Not Eligible 435 South Johnson Street Not Eligible 500 odd South Johnson Street Not Eligible 1523 Perdido Street Not Eligible flew Orleans Medical 1900 Perdido Street Net Eligible 1901 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2021 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2100 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2120 Perdido Street Not Elltrale 2126 Perdldo Street Not Eligible 2126 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2130 I Perdido Street Not Eligible 2133 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2100 odd Poydras Street Not Bale 138 South Roman Street Not Eligible Aid-City 628 South Roman Street Not Eligible 633 I South Roman Street I Nol Eligible 400 odd South Roman Street Not Eligible 600 evert South Roman Street Not Eligible 1835 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2000 Tulane Avenue Net Eligible 2122 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2t00 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2104.06 Tulane Avenue r Not Eligible Mr.. Pant Breaux Icily 17_ 2111,8 Page

3" Alinintive: Construct RevirtgAgiLit

1.-EMA% Applicant faaa i&otii lied tilt Alta Ennshitr41hy 5uusla ClaiNurie Avenue. Ti11111W Avenue. South Gelvrt Sum dotiCortoi SOW is frASible %VC for 114C CEPIMMOilK1 of 1-5plilECtrIctit 111,CilitiZZ. The APE for this Wicsna.tivc is bounded by ale Bruad. Strcei ww,expass. So Louis Stireet. Nordi Rflbetikuti Street, Tulm-ir AVEM-Te and elt /- ICI elevated ifilbershae ru lc 3, This APE is btmcd upon the assumption/ha new buildings will IRO excecd six (6) mak/

LIBLeci 4710 aniii1411r RilgirsuN w1l t C phitictt_

Norm U MO 1 _„ . . .._ _ _ -OW eleurtilarim- _ k i Mid-City Hizikort 1.)inEriL! )99;:k Roughly uounded by Diaiiilutly 51teet. Cam Saprd, Dry Park I AVOriLIO, and 1- 1 0 Nekv O►1 likorkai Oelomuriabn j Rouilli, bounded y 1-10. 'Tains. Avenueir South LlIziorty i4131unclatz1ncl of Ellgolly &oat and Tutane Avenue 2006 I

The (-diming individually ciIbibii or listed properties are loclited Withiu che APE:

PlrojimiNg eligTbiel at LINTOd kw lifla-133 • , 5141iftIN !WOVE Cato I a I pert Palo Amortean Roilding 240:i Canal Stct+41 — St. Jan4vii AIME Church 1582 222 North. Raman Street SL Loa's Cerrielery _ .1975 1E30 St, Lout Steel. C3-airy kimono!' •mitenyvirlaitou 1512 Tutorto Avonur. ENEbEry Shier 14emorrai: 211.103 450 South Motion-le Avenue Buldirig

W.IvIA ions clEruimined dug ihe following Frruperties wIthin the APE ekliitribute to histcd ter eligible National _Registcr F1isto i DiS1.160.

Banks Street I Ellialbla 2217 Banks Street riflitirgo itZ21 Banks Street EfIOlalop _ 22M EV1tole_ PA 223t MU City 23D1 cl-C118, 2315 Banks Strati 240 Banks Stria[ Mid.C1tv Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 7

2509 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City I 2515 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2539 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2549 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2604 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2619 ?tanks Street Eligible Mid-City 420 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2821 I Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2626 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City I 2656 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2205-07 Banks Street Eligible Mkt-City 1 2209-11 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2213-15 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2905-07 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2321 A-23 Ii Banks Sleet EliaIble Mid-City 2405-07 Banks Street Eligbie Mid-City 2411-43 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2415-17 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2421-23 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2425-27 I Banks Street Eligible Mid-City ' 2511.13 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2517-19 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2521.23 Banks Street Battik, Mid-City 2525-27 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2533-35 Banks Street amble Mid-City 254145 Banks Sires! Eligibll3 Mid-City 2600-02 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2605-07 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2608-10 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2812-14 Banks Street Elicibie Mid-City 2642-44 Banks Street Eligible Mid-City 2646-48 Banks Street Eligible 1 Mkt-City 1723 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1729 Blanton's Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1908 BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1922 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2114 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2115 Blew* Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2120 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2125 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2135 Bienville Avenue Ellgthle 46d-City 2209 BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1 2218 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2221 1 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2229 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City i 2313 1 2316 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City Ms Pam Meaux July 17.2008 Page 8

2318 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2321 BienvIlle Avenue Eligible MIcl-Clis, 2323 1 Blenvilie Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2326 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2334 Bienville Avenue I Eligible Mid-Cily 2335 Bienville Avenue E21i 'hie Mid-ally 2338 Manville Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2400 Manville Avenue Eligible I MM-City 2404 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 12420 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2424 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City. 2429 Weanville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2430 Bienvale Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2434 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2507 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2515 Blenvlllo Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2518 Bienville Avenue Eligible . Mid-City 2600 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1731-33 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1804.0e Morainic Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1817-19 I Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City. . 1823.27 A Sierra:lie Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1826-28 B Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1830-32 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City ) 1836-38 in Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City I 2004-08 810111/1110 AvenUe Eligible Mid-City 2022-24 Blenvlllo Avenue Eligible Mid-City 202840 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2108-10 BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2117-19 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2121-23 ! Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2127-29 Bienville Avenue I Eligible Mid-City 2204-08 Glenville Avenue Eligible Iligd-City 2217-19 Bienville Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2220-22 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2231-33 Blenvlllo Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2300-02 BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2304-04 A BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2209-11 ii I Blenvlllo Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 I Denville Avenue Eligible Mid-City i 2320-22 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 12328-30 Bienville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2337-39 Blenvine Avenue 103$0 Mid-City 2415-17 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2416-18 Blenvlllo, Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2423.25 Blenvlllo Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2431-39 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1 M. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 9

0.02 ilitenville Avenue Mid-CI 2501.03 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2504.06 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-Chy 2508-10 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 250841.5 Blenvilie Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2512-14 Glenville Avenue I &Ohio Mid-Ctly 2520-22 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2526-28 Blenville Avenue Eligible N5d-City 2530-32 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2534-38 Manville Avenue Eligible , Mid-City 2538-40 I BiernWe Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2541-43 I Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2542-44 I GienvIlle Avenue MOS Mid-City 2546-48 Manville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2808 A-10 B BlenvIlle Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2612-14 I BlenvIlte Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2616-18 1 Glenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2620-22 Blenville Avenue Eligible I Mid-City 2626-28 Blenville Avenue iEligible Mid-City 2848-50 Blenville Avenue Eligible Mid-City 138 North Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 308 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 316 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 326 South I Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 342 Sown Broaa Avenue aide Mio-city 410 South Broad Avenue Mid-City 416 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 536 South Broad Avenue Eligible 300-02 South Broad Avenue EligibleI Mid-City 308-10 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 312-14 South Broad Avenue Eligible , Mid-City 336-38 South Broad Avenue Eligible Mid-City 422-225 South Broad Avenue Mid-Clly 1800 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 1801 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 1815 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 1838 Canal Street Babe Mid-City 1801 Canal Street I Eliplble Mid-City 1936 Canal Street Eli ibis Mid-City 2041 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 2120 Canal Street ibie Vaid-City 2311 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 2931 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 2335 Canal Street Eligible Mid-CIty 2400 Canal Street Eligibio Mld-Ctty 2540 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 1928-34 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City Mc. Pam Firma July 17.7008 Page 10

2317 A-H Canal Street ramble Mid-City 2501.07 Canal Street Eligible Mid-City 450 South Claiborne Avenue Eligible New Orleans Medical 300 even South Claiborne Avenue Ellolble New Orleans Medical 2024 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2104 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-Clly 2114 Cleveland Avenue .11kjible Mid-City 2118 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City Z200 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2336 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-Clly 2400 Cleveland Avenue algible Mid-City 2402 Cleveland Avenue Elig ble Mid-City 2416 Cleveland Avenue Eli ibie MIS 2422 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MId-City 2430 Cleveland Avenue Elpible Mkl-City 2434 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2438 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid Cily 2504 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2508 Cleveland Avenue Elicible Mid-City 2512 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2513 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MId-City 2514 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2518 Cleveland Avenue Brie Mid-City 2519 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2521 Cleveland Avenue Elictle Mid-City 2626 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mld-City 2527 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2530 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MICI-CRy 2538 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2542 Cleveland Avorum Eligible Mid-City 2547 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 200 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2814 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MIdsCity_ 2622 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mfo-City 2628 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2832 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1806.07 Cleveland Avenue Bebe Mid-City 1808.10 Cleveland Avenue Beide Mid-City 1809-11 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1905-07 Cleveland Avenue Elicible Mid-City 1928-28 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1032-34 Cleveland Avenue Eligible MId-Sibr 1933-35 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1936.38 A Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 1939-41 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City 2000-02 Cleveland Avenue Eligbe Mid-City 2008-10 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-City M.E. Porn Evesiu3 July 17, 2038 Page IM 1

203.40 Cleveland Avenue Bigot]le 1 ivIld.Cily 2034-36 Cievallend Aventaii apible Mid.-Clly 2038-40 Cleveland Avenue . aulble Folld-Ctry 2100.02 Cleveland Avoriu- T Eligible MEd.Citi 2106.00 Cleveland Avenue ibie Mid-City 2226-28 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid-Chi 2330-12 Cleveiend Averwo Eligible IV110-Cily - 12314+10 1 Chweiand Avenue Eligible Mitl.City ' 2010.20 : Glove and Avenue Eligible. Mid-Lily I 2328-38 Cleveland Avorrile _, Eligible _Alcily. 241D-11 2 Cleveland. Avenue ' Elegible ii61-Cliy 2410.20 Cleveland Aveilue Egible . Mid-City 2500-02 Cleveland A venue _ Eligible Vld.CV 2501.03 Cleveland Aveliue lErigible liAld.City 2506-n7 Cleveland Avenue 1 1.ble Mid-City 2500-11 Cleveland Avenue 1[131e - MIO.City 2522-24 Cleveland Avenue Eil!lble Mici-.,11 ZS32.34 Cleveland Avenue Eligible iold.cliy 2541448 Cleveland Avenue Eligible Mid.Citi 2600 ,02 Cieveland Avenue Eligible MId-City 2884-06 Cleveland A voi ate Eligible MId.oly 2607-09 Cleveland Avenue Able Mid.Cny 2621-26 . Develard MIMI.* ELTrle Mid-Clly 2036-3/3 [Cleveland venue Eigtole MICI-Dly -I 0011 onti SIP eel EFeslibla - llitt,Clit 1810 Conti Streel Eligible _0m .01k1,Ctly 1834 Conti Streel Eligible Mid-00y I E13 Oonli Strew Eligible I fetid-City ;919 Conti Street Eligible [ Mid-Gil Tan Conti Street Eligible 1011d-Cily 2021 Gant! Street I Elf hie Mid-C ity 2028 Curt Sireel Efiglilia %/lid-City 2216 beort Strum BOls ,hid-ClIv 2339 Ccardi Strati Eligible ' Mid-C4 2320 Conti Street Eligible Mid-Cily 2322 Conti Street Eligible I Mld-Clty 2327 Coritl Street 9 Ole Mid-City 2330 _ Conti Street Eligible Mtd, ity 2331 Conti. Simi Eligible Mid-City 2324 Corgi Street EH Ible MIci.Citj 2335 Coati Slree1 Eligible MIO.City 242 r Cent Street Eligible Mid-City . 2500 Genii SI! eel Eligible Mid-Criy_ 2507 Com Sireoi Eligible Mid-City 1'813-15 I Conti Street Egiglble Mid-City 1810.21 1 Conti Streol Eligible hillo-Cltv 1820-22 I Con!' &eat [ Eligible Mid.Citif Ms. Porn Breaux July 17,2008 Pap 12

1833-35 Conti Sheet I Sip Rile Mid-City 1837-39 Comi Street Eligible Mid-CitY 1902-02 Et Conti Street ElieIbie ' Mid-City 1922 A-8 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 1932-34 Conti Street Eligible i Mid-City 1933-36 Conti Street Eligible Mld-City 201345 Conti Street Eligible Miday 2017-19 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2025-27 Conti Street Eligible Mit:City 2100.02 Cann Street Eligible Mid-City 2101-03 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2104-06 Conti Street Eligible l Mtd-City 210840 I Cony Street Eligible Mid-City 2111-13 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2112-14 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2115-19 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2116-18 Conti Street Eligible j Mid-City 2209.11 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City. 2213-15 Conti Street Eligible Mkt-City 2217-19 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2221-21.5 1 Contr Street Eltible Mid-Ctr 2224-26 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2225.23 Conti Street Ettble MId•City 2227-29 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2231-33 Conti Strout Eligible MId-City. 2301.03 Cod Street Stale Mid-City 2305-07 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2311.13 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 Cony Street Eligible Mid-City 2319-21 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2330.38 Conn Street Eligible Mid-City 2337-39 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2415.15 A Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2504-08 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2508-10 Conti Street Elipitgo Mid-City 2511-15 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2512-14 t Corgi Street Eligible Mid-City 2517-19 Conti Sheol Eligible Mid-City 2520-22 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2521.29 Conti Street I Eligible Mld-City 2524-28 Conti Street I Eligible Mid-City 2530-32 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 2825-27 Conti Street Eligible Mid-City 125 North Der tinny Street 3 Eligible Mid-City 131 South Derbigny Street Eligible Mld-City 305 North Dorbigny Street Eligible Mid-City 31547 North Derbiony Street I Eligible i Mid-City Ms. Psm Bream July 17.2008 Pagc 13

921-23 Dec'n Street South Domenots Street El a ble North Dor•enols Street Eliciae Mid-Clt South Do Eli! .le Mld-Cit South Do ends Street Eligible Mid-Clt Do r emits Street 312 South Dor enols Street 318 Sattlh Dor °note Street El tie 512 South enols Sheet Itle 526 South enois Street Mid-C11 South Ms Street . Eli Otte Mid-Cli South Do enols Street Do , :nets Street South Do Imola Street El • ibis Mid-C1 118-18 South Do enols Street 120-22 South Doroenols Street El big Mid-C11 130.32 South Dorgenois Street Eligible Mld-City 217-19 South __Dorgenols Street Eligible Mid-City 22244 South Dorgenois Street Eligible Mid-City 314-18 North Diamonds Street Eligible Mid-City 318-20 North Dorgenois Seem Bible I Mid-City 81840 South Dorgenois Street Eligible Mid-Clhe 328.28 South I Dorgenels Street I Eligible Mid-City 618-18 South Dorgenots Street J Edict& Mid-CIty 022 Frerel Slf 001 Eligible New Orleans Medical 124 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 126 South Gelvez.Street Eligible I Mid-City 200 South Gelvez Street Eligible 1 Mid-aly 217 South I Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 224 South Calvet Street Eligible Mid-City 226 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 227 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 299 i South Gahm: Street Eligible I Mid-City 237 -, South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 909 South Galvez Street EGulble Mtd-Ctly 321 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 523 South Galvez Street lode Mid-Clly 627 South Galvin Street Eligible Mid-City 529 South Cake: Street Eligible .Mid-City 128.28 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 12943 South I Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 214-18 Nardi Galvez Street. Eligible Mid-City 218-20 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid•Cijy 223-23 C South Gaivez Sheet Eligible Mid-City 228-29 B South I Galvin Street El Bible Mld-City 230-32 South Galvez Street Eli Me 301-03 South Galva Street amble I lihd-Clly Ms. Pam Bteaut July 17, 2008 Page 14

305-07 South I Ca!vex Street Eliplife I Mid-City 311.13 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-CRY 312-14 North Galvez Street Eligible Mld-C4 316-18 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 320-22 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 325-27 South Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 413-15.5 North Galvez Street Eligible Mid-City 417-19 North Gelvez Street Eligible Mid-City 421.23 North Salver Street Eligible Mid-City 424-28 North ! Galva Street Eligible Mid-City 42527 North Galvez Streel Eligible Mtd-City 428-30 North eaten Steel Ergbe Mid-City 533-36 South Salver Street Eligible Mid-City 1600 Gravier Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 2208 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2228 Gravier Sheet ' Elie Ible Mid-City 2300 Gravity Street Eligible Mid-City 2307 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2312 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2318 Graver Street Eligible Mid-City I 2326 Gravier Street Al! ibis Mid-City 2409 Gravier Street I Ekcible Mid-City 2410 I Grainer Street 1 Eligible Mid-City 2414 Gravier Street Erkible Mid-City 2419 Crevice Street Scalia Mid-City 2421 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2608 Gravier Street Eligible Mkt-City 2507 Gravler Street a igible Mid-City 2518 I Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2523 1 Gravies. Street Eligible Mid-City 2524 Gravler Street Eligible Mid. Clly 2544 i Greeter Street Eligible Mld-City 2600 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2600 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City .21501 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2601 Gravler Street Male Mid-City 1504-08 Greiner Street Eligible Now Orleans Medical 2212-14 Gravler Street aigible Mid-City 2304.06 Gravler Street Eligible Mki-City 2308-10 Gravler Street Eligible Mld-City 2308-11 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2317-19 I Gravfer Street Eligible Mid-City 2321-23 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City " 2322-24 Gravler Sheet Eligible Mid-City 2325-V Grader Street Eligible Mid-City 2328-30 Grainer Strati Eligible Mid-City 2332 A-B Gravier Street Sleds Mid-City It Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 15

2336.38 I Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City I 2417-19 Gravier Street Eligible Mil-City 2420-22 Gravler Street Egli Mid-City 2429-31 I Gravler Street Eligible bAld-City 2432-34 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2433-35 Gravfor Street Eligible Mid-City 2437-39 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2509-11 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2513-15 Gravity Street Eligible Mid-Clly 2517-19 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City I 2531-33 Gravier Street Eligible Mid-City 2535-37 Greylor Street Eligible Mid-City 2539-41 Gravler Street Eligible Mid-City 2543-45 Gravies' Street Eligible Mid-City 2655-61 Gravice Street nlible Mid-City 1016 bandits Street Eligible Mid-City 1904 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 1919 I lbervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 1929 ibarvillo Street Eligible Mid-City 1931 lbervlite Street Eligible Mid-City 1932 tbervllle Street Eligible Mid-City 2001 lberville Sheet Eligible MId-Clty 2020 j bovine Street " Eligible Mid-City 2022 Manilla Street Eligible Mid-City 2023 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2180 lbeivIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2104 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2105 lbervfile Street Eligible MId-City 2123 ' iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2217 Ileardie Street Eligible Mid-City 2220 ibervIlle Street i Eligible Mid-City 2221 lbemille Street El r be Mld-C 2229 ibeiville Street Ell thie Mid-Cit 2235 ibervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2305 lborville Street Eli, ible Mid-Ci 2407 lbeivIllo Street Eligible Mid-City 243t lbervele Street Ell ible Mid-City 2435 berville Street Eli. We Mid-Cl 2609 I lberville Street l_ktible 11,44d-Clly 2653 ibervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2659 iberville Street Eligible IMid-City 2663 Manville Street Eligible " Mid-City 1900-02 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 1921.23 lbervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 1925-27 Iburville Street Eligible Mid-City 1933-39 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2000.02 i lbervIlle Street Eligible MId-Cily Ms. Pam litmoux July 17.2008 Page Id

2028-30 ' thervIlle Street Eligible Mid-City 2038-38 !boodle Street Eligible Mid-City 2101.03 (benfille Street Eligible MIct-CIW 2108-10 lberyale Street Eligible Mid-City 2111-13 lberville Street Engage Mid-City 2112-14 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2115-17 limn/Ills Street I Eligible Mid-City 2118.18 iberville Street Eligible Mk-City 2120.22 iberville Street Elluible Mid-City 212448 iberville Street Eligible I Mid-City 2127-29 iberville Street Eligible , Mid-City 2128-30 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2222-22 5 lberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2224-28 Menage Street Eligible Mid-City 2225-27 I ibervilie Street Eligible Mid-City 2228-30 ~ I thennilie Sires Eligible Mid-City 2232.34 I, ibelynle Street Eligible Mid-City 2300.02 I bervile Street Eligible Mid-City 2301.03 I iberville Street Elig11310 Mld-City 2304-06 1 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2307-00 tberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2311.13 t lberville Streei Elifilble Mid-City 2315-17 iberville Sees arable Mid-City 2310.21 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2328-28 iberville Street ElIctble Mid-City 2330-32 lberville Street Eligible MId-City 2337-39 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2401.03 lberville Street Elia Ibis Mid-City 241113 lberville Slreei Eligible Mid-City 2415-17 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 242143 iberville Street Eligible Mid-City 2627-29 iberville Strom Eligible Mid-City 2655-57 Mervin° Street Eligible Mid-City 212 South Johnson Sires! Eligible Mid-City 216 South I Johnson Strobl Eligible Mid-City 217 North Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 325 South Johnson Street Eligible MId-City 200-11 North Johnson Street Eliglde ' Mld-City 220.22 South Johnson Street Eligible Mid-Oily 221-23 North Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 224-26 South Johnson Sues/ allble Mid-City 317-19 North Johnson Street Elkdble Mid-City 321-25 North Johnson Street Eligible Mid-City 405 LaSalle Street Eligible New °vincula Medical 439 LaSalle Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 445 LaSalle Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 415 Manasseh Place Eligible liAld-CIty Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 17

419 Manassas Place Eligible MW-City 421 I Menasses Place Eligibte _ Mid-City 425 Manasses Place Eligible Mid-City 427 1 Manassas Place I BigEt3le Mid-City 414.18 Manassas Place Eligible Mld•C0y 117 Notch Miro Street antle 1,41d-Cliy 120 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 200 South Miro Sweet Eligible Mid-City 219 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 218 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 217 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 218 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 218 South Miro Street Eligible I Mid-City 219 South Miro Street Eligible MW-City 221 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 226 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 236 South Miro Street dole M41-City 315 South Um Street 1 MId-CIIY 329 South Miro Street Eligible Mks-City 404 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-Clly 409 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 414.6 North Miro Street Eligible Mid•Clty 418 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 623 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 628 South Miro Street Eligible MId-City 116-18 North Miro Street Eligible Mld-City 120-22 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 123-25 North Miro Street I Eligible Mid-City 222-24 North Miro Sheet Eligible Mid-Clty 1,222-24 South Miro Street Mid-City • Ellofble Mid-City I 228-30 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 7.3234 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 300-02 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-Clly 310-12 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-011y 314.18 North Miro Street Eligible Mid•City 91446 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 315-17 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 918-20 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 31840 snub Miro Street Eligible Mtd-City 3t9-21 North Mire Street Eligible Mid-City 1 319-21 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 322-24 Ncrth i Miro Street Eligible Mid•City 322-24 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 3211.25 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 323.25 South I Miro Street 1:1Ssible Mid City 412-14 North I Miro Street Eligible Mid-City MS. Pam Brom: July 17. 2008 Page 18

413-15 North Miro Street I Eligible I Mid-City 417-19 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 42C-22 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 428-28 j North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 432-34 North Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 532-34 South Miro Street Eligible I Mid-City 536-38 South Miro Street Bigot° i Mid-City 620-22 South Miro Street Ertgible Mid-City 624-26 South Miro Street I Eligible Mid-City 625-27 South Mire Street I Eligible Mid-City 828-30 South Miro Street Eligible Mid-City 2411.13 Oak Place Eligible Mid-City 2415-17 Oak Place Eligible Mid-City 1823 Palmyra Streal i Eligible Mid-City 1837 Palmyra Street I Eligible Mid-City 1919 Palmyra Street ; Eligible Mid-City 2009 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2216 Palmyra Street Eligible MEd-City 2220 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City ' 2310 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-Ctly 2313 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2314 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mld-City 2316 I Palmyra throat Eligible Mid-City 2317 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2320 Palmyra Sheet Eligible Mid-City 2322 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2326 Palmyra Street Eligible Mld-City 2327 Palmyra Sliest Eligible Mid-City 2339 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2401 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2404 ' Palmyra Street Eligible Mkt-City 2405 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2408 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2411 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2412 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2414 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2415 i Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2420 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-Clly 2426 I Palmyra Street Ellgit4e Mid-City 2427 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2431 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2508 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2512 Palmyra Street Eligible MM-City 2516 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2517 Palmyra Sheet Eligible Mid-City 2521 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2524 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pain Myatt* July 17.2008 Page 19

12526 I Palmyra Street ' Eligible Mid-City 2527 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-Clly 2543 Palmyra Street I Eligible Mid-City 2547 Palmyra Street I Bebe Mid-City 2601 Palmyra Street „Ekfibkw _ Mid-Clly 2504 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2608 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2611 Palmyra Street I Eligible Mia-City 2620 Palmyra Street Etiolate Mid-City 2622 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2635 Palmyra Street Eligible Mfd-City 2653 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1829-31 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 191446 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-Oily 191547 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1921-23 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1925-27 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 1933-37 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2028.30 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2101-03 Palmyra Street Eligible MId-Oily 2212-14 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2217-19 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2224-24 A Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2225-29 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2301-03 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2305-07 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2319.21 Palmyra Street Eligible ' MISCIty 2323 A-8 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid fly 2329-31 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2407-09 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City Eligible Mid-City yr EIIgISa Mid-City Palmyra Street Elleible Mid-Clt Palmyra Street Eligible Mld City 2501-03 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2504 A-8 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2605-07 Palmyra Skeet Eligible Mid-Oily 2513.15 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2520-22 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid City 2523-25 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2529-31 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2532-34 Pafrnyra S heen Eligible Mid-City 2533-39 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2537.41 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2605-07 Palmyra Street Eligible 2612-14 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2613-17 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City Mit Pam Breaux July 17,2008 Page 20

2619-21 Palmyra Street 1 SigUs Mid-City 2823-2.5 I Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2826.28 Palmyra Street 1 Eligible Mid-City 2627-29 Palmyra Street Eligible Mid-City 2631-33 Palmyra Street Eligible I Mid-City 2634-36 Palmyra Street Elipibin Mid-City 1601 Perdido Street Eligible New Orleans Medea! 1601 Perdido Street Eligible New Orleans Medical 216 South Prieur Street Elicible Mid-City 217 North Prime Street Eligible Mid-City 218 South PrIeur Street Eligible Mid-City 221 North Piteur Street Eligible Mid-City 328 North Prieur Street Eligible Mid-City 215-17 I South Prieur Street Eligible Mkt-City 219 A-21 B South Priem Street Eligible Mkt-City 220-22A South Perna Sean Eligeyte Mid-CIty 223-25 A South Priem Street Eligible Mid-City 314-16 North Poets Street Eligible Mid-City 322445 North Prieur Street Eligible Mid-City 416-18 I North Prieto Street Eligible Mid-City 419.21 I North Prieur Street Eligible MM-Clly 201 North Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 214 ISouth Rocheblave Street I Eligible Mid-City 215 North Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 217 i South Rocheblave Street Eligible MISCity 2i8 South Rocheblave Street Bigible Mid-City .223 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mkt-City 224 South Rocheblave Street Elicible Mid-City 318 ' South ' Rocheblave Street Bite Mid-City 320 North Rochableve Street Eligible Mid-City 321 North Rocheblave Sheet Eligible i Mid-City 323 South Rochebleve Street Bitable Mid-City 328 North Rachel:Java Street Eligible Mid-City 411 North Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 513 South Rochablave Street Eligible Mid-City 519 South Rochobleve Street Eligible Mid•City 524 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 628 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 531 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mld-City 534 South Rochebleve Street Eligible Mid-City 536 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 613 South j Roo:Mobley° Street Elicible Mid-City 813 South I Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 115-17 South Rocheblave Strew Eligible Mid-City 219-21 South RectroLlave Street Eligible Mid-City 227-29 South Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City 310-12 I North Rocheblave Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 21

314-18 I Noah Rochebleve Street Eligible Mid-City 317.19 I South I Rachebleve Street Eligible Mid-City 32325 North Rochebtave Street Eligible Mid-City 324-28 I North I Rachel:gave Street Eligible Mid-City 424-76 North Roehoblave Street 1 EilatIt4e I Mid-City 521-23 South Rot:Mobley* Street Eligible Mid-City 537-39 South Rochebleve Street Eligible Mid-City 615-1/ South Rochablave Street Eligible Mid-City 641-43 1 South Rochableva Street Eligible Mid-City 127 I North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 127 South Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 215 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 219 Norm Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 222 North Roman Street =Arable Mid-City 222 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 301 South Roman Street Eligible Kid-City 401 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 203-05 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 207-09 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 211-13 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 303-05 South Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 909-1I North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 315.17 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 318-10 A North Roman Street ,Sig n e Mid-Gay 319.21 North Roman Street 1 Eligible Kid-City 320-22 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 329-25 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 324-24.5 North Roman Street Eligible Mid-City 1600 Saint Louts Street Eligible 2328 Saun Louts Street Eligible Mid-City 1924-28 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2215-18 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2400-02 Saint Louts Street Eligible liNd-City 2404.06 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 240810 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2412-14 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2418-18 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2420-22 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2424-28 Saint Louts Street Eligible Mid-City 2428-30 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 2432-34 Saint Louts Street Eligible Mid-Ctty 2436-38 Saint Louis Street Eligible Mid-City 124 North tone Street Eligible 0,01-City 212 North Tonti Street Eligible Mid-City 213 South Total Street Eligible Mid-City 217 South Tonll Street Eligible Mid-City 222 North Tont! Street Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17. 2008 Page 22

223 South Ton8Street Ell•thle Mid-Cit 224 South Tani Street Ell•ible Mld-Cit 310 North Toni] Street Ell • Ible MId-Cft 310 South Tonti Street Eli! Ible Mid-Ci 314 South Tontl Street Ell ibis MId-at 317 South Toni] Street Ell• ible Mid-CR - 319 South Tong Street Ellgye Mid-Cit 320 North Tontl Street Etklble MId CR 322 North Tontl Street Eli. ible Mid-C1 923 South ' Toni] Street El ible Mfd-Cft 325 South Toni] Street Ell Rile Mld-Cit 329 North I Toni] Street Ell!lble Mid-Cit 413 North I TontS Street Elie Ibis Mid-Cit 414 North T.onti Street MI ible Mid-CI 639 South Tonti Street Ell.lble Mid-C11." 120-22 North Toni] Street Eligible Mid-City 212-14 South Tonti Street Eli. ibis I Mid-Cit 214-18 North 1 onti Street Eli a Mld-C 218-20 North Tontl Sheet Ell, Ible Mid-Cit 218-20 South Toni] Street Ell Ible Mid-Cl 219-21 B North Tonti Street Ell ibis Mid-CU 228.30 South Thrill Street Eli, Ibis Mid-Cit 326.28 North Tonti Street Ell able Mid-Ci 333-35 North Tonti Street Ell Ibis Mid-Cit 337-34 North Tana Street Ell ible Mid-Cit 408-10 Nonh Tont( Street Ell•Ible Mid-Cit 421-23 North Tonti Street Eligible MId-Cil 425-27 North Tend Street Eli .1ble Mld-CJI 54143 South Tontl Street Eligible Mid-Ci 544-48 South Toni] Street El' iblo MId-City 552-54 South Toni] Street Ell ible Mid-Cit 1430 Tulane Avenue Eli Rale New Orleans Medical 1532 Tulane Avenue Ell ible New Orleans Medical 1541 ! Tulane Avenue Ell Ibis New Orleans Medical 1542 ?thane Avenue i Eligible I New Orleans Medical 1544 Tulane Avenue Ell. ble I . Orl.; 1 i .1 1545 .,1- . •r1-• .41 1802 Eli. ible MId-C11 2234 I ulane Avenue Ell!ible Mid-Ci t 2309 Tulane Avenue EIi•ible MId-Ci 2324 Tulane Avenue Eli.lble I Mid-C 2996 Tulane Avenue El Ible Mid-CI MOO Tulane Avenue Ell thle MId-C1 2401 Tulane Avenue i Eli!lble Mid-Cl 2514 Tulane Avenue Eli•lble Mid-Cit 2518 Tulane Avenue Ell able Mid-Cit 2537 I Tulane Avenue Eli.lble Mid-Cit

Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 23

2500-02 I Tulane Avenue EligiDie Mid-City J 2508-10 A I I Tulane Avenue Eligible I MItheitv 12522.24 I Tulane Avenue ElieIde Mid-City 2526-28 I I Tulane Avenue Eligible I idoci.ow I, 253042 Tulare Avenue Eligible MWCtt 2542-44 Tulane Avenue Eligible Mid-City

FEMA has determined that the following properties within the APE do not contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District nor are they individually eligible for listing in the NRIIP.

Ialrecticm Stmet Marne Detatsdnosion. i.Hisark01111$4, 270:11 Banks Street Nat Etiolate 12111 Banks Stoat Not Elielble 2121 Banks Street Not Eligible 2438 Banks Street I Not Eligible Mlid-CIty 2620 I Banks Street I Nol Eligible Mid-CIty 2616 Banks Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2830 Banks Street Not Eligible Mid-Oily 2631 Banks Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2893 I Banks Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2107.09 j Banks Slreet Not Eligible 2326.27 I Banks Street Not Eligible Ad-City 1818 Senna Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1829 Manville Avenue Not Eligible Ad•Clty 1839 Glenville Avenue Not Eligible k4d-City 1929 BIMINI Avenue I Not Eligible Md-City 2001 BionvIllo Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2012 Manville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2200 Birinyi:10 Avenue Not Eligible Mld-City 2205 Beeville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2307 Manville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2401 Blenville Avenue Not Eligible MId-City 2438 Band ill Avenue Not Eligible Md-City 2529 Manville Avenue Not Eligible Md-City 2535 Manville Avenue Not Ellaible Mid-City 1808.10 Manville Avonuo Not Eligible Mil-City 1814-16 Blom& Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2101-03 Blenville Avenue Not Eligible MId-City 2210 A-G Blenville Avenue Nol Eligible Mid-City 2315-17 Glenville Avenue Nat Eligible Mid-City 2606 A-E Glenville Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 433 Bolivar Street Not Eligible 533 Bolivar Street Not Eligible 2426 Bradley Plain Not Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pant Breaux July 17.2008 Page 74

200 South Broad Avenue 1 Not Eligible , Mid-City 210 North Broad Avenue I Not Ellaible Mid-City 214 North Broad Avenue 1 Not Eligible Mkt-COY 230 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 300 North I Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 320 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 332 South I Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 400 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 480 North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 518 South Broad Avenue Not Eggibie Mid-City 522 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 538 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 130-36 South I Broad Avenue I Not Eligible Mid-City 138 A North Broad Avenue Not Eligible Mid-Clly 2t8-20 South Broad Avenue Not Eligible mithcity 1830 Canal Street Not Eligible 1661 Canal Street Not Eligible 1808 I Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1820 Canal Street Nal Eligible Mid-City 1832 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1900 I Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1915 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1939 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2000 Canal Street ; Not Eligible Mid-City 2001 Canal Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2025 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2032 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2115 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2201 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2220 Canal Street Not Eligible MId-City I 2301 ' Canal Street Not Eligible MId-City 2322 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2923 Canal Street Not Ellcitlic Mid-City 2330 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2337 CanalStreet Not Eligible Mid-City 2475 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2500 Canal Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2512 CanalStreet Not Eligible Mid-City 2515 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2525 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2528 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2530 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2542 Canal Street Not Eligible Mil-City 2601 I Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2609 1 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2628 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2640 Canal Street Not Stable I Mid-City Mv. Pere Breaux July 17.2008 Page 25

2650 Canal Street Not Eligible 1 Mid-City 2661 Canal Street Not BILIS° t Mid•City 1700 even Canal Street Not Ettliae 1912-18 Canal Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2017-21 Canal Street Not Eligible i Mid-Clly 2024-30 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2216-22 Canal Street Not Eligible I Mid-City 2233-35 Canal Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2536-38 Canal Street Not Eligible f Mid-Clly i 2619-21 Canal Street Not Ell•lble i Mid-City 111 Narbi Claiborne Avenue Not Bgible I 201 North Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible I 217 North Clarborne Avenue Not Eligible 301 North Claiborne Avenue , Not Eligible 425 North Claiborne Avenue I Not Eligible 401A-C South_ Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible 405-19 North Claiborne Avenue Not Eligible a 1631 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible 1801 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1817 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible MIO-City 1925 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2030 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2204 Cleveland Avenue Nd Bottle Mid-City 2208 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2212 Cleveland Avenue Not amble i Mid-City 2224 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2428 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2620 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2634 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2101-09 i Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2322-24 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2326.28.5 Cleveland Avenue Not Eligible Mid-CIty • 1700 Conti Street Not Beible 1804 Cana Street Not =liable Mld-City 1817 Conti Street Nat Eligible Mid-City 1826 I Conti Street Not Eirible Mid-City 1904 Conti Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 1925 Conti Strom Not Eligible Mid-City 2009 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2228 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2312 I Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2316 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2326 Conti Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2410 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2525 Conti Street Not Eligible 2636 I Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2538 I Coral Street Not Brittle Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 26

2540 Conti Street : Not Eligible ! Mid-City i 2615 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City ' 2617 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2619 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2637 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2645 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1808-12 Conti Strom Not Eligible Mid-City 2411-13 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2417-19 Conti Street Not Eligible MId-City 2425-27 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2429-31 Conti Street Noi Eligible Mid-City 2433-35 Conti Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2437-39 Conti Street Not Eligible Mtd-City 316 North Derbtgny Street Not Eligible Mid-City 322 North Dortegny Street Not Eligible Mid-City 327 Norm Derbigny Street Not Eligible Mid-City 223-23 C North Derbigny Street Nol Eligibre Mid-City 329-31 ' North Demigny Street Not Eligible Mid-City 122 North Dorgenois Sireel Not Eligible MId-City 127 North Dorgenols Street Not Eligible Mid•City 135 South batwing's Street Not Eligible Mid-City 221 North Dorgenots Street Not Eligible Mid-City 322 North Doman°Is Street Not Eligible Mid-City 329 South Dorgenois Street Not Eligible MId-City 412 South Dorgan°Is Street Not Eligible Mid-City 121-23 North Dorgonois Street Not Eligible Mid-City 204-08 North [Seriphs Street Not Eligible Mid-City 215-17 9 South Dargenois Street Not Eligible Mid-City 324 A-F South Dorgenols Street Not Elicdble Mid-City 100 North Gahm &met Not Eligible Mid-City 119 North Galvez Street Not Digit* Mid-City 119 South Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 120 North Galvin Street Not Eligible Mid-City 129 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mio-Clly 141 North Gelvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 200 North Calvet Street Not Eligible Mid-City 201 North Gelvez Street Nol Eligible Mid-City 213 North Galva Street Not Eligible Mid-City 221 North Galvin Street Not Eligible Mid-City 310 South Gelvez Sheet Not Eligible Mld-Cllr 315 North Gelvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 319 South Gelvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 331 North GaNez Street Nat Eligible Mid-City 400 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mtd-City 414 North Galvin Street Not Eligible MId-Clly 432 North Gelvez Street Not EliglWe 435 Norm Galvez Street Not Eligible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17, 2008 Page 27

450 South Galvez Street Not Eligible J 455 South Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 538 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 555 South Gatvez Street Not Eligible 526 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 648 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 745 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 201-03 South Galvez. Street Nat Eligible Mid-City 239-41 South Gatvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 328-30 1 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mid-City 401-03 North Galvez Street Not Eligible Mltt•Cey 420-22 South Calvet Street Not Eligible 424-28 South Galvez Skeet Not Eligible 428.30 South Gatvez Street Not Eligible 436-38 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 508-10 South Galvez Street Not Eligible 601 (B) South Galvez Street Not Eligible I 601 (Al South Galvez Street Not Eligible ... ' 1881 Gravier Street Not Eligible Now Orleans Medical 1800 I °raider Street I Not Eligible 1900 Crevice Street Not Eligible 2020 Gravler Street Not Eligible 2025 Gravier Street I Not Eligible 2314 Greater Street Not Eligible ( Mid-City 2400 Gravler Street Not Eligible MId-Cey 2413 Greater Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2425 Gravter Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2501 Wavier Street Not Eligible Mld-City 2510 Wavier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2527 Greater Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2619 I Grassier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2641 Wavier Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2649 Gravler Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2233-35 Gravies Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2528-30 I Greater Street Not Bicible Mid-City 2635-37 Wavier Skeet Not Eligible Mid-City 2645.47 Gravler Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1804 I tberville Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1836 Mervin. Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2009 tbervale Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2011 ibervIlle Street I Not a fgible Mid-CIty 2019 there& Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2314 tbendita Street Not a IgIble Mid-City 2323 Ibervilie Street 1 Nat Eligible Mid •City 2405 'bared?* Street I Not Eillible Mid-City 2516 lbervilla Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2525 lberville Street Not Eligible Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 28

2545 lberville Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2601 lberyille Street Not Eligible. Mid•City 2604 I ibervIlle Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2624 I lberylile Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2625 iberyille Street Not Eligible Mid-Cily 1911-13 iberyille Street Not Eligible Mid-City 210 North Jonnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 214 North I Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 217 South Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City I 219 South Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 223 North Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-Oily 417 South Johnson Street Not Eligible 430 North I Johnson Street Not Eligible 435 South Johnson Street Not Eligible 127-29 North Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 128-30 Nor th Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 223-25 South Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 415-17 North Johnson Street Not Eligible , Mid-City 418-20 Nonh ' Johnson Street Not Eligible Mid-City 50Q odd South Johnson Street Not Eligible 29(11 Julia Street Not Eligible 2400 odd Julia Street Not Eligible 2036 Lafayette Street Not Eligible 2047-51 Lalayelte.Street Not Eligible 201 South Miro Street Not Eligible Mid-City 223 North Miro Street Not Eligible Mid-City 305 South Mro Street Not Eligible Mid-City 326 North Miro Street Not Eligible Mid-City 512 South Miro Street Not Eligible Mid-City 6t9 South I Miro Street Not Eligible MId-City 121-21 S North Miro Street Not Eligible I Mid-City 206-08 South Miro Street Not Eligible I Mid-City 632-34 South I Miro Street Not Eligible MId‘City 2408-10 Oak Place I Not Eligible Mid-City 2419-37 Oak Plage Not Eligible Mid-City 1827 Palmyra Street Not Eligible AM-City 1911 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2106 Palm_yra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2113 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2115 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2123 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2127 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City, 2332 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City . 2338 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2609 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2637 Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2644 Palmyra Street Not Eligible I Mid-City Ms. Pam Breaux July 17.2008 Page 29

2657 Palmyra Street Not Eligible I Mid•City 1939-39.5 Paimyra.Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2119-21 1 I Palmyra Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1523 Perdido Street Nat Eligible I New Orleans Medical 1800 Perdido Street Not Eligible 1901 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2021 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2100 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2120 I Perdido Street Not Eligible 2125 Perdido Street Nat Eligible 2126 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2130 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2300 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2310 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2427 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2429 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2431 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2505 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2507 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2525 .Perdido Street Not Eligible 2527 Perdido Street Not Eligible. 2223-27 Perdido Street Not Eligible 2050 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2056 Poydras Street Not Eligible I 2070 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2100 Poydras Street Not mi gible 2120 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2139 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2138 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2222 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2235 Poydres Street Not Eligible 2237 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2239 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2532 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2538 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2600 Poydras Street I Not Eligible 2654 Poydras Street Not Eligible 2100 odd Poydras Street Not Eligible 2200 even Poydras Street Not Eligible 128 South Prieur Street Not Eligible Mid-City 422 North Prieur Street Not Eligible Mid-City 433 North Prteur Street Not Eligible 216-18 North Pdeur Street Not Eligible Mid-City 220.22 North ['deur Street Not. Eligible Mid-City 218 North Rocheblave Street Not Eligible . Mid-City 300 South Rocheblave Street Not Eligible Mid-City 530 South Rocheblave Street t Not Eligible Mid-City Ms, Pam Breaux July 17. 2008 Page 30

1540 South Rochobleve Street Not Eligible Mid-Clly 634 South Roclieblave Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1640 South Rochebtave Street Not Eligible Mid-City 114-18 North Rootlet:gave Street Not Eligible Mid-City 318.15 North Rochebtztve Street Not Eligible Mid-City 214-16 South Rocitableve Street Notll iil Uzi liAid-Cay 315 A-F South Rochableve Street I Not Eligible i ked-C11y 324-24 A South Rochebleve Street NM Eligible Mad-City 120 North Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 120 South Roman Street Not Eligible MId-City -136 South Roman Street Not Eligible. Mid-City 201 North Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 210 i South Roman Street Not Eligible I Mid-City 218 I South Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 225 North Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 526 South Roman Street Not Eligible 228.28.5 South Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 326-28 North Roman Street Not Eligible Mid-City 400 odd South Roman Street Not Eligible 1936 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2118 Saint Louts Street Not Ekfble 2320 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2336 Saint Louis Street I Not Eligible Mid-City 2500 Saint Louis Street I Nol Eligible 2608 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2620 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2626 Saint Louts Street Not Eligible MictellY 1912.20 Saint Louis Street Nol Eligible Mid-City 2212-14 Saint Louts Street Not Eligible Mid-City 2220-22 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible Mid.City 2304 A-S Saint Louis Street Not Eligible MItl-City 211 South Tone Street Not Elicible Mid-City 313 South Tong Street Not Eligible Mid-City 409 North Tong Street Not Eligible MId-City. 614 South long Street Nol Eligible Mid-City 730 South Tont Street Not Eligible 21517 North Tong Street Not Eligible Mid-City 318-18 North Tong Street Not Eligible Mid-City 401.03 North Tont Street Not Eligible Mid-City 4054)7 North Tont) Street Not Eligible Mid-City 1635 Tulane Avenue Nor Eligible 1831 Tutees Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 1909 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2000 1ulene Avenue Not Eligible 2017 Tulane Avenue NotUgible 2100 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2122 Tubule Avenue l Not Eligible Mik Pent Btraux July 17 2008 Page 31

2201 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2222 iulano Avenue I Not Eligible Mid-City 2231 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2315 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2320 Tulane AVonuo Not Eligible Mid-City 2424 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2504 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2500 Tularie Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2601 Tulare, Avarua Net Elide Mid-City 2614 Tulare Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2642 Tulare] Avenue Not Eligible Mid•CtIV 2644 Tulane Avenue Not Eliafbie Mid-Cl 2647 Thane Avenue Not Ellgtole Mid-City 2655 Tune Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City 2855 I Tulane Avenue Not acible Ald•Ctly 3018 I Tulane Avenue I Not Eligible Mid•City 2100 Tularte Avenue Not Eligible 2104-08 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible 2323-25 Tulane Avenue Not Eligible Mid-City

FEMA has identified the following properties within the APE that may be eligible for individual listing in the NRHP. FEMA will consult with your office on the eligibility of these properties when our evaluations are ecunplete. re Address Street Dixie Brewery 2401 'Thiene Avenue Falstaff Brewery 2800 Gravier Street Orleans House 1800 I Canal Street Pump Station No. 15 2491 Palmyra lAcOonogh No. 11 236 South Neuf Street Deutsches Maus 300 South Galvez Street St. Joseph% Church 1800 Tulane Avenue Grace United Church 2001 iberville Street lAcDottogh No. 30 2228 Gravier Street k95. Pant Breaux ii k 7. ;OM Paitv

FEMA requesig the SI.IPO's concurrence on its determinations regardiuu ilie AK fur each Alternative: ilic steps has iaken w identi6. ant) cvaliuue situctures 1 ithin mcli APrE.... rind F1.-tIvIA's applicni ion or the Naiirinal Register criteria and deleentinalions of Naiional Register eligibility for standing Structures within ench APE pursuant to the 2004 Sialetvide PA.

Please corium Tish Rankin al 337) 2R I.5637 r '1 ish.liuktit.o-dsociates.dlii..diit if ijoau have any questions or need additional informal ion.

Sinceiely,

FloWurd Bush Etwiroarnentai Liaison Ofricet Federal Emergency Managernent Agency

Don Klima Advisory Council on Hisioric. Preaervation Pain Perkins. Facility Planning and Control Kathleen Schaniet 1i Deparinumt of Veierans Affairs

The FEMNSIIPO liaison concurs whit f'EMA's determination regardinv ilic API: for each Alternative: the stens FEMA has taken lo 41entiry and evaluate si:inding sinicturcs wiihin each APE; and IT MA's virtiliC Nati-nal Register criteria and deleTT1111141iUTI5 Oi National Register eligiihility 1-01 standing structures within each APE.

Juson A. Eaten-. FEMildSi1P0 Li2isnn for Areltae0100 Owe

The 51-IP0 reVietACI fix standing structures enoeurs with FE A's determination regarding ale APE for each Aliernaiive: the $ieprs FEW 1116 ialtim to identify and evaluate standing stioeture-.5 within each APE: and FEMA's application of i he National Regisivr crileria and deierinimitions of National Register eligibility for standing structures within, each APE.

klichazI V arriado. ROvitnicr d Sttildiriu Cirstauret Dale

TInoszlay. Jity 17. 2008 —a' FIN fib Una IS MOktelinfamiloi •••11.01.m. hen al Pelona] Efted 011OPS•ine.a ail a M. - .10 Itledkad Centsr of Louisiana at New Orleans 0 500 FEMAi is ps.. no, ...wan. en . met Current hle.i.NO Fatale!. (10111111.001,... %MOW Oilmnil Ivo P.0 1stAlternative: Repair In Place Feet 11••••••Shini. trar 14 °MSEL INIM noolooliNies • nl.. in.I.Or14 ...... 1“18 •0104. Its Nyasa ;aback. Dishy' ..-ries._ rAFrrLE s 4:41,44 y.er --san-aNSt.-- 3:Cil ir, .,,,_—,Sa4.. in t Loui • mitscts . IX r ; fj"." • -11- 64:Pni 0 te rv:: i di vii, — 21D 7 KS;Ir.

en OP.KP L_ ; tfir Xisj f 1 mg ):01

aibilariStENVILLE ST :iiM-1 rts.Lc AVE > - lEdik? 4 7- ' AI 4 olr "1—ILLI esTiis - . 1‘ ' SFAVILLE ST rr o' . Cffp et Central al,,,,.:: -- Business N • . , ii9isirict _ .

I . t...,.. 1 . ---..? • z , , _ aunty Hospital r. 1...... I C SElota' a tY 1 - — t c.1 CLEYCCAND AVE 1532 Tularto Avenue i—r- --.-i - I Or' IL, ;"( r t - 'It"0 a. •ZI.a i n1.. al = 31.,.. kV' 4 _n t. 0 WI •)! I Or- .. e . PALtivea St_ r 119's ...-.: id A '. •rd ' .0-'1 ' . '±- \ a :••• • .1., (Irk 4.

ca leans \ Me.dlcal- , cc -Historic-DisitieN51 -4:astr- • - - rto _ . 11‘ ,V

N ; Sister Stanislaus 34,, ' I ti 40.0 South Claiborne Avenue '.: 1-1-1;;;Cr-0ts- *de .1 r 1 I aCtitdd..;15S1----- "es: st ---sr\d-st-Jimi k illidir. ------..,r.-T7a:GALit73 ... ."------%. • f r.,..- .1..‘ 1 , i • . 1 Figure 1 - —or —.WOW inursasy, July 1?. 200e 10/1 MI OWL IA OILY Mn Cy.. ninny. Lay onisdlyyworply fenny. kw et Pecentaf Eesa AM selenium try no in ate, tn f, Medical Center at Louisiana at New Orleans 0 500 FEMA an 0•60•Orly now V? we to no .yjyy.i. 2nd Alternative: Replace Existing MCLNO Facilities Cu-rant MOJIG r nine, SWIM Orts.mok ercat.yr nAnYI Feet OaNdIPIAINS Ty and rannY on Current Silos •••••••••11norlayw sy .y11, Mk,/ TN, 4+0 re", NI. NAUllttliRbgtflW Kivivrrt :Minn

u wa• ) CONTI ST —

L - l f. • • I , r diENinue sr 0?avd!'-

2 cc - Ay scr% PILIA4gERvk IA51 • E> • - I _ Z... h...... ,‘ fL— I ;Wk. eat IriiltIE ST , __ — 1 fit I 4 1 a.....1 .... MI I I 1 • 4 .4; si=me." C , . - •-s-- —at-. 'r..casilit Sz-.1: hir ii3Aie i —r -.Lowey istItL_All ea' E — it.'T t-t ...... “._ New Orleans Public Library r 1. k 210 Loyola Avenue §,

curvy Hospital 1532 TulsaAvenue

cis:..ssrrE1141_ Siete Oft° Buildings 301 Loyola Avenue is 325 Loyola Menue

alir...fr, • .14

Figure 2 Tharsnav .1uls• 17 2008 1.10111M it tnt OM, Sop Steven •• prat* mermen ••••••••••• Non nt Potenila Ettocl inSerSay in-pining se Medical Canter of Louisiana at Now Orleans p 0 500 tinannt MCI-NO Facilites FEMA I Iftilleing insets me v..* eppeo. 11••••••••• Ikea an arw e oft ran 3rd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facallies Feet 1 Plutccal MCW10 Locninn aria Norio timeal am 1. • •Nana we 122 11/11•111002 80, ..”.••••• *isms us los ..m.tos ftacgtai Rognnr Histre Olsurt

411n :=ist7: LOUIS 57 s;:inci_oussitr- J 4 1 . •,... . 7,4401F"shi:-t- ' 51'13 •irev -4, frIaL..s. ri--;,__ rj „-,ir1/4 ,rti errieter Aveux, St 1-01715.5111191 OAK PI: i ii_c -,-:_*---nNymber.,. - ,L. FL-a ___„ , :9;:.;r) Nil cr 1 ea rre- .. , 17; 11n*.en sil-- lil•tti SL Louis Cemetery No. 2 • 1,u-, >. • ',7, ' fly 1600 St. Louis Strom w S , k -.. . IN7711 Ls B'ENVI(tC AVE i13-17-41,14"M CI 0 ' • 1".?7- l ; 11 71" ...'IBERVILLE Si a ID . Pen American 12 11 T. --cg Eltiltung n r 4.'- , • • > _ 2400 Canal Streel 1 1 • , ID I • .- 4 4.T..- is . i 4 __ „...... ---:.* _ CANALyST L , 'dr ../ IT - Lower; Central'. c re./NOWSTI • i • ; . - • - - I Me, - • Char:4y Hospital r,,,N a.Busines5Djst r 1-7-1 ;17 - 1 A,. , tlsr . k . ty__Miflegjtyl 7 1 11 11 1111:11 VI ;Pit3 - li •• :A "VW iStorics.: -•1•-.7„. _ •-• • 7 • /7 f —CLEVE/AND AVE 4 ii,f. t ilt- 4 L t ....1 1.;44' Districts. is., 4L.44.1 lait arm • - • L:r0Weritentrc I tel ± 1*. ii ta SL '-•::,:thititAit ," — 2--;., Busine4s: Di strictu to ;IL., .4, 1„ ; •_,..._i o • 4,.. e, 0.,44 , ,..z.;_ you n rtc:ilnreaseec :2e4-„,t-t,I. -,,,..... 4 • l' . - 4.4.' ,, I * . -. • : 811:c W Ctify-4a c . OrIpans\ • Ilitatar •.rop.—. 0 Lit McilicalL - r-- ii- :r. '' g .,- -- - ;o"' - i Hit-,toriabistiict>t, p— •-• r In * '6 ' 1.4 NI Se - 4-11 a, • •11 Yi r)or: ;Alli:H eit 1lik : r e -tit"; ate _ • a•L: t,4

Sis or Stirtslaus 450 South CUdbame Avenue lost

HOWARD AVE Figure 3

MiICIII.LL J. LANPRIEU date of Eouisionn PAM OREM.. LieUTCNANT GovEamon OFFICE OF THE LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR AserecTiutv DEPARTMENT OF CULTURE. RECREATION & TOURISM OFFICE OF CULT MULL DEVELOPMENT

August 5, 2008

Mr. Howard R. Bush Environmental Liaison Officer U.S. Department of Homeland Security FEMA-DR-160311607-LA Louisiana Transitional Recovery Office One Seine Court New Orleans, LA 70114

Re: Request for SHPO Concurrence Medical Cenrerof Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) Area of Potential Effects (APE) and National Register of Historic Places (NItH11 Determination of Eligibility Assessment New Orleans, Orleans Parish, LA

Dear Mr. Bush:

Thank you for your letter of July 17, 2008 that we received July 23, 2008. concerning the above-referenced undertaking. We concur with your assessment of the provisional APEa for the following MCLNO Alternatives. noting that all were acsraart based on a list of assumptions that included issues such as elevation visual effect, construction vibration, staging areas, and demolition that were discussed at our informal meeting on July 9, 2008, and at the meeting with the consulting panics on July 23. We would also note that our assumptions were made less certain at the consultation meeting on July 23, when representatives of MCLNO stated that they could not give any particulars on the scope of their project.

We recap, below, the-three alternative approaches to the project, the provisional APE l'ot each, mid the assumptions for each. The scope of each provisional APE is understood to speak to buildings only, with archaeological resource issues to be worked out separately.

a' 0 @Oh 114?-iti I BATON liCktiag, LOUISIANA 7011.64-443117 • PRONE c2.15/ 3.11Z-PEO0 • FAX 1E2E1 21111-11172 • TYWV1.0ftT.C.TATE.L.A.I.It. AN ;RIMS OPPUITTURITT ElipLoyrn Mr. !toward R. Bush August 5.2008 Page 2

L. Alternative I—Repair MCLNO in Place: the provisional APE for this alternative is the existing footprint of the MCLNO campus as illustrated in Figure 1 (see attachment). Assumptions for Alternative I's Provisional APE: n. No pile driving. b. No ground clearance in staging area. c. Controlled range of vibration associated with repair/construction, to be agreed upon through subsequent consultation.

2. Alternative 2—Replace Existing MCLNO Facilities on the Existing Site: The provisional APE for this alternative includes the existing MCLNO campus as well as those blocks bounded by the 1-10 elevated Interstate, Poydras Street, Loyola Avenue and Cleveland Avenue, as illustrated in Figure 2 (see attachment), Assumptions for Alternative 2's Provisional. APE: a. Wholesale demolition of MCLNO in its entirety. b. Staging areas are included within APE. c. New construction limited to 20 stories in height d. Controlled range of vibration associated with replacementkonsunction, to be agreed upon through subsequent consultation

3 Alternative 3—Construct Replacement Facilities: FEMA's applicant has identified the area bounded by South Claiborne Avenue, Tulane Avenue, South Galvez Street and Canal Street ss n feasible she for the construction of replacement facilities. The provision"! APE for this alternative is bounded by the Broad Street overpass, St. Louis Street, North Robertson Street, South Robertson Street, Tulane Avenue, the 1-10 elevated Interstate, and the boundaries of the New Orleans Medical Historic District, as illustrated in Figure 3 (see attatirment). Assumptions for Alternative 3's Provisional APE: a. Controlled range of vibration associated with new construction, to be agreed upon through subsequent consultation. b. New construction limited to six stories in height. c. If historic properties were moved from the APE to other locations, the receiving locations would constants part of Noe Provisional APE.

In reference to the determination of'eligibility of NRI-IP historic districts and properties Individually eligible for or listed in the NRIIP, weconcur with FEMA's assessment with one exception. For the properties listed under Alternative 1: Repair MCLNO in Place, one MCLNO building is located within the boundary of the Mid-City National Register District. As such, the Mit1•City National Register District should be added to the list of historic properties. Mr. Hower-dB_ Bush August 5, 20011 Page 3

Finally, w regard to the nice prop ea within Altmann 3 that a id tiff as perhaps being eligible for individ112/ list rig in the NREEPove look forward to the opportunity to diacuss that subject with you in the Dear hum,

It you have any questions, please contact Mike Varnado in the Division of Hisrorrio Preservation tit (225) 2 t 9-4596.

Si n c EY-6y,

RI bt-rt Collins rtcputy slim Kistoric Pm9ervation Officer

RC:MV:s cc by email: Secretary Pain Breaux Assissarit Secretary Scort fluichesou Pam Perkins. Facility Miming and Control John Ketchum, FEMA Letitia Rankin, FEW Don Klink Advisory Council cc Historic Prescrvotion }Wry Harris, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Jeff Durbiu. Advisory CGIEriCil on Hi! ric Preterva rico Ctursaiting Parties DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Office of Construction & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

September 9, 2008

Robert Collins Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer Office of Cultural Development 1051 N. 3c° Street Baton Rouge, LA 70802

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans, LA Lindy Boggs Alternative, New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana

Dear Mr. Collins

As a result of damages from Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, the Department of Veterans Affairs will replace the healthcare facilities comprising the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) located in New Orleans, LA. The replacement of healthcare facilities is viewed as vital to the city and region's overall recovery and improvement because of the central role this hospital plays in the health and safety of all area residents.

VA is consulting with the Louisiana State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) regarding the three alternatives previously identified for this phase. The VA seeks to add an alternative, the Lindy Boggs site, The Lindy Boggs site consists of an approximately 40 acre site of multiple city blocks loosely bounded by Bienville Avenue, North Jefferson Davis Parkway, Toulouse Street and North Solomon Street. VA has determined previously the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each Area of Potential Effect (APE) and has consulted on those eligibility determinations. VA will consult with the State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) regarding the delineation of APEs for areas in which archeological properties may be affected as well as identification and evaluation of archaeological properties in a subsequent step of the Section 106 review.

This letter requests SHPO's concurrence on VA's determinations regarding the proposed APE for the Lindy Boggs Site as we discussed in person on August 5th, the National Register eligibility of standing structures located within each APE as discussed with Ms. Valerie Gomez on August Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 2

Proposed Area of Potential Effect

The proposed APE for the Lindy Boggs site is bounded by Orleans Avenue, Bayou St, John, North Rendon Street, Canal Street, North Scott Street, lberville Street, and North Hennessey Street as illustrated in Figure I. It also includes the existing VAMC building (not shown).

The APE is based on the assumptions that new construction will not exceed six (6) stories in height, the existing Lindy Boggs hospital will be not be utilized and will be demolished, there will no excessive vibratory effect, and the existing VAMC will no longer function as a hospital facility.

Historic Structure Identification and Evaluation

The proposed APE contains portions of the Parkview Historic District and the Mid-City Historic District,

Eligble National Register Districts 1 District Date Boundaries Parkview 1995 bounded roughly by City Park Avenue, Bayou St. John, Orleans Avenue, Rocheblave Street, Lafitte Street, and St. Louis Street Mid-City 1993 bounded roughly by Derbigny Street, Conti Street, City Park Avenue, and 1-10

VA has determined that the following properties with the APE contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District.

Address Direction Street District 509 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NM 601 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 605 A-B-C- D North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 606 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 609 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 610 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 614 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 618 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 620 North Carrot Iton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 621.23 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 625.27 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 629-31 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NUM Mr. Collins September 4, 2008 Page 3

Address Direction Street District 630 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 633-35 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 636 North ...__ Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 644 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 700-02 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 708-10 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 729 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 731 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 637/4100 A- Carrollton Avenue/St. Peter B North Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 623 North Cortez Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 636 North Cortez Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 500-02 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 503 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 504-06 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 503-07 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 512 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 513 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 515-17 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 516-18 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-[D 520-22 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 610 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 612-14 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 613 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 616-18 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 621 David Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 604-06 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 610 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 618-20 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 634-36 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 638 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD _642 North Hennessey Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 4

Address Direction Street District 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3700 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRI-1D 3738-40 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3814 Orlea.ns Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3816-18 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3820 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3824-26 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3828-30 Orleans Avenue CCar~trihutes to Parkview NRHD 3832 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3836-38 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3840-42 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3904-06 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3908-10 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3912-14 Orleans Avenue • Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3916-18 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3920-22 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4000 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4008-10 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4014 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4166-68 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4170-72 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4176 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4182 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4186 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4190 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4192-94 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4200-02 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview N111-113 4206-10 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4212-14 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4216-18 . Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4220-22 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4226 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4228-30 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4232 Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD Orleans Avenue Contributes to Parkview NRHD 614-16 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 618-20 North Pierce Street Contributes to ParkviewNRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 5

Address Direction Street District 619-21 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 622-24 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NR}-ID 625 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 626-28 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRIID 627-29 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 632-34 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 635-37 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 636-38 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 639 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 640-42 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 644 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 650-52 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NMI) 654-56 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 658-60 North Pierce Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4117-19 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4118 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4121 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD

4122 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4125-27 Saint Peter Street J Contributes to Parkview NR1-1D 4126 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 4129-31 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview 'NM) 4130 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NNW 4134-36 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4138-40 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 4142-44 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4143-45 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview MUM 4 [46-48 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4147-49 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 4150-52 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4154-56 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4170 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4]74-76 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4178-80 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4182-84 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4186-88 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4200 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4206 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4210 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 6

• Address Direction Street — District 4214 Saint Peter Street .. Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4220 Saint Peter Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 617 North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 619-21 North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NR1-ID 623-25 . North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 627-29 North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 633 North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NM-ID 700-02 North Scott Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 502 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 508 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 510 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 514 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 516 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 601 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD _ 607 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 616-18 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 617 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 621 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 622 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 626-32 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 638 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 711 A-13 North Solomon Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 3901-03 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3905-07 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3909-11 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3913 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3917-19 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3921-23 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3925-27 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3929-31 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3933 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 3937 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4005 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD .4113-15 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4117 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4119-21 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4123 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRI-ID 4129 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 7

Address Direction Street District 4135 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4139-41 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4142-44 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4143-45 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4146 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4147-49 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4150-52 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4151-53 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4154-56 A- B Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4155 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4158-60 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4159-61 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRJ-ID 4165 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4168 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4169-71 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4172 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4173-75 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4177-79 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD 4221 Toulouse Street Contributes to Parkview NRHD

Address Direction Street District 3300 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3301 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3304-06 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3305-07 Bienville Avenue _Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3317-19 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3320 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3323 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3330-32 A Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3336 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3340 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3420-22 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3424-26.5 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3428-30 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3432-34 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3636 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NAND 3710 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3712 Bienville Avenue _ Contributes to Mid-City NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 8

Address Direction Street District 3716 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3720 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3722 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3730 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NM-1D 3806-08 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3810-12 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3826-28 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3830-32 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 3834-36 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NM-1D 3838-40 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3900-02 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3904 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3908-10 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3912 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3916-18 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3920-22 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3924-26 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3932-34 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3936 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4144-46 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4148 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4152-54 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4158 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4160-62 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4164-66 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4168-70 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4172-74 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4176 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4200-02 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4210 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4214 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4222 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4226 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4230 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NM-1D 4238 Bienville Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3517 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3527 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3601-03 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3609 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3631 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NM-1D 3701 Canal Street _Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3715-17 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 3723 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3727 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NM-1D Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 9

Address . Direction Street District ,_3731 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3827 Canal Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 200 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NR1-11D 208- I 0 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 214 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 220 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 320 North Carrollton Avenue Contributes to Mid-c_ityL',11:1HD 117-19 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 121-23 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 125-27 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 129-31 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 133-35 North Clark Street Contributes to M id-City NRHD 137 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 200-02 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 204-06 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 208-10 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 216-18 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 221 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NR1-1D 233-35 North Clark Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3300 Conti Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3304-06 Conti. Street Contributes to Mid-City NR.1-11D 118 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 120-22 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 124-26 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 130-32 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 131-33 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 135-37 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD I 38 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 213-15 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 219-21 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 220-22 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 602 North Cortez Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-1D 200-02 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 204-06 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 208-10 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 212-14 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 219-21 illill=11111.1.11EMMIC.MiDavkl Street Cor 222 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 223-25 David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 227-29 L David Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 115 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-CityNREID 123 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NM 124-26 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 125-25.5 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 10

Address Direction Street District 128 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 129-31 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 133-35 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 139 North Genois Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3313-13,5 !ben/ilk Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 3315 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3319-21 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-Ci NRI-1D 3320-22 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3323-25 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-1D 3324-26 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3328-30 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3419-21 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3420-22 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-Ci NRHD 3421-23.5 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3424-26 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-Ci NRHD 3428-28 A Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3501-03 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3520 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3601-03 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 3605-07 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3609-11.5 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3613-15 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3617-19 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3622-24 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NEM 3625 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3631 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3701 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3705 lberville Street Contributes Co Mid-City NRHD 3711 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3715 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3717-19 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3721 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3722-24 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3731 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3737 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3805-07 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-1D 3809-11 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3821-23 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-CitzNRHD 3829 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 1835 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3909-11 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3917-19 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD _ 3921 A-C 1 lberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 3925-27 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD Mr, Collins September 9, 2008 Page 12

Address Direction Street District 133-35 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 137-39 A North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 201 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 207 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NR 1D 211 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NR1-1D 215 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-CityNRI-1D 219 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 315-17 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-Ct NRI-113 331-33 B North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 215 North Scott Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD_ 217-19 North Scott Street _ Contributes to Mid-City NR[-(D 214 r North Solomon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 216 North Solomon Street , Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 222 North Solomon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 120 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City ]NRHD 131 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 134-36 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 137 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI:ID 140 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD I42 North - Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 146-48 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 212 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRI-ID 215 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 217 North Telemachus Street Contributes to Mid-City NREID

VA has determined that the following properties within the APE do not contribute to a listed or eligible National Register Historic District nor are they individually eligible for listing in the

Address Directio n Street Determination 3308 13ienville Avenue Not Eligjble 3313 Bienvi I le Avenue Not Eligible 3328 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3333 Bienyille Avenue Not Elible 3402 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3522-24 Bienville Avenue _Not Eligible 3702 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3708 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3800 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3816 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 3822 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible 4000 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible _4136 Bienville Avenue Not Eligible Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 11

Address Direetion Street District 4001-03 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 400507 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4009-11 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4017-19 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-Ci . NRHD 4021 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4133-35 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4137-39 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4143-45 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4149 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4151 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4163-65 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City N111-1D 4201 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-Cite NRHD 4205 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4215 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-gy_NRI-ID 4217-19 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4227 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4231-33 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 4235-37 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NUR) 4239-41 Iberville Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 122-24.5 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 126-28 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NEED 130-32 A North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 134-40 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 135 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 200-02 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 201 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 208-10 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City' NRHD 213-15 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 214 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 216-18 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 217-19 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 221 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 224-28 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 225 North Jefferson Davis Parkwa Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 316-18 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 320-22 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City N111-110 326 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Contributes to Mid-City NEED 204-04.5 North Pierce Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 212 North Pierce Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 213-15 North Pierce Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 214-16 North Pierce Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 224 North Pierce Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHI) 125 North Rendon Street Contributes to Mid-City NRHD 129-31 North Rendon Street i_ Contributes to Mid-City NRHD Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 13

Address Direction Street Determination 4142 Bienville Avenue Not Eli • ible 4234 Bienville Avenue Not Eli_ible 3301 Canal Street Not Eli_ible 3309 Canal Street Not Eligible 3401 Canal Street Not Eli .ible 3501 Canal Street Not Eli:ible 3535 Canal Street Not Eli:ible 3625 Canal Street Not Eli:ible 3637 Canal Street Not Eli ible 3801 Canal Street Not Eli:ible 201 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eligible 206 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli ible 215 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli ible 216 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli• ible 231 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli:ible 232 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli:ible 232 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli_ible 330 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli ible 527 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli:ible 600 North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli ible 601D North Carrollton Avenue Not Eli:ible 212-14 North Clark Street Not Eli_ible 3310 Conti Street Not Eli_ible 3314-16 Conti Street Not Eli ible 216 North Cortez Street Not Eli tible 508 David Street Not Eli:ible 509 David Street Not Eli:ible 608 David Street Not Eli • ible 223 North Genois Street Not Eli_ible 229 North Genois Street Not Eliible 622 North Hennesse Street Not Eli:ible 3522-36 Iberville Street Not Eli lible 3635 Iberville Street Not Eli • ible 3727 Iberville Street Not Eli:ible 4161-61-5 Iberville Street Not Eligible 120 North Jefferson Davis Parkway Not Eli:ible 209-11 North Jefferson Davis Parkwa Not Eli:ible 330-36 North Jefferson Davis Parkwa Not Elitible 3600 Orleans Avenue Not Eli:ible 3806 Orleans Avenue Not Eli:ible 3924 Orleans Avenue Not Eli:ible 4004-06 Orleans Avenue Not Eli. ible 4134 Orleans Avenue Not Eli ible 4140 Orleans Avenue Not Eli ible Mr. Collins September 9, 2008 Page 14

Address Direction Street Determination 220 North Pierce Street Not Eligible 651 North Pierce Street Not Eligible 223 North Rendon Street Not Eligible 4149 Saint Louis Street Not Eligible 4157 _ Saint Louis Street Not Eligible 4226A Saint Peter Street Not Eligible 635 North Scott Street Not Eligible 132 North Telemachus Street Not Eligible 145 North Telemachus Street Not Eligible 3501 Toulouse Street Not Eligible 4001 Toulouse Street Not Eligible 4114 Toulouse Street Not Eligible _ 4136 Toulouse Street Not Eligible 4176 Toulouse Street Not Eligible 4225-27 Toulouse Street Not Eligible 4241 Toulouse Street Not Eligible

VA has identified one property within the APE that may be eligible for individual listing in the NRHP. VA will consult with your office on the eligibility of this property when our evaluations are complete.

VA requests the SHPO's concurrence on its determinations regarding this APE for the Lindy Boggs Alternative; the steps VA has taken to identify and evaluate standing structures within each APE; and VA's application of the National Register criteria and determinations of National Register eligibility for standing structures within this APE.

Please contact me at (202) 461-8254 or [email protected] if you have any questions or need additional information.

Sincerely,

Kathleen Scharnel Federal Preservation Officer U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

Cc: Don Klima, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation John Ketchum, Federal Emergency Management Agency 0

fJ 0 0 ea

Proposed Lindy Boggs Foolprinls and Area of CI Lindy Boggs Footprints Lirroy Boggs Area of Potential Effect PoMoho! Elrod with Asscciarsd NRHP Parkview Historic OWCricl Cri Mid-City Hien:sic District Historic Districts. DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Office of Construction & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

September 9, 2008

Robert Collins Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer Department of Culture, Recreation & Tourism P.O. Box 44:47 Baton Rouge, LA 70804

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs New Orleans Medical Campus (VAMC) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans, LA

Dear Mr. Collins,

Thank you for your letter of August 5, 2008. concerning the above-referenced undertaking. We again thank you for your patience regarding the Lindy Boggs alternative. Your office has been most kind.

VA apologizes for any irregularities in our letter to you dated July 17, 2008. You are correct in your understanding of the assumptions of the provisional APEs for the previously discussed alternatives. For the sake of clarification:

• VA agrees that the New Orleans Public Library is not an individually listed NRHP property but a contributing element of the Lower Central Business District. • VA agrees that the New Orleans City Hall, 1300 Poydras Street, is within the boundaries of the APE for the first alternative and is considered by SHPO and FEMA as eligible for listing in the NRHP. • VA agrees that the existing VAMC, located at 1601 Perdido Street, is a contributing element of the New Orleans Medical Historic District. • VA agrees that the APE for Alternative 3 is encompassed by: the Broad Street overpass, St. Louis Street, North Robertson Street, South Robertson Street, Tulane Avenue, the elevated 1-10, and the boundaries of the New Orleans Medical Historic District.

Furthermore, it has come to our attention that in a warehouse in the Ochsner Site is a National Register listed steam locomotive. If the Ochsner Site is chosen, the warehouse will no longer be a suitable location for its storage. VA will be sure to allow the owner of the locomotive ample time to find a new facility for the storage of the locomotive. Mr. Robert Collins September 9, 2008 Page 2

Thank you again for your patience. Please contact me at (202) 4614254 or Kathleen.Schame12(74 va.gov if you have any questions or need additional information.

Sincerely,

L1--sa.-,..,-...'C/- ' -""-• Kathleen Scharriel Federal Preservation Officer U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

Cc by email: John Ketchum, FEMA Laetitia Rankin, FEMA Kathy Baumgaertner, FEMA Howard Bush, FEMA Don Klima, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Katry Harris, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Jeff Durbin, Advisory Council Qn Historic Preservation us. Dtpartinunt of Itontclanc1 Security Fedual Entergcncy Martagrrnent Agency FEMA-14503/1107-Dik-LA Lesbians Transitional Runway Office tr0 Poplin's St. 14th Root Errifitinmental Ns+ Orkarrt. Leona 70130 FEMA

November 14, 2008

Scott Hutcheson State Historic Preservation Officer Office of Culture Recreation and Tourism Post Office Box 44247 Baton Rouge, LA 70804

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Medical Center or Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. New Orleans, LA Applicant: Louisiana Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control

Dear Mr. Hutcheson:

Ina letter dated July 17, 2008. FEMA sought concurrence from your office regarding Areas of Potential Effect (APEs) for the above referenced Undertaking and identified historic standing structures contained within those APEs. During the identification and evaluation process, FEMA and our co-lead federal agency, the US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), determined that some areas within the Mid-City National Register Historic District (NRIID) had sustained loss of integrity due to demolitions and renovations associated with Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. FEMA and VA requested an evaluation of the Mid-City NRHD by the Keeper of the National Register of Historic Places (Keeper). The Keeper's evaluation resulted in recommended changes to the existing boundary of the district to reflect loss of integrity of the NR1iD since its inclusion in the NRHP in 1993. A map of the district indicating the Keeper's recommendations is attached,

FEMA has re-evaluated the buildings within the APE for the New Construction alternative that fall outside of the Keeper's recommended boundaries of the Mid-City NRIID (see attachments). Thirty-four (34) buildings were identified in our July 17 letter as contributing to the district that now lie outside of the Keeper's recommended boundaries. These buildings are listed below:

Address Street 'I 1723 Blenville Avenue 2 1729 I Blenville Avenue 3 1731-33 BlenvIlle Avenue 4 1800 Canal Street 5 1838 Canal Street 6 1805.07 I Cleveland Avenue 7 1808-10 Cleveland Avenue 8 1809-11 Cleveland Avenue Paw art

9 2025-27 Conn Street 10 2410 1 Gravier Street 11 2414 Gravier Street 12 2416 Crawler Street 13 2506 Gravier Sung 14 2518 I Grower Street 15. 2524 Gravier Street 16 2544 Gravier Street 17 2601 Grower Street 18 2420.22 Gravier Street 19 2432-34 Gravier Street 20 2865-61 Gravier Street 2' 1823 Palmyra Street 22 1837 Palmyra Street 2.3 1829-31 Palmyra Street 24 1914-16 Palmyra Sliest 25 2028-30 Palmyra Street 26 536 South Broad Avenue 27 131 South Derbigny Street 28 325 South Johnson Street 29 613 South Rocheblave Street 30 613 South Rollettleve Street 31 615-17 South Rocheblave Street 32 641.43 South Rocheblave Street 33 301 South Roman Street 34 303.05 South Roman Street

Of the 34 buildings, FEMA has determined that one building, 1800018AI Street is eligible rot listing in die National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) FEMA will seek your concurrence with this finding in a subsequent tenet. None of the renaming 33 buildings meets the criteria of significance required for Individual listing to ihe NRHP. FEMA requests ccncurrence from your orrice wish our determinniion mat thew 33 buildings are no longer Historic Properties for ilte purposes of this thutenakintr. Should need additional infonnation. please contact fist, Rankin at 133712815637 or I ish Rankincrianuciniesilhs.vot

Sincerely, \ I r„, .w...... 1..... 1 ." .S. Roy I/Environmental Liaison Officer FEMA-DR- I 603-LA. FEMA-13R-1607

Attachments re4 kailiteen Schainel. t 1S Depanment of Veterans Affairs Don Filima, Adviwiy council on Historic Preservation Pam Perkins. Louisiana Division of Administration, Department of Facility Planning and Control nillifITO.O. 4..I IV Contra Pebitay &seal' 4r, • a...... Ss. 11.1%.••• WAS* 3%.1.1••• al las wra .• oo N 2 • ft. CD .TO 0.114.11.0 1.1001 INM.O AM.. torsta..• Mid-City Historic District tAtI•Cti Mast: D'm *saes. imago M...... is naiad summons*, on %a I dp.114.1 SOW II "Ton nano - I hiroLer CO.at Do Panowairtit anon wr Showing Results of National Park Service Recommendations el Hari, a pub% September 23.2008 PAS-7,-Calkl In InSectallf bared 0 0.26 DR4A 903 rre us Inn Ccnsmeion Arrest 8V• aim PTO Atnenver•

:go - I i • .Ni Is viii_ , in' rip _.±1. _t it fl a: z_Ti t.

1•••••••=1.111MMII• I.J.111•11••••••••••IMIMV.M...... a.,.....ni •••• *VT, MP -,14741 Mid-City Historic District Plis F EM A INS • 41.• Showing Results of National Park Service Recommendations October 29, 2008 v.,

I 1 Si LOWS ST H •

i r l Ks.ssisja r ____ Q?. , —4 nl , 4

! FT IIj sANALsr MOM 111W

21111111 Mir 11 IllllIllIl 11111111 1111111111L 111;11111 = 111111111 F-11 1rt .1111111111%111111111

110 A ; I I I - I k of Potentitaba. 1.1tiow Cembliden Mame* keit- 1( tAtIsy_trrk LW Wee. Su Cowl 65Ge6et Szrxtar) 7 110C.4yra..tocnt *1= Da 10 I be ifteirall4S11. Irteptp IA al In WM:1a* Liond ift,POWTPWAFRAIN „ xnansr l`sammt- ‘ Re-Evaluation of Notional Rafstor nosed on Nalienal Park ServIce Be Ur? d.a•rlit Razornmondall ns LE-.1.-••••=•-• •I• 0130beir 29. 2004 Vt.

T„ 11110 rdonviOlorrmue

I I 131 Sloth 130Flgrr 11000

1547 011ReAdraNtlemt

tiraLit CMIMMLIVIONL 11113.0.1 L 0:15.01 MEOW/goo" 53B 51 41 Rim Aulopapp

#01111 Grgyair llgel

tOixr1 Gaily Mea I 2410 000501r Ali tit0N 4. 00■01 „- 1 tStf, artroar ▪ Formilf • Fornriii, tempo,. la %ION a 4114* 0 weir alltpnl. YA LL4C .PGIJt3reN4rs 20[11 Ilia~ i M l 10.14:14.11.0.1Truagru 013 Soulli 110;110bilve 3izeb4 • P.IL-01).-4.11ribs. orruv74.1,111.. 41 111194111 wow P.I.PCIFV-C.441.4.11+12,+01.114 “444irom

irTi ZOICA MIC4 IAN11,11 4 ,o

44 I d1 134a1M poalYlQlIor 9inZ1 US. Dcpannitto of Homeland Security Frdesal Emergency Management Agency FEMA-160311607-0R-LA Louisiana Trainload Recowny Office 1150 Poydru Si.. Idth Floor Ernimommod New Orleans. Louirinna70130 FEMA

November 14. 2008

Scott Hutcheson State Historic Preservation Officer Office of Culture Recreation and Tourism Post Office Box 44247 Baton Rouge. LA 70804

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. New Orleans, LA Applicant: Louisiana Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control

Dear Mr. Hutcheson:

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) will be providing funds authorized under the Robert T Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act, P.L. 93-288, as amended, in response to the following major Disaster Declarations;

1) FEMA-DR-1603-LA, dated August 29, 2005, as amended 2) FEMA-DR-1607-LA, dated September 23, 2005.

In a letter dated July 17, 2008, FEMA sought concurrence from your office regarding Areas of Potential Effect (APBs) for the above referenced Undertaking and identified historic starding structures contained within those APES. FEMA has conducted evaluations of eight buildings within the APE for Alternative 3: Construct Replacement Facilities to determine whether they meet criteria for individual listing in the National Register of lEstoric Places. These buildings am listed below:

Building Name Address Street Dixie Btewes y 2401 Tulare Avenue Falstaff Brewery 2600 Grainer Street Orleans House 1800 Canal Street McDonogh No. 11 236 South Pi eur Street Deutsches Haus 200 South Galvez Street St. Joseph's Church 1800 Tulane Avenue Grace United Church 2001 Melville Street McDonogh No. 30 2228 Gray's!. Street fake 2 tkienvaiinhont uC Llugathidi 4 fitowimi

FEN1A Zia deterrnirpect that all of die elabt butldirto pos,sess the le} ei orsignificance required for idual listing in dm National Register of Historic. Places Dctermlnations for each or 'Huse build1ng5 airing ',yob plrotoeraphs and maps are ailaCked ror your reviuve • F E MA l'eqUe5IS concurrence riLoin your orrice ilia! drew baileinasara kir living Register rrc lititoric Notre& Should you raced additional information. pleasil contact I oda Rankin. at 5.37) 2a 1.5637 or TiATLERkill wit 2{11r

Sou

r Y are S Rny Iinviverunetnal L-iit snix Officer TEMA-DR-103-1.A. FENIA-DR-140

Altac111111CP15

. Katiiken Schantel_ US Dcpartzent of Veterans A ITairs DOn Klima. Advisory C'otincit co I•ligtoric Prcnrvation Pam Pmitins. toitkiatia Dist, WOO or Administratim. Depanmeol Pim i lit5 Planning and Centrol Description A. six-story trrick building w-ith white stone trim, nattnd arches, a C4r1137iI Mansard dome, atld 4 Cfairr kurct, Dixie Brewery was tlesiett by William 111211.0 - rhino- was a Gernian-buni architect °Clive in New OrleAus in the tniv ftitaeicerat century. responsible for several ornate amble shotguns in the veil?, as welt U3 the Weekerting Brewery., formerly located at Magazine and C.enip Streets. Dixie Brewery is arse of the rwo extant buildings from the city's early 20I1 century brewery district, The properly Ilea been erribtotlect in litigation said the building sits abandoned hind W07: I Morey

By 1908 the Dixie brewery assumed the basis of rite modern shape, 'Die origniul Lf-shaped atriicture ranging from 1 story along its Banks Street ;.ilde to 15 stones lacing Tulrate has undergone few alterations. A struilI atm. repair shop wes added eking the north side by IWO and expanded by 1051 Also by 1951 a series of small structures were attached to the inner sides of the ehapc. A 1-titury structure constructed for bottle storage by 1.940 along the. Ettichenlave side of the Mick woo renovorl within the following decade (Sanborn Fire Insurance rvharil.

The mast prominent afteranon to the site is on the north side of the structure along Tulane Avenue. A bottling facility ranging betw{:en I *ad 2 stories wan added at that location by 1940. By 05 I. the bottling facility was expanded along the Tulane side of the block to tlxe Rochebtave iniersectiou, a move that coincided with the raineval of the recently added bottle eitoragtitheility (Sanborn Fire Insurance Nlitpil).

Before Katrina and subsequent looting, lire Dixie Brewery possessed snme poniculutly unique elements, The beer was brewed in a large, solid-copper kettle (that Wear Disney emulated rot its Inewpuh in Disney World, Orlando, Florida) and fermented in a row of open cypress iwrks. The building iiho spored large grain silos on the roof pain led to look like Dixie Beer cans {]Brand 2007).

History The history of beer brewing in New Orleans follows the trajectory of the multinal Acme* the nation, brewing emerged itS an industrial concern and came increasingly under Ilse control or large producers from the end of the Civil War until the 1890s, According to tit least one hictorten New Orleans introduced the use of artificially manufactured ice to the brewing process In the late 1860s (Stack 2000;440). With the emergenta of tile twentieth century, local sad' regional brawaries .gainod a firm foothold, often by expanding from their own saloons and ilium-us, mei) pH/110,11km ricse.pd ail Intl Ihe largest breweries out of business (Stook 2U00436)

Beer brewing was a thriving industry in New Orleans for almost 100 years. Samuel and Louis Faanneht. Swiss immigovas, kicked all the industry in the Crescent City In 11152 (Breerwood 2006). The city's brewery district grew steadily (Toni the inid-nititteenth to the aarly-rwenileth cennity, largely centered around Tulane Avenue, Valentine Mum who Lame into the beer brewing bitsisiess as n saloon keeper, opened Dixie Brewery on Halloween of 1907 (Thomas 2006: Living I), The Brewery, ono of ihineen operating in the ray. thrived land Fraihilion. but managed to reinvent itself as the Dixie Brewing Company and produce non-alcoholic beverages until the re tirriarlarherii wax repealed irn 1913, A* Ilse: beer business became increasingly competitive in the mid-2011' ceoluty. ell the eity's breweries shut down with the exception of Dixie. Though h survived pirnhitiitiona Dixie was in rinauciel Unable by the i970s, especially after a tainted haith of titer went OW to ihe public ever the Fourth of July weekend in 1975.

Joe Emir' Kendra Bruno stepped to and purchased the ailing business ni 1985, The Broom sei oltmrt righting the debt-ndrien eittetprise, Taking advantage of the lieginaing of the craft Mid Tnicrokyrew trend they released a new hers that many credit with having saved the brewer)+, Dixie Blackened Voodoo Lager_ Following the success of this new line Dixie turned oui a landfill of caw trine/111y ieeinii-ne.cl

Delnymiralion agibility Dixie Breverrr Pago I of 3 new beers To stabilize its market Dixie moved into the production of soil drinks alongside hs beer and by 2000 produced a popular root beer (Reid 20(30).

To some, Dixie has come to symbolize the city. In Isle 1990. Dixie became the first American-produced beer sold in the Soviet Union. The Brunos noted that overseas identification of the brand with the renowned Crescent City was what gave than this unique opportunity (Modern Brewery Age. 12 November 1990).

Dixie remained a functioning brewery and business until Hurricane Katrina (McNulty 2007). Until the storm Dixie was one of the few remaining regional breweries remaining in the South, Although the brewery is nu longer used to produce Dixie, there are plans to do so. Until that time, the Brunos meet local and nationwide demand for the distinctive beer though a conlnict arrangement with Minhus Craft Brewery of Wisconsin.

Eligibility Recommendation Dixie Brewery has been nominated as a Local Landmark by die Historic District Landmarks Commission. The building has been identified as a "Selected i andrnzirk" within the Mid-City National Register Historic District nomination. Dixie Brewery is eligible for the National Register applying Criterion A: Industry n part of New Orleans' brewing past of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries The property is also eligible for the National Register under Criterion C: Architecture as an example or Romanesque Revival architecture applied to an industrial form, wilh its heavy brick arches, massive tower, and banks of windows. While Dixie hos accrued a number of historic additions, they are not as significant, nor as iconic, as the main block with the massive tower and Mansard dome that is recognized across New Orleans.

Determination of Eligibility: Dixie Brewery Page 2 of 3 Works Cited

Brand. WiPram 2007 Column on visit to New Orleans and Dixie Beer. 7 November, Who/ on Tap. Available online at linp://www.ibab272_corafbeer.2007fl1/07k-columa-about-new-oriearis-aud-dkie-beer. Accessed online OA l August 2008.

Breerwood, John 2006 "Dixie; Floated, but not Finished," Where Y 'ar.

McNu I ly, Ian 2007 "Dixie Beer Returns with the Help ore German-born Brewer oo the Northstiore," Gambit Weekly. 20 February. New Orleans- Louisiana. wwwilmtufneworicaris,com Electronic Document accessed 26 June 2008.

Lind, Angus 2006 "Not Tapped Out- Dixie Brewery Comers Plot Their Comeback,' 7illieV-PICCW10- 9 May; Honey L New Orleans, Louisiana vi-g-,A.aewsbnukultt Electronic dooment accessed 26 June mog.

Modern Brewery Age 1990 —Soviet union will be Whistlins Dixie as Beer Arrives," Modern Brewoy Age, 12 November.

Reid, Peter V. K._ 2000 "Wish I had a Dixie," Modem Brewery Are. 27 November.

Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, New Or ears, Louisiana Var. insurance Maps of New Weans. Weans Parish. Louisiana. Avaflable online at Jitindfsa n.

Slack. Martin 2000 "Local and Regional Breweries in America's Brewing Industry, 186 10 1920.."' The Bum a .3 History Review, Autumn 2000.

Thomas, Greg 2007 "Tax Breaks Co Scrutiny, Puss- Developer is Reveal Income of Projects," rimil-Pirayniie. 17 February. Living I. New Orleans, Louisiana. www,itewplitiA,crmit Electronic doe oirleat accessed 26 June 2008.

Deterrrilivalca orEllgibillty: Dixie Brewery Page 3 or3 Description The Palatal Brewery site occupies much of the block that is bounded by Crmvier Street to the north, South Dorgenois Street to the east. South Broad Avenue to the west and Perdido Street to the south. The site contains a series of connected structures constructed of steel-fmme and load-hearing masonry walls.

The concrete slab-on-grade foundation footprint is Inquiet. and die building heights span between five and ten stories. Roofs are flat except for n gable roof on a three-story addition to the linear warehouse on the South Dorgenois Street side of the she. A two-story addition, which sits atop to the original building on the Gravier Street gide of the site, also has n gable roof, and third addition located within the center of site features n gable parapet roof, Roofing materials arc not known. At the time of the building's survey, original windows and doors had been removed as part of a renovation project to convert the building into apartments and retail spaces, Since the survey, most of the wood windows on the South Dorgenois Sheet elevation have been replaced with new wood windows. Many of the original metal, louvered windows found throughout the complex also have been replaced with fixed-in-place, multi-pane metal windows.

What appears to be the original structure stands at the corner of Gravest and South Dorgenois streets, although wine modifications have been made to it. The building Is manly industrial with the first floor denoted on the exterior by horizontal bands of concrete that cover the masonry walls. A band of molded concrete ems along the foundation, and u molded concrete plaque sits above the canter entrance at South Uorgenois and Gravier streets. Two black iron brackets once held lanterns on either side of the entry (the lanterns had been removed at the time of the building's survey).

Heading south along South Dorgenois Street front the onginel building, the site contains a smokestack displaying the Falstaff name in red lettering and a linear, two-story stricture with a concrete stucco facade. A three-story addition, with a gable roof, concrete stucco façade and decorative bands of bricks at its corners, sits atop this structure_ A two-story masonry warehouse is located on the southeast portico of the site. It is believed that this is a later addition as h does not appear on the 1940 Sanborn map of the site. The former bottling plant, the Mllest structure on the site at seven stories, is connected to the original building's western side. The plant's structural system is visible on the exterior.

The brewery still retains nvo of its landmark features — the statue of King Garribnnus, the patron of beer, and the most notably, the vertical Falstaff sign that rises above the building. The statue of King Gernbnaus stands atop the earner entrance of the original structure. The vertical sign, which sits atop the bottling plant. is capped with a weather ball that has not functioned continuously since the brewery closed.

History It is believed the original building was constructed c. 1911 by the National Brewing Co. (1908 Sanborn maps show an empty square where the brewery now sits). In 1936, the St. Lank, Missouri-based Falstaff Brewing Corporation houghs the National Brewing Co, and its New Orleans plant and began embarking on plans to expand the facility (Thomas 2006; n.p.). Most of the buildings on site date to Falstaff's refurbishment and expansion of the brewery Monies 2006; n.p.). Circa !937 architectural plans on file at the New Orleans Public Library show that the architectural firm of Bendemagcl and Casale designed a warehouse for the brewery.

Falstaff became one of the three major breweries In New Orleans, including Dixie Beer and the Jackson Brewery (inside Northside, March/April 2006; n.p,), Falstaff expanded ha brewery spin in 1945 and 1950. Architect Philip P. Carole designed a cellar addition in 1945, according to plans on file in the New Orleans Public Library. In 1950, he and partner• Bob W. Layer were hired for additions and alterations to

Detamilnatian of Eligibility: Falstaff Brewery Page or3 die bottling plant, ancording le architectural plans on file at the New Orleans Public Library. his believed that this is when the iconic vertical Falstaff sign and weather bail were added to the brewery (Inside Northside, lvlarchiApril 2006; rt.p.),

The brewery sat abantiorEed from 1978 to 20)( when it was purchased for $1.i milj ion by developer Theodore Mondale of 'F. Mondale Consquetion and his partners the Rensissanct Property Group (Thorria$ 23 halm 2006; ri,p,), The developer& began renovating the brewery to convert la into 149 mixed-inccine apartments and retail apace. The Fniataff office building at 2601 Grayer Street was demolished ns part of the project.

Eligibility Recommendotinn The Palatarf Brewery has been nornitmtmd as a loud landivatk by the New Orleans Historic District LandltErk$ The brieWL11/ is eligible for individaal listing in the National Register of Historic~ Maces under Criterion4 Indlietre. as part of Hew Orleans' brewing past of the late nineteenth rind early twentieth ter m ies,

i?eterrn nal ion QrAgibiily Falstaff Brew ED. Page 2 ui3 Works Cited

Bendernaget and Cazale 1937 Plans for additions and attentions to Falstaff Brewery. Held at New Orleans Public Library, New Orleans, Louisiana.

Inside Northside 2006 "Beer in New Orleans", March-April. Available online at kunanagatMarchAtiritablatt I Liling

Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, New Orleans, Louisiana 1940 Insurance Maps of New Orleans, Orleans Parish. Louisiana. Available online at lutpaanbormumixom.

Thomas, Greg 2006 Article on Falstaff Brewery sale. 23 June. New Oil wins, Louisiana.

Detaminazion of Eligibility: Falstaff Brewery Page 3 of 3 Description Located at IMO Canal Street, the Charles Or house is one of the City's most outstanding eitamples of ViClOtintl Art 115 corner tower. !Latin hwy. asvrranettical facade and decorative wood work, the house 529.nreS Queer! Anne acid Eastlake style influences

The asymmetrical, rwn-story house appears to be Feeble on a brick can wail foupdatiusi, fratur decorative foundation vents Construction is wtood.frarne, and the moderate pitched hip roof it covered with asphalt shingles with barrel ridge tiles. The home features two tiorroris on each or Ilk eleYalicins, for a total of eieht_ The dormer& iir paired cxcepi for those on the StitlaliNal rilltEt dfik111112EM iippc-ar to be e later addition lo the batlike, as a photo frOrn the time of construction does riot show them. Decorative wooden brackets are found nil eir1her side of the dormers on the northeast arid southeast elevations. the home's sheathing is varied. I§ real WO toical of the Queen Anne style, The front facade features eirop- lap siding, as well as panels underneath the windows of the hotric's two-story pmjecting bays.. Other are clad in weather-hoards, The double-bung, one-over-one window, appal; to he ongirna, according lo a photo of the house al the Hine of its consrliCtiCifl- The %:nillieitat devotion contains some douhle-hong, two-over-twts wood windows;

While much or the original Queen Anne and FAseake style eleinimis have been removed from die name, those that (main acre fine t_it envies of die slits, Elements Mal have been I-moved itn-lud2 Two projecting gables on the mor.htesi etevalion, a secor2d story porch with spiodla-like balusiindes and rwo citoular porches at the northwest and riorilletoi carnets, The Eapola that meaint eta the house has been /Attract, hit is seal} a good example of the sty/e. The first floor porch that remains feature! turned wood posts and Ea6ila1te Style carved decoration. The first floor of projecting bay al Canal and South Dorgcnois streets features carved wood brat- k4s, at does the southeast elevation,

1 ksto ry The house was constructed in 1899 liar Charles Orleans, a cemetery memorial builder, whose faintly visited the home until 1934 (Huber 1914:39), Orleans was born in tvInntvegi, rintadti, Deeemaher 12, 1142 and began his career there overseeing the erection of a church (Miner 1998: rip.). Orleans' checkered career m the building trade took him to New York, Chicago and Purim_ it la reputed that he made and lost two fortunes and came to New Orleans after curferirig from had hick in Chicago (Huber, McDowell, and Cistisiorvich 1974; 611

Orleans' career in New Orleans thrived He eretted tawny of the imaisoletratt in Metairie Ceinctery and claewlu= He had the leuding n iorturrami firm in die city mmiii about 1391 when he losi ihc competition to design and build the inanirMall erected in memory of Superimiendela ci Police Davie C. Hennessy, who wait sbai by activists from the New Orleans Sicilian colony (Huber, McDowell, and Christovich 1974: 6i).

Orientis is listed for the first time tit file 1886 New Orleans rine Directory, 05 Or OBE111 filYr ()minim. Company at 36 Caro-ndelet %Teel (101101- directories show his prOceSOOT1 11S Lt anise contractor and designer of monumental hirildnig works). City directories dating from 1886 it) 1892 indicate that he resided at 359 Canal Street, then 144 Carud Street_ It was not until 1900 that the directory lilts his residence as the 1800 block or Canal Street; runher, data from the 1900 United Stales Census lists Orleans' house at Canal Strew. °Hamm pnued Away in 1923 iHuher, McDowell. and Christavich 1974: 61), tleteria icstion of:lily °demi t louse Page. I oft The house combined to hen residence until 1978 when it was purchased by the Orleans Parish Medical Society. The organization altered the home into offices, removing much of the gmgcbread and altering the cupola. The house now stands as one of few remaining residential style structures dating to the laic 10' century along this section of Cartel Street,

Eligibility Recommendation The Historic Distrito Landmarks Commission lists the Charles Orleans House as a Local Landmark. in 2008, the Louisiana Landmarks Society listed thr house as one of the Nine Most Endangered Sites In New Orleans.

The building is eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Htstonc Places under Criterion C•. Architecture as It embodies the distinctive characteristics of Queen Anne style h is unlikely thin the structure is eligible for listing in the Notional Register under Critenon A, gus there is no evidence that the building is associated with an event significant at the local, state, or tuitional level Inclusion under Criterion B is unlikely because it is not the only structure associated with Charles Orleans' pmductive life, since many of the cemetery monuments Orleans designed and constructed still remain. Eligibility under Criterion /1 (if the property has not yielded, nor is it likely to yield information important In prehistory or history) has nut been aced

Determination of Eligibility; Orleans Huse Page 2 of) Works Cited

Brock, Eric J. 1999 Images of America: New Orleans. Arcadia Publishing. Mount Pleasant, South Carolina.. 1999

Huber, Leonard V., Peggy McDowell and Mary Louise Christovich 1974 New Orleans Architecture Vol. Ilk The Cemeteries. Pelican Publishing Co., Gretna, Louisiana.

Miller, Mike 2008 Biography of Orleans, Charles A. Biography and Historical Memories of Louisiana from LAGenWeb Archives, litionlwww.usewarchives.oreanllafilesitint. accessed 29 July 2008

New Orleans City Directories Var. Directories of residents of the city of New Orleans. Held at the New Orleans Public Library.

United States Census Bureau 2006 United States Federal Census Images, 1820 — 1930. Online records extracted from www.ancestry.com on 29 July 2008.

Detamination of Eligibility: Orleans House Page 3 of 3 Description Mc Gamut. School No. 14 was constructed in 1878 in the neighborhood popularly m I Ic.1 Mid-City. The [tract-pal archtleel of the Menoncigh Schools in the late 191"' century was Wi!limn Frcret, o re/ehrated local arclitecci told New Orleans native. Frerstes public school designs are highly regarded even today with their symmetrierd facades. natural light, sad ale play space (Ferranti 19911. Iviononogh No. t 1 was one or Frerrei antsi grant# designs with Mrmsard roof and Necood French Empire derailing. Stunt of McDrinogh No, I I's original alchitectoral feat ne* itnyt been itame/y the elegant roof, bin the striking reollinti, large milde ws. and facade synneeiry mum-

History John McDonaglt was! born in Baltimore in i179 where Ins father owned ertenirve rea1 estate. ,mitre lYkOoilogii began his eatrer In [ j at the inirnandle know of VI' elliatu Taylor. Taylor decl 1)005 domestically end internationally, eventually set:Kling John Ivieporiugh to other posts including Nrw Orleans l dine 1983: 5-10). John .lvicDoriogli eventually became nn important agent for Trifine in New °Hearts where he formed metteral trading businesses over many years including lilebonogh & Parie. J. MeOunoglis Jr. & Company, and Shepherd Brown. & Company (Allan 19831 12.16). inspired by his father's success iki rcal estate mid his own Pilii,XeS5 in the mercantile bush-leas, IV Done heg-rin purchasing real estate in 1803. idc.Dolicigh's fort large reul entaie purchases were large Beal tracts in Spanish fail Florida. During the next years Donal,* continued to purchase real estate including uthare rmidences and rural plantations sprer3d throughout the RouilicaM. By 1806 he Wit his time tending to his trier-Anint bkouness and his Teti esiale holdings rAlhui 1983! 17-20).

rhotigh New Orleans wris a Spanish nerrirory when McDonogh moved to New Orleans, he remained onion patriot. la PM. MrDuattgb participated in the Bark Dr Chalmette Mew Orleans) during the War 4,3r 18 l2 Athol 198.3: 3(t), In 1817, McDontigh loll his urban New Orleans borne to Live at one of his plant/Moto along the west bank of the lvlirissippi River, upriver kiln the Vieur Cat-re in New Orleans, The city around this plantation became known a MeDotroghvillc, anti more receraly. Gretna. At this poim, Menovogh increasingly became known as an arcantrie Itermii (Allan 19831 31-35). Maionogh also began his philanthropic pursuit:I, begrrova$ with a few orphans LOCktilias iffs younger siblings. MoDonogli paid the living expenses and education dues for Si2veral orphaus while he managed his extensive land holdings (Allan l 983; 31-11).

Ai the same time that MoDonogh was beginning hia philanthropic pursuits, he deibisal a eomplea way in which his slaves could earn their freedom, Ili 11322, lie ileenaly offered his slaves money in exchange ka: their work and then aftErwed them io buy their freedom with the wages he paid. The first group of Ivicnonagli's staves earned their freedom irl 142 and promptly le for Liberia. Africa. Though Meflontigh received negative feedback float his fel/ow slave-owning colleagues, he maintained throughout the rest of his lift brit manamission oI slave* woo desirable and re-colonization of Africa 1.1,110 UM. best FECSINC OilirGele for fired slaves (Allan 4983 43-53).

On @ember 26. 1850. John Mr:Dinuigh died on his plantation in Mail. orroghvale. His will WW1 reVehirCd shortly therealitar, end contained many surprising requests. The will provided the City of New Orleans am! die City of Baltimore eath half of ilia bulk of iris estate 10 he din the carn-t-rnc 'Nun of fret schools for the education of the lowest classes Other purvisinos or his will providefi money for his widowed sister, and the frrial rrianurnmDion of his remaining slaves.. (Allan 1983: 64, 75-77), Merionogki'li mate, however, remained =bolded in the ciiorti as the will execiriors toed to Mkt Mak)110g111‘ COMOVX lest wishes a reality. The Civil War anti further legal challenges in the will ries:rated in the slow application nf McDonogh's wishes, However, eventually line City of New Orleans opened ovet 3t public sabot's

terrninatiOrl. Of Eligfbilikyl Sehulil No, I I rip i of 1 throughout OrInens and Jefferson Parish wilh die proceeds frvin lkeicDonogh's estate (Allan I 9a3): Even though the funding wu claw Da be Elpfdied, Ihe lvlenlonughss financing rnahled the local %thou] district to kiild and maintain facillnies during the Leon Reconstruct(On years arid well iino the 21)' century (Devon And Logsdon I901).

Meriunagh No, I I was built in 11(7/3 at fir corner of Sutra] Pitcvr and Palmyra greet (Minn 1983- lid) MQDrinogh No. I I was our of 13 tinikirogri dosignex1 by William A. Frcret. o prurninunt New Oilcans no: tiled between 1815 and 1834. The original design a the building followed the same pateirl 115 with Mc Dom:10i No. 6 And 7, This design had PM ripen basement (gronnd fluor) for coveted play Apart mad the two upper floors al instnictional space. McDoaugh also incorporated sliding wells in the classrooms to allow rot flexible space atilivincon erguvon 1991.. 310-3 la

MiXionogh was bier renovated in 1951 and houced the New Weans Clatter for Ilealilt Careers and rvIergaret [laugher). School Wan I 983; (02). kleDoeogh No. I I is apses on rnipartent site in the prubIIe school systera'5 history of raeiiii deeg-ragalton. In January I 960, court-ordered rteiegeegatiori /int look ;liner in the Orleans Parish School Syr5tern Ill McDonogb Nil 19 and Frania elenieritary schools. the jati af 1961. six. or the I I Orleans Parish schools had young African-American students =Toned in the firit irnii second grade*, including MaDuciogli No. I I (Devore ond Logsdon 1991). At sometime the roolline was Tridiceily rhanged with the removal of ihe towers, mansard roof, and circular windows.

Eligibility Recommendation .the blinding has been most recently wied by the New (Meant Center l-nr Realdt COIN= and is nuncitly undergoing renovation from Hurricane 14. irrinn damage Mer.torsoith No 11 is eiligible FLIT the National ltegister under Criterion A: EducallOil 119 lin example of the education system developed in New Orlesin 0 well s4 Critenott C- Archilecrure

Daenni manor] of lFllglhi1 1 . Dimriogb SLlioral Na i t Page2 or! Works Cited

Alleys, 198.3 Li c' and Fronk of JON: McDonbRip Reprimed by the kffessou Pgui011-ristorical Currimissiaci. Merairie.

Devores Donald E. and Joseph Logsdon 1991 Co Nurros CIO) Schoott Putdire 54:10rafiurt Orleam, 4!-!991. UnileMitY air Sple-11PVt*MTD LQUiS 114114 Afaytri c.

Ferguson, John C. 1‘.K.J.1 "The Arebilecture of Fthicsilicil: The Public School Buil/in-1p of New Orleans," is CTTSCC?il City Sehopts Pobrir Edigralton En New °drum. /84/ , /CV Appendix 1. University of Southwestern Louisiana. Lafayette.

DelerrnInsucn of B111111)1111 rvIcOoncgii Se FitacINo. It Pep 3 cf 3 D CAC liptiuui The Oeuisches tfaus is a etartgal nrganirratirla inside` the Mid-City National Register District dedicated ro the preservation eon celebration 01 German !tentage_ Three German civic societies joined in 1928 los purchase a structure that coiad home for a1$ the activineis of the city's German sonterti%" (Stewart arid Woodruff rui.:31. Now in its eightieth y-eiu-, members of the f.k.iiimikits Haw still hosts cultured events such as Olcioberfest, movies, langtuage Blesses, concerts., and the LATfiallliterit of a Biergifft en from then- loestion on South Cia I vez Street

Cumberland Telephone and Telegraph Company bought the property in February 1910, suggesting a construction dale of 1910-19/2. The Southern Bell Telephone and Telegraph Compauy purchased the properly in 1926 only to sell to the Deintogivy Nam in January 1928, A large crowd gathered at the deilluation in Noverribur rf thal year. The sirs cture was expanded in 19-30 to accommodate its rapidly expanding membership. A dining room mid two howling Ekfleys were frieludad in the renovation (Stewart and Wood/a:n1473)..

The ',eta:II:hes farts is a rwo-story brick Itiruchire with little exterior ornamentation exempt a raw of dernrils beneath the white cornice and a classical door overhang. Members enjoy tt pavilion Style dining roam with a view of the garden. The accred Alory is a mitering room with a stage as ont end. The Driiisthra Haut lost roust of its original woodwork der to floodirt' frau' Hurricane Katrina but trews of volunteers wettable to save the rest of the smucium

History itecrtiimall or GC:MUM 1.131.0 LOT.Lisialiu began as early as 1717 when John Law mud the Clitriplifty of the West took control of the fledgling settlement al New Orleans (Campanella 200.6147). Many of those who survived the voyage settled upriver of New Orleans in an area that became known ea La Carr de* Allemands, or the Gentian Coast. This aigiculMral camrmmiry produced ricc corn, beans, peas. and tobacco which could be sold cloworiver in New Orleans (Merrill 2005:24-25).

Witt and famine drove large numbers of Guanaco into New Orleans in the I 810s, German immigration to the Crescent City continued to Mcrerise lbr the next forty years. During the 1830s toughly 9,000 Germans enterell the port of NeW ollearlii. This influx was fbIlowed by another near 42.000 in the 1840s. Gen-mans accounted for approximately 35 pertent of all Ora-Migration to the nit} from the Inas through the t$3505(Merrill 2005;56)- 'Dough twiny of these inn ants continued on to other places, New Orleans had a amble and active German potation= by the outbreA of the Civil War.

The Derofche Gesellschaft (the German Society) emerged as one of the most prominent trianifiemnions of the activities of the otty's German population. The society formed in ig47 to help ilia large number of ittnitgrentoi entering New Orleans Marty of &etc. trintigrants Kpalce no English or Were badly in need or financial ossitarkee 205:57). tit iis firsi to r of operation, the Gus-roan Society aptly illustrated ihe efforts ii ward Intralle Weil into Ihe iiiture by raking res-pansiliiity for ilic care tsf thirty immigrant wphans from Germany (Merril! 2005'.59)•

During ?aid niter the Civil War the Cterman population grew very slowly. Hy 1860, oflicial records indicated that New Orleans was home to the largest German population in the American South (Campanella 2006:248). Just thirty years law eta-in-tales placed the number of Get-man-born residents of the ciry at over f 14300, lire same estimares placed the population of American-born New Orleuntans min C'tin-tuan-burri pa-rrvu at over 47.30(1 ICamprinella 2006:249)_ Dritteho Hato ,7eptesents an imps rant clement of the social Life of GE-m.1ms of New Odium beneficent organizations. One author places the number or such ownizsiLiCIES formed by Germano ii#

DcL'errnified KM or Eligibility- Deursek !lusts Page I of 3 daring the nitteiecnth =Wry at: 43 fraternal oilarnzatie[15, 26 religious on 24 German berrovolcm otezies, 24 military orgonizatiom 2 tinging sad musical goirpoi t TPa(le aTirl professional ass.ucintions, 17 volunteer fife companies,. . drum societies, 9 heritage socieuea. 8 apprtins clubs, 7 weieties, 6 cultural societies, end 2 handicraft clubs, T11-061 CD New ikleputs (Campanella 2006:249)4 Germans bonded together to maintain their control ratditioia. for recreation, and to support their compatriots who could not support themselves.

Recommendation Detaritia! Maus is eligible for the National Register of Historic Maces under cr4enni I A: German Cultural liistftry. The important and -unique cunitibutiona of Germans and theft henericent moieties to the development or New Orleamc arena' preserved anywhere eNe in the city. In addition, anti. location is the mosi notable eiample of the ethrisr grottie& cfforL4 to rtri—Nerve its culturril Identity nod thrive in the diverse Cre.went City,

Dew/ruination or. Evitoty-.. Deutsches Hares Prize 2 of Works Cited

Campanella, Richard 2906 Geographies of New 01411111 Center for Louisiana Studies: University of Louisiana at Lafayette, Lafayette, Louisiana.

Merrill, Ellen C. 2005 Germans of Louisiana. Pelican Publishing Company: Gretna, Louisiana.

Stews;.. Jack and Ann Woodruff n.d. History of the "Deutcher Haus • (unpublished)

13eumuration of Deutsahes Haus Page 3 of 3 Description Saint Joseph's is the largest historical church in New Orleans. measuring 110 feet in width by 225 feet in length and standing 150 feet tall. The massive brick church is documented to contain two million bricks in the foundation alone (States-kern (S-I], 12 March 1975:n.p.). The building is Romanesque style with several important architectural details. The façade consists of three bays — the center entrance bay, and two outer bays. The center bay consists of a three-arched arcade supported by octagonal column shafts with Corinthian capitals. A large rose window dominates the façade which is topped with an Dreaded row of 9 bricked-in arched windows set at an angle to one another forming an upside-down V. The two outer bays aro undeveloped bell towers that contain four stories of windows. The first row consists of arched stained-glass windows with traditional engaged Corinthian.columns The upper three fenestrations have similar, but smaller, windows. The nave portion of the building (side elevations) have three rows of windows separated by buttresses. The first row of windows consists of elongated arched windows, most of whom have been bricked over. The next fenestration consists of a row of five sets of three arched windows. The clerestory fenestration consists of 10 sets of three windows (ono roundel window flanked by two arched windows). The building is unique because it does not have either an apse or transepts, and the two bell towers on the front are unfinished. The interior of the church is accentuated by columns, arches, flying buttresses, and a beamed ceiling.

History The parish of St. Joseph was created, in 1844 (Cluistovich et al. 199S: 31). The first St. Joseph's Church was on Common Street (present-day Thrum Avenue) between Freret and Howard Streets, opposite the site of the Charity Hospital. On the same block were two schools, a boys and girls, associated with St. Joseph's Church (Robinson 1883). The religious order of the Vincentian priests, a loose collection of followers inspired by St. Vincent de Paul, tank over the parish in 1858 (St. Joseph's Parish 1968). In 1896 The current site was purchased in 1866 to serve the increased needs of the parish es well as the site for its expanded educational services. The former church became St. Katherine's and was ultimately demolished in 1964 (Si Joseph's Parish 200$).

In 1869 the groundbreaking ceremonies for thc present St. Joseph's Church building were witnessed by a large crowd. The first plan, designed by architect Thomas 0' Neill, however, were nut structurally sound. The WO* on the Church was halted for 10 years starting in 1875. Around 1885 the structural problems were fixed and construction continued using the plans of architect P.C. Keely (Christovielt et al. 1998: 31). Brooklyn-based architect Charles Patrick ICeely, a student of A.W.N. Pugin, designed the current structure at 1802 Wane Avenue. Pugin advocated Gothic Revival Style through essays and building designs (Poesch and Bacot, eds,. 1997; 208-213), Keely helped to popularize the Gothic Revival style in the United States, designing more than 500 Catholic churches over the course of his career (McAleer 1986;134) Among Keety's masterpiect% is the Church of St. Charles Borromeo in Brooklyn, the Cathedral of St. John and St. Finnibar in Charleston and St. Mary's Basilica in Halifax, Nova Scotia (Patrick 1980:137; McAleer 1986:134).

St. Joseph's Church was finished in 1892, almost 30 years after construction started. When it was finished, St. Joseph's Church was the largest church in the City of New Orleans. Some sections of the church including the projecting towers, nese, and transepts were never completed (Christovich et al. 1998: 31), The Church lacked much of its current interior ornamentation when it was finished in 1892. The main altar, various pictures, and pews were added over time as donations and funds were available. The only interior addition that affected the exterior is the replacement of the original clear glass windows with stained glass windows (St. Joseph's Parish 2008). In the late twentieth century two associated buildings

Determination of Eligibility: St. Joseph's Church Paget of 3 on the same block, a rectory and school, were demolished to accommodate the expanding Louisiana State University (LW) medical school (fS-1), 12 March I 975:p.a. Sanborn 1940),

Eligibility Recommendation Saint Joseph's Church is listed by the Historic District Landmarks Commission as a Local Landmark and is eligible for inclusion in the National Register under Criterion C: Architecture es an example of Romanesque religious;architecture.

Determination of Eligibility: St. Joseph's Church Pagel: or3 Works Cited

Christovich, Mary Louisa, Routh= Toledano, Betsy Swans,on.8.nct Pat Holden 1998 N#'' Orleans Archilectiura: Valium* 11; Thr American Soeitn• (Faubourg .40tary)_ Pelican Publishing Company, Gretna.

MUtker, J. Phillip 1986 Si. Mary's (1820-18341. Halifax: An Early Example of the Use of Gothic Revival Forms in Canada. The Jountal of Mc Society of Arcbiiecinral Historians 42(2): 13-4-14.7.

Patrick. lanes I ORO Eccelesi asti cal Gothic in the Anichollurn South. If'interthor Portfollo 15(2)71 lir US.

Robinson, E. 188.3 Robinson's Atlas of ehe C7 of Now Orleans. Lotsisiona, E Robinson. New York. Wine) Available ut haralarw-w.notarialarchives.orsh-obinsortfittchsx.bitn.

Sanborn Fire insurance Map, New Orleans, Louisiana 1940 hauranee Maps of New Orleans-, Orleans Parish. Louisiana. Available. online al littp://sanhorri.umicorn.

States-item (S-I) [New Orlethx. Louisiana 1975 "Places for the New Louisiana State Univ-ersity (1511) Medical Center." 12 II/larch. New Orleans, Louisiana.

SL. Joseph's Parish 19(i 75rm Anniversary Celeimition Program. St. Joseph Ts Pensh, New Orleans. 2008 .4 Brief Hirtory, 9, Joseph's Parish, New Orleans, [Online) (Aeussed I August 2ooto.

Deterrninxion of Eligiiglity. Sc. Jose-ph's Church Page 1 al 3 Description St. John's Evangelical Lutheran Church, now associated with the congregation of Grace United Methodist, dates to the late nineteenth century and epitomizes the Gothic Revival style popular during that time period. The church features a unique corner tower with decorative brick work, a prominent rose window, and sharply arched windows end prominent main entry. A historic rendering of the church from 1871 shows that some architectural detailing has changed (Figure 1). These changes include the removal of vergeboard on the crass gables, and the removal of the belfry and spire on the tower.

History Grace United Methodist Church began ns the St. John Evangelical Lutheran Church when it was built between 1852 and 1853 (Della 1894). It is difficult in determine when Protestants first came to New Orleans_ The colony was largely Catholic and lawn passed by the ruling authority banned the practice of other belief systems besides Catholicism Weller 1894: 9). The Treaty of San Lorenzo, signed to 1795, gave American citizens free use of the )olississippi River. This resulted in an influx of American settlers into the area, who also brought their Protestant beliefs. in 1805 the first open meeting of Protestants occurred in New Orleans. Soon after, different sects Of ProtraMens broke away from the original congregation end consuucted their individual elnuches (Defier 1594: 10.1 I). in :826 the first German Protestant Church received a permit from the city to gather- This congregation eventually constructed a church building on Clio Street between St. Charles Street and Carondelet Street. This congregation was popularly known as the Clio Church (Miler 1894:10-14). The 1840s and 1850s proved difficult for the Clio Church congregation. The congregation fragmented and several new German Protestant clenches were formed including the Evangelical Lutheran St. John's Congregation (Belles 1894;15-17),

The first building constructed on the present site of the St. John's Evangelical Lutheran/Grace United Methodist Church was constructed In 1852. The land was donated by two ofits members, M. Haas and Hein. Weber. The first building was a small "prayerhotthe" that later became a kitchen and parsonage. A larger, permanent meeting building was else built between 1852 and 1853. This building is the extant church on the site. On 20 March 1853 the church watt dedicated by the congregation (Dealer 1894: 65), A pastor from the Missouri Synod was assigned to the congregation but dissent among members of the congregation resulted in further splintering within the congregation with some members leaving the church for a Presbyterian Church and others Iowan for a Reformed Church, However, the Church did remain in the Missouri Synod and membership Increased Mailer 1894: 65-67). In 1855, bells for the church were donated by Martin lialbritter who serval as the congregation president for about 40 years (Defier 1894: 67).

The Gothic Revival styling and design of the St. John's Church building reflects the influence of the Protestant Reformation and the Romanticism movement on all aspects of society including architecture and an. This influence was especially fell in Northern Europe (Bertescb 1965: 61). The Reformation movement was based on the notion of returning to basic religious teachings by rejecting the complex pageantry that typified Medieval Cethorteism As a result, most Protestant sects worked to incorporate asceticism into the &sip of their thumb buildings_ Along with the Protestant Reformation, the rise of Romanticism at the nun of the nineteenth century resulted in a retrospective treatment of the grand Gothic cathedrab built in the Middle Ages. For these reasons, the Gothic Revival Style became popularized at the rum of the Tall Wealth century. Prominent ambliecia such as A.W.N. Pugin in Britain supported the movement back to Gothic, only simplified, through essays and building designs (Poesch and Bacot. eds., 1997: 208.213). The St. John Evangelical Lutheran Congregation/Grace United Methodist Church building reflects the popularity of the Gothic Revival style. ha sharply arched windows, heavy wooden

Determination of Eligibility: St. John's Evangelical Lutheran I Grace United Methodist Church Page 1 or 1 hunt door,. bell tower, large rose window. steeply pitched roof, and imposing enirenee makes it an excellent example of Gothic Revival arehite•ciarc_ fa 1857 N caliEd SL John's ruid St, WINMICK. MNOCi41iO4 with the thumb wt c.onin rtalied nearby on South Johnson Street. The Robiiisair Intl IA the sehunI a '1,Gierman Lutheian School,' and tater Sanborn Fire Insurance maps Elesignide the school tar belonging to SL John's (Robinson 103; Swaim 1895, 19(18). A few years later in 1866 root kits on tr'Anal Street were purchaued tu round ibt 31. John's Cemetery. The cemetery was later expanded to 13 kris in 1883 °kilo- 1894.: 673 The congregation also Formed a sister congregation on the Weal bank of the Mississippi River with a Chula 1111111ed the Evangelical-WI-man Trinity Congregation. This congregation was minigeted by Sr` John's pastor for a short rune (Della 1894: 68). in 1891 a neighborhnod fire destroyed the orig-Toril panel-age and another later building, the custodian's ganders. The parsonage was mho& that same year .tDeiler 1894. 68-69). In 1882 divisioti occurred within the church on vihrshor to use the Eogliab language insvivices. Thom wi%hing In remain using Certaiin the tonpage in die church remained with the congtegntior st Prieur Street and lbervilie Stem. li wa.! not until 1893 the a few English-language service ware hcid its the church (Merrill '2005: 20((). A 1908 map idiom the men church hinIding hid expandol to its cunerit Footprint (Sanborn icfogy In 1917 ihe congregation sold the church buildmg anti built of new building at Pierce Street and Canal Street tMerril1 20051 206) By 1940 the property had txamferred to the African-Americtrn congregation, Cinice Methodist, while the t.uhool was now desigouted as the Tulime Thiplist Church (Sanborn 1940).

Reentninembirlon The church is lisied a:s a local lrindmark and i eligible for the National Register under Criterion C; Arciiiteeture as an example of the a-011ie Re1fil211 Nryie popular in the United States in the ante nineteenth century. The church may also be eligible wide' Criterion A:. Edutc Heritap a illusrrative or iiir JO= of Getman immigrarits in New Orleans durinn dm same time period_

Determination of Eligibility; st. Evangelical boon i Crnet Untied Methadist Calla Pam'_ Of '1 Works Cited

Benesch, Otto 1964 The Art of the Renaissance in Northern Europe: la Relation to the Contetnporary Spiritual and Intellectual Movements. Phaidon Press, London

Deiler, I. Hanna 1894 A History of the German Churches in Louisiana (1823-1493), Translated by Marie Stella Condon. University of Southwestern Louisiana, Lafayette.

Merrill, Ellen C. 2005 Germans ofLouisiana. Pelican Publishing Company, Gretna.

Poesch, Jessie and Barbara SoRelle Bacot, editors 1997 Louisiana Buildings: 1720-1940. Louisiana State University Press, Baton Rouge.

Robinson, E. 1883 Robinson's Atlas of the City of New Orleans-, Louisiana. E Robinson, New York. [Online] Available at http://www.notarialarchives.org/robinsonrindez.htm.

Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, New Orleans, Louisiana 1895 Insurance Maps of New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, Available online at jiturllsanbonLinni,com.

1908 Insurance Maps of New Orleans, Orleans Parish. Louisiana. Available online at Ittly;Thlanbontutni.entn. 1940 Insurance Maps of New Orleans. Orleans Parish, Louisiana, Available online al http:Ilsanbortimmiscom.

Determination of Eligibility: St. John's Evangelical Lutheran r Grace United Methodist Church Page 3 of 3 Description McDonogh School No. 30 was constructed in 1894 on the corner of Gravier Street and South Miro Street. The building follows the basic design of other McDonogh schools with a piano nobile entrance, two enclosed upper floors, and an originally open (now enclosed) ground floor designed for covered play space. The facade retains its original segmental arched windows on the first floor, and arched windows on the second floor. Towers adorn three corners, possibly missing the original fourth tower on the southeast corner. Remaining architectural details include extensive dentil detailing, course brick buttresses, and highly stylized window cornices on the façade and one side elevation.

History John McDonogh was born in Baltimore in 1779 where his father owned extensive real estate. John McDonogh began his career in Baltimore at the mercantile house of William Taylor. Taylor traded both domestically and internationally, eventually sending John McDonogh to other ports including New Orleans (Allan 1983: 5-10). John McDonogh eventually became an important agent for Taylor in New Orleans where he formed several trading businesses over many years including McDonogh & Payne, J. McDonogh, Jr. & Company, and Shepherd Brown & Company (Allan 1983: 12-16).

Inspired by his father's success in real estate and his own success in the mercantile business, McDonogh began purchasing real estate in 1803. McDonogh's first large real estate purchases were large land tracts in Spanish West Florida. During the next years McDonogh continued to purchase real estate including urban residences and rural plantations spread throughout the southeast. By 1806 he split his time tending to his merchant business and his real estate holdings (Allan 1983: 17-20).

Though New Orleans was a Spanish territory when McDonogh moved to New Orleans, he remained a union patriot. In 1815, McDonogh participated in the Battle of Chalmette (New Orleans) during the War of 1812 (Allan 1983: 30). In 1817, McDonogh left his urban New Orleans home to live at one of his plantations along the west bank of the Mississippi River, upriver from the Vieux Carre in New Orleans. The city around this plantation became known as McDonoghville, and more recently, Gretna. At this point, McDonogh increasingly became known as an eccentric hermit (Allan 1983: 31-35). McDonogh also began his philanthropic pursuits, beginning with a few orphans including his younger siblings. McDonogh paid the living expenses and education dues for several orphans while he managed his extensive land holdings (Allan 1983: 31-41).

At the same time that McDonogh was beginning his philanthropic pursuits, he devised a complex way in which his slaves could earn their freedom. In 1822, he secretly offered his slaves money in exchange for their work and then allowed them to buy their freedom with the wages he paid. The first group of McDonogh's slaves earned their freedom in 1842 and promptly left for Liberia, Africa. Though McDonogh received negative feedback from his fellow slave-owning colleagues, he maintained throughout the rest of his life that manumission of slaves was desirable and re-colonization of Africa was the best possible outcome for freed slaves (Allan 1983 43-53).

On October 26, 1850, John McDonogh died on his plantation in McDonoghville. His will was revealed shortly thereafter, and contained many surprising requests. The will provided the City of New Orleans and the City of Baltimore each half of the bulk of his estate to be used in the construction of free schools for the education of the lowest classes. Other provisions of his will provided for his widowed sister and the final manumission of his remaining slaves. (Allan 1983: 64, 75-77). McDonogh's estate, however, remained embroiled in the courts as the will executors tried to make McDonogh's last wishes a reality. The Civil War and further legal challenges to the will resulted in the slow application of McDonogh's wishes. However, eventually the City of New Orleans opened over 30 public schools throughout Orleans

Determination of Eligibility: McDonogh School. No. 30 Page 1 of 3 and Jefferson Parish (Allan 1983). Even though the funding was slow to be applied, McDonogh's financing enabled the local school district to build and maintain facilities during the lean Reconstruction years and well into the 20111 century (Devore and Logsdon 1991).

In 1883 most settlement in the area of McDonogh No. 30 remained below South Galvez. Nearby the future site of McDonogh No. 30, on the other side of Galvez was the Hotel Dieu hospital located at Common Street (now Tulane Avenue) and South Johnson Street. Five blocks away, and on the less settled area lakeside of South Galvez was the Marine Hospital located at Gravier Street and South Broad Street. The block where McDonogh No. 30 was eventually located was empty in 1883 (Robinson 1883).

McDonogh No. 30 was built in 1894 at the corner of Gravier and South Miro Street. According to the 1940 Sanborn Map the building was used as a National Youth Administration (N.Y.A.) Vocational School (Sanborn 1940). It closed in 1975 and in 1977 was reopened as the Career Education Center. That same year the building suffered fire damage (Allan 1983: 105). McDonough 30 most recently was used as the studios for WYLD radio. Currently the building is vacant after sustaining damage from Hurricane Katrina and the ensuing flooding.

Eligibility Recommendation The building has been most recently used by the WYLD radio station. Currently the building is vacant. McDonogh No 30 is eligible for the National Register under Criterion C: Architecture and may also be eligible under Criterion A: Education as an example of the education system developed in New Orleans and Criterion B for the association with John McDonogh.

Determination of Eligibility: McDonogh School. No. 30 Page 2 of 3 Works Cited

Allan, William 1983 Life and Work of John McDonogh. Reprinted by the Jefferson Parish Historical Commission, Metairie.

Devore, Donald E. and Joseph Logsdon 1991 Crescent City Schools: Public Education in New Orleans, 1841-1991. University of Southwestern Louisiana, Lafayette.

Ferguson, John C. 1991 "The Architecture of Education: The Public School Buildings of New Orleans." In Crescent City Schools: Public Education in New Orleans, 1841-1991. Appendix I. University of Southwestern Louisiana, Lafayette.

Robinson, E. 1883 Robinson's Atlas of the City of New Orleans, Louisiana. E. Robinson, New York. [Online] Available at http://www.notarialarchives.org/robinson/index.htm.

Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, New Orleans, Louisiana 1940 Insurance Maps of New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana. Available online at littp://sanborn.umi.com.

Determination of Eligibility: McDonogh School. No. 30 Page 3 of 3 Attachment 1: Map 90'515:1 00'J fn.:

torn 10151511/ 'parr/ tbfr•IIVV,

Premed reelllly roeipririls with Amu of Potential Effect • ConUfbuting PolterlY O Non-Conte:ruing Property %wiles Potentially ElIgibk for btRillP Properties Potentially Ebgtbla for NRHP t. Fund Brewing Company (2600 Graver Street) 8 _ i RrOpoSad VA Campus (Orleans) Footprint 2.0012 Brewery (2401 Theme Avenue) Pr000sed LSU Campus Footprim 3 h4c3orogn No. 30(2228 GrayIto Street) 1:3 Proposed VA Campus and LSU Camara Area of Potentla Ellett 4' Destschas Han (200 S Calves Strew) 0.4o)onogn No_ 11(2001 Patnyra Street) E:3 tad-city Historic District Oullne 9. St John's Evangelical Luthcean/Grace riExisting VA Campus Rebuild Area of Potential Effect United Cbural (2001 Neville Street) _ _ ttielng VA Campus Foot: Am 7: Si icneph's Calholc Chian (11102 Tirana Avenue) C Existing LSO Campus Rebind Area of Potential Eruct 9. Odin House (1800 Canal Streell Existing LSO Campus Footprint Attachment 2: Photos Dixie Brewery 2401 Tulane Avenue, New Orleans. Orleans Parish. Louisiana View of main block of brewery

View of brewery front Mime AI/C.111W

Artaelimerw Photos Page 1 of 20 Attachment: Photos Page 2 of 20 Falstaff Brewery 26010 Gravier StrectLNew °deem Oricaus Parish, Louisiana •-• View from eravier Street

Main entrance

Artactmeair. Photo rage 3 of 2121 Falstaff Brewery 2600 Gravier Street, New Orleans, Orleans Pariah, Louisiana Brewery under renovation

Anachinentl Photos Page 4 of 20 Orleans House 1800 Canal Street.- ....New ,- Orleans Orleans Parish, Louisiana Canal Street A?: : 1 Si„.•-i.t*4 • facade t't,- - 1

' atorallit_ .• = ..._,,, - t .. ' ' li r

. ' .,

FY,-

View from Canal .-i•_ - - • -_, .4 Street and South . .„. Derbigny Street ' • ` .._. _ .

_ _--- -4. I 1 ' il

...toN --••- --t-ti • • ; -

Attachment: Photos Page 5 of 20 Orleans Rouse 1800 Canal Street, New Orleans, Orleans Parish. Louisiana Detail ol'Canal Street fnentie

•

4IP 9 1111

r -77:

6 * •

Attachment: Photo% Page 6 LA 20 McDanogb School No. II HSI Palm ra S New Orleans!. Orleans Parish, Lauisl View of building from Palmyra Street and Saud) Prieur Street

Rear of building

Attachment Maim Page S of 20 View of building from Palmyra Street and South Prieur Strecl

Attachment: Photos Pose9 of 20 Page I 0 of 20 A Deutsches Haus 200 South Galvez Street New Orleans Orleans Parish, Louisiana Main Facade

Attachment: Photos Page II or 20 Dew tsches Haus ZOO South s'vex Street., New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Leiilnhinsi DIM-diet.% earner

Nonhwegi COrner

Attachirumt: Phoick,. Page 12 or A Deutsches fill Q.ntith ral,es %AW rtA 1# itit “.• I 204 Street, . , , 1 44 . eumpanaaaa Rear of building

Attachment Maus Page 13 of 20 St Josepiei Church 1.811 haunt Avenue, New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana of church frons TLIIItlie wee

Rea] et chura

Page 14 am

St. Joseph's Church 1802 Tulane Avenue, New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana Detail of entrance

Attachment Photos Page 15 of 20 Si. Jemph's Church 1802 T u lane Aveua Neve Orleans. Orleans Parish IOC

Attachment: Photos Pagr 16 of 20

St. John's Evangelical Lutheran I Grace United Methodist Church 2001 Iberville Street, New Orleans Parish, Louisiana Historic rendering of St. John's Evangelical Luther= Church

Present day facade of church

Attachment: Photos Page 170r 2i)

St. John's Evaugentni 1,utheran fitIme United tvlethodigr Church 2001 lbery Ik Street,New °Heim Parham Louisiana

Atuichrucra: rwicri I'ag I b or 2O Mcnatiogli School No. 30 222 Gravier Street, New Oricui n °deans Parish. Louisiana Forfade of building

View urbuilding from Gruvier Street and South Mira Street

Anachtromu pint% Age iS10-1-20 MeDario& School NG. 30 2218 Growler Street, New ()deem.: ()deans Parish, Louisiana Detail

A itachmeni: ?hems Page 20 of 20 DEPARTMEN1 OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Officn of ConitnictIon & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

November 3, 200N

Mr, Ott state I hstorti. Preset-vane Office/ D4pa.rimuni LtF CiilturB, Recreation & i01145M P.O. Bo.p. t1424l Baton Roupe, LA WIRCI4

kepink:amrat of HuaLltgare Foci I kills Cosepr6ini tho (LS. Depertnmm i i Veteram Aileitv Sew OrlearoMettiol CIMPUS (VAMC) Cher wtm Da Aged by 1-4urric2ne$ Hateina and Rita. New Wen% LA

Dear Mr. Hutcheson!.

The U.S. Department of Vatarana AL it (VA) and the Federal Emeegency Mortaigement Agency (FEMAp 1101ifiCid the State Historic Preservation Officer (81-1.P0) on July 2, 200g that they hue delerrhiacd to f4.1,(111 da4it responsibilities under Sectiou 10 of the National tliftoric Pmst,rmion Act (N11PAJ for their individual Undertakings to replace the health...4te - facilities compristng the VePeriaM /arum media ens= IVAlviC) #ocEitoi in New Oilcans, Lnuiciaca that werc dm- raved by Hurririmes Katrina and Rita. The SHP° isparticipating inIEN coroulterion.

FEMA submittedaittter on October 22, 2008 requesting concurrence list Miring of individual e4biHty for fisting tri the National RettiNter cwt EliStoric Planes for the following structures: FirktaliBrinvery at 2600 Clavier Street Dime Brewery at 2401 Wane Avenue; Demsettes Haus oi 200 Smith Crelvez Svc St Joseph's Chard) ai 1802 'Ad= Avenue: MoDoniagh School No. t I al 2001 Palmyra SIT= Or1caP23 i-laaw 1 goo unit! Street: MeDonogb S6001 No. 30 at 2228 Oravier Strcei, Pumping Station No. 151 2431 Palmyra Street; and SL John',c Evangelical Luiiieran / Orem Unitad MetlindiftChirrah 20O lbervifle Swam.

VA agrees with theft-Miro or F' 1:A re2arding eLigihilicy for the above listed buildinss. Dixie Brewery and Eumping Simon Nc, 15 are located with the. proposed footpriint rer the RPC site alternative. _Litz VA oicwtta the RPCsit. the lispasition of the Dixie Brewery and Pumping Slation No. 15 will be. addressed within the Programmatic Agreement. Please contact me at (202) 4451-8254 or [email protected] if you save any questions or need additIonai information.

Singien,1

Kntbloen Schmid Federal Prmervation Office! cc: fohn Kota-nun, Federal Emergency Management Agency

PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT

APPENDIX 2:

FINDINGS OF ADVERSE EFFECTS

DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Office of Construction & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

September 9, 2008

Don L. Klima, Director Office of Federal Agency Programs Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Old Post Office 1100 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Suite 809 Washington, D.C. 20004

RE: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans, LA Determination: Adverse Effects

Dear Mr, r

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) notified the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) on July 2, 2008 that they have determined to fulfill their responsibilities under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NH PA) for their individual Undertakings to repair or replace the healthcare facilities comprising the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) located in New Orleans, Louisiana that were damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The AC HP is participating in this consultation. The Undertaking is phased to facilitate the full consideration of all potential effects as project details are developed, in accordance to the requirements outlined in 36 CFR §800.5(a)(3), and the Section 106 Programmatic Agreement (PA) will include provisions for revisiting the issue of adverse effect after the current phase, Site Selection, is completed and future effects are better defined. This letter describes anticipated adverse effects that may be identified through phased application of the Criteria of Effect and Adverse Effect for each Alternative.

Definition of the Undertaking

VA intends to replace the healthcare facilities comprising the Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) located in New Orleans, LA (Undertaking). As a part of this Undertaking, VA intends to replace the existing campus in one of four geographic locations. The course of action is dependent on completion of Section 106 review for site selection. Mr. Don L. Klima September 9, 2008 Page 2

Area of Potential Effect (APE1

Currently, four alternatives are under consideration for the VAMC portion of this undertaking; rebuild a new facility in the current VA Hospital location; rebuild a new facility at a site adjacent to Ochsner Hospital; rebuild a new facility in the RPC site bounded by South Rocheblave Street, South Galvez Street, Tulane Avenue, and Canal Street; and rebuild a new facility at the current Lindy Boggs Hospital location. The Lindy Boggs site has been added to consideration only recently; therefore, the letter regarding possible adverse effects to those historic properties within the Lindy Boggs Area of Potential Effect will follow at a future date. The Areas of Potential Effect (APEs) for the other alternatives have previously been sent to the ACHP. For clarification, maps outlining the APEs are attached.

Identification of Historic Properties

VA consulted with State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) to identify historic districts and buildings within the APEs for each Alternative. VA's letter to SHPO, dated July 17, 2008, identifies both historic and non-historic districts and buildings within the APEs.

Consultation with the SHPO on the identification and evaluation of historic standing structures was completed by a side-by-side photo and data review by the Federal agencies, The SHPO and Federal agencies made determinations of eligibility based on information collected in the summer of 2006 and winter of 2007 by teams of architectural historians who met Secretary of the Interior standards. Teams collected a minimum of four digital photographs of each building; the photographs met National Park Service minimum standards for quality. Building data was collected on hand-held GPS computers, and information collected included type, style, integrity of materials, workmanship, location, setting, and design, and whether it retained the qualities of significance as defined by 36 CFR part 800. The photos, digital determinations of eligibility and information were linked by GIS. Properties that retained the elements of integrity and significance as contributing elements to the National Register Historic District were determined to be eligible in consultation with SHPO.

The consultation did not include buildings that may meet or exceed the threshold for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Subsequent research has identified nine properties that possess the qualities of significance required for individual listing: Falstaff Brewery at 2600 Gravier Street; Dixie Brewery at 2401 Tulane Avenue; Deutsches Haus at 200 South Galvez Street; St. Joseph's Church at 1802 Tulane Avenue; McDonogh School No. 11 at 2001 Palmyra Street; Orleans House at 1800 Canal Street; McDonogh School No. 30 at 2228 Gravier Street; Pumping Station No. 15 at 2431 Palmyra. Street; and St. John's Evangelical Lutheran / Grace United Methodist Church at 2001 lberville Street. VA is currently consulting with SHPO regarding the eligibility of these properties. Mr_ Don L. Klima September 9, 2008 Page 3

Determinations of Effect

The current effects determination for each Alternative relates to anticipated effects, since the assessment of the full range of effects of future phases is not possible. Adverse effects determination will be revisited at future phases, including design, site preparation, and construction, in order to ensure that all direct and indirect effects will be identified and efforts to avoid or minimize ally potential adverse effects will be considered.

1° Alternative: Replace Existing VAMC Facilities on the Existing Site

This alternative will require the demolition of VA Hospital, and the construction of a new facility/facilities in that geographic location. The result would be a direct adverse effect to VA Hospital, as well as to the New Orleans Medical District, of which VA Hospital is a landmark element. This effort would constitute a direct adverse effect as defined by 36 CFR. §800.5(a)(2)(i). The construction of a replacement facility on this site may cause indirect adverse effects to other historic properties within the APE though the introduction of visual, atmospheric or audible elements that diminish their integrity (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(v)). If this Alternative is selected, VA will apply the Criteria of Adverse Effect at subsequent phases of the project including design, site preparation, and construction, to determine whether additional direct and indirect adverse effects are identified in order to ensure that options are avoid or minimize those adverse effects will be considered.

2" Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the Ochsner Site

This Alternative includes the construction of a new hospital facility/facilities in the site adjacent to Ochsner Medical Center (Main Campus) located at 15 14 Jefferson Highway. No historic properties have been identified within the APE for this alter-native; therefore, no direct or indirect effects have been identified.

A warehouse in this Alternative houses a National Register listed steam locomotive. If the Ochsner Site is chosen, the warehouse will no longer be a suitable location for its storage. To avoid direct effects to this property, VA will be sure to allow the owner of the locomotive ample time to find a new facility for the storage of the locomotive.

3rd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the RPC Site

This Alternative will require the demolition of properties that contribute to the significance of the Mid-City National Register Historic District (NRHD) and are located within the project area_ All ❑f the twelve blocks fall entirely inside the boundaries of the Mid-City NRHD. Consequently, both the Mid-City National Register District and the individual properties that contribute to that district may meet the definition of adverse effect set out in 36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(i), for direct effects if future phases are unable to avoid or minimize effects. Although it may be possible to minimize or mitigate the adverse effect through the relocation of some contributing buildings or Mr_ Don L. Klima September 9,2008 Page 4 to the retention of certain historic buildings, these actions also have the potential to meet the adverse effect criteria because they would result in the removal of a property from its historic location (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(iv)). This Alternative will introduce visual, atmospheric and audible elements that may diminish the integrity of the Mid-City NRHD (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(v)). Should FEMA and its applicant, the Louisiana Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control, choose to construct a new medical center on the adjacent 15-block parcel below South aalvez Street, additional Adverse Effects to the Mid-City NRHD will occur. If this Alternative is selected, VA will apply the Criteria of Adverse Effect at subsequent phases of the project including design, site preparation, and construction, to determine whether additional direct and indirect adverse effects are identified in order to ensure that options are avoid or minimize those adverse effects will be considered.

In addition to those direct effects noted above, the selection of Alternative #3, to construct replacement facility/facilities in the RPC Site, could result in the existing VAMC hospital no longer operating as a hospital. Since one of the criteria under which it has been determined eligible is as a contributing element to the New Orleans Medical Historic District, such a change in the use of the building could constitute an adverse effect, as noted in by 36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(iv), "change of the character of the property's use...that contribute to its historical significance."

VA looks forward to receiving the ACHP's comments on VA's determinations of effect for each Alternative outlined in this letter and any advice on any additional steps that VA should take to identify and evaluate historic standing structures and assess the potential effects of each alternative on these historic properties. We appreciate your interest in this Undertaking and the active role that you and other members of the ACHP staff have taken in the consultation meetings to date.

Please contact me at (202) 461-8254 or [email protected] if you have any questions or need additional information.

Sincerely,

Kathleen Schamel Federal Preservation Officer U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Enclosures cc: Ms. Katry Harris, ACHP Mr. Howard Bush, FEMA Mr. Don L. Klima September 9,2008 Page 5

Pt Alternative: Replace Existing VAMC Facilities on the Existing Site Mr. Don L. Klima September 9,2008 Page 6 rd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the Ochsner Site Mr. Don L. Klima September 9, 2008 Page 7

3rd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the RPC Site

DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS Office of Construction & Facilities Management Washington DC 20420

September 9, 2008

Don L. Klima, Director Office of Federal Agency Programs Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Old Post Office 1100 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Suite 809 Washington, D.C. 20004

Dear Mr,Klima:

The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) notified the Advisory Council on Ilistoric Preservation (ACHP) on July 2, 2008 that they have determined to fulfill their responsibilities under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NEIPA) for the Undertaking to repair or replace Healthcare Facilities in New Orleans, LA that were damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita through the development and implementation of a Programmatic Agreement (Section 106 PA). The ACHP is participating in this consultation. The Undertaking is phased to facilitate the full consideration of all potential effects as project details are developed, in accordance to the requirements outlined in 36 CFR §800.5(a)(3), and the Section 106 PA will include provisions for revisiting the issue of adverse effect after the current phase, Site Selection, is completed and future effects are better defined. This letter describes anticipated adverse effects that may be identified through phased application of the Criteria of Effect and AdVerse Effect for the Lindy Boggs Alternative.

Definition of the Undertaking

Area of Potential Effect (APE)

Currently, the VA is considering three alternatives for the VAMC Undertaking: 1' Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the Ochsner Site; 2"d Alternative; Construct Replacement Facilities at the RPC site; and ri Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities at the Lindy Boggs site, The Area of Potential Effect (APES) for the Lindy Boggs Alternative, previously sent to the ACHP, is attached to this letter.

Identification of Historic Properties

VA consulted with the SHPO to identify historic districts and buildings within the APE for the Lindy Boggs Alternative. VA's letter to SHPO identifies both historic and non- historic districts and buildings within the Lindy Boggs APE. As part of FEMA's Section 106 responsibilities for another undertaking, FEMA deployed teams of architectural historians who met Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualifications Standards to survey and evaluate all buildings within the existing boundaries of the Mid-City Historic District in late 2007 and the Parkview National Register District in the summer and fall of 2006. FEMA, VA and SHPO reviewed photographs and information collected by those surveyors to determine whether the buildings retained enough integrity and significance to contribute to the Mid-City or Parkview Historic Districts.

This consultation did not include buildings or area that may meet or exceed the threshold for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Subsequent research has identified one property that possesses the qualities of significance required for individual listing: Bayou St_ John / Carondelet Canal. VA is currently consulting with SHPO regarding the eligibility of this property.

Determinations of Effect

The current effects determination for the Lindy Boggs Alternative relates anticipated effects, since assessment of the full range of effects of future phases is not possible. Adverse effects determination will be revisited at future phases, including design, site preparation, and construction, in order to ensure that all direct and indirect effects will be identified, and efforts to avoid or minimize any potential adverse effects will be considered.

Construct Replacement Facilities at the Lindy Boggs Alternative This Alternative will Not Adversely Affect historic properties within the APE because buildings that are subject to direct adverse effects are not historic properties. It is unlikely that this Alternative will affect archaeological properties. If this Alternative is selected, VA will apply the Criteria of Adverse Effect at subsequent phases of the project including design, site preparation and construction, to determine whether additional direct Mr. Don L. Klima September 9, 2008 Page 3 and indirect adverse effects are identified in order to ensure that options to avoid or minimize those adverse effects will be considered.

The construction of a replacement facility on this site may cause indirect adverse effects to historic properties within the APE though the introduction of visual, atmospheric or audible elements that diminish their integrity (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(v)). If this Alternative is selected, VA will apply the Criteria of Adverse Effect at subsequent phases of the project including design, site preparation, and construction, to determine whether additional direct and indirect adverse effects are identified in order to ensure that options are avoid or minimize those adverse effects will be considered.

In addition to those direct effects noted above, the selection of Alternative #3, to construct replacement facility/facilities in the RFC Site, could result in the existing VAMC hospital no longer operating as a hospital. Since one of the criteria under which it has been determined eligible is as a contributing element to the New Orleans Medical Historic District, such a change in the use of the building could constitute an adverse effect, as noted in by 36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(iv), "change of the character of the property's use...that contribute to its historical significance."

VA looks forward to receiving the ACHP's comments on VA's determinations of effect for the Alternative outlined in this letter and any advice on any additional steps that VA should take at this phase to identify and evaluate historic standing structures and assess the potential effects of each alternative on these historic properties. We appreciate your interest in this Undertaking and the active role that you and other members of the ACHP staff have taken in the consultation meetings to date.

Please contact me at (202) 461-8254 or [email protected] if you have any questions or need additional information.

Sincerely,

Kathleen Schamel Federal Preservation Officer U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

cc: John Ketchum, FEMA Tish Rankin, FEMA Robert Collins, Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer Katry Harris, ACHP Mr. Dori L. Klima September 9,2008 Page 4 U.S. Department of Homeland Security Louisiana Transitional Recovery Office One Seine Court New Orleans, LA 70114 (504) 762-2018 office (504) 762-2899 fax

FEMA

November 14, 2008

Don L. Klima, Director Office of Federal Agency Programs Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Old Post Office 1100 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Suite 809 Washington, D.C. 20004

RE: FEMA Undertaking: Repair or Replacement of Healthcare Facilities Comprising the Medical Center of Louisiana at New Orleans (MCLNO) that were Damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans, LA FEMA Effect Determinations Applicant: Louisiana Division of Administration, Office of Facility Planning and Control (FP&C)

Dear Mr. Klima:

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and the City of New Orleans (CNO) are consulting with the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) and the State Historic Preservation Officer of Louisiana (SHPO) to develop a Programmatic Agreement (Section 106 PA) for their Undertakings to repair or replace Healthcare Facilities in New Orleans, LA that were damaged by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita.

FEMA has applied the Criteria of Effect and Adverse Effect for the two Alternatives under consideration for the FEMA/MCLNO Undertaking. This letter notifies the ACHP of FEMA’s determinations of effect for each Alternative and requests the ACHP’s advice on any additional steps that FEMA should take at this time to identify and evaluate historic standing structures and assess the potential effects of each alternative on historic properties.

Area of Potential Effect (APE)

FEMA consulted with the SHPO to identify an APE for the three alternatives under consideration for the FEMA/MCLNO Undertaking: 1st Alternative: Repair in Place, 2nd Alternative: Replace MCLNO Facility on Site and 3rd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities in the area bounded by South Claiborne Avenue, South Galvez Street, Tulane Avenue, Mr. Don L. Klima November 14, 2008 Page 2 and Canal Street.. Since that time, the alternative to replace the MCLNO facility on site has been determined to be infeasible and is no longer under consideration.

Identification of Historic Properties

FEMA consulted with SHPO in a letter dated July 17, 2008 to identify and evaluate historic districts and buildings within each of the APEs. At that time FEMA and VA were in the process of assessing the National Register eligibility of buildings within the APEs that may be individually eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. FEMA has determined that the following eight properties possess the qualities of significance required for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places: Falstaff Brewery, 2600 Gravier St.; Dixie Brewery, 2401 Tulane Ave., Deutsches Haus, 200 S. Galvez St.; St. Joseph’s Church, 1802 Tulane Ave.; McDonogh School No. 11, 2001 Palmyra St.; Orleans House, 1800 Canal St.; McDonogh School No. 30, 2228 Gravier St.; and St. John’s Evangelical Lutheran/Grace United Methodist Church, 2001 Iberville St. FEMA is currently consulting with SHPO regarding this eligibility determination.

FEMA and VA propose to include provisions in the Section 106 PA that will describe the steps that FEMA and the VA will take to identify and evaluate archaeological properties in the APEs after the project sites are selected.

FEMA Determinations of Effects for Site Selection

1st Alternative: Repair MCLNO in Place

This Alternative will Not Adversely Affect historic properties within the APE if repairs to character- defining features of these properties conform to the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). It will not require a change in use and will not introduce elements that will diminish the integrity or historic significance of properties in the Area of Potential Effect. It is unlikely that this Alternative will affect archaeological properties, but information about staging areas and areas of potential ground disturbance will be necessary to complete the effects analysis. If the State selects this Alternative, FEMA will ensure that treatment measures are carried out as outlined in the Section 106 PA.

2nd Alternative: Construct Replacement Facilities in the area bounded by South Claiborne Avenue, South Galvez Street, Tulane Avenue, and Canal Street

Implementation of this alternative will require the demolition of up to 42 properties that contribute to the significance of the Mid-City National Register Historic District (NRHD). This represents 1.1% of the 3,710 contributing buildings within the Mid-City NRHD. While these demolitions will Adversely Affect the Mid-City NRHD (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(i)), the demolitions will not cause a significant loss of integrity to the historic property. This Alternative may require the demolition of three properties that FEMA has determined are eligible for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places: the Deutsches Haus, the Charles Orleans House and McDonough 11 School. If these demolitions cannot be Mr. Don L. Klima November 14, 2008 Page 3 avoided, the historic properties will be Adversely Affected 06 CFR 5800.5(a)(2)(i)). This Alternative will introduce visual, atmospheric and audible elements that may diminish the integrity of the Mid-City NMI.) (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(vM In the event that FP&C fails to secure and ventilate the existing MCI NO buildings adverse effects may occur through neglect while the State seeks alternative uses for the facilities (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(vi)). It is possible that Adverse Effects could result from future uses of the. MCLNO buildings if such uses change their character and historic use (36 CFR §800.5(a) 2)(iv)). This alternative will Adversely 4ffect historic archeological properties that occur in the location of ilround-disturbine activities associated with construction of the new facility (36 CFR §800.5(a)(2)(i)). Should the VA ehoose to construct a new medical center on the adjacent Rezional Planning Commission site_ additional Adverse Effects to the Mid-City NRHD may occur. lithe State selects this Alternative, FEMA will ensure that treaument measures are carried out as outlined in the Section 106 PA.

We appreciate your interest in this Undertaking and the acke role that you and other members of the ACI-[P staff have taken in the consultation meetings. FFMA looks forward to receiving any comments or advice on additional steps that FEMA should take to identify and evaluate historic standing structures and assess the potential effects on historic properties.

Please contact Tish Rankin at (337) 281-5637 or Tish.R.ankin'4:i associates.dhs.am if you have any questions or need additional information regarding this Undertaking.

Sincerely,

Marc S. Roy Environmental Liaison Officer Federal Emergency Management Agency

cc: Pam Perkins, Facility Planning and Control Scott Hutcheson, State Historic Preservation Officer. State of Louisiana Jeff Durbin, Advisory Council on historic Preservation Kathleen Schamel,1.:3 Department of Veterans Affairs Brenda Breaux, City of New Orleans Ken Carleton, Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians

PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT

APPENDIX 3:

RECORDATION PROTOCOL

At a minimum, the photographs will document all elevations and character- defining architectural features. Digital photography will comply with the following requirements: a. Image files must be saved as Tagged Image or RAW format files using high quality compression settings. These files must be transferred as first generation Tagged Image or RAW format files that have not been degraded in quality by multiple revisions and re-saving. The images must be formatted on archival quality CD-R media. b. Digital camera files must be captured as 6 megapixel files or greater with a minimum pixel array of 3,000 pixels by 2,000 pixels. c. Color images must be produced in RGB (Red Green Blue) color mode as 24-bit or 48-bit color files. d. Photographic prints must comply with the National Park Service (NPS) March 2005 photo policy regarding photographic printing. e. The photographs must meet the NPS 75-year permanence standard. f. Paper prints will be produced in accordance with the NPS guidelines for “Acceptable Ink and Paper Combinations for Digital Images.” g. The backs of each print must be labeled in soft pencil with the following information:

i. Building Name, ii. Address, iii. Date of Photograph, iv. Description of view including direction of camera, v. Number of image in photographic set, vi. Name of photographer, and vii. Repository of CD-R media. h. VA, the City, and/or FP&C will prepare narrative histories commensurate with the significance of the historic property for each documented building and structure. This narrative will address both the site-specific history and the significant associations of the building to its neighborhood and/or historic district. i. Materials deemed by SHPO to be substantively or technically inadequate will be returned to the VA, the City, and/or FP&C for revision and resubmission. If the SHPO does not comment within a 14-day review period, VA, the City, and/or FP&C may assume that SHPO accepts the

recordation materials. VA, the City, and/or FP&C will incorporate the comments provided by SHPO to the extent feasible. j. VA, the City, and/or FP&C will prepare three sets of each recordation package. Two sets will be transmitted to the SHPO for archiving in the State Library and State Archives. One set will be archived at a publically accessible archive within the City of New Orleans.

PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT

APPENDIX 4:

ARCHITECTURAL SALVAGE

I. Architectural Salvage: This Attachment applies to the VA’s RPC Site Alternative and FEMA’s New LSU Site Alternative. For the VA’s Alternative, the VA is the applicable agency in the stipulations of this attachment. For FEMA’s Alternative, FP&C is the applicable agency in the stipulations of this attachment. In FEMA’s Alternative, FP&C will submit the salvage plan to FEMA for 14-day review prior to submission to the SHPO for review.

II. Prior to the demolition or substantial alteration of buildings and structures contributing to the Mid-City Historic District, the applicable agency will develop and implement an architectural salvage plan for the removal and reuse of significant architectural elements.

A. This Architectural Salvage Plan will detail:

1. This plan will provide for the removal of all of the following historic architectural details from each historic property: doors; wood front façade windows (including dormer windows); brackets; mantels; foundation vents; turned and/or solid wood columns; louvered wood shutters, including appropriate hardware; and decorative “gingerbread” trim, including quoins;

2. Elements with active termite infestation will not be salvaged.

3. This plan will include security of architectural details prior to the implementation of the salvage plan. See provisions for Site Security outlined in Stipulation V.B.2.(a) and Stipulation VI.C.2.(a) of the PA;

4. This plan will delineate removal, inspection, and storage provisions;

5. This plan will include identification of non-profit historic preservation organization recipient(s) of salvaged architectural elements, terms of receipt, insurance requirements, timeframe to receive elements, and reuse provisions.

6. In the event that a non-profit historic preservation organization cannot be identified by the City to receive salvaged architectural elements, the Agencies shall not have any responsibilities regarding architectural salvage.

B. The applicable agency will forward two (2) copies of the Architectural Salvage Plan to SHPO and one copy of the plan to each of the Concurring Parties for comment. If the SHPO or Concurring Parties do not comment within a 14-day review period, the applicable agency may assume that

SHPO and the Concurring Parties concur with the plan. The applicable agency will finalize the Architectural Salvage Plan after considering the SHPO’s review and Concurring Party comments and will implement the plan.

C. The applicable agency will post the final Architectural Salvage Plan to the Website.