Indian Law Reports Delhi Series 2014
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
I.L.R. (2014) 1 DELHI Part-II (June, 2014) P.S.D. 25.06.2014 (Pages 2047-2394) 600 Annual Subscription rate of I.L.R.(D.S.) 2014 INDIAN LAW REPORTS (for 6 volumes each volume consisting of 2 Parts) DELHI SERIES In Indian Rupees : 2500/- 2014 Single Part : 250/- (Containing cases determined by the High Court of Delhi) VOLUME-3, PART-II (CONTAINS GENERAL INDEX) EDITOR MS. SANGITA DHINGRA SEHGAL for Subscription Please Contact : REGISTRAR GENERAL Controller of Publications CO-EDITOR MS. NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA Department of Publication, Govt. of India, Civil Lines, Delhi-110054. (ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE) Website: www.deptpub.nic.in REPORTERS Email:[email protected], [email protected] MR. CHANDER SHEKHAR MS. ANU BAGAI Tel.: 23817823/9689/3761/3762/3764/3765 (DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE) MR. SANJOY GHOSE Fax.: 23817876 MR. GIRISH KATHPALIA MR. ASHISH MAKHIJA MR. VINAY KUMAR GUPTA (ADVOCATES) MS. SHALINDER KAUR MR. LORREN BAMNIYAL MR. GURDEEP SINGH REGISTRAR MS. ADITI CHAUDHARY MR. KESHAV K. BHATI MR. ARUN BHARDWAJ JOINT REGISTRAR MS. ANU GROVER BALIGA MR. DIG VINAY SINGH (ADDITIONAL DISTRICT PRINTED BY : J.R. COMPUTERS, 477/7, MOONGA NAGAR, & SESSIONS JUDGES) KARAWAL NAGAR ROAD DELHI-110094. AND PUBLISHED UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF HIGH COURT OF DELHI, PUBLISHED UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF HIGH COURT OF DELHI, BY THE CONTROLLER OF PUBLICATIONS, DELHI-110054—2014. BY THE CONTROLLER OF PUBLICATIONS, DELHI-110054. CONTENTS VOLUME-3, PART-II JUNE, 2014 Pages 1. Comparative Table ............................................................... (i) 2. Nominal Index ..................................................................... (v) 3. Subject Index ................................................................... (vii) 4. Case Law............................................................... 2047-2394 (ii) COMPARATIVE TABLE 2282 2014 (2) JCC 1305 ILR (DS) 2014 (III) = OTHER JOURNAL JUNE, PART-II 2353 No Equivalent Page No. Journal Page No. 2081 No Equivalent 2083 No Equivalent 2211 2014 (209) DLT 515 2205 No Equivalent 2211 2014 (6) AD (D) 664 2277 No Equivalent 2331 2014 (142) DRJ 396 2241 2014 (144) DRJ 182 2331 2014 (4) AD (D) 473 2251 2014 (4) AD (D) 156 2300 No Equivalent 2251 2014 (209) DLT 210 2127 2014 (6) AD (D) 516 2251 2014 (1) RLR 726 2127 2014 (362) ITR 97 2251 2014 CrLJ 3277 2047 2014 (7) AD (D) 128 2169 2014 (4) RAJ 361 2188 2014 (4) RAJ 170 2169 2014 (4) AD (D) 281 2233 No Equivalent 2169 2014 (58) PTC 309 2054 No Equivalent 2312 No Equivalent 2378 2014 (142) DRJ 598 2306 No Equivalent 2378 2014 (210) DLT 85 2246 No Equivalent 2378 2014 (6) AD (D) 421 2181 2014 (4) RAJ 170 2150 No Equivalent 2181 2014 (208) DLT 680 2322 No Equivalent 2200 2014 (4) AD (D) 492 2366 2014 (4) AD (D) 621 2361 No Equivalent 2366 2014 (209) DLT 468 2366 2014 (142) DRJ 613 2074 2014 (3) RAJ 266 2074 2014 (3) AD (D) 432 2114 2014 (2) JCC 982 2143 No Equivalent 2089 No Equivalent 2163 No Equivalent (i) (iv) COMPARATIVE TABLE 2014 (144) DRJ 182 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2241 OTHER JOURNAL = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2014 (362) ITR 97 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2127 JUNE, PART-II 2014 (2) JCC 982 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2114 Journal Name Page No. = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) Page No. 2014 (2) JCC 1305 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2282 2014 (6) AD (D) 664 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2211 2014 (58) PTC 309 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2169 2014 (4) AD (D) 473 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2331 2014 (4) RAJ 170 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2188 2014 (6) AD (D) 516 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2127 2014 (3) RAJ 266 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2074 2014 (7) AD (D) 128 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2047 2014 (4) RAJ 361 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2169 2014 (6) AD (D) 421 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2378 2014 (4) RAJ 170 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2181 2014 (4) AD (D) 621 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2366 2014 (1) RLR 726 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2251 2014 (3) AD (D) 432 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2074 2014 (4) AD (D) 156 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2251 2014 (4) AD (D) 281 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2169 2014 (4) AD (D) 492 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2200 2014 CrLJ 3277 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2251 2014 (209) DLT 515 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2211 2014 (210) DLT 85 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2378 2014 (209) DLT 468 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2366 2014 (209) DLT 210 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2251 2014 (208) DLT 680 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2181 2014 (142) DRJ 396 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2331 2014 (142) DRJ 598 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2378 2014 (142) DRJ 613 = ILR (DS) 2014 (III) 2366 (iii) (v) (vi) NOMINAL-INDEX Mohd. Shahid v. State ........................................................................ 2282 VOLUME-3, PART-II Munir @ CHOTA v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) ......................... 2353 JUNE, 2014 Munishwar Kumar v. Rakesh Kumar & Ors. .................................... 2081 Pages Perfetti Van Melles.P.A & Anr. v. Anil Bajaj & Ors. ......................... 2083 Arun & Ors. v. State .......................................................................... 2211 R.L. Varma & Sons (HUF) v. Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. ................. 2205 Ashish Kumar Dubey v. State Thr. CBI ............................................ 2331 Rajender Kumar v. Manju ................................................................... 2277 Ashok Kumar & Anr. v. Sunil Kumar & Ors. ................................... 2300 Rajender Prasad Gupta v. Rajeev Gagerna ......................................... 2241 At & T Communication Services India (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax-I & Anr. ..................................... 2127 Rajesh Gupta v. State through Central Bureau of Investigation ....... 2251 Babu Lal v. Atul Kumar & Anr. .......................................................... 2047 Real House Distillery Pvt. Ltd & Anr. v. Pernod Ricard S.A. & Anr ....................................................................... 2169 Bharat Lal Maurya v. Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd ........................ 2188 Rohit v. State ...................................................................................... 2312 Bhule Bisre Kalakar Co-Operative Industrial Production Society Ltd. & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors ............................. 2233 Sahil v. State ....................................................................................... 2306 Commissioner of Income Tax (Central)-II v. Income Sanjay v. Ajit Singh Bajaj .................................................................... 2246 Tax Settlement Commission & Anr. ........................................... 2054 Swastik Polytek Pvt. Ltd. v. Oriental Insurance Company ............... 2181 Deutsche Trustee Company Ltd. v. Tulip Telecom Ltd. ................... 2378 Trans India Logistics v. Union of India & Ors. ................................. 2200 Disney Enterprise, Inc & Anr. v. Dhiraj & Anr. ............................... 2150 UOI and Ors. v. Rajnesh Jain............................................................. 2361 Enforcement Directorate v. Morgan Industries Ltd. ......................... 2322 Global Infrastructure Technologies Ltd. v. Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. & Ors. .............................................. 2366 Govt. of NCT of Delhi v. Nav Nirman Construction Co. ................. 2074 Hari Singh Yadav v. State ................................................................... 2114 Kostub Investment Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax ................ 2143 Krishan Ram v. State of The NCT of Delhi ....................................... 2089 Mishra Lal v. Shri Ramesh Chander .................................................. 2163 (viii) SUBJECT-INDEX available original documents before learned Arbitrator, it cannot VOLUME-3, PART-II be permitted to urge that learned Arbitrator proceeded on basis JUNE, 2014 of fictitious documents—There was no way learned Arbitrator could have dealt with submission of fictitious documents in ARBITRATION & CONCILIATION ACT, 1996—Award— absence of original records—In view of long pendency of Petitioner Challenged Award passed by Learned Arbitration— arbitration proceedings, Court is inclined to modify rate of Plea taken, Contrary to specific directions issued by Court, interest and direct that GNCTD will pay NNCC simple interest learned Arbitrator has not, in fact, given reasons for @ 9% p.a from 28th October, 1993 till date of payment which conclusion in respect of different claims made by NNCC and shall not be later than eight weeks from today—Any delay in has virtually repeated his earlier Award, which was set aside making payment beyond that period would attract simple by Court—If claims(iii), (iv) and (v) were components of interest at 12% per annum for period of delay. claim (xvii), then there was no justification for learned Arbitrator to have again awarded a separate sum of Rs. Govt of NCT of Delhi v. Nav Nirman 2,00,000/- under claim (xvii)—Award itself was based on Construction Co. .......................................................... 2074 fictitious documents, which ought not to have been relied — Section 11 and 34—Indian Registration Act, 1908—Section upon by learned Arbitrator—Per contra plea taken, learned 17(1)(d) and 49—Indian Stamps Act, 1899—Section 35— Arbitrator has explained, both under claims (i) and (ii) and Two premises were taken on lease by Respondent— Lease again under claims (iii) to (viii) that they were all components agreements were executed on a Rs.100/- stamp paper each of all claims for profit and loss under claim (xvii)—Award in and were unregistered—Lease agreements stipulated that term respect of claim (xvii) was not challenged by Petitioner on of lease shall be 12 years—As per Petitioners, lease agreements ground now urged and was therefore impermissible—HELD—