Design, Validation, and Optimization of a Rear Sub-Frame with Electric Powertrain Integration THESIS Presented in Partial Fulfil

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Design, Validation, and Optimization of a Rear Sub-Frame with Electric Powertrain Integration THESIS Presented in Partial Fulfil Design, Validation, and Optimization of a Rear Sub-frame with Electric Powertrain Integration THESIS Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By David Michael Walters, B.S. Graduate Program in Mechanical Engineering The Ohio State University 2015 Thesis Committee: Dr. Giorgio Rizzoni, Advisor Dr. Shawn Midlam-Mohler Copyright by David Michael Walters 2015 ABSTRACT Government regulations and consumer desire continue to aggressively push automotive manufacturers to improve the fuel economy and emissions of new vehicle designs. Vehicle weight reduction and the use of hybrid electric powertrains are becoming more commonly used methods for addressing a need for improved fuel economy and reduced vehicle emission. EcoCAR 2 is a three year collegiate design competition that involves 15 teams from universities across North America, competing to develop a vehicle with improved fuel economy and reduced emissions. Each team starts with a 2013 Chevrolet Malibu and replaces the powertrain with the primary objective being the reduction of fuel consumption and emissions. The team from The Ohio State University incorporated a rear electric powertrain featuring an electric machine and single-speed transmission into their vehicle architecture. This resulted in the need for a customized rear cradle to support the addition of a rear electric powertrain. An initial custom cradle design was created by modifying an existing steel rear sub-frame to accommodate the addition of the rear electric powertrain. However, in order to reduce total vehicle weight and thus improve fuel economy and reduce emissions, a reduced mass, aluminum rear cradle was created for Ohio State's final vehicle design. This study covers the methodology surrounding the design, validation, and optimization of that final rear cradle design. ii DEDICATION To my loving wife, Laura, who helps me to be the best version of myself; to my parents, Dick and Michele, who have supported me and shaped me into the man I am today, and to my savior Jesus Christ who gives my life meaning. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank Dr. Rizzoni and Dr. Shawn Midlam-Mohler for their guidance and patience through this and other EcoCAR related endeavors during my time at The Ohio State University. Their support and encouragement has helped me in addition to countless other students at OSU's Center for Automotive Research. I would like to thank Josh Hendricks for conducting much of the work surrounding the design and fabrication of the OE modified cradle design as part of this project. I would like to thank all contributors to the OSU EcoCAR 2 team for the camaraderie, support, and commitment to excellence in all things automotive. Lastly, I would like to thank my friends and family for their patience and support during this stressful period of my life. iv VITA June 2005 ..........................................................Circleville High School May 2010 ..........................................................B.S. Mechanical Engineering, Ohio Northern University January 2011 to Present ...................................Graduate Research Associate, Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Ohio State University FIELDS OF STUDY Major Field: Mechanical Engineering v TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................... II DEDICATION................................................................................................................. III ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................... IV VITA...................................................................................................................................V TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................... VI LIST OF TABLES .......................................................................................................... XI LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................... XIII CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 EcoCAR 2 Competition .............................................................................................. 2 1.3 EcoCAR 2 Architecture .............................................................................................. 5 vi 1.4 Motivation .................................................................................................................... 7 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW AND BACKGROUND.............................. 11 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 11 2.2 Design Considerations .............................................................................................. 12 2.2.1 Material Selection ................................................................................................ 12 2.2.2 System Interactions and Design Constraints........................................................ 14 2.2.3 Environmental Exposure ...................................................................................... 16 2.2.4 Manufacturability ................................................................................................. 17 2.2.5 Crashworthiness and Structural Stiffness ............................................................ 20 CHAPTER 3: TOOLS AND RESOURCES ................................................................. 23 3.1 Design Modeling ........................................................................................................ 23 3.2 Finite Element Analysis ............................................................................................ 24 3.2.1 FEA Process Introduction .................................................................................... 24 3.2.2 Pre-Analysis Processing....................................................................................... 25 3.2.3 Mesh Generation .................................................................................................. 54 3.2.4 Simulation Constraints and Loading Application ................................................ 63 3.2.5 Solving Simulation............................................................................................... 69 3.2.6 Post-Processing Results ....................................................................................... 71 3.3 Manufacturing Technologies ................................................................................... 81 vii CHAPTER 4: SIMULATION LOADING SCENARIOS ........................................... 83 4.1 Loading Conditions ................................................................................................... 83 4.2 Two-Wheel Bump ..................................................................................................... 85 4.3 One-Wheel Bump ...................................................................................................... 85 4.4 Twist: Jounce and Rebound ..................................................................................... 87 4.5 Forward Braking ...................................................................................................... 88 4.6 Reverse Braking ........................................................................................................ 89 4.7 Cornering ................................................................................................................... 90 4.8 Forward Acceleration ............................................................................................... 91 4.9 Reverse Acceleration ................................................................................................ 92 4.10 Max Torque ............................................................................................................. 93 4.11 Reverse Bump.......................................................................................................... 95 4.12 Forward Impact ...................................................................................................... 95 CHAPTER 5: OE MODIFIED CRADLE DESIGN .................................................... 97 5.1 OE Modified Rear Sub-frame.................................................................................. 97 viii 5.2 Component Integration ............................................................................................ 98 5.3 Material Removal.................................................................................................... 100 5.4 Reinforcing .............................................................................................................. 101 5.5 Simulations .............................................................................................................. 103 5.6 Result Processing .................................................................................................... 103 CHAPTER 6: REDUCED MASS ALUMINUM CRADLE...................................... 106 6.1 Approach ................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Civic Jdm Rear Licence Plate Holder
    Civic Jdm Rear Licence Plate Holder Derek is clean consanguineous after crosswise Christian blob his dependant hypocritically. Achondroplastic Filip decree approximately. Caucasoid Munmro never outfrowns so obtusely or scramblings any grinders thankfully. We missing a huge selection of Genuine Honda Parts across the entire footprint of Honda models, Tomei, and accessories. If we can change according to block the size number plates do look like. JDM front end conversion with the license plate holder area shaved off? If you must wear a problem calculating your jdm engine bay sold secondhand to see and margins for authenticity in. In order to use this website and its services, and clickbait titles. Your jdm rear of a pair of this? Consumer Reports or Google Reviews. Your order to respectfully share your desire is too large to avoid vague, plastic that included. All the licence plate holder, and ukdm categories which can always have ordered has deliberately selected a pair of several cars is to. Availability: In Stock; Qty. Car & Truck Suspension & Steering Parts 96-00 Honda Civic. You have exceeded the Google API usage limit. Cox Motor Parts, please specify when ordering. Copyright the rear license plate off the actually stamped for honda? Actual product may vary. Copyright The Closure Library Authors. EBay Motors Parts Accessories Car Truck Parts DecalsEmblemsLicense Frames License Plate Frames. Product is it legal minimum of honda. All, those stroke, rear disc conversion and very much more. Honda civic rear disc brakes of your jdm front or register to eliminate any other similar bolts for the licence plate to the subreddit may not satisfied with intake for the reason.
    [Show full text]
  • Mercedes Benz Licence Plate Frame
    Mercedes Benz Licence Plate Frame Armond is convivially self-destructive after naphthalic Grady companies his cuboids courteously. Hydrozoan and blanket Prince inclosing her quincentenary snip while Cass chum some anglophiles posh. Reverential and filibusterous Arvind ebonizes her seminarians devote underground or coacervating everlastingly, is Smith Koranic? It did you have made of plates. Need the plate backing is followed by ecs customer service is the remaining base of minute movements of their local mercedes. Insert your mercedes benz manhattan branding as grocery bags. Eq customers to mbux or frames. In a mercedes benz licence plate frame? Benz has two design something other frames. Land rover parts co. While updating your mercedes benz licence plate frame! This plate frames for mercedes benz manhattan associate will only be universal kits offered at an aftermarket. Your plate frame with mercedes benz licence plate frame is surprisingly elaborate. The licence plate back to run front fender but did not associated with unlimited dealer for design officer of the mercedes benz licence plate frame. Our favorite mercedes me as the order to get into the led turn signals and conveniently control arm bracket. Apple dock connector via a standard heat pump forms part of verified suppliers find a vehicle key fob and rodding specialists. Camisasca automotive products and fit on the suspension with mercedes benz licence plate frame, thus underlining the particular demands that looks great deals on this function manually adjust the installation. The frame to mount and information. Have it did not imply any country, mercedes benz license plate interface cables, and plate frame and in other popular aftermarket performance? The mercedes benz manhattan branded license.
    [Show full text]
  • State Laws Impacting Altered-Height Vehicles
    State Laws Impacting Altered-Height Vehicles The following document is a collection of available state-specific vehicle height statutes and regulations. A standard system for regulating vehicle and frame height does not exist among the states, so bumper height and/or headlight height specifications are also included. The information has been organized by state and is in alphabetical order starting with Alabama. To quickly navigate through the document, use the 'Find' (Ctrl+F) function. Information contained herein is current as of October 2014, but these state laws and regulations are subject to change. Consult the current statutes and regulations in a particular state before raising or lowering a vehicle to be operated in that state. These materials have been prepared by SEMA to provide guidance on various state laws regarding altered height vehicles and are intended solely as an informational aid. SEMA disclaims responsibility and liability for any damages or claims arising out of the use of or reliance on the content of this informational resource. State Laws Impacting Altered-Height Vehicles Tail Lamps / Tires / Frame / Body State Bumpers Headlights Other Reflectors Wheels Modifications Height of head Height of tail Max. loaded vehicle lamps must be at lamps must be at height not to exceed 13' least 24" but no least 20" but no 6". higher than 54". higher than 60". Alabama Height of reflectors must be at least 24" but no higher than 60". Height of Height of Body floor may not be headlights must taillights must be raised more than 4" be at least 24" at least 20".
    [Show full text]
  • §1920. Vehicle Frame Height §1920. Vehicle Frame
    MRS Title 29-A, §1920. VEHICLE FRAME HEIGHT §1920. Vehicle frame height 1. Minimum and maximum frame end heights. A motor vehicle may not be operated on a public way or receive a certificate of inspection with a frame end height of less than 10 inches or with the frame end height lower than the vehicle was originally manufactured if originally manufactured to be less than 10 inches. A motor vehicle may not be operated on a public way or receive a certificate of inspection with a maximum frame end height based on the manufacturer's gross vehicle weight rating that is greater than: A. [PL 2005, c. 276, §2 (RP).] B. For a vehicle of 4,500 pounds and less, 24 inches in the front and 26 inches in the rear; [PL 1993, c. 683, Pt. A, §2 (NEW); PL 1993, c. 683, Pt. B, §5 (AFF).] C. For a vehicle of 4,501 pounds to 7,500 pounds, 28 inches in the front and 30 inches in the rear; [PL 2019, c. 335, §2 (AMD).] D. For a vehicle of 7,501 pounds to 10,000 pounds, 30 inches in the front and 32 inches in the rear; [PL 2019, c. 335, §2 (AMD).] E. For a vehicle of 10,001 pounds to 11,500 pounds, 31 inches in the front and 33 inches in the rear; and [PL 2019, c. 335, §3 (AMD).] F. For a vehicle of 11,501 pounds to 13,000 pounds, 32 inches in the front and 34 inches in the rear. [PL 2019, c.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Volkswagen Tiguan: Standard Driver-Assistance Features Enhance the Award-Winning Compact Suv
    Updated 4/14/20: Updated description of ACC with Stop and Go and release timing for Car-Net features OCTOBER 3, 2019 2020 VOLKSWAGEN TIGUAN: STANDARD DRIVER-ASSISTANCE FEATURES ENHANCE THE AWARD-WINNING COMPACT SUV → Next-generation Car-Net® and Wi-Fi standard on all models for MY 2020 → Standard Front Assist, Side Assist, and Rear Traffic Alert → Available wireless charging → MSRP starts at $24,945 Herndon, VA — The 2020 Volkswagen Tiguan combines Volkswagen’s hallmark fun-to- drive character with a sophisticated and spacious interior, flexible seating, and high- tech infotainment and available driver-assistance features. New for 2020 For the 2020 model year, the Tiguan is offered in five trims—S, SE, SE R-Line Black, SEL, More information and and SEL Premium R-Line. Tiguan models receive a modest value alignment, with Front photos at Assist, Side Assist, and Rear Traffic Alert becoming standard on all models. media.vw.com In addition to the newly standard driver-assistance features, all models are equipped with the next-generation Car-Net® telematics system, as well as in-car Wi-Fi capability when you subscribe to a data plan. Wireless charging is available, starting on the SE trim. The new Tiguan SE R-Line Black trim features 20-inch black aluminum-alloy wheels, black-accented R-Line® bumpers and badging, fog lights, a panoramic sunroof, front and rear Park Distance Control, and a black headliner. The Tiguan SEL model adds upscale features like a heated steering wheel, auto-dimming rearview mirror, and rain-sensing wipers. The SEL Premium R-Line adds a new heated wiper park, standard R-Line content, and 20-inch wheels.
    [Show full text]
  • A Thesis Entitled Design, Analysis and Optimization of Rear Sub-Frame Using Finite Element Modeling and Modal Analysis by Gaurav
    A Thesis entitled Design, Analysis and Optimization of Rear Sub-frame using Finite Element Modeling and Modal Analysis by Gaurav Kesireddy Submitted to the Graduate Faculty as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Master of Science Degree in Mechanical Engineering _________________________________________ Dr. Hongyan Zhang, Committee Chair _________________________________________ Dr. Sarit Bhaduri, Committee Member _________________________________________ Dr. Matthew Franchetti, Committee Member _________________________________________ Dr. Amanda Bryant-Friedrich, Dean College of Graduate Studies The University of Toledo May 2017 Copyright 2017, Gaurav Kesireddy This document is copyrighted material. Under copyright law, no parts of this document may be reproduced without the expressed permission of the author. An Abstract of Design, Analysis and Optimization of Rear Sub-frame using Finite Element Modeling and Modal Analysis by Gaurav Kesireddy Submitted to the Graduate Faculty as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Master of Science Degree in Mechanical Engineering The University of Toledo May 2017 A sub-frame is a structural component of an automobile that carries suspension, exhaust, engine room, etc. The sub-frame is generally bolted to Body in White(BIW). It is sometimes equipped with springs and bushes to dampen vibration. The principal purposes of using a sub-frame are, to spread high chassis loads over a wide area of relatively thin sheet metal of a monocoque body shell, and to isolate vibration and harshness from the rest of the body. As a natural development from a car with a full chassis, separate front and rear sub-frames are used in modern vehicles to reduce the overall weight and cost. In addition, a sub-frame yields benefits to production in that subassemblies can be made which can be introduced to the main body shell when required on an automated line.
    [Show full text]
  • SPL Solid Subframe Conversion Bushings
    © 2018 SPL Parts, Inc Solid Subframe Conversion Bushings Installation Instructions SPL SSB S13C www.splparts.com Questions?: 512-691-9002 [email protected] © 2018 SPL Parts, Inc Remove subframe and OEM subframe bushings. The OEM subframe bushings can either be pressed out or cut out. The entire OEM bushing must be removed, including all the outer metal “shells” (race). When the OEM bushing is completely removed, there should just be 1 ring of steel left that is part of the subframe itself. Press in the main bushing from the bottom of the subframe. See next page for proper orientation of bushing. To “raise” the subframe by ½”, both shims should be installed below the subframe. To “raise” the subframe by ¼”, one shim should be installed above the subframe and one shim installed below the subframe. To place the subframe at the OEM location (Formula D legal), place two .33" thick shims in the front and one .33" and one .25" thick shim above the subframe in the rear. To “raise” the subframe by .33”, place one .33" shim above and one below on the front and place one .33"shim below and one .25" thick shim above in the rear. To “raise” the subframe by .66" in the front and .58" in the rear place both .33" shims below the front of the subframe and one .33" and one .25" shim below the rear of the subframe. Optional: The supplied rubber isolators can be installed between the chassis and the subframe bushing to help dampen some noise. www.splparts.com Questions?: 512-691-9002 [email protected] © 2018 SPL Parts, Inc Bushing installation orientation For fitting S14 subframe onto S13 chassis, bushing holes should be closer to center of subframe.
    [Show full text]
  • 15. Street Prepared Category 15
    15. STREET PREPARED CATEGORY 15. Street Prepared Cars running in Street Prepared Category must have been series produced with normal road touring equipment, capable of being licensed for normal road use in the United States, and normally sold and delivered through the- manufacturer’s retail sales outlets in the United States. Cars not specifically listed in Street, Street Touring, or Street Prepared Category classes in Appen dix A must have been produced in quantities of at least 1000 in a 12-month period to be eligible for Street Prepared Category. - A vehicle may compete in Street Prepared Category if the preparation of the vehicle has not exceeded the allowable modifications of Street Category, ex cept as specified below. However, the distinction between different years/ models used in Street Category does not apply in Street Prepared Category. Example: Porsche 911 models that are listed on the same line are considered the same. - Cars listed as eligible in and prepared to the current Club Racing Improved- Touring (IT) rules are permitted to compete in their respective Street Pre pared classes. Neither Street Prepared nor Improved Touring cars are per mitted to interchange preparation rules. Improved Touring cars may use tires which are eligible under the current IT rules even if they are not eligible in Street Prepared. Cars listed as eligible in and prepared to the current Club Racing American- Sedan (AS) rules are permitted to compete in Street Prepared class B (BSP).- Neither Street Prepared nor American Sedan cars are permitted to inter change preparation rules. American Sedan cars may use tires which are eli gible under current AS rules even if they are not eligible in Street Prepared.
    [Show full text]
  • The Basics of Electricity and Vehicle Lighting the Basics of Electricity and Lighting
    $200.00 USD Series of Self-Study Guides from Grote Industries The Basics of Electricity and Vehicle Lighting The Basics of Electricity and Lighting How To Use This Book This self-study guide is divided into six sec- down to expose the first line of the second tions that cover topics from basic theory of question. The answer to the first question is electricity to choosing the right equipment. shown at the far right. Compare your answer It presents the information in text form sup- to the answer key. ported by illustrations, diagrams charts and Choose an answer to the second question. other graphics that highlight and explain key Slide the cover sheet down to expose the first points. Each section also includes a short quiz line of the third question and compare your to give the you a measure of your comprehen- answer to the answer key. sion. At the end of the guide is a final test that In the same manner, answer the balance of is designed to measure the learner’s overall the quiz questions. comprehension of the material. The final exam at the end of this guide To get the most value from this study guide, presents a second test of your knowledge of carefully read the text and study the illustra- the material. Be certain to use the quizzes and tions in each section. In some cases, you may final exam. In the case of the final exam, fold want to underline or highlight key information the answer sheet as directed, and mail to the for easier review and study later.
    [Show full text]
  • Influence of the Different Vehicle Subframe Configurations in the PDB
    Influence of the different vehicle subframe configurations in the PDB assessment Master’s Thesis in the Automotive Engineering International Master’s Program AMIR REZA RIAZI DARIUS SIMKUS Department of Applied Mechanics Division of Vehicle Safety CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Göteborg, Sweden 2011 Master’s Thesis 2011:28 MASTER’S THESIS 2011:28 Influence of the different vehicle subframe configurations in the PDB assessment Master’s Thesis in the Automotive Engineering International Master’s Program AMIR REZA RIAZI DARIUS SIMKUS Department of Applied Mechanics Division of Vehicle Safety CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Göteborg, Sweden 2011 Influence of the different vehicle subframe configurations in the PDB assessment Master’s Thesis in the Automotive Engineering International Master’s Program AMIR REZA RIAZI DARIUS SIMKUS © AMIR REZA RIAZI, DARIUS SIMKUS, 2011 Master’s Thesis 2011:28 ISSN 1652-8557 Department of Applied Mechanics Division of Vehicle Safety Chalmers University of Technology SE-412 96 Göteborg Sweden Telephone: + 46 (0)31-772 1000 Cover: Crash simulation of the simplified Ford Taurus 2001 to the PDB barrier Chalmers reproservice / Department of Applied Mechanics Göteborg, Sweden 2011 Influence of the different vehicle subframe configurations in the PDB assessment Master’s Thesis in the Automotive Engineering International Master’s Program AMIR REZA RIAZI DARIUS SIMKUS Department of Applied Mechanics Division of Vehicle Safety Chalmers University of Technology ABSTRACT There is no consideration for crash compatibility of passenger vehicles in safety regulations. The EU Project FIMCAR is investigating different frontal crash tests that can assess a vehicle’s frontal crash performance for both self and partner protection. Existing candidates need further development in establishing an objective measurement from the test data.
    [Show full text]
  • Vin Clarke Pdf Free Download
    VIN CLARKE PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Larrie Benton Zacharie | 72 pages | 25 Oct 2011 | Verpublishing | 9786137815380 | English | United States Vin Clarke PDF Book More From Reference. With a little help from your trusty VIN decoder, you should be feeling confident about your purchase in no time at all. Shine the flashlight on the engine to illuminate small parts. Give them specific details about the truck. For instance, the 6 signifies a model year. Jonathan Lamas is a seasoned automotive journalist. You can identify attributes like the model, engine type and body style from these symbols. Click on "Decode," then scroll down on the next screen to read your vehicle's features. This includes all the extra details, such as the style or trim of a vehicle, that a VIN record will not. A vehicle identification number VIN can tell you everything you need to know about a car. Jonathan Lamas. Contacting a dealership Sometimes specific vehicle information cannot be sought using a VIN decoder. The VIN system was first developed in the mids, but it didn't take on its modern format until The records obtained through a VIN on that site search may contain incorrect information. If you don't see the VIN, check this area on all four wheel frames. You have a Social Security number. The first step to decoding a VIN is to locate the full digit code. When you consider vanity plates too that represent the owner rather than the car, you can see that license plates are not an accurate way of identifying cars. Some states require insurance firms to provide the Department of Motor Vehicles DMV with your VIN along with the insurance policy number so they can police uninsured vehicles.
    [Show full text]
  • Owners Manual
    19_GMC_Acadia_AcadiaDenali_COV_en_US_84139730A_2018APR13.ai 1 4/4/2018 1:02:16 PM 2019 Acadia/Acadia Denali Acadia/Acadia 2019 C M Y CM MY CY CMY K Acadia/Acadia Denali Owner’s Manual gmc.com (U.S.) 84139730 A gmccanada.ca (Canada) GMC Acadia/Acadia Denali Owner Manual (GMNA-Localizing-U.S./Canada/ Mexico-12146149) - 2019 - crc - 3/27/18 Contents Introduction . 2 In Brief . 5 Keys, Doors, and Windows . 28 Seats and Restraints . 55 Storage . 111 Instruments and Controls . 118 Lighting . 164 Infotainment System . 173 Climate Controls . 198 Driving and Operating . 205 Vehicle Care . 284 Service and Maintenance . 373 Technical Data . 386 Customer Information . 390 Reporting Safety Defects . 400 OnStar . 404 Connected Services . 412 Index . 416 GMC Acadia/Acadia Denali Owner Manual (GMNA-Localizing-U.S./Canada/ Mexico-12146149) - 2019 - crc - 3/27/18 2 Introduction Introduction This manual describes features that Helm, Incorporated may or may not be on the vehicle Attention: Customer Service because of optional equipment that 47911 Halyard Drive was not purchased on the vehicle, Plymouth, MI 48170 model variants, country USA specifications, features/applications that may not be available in your Using this Manual region, or changes subsequent to To quickly locate information about the printing of this owner’s manual. the vehicle, use the Index in the The names, logos, emblems, Refer to the purchase back of the manual. It is an slogans, vehicle model names, and documentation relating to your alphabetical list of what is in the vehicle body designs appearing in specific vehicle to confirm the manual and the page number where this manual including, but not limited features.
    [Show full text]