Preserving Wild California an External Assessment
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PRESERVING WILD CALIFORNIA AN EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT Report to the Resources Legacy Fund Foundation Steven L. Yaffee, Sheila K. Schueller and Julia M. Wondolleck School of Natural Resources and Environment University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan April 15, 2009 The authors gratefully acknowledge the valuable inputs of numerous Preserving Wild California staff and grantees along with others in the California conservation community who shared their experiences and insights with us. Research Team Steven L. Yaffee, PhD Sheila K. Schueller, PhD Julia M. Wondolleck, PhD Michelle S. Aldridge Yvette C. Dimcheff Nicole A. Fernandes Aviva Y. Glaser José G. Gonzalez Kristen E. Johnson Lauren V. Pidot For comments and questions, please contact: Dr. Steven Yaffee School of Natural Resources and Environment University of Michigan 440 Church Street Ann Arbor MI 48109‐1041 [email protected] 734‐763‐5451 Title page photos by Tupper Ansel Blake Table of Contents Executive Summary ……..............................................................…………………………………… ix Section 1 – Introduction and Method of Assessment ………………………………………… 1 The Bottom Line ………………………………………………………………………...... 1 Methods Used to Carry Out the External Assessment …………………………................. 3 Some Caveats …………………………………………………………………………...…. 7 A Roadmap to the Report ………………………………………………………………...... 9 Section 2 – What was Intended? The Logic of the PWC Program ……………………..… 11 An Ambitious but Clear Set of Goals and Objectives ………………………………...…… 12 Six Major Types of Grantmaking Strategies …………………………………………….… 14 A Set of Quantitative and Qualitative Measures of Success ………………………….…… 16 Section 3 – What was Funded? A Snapshot of Program Activities ………………….….. 23 How were funds distributed by region? ………………………………………………….… 25 How were funds distributed by type of project? ………………………………………….... 25 How were funds distributed by region and type of project? ………………………….……. 26 How many acres were acquired? ………………………………………………………….. 27 How much did it cost? How well were funds leveraged? ……………………………….…. 29 How were funds distributed across organizations? …………………………………….…... 30 How did grantmaking vary over the five years of the program? …………………………… 31 Section 4 – Guiding and Administering the PWC Program …………………………....…… 33 Program Planning: A Strategic Approach ……………………………………………....….. 33 Multiple Interconnected Strategies = A Recipe for Success ……………………………….. 37 Measuring Success and Adapting to Change ……………………………………………….. 39 Day-to-Day Grantmaking: Strategic and Pragmatic ………………………………………... 42 Hands-On, Interactive Style ………………………………………………………………… 44 The Costs of a Below-the-Radar-Screen Approach ………………………………………… 46 Program Time Frame – Pros and Cons …………………………………………………...… 48 Streamlined Staffing, Competent Consultants …………………………………………….... 49 Section 5 – Protecting Wildlands through Strategic Land Acquisition …………..….… 55 Significant Acreage Acquired in Priority Areas ………………………………………....…... 56 Much Acquired Land Judged Valuable by Others ……………………………………...…… 63 Increased Amount and Integrity of Protected Areas …………………………………………. 67 Creating Landscape-Scale Protection ………………………………………………………... 78 Mitigating Threats; Protecting Key Species and Ecosystems ………………………………... 83 Ensuring Long Term Wildlands Protection …………………………………………………... 88 The Critical Roles Played by PWC Funding, RLFF and its Consultants …………………….. 93 Dealing with Challenges ……………………………………………………………………… 96 Contents, Figures, Tables and Cases i Section 6 – Building Organizational Capacity for Wildlands Protection ………….… 101 A Diverse Set of Organizations ……………………………………………………….…… 102 A Hands-On and Multidimensional Approach ……………………………………….……. 107 Investing in Individuals Not Just Organizations ……………………………………..…….. 112 Building Networks ……………………………………………………………………….… 113 Significant Organizational Outcomes ……………………………………………………..... 115 Credibility, Trust and Confidence ……………………………………………………….…. 118 On-the-Ground Outcomes ………………………………………………………………….. 119 Sustaining Organizational Achievements ………………………………………………….. 122 Section 7 – Changing Public Policies that Affect California Wildlands ……………….. 127 A Wide Ranging Set of Policy Accomplishments ………………………………………….. 128 Increased Conservation Funding ………………………………………………………….… 132 Playing Defense …………………………………………………………………………..…. 133 Federal Wilderness Designations – A Strategic Success …………………………………..... 136 Coupling Short Term Wins with Strategies for Long Term Change ………………………... 145 Section 8 – Building Long Term Constituencies for Wildlands Protection …………… 149 Mobilizing Traditional and Nontraditional Groups ………………………………………….. 150 Outreach to Latino Populations …………………………………………………………….... 152 Innovative Ideas; Significant but Limited Accomplishments ………………………………... 154 Mismatch between Wildlands and Latinos? ………………………………………………….. 160 Mismatch between Time Frame and Long Term Needs? ………………………………....…. 163 Clarity of Project Goals ………………………………………………………………………. 165 Recognizing Diversity within the Latino Population ………………………………………….166 Working in Culturally-Sensitive Ways ………………………………………………………. 167 Organizational Impacts and Challenges ……………………………………………………….169 Section 9 – Supporting Science and Planning to Guide Future Protection ……………. 171 New Science; Expanded Tools ……………………………………………………………..... 172 Acquisition Strategies and Land Management Plans …………………………………….…... 177 Identifying Landscape-Scale Linkages ……………………………………………………… 180 Enabling Participation in Public Planning Processes ………………………………………... 182 Building Multiparty Partnerships ……………………………………………………………. 184 From Science to Plans to Action …………………………………………………………..… 186 What about Climate Change? ……………………………………………………………...… 188 Section 10 – Toward Future Wildlands Protection …………………………………………….... 191 Strategies and Activities …..........………………………….………………………………..... 191 Grantmaking Style and Process …................…………………………………….................... 198 Appendix A – Status of Policies Influenced by PWC Activities ……………………………… 201 ii Preserving Wild California: An External Assessment | Yaffee, Schueller and Wondolleck List of Figures Figure Page 2.1 PWC program logic model ………………………………………………………. 21 3.1 Location of projects/grantees funded by the PWC program …………………….. 24 3.2 Percent of funds awarded by region ……………………………………………… 25 3.3 Percent of grants awarded by region ……………………………………………... 25 3.4 Percent of funds by project type ………………………………………………….. 25 3.5 Percent of grants by project type …………………………………………………. 25 3.6 Percent of funds awarded by region and project type ……………………………. 26 3.7 Amount of funds awarded by region and project type …………………………… 26 3.8 Distribution of acquired acreage across PWC regions …………………………… 27 3.9 Amount of acquired acreage distributed by PWC focal areas ……………………. 28 3.10 Average dollar amount of grant by region and project type ……………………… 29 3.11 Relationship between grant amount and total project cost by region …………….. 29 3.12 Number of organizations receiving PWC grants by region ………………………. 30 3.13 Number of organizations receiving grants for different types of PWC projects …. 30 3.14 Number of grants awarded by year ……………………………………………….. 31 3.15 Total $ amount awarded per year …………………………………………………. 31 3.16 Total $ amount awarded per year by region ………………………………………. 31 3.17 Total $ amount awarded per year by project type …………………………………. 31 4.1 PWC Priority and Special Opportunity Areas …………………………………….. 36 4.2 The evolution of PWC grantmaking by strategy type …………………………….. 48 4.3 The evolution of PWC grantmaking by region …………………………………… 49 5.1 Distribution of acquired acreage across PWC regions ……………………………. 57 5.2 Comparison of acquired acreage to PWC Strategy Book benchmarks ……………. 58 5.3 Relationship of acquired acreage to original PWC priorities……………………… 59 5.4 Acreage protected in PWC Priority Areas and Special Opportunity Areas ………. 60 5.5 Pattern of Catellus “railroad” lands …...………………………………………… 62 5.6 Placement of acquired parcels relative to existing protected areas ……………….. 68 5.7 Placement of acquired acreage relative to existing protected areas ……………… 68 5.8 Placement of acquired acreage by region …………………………………………. 69 5.9 Acquisition of inholdings in Wilderness Areas …………………………………… 71 5.10 Acquisition of inholdings in Wilderness Study Areas …………………………….. 71 5.11 Administrative additions to the Ishi Wilderness Area …………………………….. 72 5.12 Acquisitions in Beauty Mountain Wilderness Study Area ………………………... 74 5.13 Acquisitions in the Smith River National Recreation Area ……………………….. 76 5.14 Acquisitions within the Kern River watershed ……………………………………. 79 5.15 PWC projects helping to build the Redwoods to the Sea Corridor ……………….. 81 5.16 Final ownership of acquired acreage ……………………………………………… 89 5.17 Eventual protection level of acquired acreage ……………………………………. 90 Contents, Figures, Tables and Cases iii 6.1 Location of PWC capacity-building projects ……………………………… ……... 103 6.2 Location of organizations receiving PWC capacity-building grants ……………… 104 6.3 PWC capacity-building approach ………………………………………………... 107 7.1 Location of Fort Hunter Liggett in the Central Coast ……………………………... 129 7.2 California wilderness bills influenced by PWC grantmaking……………………… 137 9.1 PWC-funded science and negotiations helped protect the Tejon Ranch ………….. 173 9.2 Missing Linkages as articulated by PWC-grantee South Coast Wildlands ……….. 181 iv Preserving Wild California: An External Assessment | Yaffee, Schueller and Wondolleck List of Tables Table Page 4.1 Number of grants made by region and type of strategy ……………………………