CITY of DETROIT (FIRE DEPARTMENT) Public Employer-Respondent MERC Case Nos

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

CITY of DETROIT (FIRE DEPARTMENT) Public Employer-Respondent MERC Case Nos STATE OF MICHIGAN EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS COMMISSION LABOR RELATIONS DIVISION In the Matter of: CITY OF DETROIT (FIRE DEPARTMENT) Public Employer-Respondent MERC Case Nos. 19-G-1452-CE & 19-H-1646-CE -and- DETROIT FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, LOCAL 344, Labor Organization-Charging Party _________________________________________________________/ APPEARANCES: Letitia C. Jones, Senior Assistant Corporation Counsel, for Respondent Legghio & Israel, P.C., by Christopher P. Legghio and Meghan B. Boelstler, for Charging Party DECISION AND ORDER On three occasions during the summer of 2019, Respondent City of Detroit (Fire Department) (Fire Department or Employer) denied the request of Detroit Fire Fighters Association Local 344 (DFFA or Union) President Michael Nevin to “ride a firefighting rig” with his squad even though it had allowed other Union officials to do so for more than 30 years. Shortly before his request was denied, Nevin was also required to submit to a disciplinary “Garrity” interview as part of an administrative investigation. The Union alleged that the foregoing actions occurred in retaliation against, and to suppress, Nevin’s grievance filing and other protected activities. It filed respective charges alleging that the Fire Department had violated Section 10(1)(a) and (c) of the Public Employment Relations Act (PERA), MCL 423.210(1)(a) and (c). In a Decision and Recommended Order1 issued on January 5, 2021, Administrative Law Judge David Peltz found that the Employer violated Section 10(1)(c) by refusing to allow Nevin to ride a firefighting rig with his squad in retaliation for his advocacy on behalf of DFFA members, and that the actions taken by the Employer would objectively tend to restrain, interfere or coerce a reasonable employee in the exercise of his or her rights, in violation of Section 10(a)(1). However, the ALJ determined that the Employer did not act unlawfully by requiring Nevin to submit to the Garrity interview, and recommended dismissal of that charge. In its exceptions, the Employer asserts, in part, that there was insufficient evidence to support the ALJ’s finding of anti-union animus, and that his credibility determinations were not justified. We disagree. Findings concerning motive and anti-union animus rest significantly on 1 MOAHR Hearing Docket Nos. 19-015459 & 19-016519 witness credibility. The ALJ having observed the witness testimony and demeanor first hand, and not the Commission, is in the best position to make determinations concerning the credibility of witnesses. We will not overrule those determinations absent clear evidence to the contrary. The Employer has not advanced evidence sufficient to overturn the ALJ’s credibility judgments. Accordingly, we reject those exceptions and conclude that the ALJ properly found that the Employer’s refusal to allow Nevin to ride a firefighting rig constituted unlawful retaliation for Nevin’s union and other protected activities engaged in as DFFA President. The Employer also takes exception to the ALJ’s having drawn an adverse inference against it for not procuring the testimony of a witness. We find no merit in that exception and conclude that the adverse inference drawn by the ALJ was appropriate under the circumstances. Lastly, the Employer asserts that a portion of the ALJ’s recommended remedy, which would allow DFFA representatives to ride the firefighting rigs “upon request”, is overly broad, and, on that basis, it takes exception to the ALJ’s recommended affirmative order. We find merit to the Employer’s exception. Accordingly, we have modified that portion of the ALJ's proposed affirmative order. Procedural History: This case involves two unfair labor practice charges. On July 17, 2019, the Union filed an unfair labor practice charge in Case No. 19-G-1452-CE alleging that the Employer violated Sections 10(1)(a) and (c) of PERA by requiring Nevin to submit to a Garrity interview as part of an administrative investigation into the unauthorized disclosure of information, in retaliation for his Union activities. On August 8, 2019, the Union filed the charge in Case No. 19-H-1646-CE, alleging that the Employer discriminated against Nevin in violation of Section 10(1)(a) and (c) of PERA by denying his request to “ride-along” on shifts with his assigned squad company. The charges were consolidated and heard on September 26, October 30, and November 26, 2019. On January 5, 2021, ALJ Peltz issued his Decision and Recommended Order, in which he recommended that the charge in Case No. 19-G-1452-CE be dismissed. With respect to the charge in Case No. 19-H-1646-CE, the ALJ concluded that the Employer violated Section 10(1)(a) and (c) of PERA by prohibiting Union President Nevin from riding a rig with his squad. On February 24, 2021, the Employer filed exceptions to the ALJ’s Decision and Recommended Order, and, on March 8, 2021, the Union submitted a brief in support of the ALJ’s Decision and Recommended Order. No exceptions were filed over the ALJ’s recommended dismissal of the charge in Case No. 19-G-1452-CE. 2 Facts: Unless otherwise noted, we adopt the ALJ's findings of fact and repeat them only to the extent necessary. I. Background DFFA Local 344 represents a bargaining unit of approximately 769 fire fighters, emergency medical technicians, and paramedics of the City of Detroit Fire Department, including, but not limited to, Fire Chief, Deputy Fire Chief, Fire Marshall, Senior Battalion Chief and Fire Captain. The Fire Department and DFFA were parties to a collective bargaining agreement covering the period November 6, 2014, through June 30, 2019. Michael Nevin has been employed by the Fire Department for 33 years and is currently Captain of a tactical rescue squad. He was elected President of the Union in December 2015. For the first two years of Nevin’s tenure as President, the Union filed no grievances against the Fire Department. During the period 2017 to 2019 however, the Union filed approximately thirty grievances per year, as well as unfair labor practice charges and claims with the Michigan Occupational Safety and Health Administration (MIOSHA). The grievances involved contract interpretation issues, and challenges to both policy decisions made by the Fire Department and to disciplinary action imposed on unit members. In addition, the DFFA was openly critical of what it perceived to be slow 911 response times and, in November of 2018, posted Fire Department dispatch reports on social media. The evidence revealed that Chief of Department Fire Operations, Robert Distelrath, and Nevin had a fairly adversarial relationship. At the hearing, Distelrath testified that he considered Nevin to be one of the catalysts behind the DFFA grievances, which he characterized as lacking in merit and frivolous. Distelrath further testified that, although he and Nevin had known each other for a long time, that the Union president had “broken the trust” between them by going to the media and denigrating both the Fire Chief and the Fire Department. Distelrath admitted that he and Nevin had clashed over Union matters and described his relationship with the Union president as “contentious.” Distelrath also admitted that, as Fire Chief, he found certain grievances and unfair labor practice charges, including one of the charges filed by the DFFA in the instant case, “annoying”, and took criticism of the Fire Department personally. II. Denial of Nevin’s Requests to “Ride the Rigs” Under the terms of the collective bargaining agreement, members of the DFFA executive board are granted full-time Union release. Article 5, Section D of the agreement provides that the DFFA president, vice-president, secretary and treasurer “shall be permitted time off on a full-time basis with compensation to which their rank otherwise entitles them, including without limitation: salary, pension credits and contributions, seniority, etc.” Notwithstanding their full-time release from normal firefighting duties, elected union officers are still expected to maintain the training, 3 qualifications and proficiencies required of all City of Detroit fire fighters. Based in part on that requirement, Union executive board members periodically work in the field as active fire fighters, a practice referred to as “riding the rigs.” On July 26, 2019, DFFA President Nevin submitted a written request to Chief Distelrath to “ride the rigs” with his assigned company on several dates in August. Distelrath summarily denied the request without explanation and returned Nevin’s July 26 letter initialed and stamped: “DENIED -- Jul 30, 2019 -- Chief of Department.” Nevin testified that the Fire Department had always been receptive to union officers’ requests to “go out to the field” with proper advance notice and, that until Chief Distelrath denied his request, there had “never been a problem.” Distelrath admitted at the hearing that he had previously given Union Vice President Harp permission to ride a rig; that he told Harp that he could do so at any time; and that he believed the practice was a “good thing” for both Harp and the Department. Additionally, there is no dispute that Union Treasurer Verdine Day rode a rig just one day before Distelrath denied Nevin’s July 26 request. After denying Nevin’s written request to work in the field, Distelrath ordered senior Department leadership not to allow Nevin to ride a rig at any time. Nevin subsequently engaged in conversations with other City of Detroit officials, including Labor Relations Representative Hakim Berry and Deputy Commissioner Fornell. According to Nevin, Berry asked what Nevin wanted in exchange for curtailing his Union activities. Nevin further testified that Berry asked how they could “clean up the grievances” and “make this stuff go away.” Nevin told Berry that one of the things he needed was for the Fire Department to end the retaliation, including the refusal to allow him to ride a rig.
Recommended publications
  • Fire Department History
    History | City of Royal Oak History of the Royal Oak Fire Department The first Royal Oak fire department was organized in William Sullivan's home in 1908. Sullivan was elected fire chief; Harry Anderson, Secretary; and William J. Folland president. Other members included Robert McClure, Ralph Bourgeois, William A. Wheeler, Mark and Lee Halsey, Roy Gass, Freeman Robbins, Edward Roy and Edward W. Joyce. With Arthur L. Lawson ringing the St. Mary church bell whenever a fire broke out, this organization safeguarded the village until the Royal Oak Volunteer Fire Department was organized. In 1912, the village experienced a disastrous fire which threatened to destroy the business district south of Third Street. Everything was burned from Mrs. Lochbihler's to Codling's. It was a bitter cold night and a strong wind prevailed. Sparks were carried so far that other parts of the village were threatened. The Masonic Temple caught fire in several places. Help was summoned from Detroit but before it arrived the fire was under control through the valiant efforts of the volunteer group. As a result of the fire, merchants got together and formalized the Volunteer Department on February 13, 1913. Membership increased to include Roy Wing, James Allen, William West, Carlos Marshall, Delbert Geyer, Homer Ebling, George J. Scott, Julius Robar, J. Frank Codling, and Harry A. Brace. William Folland was appointed Chief on April 3, 1912. The early meetings were held in the old town hall on the northwest comer of Main and Fourth Streets. Upon the sale of this building, member's homes were used for a time.
    [Show full text]
  • P001 CD 20170227UNITED WAY.Indd
    FEBRUARY 27 - MARCH 5, 2017 FROM OUR SPONSORS Making a di erence for 100 years A century ago, United Way for Southeastern Michigan ignited a social movement that has changed lives in metro Detroit. It feeds and educates children. It secures shelter for families. It helps job seekers nd work. It unites. As part of United Way's centennial celebration, we feature here 30 champions of its many causes - corporations and nonpro ts that embrace its mission and use its model of workplace philanthropy to show employees the importance of giving back. ® Read more about how your company can make a di erence in an 8-page section that commemorates United Way’s 100th anniversary, Page S1. © Entire contents copyright 2017 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved crainsdetroit.com Vol. 33 No 9 $2 a copy. $59 a year. Crain’s Detroit Business top stories, page 3 Businesses in the footprint of the Howe Bridge wait, worry over prices on buyouts. NEWSPAPER State’s cash-strapped cities take aim at Proposal A’s limits. EMPOWERING WOMEN It takes a village to build the next generation of empowered women. As longtime partners and advocates, DTE Energy and United Way for Southeastern Michigan are providing the tools, resources and support to educate children and improve women’s lives. We’re proud to support Women United and its network of female leaders to accelerate this positive, life-changing work in our communities. Powered by Are Your Favorite Days of the Week Monday Through Friday? Then it must be because you love your job! Cool Places to Work in Michigan returns for another year.
    [Show full text]
  • Fire & Ems News
    CHABOT COLLEGE Fire Technology Program FIRE & EMS NEWS June 4, 2011 This latest issue is jam packed with fire service news stories, training opportunities, training and safety information, volunteer opportunities and employment opportunities! Whether you are a future firefighter or a current fire service professional of any rank, you should find valuable information that will help keep you educated and informed, as well as up-to-date with the fire service. CHABOT COLLEGE 2011 FIRE TECHNOLOGY SCHEDULE: Looking for Fire Technology related courses to either become a firefighter or continue your education if you are currently a firefighter so you can prepare for promotion or become the best you can be at your current rank? Why not start at Chabot College in Hayward, California where we offer a variety of courses year-round to allow students to obtain their EMT certification or recertify as an EMT, obtain their Firefighter 1 Academy Certification, or a Certificate of Achievement in Fire Technology, or a two- year degree in Fire Technology, or just take various California State Certified classes. The following classes are now available in upcoming semesters! For registration information, go to www.chabotcollege.edu SUMMER 2011 Semester: (June through early August, 2011) COURSE DAY TIMES FT 95 (Work Experience ) TBA TBA **Must also be registered in FT 96** FT 96 (Work Experience Seminar) Wednesdays (pm) 1800 – 2005 hours **Must also be registered in FT 95** Health 61 (Emergency Response – EMS First Mondays & 0900 – 1450 hours Responder) Wednesdays (all day) FALL 2011 Semester: (August through December, 2011) COURSE DAY TIMES FT 50 (Fire Protection Organization) Monday (am) 0800 – 1150 hours Note: This section (Monday morning) will be a Hybrid course with on-campus meetings and 20 lecture hours conducted over the internet.
    [Show full text]
  • Detroit Media Guide Contents
    DETROIT MEDIA GUIDE CONTENTS EXPERIENCE THE D 1 Welcome ..................................................................... 2 Detroit Basics ............................................................. 3 New Developments in The D ................................. 4 Destination Detroit ................................................... 9 Made in The D ...........................................................11 Fast Facts ................................................................... 12 Famous Detroiters .................................................. 14 EXPLORE DETROIT 15 The Detroit Experience...........................................17 Dearborn/Wayne ....................................................20 Downtown Detroit ..................................................22 Greater Novi .............................................................26 Macomb ....................................................................28 Oakland .....................................................................30 Itineraries .................................................................. 32 Annual Events ..........................................................34 STAYING WITH US 35 Accommodations (by District) ............................. 35 NAVIGATING THE D 39 Metro Detroit Map ..................................................40 Driving Distances ....................................................42 District Maps ............................................................43 Transportation .........................................................48
    [Show full text]
  • Detroit Media Guide Contents
    DETROIT MEDIA GUIDE CONTENTS EXPERIENCE THE D 1 Welcome ..................................................................... 2 Detroit Basics ............................................................. 3 New Developments in The D ................................. 4 Destination Detroit ................................................... 9 Made in The D ...........................................................11 Fast Facts ................................................................... 12 Famous Detroiters .................................................. 14 EXPLORE DETROIT 15 The Detroit Experience...........................................17 Dearborn/Wayne ....................................................20 Downtown Detroit ..................................................22 Greater Novi .............................................................26 Macomb ....................................................................28 Oakland .....................................................................30 Itineraries .................................................................. 32 Annual Events ..........................................................34 STAYING WITH US 35 Accommodations (by District) ............................. 35 NAVIGATING THE D 39 Metro Detroit Map ..................................................40 Driving Distances ....................................................42 District Maps ............................................................43 Transportation .........................................................48
    [Show full text]
  • Adam Hollier MEET the A-TEAM P.O
    Michigan Departments and Helpful Hotlines Governor’s Offi ce ........................................................................................... (517) 373-3400 Lieutenant Governor’s Offi ce .......................................................................... (517) 373-6800 Michigan Department of: Agriculture and Rural Development ............................................................ (800) 292-3939 Attorney General......................................................................................... (517) 335-7622 Civil Rights ................................................................................................. (800) 482-3604 Corrections ................................................................................................. (517) 335-1426 Education ................................................................................................... (833) 633-5788 Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy ....................................................... (800) 662-9278 Health and Human Services ........................................................................ (517) 241-3740 Insurance and Financial Services ................................................................ (877) 999-6442 Labor and Economic Opportunity ................................................................ (517) 241-6712 Licensing and Regulatory Affairs................................................................. (517) 335-9700 Military and Veterans Affairs ......................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Acknowledgements, Current Status, Knowledge Gaps, and Research
    NIOSH Firefighter Radio Communications ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TriData Corporation acknowledges the invaluable contributions of the following individuals in the preparation of this report. This document would not have been possible without the assistance of the many technology experts. We thank them for their knowledge, insights, and contribution to this study. Contact / Contributor Company Vincent Coli Vice President of Sales, Æther Wire Louis Hanson President, LH Enterprises Patrick Houghton CEO, Æther Wire Jack Jarboe Vice President, Product Development, Grace Industries Brian Kibler Senior Account Manager, Motorola Dr. Peter H. Krawarik Independent Management Consultant Nader Moayeri NIST Information Technology Laboratory Director of Communication Networks, Richard C. Meyers System Planning Corporation Santiago Moreno Vice President, Portico Architects Power Communications Research Group, Dr. John Newbury Open University, Manchester, England Professor of Electrical Engineering, Dr. John Orr Worcester Polytechnic Institute Winston Rice Consultant, RF Engineering Lance Rosen President, Plexeon Professor of Electrical Engineering, University of Southern Dr. Robert Scholtz California Leader, Construction Metrology and Automation Group, Dr. William C. Stone NIST Building and Fire Research Laboratory Hal Walls Vice President of Sales, Transtek Mike Worthington Corporate Vice President and General Manager, Motorola TriData Corporation iii September 2003 NIOSH Firefighter Radio Communications Acknowledgements In addition, we thank the fire-rescue
    [Show full text]
  • The Power's Out: Social Negligence in Detroit, 1973-2003
    THE POWER’S OUT: SOCIAL NEGLIGENCE IN DETROIT, 1973-2003 Ryan Arnold A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate College of Bowling Green State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS August 2018 Committee: Nicole Jackson, Advisor Michael Brooks Rebecca Kinney ii ABSTRACT Nicole Jackson, Advisor The Power's Out: Social Negligence in Detroit, 1973-2003 examines the ways in which the city of Detroit has deteriorated in the late twentieth due to the incompetent functionality of the power structure within the city and how they have overlooked the needs of Black inner-city residents. This thesis utilizes a combination of primary sources and secondary sources such as newspaper articles, community organizational records, autobiographies, blog posts, and interviews to contribute a narrative of Detroit that discusses the conditions of Detroit post-1967 into the twenty-first century. Although industrial decline and white flight were major contributors to Detroit’s decline, the negligence of the city administration to provide an inner-city efficient infrastructure, adequate public housing, and proper civic service response and police-community relations. Research about Detroit revealed the city corruption within Coleman A. Young's city administration was vital to the overall decline of Detroit during his twenty-year tenure. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my advisor and mentor, Dr. Nicole Jackson for her outstanding support and belief in my ability to create this thesis. I would also like to thank Dr. Rebecca Kinney and Megan Goins-Diouf for additional support, advice and guidance within my research and journey creating this thesis.
    [Show full text]
  • Second Annual Chiefs Cooking for Kids Fundraiser for the Youth
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Jeff Griffith, [email protected] Communications Director, The Youth Connection (O): 313‐826‐7099, Ext. 203 or (M): 313‐414‐1202 Second Annual Chiefs Cooking For Kids Fundraiser for The Youth Connection Set for October 2nd at Max Fisher Theater Event hosted by The Youth Connection will feature local police and fire chiefs in a battle to see whose recipe is best and who will be named the 2014 Metro Detroit Chief Chef. September 11, 2014, Detroit, MI – Join seventeen of Metro‐Detroit’s finest top brass in a chief’s cook‐off competition in support of area youth. Enjoy an evening of great food, fun and music, and elect who will be crowned Metro‐Detroit’s 2014 Chief Chef. Metropolitan Detroit Chiefs of Police, Fire and other public safety agencies will don chef aprons and hats on Thursday, October 2nd from 6‐9 p.m. in support of Detroit’s youth at the Max Fisher Music Theater in Detroit. Event co‐chairs Byna Elliott, Senior Vice President of Fifth Third Bank, and Tonya Allen, CEO of the Skillman Foundation, invite you to an evening of fine food, fabulous shopping, and music provided by 313 The Live Experience. A silent auction to benefit The Youth Connection will be held during the event with a wide variety of items for sale. Chiefs Cooking 4 Kids brings together a wide range of law enforcement and fire officials’ favorite recipes in a community‐wide effort to raise money for The Youth Connection, a non‐profit 501(c)3 agency that connects our youth to a brighter future.
    [Show full text]
  • Business News Sports Business+Autos Entertainment+Lifestyle Opinion Multimedia
    ADVERTISEMENT eEdition Stay Connected Customer Service Advertise Classifieds Homes Jobs Cars Shopping Business News Sports Business+Autos Entertainment+Lifestyle Opinion Multimedia Home Biz Business JULY 2, 2014 AT 1:00 AM Former Detroit fire HQ being turned into boutique hotel LOUIS AGUILAR THE DETROIT NEWS 0 COMMENTS Init failed: Gallery instance already initialized. A man walks past the distinctive arched red doors of the historic and vacant Detroit Fire Department headquarters building located across the street from Cobo Center in Detroit on July 2, 2014. Developers intend to turn it into a luxury hotel. (John T. Greilick / The Detroit News) 1 / 10 Detroit — A Chicago group that’s won praise for its distinct hotels has Recommend 579 formally closed plans on the historic Detroit Fire Department headquarters downtown, vowing to retain its industrial charm as it becomes an upscale Tweet 54 boutique hotel. 3 Aparium Hotel Group said Wednesday that it and Detroit developer Walter Cohen plan a $28 million renovation of the 1929 building on West Larned along with an adjacent structure that once housed the famed Pontchartrain Email Wine Cellars restaurant. More recently the building, now empty, had become a nightclub called Envy. Print ADVERTISEMENT Share The new establishment will be called The Foundation Hotel. It is tentatively A A Bloomberg business report slated to open late next year with 100 rooms. Updated morning, midday, and after the bell “We are looking to preserve not only the great history of this building, but, we want to celebrate Detroit as much as possible,” said Mario Tricoci, CEO and one of the founders of Aparium.
    [Show full text]
  • Fire Fighter Training Division Administrative Rules Public Hearing
    FIRE FIGHTER TRAINING DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE RULES PUBLIC HEARING March 24, 2021 Prepared by [email protected] Phone: 800.632.2720 Fax: 800.968.8653 www.networkreporting.com Let us assist you GLOBALLY for all of your deposition needs. FIRE FIGHTER TRAINING DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE RULES PUBLIC HEARING March 24, 2021 STATE OF MICHIGAN LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS - BUREAU OF FIRE SERVICES FIRE FIGHTER TRAINING DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE RULES PUBLIC HEARING Bureau of Fire Services Via Zoom Video Conference Wednesday, March 24, 2021, 11:00 a.m. Members Present: Ann Searles, Bureau of Fire Services Deputy Director Andrea Keown, Bureau of Fire Services Kevin Schlmeyer, Michigan Fire Marshall Robert Stokes, Regional Coordinator FFTD Dan Hammerberg, Regional Coordinator FFTD Also Present: Hollie Metts, Assistant to the Michigan Fire Marshall RECORDED BY - Anna Burns, CER 9214 Certified Electronic Recorder Network Reporting Corporation Firm Registration Number 8151 1-800-632-2720 Page 1 FIRE FIGHTER TRAINING DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE RULES PUBLIC HEARING March 24, 2021 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 2 3 Call to Order . 4 4 Regular Public Meeting. 6 5 Kyle Svoboda . 7 6 Chris Mantels. 9 7 Shaun Abbey. 12 8 Mark Fankhauser. 13 9 Michael McLeieer . 14 10 Mark Docherty. 16 11 Jack, Johnson, Jr. 18 12 Richard Clark. 18 13 Robert Cairnduff . 18 14 Alex Koshorek. 19 15 Justin Fox . 20 16 Bryce Tracy. 20 17 Adam Carroll . 21 18 Matthew Sahr . 24 19 Christopher Dean . 25 20 Jesse Marcotte . 26 21 Nicholas Vaught. 29 22 Kevin Edmond . 29 23 Eric Thomas. 30 24 Steve Heim . 31 25 Chris Krotche. 33 Page 2 FIRE FIGHTER TRAINING DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE RULES PUBLIC HEARING March 24, 2021 1 Mark Cleveland .
    [Show full text]
  • Emergency Medical Services in Detroit: Progress and Potential 2 CENTER for SUSTAINABLE HEALTH SPENDING RESEARCH BRIEF  May 2017
    CENTER FOR SUSTAINABLE HEALTH SPENDING RESEARCH BRIEF May 2017 CONTENTS EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES IN DETROIT: Investment and improvement in Detroit EMS ...........................2 PROGRESS AND POTENTIAL Community collaborations around BY ANI TURNER, DR. ROBERT DUNNE, AND KARA WISE emergency medical services in Detroit ...5 Initiative 1: Addressing the needs In 2013, the city of Detroit had fewer than 10 working ambulances. A 911 caller of frequent users of EMS .................7 with a medical emergency was likely to wait 20 minutes or more for help to arrive, Initiative 2: Real-time referrals for and there was no consistent assessment of data. Emergency medical services non-medical needs ......................8 (EMS) response and firefighting were completely separate divisions of the fire Initiative 3: Onsite clinic at a department, each with single-role providers. Detroit was the only city in the top high-need EMS hot spot .................9 200 US population centers without fire apparatus medical responders.1 Directions for the future ................10 The EMS infrastructure in Detroit has been greatly strengthened since then; the average time from 911 call receipt to arrival at the patient of a transporting Ani Turner and Kara Wise are with ambulance now approaches eight minutes for priority calls. The city received and Altarum Institute. Dr. Robert Dunne is Associate Professor in the deployed more than two dozen donated vehicles, hired and trained additional Department of Emergency Medicine personnel, implemented the SafetyPAD patient care record, and improved at Wayne State University and Medical Director of the Detroit East the intake process to more accurately assess call urgency. The city reached an Medical Control Authority.
    [Show full text]