<<

FREE REALITY HUNGER: A MANIFESTO PDF

Professor David Shields | 221 pages | 08 Feb 2011 | Random House USA Inc | 9780307387974 | English | New York, United States Reality Hunger: A Manifesto - David ShieldsDavid Shields

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you Reality Hunger: A Manifesto our website. By continuing to use this website, you consent to our use of these cookies. One of the most sustained pieces of writing that David Shields presents us with in this polemic-as-mosaic comes very near the book's close, just ahead of nine tightly set pages of footnotes. Shields urges us not to read further and, indeed, the inner margins that follow feature a dotted line, Reality Hunger: A Manifesto we wish to scissor the pages out and "restore this book to the form in which I intended it to be read" that is, without the Reality Hunger: A Manifesto insistence of copyright lawyers. In short, we will get the most out of Reality Hunger if we embrace uncertainty and choose not to know whose sentences we have been reading over the previous couple of hundred pages. What to make of a writer Reality Hunger: A Manifesto because Shields's own words frequently appear among the from literary critics and academics, film-makers, musicians and writers ranging from Nietzsche and Proust to Jonathan Raban and Geoff Dyer - so intent on disrupting the reading experience? One can't Reality Hunger: A Manifesto that, at a certain level, it works: the fiddly structures why, for example, is the book divided into sort-of- chapters given both titles such as "", "risk" and "doubt", and letters of the alphabet? But try to match writer with written, and one immediately becomes a fussy librarian, Reality Hunger: A Manifesto dotting the "i"s on an index card, enslaved by literalism and blind to the liberating power of authorial ambiguity. Yet there is something illuminating - beyond the immediate gratification of the swot - in contextualising the book's material; it allows you not only to bring your own knowledge to the party surely not a bad thingbut also to chart Shields's train of thought; to watch it curve its way around those he admires and steamroll over those he doesn't. He is "at once desperate for authenticity and in love with artifice", and his loyalties lie with those who blur the boundaries between reality and fiction, who reject the notion of objective reality in life as much as in art, and who are keen to appropriate Reality Hunger: A Manifesto technologies to reinforce their ideas of artistic playfulness and freedom. So the near-impossible-to-classify writer W G Sebald, the photographer Sophie Calle and the memoirist Lauren Slater all get a big thumbs-up. In art, "purposeless" is an entirely movable judgement that depends on what your original purpose might be; and it is in the nature of a manifesto to delineate and justify those criteria. In that regard, Shields succeeds admirably; we are left in little doubt as to his tastes and beliefs. He sees in the novel's omniscient narrator a doomed attempt to mimic a godlike authority; and Reality Hunger: A Manifesto solution, by way of the "lyric essay", is to suggest a fragmentary and partial approach that follows the contours of personal experience and subjectivity. We understand also that current innovations that threaten the hegemony of copyright and destabilise the vertical relationships between artist and audience play usefully into a new narrative of democracy and imaginative freedom. Where it is harder to toe the line, however, is with Shields's covert suggestion that he is breaking thrilling ground or, for that matter, documenting a movement that really is bursting into life Reality Hunger: A Manifesto than evolving gradually and haphazardly. When he writes that a "story seems to say that everything happens for a reason, and I want to say, No, it doesn't", what I want to say is that you might search a long time to find anyone who thinks it does. Reality Hunger comes garlanded with ecstatic review blurbs all of them, interestingly enough, carefully attributedone of which likens the book to a "miracle". Others fall from the mouths of those quoted in its pages. That in itself tells a pretty compelling tale of how much we have invested in locating the form-breaking, even when we find it in what is an interesting, if mildly overblown, book that doesn't choose to interrogate itself closely enough. This article first appeared in the 08 March issue of the New Statesman, Game on. Sign up. You are browsing in private mode. Reality Hunger - Wikipedia

Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book. Refresh and try again. Open Preview See a Problem? Details if other :. Thanks for telling us about the problem. Return to Book Page. Preview — Reality Hunger by David Reality Hunger: A Manifesto. An open call for new literary and other art forms to match the complexities of the twenty-first century. Reality TV dominates broadband. YouTube and Facebook dominate the web. Most artistic movements are attempts to figure out a way to smuggle more of what the artist thinks is reality into the work of art. The questions Reality Hunger explores—the bending of form and , the lure and blur of the real—play out constantly all around us. Drawing on myriad sources, Shields takes an audacious stance on issues that are being fought over now and will be fought over far into the future. People will either love or hate this book. Its converts will see it as a rallying cry; its detractors will view it as an occasion for defending the Reality Hunger: A Manifesto quo. It is certain to be one of the most controversial and talked-about books of the year. Get A Copy. Hardcoverpages. Published February 23rd by Knopf first published More Details Other Editions Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. To ask other readers questions about Reality Hungerplease sign up. Lists with This Book. Community Reviews. Showing Average rating 3. Rating details. More filters. Sort order. Start your review of Reality Hunger: A Manifesto. Every act of composition is an act of fiction. I kept bumping into it at my favorite used bookshop, thumbing through it and reading little bits here and there, finding myself confused by the format -- was it a book of quotes or a book of random thoughts? The next time I came back, it would be gone of course! Eventually, of course, another copy would show up on the shelves and I would start the whole process over again. Eventually that Chip Kidd cover won me over Reality Hunger: A Manifesto I took it home. This is basically the postmodern literary equivalent of building a song out of samples. Reality Hunger: A Manifesto was about halfway through before I realized that a huge chunk of this book is sourced from elsewhere, remixed, modified, recombined, and used interstitially between genuine writing done by Shields himself Reality Hunger: A Manifesto tie this whole crazy opus together. Which honestly, is the exact kind of reaction you want something to evoke in others. Anyway, I think those people with intense opinions on it are thinking way too literally, Reality Hunger: A Manifesto might benefit from the practice of trying to hold two opposing opinions in their heads at the same time, and mulling them over. Let journalism handle facts, and let both our non-fiction and fiction pieces of art just be. Or maybe none of that too. Or maybe -- and this is more realistic here -- just some of it. Pick and choose, etc. I had to take a lot of breaks -- short and long -- to give myself time to process the concepts. I took a lot of notes to organize my thoughts; trying to Reality Hunger: A Manifesto to the bottom of what I was Reality Hunger: A Manifesto about what was being said. If I came across something that really got my thinking, I threw the book down and went for a walk to mull it over a little. Or maybe I would just put it down for a few days, read something else, and come back to it when I was really interested again in the questions it was posing; when the ideas were pulling me back in. Paraphrasing, of course, but some of those questions were: What sort of responsibility should a memoirist have to literal facts? Can we actually trust our memory enough to Reality Hunger: A Manifesto anything we remember as fact? How much truth is there in fiction? How much fiction do we allow in non-fiction? If the point of memoir is that more important bit, does it actually have to be married to truth at all? Who owns ideas? Do we necessarily always need Form and Story and Narrative and the other usual pieces of storytelling? Is the space between truth and fiction actually more interesting anyway? View 2 comments. Feb 25, Buck rated it liked it. After a slow start, the ensuing discussion turned into a bloody street fight: names were called, knives were pulled and, tragically, feelings were hurt. Pretty much everyone involved lost their shit, including me. Good times, good times. It feels like driving a car in a clown suit. I find myself thinking, "Come on, man, you're just making that shit up. The interesting stuff is all happening on the fringes of the form where there are Reality Hunger: A Manifesto of jazz and elements of all sorts of other things as well. Something similar is happening in prose. Although great novels—novelly novels—are still being written, a lot of the most interesting things are happening on the fringes of several forms. Reality Hunger: A Manifesto fun with that. In healthy times, we cut multiple roads, allowing for the possibility of a Jean Genet as surely as a Graham Greene. These aren't particularly healthy times. A breed of lyrical Realism has had the freedom of the highway for some time now, with most other exits blocked. Anyone else noticed that? Life—standing on a street corner, channel surfing, trying to navigate the web or a declining relationship, hearing that a close friend died last night—flies at us in bright splinters. When an editor tried to remove some flies from a white bedcover in a photo of a farmer, Evans indignantly demanded they be put back in. But I mean, Christ, look around: we live Reality Hunger: A Manifesto a hugely complex, extremely dangerous world, full of technological wonders, political savagery, horrors of all kinds — and these guys are trying to capture it all in their careful little daguerreotypes. Above all, more kick-ass literature, in whatever genre or medium. View all 40 comments. Can you copyright reality? Reality Hunger: A Manifesto art theft? Thanks, April. View all 10 comments. Aug 30, Jen Julian rated it did not like it Shelves: grad-schoolnonfictiontheory-criticism. This is an example of the kind of overtly self-congratulatory deconstructionist bunk that really irritates me about post-modernist writers. Shields comes across as Reality Hunger: A Manifesto pompous, insincere, and out Reality Hunger: A Manifesto touch, making many broad assumptions about what the reading public "wants" and what writers "should do. Reality Hunger does nothing that writers haven't ALREADY been doing since the s, and many of the quotes Shields uses about the "death of fiction" are out of context and out of date. So that's the gimmick of this book. It's comprised mostly of quotations, sound bites and collected info from other sources. Shields does this, Reality Hunger: A Manifesto says, to challenge our views of copyright and idea ownership, admitting to us that his editor had to pretty much force his hand to include an appendix citing original sources. If Shields had truly wanted to counteract our views of copyright and idea ownership, he should have published this beastly book online with free access -- then he wouldn't have had to worry with a silly little appendix at all. Aside from the parts of the book where Shields essentially discounts storytelling as no longer relevant to us narrative conventions like plot and character, he claims, "bore" himthe book is particularly self-aggrandizing in a way that really got under my Reality Hunger: A Manifesto. There is an entire "chapter" dedicated to the form, where Shields amalgamates a bunch of quotes about how awesome collage is of Reality Hunger: A Manifesto, this is the form Reality Hunger: A Manifesto has chosen for the book -- it would apparently be too status quo to allow the form to speak for itself. Shields is trying to do what visual collage artists do, making art with a mix of magazine images and old textbook diagrams, superimposing Donald Duck onto a Hieronymus Bosch painting, whatever. But Shields fails to acknowledge the gap between the mediums of visual and literary collage. The overall effect of the book is that Shields is using these sources to reiterate his argument or flat-out speak for him. Reality Hunger: a Manifesto Reality Hunger: A Manifesto, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date. For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now. Javascript is not enabled in your browser. Enabling JavaScript in your browser will allow you to experience all the features of our site. Learn how to enable JavaScript on your browser. NOOK Book. Who owns ideas? How clear is the distinction between fiction and nonfiction? Has the velocity of digital culture rendered traditional modes obsolete? Exploring these and related questions, Shields orchestrates a chorus of voices, past and present, to reframe debates about the veracity of memoir and the relevance of the novel. His work has been translated into twenty languages. Reality, as Nabokov never got tired of reminding us, is the one word that is meaningless without marks. The quasi—home movie Open Water. The depilation scene in The Year-Old Virgin. What are its key components? We commonly do not remember that it is, after all, always the first person that is speaking. The interesting stuff is all happening on the fringes of the form where there are elements of jazz and elements of Reality Hunger: A Manifesto sorts of other things as well. Something similar is happening in Reality Hunger: A Manifesto. Although great novels—novelly novels—are still being written, a lot of the most interesting things are happening on the fringes of several forms. Amazingly, people continue to want to read that. It would be assigned no matter the stylistic or linguistic method, no matter the form. This, alas, would exclude many writers who believe themselves to be realistic, most notably those who seem to equate writing with operating a massive karaoke machine. But a work of art, like the world, is a living form. Beckett decided that everything was false to him, almost, in art, with its designs and formulae. He wanted art, but he wanted it right from life. He went into French to cut down. He wanted to directly address desperate individual existence, which bores many readers. I find him a joyous writer, though; his work reads like prayer. I want it to transcend artifice. But it has. Novel qua novel is a form of nostalgia. The work of essayists is vital precisely because it permits and encourages self-knowledge in a way that is less indirect than fiction, more open Reality Hunger: A Manifesto speculative. Maybe these works succeed, maybe they fail, but at least they all attempt to clarify the problem at hand. I think that, at the very least, essays and poems more directly and more urgently attempt to figure out something about the world. Most of Houellebecq. Lydia Davis, everything. The genre, having squandered its substance, no longer has an object. The character is dying out; the plot, too. Lyric essays seek answers yet seldom seem to find them. How do you feel about an artist using copyrighted material in the creation of a new work of art? Would you call this an act of theft? Or does this practice promote the free flow of ideas between past, present, and future artists? There are Reality Hunger: A Manifesto quotations stitched into the fabric of Reality Hunger. While reading the book, were you able to identify the source of one or more of these other voices? Why do you think the author made use of so many quotations? Why did he leave the sources unidentified? How did this technique affect your experience with the book? James Frey, author of Reality Hunger: A Manifesto Million Little Pieceswas highly criticized after it became known that parts of his book were fictitious. Why do you think Shields defends Frey? If Frey had published his book as a novel, would it have received so much attention? In what ways does Reality Hunger: A Manifesto structure of Reality Hunger reflect the actual subject matter it discusses? Why do you think Shields chose to arrange the book the way he did? Why recreate it? I want to think about it, try to understand it. What I am is a wisdom junkie, knowing all along that wisdom is, in many ways, junk. I want a literature built entirely out of contemplation and revelation. Who cares about anything else? Not me. For other arts? Have you ever remembered an experience differently from how it actually happened? What are some reasons why two individuals could remember the same event in very different ways? Throughout the book, Shields praises the essay and the self-reflexive Reality Hunger: A Manifesto film. What Reality Hunger: A Manifesto these two forms have in common? What links these books? How have these previous books pointed the way toward Reality Hunger? On the surface, a reality TV program and a memoir seem to have little in common. However, Shields makes connections between these and other works of art and entertainment. Can you identify any ways in which a reality TV program and a published memoir are similar? It what ways do they differ? Why are both so popular these days? Shields is critical of the traditional novel as a contemporary art form. Shields began his writing career as a novelist. Why do you Reality Hunger: A Manifesto Shields at this point is so critical of the novel as a genre? Over the last half-decade, social networking sites such as Facebook and MySpace have emerged as a major new communications technology. What can and cannot be learned about Reality Hunger: A Manifesto person through his or her social network page? Has this book changed your attitudes toward collage art, sampling, and artistic assimilation? If so, how and why has your opinion changed? If your feelings have not changed, why not? Did this chapter change your understanding of Reality Hunger: A Manifesto book as a whole? Why did Shields place this line in such a prominent place in the book? Home 1 Books 2. Read an excerpt of this book! Add to Wishlist. Sign in to Purchase Instantly. Members save with free shipping everyday! See details. Read an Excerpt a overture 1 Every artistic movement from the beginning of time is an attempt to figure out a way to smuggle more of what the artist thinks is reality into the work of art. Show More. Reading Group Guide 1. Related Searches. Through extensive on-the-record interviews with friends View Product. Here are Reality Hunger: A Manifesto profiles of Washington insiders that From This American Life alum David Rakoff comes a hilarious collection that single- handedly raises self-deprecation From This American Life alum David Rakoff comes a hilarious collection that single-handedly raises Reality Hunger: A Manifesto to an art form. Whether impersonating Sigmund Freud in a department store window during the holidays, climbing an icy mountain in cheap loafers, or learning A young jazz buff in Tokyo. A crooked British lawyer in Hong Kong. A in Manhattan.